No word cant describe how beautiful it is. I actually randomly clicked it. And JESUS..... That whistle...The kid..OMG...I am sure BACH will be so glad to hear it. Need more like this man.
Can we just take a moment to give some MAJOR kudos and respect to the little guy here.... A wonderfully articulated performance. The whistling and strings were excellent too.
How could he think about adding a whistling on Bach's piece? He is a genius. Bravo for job well done. You just got yourself a new subscriber. Thank you for the beautiful music
Indeed. Most people tend to see whistling as a background sound, not as a solo instrument. I had to clarify this concept to the sound technician that in my view it should be in the front.
To be frank it ws like a feel of listening some marvellous piece sitting infront of wooden house insyd deep jungle watching firecamp. .......let me tell u elaborately....i went back several months back where i lived a solo life away from my home,,people tell loneliness is a curse but i defend myself tellin loneliness is a gift by almighty which i enjoyed....and finally i vl tell dat one particular person vl stay forever and ever in my heart....
Very interesting, thank you for sharing this here. Somehow what you wrote reminded me a beautiful quote by the Kozker Rebbe who said- "Nothing is more complete than a broken heart"
Greetings from the UK, thinking of you all in your country. What a beautiful talent you both have, certainly God-given. Thank you for sharing this beautiful music with us.
Well, I don't have any knowledge about music, but as a common people, after listening to this... I've found tears in my eyes. Violin is so perfectly synced with piano!
Mr. Kaminetsky, this piece is beautiful, thank you for sharing this beautiful music with us. Your son is an amazing kid, and his smile at the end makes me smile. Thank you for all the effort and time you invested in making this video.
You are in my Bach Playing list and I listen to your performance at least three times a week. Sometimes I like most the violin, next time the piano, then the whistling. I just love it
Absolutely lovely, beautiful, I get goose bumps! And the whistling is incredible!!Apart the time and effort, you put lots of Love into this great video! And one can feel it and the soul rejoices. Thank you!!!
Meus parabéns ao jovem pianista e tb a criatividade do violinista, que começou com uma conexão da natureza, assobiando como um passarinho feliz!! Maravilhoso !! Nefertari -Rá
Superb!!! What a performance of such a soothing piece, the whistling and violin make a unique version. The kid deserves a special standing ovation he not only is a good performer but he feels the music, I can tell that for his smile of satisfaction. Grat job.
Bellísima versión!!!! felicitaciones a los músicos, es muy tierna melodía , pero la interpretación a dúo (incluido el silbido), es fantástica!!!!!, espero que sigan tocando asi por mucho tiempo, desde Argentina los escucho y han llegado a mi alma. !!!!!!
Thank you so much for your willingness to help! Please do so if you can. I recently started to upload a new musical video, hoping it will reach a bigger audience sometime soon...
Thanks my friend, happy you liked it. unfortunately, i am not familiar enough with the youtube algorythm. i am open for ideas / suggestions, if you may have any...
Gracias!!, Gracias!!, una de las mejores músicas clásicas y una de las mejores improvisaciones, y uno de los mejores dúos interpretando esta música que es una caricia al Alma. Muchas gracias por compartir esta maravilla!!
Wonderful piece played by you both.. love to see his fingering& smile.. no words to describe.. thank you for the unique performance.. 1st class.. love from Malaysia..💖
We invested much time and effort in this video, we hope you'll enjoy it! Thanks for listening
מקסים ! שילוב נפלא ומרגש כל כך. עלו והצליחו !
@@shimonlavi4102 כיף לשמוע ממך שמעון, שמח מאוד שנהנתם
But let me tell you something, this is not originally Bach, the original is much better than this, isnt it?
Thank you so much for this beutyful perfect 👌 pieces 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👍❤️❤️❤️
Thank you so much for this it's beautiful ,you guys make this world more beautiful!! 🔥❤️
No word cant describe how beautiful it is. I actually randomly clicked it. And JESUS..... That whistle...The kid..OMG...I am sure BACH will be so glad to hear it. Need more like this man.
Thanks so much for your beautiful feedback, very happy you like it. thanks for the encouragement, hopefully we'll make more videos...
This is the most beautiful pieces I've heard in my lifetime. The whistling makes it perfect.
Wow, thank you so much for your beautiful feedback. We recently recorded some new pieces and we are planning to post them very soon...
