She placed 40th out of 40 with 4 points. While deserving to be in the top 5 of the GF. So technically yes, the most underrated entry. At least of the 2010s for sure. In my opinion, the only entry more underrated than this is Czech Republic 2007 which scored 42d out of 42 with just 1 point, while deserving to win the whole contest.
Bernhardina Hörnstein I completely agree with you! She was the WINNER this year for me! 12 points from Japan. You were amazing Melanie and you shone brighter than anyone else!
MmeKastaffiore Take into consideration that it's very hard to sing with some muscles of lower stomach and pelvis paralyzed, so she (Monika form Poland) simply cannot do as good as many other singers. In my opinion Melanie sings very good but the lyrics are awful. In short - Belgium should win this year.
I'm really surprised that this song isn't going into the final. The voice, music and lyrics are all fantastic. Still it's the best song for me. Many greetings from Russia.
I hope she will go in the final! She wrote lyrics, make music, she sings! And she looks so beautiful. Greetings from Bosnia and Herzegovina to Switzerland! For me, it's a good choice!
This is absolutly epic, Her vocals were amazing ! I still don't understand how it finish last... Switzerland is clearly the most underrated country ever (2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 & 2018 deserved Better)
Well actually agree.. as a Hungarian I always think that we were the most underrated than I realise that Switzerland actually had it worse... we were always at least qualified for the grand finale...I was nostalgia trippin and looked up this masterpiece and was shocked she did not even made it into the finale....
Did Europe fall asleep during her performance or what? I'm surprised she's not in the final. This song deserves to be in the final more than some others that had qualified. Best regards from Lithuania!
TrueElemental ASMR well, I don't dislike the cypriot song, but I just think that Ireland, Malta, and Iceland had better songs... It could have finished in 10th maybe
ottolamer Chusik doch! Deutschland und Österreich mussten gar nicht am Halbfinale teilnehmen, also ist dies deren Punktzahl. Außerdem, schlechter als 0 geht nicht und deshalb ist es so.
Mr D. nein, weil im Finale an sich schon die "Besseren" teilnehmen, und somit herrscht im Finale stärkere Konkurrenz. Aber egal wie mans anschaut, alle 3 waren scheisse obwohl sie gute lieder hatten
Mr D. But Switzerland is the last one, because she didn't made to the final (and has the lowest score from the 2 semi-finals). Germany and Austria are 26th and 27th out of the 40 countries.
I really don't understand how this song could not make it to the finals. Such a beatiful woman singing this beautiful song, the lights, the visual effects, everything is just perfect.
What a voice!!! What an amazing stage performance perfectly matching with the mood of the song!!! Melanie you definitely shined last night!!! Damn Greece was in 1st semifinal and i could not vote and surely deserved to qualify...
Are you talking about Euro Neuro xD? Then I would say Igranka (2013) is the most underrated entry from Montenegro! But we sure can add Melanie René to the list of most underrated entry list.
I enjoyed this performance. Cannot believe it is not in the final. At first I didn't like this song, but It has grown on me. Switzerland deserved to be in the final, really!. Well done Melanie & team! .
I'm so sad!! I love this song so much. Not fare it didn't qualify for the final. Love you Melanie! I got the song on ITunes, listening to it all the time now ;-)
Poor Mélanie René was really underrated. I thought she had a song to finish at least in the top 10. Her song was modern, catchy and well-written. I don't get how she could place last in the 2nd semi-final. Well, Switzerland can still be very proud of her. All the best for next year, from Germany! :)
I'm still bitter that she ended up last. :( Her voice, staging, emotions were perfect. Switzerland deserved at least top 15. Also, I LOVE 2:23, so powerful
I can't understand why she didn't qualified and I'm from Spain, I don't think she copied Edurne's dress change because Melanie didn't change her dress, she wears a cape over her dress.
