Fun fact, during the development of dormitabis, I was contacted to do the voice of Garvey. Once I read the script I got out of the project. I was about 16-17 at the time I think, but I could do a good discount joker impression which the dev wanted. Glad I didn’t knowing what happened.
I didn’t actually know the other VA, I never contacted them and I kinda stopped following the project after a while. The lines could have changed in that time though. But essentially, throughout the nights, “Tom” would admit to various crimes that he committed around Fazbears, including the SA line. This wasn’t in a script document or anything either keep in mind, this was just put into email, I’m sure that had I recorded the lines they might have added more or altered the script more. But I kinda noped out and used the excuse of school work (which was partially valid as I was about a junior maybe in high school at the time.)
I always found it creepy that Dormitabus practically tells you the developer controversy. Garvey is practically a spitting image of the offending developer, deviancy and all.
@@DjDeadpig oh god. That’d make it at least tolerable in the sense of not projecting shit the others into. But still repulsive given who it’s calling out and shit.
My main gripe with JR’s is a lack of variety in the main gameplay loop. The 6 animatronics that you deal with function mostly the same. I think there should be at an animatronic that becomes active in the later nights (anywhere between night 2 or 4) to spice things up. There’s more problems the player has to juggle, which is more interesting than just increasing the AI difficulty each night.
I think JR's creator should add: -Phone calls each night -Each night in 5 first night add an animatronic (1 night add 2 if there are 6 ones) -Make an unique gameplay at night 6 -Change the story more logical Then JR's may be much better than the version we have
The worst part about dormitabis is that in the extras if you go to havoc chica her description is: her arms describe the way she died, which is terrifying
Dormidabis being on top number 1, I can understand and totally agree regarding the controversy that is included in this game and also related to the game developer. But JR's being on 2nd, I'm not buying what you have say about the gameplay, because I enjoyed it. But that's just my opinion, please don't judge me.
I will admit, post-shift 2 is a pretty unfair game, but for some positives, the music was really good, creative mechanics, etc. I’m glad the dev is improving it to make it easier. Oh yea, dormitiabis is really fucking stupid and I can agree with that.
1 thing im confused is when people say that the tutorials in fnaf fan games are vauge. But when you get games like post shift 2, who alphabet soups you what to do, it gives me a general confusion on how tutorials should be structured to make people happy
This video made you my new favorite RUclipsr and it’s when I found out how you feel about dormitabis and I actually feel the same way about that game and one thing me and you have in common is that we both have a grudge on both dormitabis and garvey
Even though I was banking on JR’s being #1, I’m glad it turned out to be Dormitabis because this game deserved it more and here’s why in my opinion. Even though I really don’t like JR’s (mostly because of Ramenov) it at least had good visuals and SOME people on the team who actually cared about the game being good while Dormitabis features unnecessary child rape in a FNaF fan-game which reflects how fucked up in the head its creator is. AT LEAST for One Night at Flumpty’s, Jonochrome didn’t reflect his previous actions into his game and came out to sincerely apologise to everyone about his actions and respectfully left the internet and who knows if or when he’ll return. If he did then I’m not sure how I’d feel, even if I do still respect how he sorted out the situation at the time. Don’t know if it means he can just be allowed to come back on the internet and everything is “back to normal”. (I hate to admit this but I had to type out most of this comment all over again because I refreshed the comments, I hate when this happens! 😭😭) Great vid as always Tyler!
I was expecting Dormitabas on here. I agree with you on all the wrong things about Jr's and Dormitabas. Thank God I'm more into FnaC, Popgoes, TJOC, and Final Nights than those 2 games that had their creators being horrible people.
While I do agree with mac tonight 2 being a very bad fangame, the one I find worse than mac tonight 2 also made by malrat would have to be FNATI 2017, to me there's just a lot more problems than mac tonight 2 ever had, firstly, the ai is all over the place on how hard it is, by night 5 you'd be on the edge of your seat waiting for the next camera to pop up, secondly, the biggest one is how you cannot see much at all, the fog in the game is horrible in the cameras and office, looking for characters is just a pain, especially for pirate caverns, since you aren't given a clear indication on where you are going, you're stuck wondering around the place, and the second floor is the worst, undying does whatever the hell he wants, and it's the most darkest and hard to see places out of all of them in the game. Another thing is the lack of, or no mechanics at all, I know that it is supposed to be a reboot/remake of the original game, but there's been many other games that have remade fnati that turned out great like radiance's for example, but this game has nothing much in it, the ambience sounds basic, the sounds are exactly the same, all you do is hide and shut off a camera, that is it, the only sorta new mechanic is with minnie, the problem, is just that it doesn't work at all, you're supposed to listen for complete silence, then go check for where she is and shut off the camera she's in, the problem is how you cannot tell what's ambience and what isn't, and most of the time, you'd end up dying to minnie because you thought she wasn't there. I again personally think that while mac tongiht 2 is bad, FNATI 2017 takes the cake as being way worse than mac tonight 2, at least in mac tonight 2, there were some things that made it unique or somewhat enjoyable even for it's badness, but FNATI 2017 just doesn't have that, whatsoever
Now that you mention it, your right. How the fuck did a knife hurt that ghost girl? Why is she haunting the restaurant? I was so focused on the designs of the animatronics, that I accidentally overlooked the plot holes of Jr's.