I'm muslim and i love your work. Music has that power to go through the frontiers of religion and origins. Continu you are amazing
Thank you my friend, very much appreciated.
Maybe the best video i've seen on youtube. Thank You!
Wow, thanks so much for sharing
This is the best arrangement of this beautiful piece I ever heard
So great to hear, thanks for sharing
Such a great son to have and he is lucky to have such kind spirited father
Thank you, very much appreciated.
Thoroughly enjoyed it. Thanks.
Thank you
Je ne parle pas anglais mais j’ai trouvé cette prestation INCROYABLE !!!!! J’en ai eu les larmes aux yeux 😭😭😭😍😍♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
thank you so much!!!
I really love it. Made me cry.
What a marvellous performance by father and son duo!!
Thank you so much for sharing, happy you liked it
Une très belle inspiration dans l'arrengement
Thank you so much!
its a full package of G minor by bach....like movie music...
Thank you very much
Can we just take a moment to give some MAJOR kudos and respect to the little guy here.... A wonderfully articulated performance. The whistling and strings were excellent too.
thank you so much for your beautiful feedback.
CLAPS CLAPS IM REALLY PROUDDDDD OMG THANK YOU FOR THIS AMAZING BEAUTIFULLY SONG OMGGGGG🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thank you so much for your beautiful comment, very much appreciated
That whistling was beatifull, that counterpoint was awesome, Luo Ni would be proud.
Thank you for your feedback, happy you liked it.
The best arrangement for this piece, by far. and the violin/guitar thing. Holy crap.
Great job.
The passion in his fingers.
Thank you
Thank you so much for your beautiful feedback' happy you liked it
Великолепно!
Thank you!
AMEI❤ Entrou na minha alma esta música de BACH com este arranjo! Ficou uma obra-prima!!😍👏👏👏👏🎶🎶🎵
Thank you so much for sharing
Beautiful sir. U brought the heavens on to your platform.
Thank you so much!
Amazing , I can listen to it all day
Thank you so much, happy to hear..
How could he think about adding a whistling on Bach's piece?
He is a genius. Bravo for job well done.
You just got yourself a new subscriber.
Thank you for the beautiful music
thank you for your beautiful feedback, very much appreciated.
I only describe it with one word WONDERFUL
Thank you so much!
Truly stunning . We want more!
Thank you Jeremy, working on it...
One of the most hauntingly beautifully played renditions of G minor Bach/Luo Ni I've ever heard. 👏
thank you so much, so great to hear.
מופלא.
גן עדן עלי האדמות.
תודה על כל רגע של מוזיקה.
4 דקות של נחת ושלווה לנפש.
ממש כיף לשמוע, תודה רבה על התגובה מחממת הלב
If he plays this great at such a young age, imagine how he'd sound when he's in his 20's. Amazing, bravo to both of you.
Thank you. Keeping it on is not an easy thing to do, although I do hope he continues...
Congratulations. Beautiful the boy focusing in playing and the dedication. Example.
Thanks so much for your feedback
i have never thought that whistling could be as beautiful as this.
Indeed. Most people tend to see whistling as a background sound, not as a solo instrument. I had to clarify this concept to the sound technician that in my view it should be in the front.
This is so beautiful
Thank you so much!
This is genius!! Hi from Kazakhstan! 🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿
thank you so much! happy to hear from you
Omg so beautiful tahnksssss❤❤❤
Thank you so much!
To be frank it ws like a feel of listening some marvellous piece sitting infront of wooden house insyd deep jungle watching firecamp. .......let me tell u elaborately....i went back several months back where i lived a solo life away from my home,,people tell loneliness is a curse but i defend myself tellin loneliness is a gift by almighty which i enjoyed....and finally i vl tell dat one particular person vl stay forever and ever in my heart....
Very interesting, thank you for sharing this here. Somehow what you wrote reminded me a beautiful quote by the Kozker Rebbe who said- "Nothing is more complete than a broken heart"
Greetings from the UK, thinking of you all in your country. What a beautiful talent you both have, certainly God-given. Thank you for sharing this beautiful music with us.
Thank you so much for your wishes, thought and beautiful feedback
Υπέροχο. Μεγαλειώδες. Ευχαριστούμε. In some instances, it reminded to me Adon Olam. Maybe my impression.
