@@LGNDado”umm actually when he was on the mountain firing at Pinkertons after the cutscene of John leaving, there was no indication that anyone was hit so you’re wrong”-🤓
Feats go to dutch. He killed the biggest oilman in America He was the most wanted man in america He helped sink a cuban warship He survived being stranded on a tropical island He shot someone from Miles away using one of if not the most inaccurate pistol of all time He was responsible for the blackwater massacre He was responsible for the saint denis bank robbery He was the leader of the most successful gang in america (succesful before the BW massacre) And He headshotted 4 guys in 3 seconds (during the braithwaite manor raid)
Arthur in chapter 2 in the mission where levictus cornwall appears for the first time Arthur kills 4 soldiers with superhuman speed and precision dutch never came close to doing what arthur did
Actually you're making a mistake when you said he almost outdrew Micah. He DID outdraw Micah despite Micah drawing first "Hi my name is Logan Jackson who looks for attention on the internet cuz I'm a sad and lonely loser who lives in his mom's basement and gets no attention from my parents" -🤓
This is the beat comparison that i saw so far,the fact that u actually explain everything,it’s much better that simple points show,the only thing that i didn’t agree with,is that Arthur didn’t almost outdrew micah,he did outdraw micah,but everything else on point,much love and respect
I will say that, at least from comparing the video, I’m like 99% positive that Arthur, even while sick with TB is able to outdraw Micah, even with Micah drawing first. Like watching the clip over, he is near “instant” with drawing his gun as compared to Micah.
He also outdrew Micah by a long shot during Chapter 3 when Bill got caught at gunpoint by the Grays. For the average player, Arthur also gets most of the lawmen. For a great player, Arthur kills all the lawmen before Micah even makes a shot. Arthur was far beyond Micah.
I agree with this an awful lot, but I felt like a point of view that I saw(maybe others, idk) is how Dutch’s willpower can hardly be touched. Don’t get me wrong, Arthur still wins that one but, I thought it had to be said at some point. After his concussion, Dutch was never able to let go of his plan and was willing to go to extreme lengths, stopping at nothing.
In a duel, both would be extremely close to winning, but it would end up in a *draw* (they would both die due to their speed. Arthur would draw first, fire, and Dutch would be .556 miliseconds from firing first, but is still wounded. Arthur is then shot by Dutch, and so they both have hit each other in a fast duel.)
Yay first one of these that actually compares two characters from the same game instead of some random character from a completely different game that’s based in a completely different time (like red dead 2 vs ghost of Tsushima makes no sense)
Dutch missed several shots in Guarma and was easilly distracted and that gave the dictator time to escape, he didnt have a well perfomance in none of the mission that he is with us, you can see in guarma that he is similar habilities with a npc, even javier had a better permance. Arthur shoot a dinamite that Dutch himself launch in the air in that Saint Denis trap made by Angelo Bronte, was service as a sniper in the "Red Dead Redemption" mission, was able to use deadeye in a maxim and other stuff. And its quite obvious, to have a quickdraw like he you need to be precise and fast, they dont work alone, and more quick more accuracy is need, all the gold medal requirements confirm about his accuracy. But very good edit, you are probably the firts one who justify and in a very deep level of lore knowledge, most of guys just dont paid attention about history details and trie to make serious content without any basis and just say what get they attention more or just favoritism, it frust me a lot, but you are an example and I felt need congratulate you for the good work
@@nationstremblebeforeme1487bro your forgetting Arthur had tb and he still was able to beat Micah ass and dutch went out like a bitch bro killed himself at least Arthur and John took there death
And again, Arthur didn’t die of TB, Micah beat the absolute crap out of him, and his tuberculosis made him lose that fight, but still, Micah killed him.
thank you for all the support in the comments♥️
Song name. Please, it sounds like a bop
@@orrgroup9928 on my own slowed and reverb
@@ashyzu Your a savior god bless you
The fact that you add explaination makes it better
Bruh
I love that it is detailed and with proof of that info, respect the effort bro
Mr. Bell!
Fr
me too as well never seen a video with real proof major respect I'm subbing
Dutch's accuracy is crazy, like what the hell
Yeah he also has solo deadeye in rdr1 which is crazy
i mean he did teach john and arthur how to fight and shoot
arthur got a dead eye bruh
Well arthurs is more crazy, never missed a single shot in a cutscene im pretty sure
@@LGNDado”umm actually when he was on the mountain firing at Pinkertons after the cutscene of John leaving, there was no indication that anyone was hit so you’re wrong”-🤓
Yo first one I've seen that actually explains it
Yeah. This is awesome actually.
First and last
Dutch: you can’t kill me! I raised you!
Arthur: X
X X X
X X X
X
And from 8 marks he has the M1899 which means he there to mess him up
love explanations, makes it more understandable to why a character could win
Arthur is one of the best fictional characters ever in my opinion.
Same
Leon kennedy is the goat
@@darsanmprasad1741Lmao. Nope.
Feats go to dutch.
