“Can’t Rule Out A Joint Front Between Pakistan And China” - Nirupama Rao | Faye D'Souza

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025

Комментарии • 121

  • @joelaranha9248
    @joelaranha9248 4 года назад +13

    Faye you are a Anchor of incredible positive energy which comes all the way across to us. You warm our hearts we absolutely love you ❤️❤️❤️

  • @devduttabhattacharya5733
    @devduttabhattacharya5733 4 года назад +1

    So well explained Madam Rao.This makes real sense. So we have push and hold on to our territory till the winter sets in. We have answer them by their on terms Jai Hind

  • @lilyaranha5272
    @lilyaranha5272 4 года назад +5

    Thank u Faye, delight to watch it, awesome journalist 😊🌟👍👍👏

  • @soccourgonsalves9030
    @soccourgonsalves9030 4 года назад +1

    Faye keep it up and do not give in to fear, we really appreciate your work

  • @iyerlawofficellc3907
    @iyerlawofficellc3907 4 года назад +2

    The 1962 defeat by China was terrible leadership of Nehru who was not a strategist and did not use the Indian Airforce because some BABUS in the Defense Ministry did not want for any aircrafts to be lost in action but wanted to keep it as a show piece. Nehru pacified China on Tibet and the East Turkistan occupation by China.

  • @NATURELOVERAKAAnup
    @NATURELOVERAKAAnup 4 года назад +4

    Wow Nice timing for this video, just as Live Finished 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @dhenukasharma5967
    @dhenukasharma5967 4 года назад +5

    Now that's how a diplomat speaks. So so delicate. It's upto us to read between the lines with a damn magnifying glass to understand what the ambassador is saying while not saying...

    • @thomasranjit7781
      @thomasranjit7781 4 года назад +1

      U must be BJP IT cell worker

    • @dhenukasharma5967
      @dhenukasharma5967 4 года назад

      @@thomasranjit7781 I'm not.. I hate them...but when people come from knowledgeable sources... listening to them is good for our own understanding...that lady has served in a powerful post unlike you or me... Experience is experience, knowledge is knowledge irrespective of political stands

    • @dhenukasharma5967
      @dhenukasharma5967 4 года назад

      @@thomasranjit7781 I didn't say she is amazing.. I said look at the delicate way of framing statements.. something we can all learn...coz otherwise what is the difference between us and internet trolls

    • @thomasranjit7781
      @thomasranjit7781 4 года назад

      @@dhenukasharma5967 dealing with China is very sensitive issue..U can expect the third world war in coming years..

  • @humayunbawkher5372
    @humayunbawkher5372 4 года назад

    Insightful & realistic analysis. Starting a war with China may be tempting but once it starts it may not end quickly. People need to be taken into confidence on what is most feasible and best for India and not be surprised again.

  • @sanatanindology905
    @sanatanindology905 4 года назад +3

    According to Nirupama Rao( and giving her ample credit for her diplomacy) whenever she says..I hope Indian Army is doing this....I hope Indian Govt thinks...I hope....she actually means she thinks these institutions "Do Not".

  • @saleemc
    @saleemc 4 года назад +2

    Very interesting discussion between these to amazing ladies. I am very surprised there was no mention of abrogation of Article 370 and Indians strategic aim egged on by the US to sabotage the China Pakistan corridor route.

  • @waseemrahman5033
    @waseemrahman5033 4 года назад +1

    Go to UN? But you won’t because then you have to solve a 72 year old Kashmir problem.

  • @firetree2007
    @firetree2007 4 года назад

    She sincerely wants a good relationship between China and India, however, not much she can do about the situation.

  • @49jayant
    @49jayant 4 года назад

    My God.. she has been handling China since 1988.. her know ledge is as good as the morning news paper..

  • @markchiu1716
    @markchiu1716 4 года назад +3

    Ladakh is historically part of Tibet and Tibet is part of China, the reason China does not give up the Ladakh claim is based on this. China lost Ladakh in the 19th century just like ceding Hong Kong/Taiwan/Macao to other colonialists but the difference is no Chinese administration recognized/signed any treaty with the British Empire. The border dispute between China and India was created by the British Empire not directly by the Chinese and Indian people. The two countries live peacefully for thousands of years until the English came in.

    • @markchiu1716
      @markchiu1716 4 года назад

      Arunachal Pradesh is a similar case. the so-called Tibetan government by that time was a puppet government supported by the British colonists and would do whatever it could to please them. The authority of the Republic of China and the People's of Republic China never recognize the Simla Accord and the McMahon Line and that is why there is border issue there. The reason China retreated after the occupation of Arunachal Pradesh in 1962 was trying to downplay the issue with India and hope to negotiate with Indian to solve these issues. I would say China never wants a war with India. But it seems some Indian politicians inherit certain characters from British colonist

    • @thomasranjit7781
      @thomasranjit7781 4 года назад +1

      Tibet is a indipendent country. According to Japan China is part of Japanese territory,what U will do ???

