उत्तरकाण्ड सच है या झूठ? | Decoding Uttarkand of Valmiki Ramayana | Raja Ram Series #3
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 июл 2024
- ☀️ इस मकरसक्रांति संस्कृत भाषा सीख कर अपनी आध्यात्मिक यात्रा प्रारम्भ करें।
Use Coupon Code "MAKAR25" to avail 25% discount
on all Shikshanam course! 🕉️
🚨Coupons are Limited. Enroll Today!
Download Shikshanam App: bit.ly/3LehPc5
Or visit the website: www.hyperquest.in/courses
👩🏫 हमारे "Shikshanam" App पर ही हिन्दू दर्शनों 🕉️को भी सीखें ! और जीवन के कठिन से कठिन प्रश्नों के पाखण्डरहित तार्किक हल पाएं।
🙏आज ही अपना कोर्स चुनें!
---------------------------------------------------
दोस्तों, Hyper Quest के एपिसोड 75 में आपका स्वागत है, और आज के इस एपिसोड में हम वाल्मीकि रामायण का एक विस्तृत विश्लेषण करेंगे। हम वाल्मीकि रामायण के विवादास्पद उत्तर काण्ड की authenticity का पता लगाने का प्रयास करेंगे।
Friends, welcome to episode 75 of Hyper Quest, and in today's episode, we will conduct an in-depth analysis of Valmiki Ramayana. We will strive to determine the authenticity of the controversial Uttara Kanda in Valmiki Ramayana.
Research assisted by: Sajal Sahay
#rammandir #ramayan #ayodhya
---------------------------------------
𝗪𝗔𝗧𝗖𝗛 𝗢𝗨𝗥 𝗧𝗢𝗣 𝗩𝗜𝗗𝗘𝗢𝗦:
🎥 सनातन धर्म में Menstruation का सच: • Myths about Menstruati...
🎥 सरस्वती नदी की सच्चाई क्यों छुपाई जा रही है?: • Why the history of Sar...
🎥 सनातन धर्म को कहाँ से और कैसे पढ़े?: • Reading guide on Sanat...
🎥 योग वासिष्ठ में Time Travel, Multiverse और Aliens!: • योग वासिष्ठ में Time T...
🎥 काकभुशुण्डी और ब्रह्मांड: • Kakbhushundi's Theory ...
---------------------------------------
𝗞𝗡𝗢𝗪 𝗔𝗕𝗢𝗨𝗧 𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗛𝗢𝗦𝗧:
🙋♂️ Meet Vishal Chaurasia, the inquisitive host with a voracious appetite for knowledge! Graduating from IIT Patna in 2016, this bookworm has devoured over 250 captivating titles, exploring everything from popular science to religious philosophies. With an insatiable curiosity about the universe and the enigmatic concept of God, he's on a quest to unravel the secrets of existence. Let's join him on his Hyper Quest!
His Favourite Books: [English]
📘 Complete Works Of Swami Vivekananda: amzn.to/3is1oOc
📗 The Battle of Sanskrit by Rajiv Malhotra: amzn.to/3rAk6XY
📙 Patanjali Yoga Sutras by Swami Vivekanand: amzn.to/3Q7xRaO
📕 Astrophysics For People In A Hurry: amzn.to/3IyXT3d
📗 Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science: amzn.to/3QqAzqj
📘 Quantum Mechanics: The Theoretical Minimum: amzn.to/3jXXPj3
विशाल की प्रिय पुस्तकें: [हिंदी में]
📙 संस्कृत सीखे: संस्कृत स्वयं - शिक्षक [श्रीपद दामोदर सातवलेकर]: amzn.to/3rxM0UL
📘 स्वामी विवेकानंद जी का राज योग, कर्म योग, भक्ति योग, और ज्ञान योग : amzn.to/3k55TPh
📗 स्वामी दयानंद सरस्वती जी की "सत्यार्थ प्रकाश" : amzn.to/3GxIMVb
📕 सेपियंस : मानव जाति का संक्षिप्त इतिहास : amzn.to/3QAvdZx
📗 गीता प्रेस द्वारा प्रमुख 11 उपनिषदों का सेट: amzn.to/3iy5PHb
📘 लघुसिध्दान्त कौमुदी [पाणिनि व्याकरण की प्रारंभिक शिक्षा ]: amzn.to/44tJhtR
----------------------------------------
𝗖𝗢𝗡𝗡𝗘𝗖𝗧 𝗪𝗜𝗧𝗛 𝗨𝗦 𝗢𝗡:
For Quick Knowledge and Daily Stories on Sanātana Dharma
🔹 Instagram: / hyperquest
🔹 Facebook: / hyperquest
🔹Threads: www.threads.net/@hyperquest
🔹Telegram: t.me/hyperquestchannel
🔹 Whatsapp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va8O...
