There seems to be a lot of hate on this video for me "telling people what to do." That's literally the point of this series, people submit me things they want critiqued. With the reaction on this video being so negative, I'm not super likely to continue this series, but let me know one way or another.
I think you should continue the series cus I'm sure many other people like myself find it very a good way to get advice for things we might be doing that are similar to what you're critiquing. It's just that even if we find the video helpful we're not likely to post a comment unless we have some specific advice to thank you for, while if people are unhappy with something they're far more likely to comment. Please keep up the series! Quite a few of my friends also watch you and learn a lot from these videos :)
I was actually thinking as I watched this that it's kind of funny that this series really hinges on both you and the people submitting their videos thinking that you're better than them. But like...it's not an ego thing. At least I don't take it that way. People send their videos in because they recognise, or at least believe, that you have some kind of musical authority that they don't have. I don't see anything wrong with this. Music is so subjective, but that doesn't mean that you don't have authority and experience that other's don't have. I find this series fascinating and helpful, so add me to the list of non-haters, please. Cheers!
Hey Adam, I don't know if you saw my first comment, but I was (and still am) very appreciative of your feedback (and the commenters who have given constructive feedback). I think the negative feedback you are receiving is mostly from people who never understood theory properly and fail to grasp the purpose of this series, and the power that music theory has on a composer/composition. These people are probably the same people who think guitarists like Jimi Hendrix play with feeling and guitarists like Yngwie Malmsteen are just a mess of notes played really fast. This is my favourite series from your channel and have thoroughly enjoyed every episode. It would be a shame if you were to cancel it. In the end, you decide what to do. but I think the way this series enables musicians all over the world to share their knowledge and experiences with regards to performing/composing (near-)instantaneously is an intellectually-enriching experience like no other. Take care and all the best.
I really had to see what he had to say about the Eb11 chord. He's done great and helpful (to say the least) videos in the past but what I found here was akin to someone attempting to use their "superior knowledge" (whether it actually is or not compared to the people who submitted songs we'll never know) to tell people how they "got it wrong". (Dig up Tchaikovsky and tell him that his use of 11th, and 13th chords was over indulgent or some such rubbish) Music is subjective. Therefore, the whole premise of this is beyond silly.
@@MyXxx77 That's why Adam says many times throughout this series that music is subjective, and to take his advice with a grain of salt. Even in this video, in the example of when he's talking about the Eb11 chord, Adam tells the submitter to use the Eb11 chord if it sounds right to them. People ask him for critique or for suggestions on how to improve, and Adam gives his personal opinion on their piece. I don't know of any time that Adam has straight up told somebody that their writing is wrong. He knows it's subjective. I don't know where you're getting the idea that the whole premise of this is silly. Artists should always be seeking ways to improve. If an artist doesn't know how they could potentially improve, what are they going to do other than ask someone they look up to?
ikr. it's not even a "I hate when people do this! it's wrong and I hate it!" it's a "here's what this is and here's why you would want to do xyz instead"
Actually, I thought the critique of that piece of music was a bit of a big steaming hot pile of dog and horseshit combined and forged into a prick in hellfire. The was was really pleasing to listen to. THAT is what should matter. Not common practices. I normally agree with Neely but fuck him this time. That was shit.
WN Games did you pause and write this comment before Adam went on to say how that’s just his opinion and if he really likes the sound of that then that’s perfectly fine too?
I've been working on amazing compositions by Frederic Chopin lately and i've noticed that he sometimes uses bizarre note combinations that sounds like absolute shit when played equally loud. But, when you drop the volume of certain dissonant notes, it suddenly becomes magical and beautiful! So if it sounds like shit, try fiddling with dynamics. New doors could open.
This all the way. Me and my Bass Buddy have been working on a new track for about a week or so, and there was an interval in one of the chords he was using (I’m the drums sax guitar guy, he’s way more knowledgeable about chords and harmony, I’m intermediate, maybe a little above basic, he’s a fuckin out the womb genius) so we started talking about this chord and messing around with some other voicings that would have the same harmonic feel. Kinda talking about Jacob Colliers idea of negative harmony and the idea that you can have two chords with the same harmonic resolution based off distance from the chord center. After about an hour of this one chord, we just brought the dynamic down a little and it was exactly what we wanted. Sometimes heavy, theory dense work around aren’t the answer. Sometimes you just gotta feel it different.
@@TheVergile That's a bit like saying leave the herbs and spices that taste awful if you eat a spoon full of them out of your cooking. They add tone, depth and tension to the music. Too much is unpleasant but get it right and you create something really special.
It's not stupid - its just when people do stuff like try and stuff a world record number of chords into a song just because they can and they miss the whole point of the music. My old guitar teacher would have a fit if he saw that version of jingle bells.
The Gb to the Abb would still have the same minor ninth interval that makes the Eb11 chord sound so bad. I can't tell if you're being satirical or not but just in case.
I'm a year late to the party, but I just wanted to say I thoroughly enjoyed this vid. I've had several music teachers/mentors over the years, and if they'd been as constructive in their feedback as you are here, I might still be playing. You're honest without being cruel, and it appears that you prioritize support and encouragement in your assessments, which is integral to any performer's (or at least my) growing confidence. "Here's what I think you're going for. Here's what I like. Here's what I don't. Here's why. Here's how you could choose to address it. Here's to you and all the effort you've put in." Major respect, man!
Well use them if you have a good reason to, just know why you're using them. They sound very dissonant, but if that's what you're going for, go for it.
Ignore the negative comments. A musician with this much theoretical know-how is a role-model and fount of wisdom for all my pop music students. Keep up the excellent work.
Hi, I just saw this video and, well, I can't speak for music theory cause I don't know pretty much anything about it, but I like it that you are absolutely gentle with critique and stress out that it's mostly your opinion and you give detailed info why you think something should be this or that. Keep it up!
Adam: I really appreciate your use of the "repeat 1439 times" sign here, it reminds me a lot of Bela Bartocs opus 23: Von meiner Badewanne. But i strongly suggest you try and let other bars in your life.
His opinion is not objective, no matter the point of view, so it can't be fair. He just rearranged the the song to his liking and said that it was better, period.
Vocalead For the ones that he changed it seemed like he said "Do this because I don't like this chord. But you can still do that if you want". The other critiques he gave were about technique, which are objective. And the one Danielle wrote he even said he liked where she was going with it. I don't see anything wrong with this.
I agree somewhat, I mean, little less than half the video is about technique, however his subjective opinions are very snobby. Who's to say the licks on the first guy's guitar video "don't match", "phrase/response" is just one of several available phrasing techniques, you don't have to follow it if you don't want to... I'm just saying he has a very "know-it-all" attitude just because he has some theoretical musical knowledge, but you shouldn't abuse that, everything auditively speaking is subjective, and confidently saying "this chord does not match this other one" just because some guy wrote a book about it 60 years ago doesn't mean it's an absolute truth. Often in music, those who write theory books are people observing and describing other people's (the actual composers) work and methods, and these should NEVER be taken in as rules, which happens a lot.
