Also, the Beast is technically the Ruler of that Castle being a Cursed Prince! I'll be honest, Maurice was trespassing on HIS territory. Since he's the Ruler, he can do whatever he wants to whoever trespasses. The Kidnapping and False Imprisonment charges should indeed be dropped! Also also, Lumière invited Maurice AGAINST the Beast's will! It is Lumière who should be charged here with Disobedience towards a Monarch. I'll DEFO give him the Coercion though because starving someone is indeed a crime.
Actually kidnapping is defined by _unlawful seizure or detention of a person by force, fraud or coercion._ The Beast detained an unwilling Maurice in the carriage, regardless of where the carriage was going, therefore taking away his autonomy. But a lawyer could say that the Beast could have just turned Maurice out at the gate and putting him in the carriage was a kindness However given that the Beast is actually Prince Adam, it would make him the authority figure in the area, also no harm came to Maurice except a bit of sickness, so he wouldn't be charged. And Maurice _was_ trespassing. Then again, a court could argue he was in imminent danger (wolves) and was invited in by a resident of the castle (Lumiere). He wasn't to know that he wasn't welcome. Bit of both sides there and I like the debate...
well with what i learned about how kidnapping works, it's a common thing for kidnappers to not let their victims see where they're taken. their victims can get disoriented when trying to escape from captivity, it's basically how the kidnappers can take advantage of that. and for Maurice, his face wasn't covered up or that the windows of that spider like carriage wasn't concealed either, so he was able to see where he's being taken, which is surely the village where he belongs anyway.
"You could say that this is not Kidnapping but a Guy in an Ice Cream Truck can do the same thing"? What about a Suspicious-Looking White Van with the Label "Free Candy" on it?🤣
Technically, Robinhood would also get a rack-up on embezzlement charges (He Robs the Rich and Gives to the Poor) even if it was for the purpose of paying King Richard's ransom.
@@z-ro1641 I understand that, however I feel that it could be argued in court in this way. Either way, Beast could have simply kicked him out instead of falsely imprisoning him and leaving him in cruel conditions
It is not really kidnapping when the Beast sent Maurice back to the village, because that is where Maurice lives anyway, and it is a relatively small town in respects. Peter Pan is just a boy in appearance and in a set personality, he has little understanding about what laws are applied on Earth and he does not want any strange grownups to know about the magic of Neverland, so Peter Pan had no real choice, but to sneak into the Nursery to find his shadow and everyone who knows the story of Peter Pan would understand that his real purpose for stopping near open windows was to hear stories being told by the grownups of the households to their own children so that he could relay the stories to the Lost Boys and also because none of the Lost Boys knew any stories. Because, Peter's story was about something that happened prior to Wendy's time in the story; How are we to know that cutting off Hook's hand wasn't defense on his part? I'd call it innocent until proven guilty for that one. Hook attacked Peter first in that battle at Skull Island, so technically Hook is the one to be given the Attempted Murder charge.
I count that Captain Hook impersonation Peter Pan did as Identity Fraud, same with Robinhood impersonating the other guards of the king’s castle including the bear guard.
Objection, your honor! Despite his masculine build after his training montage, Hercules is a Minor throughout this entire story. Even if we make the argument that he is first shown as a one-year-old, the climax happens sixteen years later. At most that would make him 17 and a few months, at minimum, without the argument, 16. A citizen cannot be charged for any crime, unless it's a serious offense such as murder, until their 18th birthday. They may be shunned and persecuted by the people, but the courts have no legal standing.
Technically; Hercules is supposed to take place in Ancient times; all the elements shown in Disney movies like this one and Aladdin were timeline inconsistences; so, driving laws would be virtually non-existent for several thousands of years, even if you were driving a chariot, and animal protection laws didn't exist in those times either. And what happened with the Donkey was an accident, but Hercules did save her life and he did apologize sincerely. The Property damage was accidental too, as Hercules has had trouble controlling his strength, due to lack of body mass to counterweight his lack of density. Animated Courtroom, you are being quite as harsh on 'skinny-teen' Hercules as the towns people were. That didn't look like intended assault on Phil; he was just overexcited to get his hero training and that was meant to be a handshake, because 'again' he just hasn't mastered control of his strength; it is only when we get to his muscular stage, that law offenses really count, like the scene when Hercules damaged Phil's Gym equipment and the scene when he did assault him over the matter of Megara, just before Hades' appearance to bargain with him.