I actually really liked JR'S. But I'm really happy that we have the opposite opinion. There are so many errors in the game design and so on in the game but no one is talking about it. (What do you think of fnaf plus? )
I dont think dormitabis is " THE WORST FNAF FANGAME OF ALL TIME " this game has some great ideas, the graphics are bad but in the same time nostalgic, golden freddy be the phone guy bit at the same time crying child is pretty cool, the ambience of this game is just: YOU COME HERE FOR YOUR REAL SUFFERING Yes: blackout is a terrible person And: dormitabis remake unofficial and dormitabis remastered is coming soon
I just realized how similar fnac 2 is to the classic version of fnati 1. Mechanics revolving around cameras and audio 2. Abandoned characters and person going to an abandoned location 3. and finally: Half assed jumpscares but at least fnati 1.0 being bland and kinda bad is ok as it was almost one of the 1st fnaf fan games
I would not be surprised if Dormitbius is in this video (cause of the infamous scene and the creator being really horrible). Edit: Yep, I was right. That game 100% deserves to be considered the worst FNAF fangame.
@@ryanlally8116 It had a part where William Alfton (named something else, I forgot what though) r*ping the girl who became Chica (I know it was off-screen, but they still explained it in like graphic detail I think). It was then revealed that the creator was a p*dophile and n*crophile.
I know I already commented this on uhyeah’s video on Dormitabis, but I somehow managed to reach Night 8 of Dormitabis before quitting. Looking back (especially knowing the creator’s messed up actions), I”m glad I did.
The original dormitabis was terrible and just in general disgusting, but luckily dormitabis remastered is supposes to be better and changed the story and everything. Its by a completely different development team blackout isnt involved with it in anyway (thank god) the new development team is expelled studios. They also changed the terrible cringy tapes
Ok im not gonna sugarcoat my statement, while FNIA failed at being a Parody FNAF Fan-Game cuz of how it tries really hard to be 18+; Dormitabis on the other hand failed along crash and burning to the ground at being a actual scary FNAF Fan-Game for the reasons following: • Nicchi being a downright abuser to those that worked for him (especially being revealed as a P-Bear) •The Presentation, while taking place in a alt timeline of FNAF 3, feels mid in a few places •The Gameplay is one massive clusterfunk when trying to hide from the Havoc Animatronics, looking at the camera, finding the Keys & Tapes, & it has 11 nights along a secret 12th night that requires the player to click on AMIREAL's nose really fast just to gain access (oh, and Peter Write doesn't explain how to deal with the Havoc Animatronics, IN WHICH MEANS YOU HAVE TO GO BACK TO THE BEGINNING AND CHECK THE INSTRUCTIONS) •The Havoc Animatronics design being uninspired along their motivation of getting ectoplasm out of John Write in which is mainly stuffing him into a Animatronic Suit cuz FNAF 1 did that (Golden Call can eat a fricken brick due to how difficult he is to deal with) •While a neat concept, The Cardboard Theatre is also a massive clusterfunk to complete as it requires the player to be fast as heck while getting both keys to unlock the True Ending (especially when mary is gonna get Garvey'd) •Speaking of Garvey, his Boss Night is just unbearable to complete as there is a 50/50 chance he'll kill you if you don't make it back to your starting position & the fact that he is Nicchi's Self Insert, just ruins this game altogether (& the fact that his Backstory is a School Shooter-equse dumpster fire which is a very, very, very idiotic idea full stop). The only saving grace there is to this game is the fact that some people are remaking this game without Nicchi's Involvement (hopefully they can fix everything else about this fangame).
literally glad the person whom tried to groom me (Nicchi) didnt get the full love he doesnt deserve. i was contacted to voice act the fucking 15 year old screaming, yeah, i said fuck no.
Given the large amount of love these games still receive to this day shows that it's really a matter of opinion, but what the maker of Dormitabis did should be omitted from a remaster and left to fade.