Vocalead I didn't find his comments snobby. He gave them criticism, which is what they sent the videos in for. The first video, I found what he said makes sense. He basically told the guy to try and be more creative with how he played the chords, which makes sense and should be encouraged. For the second one he just told him that he should be following the phrase/response technique. I thought it sounded good. But again, maybe for another time that the guy plays something he could try and do that and implement it and see if he likes it. That's what it is about music critique that people don't understand. When someone gives a criticism for music it isn't a "Do this now because yours is garbage and mine is better." It's more of a "I learned this way and most conventions do this, try that". Which was what it sounded like he was saying most of the time. It's like coding. When I review code, i don't look at it like "Oh gross why would you do that, it's awful do it this way". It's more like what he said to Danielle, "I like where you're going with this, But...". Obviously some people do that, but it didn't seem to me like that's what he was doing in this video.
Didn't know you played music Nj so funny to see you here haha. I already love your R6 memeful content it would be great if you could include some of your music play in one of your video! Keep up the good work anyway :)
This made me laugh hard, although Toxic Potato read my mind. The reason why I brought that up was so I could have someone like Adam Neely, who is well-informed in Jazz harmony/chord voicings (among other things) to pick out things like that.
Personally speaking, if the idea of "metal" is about breaking conventions, what better way to break convention than to notate a metal track in standard musical notation? \m/
Hi, Adam! Referring to the "negative critique" and your question, whether you should continue this series: I personally think that the way you explain things, is highly virtuosic. I do not know you as a practical musician yet (need to check that out... I guess, though, that your virtuosity there is probably as vivid as it is with your words), but whatever video of yours I see, it always makes me "Whoa - what well-chosen words, how incredibly well formulated!" and things like that. This is the main take-away I get from the videos and the main reason, why I really highly appreciate you channel and your work, because eventually every musicians needs to also build up a repertoire of proper vocabulary to explain his/her musical intentions with more then phrases like "I feel...", "my guts tell me to do that...". And even though one might already know a topic, it is a completely different story talking about it (Richard Feynman comes to mind...). BTW: I'd really be interested, if a topic like "how to talk and not talk about music" would be worth a video for you... :-) Keep 'em coming, please!
People who are hating on you by acting butt hurt have never had a teacher before. You made a 15 minute video to help someone arrange music and somehow that's interpreted as hatred and arrogance? Cmon people.
ikr. it's not even a "I hate when people do this! it's wrong and I hate it!" it's a "here's what this is and here's why you would want to do xyz instead"
I would like to kindly redact my previous comment from much earlier. I watched more videos from you from months and I've seen how applicable the things you teach are and how amazing of a teacher you are. You are a gem of RUclips and I'm so thankful I watched more.
Hi Adam - I was really impressed by your breadth of knowledge, your on point critique, and your respect for those who submitted. It was a lot of fun watching your video.
Hey Adam, I think this video is excellent. It's like you're leading a huge masterclass for the RUclips community! That's wonderful. You're an expert, and you have an invaluable expert opinion. Please don't listen to the haters, because what you're doing is great.
Love your "show", here. It's fun to hear the submissions and your analysis. It's good to see you're willing to comment on a wide range of styles, and levels of musicianship. You seem knowledgeable enough to have relevant things to say about style, technique, arrangement and voicing, and its good to get feedback from someone who listens as carefully as you do, whether one agrees with your opinions or not. Keep up the good work!
I've given up on studying music ages ago. I once dreamed of being a professional musician, but ended up assuming it was not for me. I still play my guitar every day, but just for fun, not really practicing or studying. When I watched this video, however, I felt like saving it for later, and it became the first video in my new playlist "Studying Music". I didn't really thinK before I gave it that name, but now I guess I feel like studying music again. Anyway, thank you Adam for sharing your knowledge!
For me at least, it's so bad I love it. It sounds like if Nintendo had to make a song in 10 minutes and none of the musicians or songwriters were in the room. I just can't find room in my heart to fault it for being what it is.
Please continue this series Adam! It's a great outlet for real constructive criticism from a peer/teacher. I'd wager that a great many musicians that don't have a chance to play live, or aren't confident enough to play live, only have friends and family to give them feedback that don't play music. The most they can get from them is "It doesn't sound good" or "Yeah, that's pretty good." There's no help in that. I suspect that many of the people giving you negative feedback fall somewhere in the scenario I've described above. I say this with no malice, maybe some condescension, but no ill intent. The negative response to this series is, sadly, to be expected. You yourself understand that music is a passion that can be approached in multiple ways, but you also understand the misconception that many have about music theory. Most do not. If you don't want to deal with nonconstructive criticism you receive from this series, discontinue it, but I think we need to lead by example. Even if they don't understand it, please continue to be example of how to give constructive criticism for them. They clearly need it. That and when anyone uses language that sounds like commands on the Internet, trolls and the impatient pounce on it.
I may be demonstrating my ignorance, but I actuallly really found your video instructive. So thank you. Your musical knowledge is just so many levels above mine that I’m in awe.
I came across this and found it really interesting. I then read your comment and skimmed through some of the others. I'd say, don't be discouraged. I'm an amateur player (recorder) who wants to learn more and am lucky enough to have a great teacher (also a professional performer) who gives me exactly the type of advice you give, and that is what helps me improve. There's no point in me playing through, say, a Bach Partita and her saying it's wonderful. If it's OK, she says so (which is nice), but what I really want to know is how to do it better, because I know for sure it can be. And that's what you're doing here. And I for one learned a number of things from your video. Those who don't want criticism won't submit videos. Those who don't want to watch constructive criticism and learn from it aren't forced to watch. Those who don't understand why it's necessary, in my view don't want to be better musicians (it won't be because they are brilliant because if they were they would understand). Stick at it. I, and I'm sure many others, find it very useful indeed.
I came in on the tail end of this series, but I think this series is great! My comment a year too late but thought I would say what a great job you're doing with You Tube.
i’ve always liked stacking it 1 4 5 7 with the 3rd out on top as you get a major 7 between both the root & seven and the 4 and the 3 (but that runs the risk of making the 4 sound like the root)
Cheers Alex, if you're interested, my channel has both the version I submitted to Adam as well as a new updated version that takes all the great feedback I've received and puts it to good use.
Probably wont ever read this but I enjoy and appreciate your feedback on everything. I disagree that youre arrogant - I like your constructive criticism and I think you should keep making these 👍
I decided to write a short tune that is based on Eb11, has some "Teen Town" funk to it, and will be 15+ minutes in length. I'll submit my submission soon, Adam so I can learn how to suck better. (two of these qualities are true and being 15+ minutes isn't one of them)
hey adam could you do a series on jazz listening?? i understand that for copyright issues it is difficult to do on youtube but maybe on another platform? love your stuff :)
Dude, you're so cool. Your understanding and acceptance of SO MANY musical disciplines, ability to convey them, and create videos with just enough cheezy youtube humour (Jazz, Jazz, Jaaaazz) keeps me coming back again and again. I'm even finding, as a hobbyist musician who plays mainly by ear, and understands basic notations, the visual notations of every chord you talk about with the overlay of audio of the chord itself is starting get in my brain and im understanding music in a different way. Keep it up. Much love.
The first thing I learned on bass was Portrait of Tracy. Perfected it after only a few months. It may not be Teen Town, but it helped me get proper technique early on when learning.
