Windows 11 ARM on Raspberry Pi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июл 2024
- Raspberry Pi 4 Windows 11 installation and demo, achieved using materials developed by the Windows on Raspberry (WoR) project and BotSpot. And of course Microsoft. :)
The Windows on Raspberry website is here:
www.worproject.com/
And Botspot’s WoR flasher page is here:
github.com/Botspot/wor-flasher
Microsoft’s Windows on ARM overview is here:
docs.microsoft.com/en-us/wind...
The commands to execute in a terminal, as shown in the video, are:
git clone github.com/Botspot/wor-flasher
and then
~/wor-flasher/install-wor-gui.sh
As far as I am aware, the method for installing the ARM version of Windows 11 on a Raspberry Pi demonstrated in this video is legal, as all proprietary Windows components are downloaded straight from Microsoft's update servers using uupdump. This appears to have been confirmed by Gordon Hollingworth from Raspberry Pi here: forums.raspberrypi.com/viewto...
Good luck! :)
More videos on SBCs and wider computing and related topics can be found at / explainingcomputers
And you can access exclusive members-only videos and other perks by becoming a channel member here: / @explainingcomputers
You may also like my ExplainingTheFuture channel at: / explainingthefuture
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
01:07 WoR Flasher
04:53 Installation
07:40 Windows on Pi
11:13 Pi Passmark
#RaspberryPi #Windows #Windows11 #ExplainingComputers 
Наука
I noticed when you looked at "about system" that it indicated that only 2.92 GB of RAM was usable. Note that if you visit the UEFI menu (included with Windows on Raspberry), you can disable the option marked "Limit RAM use to 3GB".
Hmm nice on some computers they show it like that, thought that was allocated to iGPU
@@efeloteishe4675 the iGPU on the Pi becomes unstable if allocated more than 512MB, and is rarely allocated more than 256MB. If the discrepancy in RAM amount was just due to video memory, it should be closer to 3.2-3.6 GB.
How to do it sir
@@ydiadi_ more people should find out if you could hacktosh arm computers now a days
@@NicVandEmZ I would love Apple Pi project myself
I had Windows 11, on my Raspberry Pi 4, 8Gb version few months ago, I did the installation from windows and was fair more complicated, I'm glad to see the installation from Linux more easy to do.
I've been running x86 and x64 native windows programs without problems (until now no program had give me problems), I use Netflix and RUclips video streaming without delay, so I really happy with the performance.
My initial motivation have been running Windows programs on a cheap and low energy consumption environment, I would be grateful if you can make energy consumption testing on this setup comparing with RaspberryOS or other OS.
Thanks for the great content as always!
Why would you bother installing Windows if all you're going to do is stream content and not use programs that are relying on the Windows platform?
@@i_used_adblock_to_watch_this Just for testing, and obviously I installed other programs as well, like Dos games running on DoxBox, SNES Emulator, trading utilities like MT5 and Ninjatrader for algotrading, and Office 2019.
Hi, could you enlighte me if I can plug USB webcam in the RPI win11 and run a Zoon meeting? Thanks
@@marcelo_luz I've never did the test because I don't have a webcam, but wireless keyboard, external hard drives, gamepad, all of them worked fine.
@@cyberstorm45 Thanks! Just one more question: do you know if Remote Access (Microsoft RDP) works properly? My main reason to build this solution is to use the most of time as a client server because Ms RDP in my experience isost fluid and flexible application to it.
Greetings Mr. CB and community!
It is always a treat to watch an educational and interesting video about technology, and at the same time to be hilarious by design. What a ride with the snail joke! Great content as always!
Half an hour to install - holy moly! Shows the difference in speed between a Pi and modern desktop. Last time I did a clean install it took a few minutes!
Well its more SD Card vs SSD speed than the speed of the machine
@@fdmazlum I will be trying this on a SSD as I dont think SD card is fast enough ! to have a useable experience
The thing I love about windows 7... is that when I open the settings, it opens the settings. I don't have to wait some inexplicable amount of time for it to do nothing more taxing than populate a window with a few icons. And this is on a 10 year old PC... but this is 2022 of course and microsoft are like "you want to open a window... hmm.... that's very complicated you know...."
Cool story bro.