Request If Family Guy characters being charged for their crimes 1. Peter Griffin 2. Stewie Griffin 3. Brian Griffin 4. Giant Chicken 5. Glenn Quagmire 6. Cleveland Brown 7. Joe Swanson 8. James Woods
13:18 she knocked on the door and asked if anyone was home, so it wasn’t breaking and entering, although she did not have permission to enter the house, so it is just another trespass crime.
@@miscellaneoussarnian5282I thought his wife was given a poisoned tunic by a centaur (who wanted the wife) which was what drove Heracles mad. Although I'm pretty sure that Hera was involved somewhere
@@jarlairess Heracles killed Megara. It was Deianira who was tricked Nessus into poisoning Heracles the murder of Megara was the reason why Heracles went on his famous 12 labours of Slaying Nemean Lion, Slaying the Lernaean Hydra, capturing the Ceryneian Hind, capturing the Erymanthian Boar, cleaning the Augean Stables, slaying the Stymphalian Birds, capturing the Cretan Bull (which Theseus later killed once the Minotaur’s father was released), stealing the Mares of Diomedes, obtaining Hippolyta’s Gridle, stealing Geryon’s Red Cattle, picking the Hesperides’ Golden Apples, and retrieving Kerberos
Would peter really be charged for much of anything. After all, he's technically and developmentally a juvenile, as nobody can grow up in never land. And his enemies who he harms are outlaw pirates as someone else pointed out
Lumiere invited a stranger into the Beast's castle WITHOUT his permission. A servant can't just let stranger sit on the owner's main furniture without his knowledge. Therefore Beast did have a right to imprison him
4:25 Objection. What about the taming and romance. And then there's the matter of their lives getting better after the curse was broken. Not to mention the royalty aspect.
Uuuuhhhh... 2:54 Lumiere invited Beauty Father without the Beast permission, and Lumiere was well aware he was NOT suppossed to invite people without the Beast permission, as Cogsworth actually brought up the Beast would not like that, but Lumiere and the others ignored that detail when brought up.
To be fair Robin Hood is doing this for his kingdom and it's people because the tax by the prince is unfair as he is knowingly taxing the poor knowing that they are not able to provide for themselves to survive and Robin Hood is never charged by the true rulers of the kingdom so he was likely pardoned of all charges against him by the princes parents before they sent him to hard labour for his crimes.
Nice!😊 Next: Pixar heroes that I suggested, Cuphead, Mugman, and the Devil from The Cuphead Show! (Netflix), and Cricket Green from Big City Greens & Big City Greens the Movie: Spacecation.
What If Disney Heroes Were CHARGED For Their Crimes? In considering the hypothetical scenario where Disney heroes were charged for their crimes, it is essential to analyze the actions of these characters within their respective narratives and the moral implications of those actions. Many Disney heroes, while often portrayed as virtuous and noble, have engaged in behavior that could be interpreted as criminal or morally questionable. This analysis will explore several key characters and their potential charges based on their actions. 1. Aladdin: Theft and Deception Aladdin, from “Aladdin,” is a classic example of a hero who engages in theft. He steals bread to survive and later steals a magic lamp from the Cave of Wonders. While his intentions may be noble-helping himself and others-his actions could lead to charges of theft and deception. The legal system might categorize his initial acts as petty theft due to his socioeconomic status, but stealing the lamp could be viewed as grand theft due to its value. 2. Mulan: Disguise and Desertion Mulan’s story involves her disguising herself as a man to take her father’s place in the army, which raises questions about identity fraud and desertion. In many legal systems, enlisting under false pretenses can lead to serious consequences, including charges related to military law. Additionally, her initial act of leaving home without permission could be seen as desertion or abandonment. 3. Hercules: Property Damage In “Hercules,” our hero battles various monsters and villains throughout his journey. However, these battles often result in significant property damage-whether it’s collapsing buildings or destroying landscapes during fights. If Hercules were charged with property damage or reckless endangerment, he might face penalties for the collateral damage caused by his heroic deeds. 4. Peter Pan: Abduction Peter Pan’s adventures in Neverland involve taking children away from their homes without parental consent. This act could be classified as abduction or kidnapping under modern laws. While Peter’s intentions are not malicious-he seeks companionship-the legal ramifications of removing children from their families would likely lead to serious charges. 