+KAL EL yeah, I think so too.. 'Cause if you look at the points the different countries gave the others, many countries always give the same countries the most amount of points regardless of their performance..for example, (i don't want to offend anyone) the eastern countries hold together really well.. it's always the same, always has been and unfortunately it'll probably always stay the same..😪
Emmanuel Ibarra I understand why she didn't qualify. When I first heard the song i thought it's bad and didn't like it. I had to listen it a few times. Then i liked it.
I saw the ranking of the 2nd semi-final and what?! Switzerland being last with 4 points?!? o____O I don't think we were that bad even the Finnish group got at least 13 points for their song (not hating on Finland but our Swiss entry wasn't bad).
Never was one of my favourites but this was one of the best performances of the second semifinal, deserved to qualify. Thank you Europe one more time...
I really don't understand why this not deserve the Grand Final, are you crazy Europe, i still fan Melanie René! Stay tuned! Kisses from The Netherlands!❤️
Switzerland was one of my favourites and now they are out! :( I don't get it. She had a fantastic performance and the song was really good as well. I think this year's entry was even better than the Swiss entry in 2014. Good luck from Germany! :)
Yo cuando vi que solo quedaba un sitio y no habian pasado ni Suiza ni Malta ni Islandia tampoco Irlanda me puse venga Malta o Suiza pero escuche Israel y me quede comooooo? Lo mismo paso en la primera que no paso Bielorusia ni Holanda...
Avril Lavigne I was sure she will be there in the final. And if she not the winner- but for me she the best - I think she will be the second or the third place.
I reckon that people DID like the song but rather it wasnt their 1st or second. Because I've seen a video that compiled people's tops and Switzerland was 17th
Девушка очень красивая. Очень красивое и качественное выступление. Слова песни до глубины души зацепили. Очень жаль, что на не прошла в финал. :( The girl is very beautiful. Very beautiful and high-quality action. Lyrics deeply hooked. It is a pity that did not pass the final. :(
Eurovision top 10 OF ALL TIME: 1. Rhythm inside - Belgium 2. Calm after the storm - The Netherlands 3. Time to shine - Switzerland 4. City Lights - Belgium 5. Ghost - Germany 6. Lighthouse - Croatia 7. You and me - Switzerland 8. Grande Amore - Italy 9. Amar Pelos Dois - Portugal 10. Chidren of the Universe - United Kingdom
Switzerland should give her another chance in some way. She managed to take a hopeless song and made it look like a qualifier. Had this been in SF1 I'm sure she would be there on Saturday.
![Eurovision 2015 (Switzerland) : [WINNER] Mélanie René - Time to Shine (Live in national final)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sVsHEnJT92A/mqdefault.jpg)
Easily the most underrated entry of all-time. And no, being the most difficult year ever isn't an excuse for letting this piece of art out.
She placed 40th out of 40 with 4 points. While deserving to be in the top 5 of the GF. So technically yes, the most underrated entry. At least of the 2010s for sure.
In my opinion, the only entry more underrated than this is Czech Republic 2007 which scored 42d out of 42 with just 1 point, while deserving to win the whole contest.
Even if she had not passed, I will continue listening to this song, as I love it.
Lo mismo digo
David Sánchez MELANIE FANTASTIC SINGER AND ORIGINAL SONG AND PERFORMANCE :(:(
David Sánchez yo tbmn en serio
Hollandique Same
David Sánchez I still listen. ☺️
W I N N E R !! She was amazing and she is the winner in my eyes! We voted for this is Sweden and we love the song here. You are great, Melanie!!!
*in Sweden
Bernhardina Hörnstein I completely agree with you! She was the WINNER this year for me! 12 points from Japan. You were amazing Melanie and you shone brighter than anyone else!
Bernhardina Hörnstein The same over here! Melanie's song was far better than Cyprus' and many others. Robbed.
Greetings from Spain.
Bernhardina Hörnstein I also agree with you. She deserved the final so much. 12 Points from Germany for the real winner Melanie.
