i feel like ive only seen a few other fandoms have a big music side - homestuck, undertale, touhou and fnaf to name a few. (and as of most recently i’d say dream smp is probably going to join that list because theyve been going hard with the fan songs over there) the music has always been one of my favorite aspects of the mlp fandom great video as always :D
Now this, I haven't started it yet, but this is a video I personally can REALLY get behind. I remember listening to the music the fandom created for so long over my time being in it. I don't consider myself a brony anymore nowadays but DAMN do I still love the music it produced. I'm still keeping up with some of my favorite artists from the time including The Living Tombstone, Silva Hound, Aviators, and 4EverfreeBrony. They're still making banging music to this day, I highly recommend to anyone who reads this to check out their newer stuff cuz I feel like they're only improving as time goes on.
The song “bones and skin“ was part of a series I believe called mentally advanced. They do have context within that series. The context for that song is that twilight got possessed by a demon, and applejack and rarity are trying to go get her so they could do a ritual that would get the demon out of her, while avoiding the monsters that now live inside her home. The series mentally advanced was also based off of several fanfictions. Although, most of them are only loosely based. I think the only exception was the “star in yellow”, where it was actually rather close to the actual fic.
I sure hope you've heard Flutterwonder and all homages it spawned, anything from SoGreatAndPowerful, the theme songs from AcousticBrony, anything from Foozogs, Twilight's Sonata, and all homages it spawned and the Fighting is Magic themes, they're all great!!
I'm so happy that The Mirror by Synthis made it onto the list! Plus I'm able to discover brony songs I never knew existed until now. Cheers mate and I can't wait for part 2.
Someone might have said this, but the stuff like bones and skin, tubby wubby pony waifu are from animations called rainbow dash presents and they’re so good!! If u watch them the songs make sense.
Now I'm expecting something really good in part 2! Would love to see more current brony producers, however, our tastes might be different so it's interesting what you'll pick.
Right? I can get behind criticising Pink Pony for the lack of structure (despite original song being INTENTIONALLY unstructured), but placing it behind Random Encounters song?! I think Shunks just isn't a fan of Eminem.
For “rainbow fun factory“, my best guess for the reason why they gave her that accent was because she was trying to act friendly for the kids. So that they would not freak out the fact that they’re going to be all turned into rainbows.
Honestly as someone who adores 20% Cooler I can totally see where you’re coming from. I get the angle that Ken was going for but the pony lines felt really shoehorned in and with very minimal editing to the song and the album art and a new music video it would be entirely separated and that kinda makes me sad. It’s also uncomfortably horny at times which I don’t like. But off the top of my head I can literally only think of 3 lines that actually have anything to do with MLP. So like from that angle it’s bad but I just like it in a kind of way that’s hard to place. It’s just nice to me lol but I fully see how a lot of people wouldn’t really like it
My personal top 10 in no particular order 1. the derpy's journey trilogy by derpidety/kind tide/kind sounds. It's inspired by the bubbles fanfic but there's no lyrics so it's hardly pony related but it's absolutely beautiful. I keep going back to it for inspiration and it's made me cry more than i'd like to admit 2. friendship is magic orchestration by marcus warner/evening star. the guy does some really high quality stuff worth checking out 3. fighting is magic title theme. i think of it as the proper theme of the show tbh 4. good girl. I wish there was a non pony version because holy crap it's amazing 5. lullaby for a princess. obviously. 6. house of glass by 4everfreebrony. beautiful lyrics it makes me cry 10/10 7. Wonderbolt. Freaking powerhouse vocals i wish they would do a new version so badlyyy 8. foozogz- make it special, sparkle, together, faded. the vocal chops are done so well! 9. Hay mrs derpy. so pretty and would fit perfectly into the official fallout soundtrack 10. Midnight frenzy - duo cartoonist. super upset that duo cartoonist deleted all their stuff and stopped all the pony related projects. they're such amazing animators and this song would have fit so well into luna's origin story
Probably the only problem I have with this is just the whole thing where you don't understand the Dawn Somewhere songs. They're all part of a series called "Rainbow Dash Presents", which makes the songs make sense when you watch them in context. Like with the monkey Joker thing, iirc Dash was having a dream and woke up in this monkey world where her adoptive monkey dad is monkey batman and monkey joker kind of falls in love with Dash, then they go on a date for some reason. Generally the series is really jokey and doesn't take itself seriously at all, all the stories are either the grimdark stories all twisted in a comedic and fun way, or just some random story made up by the creators
Some of the most iconic songs of the fandom, both new and old in the bottom 50... okay i have to see what you put in the top 50, my curiosity is peaked. Solidarity and other final songs were like the final calling card of the show's era of the fandom and everything else after the Solidarity songs kinda has this new space for the new songs to expand with new imagination and ideas to try. So with Solidarity in the bottom 50, i really wonder what you'll put in the top 50. 91- Hold on, ShadyVox (voice actor of Button) definitely has the range. If you haven't already, you should look into his other works like Sheriff Hayseed on his RUclips channel. ShadyVox has the range. It's just that's his Button voice doesn't have the same reach. Otherwise, this was a good video. I don't agree with a lot of it but that's just opinions.