    • @thomasranjit7781
      @thomasranjit7781 4 года назад

      What about south China sea ??? China claims all of it...the Chinese leadership forget pride comes before a mighty fall..

    • @markchiu1716
      @markchiu1716 4 года назад +1

      Thomas Ranjit Well, Japan never defeat and rule China during WWII, so they cannot claim that which is quite different between British and India. With the great sacrifices of Chinese people and the help from the Soviet and the US, China helped force Japan to surrender. That is why China is one of the five permanent members of UN Security Council. I heard India wants to be part of it too. But according to Indian history, it is so easy to be defeated and colonized by many outsiders. Only maurya dynasty was found by native Indian and that was 2000 years ago... India has to prove it can do something good for this world first. Build toilet first is good step

    • @markchiu1716
      @markchiu1716 4 года назад +1

      Vihari Royal In November 1946, the Republic of China sent naval ships to take control of these islands after the surrender of Japan. Actually US navy was there with the Chinese Navy to take back the island. Simply because Republic Of China evacuated to Taiwan in 1949, US changed the mind. That is also a good lesson for my Indian friends.

  • @oops262686
    @oops262686 4 года назад +5

    we are a divided democracy

    • @SinghalLouis
      @SinghalLouis 4 года назад +5

      We have a divider-in-chief at the top.. two actually..

    • @SinghalLouis
      @SinghalLouis 4 года назад +2

      @S R look at you crying.. truth hurts, doesn't it.. pathetic illiterate bootlickers

  • @prabhasivaraman320
    @prabhasivaraman320 4 года назад

    I enjoyed this interview. A topical subject discussed with clarity and diplomatically. Kudos to you Faye for bringing out the best from your guests.

  • @satishpatil5865
    @satishpatil5865 4 года назад

    Keep on Faye. Its just people are not habitual for such long discussions. But don't loose hope. Time will bring the change. You are doing excellent job. More power to you.

  • @shaunvegburger5718
    @shaunvegburger5718 4 года назад +2

    The MAD (Modi, Amit, Doval) government haS pushed India into a corner, there is no going back.
    The social, economic, military, mutiny, and corruption thaT exists in India is very close to the conditions that existed in USSR in 1990.
    Expect the announcement of dismemberment of India on December 26, 2021 - exactly 30 years after the disintegration of USSR.
    This could be a blessing in disguise, as obvious from the bouncing back of Russia, Central Asian Republics, and to a lesser extent, Ukraine and Estonia.

    • @sridharmurthy1076
      @sridharmurthy1076 4 года назад

      Shaun Vegburger 🖕

    • @Raj-nh3fc
      @Raj-nh3fc 4 года назад

      Bollocks! This is the best nation centric government that India has had since independance. They live and work for India and Indians. The unsatisfied groups are either congress supporters or muslims. Putting it plainly. And they have their own dirty agenda.

  • @adruvitpandit5816
    @adruvitpandit5816 4 года назад

    Brilliant, another RUclipsr in the making.

  • @indian5189
    @indian5189 4 года назад

    How come a journalist of such a stature is not getting views. Without financial backing such great minds will not reach enough people to have a well informed democracy. We need an independent public funded media house.

  • @vinay11163
    @vinay11163 4 года назад +2

    Very nice debate

  • @shahrookherani870
    @shahrookherani870 4 года назад

    They say to compare is to destroy, that statement must come with a rider, only in philosophy. Here we have a learned lady of substance one cannot ignore. If, there is a measuring instrument in politics for intelligence, she would, as a single unit outweigh the entire governing party, along with it’s allies. Just one word ‘DECIMATE.’ A timely and intelligent choice by Faye, aam aadmi need to know from a ‘medium of truth’.🙏

  • @daljitchadha929
    @daljitchadha929 4 года назад +1

    What a lovable person you are Faye. God bless you always.

  • @wethepeople1680
    @wethepeople1680 4 года назад +1

    But Modi did surgical strike and balakot strikes in Pakistan. It proves that he himself is very abled prime minister. . But some people in India are helping Pakistan and China...First time we have a PM who is not afraid of anyone ,Pakistan or China or whoever... but We need the traitors in our country to sent to jail ,like intellectuals and Lutyens....
    The 10th avatar of Vishnu ( modi obviously) has retaliated properly ..Which the spineless khangress has never done in 70 years.
    Ha ha , that was a joke
    ...This is how a blind right wing extremist would have said...
    A Vacant PM seat is better for the country than modi sitting as PM . His deeds always prove disastrous for people.