-----------------------------------------
𝗘𝗤𝗨𝗜𝗣𝗠𝗘𝗡𝗧 𝗨𝗦𝗘𝗗 𝗜𝗡 𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗩𝗜𝗗𝗘𝗢:
🎙️ Mic: amzn.to/44KqL0a
📷 Camera: amzn.to/3Oh4Ic9
☂️ Softbox: amzn.to/43t7eQM
📸 Lens: amzn.to/3K12tau
💡 Key Light: amzn.to/43p6cVT
🚥 RGB Light: amzn.to/44MyYRz
🔭 Tripod: amzn.to/44tzZOz
----------------------------------------
Intro: (0:00)
उत्तरकांड का 'उत्तर' : (1:11)
उत्तरकाण्ड प्रक्षिप्त है ? : (3:35)
उत्तरकाण्ड प्रमाणिक है ? : (8:13)
----------------------------------------
Thanks for watching the video.
धन्यवाद, आपके बहुमूल्य समय के लिए। 🙏🏼
☀ इस मकरसक्रांति संस्कृत भाषा सीख कर अपनी आध्यात्मिक यात्रा प्रारम्भ करें।
Use Coupon Code "MAKAR25" to avail 25% discount on all Shikshanam course! 🕉
🚨Coupons are Limited. Enroll Today!
Download Shikshanam App: bit.ly/3LehPc5
Or visit the website: www.hyperquest.in/courses
Meri apse binti hay ki kripaya ispe ek video banaye ki vailmiki ramayana me unke khadyavyas ko leke keya likha gaya hay or Raja dasarath ki shikar ke waje se pane wala shrap ki bare me vi keipiya khulasha ki jiye😊🙏jay shree Krishna
Karpurgauram ka arth Kya h apne Sanskrit teacher se puchhkar batao.
Please make a video on the battle of ten kings(dasrajana yudhh)and mittani inscription of Syria
bhai p lease iss aak question hai mera ispe video jarur lana kya ramsetu sahi mai tha?
Plz bhagwan ram par jo meat or wine khane ka baat or shikar k bare mein likha hein uske upar bhi video banayiye 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️
Your channel deserves more and more views and followers you are doing great Job by creating awareness about our culture 😊
कई बार कुछ प्रश्नों का उत्तर हमारे पास नही होता पर आप जो भी ज्ञान दे रहे है उससे कई प्रश्नों के उत्तर मिल रहे है । श्री हरि।।।
विशाल जी आपका प्रयास सराहनीय है। हिन्दू धर्म (ग्रन्थ) इतना बृहद है कि कोइ व्यक्ति विशेष इसका गहन अध्ययन करके सटीक निष्कर्ष दे पाए यह सर्वथा झूठ होगा। क्योंकि इनके अध्ययन करना एक प्रकार से असंभव है। इसलिए कोई इनके बारे में तर्क नहीं दे सकता। आपका प्रयास सराहनीय है। मै भी अपने इन ग्रंथों का ज्ञान पाना चाहता हूं परन्तु उम्र और गृहस्थ के जंजाल से समय और सम्पत्ति के अभाव के कारण अनभिज्ञ रहता हूं। आपको अनेकों धन्यवाद जो ऐसे कार्यक्रम लाने के लिए।
Thank you for bringing this videos on uttarkand bhai...
Jai Shree Ram... ❤❤
Thanks for sharing valuable information on Uttar Kand of Ramayan. I just love your research work on Hinduism. Jai Shri Ram 🙏
सर आपके पास ज्ञान तो बहुत बढ़िया है और।कंटेंट में भी दम ह परंतु आपके चेंनल का नाम ऐसा है कि कोई आसानी से उस तक नही पहुच सकता इसके लिए मेरा आपसे निवेदन है कि आप आपके चेंनल का नाम चेंज कर के देखिये आपको 10 मिलियन से ज्यादा व्यू ओर सब्सक्राइबर मिलेंगे इससे आपके फैन को काफी खुशी होगी उसमे एक मे भी हु
SatyaVachan
बालकांड में एक श्लोक है जिसमें बताया गया है कि रामायण में उत्तर कांड सहित छह कांड हैं। इस श्लोक में उत्तरकाण्ड का अलग से उल्लेख क्यों है? रामायण में सात कांड हैं ऐसा क्यों नहीं कहा ? इससे लगता है कि उत्तरकांड बाद में जोड़ा गया है और इसको उचित बताने के लिए बालकांड में भी मिलावट की गई है।
ये भि तो हो सकता है कि इस श्लोक का अर्थ है कि उत्तराकांड को पढ़ना आवश्यक नहि हे।
हा भाई मिलावट ही की गई है ताकि लोगो को सच लगे की उत्तर काण्ड सच ही वरना ये अलग से नही लिखा होता उत्तर काण्ड सहित छह काण्ड हे समझ सकते हो की ये बादमें मिलाया है।
उत्तरकांड रामायण का अभिन्न हिस्सा है ।।
@@kafir-e-aazam8499aata mila?
But in Mahabharata Padma puran usme uttarkand ki vag mention hota hay or ravan ka character vi usi me explained hay zada Thora doubt rahe hi jata hay....or uttarkand alag se mentioned
Hay or shkola number 24000 and 500 swarga kaha jata hay original me vi ayese hi explained hay uski lekhni ko katke ye shloka number or sarga number change Nehi Kiya ja sakta hay na
अगली दोनों वीडियो का बेसब्री से इंतजार रहेगा भाई ,क्योकि ऐसे प्रश्न मेरे मन मे भी है😇जय महाकाल🙏🌳🌳
Kya aap ujjain se hai ?