Having fnf magic in the backround of the video. Lol funny but cool, I like the songs. And music is one of the many things I like. As long as it isn't weird
I only so far mainly disagree with Pegasus Device; I think that it gives both speakers personality unlike most other Rainbow Factory song and I think it sounds really cool.
The MLP Songs I Heard back when I was a Brony Where These Ones, The Rainbow Factory, Pegasus Device, Discord September, Nightmare Night, 20% Cooler, Love Me Cheerile, {Im Suprised I Remember Those Songs, It was a While Back when I Heard Those Songs, Like Years Ago!}
I agree with Daddy Discord. Look, I love that song to pieces, but it's hard to understand some of the words in the original and it's a shame. I could never hate it though, but that might just be nostalgia
in defense of 20% cooler, I always thought of it as just an electro party song with brony references. also, as surprising as it may sound, some bronies are normal people that have lives outside the internet and go out to parties and shit. may be nostalgia talking but i think its fine for what it is, sounds good and the brony references aren't too out there, so if you aren't part of the fandom you wouldn't even have any idea it's about mlp.
This wasn’t mentioned but The Siren’s Call is technically a parody. I don’t think most people are aware of that unless you’re already familiar with the original song.
I wanted to start by saying that you're one of the best pony-tubers by far, your videos are neatly structured, and you manage to talk about ponies calmly and rationally, yet in an entertaining way. But through ALL of your videos, among every opinion i may or may not agree with, your diss of the Pink Pony song left a burning mark on my consciousness, NO, i don't have anything better to think about! I can kinda get the critique of it being unstructured, but didn't the original Eminem song already have him making fun of a whole bunch of different subjects and people, why should the pony version make it more focused on any one particular thing? And even with it being unstructured, it still has some clever jokes and a singer staying on key, which is already more than i could say about a *number* of songs mentioned in this video. Seriously, you put it lower than a fucking random encounter song. So are you just not into Eminem, or what's the deal?
Random Encounters does live action musicals and sometimes does animated musicals cuphead the musical was animated by them it wasn't good, so they decided to get the whole community together reanimate the musical.
K so the dawn somewhere songs are more funny with context. A lot of the ones you presented are from a series called rainbow dash presents which is just like- parodies of fan fictions. It works off of their flaws and poor writing choices to make really funny shit. It’s better with context.
It's important to mention that Tubby Wubby Pony Waifu's instrumental isn't original, kinda like Discord's Puppet. It was a melody also sampled by Lil Uzi Vert's producers. It's great and here: www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/116075
i feel like ive only seen a few other fandoms have a big music side - homestuck, undertale, touhou and fnaf to name a few. (and as of most recently i’d say dream smp is probably going to join that list because theyve been going hard with the fan songs over there)
the music has always been one of my favorite aspects of the mlp fandom
great video as always :D
and friday night funkin kinda
@@dominogaming4745 maybe music but idk about songs (as in with voices which aren’t beep boop)
Now this, I haven't started it yet, but this is a video I personally can REALLY get behind. I remember listening to the music the fandom created for so long over my time being in it. I don't consider myself a brony anymore nowadays but DAMN do I still love the music it produced. I'm still keeping up with some of my favorite artists from the time including The Living Tombstone, Silva Hound, Aviators, and 4EverfreeBrony. They're still making banging music to this day, I highly recommend to anyone who reads this to check out their newer stuff cuz I feel like they're only improving as time goes on.