  • @narayanshenvi8154
    @narayanshenvi8154 4 года назад +2

    Mrs. Rao, we know your junior is now EAM. It's OK. Be a sport.

  • @asingh7608
    @asingh7608 4 года назад +2

    Sorry to say Former Foreign Secretary we did not do it because we were not allowed to do it. I am a economic major under graduate back in 2003 masters in 2007 and I am from Texas by profession I was a banker then. You guys are incompetent in foreign service. With Congress government. I live in Texas come and ask me I personally can give China run for there money. Remember China made money from USA not from Africa or India. I am living in US for a while. I know how business is done. PM Modi came in is working hard to make sure country is moving in the right direction. I know exactly how money works and that US based financial intuition. Come and talk to me will give you inside out.

  • @SinghalLouis
    @SinghalLouis 4 года назад +2

    What do you mean, you can't rule out.. it's happening right now right in front of our eyes.. What's there to rule out

    • @dhenukasharma5967
      @dhenukasharma5967 4 года назад +2

      Dude that's called diplomatic statements.. they never say anything directly coz then it becomes accusations or demands... You can make powerful statements even when u are being subtle... Rao has spoken this way all her career now it's a hard habit to leave

  • @dhirajsharma1475
    @dhirajsharma1475 4 года назад

    Very nice thaughtful discussion

  • @nri6878
    @nri6878 4 года назад +4

    Can you do a report or stream on inflated electricity bills

    • @nri6878
      @nri6878 4 года назад

      @Malik Ahmad the matter I'm requesting to be discussed is local issue and has nothing to do with country. Can u please delete your reply to my comment as it was unnecessary.

    • @nri6878
      @nri6878 4 года назад

      @Malik Ahmad you are again being stubborn and poking your nose unnecessarily....you are an independent nation and your problems are your own problems and our problem are our own problems and does not require your mediation ok...do you get it....hope you do... And stop referring me as your friend.....I don't know who u are and I'm not interested in your friendship.....so please stay-off.

    • @Parasuram5
      @Parasuram5 4 года назад

      Ms Rao has become a poster gold of all anti-Modi forces. Her interview with Karan Thapar is widely qouted in Pakistan. Very obvious she has a sinister agenda. With people like her does India need enemies

  • @MrSmoovefan1231
    @MrSmoovefan1231 4 года назад

    She is one intelligent voice on RUclips lately.

  • @najeebmemon984
    @najeebmemon984 4 года назад

    In our area there is a saying that "if you want to be an elder or bigger one than you have to act like that as well" means elder has to go to the younger one and ask if he has any problem we could solve it together

    • @ZafarIqbal-sn8go
      @ZafarIqbal-sn8go 4 года назад

      When the intention is to whimsically cash the divide, why should the elderly reach the younger and exert for a mutual reconciliation?

    • @ytadltspv
      @ytadltspv 4 года назад +1

      @@ZafarIqbal-sn8go all the more reason why reaching out is important-the younger one can do a lot of irreparable damage to self and others, if pushed to the wall, the elderly can just destroy the younger one. no one really wins-and everyone knows it. its just a matter of not blinking first!

  • @saurabhreddragons
    @saurabhreddragons 4 года назад +1

    Woah.... 😲😲😲😲😲😲

    • @AlphonseSelvaraj
      @AlphonseSelvaraj 4 года назад

      Firm fearless yet diplomatic synthesis of the situation and ways forward to be economically progressive and militarily well prepared to deal with china on our long borders for long time. Thanks 😊 great Faye and FS.Nirpama Rao.

  • @mehboobelahi8897
    @mehboobelahi8897 4 года назад

    Some sensible do exist in India

  • @iyerlawofficellc3907
    @iyerlawofficellc3907 4 года назад

    China accepted the MacMohan line for Burma or Myanmar so it must accept it for India

  • @satpurush2592
    @satpurush2592 4 года назад

    When I look beyond words and things spoken in this interview, what I infer is politics again.

  • @fayyazcchary4488
    @fayyazcchary4488 4 года назад

    It all started because amit Shah threatened both China and pakistan on aksai chin and gilgit baltistan in parliament threatened to take back by force .now everyone crying In India.

  • @shaikhasiruddin
    @shaikhasiruddin 4 года назад

    Appreciate..

  • @markchiu1716
    @markchiu1716 4 года назад +1

    Interesting, I think the two sides have a totally different understanding of LAC. I think the movement that the Indian parliament voted to change Kashmir's status which including the Ladakh is one of the triggers.