Toxic Potato yeah I know exactly what you mean. I've been playing ever since I was a kid but only in churches and stuff, stuff really started to turn around once I was exposed to jazz in 9th grade and did 4 piece jazz combo all 4 years of highschool. Changed my life in such a great way
The original homeowners violated the HOA by messing up the garden and got evicted, then there was a racially motivated familial homicide on the way out, it only goes downhill.
If you want to be good at something you need to get constructive feedback. This video is great. People who want to live in their own little egg and never have their art critiqued can go somewhere else and suck on their own.
You are only partially right. One should not allow other people's opinions to modify your art. Some people are more musically sensitive than others, so some may not need as much constructive criticism as others. The danger is to confine art to rules and norms, forgetting that it's a personal thing. With that said it depends. If the person simply does not understand how music works, then that's one thing. However, if the musician is experienced and knows what he is doing and just so happens to want a slightly odd or different sound, well then it doesn't matter if someone else doesn't like it, the important thing is that the musician in question does. Debussy was critiqued heavily for his unorthodox compositional style at times. That clearly didn't stop him, though; and thank goodness it didn't.
"People who want to live in their own little egg and never have their art critiqued" - you've described artists. Every musician, and poet or writer i admire despised critics to some degree or other- as it should be; the two are in direct opposition. The artist assembles something and the critic attempts to pull it apart. Fortunately, as with the battle of good and evil, the critic is bound to lose. A song is as hard to destroy as it is to create- if not harder- and critics are much less passionate about their work.
@@julianmanjarres1998 Very well said. Furthermore, if someone doesn't know what they're doing, they might stumble into something, and it could turn into a beautiful song. It's my experience that true art is not arrived at logically. Bob Dylan didn't sit down and think out "It's Alright, Ma ". He couldn't have done it. And do you think Beethoven wrote his 9th symphony by way of logic? There's no way.
This series was EXTREMELY helpful!! Continue them; people will naturally be themselves. But don’t let ‘offended people’ dictate what kind of videos you produce. Think of those of us whom love your content when you upload. 😊 keep up the good work and keep the composition vids coming 🙂 we love them!!!!!
Oooh, that instrumental metal thing. I definitely want to hear the end product of that. And I appreciated the "Guitarmony" pun. Makes me want to listen to the Heathen song.
Cheers mate! There is a new version on my channel with feedback incorporated. It's probably finished but I may make some minor changes before beginning the recording process. I've linked it below, and Heathen is a great band. Apparently a new album is in the works. ruclips.net/video/bBBR6kMxjsY/видео.html
It's from Mezzo TV Channel. They play recordings of classical music but usually after 9 pm or so they play jazz and announce it with this j a z z thing
Much respect. You obviously know your way around theory, and your critiques are honest, never snarky, and you clearly delineate between common practice and your own opinion. Very cool. And I appreciate your willingness to go past commenting on theory and into timbre and dynamics. If anybody has a problem with that, they're obviously more interested in protecting their feelings than they are learning and improving. I'm subscribing, and I'll be recommending your channel to friends.
It is a really good breakdown but I agree with Adam that it might not come out super cleanly when being played live at that tempo. It would be an awesome technique on guitar though.
Caleb wilson hey Caleb! Its a french music channel dedicated to classical music, ballet, jazz, world music... Many concerts on youtube are recorded from there. The interlude plays normally between shows and such.
I love the advice you gave to that young bass player. When I had my older brother first teach me a harder riff. His advice was to slow it down, relax and make it musical. Then worry about playing it faster. It is actually easier to play it fast once you master it than to play it slowly and still make it sound musical. This helps when doing advanced guitar picking techniques a la Blind Blake or something equally advanced.
Was gonna disagree... until I thought about it for five seconds and realized that G to Ab minor 9th interval would be there. It's not impossible to make a minor 9th sound good, just difficult to find the right place for it (An intentionally dissonant metal riff, for instance).
Please don't stop the series - I love hearing your critiques. You have a lot of wisdom, and not sharing it because some people don't know how to charitably interpret criticism would be a loss for the rest of us!
Amazing how you look respectfully at pieces that most common people would say: "I don't understand this, therefore it's shit, i don't understand why its shit either, but it is", and you understand both what the creation is meant to convey and how they could be optimized in conveying that feeling, like in "The Billy Bumbler" piece, it feels to me that it is meant to sound weird and uneasy, to convey something chaotic and sloppy and I really like the way it succeeds in doing that without sounding like garbage (except as you said the effects could have been better blent and it could have more "swing" to it). As for Hayden H piece, I understand that Eb11 chord and I think he will probably leave it there, because even though the chord might sound dissonant, when played note-by-note (like in the song) it's musical function is more perceptible than the aggregate chord itself, thus the thirds increments with all that bright can convey this "dreamy" sensation (which I strongly believe was the intention) and be clean over the note-sequence time it is set to play. Idk if that's really that, i'm not a musician at all so I might be talking shit here and I apologize if that's the case
Sid R. I see, I used the word strum because in DAWs and software like guitar pro that's the name of "play this chord note by note using this time function", English is not my native language, I have no idea the correct term I intended to use.
You're right, music is all about what you are trying to convey, this guy thinks he owns music bzecause he applies music theory that's only relevant in a classical context.
dude, you are a boss and anyone that is honestly hungry to learn and grow should value your suggestions and insights. . . .not so they then change those things and say "welp, I fixed that" but more that they are then aware of those concepts and choices and make them more thoughtfully and deliberately in the future. AwAreNeSs. . .
Yes! Do keep doing this. Just laugh at the negativity. Would you people rather receive criticism from a teacher or a friend or family member that you're going to have to see repeatedly, and every time you encounter them you're thinking "Screw this guy!", or from somebody you don't know can be objective and honest and you won't encounter in your daily life?
So much more functional. I love how you completely drained the 'jazz' out of it. At first I thought you were going to throw a lot of pseudo-theory at us to remind us how educated you are, but I didn't hear any buzzwords, and the final product was so much more functional than the original. Whew. Thanks.
I'm confused, the title doesn't seem to match what he's describing. Isn't the problem that he uses the Eb11 in stacked thirds, not Eb11 itself? When he rearranges the notes, it's still a voicing of Eb11. And isn't there going to be the same problem with any 11 chord, regardless of the root (E11, F11, Gb11, etc)?
I still think the 11th is the problem itself. If it's not subbing for the 5th or suspending the 3rd or being added in a plain triad, then why is it there? It just sounds messy anywhere, in my opinion (but only mine).
Appreciate your insights. But the first guy hit the nail on the head. (Kudos!) It's obvious he was trying to do exactly what he did: arrange Jingle Bells over a chromatic progression. Most people would never try such a thing, but this badass embraced an onerous rule and then pulled it off. Art thrives on limitations.
They got one, but you should maybe not use it. If u have a slow connection and your ping varies from 10ms to 100ms, those internet metronomes could ruin your time feel.
And, i've tried something: i load the google page with the metronome, then I put my computer in offline mode (no internet). the metronome continues. I think the html page contain a script that read the data of the internal clock of your computer (the data send by the quartz) so I don't think there is any kind of ping when you use the metronome of Google because it's an offline metronome.