5. The Incredibles: Vigilantism The Parr family from “The Incredibles” operates outside the law as vigilantes after superheroes are banned. Their actions against criminals could lead to charges of vigilantism, which is illegal in most jurisdictions because it undermines lawful authority and can lead to chaos in society. 6. Pocahontas: Interference with Government Affairs Pocahontas’ involvement with John Smith during a time of conflict between Native Americans and European settlers raises complex issues regarding interference with government affairs and potential treason against her tribe’s interests. Her actions might be scrutinized under laws concerning loyalty to one’s nation or community. Conclusion If Disney heroes were charged for their crimes based on their narratives, they would face various legal challenges depending on the nature of their actions. Each character embodies traits that complicate traditional notions of heroism when viewed through a legal lens; thus, while they may be celebrated for their bravery and good intentions, they also engage in behaviors that could warrant serious legal repercussions. The probability that this analysis accurately reflects how Disney heroes might be charged for their crimes is high due to the logical examination of each character’s actions within a legal framework.
Video idea: If Dr. K (The sort of villain of changed special edition) was charged for his crimes. This would be Interesting because the character is from an video game. Also if you wondering how to see the whole game without paying for it there is lots of videos of the full game
that kidnapping charge wasn't a crime, he was taking him back to his home, besides it's only kidnapping if the victim is taken to someplace unknown.
Also, the Beast is technically the Ruler of that Castle being a Cursed Prince! I'll be honest, Maurice was trespassing on HIS territory. Since he's the Ruler, he can do whatever he wants to whoever trespasses. The Kidnapping and False Imprisonment charges should indeed be dropped!
Also also, Lumière invited Maurice AGAINST the Beast's will! It is Lumière who should be charged here with Disobedience towards a Monarch.
I'll DEFO give him the Coercion though because starving someone is indeed a crime.
@@MALEMization yeah good point, the prince's staff had let Maurice in without his permission directly, so putting him in jail is justifiable enough.
Actually kidnapping is defined by _unlawful seizure or detention of a person by force, fraud or coercion._
The Beast detained an unwilling Maurice in the carriage, regardless of where the carriage was going, therefore taking away his autonomy. But a lawyer could say that the Beast could have just turned Maurice out at the gate and putting him in the carriage was a kindness
However given that the Beast is actually Prince Adam, it would make him the authority figure in the area, also no harm came to Maurice except a bit of sickness, so he wouldn't be charged. And Maurice _was_ trespassing.
Then again, a court could argue he was in imminent danger (wolves) and was invited in by a resident of the castle (Lumiere). He wasn't to know that he wasn't welcome.
Bit of both sides there and I like the debate...
well with what i learned about how kidnapping works, it's a common thing for kidnappers to not let their victims see where they're taken.
their victims can get disoriented when trying to escape from captivity, it's basically how the kidnappers can take advantage of that.
and for Maurice, his face wasn't covered up or that the windows of that spider like carriage wasn't concealed either, so he was able to see where he's being taken, which is surely the village where he belongs anyway.
"You could say that this is not Kidnapping but a Guy in an Ice Cream Truck can do the same thing"?
What about a Suspicious-Looking White Van with the Label "Free Candy" on it?🤣
Pirates are outlaws, so you can't be prosecuted for harming them.
4:25 He'll Serve Decent Years Behind Bars Unlike The Villain Counterpart
Technically, Robinhood would also get a rack-up on embezzlement charges (He Robs the Rich and Gives to the Poor) even if it was for the purpose of paying King Richard's ransom.
Lumiere is a servant of the castle not the master, Beast is. Therefore he needs permission from the Beast
Yes, but Monsieur Maurice couldn't have known that. He was still invited in
@@largedarkrooster6371 That’s like saying going into someone’s house invited by the maid of it without the real owner’s knowledge
@@z-ro1641 I understand that, however I feel that it could be argued in court in this way. Either way, Beast could have simply kicked him out instead of falsely imprisoning him and leaving him in cruel conditions
It is not really kidnapping when the Beast sent Maurice back to the village, because that is where Maurice lives anyway, and it is a relatively small town in respects.