You are by far the best teacher for soft soft . It's very complicated at first - overwhelming, actually - but, you make it doable for
Excellent and interesting video Chris, thank you. Loaded Win 11 on my Pi4 8GB, but as mentioned by others, Win 11 is painfully slow. Given that it was possible at all, is highly commendable. I look forward to further developments/upgrades/downloads in the coming months. Perhaps a future Pi5 fitted with an SSD will significantly improve performance.
Windows 11 on a Pi, who’d have thought it! What fun and I loved the chats with a snail. Great stuff, thanks for another brilliant video.
I didn't think it - if that helps at all.
Really neat. Nice to see how versatile the Raspberry Pi is.
Brilliant little oddity here, great glimpse! I especially enjoyed the tea and snail sidebars, nicely done!
All the snail bits were wonderful. Incredible video!
Thanks for another Sunday vid in the USA. Good show! Windows ARM on the Raspberry Pi foreshadows what may very well be a glimpse of the possibilities of the Pi 5, 6, 7, ... as "Hope Springs"!
Nice work Chris. I just don't know how you find the content every week but you do. Keep up the great work.
Great video Chris!
I will be trying this out next week. Easy to follow instructions, all I need now is a few snails 🐌 to pass my time.
Jolly superior video, once again 👍. A perfect presentation of possible solipsistic prolepses powered by energy-sipping ARM crisps. With appreciation and regards.
Loved the comparison to snails when doing Windows updates. Great overview!
This is very exciting and makes me hopeful for the future raspberry pi models.
What a great video. Your eccentric characteristics really shined in a really good way. "I am going to wait and have tea!" You are wonderful, good sir!
An interesting and entertaining video; your dialogue was very funny, especially about the snails. Shows how flexible the Pi is. I haven’t got one, thinking of getting a Pi, a 400, at Christmas.
I'm impressed! I had no idea this was even in development, but that's why I follow you :)
Definitely a PI OS that is perfectly suited for snail use.
The concept is great, even if the hardware and lack of complete drivers will never make it a realistic day to day proposition.
But a potentially useful pointer for the next iteration of the board.
Yv
The reason there are no drivers is that Qualcomm had an exclusivity agreement with Microsoft for Windows on ARM, but we believe that that deal is soon to expire.
Amazing! I just got my hands on an RPI 4b with 2gb ram. I'm super excited about applications with machine learning on the Pi.
An extraordinary video! I would also like to thank WoR and Botspot for their stirling work - well done to all involved!
However, I am worried that the Anatidae in the park are not getting the attention they deserve, and various slimy Mollusca have slithered in to your affections.
hey hoss. Sundays are usually a slow upload day regarding my favorite youtubers.
sometimes i get a little nervous if you don't upload at the exact time you usually do, but you're pretty rock-solid in being there on time, rock-solid in being there every sunday.
thank you sir, i appreciate your efforts and look forward to your vids every sunday.
you have a breadth of knowledge regarding any platform, os, etc. Thank you for expanding my mind with your knowledge.
i believe that, in a previous video, you asked your audience what our interest is. I can only speak for myself.
home automation, home security using only rasberry pis and whatever OPEN SOURCE that doesn't phone home software you choose (i sometimes step into my kitchen naked and i don't want the world to see my how little my puppy is).
i know you've touched on this topic, but i would love to see a complete start-to-finish series on the matter rather than tid-bits here and there.
i've watched vids from DIY Perks
(ruclips.net/video/CouxmNqxO4A/видео.html)
to Smart Home Solver
(ruclips.net/video/A73u1S0yQoE/видео.html)
the problem i have with the latter is that he usually uses solutions that phone home. Well, that and all his "incredible" sh*t is generally geared towards turning lights on and off. Seems there's gotta be more valuable solutions to automating one's home. Seems like there's a solution out there that doesn't report to AWS your current position in your home.
i'd love to see you dig into the home automation realm.
keep in mind, i run on windows and while i'm dev'ing software, i have an extra screen that i could keep track of what's going on in my house, with my house, around my house.
i live in Florida, United States, so certainly part of that would be a system that uses whole house fans, motors that open and close windows, cues to the HVAC to turn on or off, all driven by the current heat index, the temperature in the attic, the temperature outside, et alis.
do a series on how to implement that, i will follow along step by step, plus like every vid (i'm already subscribed with notifications on).
p.s. I do believe you have the driest sense of humor in the history of mankind. How do you manage to generate enough saliva to swallow food? :)
you rock hoss. :)
ps. These brits suck: ruclips.net/video/y-E7_VHLvkE/видео.html
you should be ashamed of your country.
ok, ok, maybe not as much as what america's produced:
ruclips.net/video/aYDfwUJzYQg/видео.html
busting your chops hoss, tryin' a make ya think. I'm here all week, tip your waitress.