Man, i used to love Dormitibus when it first came out, everything from the look and animatronics, even the gameplay felt admitably clunky but like it could be polished to make a really fun fangame, with some oddly detailed lore but still, interesting to see just how deperaved and psychotic the killer was up close like that. But nowadays, hearing how everybody absolutely hates the guts out of the dev (For a VERY good reason, holy hell i did not realize just how horrible he was until this) and hearing opinions on it seem to be universally hated almost, im curious if the remake is going to be able to bring that old spark back from when i first saw the game...its got an uphill battle for sure
Alright, I know this doesn't have much to do with the video, but I have some ( in my opinion) interesting ideas for FNAF fangames. I would make them, but I don't have a PC. Here they are: •Bon's Burgers (This fangame would be based on The Walten Files and would be a mix between standard FNAF style gameplay and old school point-and-click horror games. It would also be 2D. I got the idea from the fact that The Walten Files was initially going to be a game. If I did develop this, the main problem developing would be making the gameplay work and the story at least okay.) •Fear of Fur (This would be like Animator's Hell where it's multiple people from a community as the antagonists. However, instead of people from the FNAF animation community, it would be notable furries in the Furry Fandom and characters that are popular with furries like characters from Zootopia and Beastars. This idea mainly comes from my somewhat involvement in the community and the fact that I think that a lot of characters in the Fandom would make for great and interesting character designs for a FNAF game. The main problem developing this game would be the matter of using the popular furries. I feel like they might be fine, but a lot of FNAF fans might go to them and bug them about Five Nights at Freddy's.) •Pooh's Corner (Based off of a real show that used to air on Disney Channel. It would involve the player fending off against Winnie the Pooh characters in the set of the show. This is a lot like many fangames based off of kids shows. The main problem would be making the characters from Winnie the Pooh creepy (especially Rabbit since I could see it being easy accidentally making him a Glitchtrap clone).) •Fanverse Custom Night (Basically Ultimate Custom Night but with less enemies and the enemies consist of characters from games included in the Fanverse initiative. Not much to say. The main problem would be finding a way to make the mechanics flow together well.) I could not think of that much fangames based off of fully original ideas, so these are the ideas I have. That's really all I have to say. Again, nothing to do with the video, I just wanted to share these.
My biggest qualm with jr’s was with the animatronic designs. Not that they were bad, god no they were great, but that they were simply underused. These designs were hyped to hell and back before the game’s release, but when the game came out, you really couldn’t see them. The cameras are too dark and dirty to clearly make out the designs, and in the back room you see a headless version of them, only for a few seconds before the ghost is back to haunting another robot. I wanted to actually SEE these designs in game. I wanted to see them up close, I wanted to see them move through the office, to get to see their creepiness. But no. And night 6 gives us almost completely different designs that once again, due to the environment, are not allowed to shine as much as they could. It’s a really disappointing use of wonderful models in my opinion. They could’ve done more, and this extends to the lore as well (seriously who tf are we playing as???)
I think Dormitabis was trying to go for the same look as FNAF 3, although there’s a big difference in that FNAF 3 doesn’t give me a headache. I’m not kidding about that ether, the animation for crawling under the desk in particular gave me a headache. As for JRs, I like the normal gameplay due to the investigation aspect of figuring out which one is possessed, but the night 6 and the other complaints I agree with.
Honestly, Trtf2 rebuilt should’ve been here as the new number 1. It’s developer is a complete asshole and the game is an unbalanced unfaithful remake of an already poorly aged game. The animatronic designs also don’t fit in with the trtf universe. Say what you will about Tyler Ahlstrom, at least he released 4 four games in a year and was a one man army, Kiilsto (the new dev) harassed and bullied his own staff and cut some of the best parts of his game out to get the game out as quickly as possible.
Yea to be honest I’d probably put return to Freddy’s 1 as number 1 worst just because it used stolen assets, at least Dormitabis used it’s own for better or for worse, it probably be on my number 2 for how in hindsight how poorly it’s aged (especially the story and the horrific actions Garvey committed on a 15 year old). Also some things blackout is into and has done really doesn’t help its case either.
FNIA may be weird and a bit gross but at the end day it’s nothing harmful and the game’s creator likes HOGGGGGG RIDAAAA. Dormitabas is…you get it,and the creator of Dormitabas doesn’t like HOGGGG RIDAAA so instant L
Honestly, I want to see you play Project Readjusted 3 and hear your thoughts about it. You can talk shit about the Creator all you want. Dormitabis was one of my favorite fan games back in the day, but now it's hard looking at it. Or thinking about it.