Peter Pan is just a boy in appearance and in a set personality, he has little understanding about what laws are applied on Earth and he does not want any strange grownups to know about the magic of Neverland, so Peter Pan had no real choice, but to sneak into the Nursery to find his shadow and everyone who knows the story of Peter Pan would understand that his real purpose for stopping near open windows was to hear stories being told by the grownups of the households to their own children so that he could relay the stories to the Lost Boys and also because none of the Lost Boys knew any stories.
Because, Peter's story was about something that happened prior to Wendy's time in the story; How are we to know that cutting off Hook's hand wasn't defense on his part? I'd call it innocent until proven guilty for that one.
Hook attacked Peter first in that battle at Skull Island, so technically Hook is the one to be given the Attempted Murder charge.
I count that Captain Hook impersonation Peter Pan did as Identity Fraud, same with Robinhood impersonating the other guards of the king’s castle including the bear guard.
Objection, your honor! Despite his masculine build after his training montage, Hercules is a Minor throughout this entire story. Even if we make the argument that he is first shown as a one-year-old, the climax happens sixteen years later. At most that would make him 17 and a few months, at minimum, without the argument, 16. A citizen cannot be charged for any crime, unless it's a serious offense such as murder, until their 18th birthday. They may be shunned and persecuted by the people, but the courts have no legal standing.
Video idea: if SML villains were charged with crimes
That takes a lot of hours to do. I requested if he could charge Chris McLean and even if he doesn’t, I can understand..
What sml
@@ITMARSHY A Super Mario Logan
there's 2 versions of sml. nintendo plushies and human puppets.
@@Shield-Scopebro he literary did like yt villans before which was 1 hour long
Technically; Hercules is supposed to take place in Ancient times; all the elements shown in Disney movies like this one and Aladdin were timeline inconsistences; so, driving laws would be virtually non-existent for several thousands of years, even if you were driving a chariot, and animal protection laws didn't exist in those times either. And what happened with the Donkey was an accident, but Hercules did save her life and he did apologize sincerely. The Property damage was accidental too, as Hercules has had trouble controlling his strength, due to lack of body mass to counterweight his lack of density. Animated Courtroom, you are being quite as harsh on 'skinny-teen' Hercules as the towns people were. That didn't look like intended assault on Phil; he was just overexcited to get his hero training and that was meant to be a handshake, because 'again' he just hasn't mastered control of his strength; it is only when we get to his muscular stage, that law offenses really count, like the scene when Hercules damaged Phil's Gym equipment and the scene when he did assault him over the matter of Megara, just before Hades' appearance to bargain with him.
Request
If Family Guy characters being charged for their crimes
1. Peter Griffin
2. Stewie Griffin
3. Brian Griffin
4. Giant Chicken
5. Glenn Quagmire
6. Cleveland Brown
7. Joe Swanson
8. James Woods
13:18 she knocked on the door and asked if anyone was home, so it wasn’t breaking and entering, although she did not have permission to enter the house, so it is just another trespass crime.
Disney villains to be charged for their crimes (Lady Tremaine, Jafar, Gaston, Claude Frollo, and Hades), please 🙏
The word MR SHIMMME made me laugh so hard😂
3:02 Objection, your honor. Lumiere had no right to do so, as Cogsworth warned. This makes the beast in the right.
dang you always get these vids out fast, mad respect to you sir!!
Prince John: How dare you not my sword 🗡 out of my hand ✋! Now you treated me like a coward!
Idea:If Paw Patrol Movie Villains where Charged for Their Crimes
in greek myth. Heracles accidentally killed his music teacher.