जी नही।
किन्तु क्या महाकाल जी पर केवल उज्जैन वालो का ही अधिकार है?😇🌳
@@avikatyagi2894 जी नहीं, उन पर श्रद्धा रखने वाले हर भक्त का हो सकता है।
किंतु आपको ऐसा क्यों लग रहा है?
@@enthusiast.h5 पहले आप कहिए आपको क्यो लगा कि मैं उज्जैन से हूं?🌳
@@avikatyagi2894 जय महाकाल देखकर..आधिकांश उज्जैनवासी वार्तालाप की शुरूवात में यह बोलते है।
अब आप बताइए आपको ऐसा क्यों लगता है?
मेरे सभी दोस्तों को जय श्री राम 🚩🚩🚩🚩🕉️🕉️🕉️
Jai shree Ram
Jai sri ram🙏♥️♥️🌹🚩
जय श्री राम 🙏
पूज्यनीय तुलसी पीठ के जगद्गुरु श्री श्री रामभद्राचर्य महाराज जी भी इस कांड को बाद में जोड़ा गया बताते हैं
पुज्य रामानन्द सागरजी ने भी कहा था कि इस कांड को बनाना अच्छा नहीं है. इसलिए उत्तरकांड की शूटिंग बाद में हुई
वह शुटिंग भी राजीव गांधी सरकार द्वारा निर्मित दबाव के कारण किया गया था
@@user-xk9rq4om3m बिल्कुल सही कहा आपने
@@deependrasingh7581 अच्छा क्या बात करते हो कुछ आता जाता हैं या नहीं आपको दिक्कत क्या उत्तरकांड से बताओं
एक कारण बताओं कोई भी ................(पर याद रहे आगे पिछे कि बात पढ़ कर बतानो
)
उत्तर काण्ड में कुछ चीजे बाद में जोड़ी गई है
1. यदि किसी शुद्र के तापस्य से किसी ब्राह्मण का पुत्र मर जाता है तो फिर वाल्मीकि जी के साधना से भी तो किसी की मृत्यु होनी चाहिए।
2. वाल्मीकि रामायण के युद्ध कांड में अंत में स्पष्ट लिखा हु है इस प्रकार राम और राम के पुत्रो ने हजारे वर्ष राज्य किया। और
यह बताता है रामायण यही पर समाप्त हो गई।
Apne shi kha
Ved padhne se
महर्षि वाल्मीकि शूद्र नही थे वरन महर्षि प्रचेता के पुत्र थे और आध्यात्मिक पठन पाठन उनका वंशगत कार्य था ।
Sanskrit words has different meanings as per situations. True
Ram Bhadrachary Ji told that Sri Ram Ji never leave Sita Mata. I have seen in a video..
Ye Pani ke kavi koi sapna dekha aur bad me Ramayana me Joda gya.
I'm extremely thankful to u to search the truth in this Kaliyug.👌Job Sir 🙏🙏🙏
मान्यवर ,हिन्दू सनातनी समाज आपका सदैवआभारी रहेगा ,सनातन और शास्त्रों के बिरोधियो के प्रपंच होते रहे हैं ।।
सर आप डाॅ विकास दिव्यकीर्ति द्वारा कहें गए वाल्मीकि रामायण में वर्णित आपत्तिजनक घटनाएं जैसे श्री राम द्वारा मांस और मदिरा सेवन और वैश्या भोग पर भी एक विडियो बनाए। ❤🙏🏻
Bro unho na asa nahi kaha bass isi ka bara ma kaha joa video ma batya gaya ha
0:57 start
8:36 sponsor start
9:34 sponsor end
Isme galat kya hai
जय श्री राम🙏
जय सीता माता🙏
जय लक्ष्मण भगवान🙏
जय श्री हनुमान🙏
जय भरत महाराज🙏
जय शत्रुघ्न महाराज🙏
ज्ञानवर्धक वीडियो है,,,, उस समय की मान्यताओं एवं परिस्थितियों का अध्ययन एवं अनुशीलन बहुत आवश्यक है,,, तभी कोई निष्कर्ष निकाला जा सकता है,, और कथा का मर्म भी समझा जा सकता है।
वाल्मीकि जी ने उत्तर कांड लिखा है, मानस में भी तुलसी दास जी ने उत्तर कांड लिखा है,
और मुझे ऐसी कोई कथा नहीं लगी कि जो मिलावटी हो,
हम जब तक ज्ञान नहीं रखते और किसी के सवाल का जवाब नहीं दे पाते तो हम अपने बचाव में सीधा बोल देते हैं कि ये चीज मिलावटी है, जब कि हमें अपने ग्रंथो का अध्ययन करना चाहिए,
1 -2 चीजे बताऊं तो शम्भुक वध इसलिए किया गया कि शम्भूक कोई अच्छी पूजा या यज्ञ नहीं कर रहा था जबकि वो एक चण्ड पूजा कर रहा था जो अनुचित है और उसने बलि के लिए 3 अलग अलग जान भी ली थीं, और ऐसे व्यक्ति का वध कहीं से अनुचित नहीं है, बस दिक्कत कुछ लोगों को है कि इससे उनकी राजनीति में दम पड़ जाता है , क्योंकि शंभुक शुद्र लिखा हुआ है बस इसलिए!