I really,really liked the FnF music in the background ;3
Really? It felt really distracting to me. Takes focus away from what’s being said
I can't even hear it.
Same
@@oatatas yeah
Never thought I'd be watching a video about brony music with fnf music playing in the background but here I am.... And you know what I'm here for it
Yea
If you've made it this far down into the comment section, this is a reminder that Shunks uses she/her pronouns. :)
Of course she does.
this is the first comment I saw XD
@@SugarVivStudios same!
hey just so y'all know he recently detransitioned. he uses he/him pronouns now!
The song “bones and skin“ was part of a series I believe called mentally advanced. They do have context within that series. The context for that song is that twilight got possessed by a demon, and applejack and rarity are trying to go get her so they could do a ritual that would get the demon out of her, while avoiding the monsters that now live inside her home.
The series mentally advanced was also based off of several fanfictions. Although, most of them are only loosely based. I think the only exception was the “star in yellow”, where it was actually rather close to the actual fic.
I sure hope you've heard Flutterwonder and all homages it spawned, anything from SoGreatAndPowerful, the theme songs from AcousticBrony, anything from Foozogs, Twilight's Sonata, and all homages it spawned and the Fighting is Magic themes, they're all great!!
Shunks secretly loves all of the Brony songs
ALSO CATS MILLIONAIRE!! WOO i love her work
Cats Millionare is just amaaaazzziiiing!!!
I'm so happy that The Mirror by Synthis made it onto the list!
Plus I'm able to discover brony songs I never knew existed until now.
Cheers mate and I can't wait for part 2.
hell yes thank you for including Cats Millionaire! devi is fantastic :)
Gotta say haven't heard of 60% presented, thanks you for some suggestions! P.S. loving the list!
SlyphStorm version of Octavia's overturn is a lot better if you ask me. I enjoyed the video! and finely subscribed, can't wait for the next part
honestly i've been looking for some new brony music to listen to, i honestly can't wait to see what your #1 is tbh
Also, it is very cool to see someone knowledgeable of brony songs from over the years. I've been here since 2012, so it feels nice. UWU Lol
Someone might have said this, but the stuff like bones and skin, tubby wubby pony waifu are from animations called rainbow dash presents and they’re so good!! If u watch them the songs make sense.
Yea was boutta comment that myself. There is a story to them and you do need the context and with the context the songs are much better
Now I'm expecting something really good in part 2! Would love to see more current brony producers, however, our tastes might be different so it's interesting what you'll pick.
"let's start with the worst one" not one of my favorites 😭
Right? I can get behind criticising Pink Pony for the lack of structure (despite original song being INTENTIONALLY unstructured), but placing it behind Random Encounters song?! I think Shunks just isn't a fan of Eminem.
Number 69, (nice) It doesn't get much better than that.
Hey so I just binged every video on your channel, loved every second of it! (also, love ur yaksona)
the name's rony, [take glasses off] b. rony (cheering_sound.wav)
The names rony... pepper rony
I’m hungry now
Bc of mlp I started to hear hardstyle, and I don’t regret it
I essentially got back to dubstep lol
For “rainbow fun factory“, my best guess for the reason why they gave her that accent was because she was trying to act friendly for the kids. So that they would not freak out the fact that they’re going to be all turned into rainbows.
Aww yeah awesome video...