Your thoughts on Jrs are very similar to mine, the only thing that differs is our opinions on the main nights. I personally loved the Guess who idea behind the gameplay. Never finished the game because of how annoying night 6 was so I don't know if that crap gets any better post main story.
I'd honestly have to agree on Jr's, it is highly overrated Gameplay is dull, the story is poorly written, and while it may sound scary on paper, the execution was just, well, a horror game that tries to be scary but fails
I used to love Dormitabis when it was realesed i loved how the game had gore wich i personally think what fnaf should really have but now I can't even play the game anymore after I find out what Nicchi did and thinking that Garvey the main antagonist of the game was a self inter of Nicchi imself it's just disguting
Still remember Taste Gaming (a kids youtuber) played Dormitabis and said it was one of the best fangames he’d ever played Uh ooooohhhh Seriously though, when I learnt what happened I was done with Dormitabis. It was always a guilty pleasure fangame of mine and I’d even had permission to use some chars from it in a (now-cancelled) fangame. But now that I know what really happened… yikes.
Even though FNIA is just weird (or bad to certain people despite remakes being a thing along me and my twin bros planned one aswell), yea.......... these fan games are just downright terrible.
Just genuinely curious... What is your favourite five nights with Mac tonight game and why? Mine is fnwmt 1 remastered, I think simplicity goes a long way.
I din’t think Post-Shift 2 is a bad game. If the rng and difficulty was balanced, and if the movement animations were sped up, Post-Shift 2 would be a solid game at least for Part A.
Great video! It's nice to hear ur opinions on these games. Hopefully there will be a part 3 for this series. Ohh and also. Dormitabis and nicchi sucks!
I'd assume the ghost girl is able to be hit by the knife because its a weird purgatory knife because theyre in purgagory at that time??? idk I'm just trying to think of a logical reason
tylerland264 have you hear the jr's dlc is coming this year it planes on fixing the story and gameplay also it has the toy animatronics so yea what do you think of it so far.
Here is my rant on Dormitabis This has the MOST uglyist Gamejolt graphics I've ever seen and just lazily attaches a bunch of fan models and shapes together to reference Mangle also the voice acting is trash lines like "there was this hot 15 year old" doesn't add horror it just makes it gross now time for the main problem with this game and why it's hated. Like I've said about Chica by Mandopony I know that there are "hints" at love or sexuality i FNAF but it was always sub-texted like in Toy Chica's High School Years or in the background like Phone Dude talking about "making out in the corner" here they take away Springtrap's child and night guard murder aspect and just make him "the other guy" like Me and Cody Leach have said we go for the killers and the villains in these horror games,shows,and movies they are the main marketing it's impossible to turn someone into a beloved icon when he or she is "doing thing to kids" also I hate how Blackout just got off scott-free for commiting crimes like this in real life
Honestly for the original Dormitabis, the only real compliment I can give is golden calls design, I remember really loving his design, but his design in the remaster is just a lot better with glowing eyes and he has a better walk cycle, while the original wasn’t the worst (especially compared to cakebear) it didn’t seem very robotic.
As a guy who used to like the game that you put on number one I hate the game now not because of the game itself the game itself is actually not that bad it's not terrible but it's not great but it's because of its story and how it's tainted by the artist idea There is a thing called separate the artist from the game but I can't separate the artist from this game when literally one of its cutscenes is the purple guy dragging a girl into a storage room and we know what's probably going to happen because the guy who made the game is also one of those people so no I like everyone else in you I can't separate the game from its artists because the artist literally has his sick thoughts in this game screw number one like that game can go burn in hell.
You really can’t separate the art from the artist when the artists views and actions n such are baked into the text or whatever medium they make. Because then the art supports the artist. Which if you’re trying to separate then it shouldn’t do.
@@fritzy8318 that's what I meant like sometimes you can but in this case you can't the game is literally featuring things. He's into like well P******** like I would be able to separate it from the artist if it didn't feature things that are straight-up alluding to what he did it's sick and I can't enjoy a game that featured a thing that he enjoys in a sickly tone.
I loved Jnrs and Dormitabis,only fan games aside from TJOC to genuinely give me terrifying nightmares,they are 1 of the best fan games i've ever played
The one thing I kinda like about dormitabis is how the game handles the amount of animatronics in a night where some animatronics are on while others are not I'm not saying this game is good or anything like that I'm just saying the one thing that's decent about it
You know, i don't really understand why people say that the jumpscares in JR's suck. I mean, for me they actually work. I mean, the fact that they scream straight in your face rather than just attacking you in diferent ways according to their designs and other stuff is actually a really cool and creepy idea for the jumpscare animations in this kind of games. They just look way too realistic to me because of how they're made, it actually feels like they're screaming at you for real, and then proceed to murder you in cold blood, which is something that i kinda adore. Also, about the jumpscare noises. They're actually good! What the heck were you saying when you said that the jumpscare sound was bland? (I mean clearly you were referring to the previous jumpscare sound before the patches but still) The jumpscare sounds for me are fantastic, and they fit with the animatronics perfectly. And the fact that during Night 6 the jumpscare sound turns into the Fnaf 2 jumpscare sound but BETTER, is perfect! So. In summary, the jumpscares of this game are actually goo. Contrary to what you say, these jumpscares aren't bad! Now... This is just my opinion. And i'd kindly like to hear why you think the jumpscare animations in this game are bad for you. Be honest.
