Gfriend's Buddy then again she's underrated as a singer. People only pay attention to her visuals. She needs some spotlight for her singing. Furthermore she used to be in a dance trio with yuri and hyoyeon
I listen to Blackpink, TWICE, Itzy and other gen 3 kpop girl groups but I keep coming back to my OG girl group because of this. They have the best ballad songs for a girl group. Still the best. Proud sone for 11 years.
I got stunned like a vegetable by Sunny and especially Yuri's High notes OMG OMG OMG THEY'RE REALLY GREAT Those 5 people are making a huge mistake by disliking this song of heavens!!!!
NO JAMS WITH LIPSTICK CHATEAU only SM would let Sunny and some of the other members who don't really do the high notes and runs in the songs a chance to actually do that cuz I feel like if they put more effort and time into working with those members they can get better but they just only focus on the members with the strongest vocals which is helpful but not all that fair
NO JAMS WITH LIPSTICK CHATEAU I know that's very true I wish SM would work with her a bit more just because I feel like if she got more lines than she would have more studio time which would better her vocal range and I feel like she's been in Girls Generation for so long that her vocal range should be a bit better but it's not because SM wasn't working with her enough
I wish that there were more live performances of this song 😭 One of the songs wherein the talent of vocal line is shown as well as the dancing line. This group is truly a vocal group 🥺
For this performance the notables are: Especially their Vocals HyoSoo Harmony YoonSun Harmony Yuri Highnotes Sunny Highnotes TaeTiSeoJes Highnotes As usual. Taeyeon Low Notes. Their Adlibs 💕
I’ll always comeback to this video forever. Why?? because, Yuri wrote this song. 5 members hit high notes. HyoSoo voices really blended well. This may be an underrated song of soshi, but this will remain LEGENDARY AND ICONIC.
mg.. where do i start. the memories. for the longest time, this was my favourite ballad. i held my breath when Taeyeon started singing, her voice is so warm and rich. yuri too. Her emotions really showed. that's to be expected, as she made the song. good job putting YoonSun and HyoSoo together. yoonsun has similar vocal tone and soo's smooth, warmer tone really fit with hyoyeon's slightly high-pitched yet scruffy-ish voice. Sica sounded like an angel. tiffany's husky voice was wow. Seohyun too. Her voice was so pure and soothing. and Sunny's ringing voice. ugh this was amazing. nostalgia.
Wow this song was written by Yuri right? And sooyoung can write song also they both talented, their voice is pretty much okay.. Wow amazing girls,, if shy debut it is going to be an amazing sub unit, main dancers, composer, beautiful voice, best body, beautiful faces, funny and great personality... Cant wait to see them slaying music chart..
I've listened to this about 10 or more times to ensure I was seeing and hearing right... Now I've made my decision and the only two who hit those high notes out of the park was Sunny and surprisingly Yuri.... Sooyoung and Hyoyeon sounded great together Seohyun first solo was amazing... But Sunny and Yuri made this song.
Hyoyeon and Sooyoung sound so stable it’s incredible how SM just straight out like to cut their lines and give them to others for no reason than them being less popular. Seohyun and Yuri did amazing! Sooyoung and Hyoyeon did beautifully! Taeyeon and Sunny just blew my mind! Yoona also did very well. I can’t say much for Fany or Sica but it’s been years now and I’m sure they improved. I actually went to a Tiffany fanmeet/concert and I fell in love with her even more than I already had. Still this performance is one of the better ones they had of this song.
0:40- Hyoyeon surprising you on a ballad! Listen to her and SooYoung harmonize! Two of SNSD's dance line artists absolutely kill it vocally. First time I ever recall a camera zooming square on Hyoyeon singing. Usually for years the cameras would focus anywhere BUT on Hyoyeon when she was singing.
The video just appeared on my home feed, and I was curious what "mistake" they did while singing ballad song like this. And then I just realized the title of the song is mistake lol
Hearing this again. Tiffany- out of the tune/beat compare to the original track Sica-she's hard reaching the highnote Taeyeon- she always ate the CD! Bravo Sunny&Yuri- wow! This 2 girls should have more lines
Jessica's high note here is more difficult than the rest tho. Taeyeon's high note is an open vowel which is why it's easier to belt out. Jessica has "i" with letter e sounds which is closed vowel. There's no way you can hit it without thinning your voice so Jessica did a good job.