And his Wife and Kids (albeit under a spell put by Hera)
@@miscellaneoussarnian5282I thought his wife was given a poisoned tunic by a centaur (who wanted the wife) which was what drove Heracles mad. Although I'm pretty sure that Hera was involved somewhere
@@jarlairess Heracles killed Megara. It was Deianira who was tricked Nessus into poisoning Heracles
the murder of Megara was the reason why Heracles went on his famous 12 labours of Slaying Nemean Lion, Slaying the Lernaean Hydra, capturing the Ceryneian Hind, capturing the Erymanthian Boar, cleaning the Augean Stables, slaying the Stymphalian Birds, capturing the Cretan Bull (which Theseus later killed once the Minotaur’s father was released), stealing the Mares of Diomedes, obtaining Hippolyta’s Gridle, stealing Geryon’s Red Cattle, picking the Hesperides’ Golden Apples, and retrieving Kerberos
@@miscellaneoussarnian5282mythology doesn’t seem to canon at all.
@@KadeStringer2.0 I know. Tantalus tried to steal the dog forged by Hephaestus that guarded a Baby Zeus
Peter could live throughout those entire years becuase in where peter lives he never ages
Would peter really be charged for much of anything. After all, he's technically and developmentally a juvenile, as nobody can grow up in never land. And his enemies who he harms are outlaw pirates as someone else pointed out
7:46 Whoa! Robin! Digging the new threads!
13:18 It's just Entering Without Permission, I'll Give Both Like Days of Jail
Lumiere invited a stranger into the Beast's castle WITHOUT his permission. A servant can't just let stranger sit on the owner's main furniture without his knowledge. Therefore Beast did have a right to imprison him
0:24 Does it really count as driving when one is running?
1:15 that was an accident what Hercules did
The Beast was pardoned because he was married with Belle ✅
Video idea Disney pets charged for their crimes
You know what would be great? A video game series where protagonist/antagonists were charged for their crimes.
4:29 Yeah... I got nothing. He's technically a minor, but given his apparent immortality, who knows how old he really is.
Idea: What if Avatar: The Last Airbender villains/heroes were charged for their crimes?
Everyone: death penalty.
Even Iroh. Treason.
Can you charge the villains and characters of Pete's Dragon and Frankenweenie for their crimes please
4:25 Objection. What about the taming and romance. And then there's the matter of their lives getting better after the curse was broken. Not to mention the royalty aspect.
This one is so funny for hook calling crocodile
Peter Pan, I laughed with him because I laugh on that codfish hook that’s I love to make jokes
Also Florian is 31 whilst Snow White is 14
Video idea: If Batman Arkham were charged for his crimes
Maybe you should do a video explaining in depth the various charges these characters face.
Video idea if Alta and loķ villains were charged for their crimes
Nostalgic Beauty And The Beast 1991
Uuuuhhhh... 2:54 Lumiere invited Beauty Father without the Beast permission, and Lumiere was well aware he was NOT suppossed to invite people without the Beast permission, as Cogsworth actually brought up the Beast would not like that, but Lumiere and the others ignored that detail when brought up.
6:04 "Great voice acting." lol Surprised you're not going for "ID fraud".
Hercules Is The Best Hero In Disney
If nickelodeon villains were charged for their crimes
Idea: If Meta Runner Villains were charged for their crimes (Evelyn, Lucks, Sheridan]
To be fair Robin Hood is doing this for his kingdom and it's people because the tax by the prince is unfair as he is knowingly taxing the poor knowing that they are not able to provide for themselves to survive and Robin Hood is never charged by the true rulers of the kingdom so he was likely pardoned of all charges against him by the princes parents before they sent him to hard labour for his crimes.
Video idea: if animated RUclipsrs were charged for their crimes
The bounty has spoken 12:26 🦊✅
Damn just uploaded? Nice!
Wait, why is Robin Hood being charged for crimes committed by Little John too?😂
Lol
The good guy beast. He always become the prince from Disney. Not a clue.
Nice!😊 Next: Pixar heroes that I suggested, Cuphead, Mugman, and the Devil from The Cuphead Show! (Netflix), and Cricket Green from Big City Greens & Big City Greens the Movie: Spacecation.
What If Disney Heroes Were CHARGED For Their Crimes?
In considering the hypothetical scenario where Disney heroes were charged for their crimes, it is essential to analyze the actions of these characters within their respective narratives and the moral implications of those actions. Many Disney heroes, while often portrayed as virtuous and noble, have engaged in behavior that could be interpreted as criminal or morally questionable. This analysis will explore several key characters and their potential charges based on their actions.