As Dimitri noted, online metronomes use an "offline" clock, ping isn't really a factor. The network is used just for loading the metronome web application.
I like the fact you have a very strong opinion and people forget these are just suggestions on what you think would be better. There’s no point in sugar coating . That would only devalue your analysis.. Keep up this series. Please
There seems to be a lot of hate on this video for me "telling people what to do." That's literally the point of this series, people submit me things they want critiqued. With the reaction on this video being so negative, I'm not super likely to continue this series, but let me know one way or another.
I think you should continue the series cus I'm sure many other people like myself find it very a good way to get advice for things we might be doing that are similar to what you're critiquing. It's just that even if we find the video helpful we're not likely to post a comment unless we have some specific advice to thank you for, while if people are unhappy with something they're far more likely to comment. Please keep up the series! Quite a few of my friends also watch you and learn a lot from these videos :)
You're arrogant af
I was actually thinking as I watched this that it's kind of funny that this series really hinges on both you and the people submitting their videos thinking that you're better than them. But like...it's not an ego thing. At least I don't take it that way. People send their videos in because they recognise, or at least believe, that you have some kind of musical authority that they don't have. I don't see anything wrong with this. Music is so subjective, but that doesn't mean that you don't have authority and experience that other's don't have. I find this series fascinating and helpful, so add me to the list of non-haters, please. Cheers!
Adam, the response is mostly positive, don't let the comments fool you.
Hey Adam, I don't know if you saw my first comment, but I was (and still am) very appreciative of your feedback (and the commenters who have given constructive feedback). I think the negative feedback you are receiving is mostly from people who never understood theory properly and fail to grasp the purpose of this series, and the power that music theory has on a composer/composition. These people are probably the same people who think guitarists like Jimi Hendrix play with feeling and guitarists like Yngwie Malmsteen are just a mess of notes played really fast.
This is my favourite series from your channel and have thoroughly enjoyed every episode. It would be a shame if you were to cancel it. In the end, you decide what to do. but I think the way this series enables musicians all over the world to share their knowledge and experiences with regards to performing/composing (near-)instantaneously is an intellectually-enriching experience like no other.
Take care and all the best.
why the hell would someone click on a video abt critiquing music, and then get mad when the person in the video is critiquing music
So true
Because the title of the Video triggered mentioned person
I really had to see what he had to say about the Eb11 chord. He's done great and helpful (to say the least) videos in the past but what I found here was akin to someone attempting to use their "superior knowledge" (whether it actually is or not compared to the people who submitted songs we'll never know) to tell people how they "got it wrong". (Dig up Tchaikovsky and tell him that his use of 11th, and 13th chords was over indulgent or some such rubbish) Music is subjective. Therefore, the whole premise of this is beyond silly.
@@MyXxx77 That's why Adam says many times throughout this series that music is subjective, and to take his advice with a grain of salt. Even in this video, in the example of when he's talking about the Eb11 chord, Adam tells the submitter to use the Eb11 chord if it sounds right to them. People ask him for critique or for suggestions on how to improve, and Adam gives his personal opinion on their piece.
I don't know of any time that Adam has straight up told somebody that their writing is wrong. He knows it's subjective. I don't know where you're getting the idea that the whole premise of this is silly. Artists should always be seeking ways to improve. If an artist doesn't know how they could potentially improve, what are they going to do other than ask someone they look up to?
ikr. it's not even a "I hate when people do this! it's wrong and I hate it!" it's a "here's what this is and here's why you would want to do xyz instead"
Simple rule: don't play anything that sounds like shit
Mozart : "I put together notes that love themselve"
My fucking hero!
Upload more Rick!
the man!
Yeah but the problem is that when I do something that sounds like shit I don’t know what I’m doing wrong and how to change it
I wonder if the dude who sent the email about his composition saw the title of this video and was like "fuUuuuuuck"
oh shit I didn't even think about that haha
Actually, I thought the critique of that piece of music was a bit of a big steaming hot pile of dog and horseshit combined and forged into a prick in hellfire. The was was really pleasing to listen to. THAT is what should matter. Not common practices. I normally agree with Neely but fuck him this time. That was shit.
WN Games did you pause and write this comment before Adam went on to say how that’s just his opinion and if he really likes the sound of that then that’s perfectly fine too?
Gender Fluid no, actually
@@ShyDigi Also the person who submitted it literally specifically asked for critique on standard practices. Listen to 5:58-6:04 again.
I've been working on amazing compositions by Frederic Chopin lately and i've noticed that he sometimes uses bizarre note combinations that sounds like absolute shit when played equally loud. But, when you drop the volume of certain dissonant notes, it suddenly becomes magical and beautiful! So if it sounds like shit, try fiddling with dynamics. New doors could open.
This all the way. Me and my Bass Buddy have been working on a new track for about a week or so, and there was an interval in one of the chords he was using (I’m the drums sax guitar guy, he’s way more knowledgeable about chords and harmony, I’m intermediate, maybe a little above basic, he’s a fuckin out the womb genius) so we started talking about this chord and messing around with some other voicings that would have the same harmonic feel. Kinda talking about Jacob Colliers idea of negative harmony and the idea that you can have two chords with the same harmonic resolution based off distance from the chord center. After about an hour of this one chord, we just brought the dynamic down a little and it was exactly what we wanted. Sometimes heavy, theory dense work around aren’t the answer. Sometimes you just gotta feel it different.
Taken to the extreme you could as well just leave them out ^^
@@TheVergile That's a bit like saying leave the herbs and spices that taste awful if you eat a spoon full of them out of your cooking. They add tone, depth and tension to the music. Too much is unpleasant but get it right and you create something really special.
@@smithersrob nah, what im saying is that in the extreme youll basically reach the realm of homeopathic pepper and placebo salt
@@smithersrob Leave spices out then slowly add back. Gotta make sure main ingredients are good quality and cooked properly. Then add spices.
"Jazz is stupid! I mean, just play the right notes!" -Angela, from The Office
whipsnade13 - well, she’s not wrong
Edit: I have since learned the error of my ways
"Why are you booing me?
I'm right!"
-Wayne Gretzky
-Michael Scott
@@rhys2275 character development!
It's not stupid - its just when people do stuff like try and stuff a world record number of chords into a song just because they can and they miss the whole point of the music. My old guitar teacher would have a fit if he saw that version of jingle bells.
Jazz! *jazz* JAZZ! ʲᵃᶻᶻ J A Z Z jazz... Jazz!
JAZZ!
Jaazz..
ｊａｚｚ
dank lord Adam came up with the littest meme 2k18
J Â Â Z
I wrote a song today. The chords was C F G and then back to C.. And I'm happy with just that
Most of my favourite songs have very simple chord progressions.
you shouldn't have put the C at the end. it makes it too cliche.
Okay, think I change it to C# then :-)
@@kanibalismeboy now you're talking
@@kanibalismeboy Too jazz. Try C-F-C-G-C. The middle C makes the last one sound less clichéd, counterintuintive though it is.