Lol do you even realize how hard the line given to Jessica on the bridge? Your voice has to be thin to hit it while doing it on runs. What Yuri did was really great for a non vocalist member of a group, but for main vocalists, it is just something that they should have to begin with. The end line or the vowel is easy to open so it's easier to hit. On Sunny's Part, she didnt even really tried hard because thats how high her natural voice can go. So I dont what are your basis for degrading a main vocalist just to please your shit mentality and hate towards her
Both of them slayed but just equal to jessica we cant deny the fact jessica is a better singer than themThough i am yuri biased jessica is still better in vocal😊
![[EN] TWICE JIHYO was in SM Entertainment???](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qpdpsTxxHnY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH-Lyrics] Forever - SNSD (Kiss Radio Live Ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WDaY6b06Qms/mqdefault.jpg)
For some reason Hyo and Sooyoung sound sooo good together... and Yuri was OMG WTF! #SHY anybody?
Yes me too I pray for #SHY
Add yoona in! SHYY
+GSL1999 Yoone receive too many spotlights, Because she is their center image so I think Its time SHY to shine now
+LeeYoonJiGT Lol Yoona*
Gfriend's Buddy then again she's underrated as a singer. People only pay attention to her visuals. She needs some spotlight for her singing. Furthermore she used to be in a dance trio with yuri and hyoyeon
I listen to Blackpink, TWICE, Itzy and other gen 3 kpop girl groups but I keep coming back to my OG girl group because of this. They have the best ballad songs for a girl group. Still the best. Proud sone for 11 years.
I know that Yuri is a great singer,but I was surprised to hear her high notes!And Lee Sunkyu 😍
I got stunned like a vegetable by Sunny and especially Yuri's High notes OMG OMG OMG THEY'RE REALLY GREAT Those 5 people are making a huge mistake by disliking this song of heavens!!!!
NO JAMS WITH LIPSTICK CHATEAU only SM would let Sunny and some of the other members who don't really do the high notes and runs in the songs a chance to actually do that cuz I feel like if they put more effort and time into working with those members they can get better but they just only focus on the members with the strongest vocals which is helpful but not all that fair
chelsie agyemang Just take hyoyeon for example. She can sing well but doesnt get a lot of lines
NO JAMS WITH LIPSTICK CHATEAU I know that's very true I wish SM would work with her a bit more just because I feel like if she got more lines than she would have more studio time which would better her vocal range and I feel like she's been in Girls Generation for so long that her vocal range should be a bit better but it's not because SM wasn't working with her enough
chelsie agyemang ikr
It's been 7 years since this song first came out but it still my SNSD's fave ballad.
same here 🤗
Mine too
I wish that there were more live performances of this song 😭 One of the songs wherein the talent of vocal line is shown as well as the dancing line. This group is truly a vocal group 🥺
Step Huen Taeyeon, Jessica, Yuri, Sunny, Seohyun ROCKED THOSE HIGH NOTES
Yuri high note makes me so OMG
YURI'S HIGH NOTE SLAYY QUEEN
For this performance the notables are:
Especially their Vocals
HyoSoo Harmony
YoonSun Harmony
Yuri Highnotes
Sunny Highnotes
TaeTiSeoJes Highnotes As usual.
Taeyeon Low Notes.
Their Adlibs 💕
YURI HIGH NOTE.
Sam Sena Sunny's high note is also amazing.
Taeyeon is really good here omg. I like how smooth she sings here.
I’ll always comeback to this video forever. Why??
because, Yuri wrote this song.
5 members hit high notes.
HyoSoo voices really blended well.
This may be an underrated song of soshi, but this will remain LEGENDARY AND ICONIC.