Both excellent bands!
@@Axl_Pose all day hoss :)
Always look forward to having EC publishing another video. Makes my Sundays a little better.
I do have a limited data right now, but since a new ExplainingComputers video is up, I must watch it 😁👌
Thanks for watching! :)
If on limited mobile data just set the resolution to 360p
Thanks so much for the great content as always 😊, I needed some help flashing windows on my 8gb rpi-4 wor-flasher on windows never worked right even when writing on an SSD and all the other Linux tutorials were super confusing and didn't exactly work for me, been watching u since the collosus video I believe, love your channel man
Thanks for watching. :) Visiting Colossus seems so long ago now.
This is cool! I have Win11 ARM installed on my 16” MBP using Parallels. Which I think is the only place I’ll be installing Win11, for now.
Another great video - Thanks, Chris.
Oh and thank the snail for his/her input.
Nice Video Chris, thanks for all you do.
Wow that's amazing! Another great video, thank you Chris!
My birthday today, so this was a very interesting video. The fact that you can run Windoze at all on a PI is quite amazing. It seems to be reasonably responsive too, considering that Windoze 11 expects much more modern PC hardware and not an ARM SBC. Great video. Thanks for posting. Not had much luck trying to run Windoze apps under WINE in various Linux distros - I wonder how this setup would work with some Windoze application installs? I have a PI4, so perhaps I will try it out just for the purposes of experimentation.
I would put "a Windows 11 license" above "another pair of socks" in my "Top Ten List of Least Favourite Birthday Presents" - at least another pair of socks might be of use eventually.
I feel like we are slowly watching this man’s descent into madness. As he is doing this installation, he converses with snails about the meaning of life. He names his scissors. I’m just waiting for sock puppets he introduces as his most trusted friend then complains that it is not talking loudly enough for the mic to pick up the conversation he is hearing in his head.
They said Newton was mad. They said Einstein was mad. They said my Uncle Louis was mad.
Actually, they were right on that one. Uncle Louis was mad as a box of hornets.
Great video, as always. To be honest, I probably won’t ever try this, but it’s nice to know that it’s possible.
Interesting possibilities for Rasberry. Thanks for the video.
Another excellent offering Christopher, but it does seem strange seeing that, a bit like sandals and socks...can be done, but I'll let others try it 🙂
Thank you!
LOL. Good point there. May not be the height of fashion but practical when you need to put on some footwear quickly and just don't have the time or energy to find your shoes. ;-)
@@dang48 Aha, so now I know what Linus of LTT's secret account is.
@@anon_y_mousse :D
Agree. Cool to see but since I don't run Windows on my desktop, I'll certainly not bother doing it on my Pi 4.
Fascinating! I'm surprised it was able to run that well.
This was interesting. I think Windows 11 would likely best fit on a proper X86/X64 based SBC like some of the other's you've shown on the channel. Full props to the folks who got it working!
Well, yes, and that makes all the more sense now we cannot get Pi's at their proper price anyway. A latte Panda V1 4GB/64GB is 159 USD (139 EUR/122 GBP) now, which is less than what scalpers will have you pay for a Pi 4. To be sure, it is not exactly a powerhouse with its Atom processor, but for some purposes, it will do the job and properly supports Windows.
@@BilisNegra
The Latte Panda would certainly be more powerful than an RPi4, even with the limitation of the Atom SOC, which(if we're being fair) isn't a garbage SOC.
Nice already Sunday I love your raspberry pi videos
Greetings!
Another great and very informative video.For people who are just starting out with this tech, Explaining Computers is the best place to start.
Thank you Chris. This is an amazing development.
Thanks for the information, I quite interested in Windows on arm
I have to admit, I was surprised how well it worked on the Pi.
Hey Chris, I really enjoy your videos.
Glad you like them!