Eb11 - what a beautiful chord
J A Z Z
J A H S S
It actually looks like Еби, a russian word which means "fuck (somebody)" in imperative case
Alexander Kolchev well Eb11 you too bud
Logan Dead
*use of Eb11 chords intensifies*
whith your wrist bent at the same time
How about Ebm9(b11) Eb Gb Bb Db F Abb ( flat eleventh )
The Gb to the Abb would still have the same minor ninth interval that makes the Eb11 chord sound so bad. I can't tell if you're being satirical or not but just in case.
bmartinmusics Yes, I meant out of context. (There are 15th 17th 19th 21st and 23rd chords, Those are rarely used.)
Eb Dorian b4 = Eb F Gb Abb Bb C Db Eb
I'm a year late to the party, but I just wanted to say I thoroughly enjoyed this vid. I've had several music teachers/mentors over the years, and if they'd been as constructive in their feedback as you are here, I might still be playing.
You're honest without being cruel, and it appears that you prioritize support and encouragement in your assessments, which is integral to any performer's (or at least my) growing confidence. "Here's what I think you're going for. Here's what I like. Here's what I don't. Here's why. Here's how you could choose to address it. Here's to you and all the effort you've put in."
Major respect, man!
Agreed on all points - I just came across the video as well, and I think you describe it very well. I enjoyed the video considerably.
Gotta have that A B C# D E F# G# A (major) respect.
I like his expertise and manner too.
Exactly!
So true, so many people either bs you or just tell you where they didn't like your playing, he's really trying to help
Jazz: "they spent so much time figuring out if they could, they never bothered to stop and ask if they should."
Experimental music: "lol, cute"
If you want to skip to the Eb11 one it's 5:53
youre making the world a better place & i respect that
Thank you. Literally the only reason I clicked on this and then he plays jingle bells
Jazz!
Jazz!
Jazz!
Amazing.
I read this like 2 seconds before the video got to that point
title: Please don't use Eb11 chords!
video: Use Eb11 chords if you want to i guess
hilariuss
Well use them if you have a good reason to, just know why you're using them. They sound very dissonant, but if that's what you're going for, go for it.
Troodon Lol i listen to Meshuggah i use a Eb23 chord whenever i want
c l i c k b a i t e d
Ich Und Nicht Du hilarious
Sleep paralysis, but The Billy Bumbler is playing on repeat.
go learn what a real bumbler is, its a fictional speaking racoon from a stephen king series
Ryan Martin you killed me
Oh how I loled
*SQUELCHING INTENSIFIES*
gosh how am i gonna sleep now
Ignore the negative comments. A musician with this much theoretical know-how is a role-model and fount of wisdom for all my pop music students. Keep up the excellent work.
@Jeff T your a human for not liking a musical genre. Your a jackass for being an asshole to people who do.
"Jaaazz"
"Jaaaahz"
"Juhs"
"Jaaaaaahhhhhzzzzz"
j à â ä ã å ž ź ż ž ż z ź ž
That jaaahzz bit is one of my favorite things
Translate to English
The Billy Bumbler sounds like a panic attack
The robotic voice sounds like sharting
This is the funniest shit
... meant to mirror the experience of the listener. It both causes and sounds like the panic attack it gave you. Incredible!
Then you should stay away from Penderecki.
@@th3giv3r Don't compare this shit to Penderecki.
Adam looking as though he's about to steal my widescreen TV
Goddammit
Or go down to the docks looking for work
I spat on my phone after reading this
Little known fact: each week he breaks into a different Patreon supporter's apartment to film a Q&A.
Victor's Visuals you have a widescreen TV?
Hi, I just saw this video and, well, I can't speak for music theory cause I don't know pretty much anything about it, but I like it that you are absolutely gentle with critique and stress out that it's mostly your opinion and you give detailed info why you think something should be this or that. Keep it up!
Submitting my 84 minute magnum opus for your review.
Adam: I really appreciate your use of the "repeat 1439 times" sign here, it reminds me a lot of Bela Bartocs opus 23: Von meiner Badewanne. But i strongly suggest you try and let other bars in your life.
That instrumental metal score be sounding like I’m battling the Elite Four champion in a 90s Pokémon game.
I don't understand the butthurt in some of these comments. He's giving fair, objective critiques to people who wanted them.
You can find a lot of arrogant people in the music industry
His opinion is not objective, no matter the point of view, so it can't be fair. He just rearranged the the song to his liking and said that it was better, period.
Vocalead For the ones that he changed it seemed like he said "Do this because I don't like this chord. But you can still do that if you want". The other critiques he gave were about technique, which are objective. And the one Danielle wrote he even said he liked where she was going with it. I don't see anything wrong with this.
I agree somewhat, I mean, little less than half the video is about technique, however his subjective opinions are very snobby. Who's to say the licks on the first guy's guitar video "don't match", "phrase/response" is just one of several available phrasing techniques, you don't have to follow it if you don't want to...
I'm just saying he has a very "know-it-all" attitude just because he has some theoretical musical knowledge, but you shouldn't abuse that, everything auditively speaking is subjective, and confidently saying "this chord does not match this other one" just because some guy wrote a book about it 60 years ago doesn't mean it's an absolute truth. Often in music, those who write theory books are people observing and describing other people's (the actual composers) work and methods, and these should NEVER be taken in as rules, which happens a lot.
Vocalead I didn't find his comments snobby. He gave them criticism, which is what they sent the videos in for. The first video, I found what he said makes sense. He basically told the guy to try and be more creative with how he played the chords, which makes sense and should be encouraged. For the second one he just told him that he should be following the phrase/response technique. I thought it sounded good. But again, maybe for another time that the guy plays something he could try and do that and implement it and see if he likes it. That's what it is about music critique that people don't understand. When someone gives a criticism for music it isn't a "Do this now because yours is garbage and mine is better." It's more of a "I learned this way and most conventions do this, try that". Which was what it sounded like he was saying most of the time. It's like coding. When I review code, i don't look at it like "Oh gross why would you do that, it's awful do it this way". It's more like what he said to Danielle, "I like where you're going with this, But...". Obviously some people do that, but it didn't seem to me like that's what he was doing in this video.
11:00 Sounds like a nightmarish version of Pikmin music.
I was thinking Banjo Kazooie
I was just thinking of this. It sounds so Pikmin-esq. I'm not 100% sure, but I believe it sounds similar to a Pikmin introduction (maybe yellow?).
"Hello I'm submitting my metal music to make sure it fits the rules and guidelines"
Didn't know you played music Nj so funny to see you here haha. I already love your R6 memeful content it would be great if you could include some of your music play in one of your video! Keep up the good work anyway :)
NJOverclocked Never expected you here. Maybe a music outro next time? :)
Gotta admit, though, it's a killer track.
This made me laugh hard, although Toxic Potato read my mind. The reason why I brought that up was so I could have someone like Adam Neely, who is well-informed in Jazz harmony/chord voicings (among other things) to pick out things like that.
Personally speaking, if the idea of "metal" is about breaking conventions, what better way to break convention than to notate a metal track in standard musical notation? \m/
I was expecting Yoko Ono to start yelling “stop all wars!” Over and over again over the piece at 11:00
Danielle sucked like a bee sting!
