This was amazing. I have been struggling with not even the original text, but a 30 page commentary on Phenomenology's preface for the past week, and I have an exam on it on Monday. Your videos have given me hope that philosophy is in fact intelligible :') In addition, as a college student I sincerely wish that I could have had a chance to be in your class before I graduate this year. I loved the way you organised the thought and delivered it in a way that even I could understand. I am so grateful, I think I might actually pass my exam on Monday. Thank you Dr. Sadler :')
I am writing an essay on Hegel and I have been trying to understand this for a week. Yours is the only video I've come across that doesn't oversimplify it and that explains it in an understandable way.
i watched three other guys waffling on saying how complex and complicated these concepts were and yet this is so clear and well constructed going once again to prove if you cant explain it simply, you don't know it well enough. thank you for this. wonderful teaching
I am studying at METU which is a famous university in Turkey primarily, but also in the whole world then. Anyway, our lectures are also in English and I have an exam on Sociology. And this video enabled me to get Hegel’s idea. Its not an abstract concept then. I got his idea in a concrete way thanks to you.
these videos are very helpful, we are learning about Hegel in sociological theory, im reading paragraphs 177-196 and was struggling to follow, this has helped!
Thanks for your reply sir. Can you help me out n finding the answer for this question,i’ve spend 2 days but dont know how to cope with this. If u can then it’ll be a great help for your student ♥️ “Examine the view that hegelian spirit is nothing but evolution of human consciousness to the realization of political maturity for global human coexistence”
Nice & clear intro - would be nice to understand more fully the meaning of this self-consciousness seeking recognition through other self-consciousness in terms of the world-spirit movement: given that self-consciousness negates itself within itself for its object, is, ultimately, this movement the one consciousness in and as all consciousnesses so there is a kind of semi-anihilation of the particular within the whole? Can any self-consciousness be for-itself besides world gheist?
NO. More like the Ego as posited by Lacan is an oversimplification of one of the important elements of consciousness as posited by Hegel. Remember Lacan took some inspiration from Hegel and Freud.
I have a question about desire in the field of self help guru's do those people attract things to happen in other people's lives because their just such bigger in desire then other people?
@@SeenaTabatabai Self-help gurus - and gurus in general - are usually BS Who says anyone attracts anything to happen? Why would they have much bigger desires? So many assumptions built in to your question
@@GregoryBSadler I saw another video of yours on desire and setting a goal, I'll use an example let's say there is a person who wants to be physically superior to everyone and tries to make everyone think he is so righteous and really just wants people to keep returning to his site and referring people to his videos and books ...... but what if he was not this way what if he was genuine and set goals to truly help people become fit and did not use strong words for basic things saying running a Ultra Marathon is the suffering as to taking a shower , he called taking a shower suffering by the way....
why is he using something so specific and subjective as desire to define something so abstract like consciousness. this feels like a mix of basic materialistic psychanalysis and complex metaphysics. maybe it seems weird to me because psychanalysis was inveneted much later as a separate subject
gut gemacht, you could have given the example of the paradox of the lovers, used by kojeve (introduction to the lecture of hegel) and sartre (in being and nothingness), to illustrate the necessity of the independance of the other self-consciousness, it works very good in my view.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
This was amazing. I have been struggling with not even the original text, but a 30 page commentary on Phenomenology's preface for the past week, and I have an exam on it on Monday. Your videos have given me hope that philosophy is in fact intelligible :')
In addition, as a college student I sincerely wish that I could have had a chance to be in your class before I graduate this year. I loved the way you organised the thought and delivered it in a way that even I could understand. I am so grateful, I think I might actually pass my exam on Monday. Thank you Dr. Sadler :')
You're very welcome. You might find this interesting, if you enjoy Hegel - halfhourhegel.blogspot.com/
ara sınavımı yaparken misha'yı bulmak...
I am writing an essay on Hegel and I have been trying to understand this for a week. Yours is the only video I've come across that doesn't oversimplify it and that explains it in an understandable way.
Glad it was useful for you. There are five more like that in this playlist - ruclips.net/p/PL4gvlOxpKKIjEEG_o_XRqamupE-M5Fka-
i watched three other guys waffling on saying how complex and complicated these concepts were and yet this is so clear and well constructed going once again to prove if you cant explain it simply, you don't know it well enough. thank you for this. wonderful teaching
This is one of the simpler dialectics within Hegel's Phenomenology
Thank you so much! You explained this in a way that made me excited to learn when I’ve struggled listening to others!
You’re very welcome!
As a philosophy graduate..I’d like to thank you doctor for all your effort ..