Wow. Another gem Chris. Thank you. Snails:2 MoT:1 Ducks:NIL
I love this guy thank you Chris for making good videos for over years
Thanks for watching. :)
It's Sunday already?
Greetings Chris. This is an interesting video.
Sunday seems to come around faster and faster!
That snail killed me... almost like Windows 11 killed your poor Pi.
Anyway, that is an impressive demo what is possible on todays SBCs. As a geek, I really appreciate this kind of videos. Thank you!
Thank you Chris for yet another interesting & informative video. Maybe in the not too distant future things will have developed to provide an ultra low power desktop capable of running Windows 12 or 13 (over to the dark side), he shivers now there's a thought. On the flip side I hope that Raspberry Pi will have matured further giving the competition a run for their money. :)
This is really cool in concept.
I wonder how windows 10 behaved in the pi.
There are theories on old windows too but probably with a virtual machine unlike this.
Great video.
Thanks for this. Windows 3.1 runs well on a Pi using DOSBox: ruclips.net/video/idHQk99E4VA/видео.html
Thanks for making such a great video!
Thank you so much for making this video tutorial
A really cool look.....thanks, Chris!
Great video for Raspberry Pi win 11 amazing it works. Learned something new and very interesting. thanks for sharing Peter, Love watching your videos.
Thanks Mike.
Thanks, I installed win 11 on one of my Rasp. following your video and everything works.. it's not a
rocket but it works ... Thanks .. Greetings from Florence
Greetings. A slow rocket! :)
Your video is very helpful.. thank you so much
thank for your channel. in this channcel every help my project .
That's cool I didn't think it would run as well as it did
I really hope ARM-based computer will be part of the industry because X86 hardware is so expensive in developing country.
And RISC-V too! :) 2023 will be an interesting year for non-x86 hardware.
Yeah, I will be quite happy to see them supporting various architecture including arm RISCV and MIPS and I hope they can run any old days x86 code by Virtual machines on any CPU architecture and for the new code I hope they can compile for all architecture (Write once, run anywhere), if I can't run all the old software on Windows any more, I have no reason to stay with Windows any more even they turn to arm based
That looks like fun. I'll dig out my Pi400 when I get home and give it a go.
Hi Graham -- this is indeed a fun project to try. And it worked far better than I expected.
An interesting runthrough Chris - just wish I could buy a Pi somewhere!
You channel is really good, thank you for the quality content
You are most welcome. Thanks for watching.
It will be interesting to review once video drivers are available to test DirectX compatibility on ARM. I appreciate you and the superb video.
Absolutely 👍
Fascinating! Amazing! A fairly easy Windows 11 install that anyone can do! Nearly unbelievable! Simply wow! I can do that! Looking forward to your next video!
Greetings Perry. I was amazed that this worked so well.
@@ExplainingComputers A teen created it!
Thanks, Chris! I've known about this for a number of years, but nevertheless, it's great to see this demonstrated.
Interesting and well presented thanks.
Greetings! :)
That's neat you can run windows 11 on the raspberry pi Chris! Thanks for always sharing with us!👍💖😎JP
No problem 👍
Excellent video now my Sunday is complete!!
22H2 ARM build which is in public release is first ARM build for the masses (Windows insider).
Tested mostly on MBP M1. Though did try once on PI 4 8GB. Must test on my Pi
Seems stable. Hope the next version of PI can support windows in usable way.
Why not the other way around?
@@kevinshumaker3753 would be great too.
Great video as always! Hope that snail was nice.
Tasty, with lots of garlic...
@@kevinshumaker3753 Poor snail! 😔😅
Thanks for your support. One of the snails is still mulling around somewhere.
@@ExplainingComputers You're very much welcome! And that's great to hear. 🐌❤️
The video is was waiting for months is finally here
I got there in the end! :) I did a lot of checking on the legal side of this.
@@ExplainingComputers I knew that you might be checking the legal side this project that's you were bit late on making this amazing video
Talk to a snail, Chris? Like that bit of sarcasm. Looks like those guys @WoR did a great job. Amazing how well Win11 runs on a Pi4.
Excellent and useful explanation, thank you May God Bless.
Interesting to see, even if I really don't use windows anymore. Another good video.
6:40 Now unlocking his Windows machine is a cakewalk while Chris chats with a passing snail 😂 BTW, great video as always Sir.