Cayce D LMAOOOOO
Number 9. Number 9. Number 9.
hitting the thumbs up on this post left a punch mark in my trackpad
I definitely dug where her head was at with this one, though. A little Danny elfmanesque.
Hi, Adam! Referring to the "negative critique" and your question, whether you should continue this series: I personally think that the way you explain things, is highly virtuosic. I do not know you as a practical musician yet (need to check that out... I guess, though, that your virtuosity there is probably as vivid as it is with your words), but whatever video of yours I see, it always makes me "Whoa - what well-chosen words, how incredibly well formulated!" and things like that. This is the main take-away I get from the videos and the main reason, why I really highly appreciate you channel and your work, because eventually every musicians needs to also build up a repertoire of proper vocabulary to explain his/her musical intentions with more then phrases like "I feel...", "my guts tell me to do that...". And even though one might already know a topic, it is a completely different story talking about it (Richard Feynman comes to mind...). BTW: I'd really be interested, if a topic like "how to talk and not talk about music" would be worth a video for you... :-) Keep 'em coming, please!
Bro definitely keep this series up!!! Constructive criticism is how people improve!!!!!
People who are hating on you by acting butt hurt have never had a teacher before. You made a 15 minute video to help someone arrange music and somehow that's interpreted as hatred and arrogance? Cmon people.
@supadox Exactly correct.
ikr. it's not even a "I hate when people do this! it's wrong and I hate it!" it's a "here's what this is and here's why you would want to do xyz instead"
I would like to kindly redact my previous comment from much earlier. I watched more videos from you from months and I've seen how applicable the things you teach are and how amazing of a teacher you are. You are a gem of RUclips and I'm so thankful I watched more.
"guitarmony" is my new favourite word
Hi Adam - I was really impressed by your breadth of knowledge, your on point critique, and your respect for those who submitted. It was a lot of fun watching your video.
Hey Adam, I think this video is excellent. It's like you're leading a huge masterclass for the RUclips community! That's wonderful. You're an expert, and you have an invaluable expert opinion. Please don't listen to the haters, because what you're doing is great.
Love your "show", here. It's fun to hear the submissions and your analysis. It's good to see you're willing to comment on a wide range of styles, and levels of musicianship. You seem knowledgeable enough to have relevant things to say about style, technique, arrangement and voicing, and its good to get feedback from someone who listens as carefully as you do, whether one agrees with your opinions or not. Keep up the good work!
I've given up on studying music ages ago. I once dreamed of being a professional musician, but ended up assuming it was not for me. I still play my guitar every day, but just for fun, not really practicing or studying. When I watched this video, however, I felt like saving it for later, and it became the first video in my new playlist "Studying Music". I didn't really thinK before I gave it that name, but now I guess I feel like studying music again. Anyway, thank you Adam for sharing your knowledge!
11:00 oh good god
😂😂😂😂
That piece was horrible tbh
What the fuck lmao
if they literally took out the synth it would be like 80% better
For me at least, it's so bad I love it. It sounds like if Nintendo had to make a song in 10 minutes and none of the musicians or songwriters were in the room. I just can't find room in my heart to fault it for being what it is.
Best part of the night: Finding out The Billy Bumbler is on Spotify
Please continue this series Adam! It's a great outlet for real constructive criticism from a peer/teacher. I'd wager that a great many musicians that don't have a chance to play live, or aren't confident enough to play live, only have friends and family to give them feedback that don't play music. The most they can get from them is "It doesn't sound good" or "Yeah, that's pretty good." There's no help in that. I suspect that many of the people giving you negative feedback fall somewhere in the scenario I've described above. I say this with no malice, maybe some condescension, but no ill intent. The negative response to this series is, sadly, to be expected. You yourself understand that music is a passion that can be approached in multiple ways, but you also understand the misconception that many have about music theory. Most do not. If you don't want to deal with nonconstructive criticism you receive from this series, discontinue it, but I think we need to lead by example. Even if they don't understand it, please continue to be example of how to give constructive criticism for them. They clearly need it.
That and when anyone uses language that sounds like commands on the Internet, trolls and the impatient pounce on it.
You are one HELL of an educator. The way you approach giving input is simply marvelous.
I may be demonstrating my ignorance, but I actuallly really found your video instructive. So thank you. Your musical knowledge is just so many levels above mine that I’m in awe.
jazz jAzz JazZ jaZZ jazZ JAzZ
I came to the comments for this
JaMaAaZz!
(as in "Timmeeh!!")
That was pretty funny.
I came across this and found it really interesting. I then read your comment and skimmed through some of the others. I'd say, don't be discouraged.
I'm an amateur player (recorder) who wants to learn more and am lucky enough to have a great teacher (also a professional performer) who gives me exactly the type of advice you give, and that is what helps me improve. There's no point in me playing through, say, a Bach Partita and her saying it's wonderful. If it's OK, she says so (which is nice), but what I really want to know is how to do it better, because I know for sure it can be. And that's what you're doing here. And I for one learned a number of things from your video.
Those who don't want criticism won't submit videos. Those who don't want to watch constructive criticism and learn from it aren't forced to watch. Those who don't understand why it's necessary, in my view don't want to be better musicians (it won't be because they are brilliant because if they were they would understand).
Stick at it. I, and I'm sure many others, find it very useful indeed.
andrew cranmer couldn’t have said it better myself
“Jazz, jazz, jazz…”, oh, man, I almost spit my coffee. Great lessons, man. Subscribed.
I came in on the tail end of this series, but I think this series is great! My comment a year too late but thought I would say what a great job you're doing with You Tube.
The best voicing for an 11 chord is to just play the third and fourth next to each other. Don't play anything else. At any point. Ever.
It's also good to invert them, so it's more of a sus7 with a natural 10 on top. Sounds nice.
I gave you a like for the memes, but it actually does sound great on guitar to have an open string 11th on the same octave as the third.
i’ve always liked stacking it 1 4 5 7 with the 3rd out on top as you get a major 7 between both the root & seven and the 4 and the 3 (but that runs the risk of making the 4 sound like the root)
realised i completely missed it was an Eb11 and not an Eb🔺11 - woops!
Call me stupid, but what does the triangle mean?
The song at 6:05 reminds of what would happen if Dream Theater had to write for Final Fantasy
Hey Zidny, thanks for the complement. Both of those have had a big impact on my development as a composer.
Hayden H - Man that was great. I Would love to listen to it when recorded.
Dream Theater writing for final fantasy would be amazing
Hahaha. Rudess would not be content with repeating arpeggios.
As a percussionist I would suggest you adding ghost notes and playing a little with the toms on the drum part at the crescendo OwO
Cheers fella :3/
the song with the Eb11 was lit
Cheers Alex, if you're interested, my channel has both the version I submitted to Adam as well as a new updated version that takes all the great feedback I've received and puts it to good use.
Hayden H yessss, thank you for sharing! Was trying to find your channel
Probably wont ever read this but I enjoy and appreciate your feedback on everything. I disagree that youre arrogant - I like your constructive criticism and I think you should keep making these 👍
I decided to write a short tune that is based on Eb11, has some "Teen Town" funk to it, and will be 15+ minutes in length. I'll submit my submission soon, Adam so I can learn how to suck better.