Thank you so much!
Not sure which tune of Adon Olam you are refering to (there are a lot of tunes) but it may be..
This is by far the best g minor performance i've ever seen. The whistle and violin give more souls to the song
Thank you so much for the beautiful feedback, happy you liked it.
Esto es majestuoso la mejor versión que he escuchado de Bach Gm.
Bendiciones. Shalom
Muchas gracias, muy contento de escuchar
This is the most beautiful sound my ears have ever heard.
what a beautiful feedback! thank you so much
Спасибо за такой прекрасный дуэт. Я очарована.
Thank you for your beautiful feedback
Well, I don't have any knowledge about music, but as a common people, after listening to this...
I've found tears in my eyes.
Violin is so perfectly synced with piano!
thanks so much for sharing. sometimes no knowledge is actually better. very happy you liked it.
Es muy lindo Gracias
Thank you
Thank you
Genius. No words to describe it other than immensely creative. Wow the kid had it perfect i can barely play a few notes than giving up. Shalom.
Pianoforte e violino coppia insuperabile,strepitosi.
Grazie mille, molto felice di sentirti
Bellísimo!,!!
Thank you!
I can not discribe how much the music is wonderful
Thank you so much for sharing, very happy to hear
A very beautiful performance and Play.
Congratulation for your excellence pianist and violinist musical art.
Thank you so much, happy to hear
You..my little friend...allways remember...no one is allowed to forse you to anything...play from your heart..🖐👍
You played beautiful!
Thank you for your important message! The message was conveyed to Yehonatan, thank you.
Demn man.. I love this piece so much. That whistle brought so much much much more feeling in it.
Thank you so much!
When music is music. Thanks for sharing this beauty. It touched my soul. ♥
Thank you so much!
Mr. Kaminetsky, this piece is beautiful, thank you for sharing this beautiful music with us. Your son is an amazing kid, and his smile at the end makes me smile. Thank you for all the effort and time you invested in making this video.
Thank you very much for your comment, very happy to hear you liked it. Our next piece will be ready soon...
I keep coming back because of how beautiful this is
so great to hear, thanks for sharing
Phenomenal! I could listen to this all day! Thank you!
Thank you so much for your feedback, very happy to hear
You are in my Bach Playing list and I listen to your performance at least three times a week. Sometimes I like most the violin, next time the piano, then the whistling. I just love it
Thanks, so great to hear. Thank you for sharing
Hermoso!!!!
Thank you!
Love this video very much and keep repeating listen to this piece during driving in car. Well Done.
Love From SINGAPORE 🇸🇬
So great to hear, thanks for sharing
I enjoyed it a lot. Thanks for this beautiful song. Happy, calm, pieceful, sad, yet full of hope. 🎉
Absolutely lovely, beautiful, I get goose bumps! And the whistling is incredible!!Apart the time and effort, you put lots of Love into this great video! And one can feel it and the soul rejoices.
Thank you!!!
thank you so much for your beautiful feedback
Fabulous ❤️
Thank you!
Wow, I'm not the only one whistling to Bach.
Happy to hear you do that as well..
If this talented boy continues..he will be a great performer!!! Beautiful!!🥰 Great tempo and well played!! Thank you my friend!👌👍
Thank you very much. I hope he continues...
Это было прекрасно... 🔥❤
Thank you
Meus parabéns ao jovem pianista e tb a criatividade do violinista, que começou com uma conexão da natureza, assobiando como um passarinho feliz!! Maravilhoso !! Nefertari -Rá
Thank you so much!
this video takes my soul away i loved too much
Thank you so much, very happy to hear
כל הכבוד. נגינה נפלאה של שניכם!
תודה רבה אילן
Beautiful. Time well invested. Love that smile at the end.
Thanks Hugo, very much appreciated
Very, Very beautiful
Thank you so much!
很棒，很喜歡這個演奏速度
再搭配小提琴，真的完美。
Thank you so much.for your feedbavk
Superb!!! What a performance of such a soothing piece, the whistling and violin make a unique version. The kid deserves a special standing ovation he not only is a good performer but he feels the music, I can tell that for his smile of satisfaction. Grat job.
Thank you so much for sharing this, we really appreciate your warm feedback
serene and spectacular
Thanks so much!