You are such a treasure to the entire world-wide computer community, sir. This new video is very interesting and actually a quite amazing development for demonstrating the incredible power and versatility of the Raspberry Pi computing platform. Thank you so much for producing it! You might consider making one small change in your video though. A more accurate title for it would be something along the lines of "How To Ruin An Otherwise Perfectly Good Raspberry Pi Computer." Except for that one tiny cavil, I cannot find anything to criticize in your video. You didn't even annoy us with the phrase, "magic of film-making" this time. Please carry on as usual then, our Good Dr. Barnatt!
Fortunately, you don’t really ruin the computer, but it could have been titled “How to waste a 32 GB SD card and 3-4 hours of your time!”. Of course, you can always overwrite that SD card, but the time is lost forever, other than educational benefits.
I've just re-watched this video on a Pi400 running Windows 11. But I can't "customise" it to get audio over HDMI without activating it with a license key. Most impressive. A couple of hints: don't try to do the download over a slow link, don't try to install to a slow usb drive.
Just go insider and run Windows test versions for free. That's what I'd do.
Life-changing talks with a snail 🐌👌
Impressive! Thank you for this.
Thanks for making the video idea I suggested 😀
No problem! :) It was an interesting thing to try.
Thank you very much for another great video 🤩👋👋
Hey Chris, thanks for the splendid (as always) video. Have you tried installing Microsoft office on the pi? And it would be rather interesting to install windows again on another pi from an SSD this time and compare the two pi's to check whether there is a difference in performance between them.
That was a good looking brew!
It was.
A big thing for this kind of processor architectures (ARM and RISC-V) over x86-64 and IA-86 (which we still use for majority of computers today) is that not only it benefits for small package design, portability, and energy usage, but also in ARM-based operating systems will have their own benefits in mobile operating systems (things like idling/standby with lowest power possible, asymmetric process, and others).
Unfortunately, majority of Windows applications were not optimized for ARM (or sluggish when running it on emulation), compared to macOS' Rosetta 2 emulation and Universal 2 binary (one app with both Intel and ARM bits). It would be grateful to see if majority of the Windows apps were fully optimized for ARM, just like the Universal 2 binary's up to.
Windows has never been optimised on anything - it has always been a bloated mess.
Amazing Chris, thanks for sharing!
What we really need is Win11 on Arm running on an Apple Silicon Mac. Then we can have Bootcamp back. But this is definitely a step in the right direction. Thanks for the video.
It does run already. and pretty well. It's just not officially supported or licensed by Microsoft yet (hope they will do so one day so you can run it without breaking any laws).
@@user-xr3rb6pn9m oh, does it? I thought Microsoft had specifically done something to prevent it from running on Apple silicon.
@@LMacNeill Microsoft hasn't done anything beyond, well, refusing to do anything. Windows doesn't specifically block Apple Silicon in any way, it just hasn't got the right drivers. And it is completely legal and within Terms of Service to run Windows on an Apple Silicon Mac -- Apple does not restrict you from installing other operating systems, and Microsoft does not restrict you from running Windows on unsupported platforms. But neither will they raise a finger to help make it work, so it will be up to a third party.
@@PixlRainbow I swear I read somewhere that Microsoft and Qualcomm had signed an exclusivity agreement, such that Microsoft was not allowed to license Windows on any ARM SoC that wasn't made by Qualcomm. Am I remembering that wrong?
I recently bought a 10 year old desktop PC, pre-installed with Windows 10, to run the few Windows programs I haven't found Linux replacements for. As it has a built-in power supply and hard disk, it was cheaper than buying a Pi (even at pre chip shortage prices!), power supply and SSD. And it's faster. None of the programs I use have ARM versions, so I'd have lost out on speed even more with a Pi. Neither solution is ideal, but I think what I've done is the better option for me.
Out of curiosity, what Windows programs do you use that you can't or won't replace with OS equivalents?
@@anon_y_mousse SCARM, Templot, LaserGRBL, Silhouette Studio, VT Transaction +. 3D view in SCARM won't work in Linux, VT won't work in WINE, Templot runs nicely in WINE, but when I'm using a couple of programs that won't it seems pointless to install it just for that, as I rarely use it. None of my Linux machines are really powerful enough to run a VM, and it complicates them. I'm currently undecided between LaserGRBL and Lightburn, that does have a Linux version. It's just less hassle to run them all in Windows rather than WINE or a VM in Linux. I want to use them, not spend ages trying to tweak things to try to get them to run totally reliably!
