They didn’t break the law. In fact by not giving access to a customers phone they protected his privacy and dignity of wich one is the most important and the other one a very important law. If they had given the FBI Access they wouldn’t have broken the law either but ignored their company’s highest policy and standard(The Security and Privacy of their customers).
@@TheLonghairedBomber But it can also be argued that Apple is technically withholding/concealing evidence, which is actually a crime in the US (at least most states as far as I know)
@@PatoChu wich is understandably a very important law but a humans dignity is the most powerful law of all and towering over every other one(I don’t know if it’s the same in California). Here where I live without acknowledgment of the suspect or a definite proof of such a crime a phone can not be searched by anyone.
@@TheLonghairedBomber The FBI is not "anyone" though. Also, you're correct in one thing, it's not strictly illegal for Apple to refuse, I am just saying that it can be argued that this is obstruction of evidence which is a serious offense.
@@TheLonghairedBomberI’m not a lawyer, but I study law because i found it interesting. This would be seen as withholding information and under the necessary and proper clause which congress has power with, (and is kind of given to government agencies) they would win in court and apple would lose. Also they could’ve just done it to the one phone, but it would cost them time and for such a small portion size they saw no value
@@SawyerFan.1 because nothing is 100% secure, not because the government forces them to make it unsafe. You cannot existentially think of something until that thing has occurred. There’ll always be an exploit or an issue which the engineers haven’t thought about but a hacker has. Nothing in this world is 100% perfect, not even computer security.
Because the us would never think about banning apple for not revealing user data unlike china. Apple like any other company only cares about profit. They didn't say no to the fbi because they love their customers or because they value the users privacy, they said no because it would hurt their image and that only hurts profits
No, CCP intercepts shipments of iPhones and reprograms them first. CIA does this too sometimes usually with important targets, look up the CIA’ Tailored Access Operations center which focuses on destroying and breaking into specific targets using a tailored approach.
It's the CCP, Xi won't let them sell iPhones to china if they don't do it and since China has the most population in the world well then its safe to say Apple was scared to lose 1/3 of their profits
RUclips has a limit of 60 seconds on shorts. TikTok and Instagram have longer limits. TikToks that are not under 60 seconds just get put under regular videos.
@@dogewithagun7no one hacks android phones because no one important uses them. Kidding aside, there's a reason why huawei isnt running Android officially.
there's literally shorts about this exact thing, All they do is connect the phone to a computer. change the attempts to like a billion and use a computer to try every combination at god speed.
@@blue_ig1 I'm in the apple hate camp, but I'm not a damn idiot, I praise them for this. Damn near everything else tho... Apple can go pound sand for a hundred years before coming back to talk to me.
@@ZeldagigafanMatthew I do agree too, but I think most of the time a lot of Android users just go “Apple sucks” for no reason at all, just cause it has “Apple” on it they’ll start hating. I’m not saying all, but a lot.
"Ironclad wall of security" meanwhile peoples old and deleted photos on devices are just randomly popping up on devices long since wiped. There's also the M series built in security vulnerability that cant be patched.
You don’t know security do you? 1. Security ≠ Privacy. 1.1. As already discussed many times, the photos issue was a bug with no proven malicious intent. 2. The “M series chip vulnerability that cannot be patched” is overblown. It would require plenty of expertise and a whole lot of time to exploit, not sustainable for real-life use. It’s practically a non-issue. There was another issue with M1 which could only be exploited by manipulating the voltage flow… you know how hard it is to do that, let alone without breaking the machine and at the exact nanosecond to successfully exploit? Android manufacturer shill
or you could pug the phone in to a computer with the right conditions remove the files that forbid you from trying a lot of passwords and set up some code to try every single password and wait for it to stop. Correct me if i am wrong
I am one the biggest apple haters you can find but the one concession i will always give them is their security. It makes android firewalls look like paper in comparison
For one of my cybersecurity degree modules, I had to write an about the security of both iOS and Android. From my research, I found multiple instances where Apple has protected its users against intelligence agencies, this is much less common with Google. This difference aligns with their core philosophies, Apple emphasises security (resulting in less freedom), whereas Android prioritizes user freedom (which leads to less security).