(two of these qualities are true and being 15+ minutes isn't one of them)
Was 'Suck better' intentional innuendo?
if you regularly listen to prog rock and classical music, 15 minutes can be short, or at least average!
Write it for full orchestra in 16 movements
That prog piece was awesome, I'd love to hear it completed!
hey adam could you do a series on jazz listening?? i understand that for copyright issues it is difficult to do on youtube but maybe on another platform?
love your stuff :)
Fabian Fernandez you dont need anything to listen to jazz
+Bippy Bo - Surely you need a pair of ears?!
Dude, you're so cool. Your understanding and acceptance of SO MANY musical disciplines, ability to convey them, and create videos with just enough cheezy youtube humour (Jazz, Jazz, Jaaaazz) keeps me coming back again and again. I'm even finding, as a hobbyist musician who plays mainly by ear, and understands basic notations, the visual notations of every chord you talk about with the overlay of audio of the chord itself is starting get in my brain and im understanding music in a different way. Keep it up. Much love.
What a beautiful key/chord change in the third submission; the Fm to E.
It's a good one!
Really agree
0:29 9/11 chords? Too soon
I was more swayed by the 6/9 chords.... giggity
Some chords notation look like a math equation. I never saw A∆7 before !
its never too soon for the scientific process to begin.
+Augusto what is "∆" ?
Elia1995 It indicates a major chord.
I really like Eb11, it has somewhat of a dreamy feel to it, and add the floaty yet tense intro
Goddamn I sound like a fucking snob
Jack Rota
Everyone here sounds like a snob
That's why we're all here
Jack Rota ur saying it like it's a bad thing
sounds normal. the video sounds like a fucking snob. and yeah I'm saying it like it's a bad thing
...a snob would tell you NOT to like it...
well, if we're here it means we kind of are
I heard that synth guitar and asked "who farted?"
I want to hear that metal track in full. Sounded cool.
I want to hear the band play it.
This is the best episode of this series so far. Really effectively delivered criticism.
A year and already playing teen town? Things are looking good for that dude.
these things take time don't worry
The first thing I learned on bass was Portrait of Tracy. Perfected it after only a few months. It may not be Teen Town, but it helped me get proper technique early on when learning.
Toxic Potato yeah I know exactly what you mean. I've been playing ever since I was a kid but only in churches and stuff, stuff really started to turn around once I was exposed to jazz in 9th grade and did 4 piece jazz combo all 4 years of highschool. Changed my life in such a great way
I learned teen town after like 8 months ( cover on channel) but still cant quite nail the first 2 bars
fuck google plus thanks, I’m the dude that played.
Yeah, I didn’t play it as fast, but it was also what my teacher suggested so
today, I used for the first time in my life the Eb11 chord. And it felt so damn good...
WARNING reading the comments section may be hazardous to one's health. Swearing, putdowns, rudeness, trolling--one may lose hope in humanity.
The original homeowners violated the HOA by messing up the garden and got evicted, then there was a racially motivated familial homicide on the way out, it only goes downhill.
Too late
If you want to be good at something you need to get constructive feedback. This video is great.
People who want to live in their own little egg and never have their art critiqued can go somewhere else and suck on their own.
You are only partially right. One should not allow other people's opinions to modify your art. Some people are more musically sensitive than others, so some may not need as much constructive criticism as others.
The danger is to confine art to rules and norms, forgetting that it's a personal thing. With that said it depends. If the person simply does not understand how music works, then that's one thing. However, if the musician is experienced and knows what he is doing and just so happens to want a slightly odd or different sound, well then it doesn't matter if someone else doesn't like it, the important thing is that the musician in question does. Debussy was critiqued heavily for his unorthodox compositional style at times. That clearly didn't stop him, though; and thank goodness it didn't.
"People who want to live in their own little egg and never have their art critiqued" - you've described artists. Every musician, and poet or writer i admire despised critics to some degree or other- as it should be; the two are in direct opposition. The artist assembles something and the critic attempts to pull it apart. Fortunately, as with the battle of good and evil, the critic is bound to lose. A song is as hard to destroy as it is to create- if not harder- and critics are much less passionate about their work.
@@julianmanjarres1998 Very well said. Furthermore, if someone doesn't know what they're doing, they might stumble into something, and it could turn into a beautiful song. It's my experience that true art is not arrived at logically. Bob Dylan didn't sit down and think out "It's Alright, Ma ". He couldn't have done it. And do you think Beethoven wrote his 9th symphony by way of logic? There's no way.
Thanks for the heads up. I won't watch the video because currently I want to be bad at something, so I'm primarily looking for destructive feedback
Seesaw Massacre Adam Neely is an artist you goddamn megalomaniac.
This series was EXTREMELY helpful!! Continue them; people will naturally be themselves. But don’t let ‘offended people’ dictate what kind of videos you produce. Think of those of us whom love your content when you upload. 😊 keep up the good work and keep the composition vids coming 🙂 we love them!!!!!
“I like thicc strings” YOURE A BASS PLAYER!!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😘
You're professional and respectful in your approach, detailed and informed analysis. Good job 💞
Oooh, that instrumental metal thing. I definitely want to hear the end product of that.
And I appreciated the "Guitarmony" pun. Makes me want to listen to the Heathen song.
Cheers mate! There is a new version on my channel with feedback incorporated. It's probably finished but I may make some minor changes before beginning the recording process. I've linked it below, and Heathen is a great band. Apparently a new album is in the works.
ruclips.net/video/bBBR6kMxjsY/видео.html
ok but where did that "j a z z" sample come from
It's from Mezzo TV Channel. They play recordings of classical music but usually after 9 pm or so they play jazz and announce it with this j a z z thing
it's a nice meme
Much respect. You obviously know your way around theory, and your critiques are honest, never snarky, and you clearly delineate between common practice and your own opinion. Very cool. And I appreciate your willingness to go past commenting on theory and into timbre and dynamics. If anybody has a problem with that, they're obviously more interested in protecting their feelings than they are learning and improving. I'm subscribing, and I'll be recommending your channel to friends.
does someone know if the piece at 6:05 has been recorded because it sounds incredible
"I like the idea of this piece of music" Adam being polite for "This music is an atonal junkyard of dissonance."
to be honest, it would make more sens if that performance was in the middle of another ppiece rather than stand-alone.
I love the occasional junkyard of dissonance.
OÄKTA DOPBOK It's not atonal though. It's just muddied by extreme chromaticsm.
I actually like it, I think it's (intentionally) very funny
I like to make people cringe and convulse when listening to my music.
DharmaMidget ahahahah
DharmaMidget perfect! It's not powerful art without a powerful response, am I right?
I can hear that metal jam sounding awesome fully realized.
you keep talking about TOAN but how do i get a GUD TOAN? how do i know if my TOAN is GUD or not?
Learniing how to spell is gud staRt
Buy a metal zone, make sure it's true bypass, and you're good to go
Ian Stahl don't forget a tele
Gudtoan means "The God Toilet" in swedish
caprianders teach me more swedish
I was gonna watch this video but then I got an ad that said Yousician™ was the best way to learn music and unsubscribed immediately
You unsubbed because youtube automatically added an ad that was in the same category as the content of the video? can we say "childish"?