Switzerland is out and i am from switzerland 😢😢
17th in semi 2 with 4 points? Wtf?
-Vocals 10/10
-Staging 10/10
-Outfit 10/10
-Song overall 10/10
Europe, i need an explanation
THIS deserved pass to the final!
Yo tambien lo pienso
ESC - Spain. More than Poland or Cyprus, for sure. I'm sorry for the Polish lady, but her performance was really weak.
MmeKastaffiore
Instead of Cyprus. Poland deserved the pass.
ESC - Spain. I liked the studio version of Poland. But being honest, the performance was horrible.
MmeKastaffiore Take into consideration that it's very hard to sing with some muscles of lower stomach and pelvis paralyzed, so she (Monika form Poland) simply cannot do as good as many other singers.
In my opinion Melanie sings very good but the lyrics are awful. In short - Belgium should win this year.
what a shame they didn't pass.. i loved it! best swiss entry since 10 years.
I'm really surprised that this song isn't going into the final. The voice, music and lyrics are all fantastic. Still it's the best song for me. Many greetings from Russia.
In my opinion, the best song at the 2015 festival. I often return to the song.
2016 and still here. I loved this song so much..
Me too!!!😃
2017! :D
Ultraviolence June 2018
2020 😅🤣
2021
I hope she will go in the final! She wrote lyrics, make music, she sings! And she looks so beautiful.
Greetings from Bosnia and Herzegovina to Switzerland! For me, it's a good choice!
SHE WROTE IT? That actually makes this masterpiece of art even more underrated
Most underated song ever in the contest! I LOVE IT!
S W I T Z E R L A N D
M A L T A
You are the best!!!
WHY??? Really nice powerful song. WHY????????
Still don't understand why this and Belarus didn't qualify
And Malta
@Antonio Ferrara San Marino LOL
@Antonio Ferrara everyone in the final ... 😑😒😓😔
And Ireland
This is absolutly epic, Her vocals were amazing ! I still don't understand how it finish last... Switzerland is clearly the most underrated country ever (2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017 & 2018 deserved Better)
This comment could've been written by me lol 😁 Switzerland is my favourite country in ESC 🇨🇭
Well actually agree.. as a Hungarian I always think that we were the most underrated than I realise that Switzerland actually had it worse... we were always at least qualified for the grand finale...I was nostalgia trippin and looked up this masterpiece and was shocked she did not even made it into the finale....
2010 was good too imo…
2019,2021,2023 are also a little underrated
@@hehedutch2019? 4th place is not underrated
It's 2021 and I still can't believe this finished last in whole contest
2024 calling, we still can‘t believe
Did Europe fall asleep during her performance or what? I'm surprised she's not in the final. This song deserves to be in the final more than some others that had qualified. Best regards from Lithuania!
This song received 4 points at all, and the Cypriot one received almost 100. I'll never understand you, Europe
The same feelings
Leonardo Oliveira Azevedo I am half cypriot and i agree 100per cent. I mean its one of my favorite songs. Lots of positivity..
TrueElemental ASMR well, I don't dislike the cypriot song, but I just think that Ireland, Malta, and Iceland had better songs... It could have finished in 10th maybe
Μy thoughts exacly.. mabye. but for me when i heard it passed. i was like really?
This one wasn't so good
I voted her and I was so sad when she didn't passed! You deserved to go to the final, your song is amazing and so your voice.
What?! She is the last with the lowest points this year, 40/40?! I can not believe that x.x
I love this so much♥♥
JA vorallen die Top 3 haben sich viel zu schnell vom Rest abgesetzt, voll unspannend :(
ottolamer Chusik doch! Deutschland und Österreich mussten gar nicht am Halbfinale teilnehmen, also ist dies deren Punktzahl. Außerdem, schlechter als 0 geht nicht und deshalb ist es so.
das platziert sie trotzdem besser als alle die, die im Halbfinale ausgeschieden sind...