Yeah but if they can find a way in Apple can find it aswell and then like you said fix it so I dont see the problem if anything if a third party finds a exploit Its way riskier than when apple does it themselfes
This is a tricky situation. It’s why Apple security is so “weird” people can do illegal stuff (mainly drugs) on their iPhones and probably be good because Apple security is insane. So if someone were to commit a minor crime like drugs or something of that sort… I think it’s good that Apple wouldn’t turn them over to the most powerful people in the U.S. government. But then with terrorists it becomes more difficult. I can easily forgive someone who does drugs but killing 16 people 😬 from the perspective of the shooter however, they certainly wouldn’t want their phones info leaked to the fbi so they are now counting on Apple to not dig that hole as well.
Isn’t there a company specializing in hacking phones? The one that Jeff bazos phone got hacked by? I don’t remember the name of the company but like i know that the king of Saudi arabia paid the company to hack the phone or something
Hey carterpc yousaid not to ask for pc But didn't said not to ask for gpu Can u send me an rtx 30 or 40 series I am building a pc and a bit short for gpu
In my opinion, this is good security. They manage to keep their customer's data private even if it means breaking the law.
They didn’t break the law. In fact by not giving access to a customers phone they protected his privacy and dignity of wich one is the most important and the other one a very important law. If they had given the FBI Access they wouldn’t have broken the law either but ignored their company’s highest policy and standard(The Security and Privacy of their customers).
@@TheLonghairedBomber But it can also be argued that Apple is technically withholding/concealing evidence, which is actually a crime in the US (at least most states as far as I know)
@@PatoChu wich is understandably a very important law but a humans dignity is the most powerful law of all and towering over every other one(I don’t know if it’s the same in California). Here where I live without acknowledgment of the suspect or a definite proof of such a crime a phone can not be searched by anyone.
@@TheLonghairedBomber The FBI is not "anyone" though. Also, you're correct in one thing, it's not strictly illegal for Apple to refuse, I am just saying that it can be argued that this is obstruction of evidence which is a serious offense.
@@TheLonghairedBomberI’m not a lawyer, but I study law because i found it interesting. This would be seen as withholding information and under the necessary and proper clause which congress has power with, (and is kind of given to government agencies) they would win in court and apple would lose. Also they could’ve just done it to the one phone, but it would cost them time and for such a small portion size they saw no value
Apple really said "snitches get stitches, and were not google"
💀
Google also rejects subpoenas a lot
Audio delay hit different🔛🔝😭🙏🏽🔥🔥🔥🔥
bruh didn’t even notice
At the beginning
Thanks for this I believed it was my headphones
only in the beginning tho
@@hyek2.0 ye
I swear I thought that David fella was the EMOTIONAL DAMAGE dude
Steven he😂
@@ClaytonHenson exactly
“all Asians look the same”
-a smart guy
@@acer1kylesf943 true💀
thats his successful cousin timmy
Apple should give us data how to bring carter to do the thugshake
Fr
They should give us the data where it shows video footage of Carter doing the thug shake
I think Apple already has a backdoor like that, this situation just wasn't worth it to make it public
Every single device with an operating system created or maintained within the U.S. in the last decade has one.
@@normifiedas proven by?
@@tdrg_ It's bro science, Trust him
@@tdrg_ the fact all of them have been broken at some point
@@SawyerFan.1 because nothing is 100% secure, not because the government forces them to make it unsafe. You cannot existentially think of something until that thing has occurred. There’ll always be an exploit or an issue which the engineers haven’t thought about but a hacker has. Nothing in this world is 100% perfect, not even computer security.
Tim Cook really Cooked
Wasn’t it Steve Jobs back theb
@hellstorm82819 no Tim Cook had been CEO of Apple for 5 years then
@@luke_webster2015 was 9 years ago.
@@luke_webster 13 years...
@1dome yeah but at the time it was 5 years
Well that's one way to break the law to help the law
Apple said yes to China reading messages of protesting citizens
Until they move their supply chain out of China they have to bow to the communist regime
Because the us would never think about banning apple for not revealing user data unlike china. Apple like any other company only cares about profit. They didn't say no to the fbi because they love their customers or because they value the users privacy, they said no because it would hurt their image and that only hurts profits
No, CCP intercepts shipments of iPhones and reprograms them first. CIA does this too sometimes usually with important targets, look up the CIA’ Tailored Access Operations center which focuses on destroying and breaking into specific targets using a tailored approach.