Honestly as someone who adores 20% Cooler I can totally see where you’re coming from. I get the angle that Ken was going for but the pony lines felt really shoehorned in and with very minimal editing to the song and the album art and a new music video it would be entirely separated and that kinda makes me sad. It’s also uncomfortably horny at times which I don’t like. But off the top of my head I can literally only think of 3 lines that actually have anything to do with MLP. So like from that angle it’s bad but I just like it in a kind of way that’s hard to place. It’s just nice to me lol but I fully see how a lot of people wouldn’t really like it
My personal top 10 in no particular order
1. the derpy's journey trilogy by derpidety/kind tide/kind sounds. It's inspired by the bubbles fanfic but there's no lyrics so it's hardly pony related but it's absolutely beautiful. I keep going back to it for inspiration and it's made me cry more than i'd like to admit
2. friendship is magic orchestration by marcus warner/evening star. the guy does some really high quality stuff worth checking out
3. fighting is magic title theme. i think of it as the proper theme of the show tbh
4. good girl. I wish there was a non pony version because holy crap it's amazing
5. lullaby for a princess. obviously.
6. house of glass by 4everfreebrony. beautiful lyrics it makes me cry 10/10
7. Wonderbolt. Freaking powerhouse vocals i wish they would do a new version so badlyyy
8. foozogz- make it special, sparkle, together, faded. the vocal chops are done so well!
9. Hay mrs derpy. so pretty and would fit perfectly into the official fallout soundtrack
10. Midnight frenzy - duo cartoonist. super upset that duo cartoonist deleted all their stuff and stopped all the pony related projects. they're such amazing animators and this song would have fit so well into luna's origin story
Bbbb
Probably the only problem I have with this is just the whole thing where you don't understand the Dawn Somewhere songs. They're all part of a series called "Rainbow Dash Presents", which makes the songs make sense when you watch them in context. Like with the monkey Joker thing, iirc Dash was having a dream and woke up in this monkey world where her adoptive monkey dad is monkey batman and monkey joker kind of falls in love with Dash, then they go on a date for some reason. Generally the series is really jokey and doesn't take itself seriously at all, all the stories are either the grimdark stories all twisted in a comedic and fun way, or just some random story made up by the creators
I knew that people have made mlp songs but i didn't know that there would be so many of them holy shit
Some of the most iconic songs of the fandom, both new and old in the bottom 50... okay i have to see what you put in the top 50, my curiosity is peaked.
Solidarity and other final songs were like the final calling card of the show's era of the fandom and everything else after the Solidarity songs kinda has this new space for the new songs to expand with new imagination and ideas to try. So with Solidarity in the bottom 50, i really wonder what you'll put in the top 50.
91- Hold on, ShadyVox (voice actor of Button) definitely has the range. If you haven't already, you should look into his other works like Sheriff Hayseed on his RUclips channel. ShadyVox has the range. It's just that's his Button voice doesn't have the same reach.
Otherwise, this was a good video. I don't agree with a lot of it but that's just opinions.
Having fnf magic in the backround of the video. Lol funny but cool, I like the songs.
And music is one of the many things I like. As long as it isn't weird
I like this list a lot but maaan you can see the reviewer is new to the fandom xD.
That lets him give a fresh look into them though.
*her
@@kalekoi Whoops, sorry! And thanks for the info.
CATS MILLIONAIREEE i wish you listened to her mini album about nightmare moon/luna... she made a few mlp albuma n i love em all :)
Ohhh now songs I’ve never heard of, time to update my list
I hope Who Am I? by Blackened Blue is on Part 2
if sogreatandpowerful IZNT in the next part im gonna SCREAM!!!!!/j/lh
I hope exclusive royal canterlot wedding playset is on the list in the next video
I actually cried when I first watched daddy discord
GOODNESS you're not wrong about the Tally Hall thing!
I only so far mainly disagree with Pegasus Device; I think that it gives both speakers personality unlike most other Rainbow Factory song and I think it sounds really cool.
I didn’t know this many MLP songs existed 😭
All these songs got nostogia for
Oh shoot you like tally hall? Nice!