Everyone did a good job but Taeyeon is flawless here. So smooth so clear so controlled 😍 I can’t get over this performance
Yuri really did a great job by writing this song
mg.. where do i start. the memories. for the longest time, this was my favourite ballad. i held my breath when Taeyeon started singing, her voice is so warm and rich. yuri too. Her emotions really showed. that's to be expected, as she made the song. good job putting YoonSun and HyoSoo together. yoonsun has similar vocal tone and soo's smooth, warmer tone really fit with hyoyeon's slightly high-pitched yet scruffy-ish voice. Sica sounded like an angel. tiffany's husky voice was wow. Seohyun too. Her voice was so pure and soothing. and Sunny's ringing voice. ugh this was amazing. nostalgia.
i like how everyone exaggerated their moves when they touch high tone and then theres taeyeon who sing calmly lol
Well.. her name literally means calm lol
Song written by kwon yuri, thankyou for making this beautifull song
taeyeon is freakin perfect
Wow this song was written by Yuri right? And sooyoung can write song also they both talented, their voice is pretty much okay.. Wow amazing girls,, if shy debut it is going to be an amazing sub unit, main dancers, composer, beautiful voice, best body, beautiful faces, funny and great personality... Cant wait to see them slaying music chart..
Jessica High's Note is so amazing my angelic voice
my Taeyeon never disappoints me after all these years.. still my favourite snsd since our first met.. love you Taengg!!😚
I really miss this (ot9).
Great song and great era too ):
I've listened to this about 10 or more times to ensure I was seeing and hearing right... Now I've made my decision and the only two who hit those high notes out of the park was Sunny and surprisingly Yuri.... Sooyoung and Hyoyeon sounded great together Seohyun first solo was amazing... But Sunny and Yuri made this song.
Yuri, Yoona and Seohyun so beautiful😍 Taeyeon is always amazing her voice👌
Triplets 😍
Yuri, Yoona and Seohyun so beautiful😍
Yuri high note ❤️
It's my favorite song and I try to learn to sing it sometime.
Awesome song written by Yuri...
Hyoyeon and Sooyoung sound so stable it’s incredible how SM just straight out like to cut their lines and give them to others for no reason than them being less popular. Seohyun and Yuri did amazing! Sooyoung and Hyoyeon did beautifully! Taeyeon and Sunny just blew my mind! Yoona also did very well. I can’t say much for Fany or Sica but it’s been years now and I’m sure they improved. I actually went to a Tiffany fanmeet/concert and I fell in love with her even more than I already had. Still this performance is one of the better ones they had of this song.
QUEEN TAEYEON HIT THOSE HIGH NOTE WHILE SITTING SO EFFORTLESSLY QUEEN INDEED
This song is really means to me. My ex really like snsd. And when i broke up with my ex, i sended this song to make a memory. Really sad..
+Panji Soendoro be strong dude... I kinda understand the feel...
The visuals and vocals are so perfect ❤😍👏🏻
Love this song.. Yuri is amazing 💖💖
0:40- Hyoyeon surprising you on a ballad! Listen to her and SooYoung harmonize! Two of SNSD's dance line artists absolutely kill it vocally. First time I ever recall a camera zooming square on Hyoyeon singing. Usually for years the cameras would focus anywhere BUT on Hyoyeon when she was singing.
Taeyeon sings so perfectly in this live 😍😍
back when idols can really sing
This was when Taeyeon started to steal my heart...
Tiff->Yul->Jess->Taeng->Seo->Sun the kind of high note relay only SNSD can afford to have!
who need mr removed when we have this!!
queens of kpop always slay
I love the live band as well!!! The drum and guitar are so beautiful
The video just appeared on my home feed, and I was curious what "mistake" they did while singing ballad song like this. And then I just realized the title of the song is mistake lol
Oh wow, Hyoyeon's and Sooyoung's voices complement each other so well @0:42. I can't believe they never used this combo again, or did they?
I don't think so... They usually use Hyo and Yuri's voice together, just like in Lion Heart, MrMr...
can't help but come back to 1:28 YURI JJAAAAAANG~! >O< this is too perfect huhu (but I kinda dislike how Jessica and tiffany sings here) eherm
소녀시대 사랑행복좋아합니다
THIS ERA! IS SO FINEEE
Amo essa música parece até que veio do céu! 😍 👍
E esses high notes são Deslumbrantes, o da Yuri é o meu favorito! ⭐_⭐
that's my Sunny Bunny
best soshi ballad
6 member hit highnote
👏
2019 any here?