It's the CCP, Xi won't let them sell iPhones to china if they don't do it and since China has the most population in the world well then its safe to say Apple was scared to lose 1/3 of their profits
Apple could've done that but they wanna tell everyone "privacy matters" 😂
Because it does. Apple made the right call here. And the end is a great outcome. No iPhones were backdoored, and the attacker’s phone was unlocked.
Bro Apple could cure fucking cancer and yet the Android needs would still make fun of them 💀💀💀
The 14th greatest tech fact of all time is that Carter reuploads videos
Congrats on 800k
apple aint no snitch lol
Brooo I remember this happening, it was actually mad funny
i love these long form videos plz make more
They are just longer TikTok re-uploaded
RUclips has a limit of 60 seconds on shorts. TikTok and Instagram have longer limits. TikToks that are not under 60 seconds just get put under regular videos.
This isn’t even 2 minutes, very short video how is this long form
I agree. This is a good outcome.
thats a win win win
Fr
Carter you can either go 4M dollars in debt giving everyone a pc or you can do thug shake. These are 2 awesome decisions tbh.
Here before this blows up
Remember kids, no matter how secure it is, there's always a weakness, somewhere, somehow.
Apple ain't no snitch 🗣️🗣️🗣️
OIL UP CARTER
Whenever someone says FBI i get reminded for FIB from gta v
Carter is out of school but still teaches us
Another great video ❤
ur gay
This type content is cool do more
Apple: Great security. "Meh" products.
More like good security. When was the last time you've heard that an Android has been hacked?
Agreed with the second statement
@@dogewithagun7no one hacks android phones because no one important uses them. Kidding aside, there's a reason why huawei isnt running Android officially.
@@glh7728 Huawei ain't running Android cause they were literally fucking banned from using us stuff like google
@@dogewithagun7all the time, androids keep getting viruses.
@@willy4170 yea sure buddy
Here at 15 seconds new record 🎉
Damn I thought RUclips was lagging but nah it was the video
there's literally shorts about this exact thing, All they do is connect the phone to a computer. change the attempts to like a billion and use a computer to try every combination at god speed.
I remember a similar time to this. It was when Carter refused to show himself doing the thug shake
Carter please oil up
your not funny
@@schaserneo let him be
@@schaserneoI'm not trying to be funny I'm being serious
@@Mrbobbyboohe also needs to do the thug shaker
@@Turdleburger I know right
Nice bedtime story now i gotta actually sleep ☹️
U already go to sleep 😂😂 what time zone u in fam
@@Blvck-14 12:33 am , woke up at 7 am today and i have school tmr so gotta wake at 7 as well , haven’t took a nap today as well 🫠
Apple dapple donkelley wonkelley
thank you, thank you.
10/10 Content Bro
All it took was a dead man😂😂😂😂
Class
the fbi should track carter and teach him how to do the thugshake
If only you did the thug shaker Apple would give you all the users phones.
Bro whats with the audio delay
Apple being apple
I can’t with these apple haters, “they wouldn’t let anyone break through their security system, urghh so mean”
@@blue_ig1 I'm in the apple hate camp, but I'm not a damn idiot, I praise them for this. Damn near everything else tho... Apple can go pound sand for a hundred years before coming back to talk to me.
@@ZeldagigafanMatthew well said
@@ZeldagigafanMatthew I do agree too, but I think most of the time a lot of Android users just go “Apple sucks” for no reason at all, just cause it has “Apple” on it they’ll start hating. I’m not saying all, but a lot.
@@blue_ig1 iCloud leak
"Ironclad wall of security" meanwhile peoples old and deleted photos on devices are just randomly popping up on devices long since wiped. There's also the M series built in security vulnerability that cant be patched.
You don’t know security do you?