I have to agree with Jr's, when I first played it, I had to search a guide on how to find the ghost, after learning and making a strat, nights 2-5 were way too easy and I felt bored just playing, and night 6, while I found it fun, the ghost mechanic the was very confusing and too hard to balance with all that is happening that night, but past that, the game is good, overrated, but a b- game.
why was there's no content warning for Dormitabis like your Iceberg video like no warning that your gonna talk about subject matter that ether people don't want to hear about or worst might trigger or put stress on people that MIGHT been effected by those crimes you talked about
I feel like for a fan-game or a game in general I don’t mind if it has a dark theme about a character if it’s handled well and is written like the character is the bad person and in the wrong but the problem with Dormitabis is first the creator is a disgusting creep and literally told himself off with his game and second the game implies that is valid to do shit like that irl and kinda romanize it which he just expose himself
I agree that JR's is overrated but it's that bad I mean yeah the story doesn't make sense in a few places and yeah the mangle boss fight is terrible to say the least but the games normal gameplay it's not that bad at least give it credit it a brand new idea instead of the survive to 6 AM shtick So yeah it's not the best game but it's not the worst to be this high
Fun fact, during the development of dormitabis, I was contacted to do the voice of Garvey. Once I read the script I got out of the project. I was about 16-17 at the time I think, but I could do a good discount joker impression which the dev wanted. Glad I didn’t knowing what happened.
I spelled it wrong but you know, dumb name anyway lol
His original name for Garvey was actually Tom. At least that’s what was in the script I got
I remember Garvey’s VA said he altered lines to make it less… disturbing
Can you back his claim up?
@@PigBoy99 yea I have a whole email thread. Maybe I can make a video? If people would watch it.
I didn’t actually know the other VA, I never contacted them and I kinda stopped following the project after a while. The lines could have changed in that time though. But essentially, throughout the nights, “Tom” would admit to various crimes that he committed around Fazbears, including the SA line. This wasn’t in a script document or anything either keep in mind, this was just put into email, I’m sure that had I recorded the lines they might have added more or altered the script more. But I kinda noped out and used the excuse of school work (which was partially valid as I was about a junior maybe in high school at the time.)
I always found it creepy that Dormitabus practically tells you the developer controversy. Garvey is practically a spitting image of the offending developer, deviancy and all.
Some speculate that the reason Garvey was a pedo in the lore wasn’t Nicchi’s decision, but another’s devs decision to call out Nicchi
@@DjDeadpig oh god. That’d make it at least tolerable in the sense of not projecting shit the others into. But still repulsive given who it’s calling out and shit.
It's funny how Dormitabis went from one of Tyler's favorite fangames to one of her least favorites if not her least favorite.
Dormitabis is literally the personification of one of the most genuinely heartless and vile creators I’ve ever seen in my entire life
I know how you feel, and there's one of them still active unfortunately
My main gripe with JR’s is a lack of variety in the main gameplay loop. The 6 animatronics that you deal with function mostly the same. I think there should be at an animatronic that becomes active in the later nights (anywhere between night 2 or 4) to spice things up. There’s more problems the player has to juggle, which is more interesting than just increasing the AI difficulty each night.
Except balloon boy. Who has the most boring mechanic of all time.
My complaint is that it’s boring.
I think JR's creator should add:
-Phone calls each night
-Each night in 5 first night add an animatronic (1 night add 2 if there are 6 ones)
-Make an unique gameplay at night 6
-Change the story more logical
Then JR's may be much better than the version we have
Forgot to mention this, but in Dawko’s final Dormitabis video, at the news article about the 15-year-old, you can hear Blackout LAUGHING.
What?
@@Glaster6 what?
@@PigBoy99 i watched it and i dont think he does
@@PigBoy99what?
@@ecioyt804 you know what
The worst part about dormitabis is that in the extras if you go to havoc chica her description is: her arms describe the way she died, which is terrifying
Yes unfortunately we all know that by now.