नहीं तो रामायण में 2 वध पहले भी हुए हैं :
1 - बाली का
2 - मेघनाद का ( इसका तो यज्ञ करते हुए ही किया था)
{इसपे किसी को कोई आपत्ती नहीं आती बस वहां (शंभुक के लिए) शुद्र लिखा है तो बस लग गए राजनीति चमकाने}
दूसरा सीता मैया का त्याग : तो कुछ और ग्रंथो को पढ़ने के बाद पता लगता है कि ये त्याग नहीं था, सीता माता गर्भवती थी तो उन्हें राजा जनक के क्षेत्र में (मतलब मायके) भेजा गया था जो परंपरा के तरह था लेकिन राजा जनक वेद ज्ञाता थे तो उन्हें वो धर्म संगत नहीं लगा इसीलिए राजा जनक ने जानकी को अपने क्षेत्र में तो रखा लेकिन महल में नहीं {यही माता का भी मत था वो खुद भी महल में नही रहना चाहती थीं}
तो इसलिए वाल्मीकि आश्रम में रहीं चूंकि वाल्मीकि एक देवऋषि थे इसलिए ।
फिर उसके बाद जो होना था वो हुआ भी,
माता पृथ्वी से आई थी वो वहां चली गई, और प्रभु अपने लोक ( बाकी लोगों का उद्धार हो गया)।
अगर बाल्मीकि जी उत्तर कांड में सब कुछ सत्य लिखा है तो आप कैसे कह सकते है कि संबूक हत्या इस लिए किया गया क्योंकि वो चंड पूजा कर रहा था आपके इस क्या उस समय कि लिखित किताब या ग्रंथ में ये प्रसंग लिखा है जिसे आप बता रहे हैं अतः मैं आपके इस कथन को सत्य नहीं मानता क्योंकि मनुस्मृति के अनुसार शूद्रों को पूजा पाठ तथा विद्या आदि सीखने हेतु अपराध था जिसमें कठोर डंड का प्रवधान था जिसके कारण संबूक हत्या हुआ आप अपना प्रमाण अधारित तर्क दे सकते है
जय जय श्री राम
सत्य सनातन 🙏सत्यमेव जयते🙏 जय श्री राम🙏🚩
हम उत्तराखंड में केदारखण्ड से हैं, और इस पूरे क्षेत्र को केदारखंड में बद्रीकाश्रम कहते हैं। तो वैष्णव भी, हम शैव भी हैं शाक्य भी हैं , क्योंकि हमारी अधीधाष्ट्री देवी माँ जगदम्बा भवानी हैं। और ये बद्रीनाथ का आश्रम है। तो
जम्बूद्वीप, आर्यावर्त, भारतवर्षे , उत्तराखंड, केदारखंडे, बद्रीकाश्रम मंदाकिनी तटे औंकारेश्वर भूमि ऊखीमठ (ऊषामठ) जन्मस्थली स्थित:.हम सनातनी हैं।
#HyperQuest जवाब जरूर देना।
Jai Shri Ram 🙏🚩
You will make history very nice bro and thanks to take initiative to wake up all sanatani..🎉🎉🎉🚩🚩
।। जय जय श्रीराम । जय जय हनुमान ।।
I really appreciate you giving an English title to this video. I come from a different country. I understand Hindi but am unable to read it correctly. Therefore thanks for using English.
Where are you from?
U can take help with translator or we all support you that he can put English titles
@@xenonezio5188Bangladesh
Jay Siyaram 🚩🧡🙏🏻🌸 Jay Hanuman 🚩🧡🙏🏻🌸
जय श्री राम❤❤❤❤❤
Sita Mata KI Tayag and Sambhu ka badh ek dam authentic and moral hain. Kyu? is ka answer Hyper Quest bhaiya jarur deghe. So Don't worry and don't shame about our history. 🌹🌹
Very informative....Jay Shree Ram 🙏🏻🚩
Jai shree ram ❤
जय श्री राम...🙏🙏🙏
Jay shree ram ❤❤❤
Aapke adhyayan gyan chmta vilkchan h aapke shodh ur pryas se hm bhartiy apni sankriti ke shi tatvo ko smjh pate h itne gahen gyan ur shodh ke liye aapka bhut aabhar agli dono vidios ka intjar rhega 🙏🚩jy sri ram
Reasons why Uttarkhand in interpolated: In description of Ram's character before his coronation his qualities is of a very strong person who include intolerance to gossipers and people who malign others, also he was a transparent and just always hand Sita was aa self respecting woman who was always treated with love and dignity.
Therefore Uttarkand in which ram simply directs Laxman to abandon Sita in forest without any conversation with her, and does not punish the dhoti who maligns the character of his own wife and comments on Sita is completely contradictory.
It was added later by social priests to indicate that women should stay subdued and do not leave houses without husband's permission.
Not a part of original Valmiki Ramayana.
Ye hyper quest played safe so he don't offend anyone
Bilkul shi h ye striyon ko neeche rkhne ke liye joda h
true, not a part of valmiki ramayan
Yess
Very good explanation .