The piano and violin part are very excellent but the whistling part is unbelievably beautiful. Thank you for creating this rendition.
thank you so much for the beautiful feedback, glad you enjoyed it!
Tellement bon et beau a ecouter!
So touching ... so beautiful... Respect from Sweden.
Happy to hear, thank you for your comment
@@liorviolin I do wish if you could do passacaglia one day . I have shared your video to all my list. All the best !
Bellísima versión!!!! felicitaciones a los músicos, es muy tierna melodía , pero la interpretación a dúo (incluido el silbido), es fantástica!!!!!, espero que sigan tocando asi por mucho tiempo, desde Argentina los escucho y han llegado a mi alma. !!!!!!
Thank you so much for your warm feedback
Thank you so much for your warm feedback.
no matter what country, no matter what denomination... TALENTS are all over the world...
Absolutely, thanks
Amazing! How are you able to whistle like this? Never knew the sound of whistling could be this stunning and charming, congrats to both of you!
Thank you so much! Good question - I have always been whistling...
Cool name!
You should make tutorial for the whistling
Wonderful and Amazing harmony. Very very beautiful . . .
Thank you, very much appreciated
Breathtaking !
Great to hear, thanks for your comment
Very beautiful sounds very amazing and beautiful i love it ❤️
I've listened so many version of "G minor", but this one is the best
Thank you for your feedback, very happy to hear. We already recorded new pieces and are planning to post them very soon...
Wonderful performance of this beautiful partition Bach in G minor arranged by Luo Ni
Thank you, very much appreciated.
This gave me chills. Incredible talent.
thanks for your beautiful feedback
Una obra de arte bien logrado Hasta Bach se conmoveria al escucharla
Great to hear, Thank you so much!
A heavily underrated video. I must spread this across the lands of the internet.
Thank you so much for your willingness to help! Please do so if you can.
I recently started to upload a new musical video, hoping it will reach a bigger audience sometime soon...
@@liorviolin close to 100k! I’ll keep on sharing!
Arreglos sublimes!!!!! Bravo, me ha llegado al corazón ❣️
muchas gracias
Impressionante 👍 che bravi 👏 semplicemente fantastici 🔝
thank you so much!
The skills of a child
The multi skills of an adult
The experiment.
The over all outcome
Super loved it.
Kudos
Thank you so much for the beautiful feedback. Really happy you enjoyed it
wow, perfect presentation. definitely under-rated by youtube algorithm.
Thanks my friend, happy you liked it. unfortunately, i am not familiar enough with the youtube algorythm. i am open for ideas / suggestions, if you may have any...
best G minor found on Tube!
So great to hear, thank you for your beautiful feedback
Just beautiful. I can't get enough of it. More, please.
Thank you Daniel, really happy you like it
Gracias!!, Gracias!!, una de las mejores músicas clásicas y una de las mejores improvisaciones, y uno de los mejores dúos interpretando esta música que es una caricia al Alma. Muchas gracias por compartir esta maravilla!!
Es genial escucharlo, gracias por compartir tus hermosos comentarios
No words, simply wonderful!!! Thank you!!!
So great to hear, thank you
Wow! I have absolutely no way to stop and listen to such amazing music, the best partners ever!
Wow, so great to hear. Thank you very much for your beautiful feedback
素晴らしい！
お父さんの温かい愛情に包まれた男の子が演奏後に見せたあの少し誇らしそうな笑顔が最高！
その男の子のキップが鍵盤模様になっているのも印象的で、シゲル・カワイ製のピアノがさりげなく映っている。
勿論、BWV847の原曲に相応しい素晴らしい口笛とヴァイオリンは圧巻ですね！
Waw.. incredible.. i like the combination instrumental on the minor melody..
thank you so much!
Just what I was looking for. Wonderful arrangement
so great to hear, thanks for sharing
Wonderful piece played by you both.. love to see his fingering& smile.. no words to describe.. thank you for the unique performance.. 1st class.. love from Malaysia..💖
Thank you very much for your beautiful feedback, very much appreciated.
Que gran emociòn cuando comenzò a chiflar, nunca lo espere, pero es lo mejor que he escuchado.
Muchas gracias!
Bravo !
Thank you
This is just perfect.
Thanks so much!
Thank you. I'm sure that I share the wonderful feelings as other listeners, it's was glorious !
Glad you enjoyed it!