1. Security ≠ Privacy.
1.1. As already discussed many times, the photos issue was a bug with no proven malicious intent.
2. The “M series chip vulnerability that cannot be patched” is overblown. It would require plenty of expertise and a whole lot of time to exploit, not sustainable for real-life use. It’s practically a non-issue. There was another issue with M1 which could only be exploited by manipulating the voltage flow… you know how hard it is to do that, let alone without breaking the machine and at the exact nanosecond to successfully exploit?
Android manufacturer shill
@tdrg_ dude I'm not a shill for anyone. Some photos can contain very sensitive information
Same thing happened in India a few weeks back lol 😅
Why does David look like Steven He 💀💀
the fbi’s lost it
everyone asking for a free pc but can you give me a free thug shaker
bro you gotta align the boice
do the thugshake
Do the thug shake
Apple should help carter do the thug shake
or you could pug the phone in to a computer with the right conditions remove the files that forbid you from trying a lot of passwords and set up some code to try every single password and wait for it to stop. Correct me if i am wrong
i also find all your videos very entertaining thank you
Terraria W
Ayeee I’m from the dino
Ray William Johnson but iphone
Audio delay doin the thug shake 😂😂
why does everything happen in san bernadino 💀 i just went there last wednesday
so its a big win win
Day one of asking carterpcs for a pc
I am one the biggest apple haters you can find but the one concession i will always give them is their security. It makes android firewalls look like paper in comparison
Give us access to watch you doing a “thugged shaker”
The FBI should tell Carter to do the thug shake
So is this the real carter pcs idk anymore 😭😭😭
Is it just me or is the audio felayrd
For once, good job multibillion dollar corporation.
That’s mad
Carter buy another sports bra and do the thug shake
Pumpkin 🥬
Carter oil up and do the thug shake on an Alienware PC 😩😩
1 min ago is crazy
how about for android?
For one of my cybersecurity degree modules, I had to write an about the security of both iOS and Android. From my research, I found multiple instances where Apple has protected its users against intelligence agencies, this is much less common with Google. This difference aligns with their core philosophies, Apple emphasises security (resulting in less freedom), whereas Android prioritizes user freedom (which leads to less security).
The good ending
I KNEW APPLE WAS ON CHINAS SIDE!
12 minutes ago is sexually harassing
Yeah but if they can find a way in Apple can find it aswell and then like you said fix it so I dont see the problem if anything if a third party finds a exploit Its way riskier than when apple does it themselfes
where’s the other 12? 😭
As an Android user w apple
Whoever decided to make that stupid auto erase thing deserves hell
This is a tricky situation. It’s why Apple security is so “weird” people can do illegal stuff (mainly drugs) on their iPhones and probably be good because Apple security is insane. So if someone were to commit a minor crime like drugs or something of that sort… I think it’s good that Apple wouldn’t turn them over to the most powerful people in the U.S. government. But then with terrorists it becomes more difficult. I can easily forgive someone who does drugs but killing 16 people 😬 from the perspective of the shooter however, they certainly wouldn’t want their phones info leaked to the fbi so they are now counting on Apple to not dig that hole as well.
One of the ONLY good things this dogshit monopoly has done
rare apple w
David wang and steven he are one and the same
Can i get a red magic 9s pro
Hey Carter for winning my basketball tournament I can get a new graphic card what are some good recommendation (I have a great power supply)
Yippee!
Where do u go to shcool
he graduated recently
Do the thug shake!!!
Apple gud
Bruh
Don’t care he didn’t do the thug shake
Isn’t there a company specializing in hacking phones? The one that Jeff bazos phone got hacked by? I don’t remember the name of the company but like i know that the king of Saudi arabia paid the company to hack the phone or something
Laptop? 179
Bros a full time content creator now and can't get his audio right 💀
Apple W
god damn
no views 15 seconds ago man youve feel off carter
APPLE WHY NOT DO THAT FOR THE FBI
Their lazy
@@Dirt_Biking111 Bro you have GOT to be be mentally handicapped
Because that’s compromising security for all users
@@Dirt_Biking111 did you not watch it dum monkey
Hey carterpc yousaid not to ask for pc
But didn't said not to ask for gpu
Can u send me an rtx 30 or 40 series
I am building a pc and a bit short for gpu
oil up thugg
Still not as bad as you refusing to do the thug shake
Bro why is this Fake Carterpcs doing good bruh