Mr D. nein, weil im Finale an sich schon die "Besseren" teilnehmen, und somit herrscht im Finale stärkere Konkurrenz. Aber egal wie mans anschaut, alle 3 waren scheisse obwohl sie gute lieder hatten
Mr D. But Switzerland is the last one, because she didn't made to the final (and has the lowest score from the 2 semi-finals). Germany and Austria are 26th and 27th out of the 40 countries.
Still one of my favorites ! Not deserved last place , she deserves to reach the final !!!! Switzerland this year deserves last place, not this year !
I really don't understand how this song could not make it to the finals. Such a beatiful woman singing this beautiful song, the lights, the visual effects, everything is just perfect.
What a voice!!! What an amazing stage performance perfectly matching with the mood of the song!!! Melanie you definitely shined last night!!! Damn Greece was in 1st semifinal and i could not vote and surely deserved to qualify...
Maybe the most underrated song in the history of Eurovision
Nurlan Ismayilov No, that's Montenegro 2012
Are you talking about Euro Neuro xD? Then I would say Igranka (2013) is the most underrated entry from Montenegro! But we sure can add Melanie René to the list of most underrated entry list.
+Nurlan Ismayilov i think with israel 2014.
Yes
Sure
I enjoyed this performance. Cannot believe it is not in the final.
At first I didn't like this song, but It has grown on me.
Switzerland deserved to be in the final, really!. Well done Melanie & team! .
I'm so sad!! I love this song so much. Not fare it didn't qualify for the final. Love you Melanie! I got the song on ITunes, listening to it all the time now ;-)
Poor Mélanie René was really underrated. I thought she had a song to finish at least in the top 10. Her song was modern, catchy and well-written. I don't get how she could place last in the 2nd semi-final. Well, Switzerland can still be very proud of her.
All the best for next year, from Germany! :)
I'm still bitter that she ended up last. :( Her voice, staging, emotions were perfect. Switzerland deserved at least top 15. Also, I LOVE 2:23, so powerful
Great vocals, perfect staging, beautiful singer and I haven't talked about the song itself yet. I still don't get it how this finished last.
Amazing song and amazing performance.
Last in this semi-final? I am really disappointed...
I can't understand why she didn't qualified and I'm from Spain, I don't think she copied Edurne's dress change because Melanie didn't change her dress, she wears a cape over her dress.
Emmanuel Ibarra neither do I, there were a lot of good performances and they chose Montenegro instead of this...
Felipe Welchz Montenegro was amazing. The weakest performances were Poland and Cyprus.
+KAL EL yeah, I think so too.. 'Cause if you look at the points the different countries gave the others, many countries always give the same countries the most amount of points regardless of their performance..for example, (i don't want to offend anyone) the eastern countries hold together really well.. it's always the same, always has been and unfortunately it'll probably always stay the same..😪
Chanti Becky that's really boring and unfair, it's killing slowly the contest.
Felipe Welchz didn't Melanie perform prior to Edurne?
5 years later, this is still my winner and one of the most underrated songs ever
Only 4 points?! Why Europe? I love the song ! :)
And thanks for 12 points in the televoting :)
Thanks for this song. 8 years has passed, but I still remember it. Love it!
Switzerland always underrated
Станислав Эвилвей even though they're the country that came up with this competition 😂😓
Well you did bring an AMAZING song this year :) sadly this year the 4 competition was very very strong aswell ! Big love to Gjon !
But this year they bring us GJON
that hasnt aged well
I love this song♥ Why it didn`t pass to the Final? WTF?
From Russia with love♥
Dasha Shesternina agree
Dasha Shesternina +100!