Vox Potentiae can we say “joke?”
Possibly. How do you spell it?
Tony-Atkinson, it's possible, though unlikely.
Vox Potentiae spelling is unimportant if you cant get a joke.
First thing i did when i saw the title of this video, was going and writing a tune that uses eb11 a whole bunch of times hahahaha
That Billy Bumbler tune is like... meow meow, bzz bzz, shart shart...
8:44 This actually sounds REALLY good :O I'd be very happy to hear it if it's ever officially released. Was it released since this vid came out?
I agree
It's got a Final Fantasy sort of vibe. Actually sounds good as a chip tune.
It is a really good breakdown but I agree with Adam that it might not come out super cleanly when being played live at that tempo. It would be an awesome technique on guitar though.
Reminds me of the living fortress
Reminds me of Primordial or Moonsorrow
the mezzo jazz interlude was genius eheh
Whats it from?
Caleb wilson hey Caleb! Its a french music channel dedicated to classical music, ballet, jazz, world music... Many concerts on youtube are recorded from there. The interlude plays normally between shows and such.
"Guitarmony"
I like that
I love the advice you gave to that young bass player. When I had my older brother first teach me a harder riff. His advice was to slow it down, relax and make it musical. Then worry about playing it faster. It is actually easier to play it fast once you master it than to play it slowly and still make it sound musical. This helps when doing advanced guitar picking techniques a la Blind Blake or something equally advanced.
Was gonna disagree... until I thought about it for five seconds and realized that G to Ab minor 9th interval would be there. It's not impossible to make a minor 9th sound good, just difficult to find the right place for it (An intentionally dissonant metal riff, for instance).
second and ninths work wonders on a distortion pedal
Fuck yea mr bungle
I'm a fan of your pfp. California best album.
Well my submission wasn't chosen but at least I made it into the video!
snowsurfer 251
Found you at 15:13! Haha
That metal tune in the middle really sounds a lot like the Angry Video Game Nerd theme
Exploding Fish 8020 I seriously thought it was going into that!
JCBigCat same
I was looking for that comment !
Please don't stop the series - I love hearing your critiques. You have a lot of wisdom, and not sharing it because some people don't know how to charitably interpret criticism would be a loss for the rest of us!
Please continue the series. U're doing great i really respect you as a music youtuber more tgan anyone else
The metal piece sounds like a tune found on a Nintendo 2D platform game from the 1990s.
Faxanadu springs to mind.
Good game
Amazing how you look respectfully at pieces that most common people would say: "I don't understand this, therefore it's shit, i don't understand why its shit either, but it is", and you understand both what the creation is meant to convey and how they could be optimized in conveying that feeling, like in "The Billy Bumbler" piece, it feels to me that it is meant to sound weird and uneasy, to convey something chaotic and sloppy and I really like the way it succeeds in doing that without sounding like garbage (except as you said the effects could have been better blent and it could have more "swing" to it).
As for Hayden H piece, I understand that Eb11 chord and I think he will probably leave it there, because even though the chord might sound dissonant, when played note-by-note (like in the song) it's musical function is more perceptible than the aggregate chord itself, thus the thirds increments with all that bright can convey this "dreamy" sensation (which I strongly believe was the intention) and be clean over the note-sequence time it is set to play. Idk if that's really that, i'm not a musician at all so I might be talking shit here and I apologize if that's the case
it was played on the keyboard. there is no strum.
Sid R. I see, I used the word strum because in DAWs and software like guitar pro that's the name of "play this chord note by note using this time function", English is not my native language, I have no idea the correct term I intended to use.
You're right, music is all about what you are trying to convey, this guy thinks he owns music bzecause he applies music theory that's only relevant in a classical context.
Felype Rennan woah dude. Do you watch Rick and Morty? You sound so smart as fuck
dude, you are a boss and anyone that is honestly hungry to learn and grow should value your suggestions and insights. . . .not so they then change those things and say "welp, I fixed that" but more that they are then aware of those concepts and choices and make them more thoughtfully and deliberately in the future. AwAreNeSs. . .
Instructions not clear used bassoon as toaster
Billy Bumbler would make a decent avant-garde piece.
The robotic voice thing sounds like a bad case of the sharts 😂
anti music
Yes! Do keep doing this. Just laugh at the negativity.
Would you people rather receive criticism from a teacher or a friend or family member that you're going to have to see repeatedly, and every time you encounter them you're thinking "Screw this guy!", or from somebody you don't know can be objective and honest and you won't encounter in your daily life?
So much more functional. I love how you completely drained the 'jazz' out of it. At first I thought you were going to throw a lot of pseudo-theory at us to remind us how educated you are, but I didn't hear any buzzwords, and the final product was so much more functional than the original. Whew. Thanks.
Jazz
Jazz
ｊａｚｚ
J A Z Z !
JAZZ
Джаз
I'm confused, the title doesn't seem to match what he's describing. Isn't the problem that he uses the Eb11 in stacked thirds, not Eb11 itself? When he rearranges the notes, it's still a voicing of Eb11. And isn't there going to be the same problem with any 11 chord, regardless of the root (E11, F11, Gb11, etc)?
The "problem" is the minor ninth between the 3rd and 11th. If you move the 11 down an octave so it's just a half step, it's a lot more acceptable.
I still think the 11th is the problem itself. If it's not subbing for the 5th or suspending the 3rd or being added in a plain triad, then why is it there? It just sounds messy anywhere, in my opinion (but only mine).
Part of the issue is that the specific interval he mentioned adds a lot of tension with no release, unlike the previous chords
Appreciate your insights. But the first guy hit the nail on the head. (Kudos!) It's obvious he was trying to do exactly what he did: arrange Jingle Bells over a chromatic progression. Most people would never try such a thing, but this badass embraced an onerous rule and then pulled it off. Art thrives on limitations.
I'm really glad I didn't have to play a jury for you back in music school! But, you make a lot of valid points about the submissions.
GOOGLE HAS A METRONOME????
Google has everything, our life, our secrets, our fking entire minds AND a metronome
They got one, but you should maybe not use it. If u have a slow connection and your ping varies from 10ms to 100ms, those internet metronomes could ruin your time feel.
but that can give you a trve digital feel of the music... a rythm with a ping
And, i've tried something: i load the google page with the metronome, then I put my computer in offline mode (no internet). the metronome continues. I think the html page contain a script that read the data of the internal clock of your computer (the data send by the quartz) so I don't think there is any kind of ping when you use the metronome of Google because it's an offline metronome.
As Dimitri noted, online metronomes use an "offline" clock, ping isn't really a factor. The network is used just for loading the metronome web application.
I'll use any chords I damn well please.
MomoTheBellyDancer he is Pirlo... he can do anything
MAN
Sticking it to the man lol
dats right!
lol
MomoTheBellyDancer In Italy, Andrea Is the most common male name. My name Is Andrea too actually
The "JAZZ" thing is hilarious
ｊａｚｚ
I like the fact you have a very strong opinion and people forget these are just suggestions on what you think would be better. There’s no point in sugar coating . That would only devalue your analysis.. Keep up this series. Please