Dormidabis being on top number 1, I can understand and totally agree regarding the controversy that is included in this game and also related to the game developer.
But JR's being on 2nd, I'm not buying what you have say about the gameplay, because I enjoyed it.
But that's just my opinion, please don't judge me.
I will admit, post-shift 2 is a pretty unfair game, but for some positives, the music was really good, creative mechanics, etc. I’m glad the dev is improving it to make it easier. Oh yea, dormitiabis is really fucking stupid and I can agree with that.
I hope he speeds up the walking animations a bit
1 thing im confused is when people say that the tutorials in fnaf fan games are vauge. But when you get games like post shift 2, who alphabet soups you what to do, it gives me a general confusion on how tutorials should be structured to make people happy
This video made you my new favorite RUclipsr and it’s when I found out how you feel about dormitabis and I actually feel the same way about that game and one thing me and you have in common is that we both have a grudge on both dormitabis and garvey
Even though I was banking on JR’s being #1, I’m glad it turned out to be Dormitabis because this game deserved it more and here’s why in my opinion. Even though I really don’t like JR’s (mostly because of Ramenov) it at least had good visuals and SOME people on the team who actually cared about the game being good while Dormitabis features unnecessary child rape in a FNaF fan-game which reflects how fucked up in the head its creator is.
AT LEAST for One Night at Flumpty’s, Jonochrome didn’t reflect his previous actions into his game and came out to sincerely apologise to everyone about his actions and respectfully left the internet and who knows if or when he’ll return. If he did then I’m not sure how I’d feel, even if I do still respect how he sorted out the situation at the time. Don’t know if it means he can just be allowed to come back on the internet and everything is “back to normal”.
(I hate to admit this but I had to type out most of this comment all over again because I refreshed the comments, I hate when this happens! 😭😭)
Great vid as always Tyler!
JR’s is far from being the worst but it’s not the best.
DORMIDABIS just crash EVERYTIMES and the story is HORRIBLE.!
I was expecting Dormitabas on here. I agree with you on all the wrong things about Jr's and Dormitabas. Thank God I'm more into FnaC, Popgoes, TJOC, and Final Nights than those 2 games that had their creators being horrible people.
Theres a meme about Emil Macko having killed a man, because hes the only Fanverse dev not to be embroiled in a major drama.
@@BlazingDiancie I know. I watched the fan games iceberg
Separate art from artists plz
Dormitibis I like
I love dormitabis
While I do agree with mac tonight 2 being a very bad fangame, the one I find worse than mac tonight 2 also made by malrat would have to be FNATI 2017, to me there's just a lot more problems than mac tonight 2 ever had, firstly, the ai is all over the place on how hard it is, by night 5 you'd be on the edge of your seat waiting for the next camera to pop up, secondly, the biggest one is how you cannot see much at all, the fog in the game is horrible in the cameras and office, looking for characters is just a pain, especially for pirate caverns, since you aren't given a clear indication on where you are going, you're stuck wondering around the place, and the second floor is the worst, undying does whatever the hell he wants, and it's the most darkest and hard to see places out of all of them in the game.
Another thing is the lack of, or no mechanics at all, I know that it is supposed to be a reboot/remake of the original game, but there's been many other games that have remade fnati that turned out great like radiance's for example, but this game has nothing much in it, the ambience sounds basic, the sounds are exactly the same, all you do is hide and shut off a camera, that is it, the only sorta new mechanic is with minnie, the problem, is just that it doesn't work at all, you're supposed to listen for complete silence, then go check for where she is and shut off the camera she's in, the problem is how you cannot tell what's ambience and what isn't, and most of the time, you'd end up dying to minnie because you thought she wasn't there.
I again personally think that while mac tongiht 2 is bad, FNATI 2017 takes the cake as being way worse than mac tonight 2, at least in mac tonight 2, there were some things that made it unique or somewhat enjoyable even for it's badness, but FNATI 2017 just doesn't have that, whatsoever
5.) Five Nights with Mac Tonight 2
4.) Post-Shift 2
3.) Five Nights at Candy’s 2
2.) Jr’s
1.) Dormitabis
Damn they turned into Eminem when they hit dormitabis
Now that you mention it, your right.
How the fuck did a knife hurt that ghost girl? Why is she haunting the restaurant?
I was so focused on the designs of the animatronics, that I accidentally overlooked the plot holes of Jr's.
I actually really liked JR'S. But I'm really happy that we have the opposite opinion. There are so many errors in the game design and so on in the game but no one is talking about it. (What do you think of fnaf plus? )
I love how FNaF Plus is lookin' so far!
