She was fabulous!! I don't know why Simon predicted she would go home after this performance. Her recorded version of this song was one of the best on the Season 5 CD.
She was my favorite this season, and maybe all seasons. I confess, it was partly because of her talent but mostly because of how hot she was! I was a McGheek for Melissa McGhee.
Melissa was my favorite that season and this performance was awesome. Simon isn't deaf or dumb, so when I would hear him make comments like that after good/great performances, I was left with only one conclusion; he's a liar with an agenda.
![Gotye - Somebody That I Used To Know (feat. Kimbra) [Official Music Video]](/img/1.gif)
She was fabulous!! I don't know why Simon predicted she would go home after this performance. Her recorded version of this song was one of the best on the Season 5 CD.
I agree. They put her song first on the Idol CD for this season. I think it was the strongest vocal on it.
Outstanding job, she was way underrated, what a range.
one of my favorite Idol performances of all time.
Yes, I remember her as well. Really liked this performance. I hope she's doing well.
I remember really liking Melissa's version of this song. Still do.
She was my favorite this season, and maybe all seasons. I confess, it was partly because of her talent but mostly because of how hot she was! I was a McGheek for Melissa McGhee.
i really liked her voice i thought she should have made the top 24 because she was consistent all season
Melissa was my favorite that season and this performance was awesome. Simon isn't deaf or dumb, so when I would hear him make comments like that after good/great performances, I was left with only one conclusion; he's a liar with an agenda.
I wonder where Melissa is now, she was my favourite.
Thanks for posting! :)
Ha well tell her there there is a 20 year old girl from England who still remembers her as there favourite on idol!
She is in Tampa I play guitar for her sometimes ;)
Went to high school with her
Whatever happened to her?