You're very welcome!
I am studying at METU which is a famous university in Turkey primarily, but also in the whole world then. Anyway, our lectures are also in English and I have an exam on Sociology. And this video enabled me to get Hegel’s idea. Its not an abstract concept then. I got his idea in a concrete way thanks to you.
Glad it was useful for you!
these videos are very helpful, we are learning about Hegel in sociological theory, im reading paragraphs 177-196 and was struggling to follow, this has helped!
Glad the videos have been helpful for you
I down below the comment section to leave a comment "Amazing" and I already saw so many comments, thanks a lot
You’re welcome!
Just when you thought you left Hegel there's suddenly a Hegelian paradigm that crosses into your own thought direction at another time.
He's hard to get entirely away from
I genuinely appreciate your lectures
Glad they're helpful for you!
Thank you so much I have been struggling to comprehend hegel and this helped so much
This was amazing ! Made it so easy to understand
Glad it was helpful for you
This is extraordinarily well done. Thank you, sir!
You're very welcome!
Sir on the note of German Idealism and self-consciousness, what do you think of the other figures within the tradition - i.e. Fichte and Schelling?
What are you asking?
@@GregoryBSadler Sorry, I mean do you think they are worth studying
@@shen7728 Sure, they're worth studying - if you've got the time and inclination
thank you so much! I finally can understand
Glad it was helpful for you!
Could you broadly trace the differences between Hegel's collectivized 'I' and Fichte's self-positing I (which is also similarly embodied)?
No thanks. ruclips.net/video/OV_T8Emyf6I/видео.html
Amazing explanation, thank you so much!
You're welcome!
Wow brilliant pedagogy
Well, I don't know about that, but thanks
Thanks for your reply sir. Can you help me out n finding the answer for this question,i’ve spend 2 days but dont know how to cope with this. If u can then it’ll be a great help for your student ♥️ “Examine the view that hegelian spirit is nothing but evolution of human consciousness to the realization of political maturity for global human coexistence”
This was excellent 👏
Thanks!
Nice & clear intro - would be nice to understand more fully the meaning of this self-consciousness seeking recognition through other self-consciousness in terms of the world-spirit movement: given that self-consciousness negates itself within itself for its object, is, ultimately, this movement the one consciousness in and as all consciousnesses so there is a kind of semi-anihilation of the particular within the whole? Can any self-consciousness be for-itself besides world gheist?
Every self-consciousness is for-itself, by virtue of being self-consciousness. So, yeah.
Keep reading and rereading the text
Hegels self-conciousness is basically what Lacan calls the Ego, making yourself an object.
As someone who has been working on both of over two decades, I wouldn't make that easy identification.
NO. More like the Ego as posited by Lacan is an oversimplification of one of the important elements of consciousness as posited by Hegel. Remember Lacan took some inspiration from Hegel and Freud.
What Hegel means by others?
What the word means
2 Nietzschenians disliked this video
I have a question about desire in the field of self help guru's do those people attract things to happen in other people's lives because their just such bigger in desire then other people?
Eddited.
No
@@GregoryBSadler why not?
@@SeenaTabatabai Self-help gurus - and gurus in general - are usually BS
Who says anyone attracts anything to happen?
Why would they have much bigger desires?
So many assumptions built in to your question
@@GregoryBSadler I saw another video of yours on desire and setting a goal, I'll use an example let's say there is a person who wants to be physically superior to everyone and tries to make everyone think he is so righteous and really just wants people to keep returning to his site and referring people to his videos and books ...... but what if he was not this way what if he was genuine and set goals to truly help people become fit and did not use strong words for basic things saying running a Ultra Marathon is the suffering as to taking a shower , he called taking a shower suffering by the way....
Thanx for ur video
You're welcome
useful......thanks a lot!
You're welcome!
cool talk
Thanks!
why is he using something so specific and subjective as desire to define something so abstract like consciousness. this feels like a mix of basic materialistic psychanalysis and complex metaphysics. maybe it seems weird to me because psychanalysis was inveneted much later as a separate subject
ruclips.net/video/xgf2jztjaF4/видео.html
All is vanity... One of the few good quotes from the Bible
Well, mining scripture for quotes is probably an unproductive approach
🙌🏻👍
gut gemacht, you could have given the example of the paradox of the lovers, used by kojeve (introduction to the lecture of hegel) and sartre (in being and nothingness), to illustrate the necessity of the independance of the other self-consciousness, it works very good in my view.
If it was a core concept video on Sartre or Kojeve, that would make sense
Americans never expand on anything that would help the direct message.
Straight to the point.