People said snsd was Girlsband but they're VOCAL GROUP. Fight me period
i miss this era so much
Hearing this again.
Tiffany- out of the tune/beat compare to the original track
Sica-she's hard reaching the highnote
Taeyeon- she always ate the CD! Bravo
Sunny&Yuri- wow! This 2 girls should have more lines
Jessica's high note here is more difficult than the rest tho. Taeyeon's high note is an open vowel which is why it's easier to belt out. Jessica has "i" with letter e sounds which is closed vowel. There's no way you can hit it without thinning your voice so Jessica did a good job.
The 'eu' which sounds like uh is hard. And it has to slide too in the original. So jessica actually did decently.
Without Jessica's signature vibrato she would've sound awful but thanks to her so called skill she did pretty well.
For me the only one who ruined this live is tiffany, but she not that bad.. still fantastic
Wow.. It's 2020 and I never knew that this performance is exist.
Even though it's not a full song but this is one of the best live performance. T___T
seohyun taeyeon yuri..
It’s already 12 years with you guys❤️
I miss them so sooo much and my OTP is on the looseeee hereee TaeNy and YulSic FOREVER and Taeyeonieee is still the best 😍
thank you so much!! I really love this song.
THANKS FOR RE-UPLOADING A BEST PERFORMANCE OF 9 ANGELS
i love this song so much
The voice of SooxHyo and SunxYoon
Perfect combination that ever made!
after all these years, this song still haunt my dreams.. 😋
as always.. taeyeon 😘 btw hyoyeon has very good and stable voice, i hope she get more line
JESSICA THE BEST 😍😍😍
역시....탱구♥♥
Taeyeon
Hyo and Soo sound so good together
OMG YURIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII.
They are great singer. Legend
I'm currently getting hooked on this song
Taeyeon so cute😍
TaeYeon's live was beyond beautiful
Yuri wrote this song ❤️
It’s crazy how are Gen 2 groups basically sang everything live back then. Now it’s all about having the AR play and singing under the track.
Taeyeon's last line was *chef's kiss* 💋
Thats why there was no jessisa in TTS
Snsd be like find our main vocalist. Hahaha i miss them ot9❤
The world without MR. 3 year old GG and their vocals is this consistent? Nothing less from Nation's GG.
Love Taeyeon's adlib
Yuri high note is amazing
2:15 I love this part from Sunny!
I’ll never forgive SM for letting Yuri regress to the point she only sings nasally now
Taeyeon ❤❤❤❤
I love Jessica's hair style
1:28nYuri High notes OMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
I love how they put yuri in the front to honor this song she wrote
its been 7 years :')
kwon yuri wrote that song.
Yuri snapped!
yuriiii roxx
My fav ballad .(
Damn taeyeon 😲😍
When Sunny and Yuri slay ten times more then Jessica
disagreed
Yep they really killed it. Just goes to show you that, you being the main vocalist doesn't mean you're the best.
+Glenda Salazar you can disagree but the truth is yuri and sunny nailed it
Lol do you even realize how hard the line given to Jessica on the bridge? Your voice has to be thin to hit it while doing it on runs. What Yuri did was really great for a non vocalist member of a group, but for main vocalists, it is just something that they should have to begin with. The end line or the vowel is easy to open so it's easier to hit. On Sunny's Part, she didnt even really tried hard because thats how high her natural voice can go. So I dont what are your basis for degrading a main vocalist just to please your shit mentality and hate towards her
Both of them slayed but just equal to jessica we cant deny the fact jessica is a better singer than themThough i am yuri biased jessica is still better in vocal😊
Un grupos donde todos pueden cantar!!! Nadie podra superarlas, son las reinas del kpop.
I watched 178 times today.. don't worry im still okay..
If only Sunny could sing like that all the time...
Ahhh reading these comments now (2020) hurt my Hyoyeon loving heart. At least she’s finally starting to get recognised this year 💕😭
Creo que la única nota alta que a tenido Yuri con SNSD
taeyeon!!!!!!!!!!
Why am I obsessed with this in 2021 😕