Jai Shree Krishna
Jai Shree Ram 🙏
Radha Radha 💖
बहुत ही बढिया हैं!बेहद के बेहद की परम परम परम महाशांति हैं!❤
आप बहुत अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं
किसको किसको ये चैनल पसंद है वो लाइक करें 😊❤👍
Jai shree Ram ji
Apka way of elaboration is very Nice. App Hindu ke lie ek di. icon ho jaenge. Bahat Bahat Sundar. Bhagaban Apko apka jiban Mai bahat tarakki lae or ashirvad de 🎉🎉
ग्रंथों को समझना इतना आसान होता तो आज हर कोई आचार्य होता, ये भगवान की लीला है, और इसके पीछे कई सारे कारण हैं जो पुराणों में वर्णित हैं।
जय श्री राम 🙏🚩
गर्व से कहो हम हिन्दू है।
Hindu ,Garv se kaise kahe khudko😅 ?
Apani amma se puch
@@dipanshu_tiwari448 Teri Amma Achaa Batati hai Lagta Hai .
Usi se Puch lunga 😅
@@dipanshu_tiwari448 MEre Kehne Ka matlab ye Tha Ki Hamare Grantho mai Kahi hindu shabd nahi ,,
To Ya To Garv Se Sanatani , Vaidik Dharmi ya Arya Kahe ..
Hindu kyu bole ,?
Mai Bas itna hi puchna Chah rha tha , lekin Lagta Hai Aapne Sanskar nahi Sikhe ... Sharm kariye apne bartav par...!
Jis Bhasha Mai bola tumne Usi mai Pa gaye .!!
Ab acha Lagega 👍🙏
Vishal ji NAMAN 🙏 for a very Rational Analysis. Somehow story of Shambhuk Vadh is difficult to digest if it is true .
Thank you so much for the Sanskrit course, looking forward to it
U r really a gem for sanatan dharm far better than our Godman gurus
Well what is says is after reading a book with translation or after reading someone's bhasya(Its common for anyone) but those bhasya and translations are done by Sadhu sants and gurus only
have you ever listened to ny guru? ever visited any katha?
Critical Edition Of Valmiki Ramayana
Most Authentic one,
Normal version of valmiki ramayan is full of interpolation
Jai Shree Ram ❤
Thank you so much bhaiya wanting for you next video 🙏🏻🥺
धन्यवाद 🙏
Brother you are doing a great job
This is why education is important
Thanks
Please do a podcast with Swami Sarvapriyananda ji....
Bro but you didn't answer the fact that Vibhishan said that he has never heard that a "doot" is killed.
Exactly
🙏❤
Waiting for its second part... 🙌
Love from uttarakhand sir 🕉️🚩🙏
Make a video on Devi Draupadi's character as it is given in original Mahabharata because she is the most controversial charcracter of Mahabharata some says she was filled with jealousy, anger, and revenge but some says that she was the most graceful lady that can ever be whether as a queen or as a wife or as a woman 🙏
She is also being blamed as the reason of Mahabharata 🙏
Good topic
She is not a characterful lady. No characterful lady in that era would have accepted being wife of 5 brothers. She was married to Arjuna but she wasn't satisfied with one Arjuna thus accepted wilfully. In her past life she wanted a husband of all the qualities which was impossible in one person.
He will sugar coat it nicely😂
Thankyou for your comment. We will try to bring a video on this topic soon. Stay tuned! 🙏😊
@@perpetualprosperity2963 hr kpi tere npbi ki trh nhi hai
उत्तर के तीन अर्थ प्रमुख हैं-
1-दिशा ,
2- समाधान व
3-पश्चात
Bhai Dil khus kr diya ❤❤❤❤ emotional 😢😢😢 kr diya
जय श्री राम 🙏🌹
Jay Siya Ram 🙏🙏🙏🙏
who read RAMCHARITMANAS ,PROUD TO BE SANATANI..
Yes!!!❤
जय श्रीराम🙏🚩
Dhanyawad Bhai,,, Hare Krishna 🙏
जय श्री राम
Sir I have question for you sir, are there only two epics in Hinduism only which are Ramayana and Mahabharata or are there even more lesser known epics that very less people talk about?,I would really to know your thoughts on that.🙏🕉️
There are also other epics which are not famous you can google it
Some of them are Meghnad Badh Kavya
There is also maharamayana(yogavashishta) as well
ksheera sagara mathanam ,
king pruthu ,
prahlada,
king bali ,
Ambareesha ,
Bhageeradha ,
Yayaathi ,
Lord Sri Krishna's full life story , Markandeya charitra ,
king Bharatha (on account of whom this country is called Bharatha varsham ) ,
Shankar parampara ka grnth hai 🤣🤣@@mr.gamerkabir8142
@Anubhavsengupta Ramayana and Mahabharata are the greatest works of Hindu literature and they are usually called Itihasa or history books written in an epic style. There are a lot of other epics as well but these two are the most important and holiest and authorative.