He killed the biggest oilman in America
He was the most wanted man in america
He helped sink a cuban warship
He survived being stranded on a tropical island
He shot someone from Miles away using one of if not the most inaccurate pistol of all time
He was responsible for the blackwater massacre
He was responsible for the saint denis bank robbery
He was the leader of the most successful gang in america (succesful before the BW massacre)
And He headshotted 4 guys in 3 seconds (during the braithwaite manor raid)
Arthur in chapter 2 in the mission where levictus cornwall appears for the first time Arthur kills 4 soldiers with superhuman speed and precision
dutch never came close to doing what arthur did
Dutch says in dialogue: "oh, Arthur, I would go into hell with you protecting me
and on this mission Arthur takes a sniper
you
Actually you're making a mistake when you said he almost outdrew Micah. He DID outdraw Micah despite Micah drawing first
"Hi my name is Logan Jackson who looks for attention on the internet cuz I'm a sad and lonely loser who lives in his mom's basement and gets no attention from my parents" -🤓
🤓
@@loganjackson5885 TF u mean by that?
"Actually youre making a mistake" 🤓
@@loganjackson5885 how about you mind your business?
Its an online post man relax
Arthur was the best the gang had to offer for a reason
This is the beat comparison that i saw so far,the fact that u actually explain everything,it’s much better that simple points show,the only thing that i didn’t agree with,is that Arthur didn’t almost outdrew micah,he did outdraw micah,but everything else on point,much love and respect
I will say that, at least from comparing the video, I’m like 99% positive that Arthur, even while sick with TB is able to outdraw Micah, even with Micah drawing first. Like watching the clip over, he is near “instant” with drawing his gun as compared to Micah.
He also outdrew Micah by a long shot during Chapter 3 when Bill got caught at gunpoint by the Grays. For the average player, Arthur also gets most of the lawmen. For a great player, Arthur kills all the lawmen before Micah even makes a shot. Arthur was far beyond Micah.
Wow first time I saw a good comparison with an actual explanation.
This is actually… A really good 1v1 video!
I actually like this one because it explains why they chose them for things Yknow? And they actually chose Dutch instead of favouriting Arthur. Yessss
Consider this. Dutch has a plan but he needs some goddamn faith.
Wow a 1v1 video that actually makes logical sense!
And it has explanations
But I am the one who keeps faith.
You died to fall damage
@@Ka1_TheGuy But did you see me hit the ground?
@@Ka1_TheGuy skill issue
@@lxkegosling ruclips.net/user/shortsByuiU7-RBfg?feature=share Yes.
@@lxkegosling do you have a plan?
The man with the plan
😂good humor
You can tell he really took there time with this one
At the start Arthur is like "Ahh~ great i'm doing this stupid trend again..."
Mr Pearson vs Reverend Swanson 🤣
I have a plan son
Its over Arthur!
Wish we’d seen dutch in his prime
I like how you explain each parameter with facts, as opposed to other videos of the same type
(sorry for my bad English I'm Italian)
nice English, fratello, i would recommend learning more informal English after getting a good grasp on forms English
I wish Dutch was given more feats in rdr2, he's the leader of the Vanderlinde Gang, for God's sake.
This was the best 1v1 video on youtube i have ever seen
that one npc which was just walking in the start of the game: i suffered more
"we're in a world that don't want us no more" -Arthur Morgan
I love how Dutch won accuracy just for one scene in rdr1, That aiming was almost as insane as Dutch himself at that point
People need to take advice from this on man on how to make a 1v1 video
Make a new one, love the content
i will soon ive been a little busy
kratos morgan? damn 2 legends in the same time
@@IsThatAllStranger That’s the way it is
@@kratosmorgan4971 dam
This was the most accurate - V - video I’ve ever seen thank you
The only actually good channel who does this. So many others suck, you put so much detail into your answers.
Bro amazing edit, we need more rdr2 shorts like this
That right boah I just quick drawn the subscribe button
He DID outdraw Micah
you could say that but if you put on your nerd glasses and slow down the video during their draw, arthur raises his gun like, half a second later
@@rolf8424 I think that was because he was sick if Arthur was healthy he probably could have taken out everyone there at least most of them
@@ECHOKINGXD thats a given lol if arthur wasn’t sick he’d have bodied everyone that was there
@@rolf8424 no he didn't, Micah reaches for his gun first but Arthur is the first to have Micah in his sights
@@rolf8424 FACTS
Thank you for giving an explanation this is worth not only a like but subscribe
I think this is probably the fairest match up and point assignment I’ve ever seen with one of these fight setups. Well done.
This is the best vs short ever
Most accurate video I’ve seen and thank you for explaining the details
Arthur is the rdr character of all time for me
Really love the explanations I wish others would do this
Great VS short, actually explains why he gave out points and fairly gives opportunities for both to have an edge, props to you g
I agree with this an awful lot, but I felt like a point of view that I saw(maybe others, idk) is how Dutch’s willpower can hardly be touched. Don’t get me wrong, Arthur still wins that one but, I thought it had to be said at some point. After his concussion, Dutch was never able to let go of his plan and was willing to go to extreme lengths, stopping at nothing.