  • @positrontelesystems5641
    @positrontelesystems5641 4 года назад +1

    The blunders of Manmohan Sonia government is largely irreversible but never an impossible proposition. It's still not clear what agreement was made in 2008 between Rahul Gandhi, the general secretary of Congress and his counterpart, the general secretary of Chinese Communist party. But that lead to increase of our imports from China to almost 600%.

    • @tramanarayanarao2656
      @tramanarayanarao2656 4 года назад +1

      Friends of BJP Reliance Jio Imported 4G Technology. That Accounts for the Increased Imports. Tell your Modi to Ban 5G Imports from China but you won't do that. 😏

  • @Ginio1982
    @Ginio1982 4 года назад +1

    Faye, can you discuss on one India one pension..

    • @Ginio1982
      @Ginio1982 4 года назад

      @S R I am not running the government, the government who is is collecting our taxes will do that..

  • @abhuditgreene
    @abhuditgreene 4 года назад

    Extremely disappointed with Ms. Rao's interview. In her own words, India from the 50s forwarded Panchsheel, absolute silence on Chinese Tibet grab and Hindi-Cheeni bhai-bhai doctrine only to get a 1962 in return. In her own words Chinese have been altering the goal posts with respect to claimed territories, seasoning their claims with illogical reasoning across Asia. I'm surprised that a seasoned diplomat as herself is intellectualising what essentially has been a land-grabbing, muscle flexing disposition of the Chinese. It's time that India ups the ante calling out China as enemy of democratic values, have deeper defence collaboration with USA, Japan and Australia, support the people's movement in Hongkong, recognise Taiwan and recognise the next Tibetian Dalai Lama. It's time India stops soft-peddling issues that have plagued India's foreign policy for the last 70 years. In all reasonableness it's time were need decisive, brusque, unequivocal diplomats.
    Felt the questions asked by Faye were too academic or metaphysical at best rather than forward looking.
    However, I love this channel as Faye gives voice to the issues that otherwise works remain silenced.

  • @rajeshpillaik
    @rajeshpillaik 4 года назад

    Is it true ? Yes But for what to save CEPEC INVESTMENT aka one belt one road initiative . To halt them from two from war just say forget about CEPEC and we will make it history ...

  • @positrontelesystems5641
    @positrontelesystems5641 4 года назад +2

    Faye, I am sorry, may be I am being judgemental but from what I percieved from your last question to Rao it looked like you wanted to speak out your mind about our beloved PM Modi or his government of being responsible for the tensions across the border. My advice to you please don't try to put your opinions into others mouth. If I have judged it wrong I apologise for being judgemental but from words and your body langauge I am perhaps not wrong.
    I also appreciate Nirupama Rao who undoubtedly is one of the finest ambassador and had great control on her response and gave full marks to the government for its diplomacy and an advice to all listeners to have full faith in our government.

    • @tramanarayanarao2656
      @tramanarayanarao2656 4 года назад +1

      I think you Judged her even before Watching the Video. You are Fooling No One. 🤔

  • @Raj-nh3fc
    @Raj-nh3fc 4 года назад

    The India China peace of 4 decades that Mrs. Rao refers to is nothing but India bowing down to China and keeping quiet during its grabbing of Tibet, and even Indian territory, a mismanagement that began with Nehrus foreign policy. Now when India asserts its right to defend its territory a lot of our congress and Islamic friends are unhappy. They want to see India weak and broken down. Modi and Shah have come at the right time in Indian and world politics. If you can not defend your country and its integrity and your life, what use is all this high powered, pseudorationalised analysis and thinking. I hope the Congress supporters and muslims in India realise that. Would you like to live under Chinese rule or any foreign rule for that matter? Was not more than 100 years of British domination and subjugation of India enough to open your eyes?

  • @chamankhan7396
    @chamankhan7396 4 года назад +1

    Amit shah called Bangladeshi people’s termites

    • @avsenba1165
      @avsenba1165 4 года назад

      Wow !! he called ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS as Termites NOT Bangladeshis - I guess there is a misunderstanding.

    • @chamankhan7396
      @chamankhan7396 4 года назад

      avsen ba Bangladesh information minister hasanul haq said we in Dhaka do not give any important to this statement of India can I ask u avsen bhai what statement

  • @mdhidayat1509
    @mdhidayat1509 4 года назад

    Correct sound quality mam

  • @PratyushRai
    @PratyushRai 4 года назад

    Yeah, we cant roll out. :)

  • @misterbean5308
    @misterbean5308 4 года назад

    Wow....dont worry...general rawat had promised he can fight a 2 front war for india..