Sabse prachin balmiki ramamyan hai
Thankyou for giving such a great knowledge about our prabhu Sri Ram ...jai sri ram
𝓙𝓪𝓲 𝓼𝓱𝓻𝓮𝓮 𝓱𝓪𝓻𝓲🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Love your videos...Kindly make a detailed video on Casteism in Hinduism...❤
Sanatan dharm me Varn vyvastha thi
Casteism word come from west
Cast we told today was our family blood line name
Like Chhaturvedi surname means 4 vedo ko janane vala
@@YesIcandoit-t1g Puri Shankaracharya Swami himself says everytime that caste/jati/varn all are just same concept and everything is birth based only. He deliberately promotes and supports untouchability and birth based casteism prejudicial discriminatory hierarchical structure and it's oppressive practices by citing scriptural references. Every trads folks too does the same. Thus implies the fact that casteism is inherent and inseparable part of hinduism
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Bhagwat Gita 18:41
ब्राह्मण-क्षत्रिय-विषम शूद्रनं च परंतप
कर्माणि प्रविभक्तानि स्वभाव-प्रभावैर गुणैः
ब्राह्मणों, क्षत्रियों, वैश्यों और शूद्रों के कर्तव्यों को उनके गुणों के अनुसार, उनके गुणों के अनुसार (जन्म से नहीं) वितरित किया जाता है।
Bhagwat Gita is the only truth every other things are manipulated some by the thoughts of saint some by some philosopher. They are human being they can be wrong.
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 rig ved doesnt mention a jati system , varna system is mentioned which is way different from jati system. So let me ask you, who is the ultimate dictum here?Puri shankaracharya or the vedas?
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155no one belive in pakhndi shankrachrya 😂bcz upnishad vedas said varn is by karm knly
युद्धकांड के अंत में जो फलश्रुति दी गई है वह पूरे रामायण की फलश्रुति है युद्धकांड की नहीं अतः आपका महाभारत की फलश्रुतियों वाला तर्क अनुचित लगता है।
Uttarkand is like a sequel to the main story of Ramayana.
@@agniswar3it's narratives are highly inconsistent with the narratives of all previous 6 kands
Sir I have a question for you,why is meat eating prohibited in Hinduism?,While it's true that I do eat meat but I know the real reason behind that,but I still want you to make a video on that topic.🚩🕉️
Meat-eating is not prohibited. In fact nothing is prohibited in sanatan religion. Everything action has consequences. Karma comes back to u. That is it. Think of a lion. It doesn't know anything else to eat. But he has to fight for that & he can die. But in fighting so.. he becomes king too. But he does prematurely. That is the karma.
Besides it is nature of meat food is that it makes to restless, destroys mind peace. If done too much.
But also sometimes, eating meet is necessary for warriors for quick gain of muscle power.
Observe nature. Think deeply. You will get your answer
Scriptures are filled with instances of meat eating, animal sacrifices etc
It is prohibited because we are taking the life of a living being, and it causes them harm. If we cannot create life, then we have no permission to take one... These living beings can feel pain just like us, which is why we have no permission to eat meat or kill any living beings. In the case of the food chain, it's important to note that other animals cannot differentiate between what is good and what is bad, unlike humans. Lions, for example, have no choice but to eat meat as it is a part of their natural diet, and their actions are not counted in terms of karma. Only human actions have karmic effects; animals are exempt from this.
and the person which is saying for worriors they are allowed to eat meat... thats WRONG!!! they are not!!!!....if they say they are allowed because they are worriors then ask them the proofs!!! where is it wriiten!!! beacuse our sanatan dharm .. because or sanatan dharam says "धर्म की जय हो, अधर्म का नाश हो, प्राणियों में सद्भावना हो एवं विश्व का कल्याण हो" JAI SHREE RAM
@@user-mq9fs1wf4w I can site from the scriptures
I have the answer. Meat and fish eating is not prohibited in Hinduism. Both vegetarian and non vegetarian are a part of Hinduism
In Vaishnavism and Shaivism sect of Hinduism, vegetarianism is compulsory whereas in Shaktism (worship of mother goddess like Kali, Durga and her forms) and Tantra vegetarianism is not compulsory, non veg food are allowed except beef. That's why you can see that in Bengal and Assam most of hindus are non veg. Even fish and meat are offered as prasad. (You can see various kali temples, it's a tradition). Many shakto devotees and saints like Ramakrishna Paramhansa, Swami vivekananda, sri Arobindo, bapakhepa, etc. of Bengal were non veg. They are as much as part of Hinduism as Vaishnavism and Shaivism are
Jay Shree Krishna!!!💞🙂
Bahut hi achha explanation... Dhanyawad
Jo bhi hindu rashtra chahta hai like kare❤❤
If anybody have confusion about sambook vadh please watch the video of veducation by prateek bhaiya
Ek Baar Sanatan reveals search kare Uttar Khand Ramayan ka Part Nahi Hai Oor Clear ho jaega
" AryaVart Regenerator " already proved It through proof.
Brilliantly 🎉
Ek Baar Sanatan reveals search kare Uttar Khand Ramayan ka Part Nahi Hai Oor Clear ho jaega
जय श्री राम 👏💐👏
🙏 Jai Jai Shri Ram 🙏
Please make a video on the book the beautiful tree by historian Dharampal ji it's about indigenous Indian education system and dalit and women education system and this will prove that dalits and women also get education in ancient India
Shi h esa ho
Well there was no concept of dalit in that time
Uttar kand is fully real and authentic.