Love the fact that you actually said why they earned the point that actually makes a Huge difference!!
This is the first edit that has valid good reasonable points to make, I love your edit please keep it up, ur synced too
In a duel, both would be extremely close to winning, but it would end up in a *draw* (they would both die due to their speed. Arthur would draw first, fire, and Dutch would be .556 miliseconds from firing first, but is still wounded. Arthur is then shot by Dutch, and so they both have hit each other in a fast duel.)
Yay first one of these that actually compares two characters from the same game instead of some random character from a completely different game that’s based in a completely different time (like red dead 2 vs ghost of Tsushima makes no sense)
You could've added hax there with Arthur's deadeye haha
well you never know, dutch could have deadeye too 👀
Dutch probably has dead eye considering he popped off three braithwaites without them even being able to react.
Arthur legend of the east and the west
Arthur is only the legend of the East
Dutch missed several shots in Guarma and was easilly distracted and that gave the dictator time to escape, he didnt have a well perfomance in none of the mission that he is with us, you can see in guarma that he is similar habilities with a npc, even javier had a better permance. Arthur shoot a dinamite that Dutch himself launch in the air in that Saint Denis trap made by Angelo Bronte, was service as a sniper in the "Red Dead Redemption" mission, was able to use deadeye in a maxim and other stuff. And its quite obvious, to have a quickdraw like he you need to be precise and fast, they dont work alone, and more quick more accuracy is need, all the gold medal requirements confirm about his accuracy. But very good edit, you are probably the firts one who justify and in a very deep level of lore knowledge, most of guys just dont paid attention about history details and trie to make serious content without any basis and just say what get they attention more or just favoritism, it frust me a lot, but you are an example and I felt need congratulate you for the good work
I love VS videos like this because they actually show the reasoning
thank you for being accurate and giving details you're the fucking best
I love how you do it with explanations tho
agree with all points, the apprentice passed his mentor
More of these with details they are awesome
I love the detail
if you think about it, all of arthur's skills and such were taught to him by dutch, dutch raised arthur
And Arthur outgrew Dutch
Did he Tho who survived longer in the end?
Hell no Arthur been knew how to shoot plus Arthur dad was a outlaw so what are you talking about
@@nationstremblebeforeme1487bro your forgetting Arthur had tb and he still was able to beat Micah ass and dutch went out like a bitch bro killed himself at least Arthur and John took there death
you actually make good comparisons, good job
Finally someone who acknowledges the skills Dutch actually holds as a fighter he isn't Colm he doesn't, cower behind his men.
Finally a video that is actually detailed and explains why he gives the point. Good content bro👍
This is the best comparison vid ever
We don't know everything about Dutch possible we can see in rdr3 . But I am agree
I so hope there is one
We’ve never actually seen Dutch in his prime yet
This is a great video. Respect for actually giving detailed explanations
“I have a plan Arthur…”
SUCH A GOOD VID
The man with the plan 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I got a plan
Not only did arthur defeat tommy, he gave him brain damage and destroyed a chunk of his face with nothing but his fist
Actually dutch is a fast drawer too. Maybe as fast as arthur too
Finnaly a actual good one
You missed a chance to add a tajiti rank
Intelligence could be argued Arthur is rational and logical in the heat of the moment whereas Dutch just becomes erratic and cocky.
Bro there's no TWO winners in 1v1
What if they shoot bullets at the same time and die the same time
That why its say extreme high diff
@@Why_Jrk then its tie
@@Why_Jrk two losers🗿🚬
@@Why_Jrk or draw 🗿☕
No way you put Dutch as strategist, he literally lost all his team
yeah and communication/charm goes definitely for dutch
Finally some explanations, this is underrated
Arthur carrier the gang
out of all the comparison videos i've seen so far this one is by far the best
I'd say Dutch had better feats nationally as he was more well known for the crimes of the gang.
I hate how the legend of the east outfit can’t be worn by Arthur even though Arthur is the legend of the East
Big mistake, rockstar made.
Dutch gon beat Arthur till he agrees with the Tahiti plan 🗿🍷
Finally, a worthy opponent, our battle will be legendary
Arthur who should win me or you
Arthur :- of course you dutch
John :- 🗿
YT short mode sucks. I was trying to read this good comparison
This has good points and not just stuff that basically gives points to one. Also not very based so good job:)
This is a lot better comparison or I guess versus than a lot of the other ones they have that I've seen online at least
Very good video
One of the best comparison videos I've seen so far. Great explanations too.
i have a plan Arthur
Very well elaborated and well done video
Nice edit bro and arthur is masterpiece
Arthur is the best tbh 😃
Dutch gets "I hAd A GoDAM PPLAn!"
Your right he Killed 4 Legendary Gunslingers Cold 🥶
Love your style, keep up with this!
And again, Arthur didn’t die of TB, Micah beat the absolute crap out of him, and his tuberculosis made him lose that fight, but still, Micah killed him.
Yeah I agree Arthur all the way
Bro I swear it's the best comparison I ever seen and it's facts