I dont think dormitabis is " THE WORST FNAF FANGAME OF ALL TIME "
this game has some great ideas, the graphics are bad but in the same time nostalgic, golden freddy be the phone guy bit at the same time crying child is pretty cool, the ambience of this game is just: YOU COME HERE FOR YOUR REAL SUFFERING
Yes: blackout is a terrible person
And: dormitabis remake unofficial and dormitabis remastered is coming soon
This game is nostalgic for me
I hate and Love this game at the same time
Honestly I think Dormetibis is probably the worst FNAF fan game of all time just for what it represents as a whole. Shit's rotten to the core.
Dormitabis is getting a semi-official remaster. It's under a new dev so along as it's in better hands I'm fine with it.
Remaster will be way better than the original game for sure.
I just realized how similar fnac 2 is to the classic version of fnati
1. Mechanics revolving around cameras and audio
2. Abandoned characters and person going to an abandoned location
3. and finally: Half assed jumpscares
but at least fnati 1.0 being bland and kinda bad is ok as it was almost one of the 1st fnaf fan games
I would not be surprised if Dormitbius is in this video (cause of the infamous scene and the creator being really horrible).
Edit: Yep, I was right. That game 100% deserves to be considered the worst FNAF fangame.
Who?
OH right, I forgot about Dormitabis. I learnt about it from gomotion's video, but I never saw it again afterwards. Is it that bad?
You called it!
@@ryanlally8116 It had a part where William Alfton (named something else, I forgot what though) r*ping the girl who became Chica (I know it was off-screen, but they still explained it in like graphic detail I think). It was then revealed that the creator was a p*dophile and n*crophile.
@@MontyMoleLoreMaster Holy cannoli
I know I already commented this on uhyeah’s video on Dormitabis, but I somehow managed to reach Night 8 of Dormitabis before quitting. Looking back (especially knowing the creator’s messed up actions), I”m glad I did.
The original dormitabis was terrible and just in general disgusting, but luckily dormitabis remastered is supposes to be better and changed the story and everything. Its by a completely different development team blackout isnt involved with it in anyway (thank god) the new development team is expelled studios. They also changed the terrible cringy tapes
Surprisingly the remaster have one of the best stories and voice acting from any fangame
Ok im not gonna sugarcoat my statement, while FNIA failed at being a Parody FNAF Fan-Game cuz of how it tries really hard to be 18+; Dormitabis on the other hand failed along crash and burning to the ground at being a actual scary FNAF Fan-Game for the reasons following:
• Nicchi being a downright abuser to those that worked for him (especially being revealed as a P-Bear)
•The Presentation, while taking place in a alt timeline of FNAF 3, feels mid in a few places
•The Gameplay is one massive clusterfunk when trying to hide from the Havoc Animatronics, looking at the camera, finding the Keys & Tapes, & it has 11 nights along a secret 12th night that requires the player to click on AMIREAL's nose really fast just to gain access (oh, and Peter Write doesn't explain how to deal with the Havoc Animatronics, IN WHICH MEANS YOU HAVE TO GO BACK TO THE BEGINNING AND CHECK THE INSTRUCTIONS)
•The Havoc Animatronics design being uninspired along their motivation of getting ectoplasm out of John Write in which is mainly stuffing him into a Animatronic Suit cuz FNAF 1 did that (Golden Call can eat a fricken brick due to how difficult he is to deal with)
•While a neat concept, The Cardboard Theatre is also a massive clusterfunk to complete as it requires the player to be fast as heck while getting both keys to unlock the True Ending (especially when mary is gonna get Garvey'd)
•Speaking of Garvey, his Boss Night is just unbearable to complete as there is a 50/50 chance he'll kill you if you don't make it back to your starting position & the fact that he is Nicchi's Self Insert, just ruins this game altogether (& the fact that his Backstory is a School Shooter-equse dumpster fire which is a very, very, very idiotic idea full stop).
The only saving grace there is to this game is the fact that some people are remaking this game without Nicchi's Involvement (hopefully they can fix everything else about this fangame).
Yet people will try to go the "separate art from artist" path, it's sad in a way.
"I wanna look at different shit, not the same shit."
Honestly this could be one of the best quotes of the year lol
I literally called that dormitabis would be on the list because of nicchi
I bet Nichhi's favorite movie is Cuties
@@Zebra_fandomfella03 No smarter words can describe how right that sounds
literally glad the person whom tried to groom me (Nicchi) didnt get the full love he doesnt deserve.
i was contacted to voice act the fucking 15 year old screaming, yeah, i said fuck no.
Good job for declining that sick bastard
Source?
Just because they look amazing, doesn't mean they're actually good and that's a fact over the years.