@@EcoHamletsUK Interesting. What tools do SCARM and Templot provide that you use which a regular CAD program doesn't have? Why would running LaserGRBL and Lightburn as native builds for Linux work differently from their Windows builds? Could you use Inkscape and replace Silhouette Studio? Could you use LibreOffice Calc to replace VT Transaction, possibly using templates?
Almost every Pi 4 project on the net has someone posting “why not use a refurbished PC” comment. I have just replaced a Xeon E3 server with a Pi 4 when I calculated it will cost me £150 a year in electricity compared to £10 for a Pi doing the same task. I continue to run a Windows laptop for Office apps as life is too short (I’m 70+) to learn LibreOffice. However the #1 reason for using a Pi is that it’s FUN.
@@paulmilligan3007 Fair point, but LibreOffice isn't drastically different from MS Office. Unless you're a power user there's not a lot to learn. Maybe give it a shot on your Windows laptop and if you like it, maybe switch full time to it and perhaps even install a Linux distro on that laptop?
I'll look at it on a 8GB unit. Just want to be able to change the music of my apple devises, and not just download the photos (which is the only thing I can do through Linux to date)... Great as always. Christopher, I just hope Itunes can be installed.
I think windows 11 is terrible for all users because of this gated content via microsoft account but using it on arm is a genius move. 10 years late but still a genius move.
Great video by the way.
My friend is over my house snd now I am making sure he is enjoying this video
Excellent!
I immediately thought of "Flash Gordon" where the marquee text says something like "you will enjoy, or else!!"
I'm sleep deprived, forgive me.
@@djtyros i have no idea what the original this is but what you described was me lol
@@player07441 Watch the film "Flash Gordon" from 1980. dont look it up first, enjoy the surprise of a cult classic.
@@djtyros From tvtropes: At Ming's wedding, ships fly two banners in the background. The first says "All creatures shall make merry". The second says "Under pain of death".
Funny, i did exactly the same few weeks ago, don't install the available updates though or the pi won't boot anymore.
I think if they could implement the GPU drivers this would already massively increase the performance even more.
All together i was impressed by it running and hope to see more of it soon.
I’m overall impressed about Windows on Arm64. I’m running Windows on Arm64 via Parallels on my M1 Macbook. And they have now released a preview of Visual Studio 2022 running natively.
Hopefully, there will be a high-end Raspberry Pi or similar capable to meet those capabilities of M1. I’m sure Microsoft is seeing opportunities with RPi as the hardware evolves.
I am afraid M1 cores are "performance" cores with Apple's inclusions so it's not that cheap manufacturing costs cutting Broadcom CPU....
If they ever build something like an M1 comparable chip, it's probably going to end up even more expensive than the M1 Mac Mini. And I'm not about to pay 700$ for an ARM SBC.
@@kjjustinXD why not? only 10 times more than average SBC 🤣🤣
@@ran2wild370 for 700$ i can buy an Intel NUC and just disassemble it until only the Mainboard is left and call that an SBC 🤣
And I will probably have less driver issues along the way.
Microsoft seizes every opportunity to crowbar their bloated and privacy-hating OSes on platforms that don't need them in the first place.
Very interesting Christopher, thanks for sharing
Thanks Brian, great to see you here. :)
that "tea time" transition was smooth..
Great video, found that really interesting
You are the Best! Thanks for share.
I was just about to check for the latest video, and up pops the notification.
Wow! :) RUclips is working.
Great video as usual. Have you tried Cpect emulator on a PI yet? It is the Spectrum Next emulator. With your tech background it would be interesting
Now this I must try! Noted with thanks.
Windows on arm ) I think that drives the final nail into "linux-as-desktop" coffin... So good!
Another great video. Thank you Chris. When you had a tea break I saw a chocolate bar. What kind was it and was it your favourite? If not do you have a favourite? I am from Canada and did not recognize the brand. This kind of detail I find interesting as it adds to the detail and memories for a real person hosting a weekly show on youtube. Enjoy the week and I hope to see another video very soon.
I think it was a Yorkie bar. :)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yorkie_(chocolate_bar)