The MLP Songs I Heard
back when I was a Brony
Where These Ones,
The Rainbow Factory,
Pegasus Device, Discord
September, Nightmare Night,
20% Cooler, Love Me Cheerile,
{Im Suprised I Remember
Those Songs, It was a While
Back when I Heard Those
Songs, Like Years Ago!}
I agree with Daddy Discord. Look, I love that song to pieces, but it's hard to understand some of the words in the original and it's a shame. I could never hate it though, but that might just be nostalgia
I love Love Me, Cheerilee and Flutterwonder buuut to each their own
10:50
Tally Hall is great,
Ruler of Everything,
Is the Best Tally Hall
Song, In My Opinion!
I love the song pegasus device
LETS GO AND MEET THE BRONIES MADE TEN YEAR OLD ME SO HAPPY MAN
in defense of 20% cooler, I always thought of it as just an electro party song with brony references. also, as surprising as it may sound, some bronies are normal people that have lives outside the internet and go out to parties and shit. may be nostalgia talking but i think its fine for what it is, sounds good and the brony references aren't too out there, so if you aren't part of the fandom you wouldn't even have any idea it's about mlp.
Fav yter
This wasn’t mentioned but The Siren’s Call is technically a parody. I don’t think most people are aware of that unless you’re already familiar with the original song.
Cats millionaires music is my favorite tbh
The FNF music was kind of an unexpected whiplash LOL
I'd recommend you put a fw in the title or desc Danny Gonzalez style, just to be safe yk
I wanted to start by saying that you're one of the best pony-tubers by far, your videos are neatly structured, and you manage to talk about ponies calmly and rationally, yet in an entertaining way.
But through ALL of your videos, among every opinion i may or may not agree with, your diss of the Pink Pony song left a burning mark on my consciousness, NO, i don't have anything better to think about!
I can kinda get the critique of it being unstructured, but didn't the original Eminem song already have him making fun of a whole bunch of different subjects and people, why should the pony version make it more focused on any one particular thing?
And even with it being unstructured, it still has some clever jokes and a singer staying on key, which is already more than i could say about a *number* of songs mentioned in this video. Seriously, you put it lower than a fucking random encounter song.
So are you just not into Eminem, or what's the deal?
love how he trashing on random encounters lmsaoaf
i really hope Sonic Rhymeboom will be on here bc i didnt learn every word 6 years ago for it to not be
My proper introduction to mlp is music by aviators chaos theory
Sooooooooooo im balkan and im you know slav soooooo its time for ceki breki
I'm going bonkers from some of these ratings
YAY
The homestuck cosplayers in the back
I realized my horse is in this video because the Solidarity art was used
Me: vibing to Pico at the start
Random Encounters does live action musicals and sometimes does animated musicals cuphead the musical was animated by them it wasn't good, so they decided to get the whole community together reanimate the musical.
5:11
oh my GOD THAT IS MY FAVORITE SONG HOW DARE YOU PUT IT SO LOW
K so the dawn somewhere songs are more funny with context. A lot of the ones you presented are from a series called rainbow dash presents which is just like- parodies of fan fictions. It works off of their flaws and poor writing choices to make really funny shit. It’s better with context.
❤❤❤
Why is the video flipped
ah yes
can already see the sgap comments coming in
4:27 disgusted feferi
YES
If I knew i woulf have made some suggestions too...
Dude re-upload the first one was fine
i didnt see the original upload, do you know why she reuploaded it? im curious o_O
@@conarcoin I don't know sorry
@@cynthiag5191 ohh okay
YES! ZELDA LULAMOON! :DD
cats milly ❤️
*Daftpina has joined the chat*
*DAFTPINA HAS JOINED THE CHAT*
i havent really heard a lot of these, but i think magic b**ch should be higher. but thats really just a personal opinion
Pony night funkin
gamer.
ruclips.net/video/PH1U87rNR7Q/видео.html&ab_channel=DawnSomewhere this animation/series is where tubby wubby pony waifu came from!
L take on 20% Cooler
that was just a joke hehhe
heheh
It's important to mention that Tubby Wubby Pony Waifu's instrumental isn't original, kinda like Discord's Puppet. It was a melody also sampled by Lil Uzi Vert's producers. It's great and here: www.looperman.com/tracks/detail/116075