    • @ZafarIqbal-sn8go
      @ZafarIqbal-sn8go 4 года назад

      Waiting to cheer him. I hope he is truthful.

  • @positrontelesystems5641
    @positrontelesystems5641 4 года назад

    Faye, what we largely exports to china is minerals and may be some agricultural produce and few softwares, but largely it is raw minerals and minerals are always limited because they are non renewable unlike agricultural produce and we should actually stop exporting minerals jsut not to China but anywhere else as well. They are non renewable resources and inadequate looking into our own future requirements for our forthcoming generations. Both China and USA rarely export there minerals despite of abundancy in its deposits but instead exports finished products which earn them more money and provides labor to its citizens. We should conserve our nonrenewable resources Coal, Iron ore, Copper and whatsoever.

    • @tramanarayanarao2656
      @tramanarayanarao2656 4 года назад

      That's an Interesting Way to Boot Raw Mayerials to Ambani and Adani Friends of Bjp

  • @Nagpadawala
    @Nagpadawala 4 года назад

    Read the chinese news papers and web site (IF you know Mandrin ) to understand the chinese point of view for motives to this action. Pity these " Knowledgeable sprouters " dont know Mandrin

  • @pinto.n23
    @pinto.n23 4 года назад

    Y

  • @hamid5379
    @hamid5379 4 года назад

    leading MODI from FRONT OR BACK ----------------------?/////.
    A projector and a screen, the wood panelled hall with wooden flooring and the
    conspicuous absence of any medical equipment or accessory like the I.V. stand,
    medicine cabinet, a dustbin, oxygen cylinder or for that matter even doctors and
    nurses, strengthened that MODI is leading from BACK.

  • @DRRANGARAJAN
    @DRRANGARAJAN 4 года назад

    Such an opinion appears to have been expressed without application of mind. Once Chinese are allowed within Pakistan, the will herald the gradual disappearance of Pakistan.

    • @muhammadishfaq6677
      @muhammadishfaq6677 4 года назад

      We are ok with China...right now it is your ass that china is beating...

  • @positrontelesystems5641
    @positrontelesystems5641 4 года назад

    Modi's mood is certainly not to give any concessions as for Mc mohan line to which China now disagrees and which Nehru conceded, certainly the expansionist China has set it's bad eyes on huge natural resources. China sees things in long terms may be as far as next 25 generations when it comes to conserving resources. We have been looted of our ores by UK and bad conservation policy has made our subsequent rulers to export these precious non renewable to outside world. China is eyeing perticularly the Uranium ores and Gold resources in ladakh region.Uranium to provide them with energy for next say atleast 1000 years and Gold to bring all the riches making it a true Super power. India should not concede even an inch of our land and even though no one at any given time really looks forward to war but we must defend every inch of our land and in process thus even if it leads to war, however long drawn conflict it is. China has bullied us several times and particularly more during Nehrus regime and Manmohansingh's regime.(puppet regime).

    • @tramanarayanarao2656
      @tramanarayanarao2656 4 года назад

      No Wonder Modi Called LAC as Border thus Surrendering Aksai Chin to China. 🤫

  • @DeshDuniya89
    @DeshDuniya89 4 года назад

    Hi Fye

  • @PRAKASH10001000
    @PRAKASH10001000 4 года назад

    Rao is a mediocre. Her only ability is being stooge of Gandhi Family.

  • @sridharmurthy1076
    @sridharmurthy1076 4 года назад

    Faye seems to be a favourite with Christians and muslims commenting here. Suffice to say that she is a favourite with anti nationals. Nirupama is a malayali, a natural , born communist and a certified Modi baiter.

  • @trends2morrow107
    @trends2morrow107 4 года назад +1

    Does she look 70 ? Vow

  • @manabendra62
    @manabendra62 4 года назад

    Does she knows Chinese language?

  • @mohdjunaid1064
    @mohdjunaid1064 4 года назад

    BJP spokesperson Faye 😂

  • @rakeshrathore1711
    @rakeshrathore1711 4 года назад +1

    There are lot of people with nehruvian out look and chhipkalies , poor cousins of dragon for them China is fatherland.

  • @oa6731
    @oa6731 4 года назад

    Are you also an upsc aspirant?? ❤

  • @anujchauhan1202
    @anujchauhan1202 4 года назад +2

    Biased views towards congress of this lady.

  • @Nagpadawala
    @Nagpadawala 4 года назад

    NIRUPAMA RAO === do you read and write Mandrin ???????

  • @atuldua875
    @atuldua875 4 года назад

    Failed anchor to failed diplomats