Dasha Shesternina Thank you russians !!! я вас люблю Russia should have won this year
I cried as i've heared that switzerland isnt in the final....but MELANIE, DU BISCH EUISI GWÜNNERIN!♥
Jaa!❤Si isch für üs d'Sigerin...❤
cuddlybear 00 Melani isch megaaaa gsie SWITZERLAND still wins :p
This is an amazing song and its message makes me want to cry. Shame on you, Europe!
A possible winner!! A Top 10 song, good luck!!
Surprised this didn't make it to the final. I liked this a lot.
This song deserved the final for sure..such a pity...love from greece!!
I saw her live and her voice is so powerfull
Я это видео уже раз 10 посмотрел, как же красиво развивается на ветру ее наряд, в этом видео всё красиво!!!
People voted for the countries and not for the songs.
Emmanuel Ibarra I understand why she didn't qualify. When I first heard the song i thought it's bad and didn't like it. I had to listen it a few times. Then i liked it.
We are from Russia and we love this song here. You are great, Melanie!!!
I saw the ranking of the 2nd semi-final and what?! Switzerland being last with 4 points?!? o____O
I don't think we were that bad even the Finnish group got at least 13 points for their song (not hating on Finland but our Swiss entry wasn't bad).
Calista-hime I'm from Finland and I will never understand people who like PKNP (Finnish entry), and I love your entry.❤️🇫🇮
I'm from Finland too and that sh*t song from "us" was worst song in eurovision history
@@katykate2230 They were 10th in televote and still finished last in semi xd
God damn, this song is amazing. That message behind it.. incredible!
Never was one of my favourites but this was one of the best performances of the second semifinal, deserved to qualify. Thank you Europe one more time...
Robbed :(
Here in Spain we love you Mélanie!! :)
Si en España nos gusta pero si lo piensas an pasado algunas que son una mierda y sera mas facil ganar aunque va a ser difil ganar
El problema es que esos países tienen a otros muchos alrededor que les apoyan...
Frank Jay Bee Si
***** Si, a pesar que tuviera una escena de vestuario similar a la de Edurne...
mikelennin El cambio de vestuario ha estado presente en eurovisión desde siempre, no es algo nuevo, ni copiado..
This song was the best!!! I all the time listen to it when going to the gym! Thank you for the song!!!
Юлиана Аскерова Me too ;-)
For me,this is the best song!!! Deserved to go to the final! Greetings from Serbia! :)
She deserved top 10!!! WHAT HAPPENED WITH YOU EUROPE???
I don't believe that she ended dead last! The song was amazing and entirely hers! Switzerland always underrated...
I really don't understand why this not deserve the Grand Final, are you crazy Europe, i still fan Melanie René! Stay tuned! Kisses from The Netherlands!❤️
Switzerland was one of my favourites and now they are out! :(
I don't get it. She had a fantastic performance and the song was really good as well.
I think this year's entry was even better than the Swiss entry in 2014.
Good luck from Germany! :)
The most underrating song of this contest! I still do not believe that she didn't qualify!!! It is dishonest.
Melanie performed with perfection in her voice. Vocals were passionate and clear. Sadly she did not make it because she was very deserving.
This song is so underrated! She deserves higher place😔
Cyprus in the final
Switzerland is not in the final
WHAT?
this is really shocking!... cyprus was so boring I almost fell a sleep
Yo cuando vi que solo quedaba un sitio y no habian pasado ni Suiza ni Malta ni Islandia tampoco Irlanda me puse venga Malta o Suiza pero escuche Israel y me quede comooooo?
Lo mismo paso en la primera que no paso Bielorusia ni Holanda...
Enrique González Lo mismo):
Avril Lavigne Europe is blind... I can't find another words...
Avril Lavigne I was sure she will be there in the final. And if she not the winner- but for me she the best - I think she will be the second or the third place.
Mélanié, tu as été merveilleuse! :D
You have been robbed! :S
underrated!Deserved top 3 in the final!!
For me its Eurovision absolutely WINNER!