1. Aladdin: Theft and Deception
Aladdin, from “Aladdin,” is a classic example of a hero who engages in theft. He steals bread to survive and later steals a magic lamp from the Cave of Wonders. While his intentions may be noble-helping himself and others-his actions could lead to charges of theft and deception. The legal system might categorize his initial acts as petty theft due to his socioeconomic status, but stealing the lamp could be viewed as grand theft due to its value.
2. Mulan: Disguise and Desertion
Mulan’s story involves her disguising herself as a man to take her father’s place in the army, which raises questions about identity fraud and desertion. In many legal systems, enlisting under false pretenses can lead to serious consequences, including charges related to military law. Additionally, her initial act of leaving home without permission could be seen as desertion or abandonment.
3. Hercules: Property Damage
In “Hercules,” our hero battles various monsters and villains throughout his journey. However, these battles often result in significant property damage-whether it’s collapsing buildings or destroying landscapes during fights. If Hercules were charged with property damage or reckless endangerment, he might face penalties for the collateral damage caused by his heroic deeds.
4. Peter Pan: Abduction
Peter Pan’s adventures in Neverland involve taking children away from their homes without parental consent. This act could be classified as abduction or kidnapping under modern laws. While Peter’s intentions are not malicious-he seeks companionship-the legal ramifications of removing children from their families would likely lead to serious charges.
5. The Incredibles: Vigilantism
The Parr family from “The Incredibles” operates outside the law as vigilantes after superheroes are banned. Their actions against criminals could lead to charges of vigilantism, which is illegal in most jurisdictions because it undermines lawful authority and can lead to chaos in society.
6. Pocahontas: Interference with Government Affairs
Pocahontas’ involvement with John Smith during a time of conflict between Native Americans and European settlers raises complex issues regarding interference with government affairs and potential treason against her tribe’s interests. Her actions might be scrutinized under laws concerning loyalty to one’s nation or community.
Conclusion
If Disney heroes were charged for their crimes based on their narratives, they would face various legal challenges depending on the nature of their actions. Each character embodies traits that complicate traditional notions of heroism when viewed through a legal lens; thus, while they may be celebrated for their bravery and good intentions, they also engage in behaviors that could warrant serious legal repercussions.
The probability that this analysis accurately reflects how Disney heroes might be charged for their crimes is high due to the logical examination of each character’s actions within a legal framework.
Can you do The Shawshank Redemption heroes charge for their crimes
Video idea: If Dr. K (The sort of villain of changed special edition) was charged for his crimes. This would be Interesting because the character is from an video game. Also if you wondering how to see the whole game without paying for it there is lots of videos of the full game
0:03 He Commits Things a Villain would do, But not a Lot, Just Battery and Aggrevated Battery
What about Gwendolyn zapp from big greens the movie spacecation she did crimes
Can you do if loud house and casargrande villens were charged for their crimes?
The castle Snow White was entering was the one she lived in
At 10:08 why was the charge not added?
3:57 technically it’s reverse kidnapping
Next video idea if cw,s the flash was charged for his crimes just barry allen then the rest of the arrowverse heros
2:07 That's Mental Damage LOL
0:52 for this one, I think it’s on accident
Zero to hero 1:40 🦸🏻♂️💪🏻
Wasn't the fight with that water centures(apologies for misspelling) before the "Hey, I'm walking here!" scene?
And you sure there're no more possible charges Herc got after his heroing pardoned him from his previous charges?
Well, Beast is royalty, so his status overruled Luminaire's generosity, I guess.
Breaking and Entering that's it is there other crimes for Snow White?
THE BEAST YOU WILL SENTENCE TO JAIL 16 YEARS
Can you do if tasm villains were charged for their crimes
What video will you be doing tomorrow
Could you charge Wallace and gromit for their crimes?
I have never seen heracles and snowhite
Or Robin Hood and Peter pan
None of these haven’t committed any crimes
Early gang
👇
Can you do five nights a freddy's charters if they were chger four ther crimes
11 hours
Chrage sweet pete from chip n dale rescue rangers because he's a counterpart of peter pan
Video ended early? Why?
Peter Pan didn’t commit any crimes
R from r’s epic show when?
Disaster 1:12
Ok
First
Second
Technically snow white is a minor so she'd becharged as a minor