Prove it
uttar kand is false..its later addition..uttarkand kand has so many contradictory verses to balmiki ramayan
@@_Vaibhav_Rai Sure
@@_Vaibhav_Rai ruclips.net/p/PL2QN95Ik8YgaeIjx6Dqq3sFZM6fmkKSfm&si=MM6jWL2OT2SXMG8J
@@namopatel-ij6cc if uttarkand is interpolated then other scriptures like shrimad bhagwatam , padma puran, adhyatama ramayan(written by ved vyas ji), kalidas's epic raghuvansham are also inauthentic because all these scriptures contains the story of lav kush, vanvas of mata sita and shambhuk vadh katha. If you heard about sri dhar swami who was a shankaracharya of goverdhan math in jagannath puri, he wrote a commentary on srimadh bhagwatam known as "Sri Dhari Tika" and maheshwar tirtha ji who wrote commentary on "Valmiki Ramayan" (including uttarkand) they both are fools because they believe that uttarkand is authentic. Please read "Ramayan Mimansa" granth written by dharma samrat swami karpatri ji maharaja. Swami ji gives all the ans releated to ramayan,authenticity of uttarkand,lav and kush,vanvas of mata sita, shambhuk vadh.
Mast video bhai....❤❤❤❤
Thanks for video.... appreciated your work always..
Kon kon hamare aayodhya ma aa raha hai
Jai siya Ram ❤❤❤
I respect your content and this idea, but I still think Uttar-Kand is added after the ramayan, It was not added by mugal and British. But it was added by the few corrupt Brahamans who wanted to have the power of knowledge and wanted to be the part of society where they're born and lucky, and choosen by god so they born in Brahman kul. They thought if we'll add this part and we'll use god's name to justify this no one will question this. But as time went past people started questioning it.
Ye it's arrogant of hyper quest this time or maybe they want to keep everyone faith
Bhai added hey ya nahi ye Jaane k liye hanuman ji ka ya bramha ji ka tapasya kar k pata lagalo q key wahi hee uss time main thai... Agar tumhare andar tap karne kee sakti hey to... Q key wahi hee bata saktey hey kya added hey ya nahi
बहुत अच्छा
जय श्री राम जय श्रीराम जय श्रीराम। jay Shree Ram Jayashree Ram Ram Ram Jayashree Ram.
Ram mandir wale Hindu like kare
People doesn't really understand the Uttarakand... Whatever Shri Ram was doing was Him showing things that were prevalent in the then society, what social norms were binding upon him as a human being and a king despite which He was able to keep an absolutely clean personal life unlike His own father. Shri Ram Himself mentions to Brahma that He despite being an incarnation of Vishnu, must act as an ordinary human being. And every human being by nature has his own set of social bindings, dilemma and flaws. If something is remarkable, it is because, despite these turmoils, the Man was absolutely flawless in His personal life... Valmiki, despite being the author and establishing Shri Ram as the ideal man, himself speaks out against Sita parityag, which clearly shows his motive.
The problem is, if Lord Ram was only doing what is prevalent in the society and unable to differentiate between right and wrong, he cannot be considered ideal man or God. Society always follows a great man. Uttarkand in Ramayan + many Puranas are not authentic scriptures.
@@sayantanghosh6714 On what basis or proof are you saying the Uttara Ramayana is not authentic... Is it just your feeling or do you have proof... Whereas there are proofs enough even at the beginning of Ramayana that Uttar Kaand is very much a part of it. The definition of good and bad changes with time... Lord Parashuram killed Kshatriyas 21times was it good or bad? Whenever the good established by the previous avatara becomes sour, a new avatar arrives to narrate a new idea of Dharma as per the Yuga's needs. Otherwise many actions of Krishna would not seem correct if seen in the context of the Dharma established by Rama. Rama avatar is God's Leela and He is showing us the evils prevalent in those days society and protesting against the then Brahmanical society, sometime Himself by dominating Parshuram or killing Ravana, sometime through His better half, by protesting against the prevalent customs. That is why the second name given by Valmiki to the Ramayana is Seetayasya Charita Mahatam.
@@arindamchaudhary9
I have no problem with other things you have said. There may be changes in how the avatars deal with similar problems at different times. However, some things are absolute such that definition of good and bad does not change with time.
1. Slaughtering someone doing tapasya is a criminal offence at every day and age. Forget Maryada Purushottam, even a petty offender of low IQ would not indulge in such acts. If you were Sambuk and someone just blew your head off for only performing tapasya, would you brush it off only calling it a “sour” experience or criminal experience demanding his jail or death penalty?
ruclips.net/video/vAnTHvmuqC4/видео.html
2. Again owning several wives is wrong at every day and age. According to Mahabharata Krishna Bhagwan had only 1 wife: Rukmini. Rest of the made up stories such as stealing clothes, several wives, etc are mentioned in some Bhagvat puranas, which were written several 100 years after Mahabharata was composed. If someone justifies these act in the name of bhakti, it is his own pregrogative. In Bhagvad gita 3.21, Krishna says “Whatever action is performed by a great man, common men follow in his footsteps. And whatever standards he sets by exemplary acts, all the world pursues.” Therefore either Ram or Krishna will never indulge in acts that a common man is definitely not supposed to follow.