VLADIMIR VOLKOV Well it's oficially dead last according to EBU for me it's not the best but surely it should qualify
She wasn't My winner but, come on europe!! Really 40/40? I'll never understand!
because switzerland is neutral country, switzerland not like greece and cyprus voting each other, switzerland has no allies, it's too hard to qualify
+bebi true story ...
Luigi Cioffi, 40/40= 1, so she was the winner
Eurovision Indonesia why you comment on about greece and cyprus while the most countries at the contest have over two allies for example scandinavia.
Because she performed next after Måns, maybe?
Switzerland is not in the Grand Final for only one reason: Europe (and Australia) are deaf!
I reckon that people DID like the song but rather it wasnt their 1st or second. Because I've seen a video that compiled people's tops and Switzerland was 17th
Hello from Poland!!! Poland give Switzerland 1 point :D
i loveeeeeeed this song!!!! so bad it didnt make it :(((((
It’s my motivation song. When I feel down it makes me feel OK
No puedo creer que no pasara a la final!! Sinceramente, era de mis 10 favoritas... Una lástima.... Muchos ánimos Melanie!!
Девушка очень красивая. Очень красивое и качественное выступление. Слова песни до глубины души зацепили. Очень жаль, что на не прошла в финал. :(
The girl is very beautiful. Very beautiful and high-quality action. Lyrics deeply hooked. It is a pity that did not pass the final. :(
Ольга Приписнова шикарная песня, жаль, что так мало за нее голосовали:( Почему?
This song is too good for Eurovision anyway! Not passing to the final is a compliment :)
Love from Estonia!
Ohh god. Eurovision must be deaf.
Melanie was glorious.
I love this song. That's the good thing - no matter if a song passes to the final, wins or not, you still have it, can listen to it and enjoy.
Fantastic!
I voted 8 times for Mélanie. Damn geopolitic voting!
Eurovision top 10 OF ALL TIME:
1. Rhythm inside - Belgium
2. Calm after the storm - The Netherlands
3. Time to shine - Switzerland
4. City Lights - Belgium
5. Ghost - Germany
6. Lighthouse - Croatia
7. You and me - Switzerland
8. Grande Amore - Italy
9. Amar Pelos Dois - Portugal
10. Chidren of the Universe - United Kingdom
She deserved a final. The staging was a perfection especially compared to Poland's one. Eurovision can be quite a cruel contest.
It's my favourite this year.
Greetings from Germany!
I love it. Kisses from Greece. It should have pass.
The best swiss Song in the past 20 Years!!!!
are you kidding me??? Cyprus passes and Switzerland doesn't? Europe is deaf.
Well done. She must be in a final, from Russia with love )))
Юрий Владимирович Мазуркевич perfect show
Felt in love with this song, the singer is beautiful as well :) One of my favourites
i really like this song and your performance, there are very underrated in this semifinal, totally agree with your comments!
One of the best performances, I think. So underrated, unfortunately
For me, she deserved to pass..she had ana amazing song.
She didn't deserve last place
I still listen this in 2017
im sorry switzerland, this song should been in the final!!! still 12 pts from Lithuania
Switzerland should give her another chance in some way. She managed to take a hopeless song and made it look like a qualifier. Had this been in SF1 I'm sure she would be there on Saturday.
Great job!! You deserved to be in the Grand Final!
she must be the winner . that's not fair. her voice and song is awesome.
Love it
I'm so sad... this was my winner in this semi final. Why Europe?
Love you Melanie!
ganz klar das beste lied vom ganzen song contest!!
MELANIE FANTASTIC SINGER AND ORIGINAL SONG AND PERFORMANCE :(:(
the best of the second semi final
One of the few high quality entries this year. Unfortunately she doesnt qualify, but both she and the song are perfect.
This was my 1st place out of 2015 back then and it still is. Darn you, Europe
I always liked this, could not believe it came dead last.
I love it
We love you Melanie! I'm voting on you in thursday from Poland