Unfortunately, thoughtless Hindus have become like those Muslims who perform language gymnastics to justify every abominable verse in the Quran. For them preserving the scripture, whether right or wrong, is more important than applying their brains.
ruclips.net/video/0_6jIqnUj_Q/видео.html
4. It is also possible that parts of Uttar Kand may be interpolated but it is impossible entire UttarKand is correct. First six chapters builds the satus of Ram as an ideal man, followed by Uttar Kand that undoes his image built through the first 6 chapters.
You can watch the video links and let me know if there is anything wrong. You will find the answer to your question regarding “what is the basis” of my claims
This channel justified it's name
❤❤❤❤😊har har Mahadev 🙏
No RUclipsr name druve rathee is targetted in this video😂😂
I strong urge all to read or hear original Valmiki Ramayana and the character Of Ram is of a strong brave Kshatriya with confidence and intellect to rule people and guide them. In Uttarkan Raam is portrayed as a weak person who instead of guiding his people in the right direction submits to rumor.
Completely contradicts Valmiki's portrayal of Ram's character.
Lot of research to indicate Uttarkand was added by social moral high priests to put down their own rules for women and society.
They added it to Raamayana as that was 1 reference for all families and thus gave a moral ground to their dictates.
Bro there are plenty of verses in Ramayan itself which contradicts one with another so that doesn't mean uttar kaand is not authentic
bro ram doesn't give any teachings like buddha don,t have any proof and their supernatural powers are only limited in ramayan stories when Britishser ruled on india where were ram and all 33×10^7 Devi devtas and ram murded many peoples he was a criminal in my point of view
Adbhut🎉
Great going brother.❤
Bhai kagbhushundji garun samvad uttarakhand ramcharitmanas mein hain to ye sach hi hoga valmiki ramayan ka mujhe nahi pata
@indraneelsarkar8590kagbhusndji sabse purane rambhakt hain na Jane kitni ramayan dekh chuke aur multiverse universe means anant universes bhi usi katha mein hain jisme bataya gaya Ramji ek matra supreme God hain anant universes ke ek matra swami jabki anant universes ke anant bramha vishnu mahraj etc ek ek universes ke governor Hain unke sevak
I have a hypothesis - Uttarkand is only partially interpolated and not in its entirety.
Thanks for making this video. I requested this video before on your channel. 😊
Maine sanskrit course khareed liye!🎉🥳
भाई आप आर्य समाज के दर्शन और उसका डिटेल्स में वीडियो बनाये। आखिर वो तर्क पर इतना बल देकर धर्म की व्याख्या क्यों करते है?
Bina buddhi ke dhrm ko nhi Jan skte mitra ,pakhand mai fns jaoge isliye
@@ujjwalyadav3783 इस प्रकार से अपशब्दो का प्रयोग ना करे।
😂tark par bal aur arya samaj great joke
Itna hi tark dete to donald hoffman jaise scientist advait vedanti ke sath podcast na karte schrodinger bhor ye sab advait ko praise na karke arya samaj ko karte😂 arya samaj ke satyarth padhne ke bad pata lga inka tark mitti ke der par hai
Vivekananda ka kehna tha Ram aur Krishna kabhi kisi Samay ek Achhe Raja Rahe honge Later on inko avtar Ya God Bana diya Gaya
I also Think so !!!!
*_Humne last 1000 yrs me bharat me janme kai logon ko Avtar bana diya hai_*
Adi Shankaracharya - Avtar of Shiva , Yajyavalka - Avtar of Brahma , Kumari bhatt - Avtar of Kartikiye , Kapil Rishi ( Samkhya Darshan) - Avtar of Vishnu.....
Aese Anek Example hai Jisme Bharat me Janme Bahut se Darshniko ko Avtar bana Diya Gaya hai inko insan hi Rehne Dena Chahiye usi me Inka wastav me samman hai
Aur inke naam par Chamtkarik Kahaniya likhne se bachne Chahiye
Since the story of Rāmāyaṇa had been retold poetically and dramatically to many generations, numerous mythological narratives of the Rāmāyaṇa like Rāma as an incarnation of Vishnu, Sitā as the daughter of Bhudevi (earth), Vāli, Sugreeva and Hanuman of the Kapi community as monkeys, Jambavan as the king of Rikshas (King of bears) and Jatayu, Sampati as vultures, Sagara lived for 60000 years, Rāma reigned for 11000 years etc. have been evolved.
चमत्कार की क्या परिभाषा है ???
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 Yes exactly!!
Well Said Brother
Aur Log bura mante jab koi Ram krisn ko Kalpnik kehta
Are Bhaii Jaisa Tum kahani likhe ho usko koun history manega
@@kafir-e-aazam8499
For me There is nothing Like Miracles Everything is changing The state of Prakriti Jo ki God kar sakta hai
Haan Matter and Consciousness isko Create karna impossible hai isko koi Create nahi kar sakta not even God , Isliye humare Shastron me inko Anadi / Eternal Kaha hai
@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 bahut se God and Godess jinko hindu Poojte hai wo Greek and Mesapotamia civilization se copy kiye Gaye hai Kyunki inka koi Praman India me 500 BCE se pahele nahi milta Dekhne ko , hindu Jain aur Buddhism ke Devi Devta Pe Greek and Mesapotamia civilization ka bahut Prabhav Raha hai