I was hoping Dormitabis would be somewhere on this list, especially the number 1 spot
As a fan of Dormitabis, Garvey makes it really hard for me to like the game. Hopefully the remake removes that aspect and redoes the textures.
Given the large amount of love these games still receive to this day shows that it's really a matter of opinion, but what the maker of Dormitabis did should be omitted from a remaster and left to fade.
I still remember the good old days of the old top 5 best fnaf fan games video, with Tyler praising Dormitabis unironically
I really don’t like Jr’s and it is so so overrated but I don’t think it is one of the worst fnaf fan games
Man, i used to love Dormitibus when it first came out, everything from the look and animatronics, even the gameplay felt admitably clunky but like it could be polished to make a really fun fangame, with some oddly detailed lore but still, interesting to see just how deperaved and psychotic the killer was up close like that. But nowadays, hearing how everybody absolutely hates the guts out of the dev (For a VERY good reason, holy hell i did not realize just how horrible he was until this) and hearing opinions on it seem to be universally hated almost, im curious if the remake is going to be able to bring that old spark back from when i first saw the game...its got an uphill battle for sure
Alright, I know this doesn't have much to do with the video, but I have some ( in my opinion) interesting ideas for FNAF fangames. I would make them, but I don't have a PC. Here they are:
•Bon's Burgers (This fangame would be based on The Walten Files and would be a mix between standard FNAF style gameplay and old school point-and-click horror games. It would also be 2D. I got the idea from the fact that The Walten Files was initially going to be a game. If I did develop this, the main problem developing would be making the gameplay work and the story at least okay.)
•Fear of Fur (This would be like Animator's Hell where it's multiple people from a community as the antagonists. However, instead of people from the FNAF animation community, it would be notable furries in the Furry Fandom and characters that are popular with furries like characters from Zootopia and Beastars. This idea mainly comes from my somewhat involvement in the community and the fact that I think that a lot of characters in the Fandom would make for great and interesting character designs for a FNAF game. The main problem developing this game would be the matter of using the popular furries. I feel like they might be fine, but a lot of FNAF fans might go to them and bug them about Five Nights at Freddy's.)
•Pooh's Corner (Based off of a real show that used to air on Disney Channel. It would involve the player fending off against Winnie the Pooh characters in the set of the show. This is a lot like many fangames based off of kids shows. The main problem would be making the characters from Winnie the Pooh creepy (especially Rabbit since I could see it being easy accidentally making him a Glitchtrap clone).)
•Fanverse Custom Night (Basically Ultimate Custom Night but with less enemies and the enemies consist of characters from games included in the Fanverse initiative. Not much to say. The main problem would be finding a way to make the mechanics flow together well.)
I could not think of that much fangames based off of fully original ideas, so these are the ideas I have. That's really all I have to say.
Again, nothing to do with the video, I just wanted to share these.
My biggest qualm with jr’s was with the animatronic designs. Not that they were bad, god no they were great, but that they were simply underused. These designs were hyped to hell and back before the game’s release, but when the game came out, you really couldn’t see them. The cameras are too dark and dirty to clearly make out the designs, and in the back room you see a headless version of them, only for a few seconds before the ghost is back to haunting another robot.
I wanted to actually SEE these designs in game. I wanted to see them up close, I wanted to see them move through the office, to get to see their creepiness. But no.
And night 6 gives us almost completely different designs that once again, due to the environment, are not allowed to shine as much as they could. It’s a really disappointing use of wonderful models in my opinion. They could’ve done more, and this extends to the lore as well (seriously who tf are we playing as???)
I think Dormitabis was trying to go for the same look as FNAF 3, although there’s a big difference in that FNAF 3 doesn’t give me a headache. I’m not kidding about that ether, the animation for crawling under the desk in particular gave me a headache.
As for JRs, I like the normal gameplay due to the investigation aspect of figuring out which one is possessed, but the night 6 and the other complaints I agree with.
Honestly, Trtf2 rebuilt should’ve been here as the new number 1. It’s developer is a complete asshole and the game is an unbalanced unfaithful remake of an already poorly aged game. The animatronic designs also don’t fit in with the trtf universe. Say what you will about Tyler Ahlstrom, at least he released 4 four games in a year and was a one man army, Kiilsto (the new dev) harassed and bullied his own staff and cut some of the best parts of his game out to get the game out as quickly as possible.
Yea to be honest I’d probably put return to Freddy’s 1 as number 1 worst just because it used stolen assets, at least Dormitabis used it’s own for better or for worse, it probably be on my number 2 for how in hindsight how poorly it’s aged (especially the story and the horrific actions Garvey committed on a 15 year old). Also some things blackout is into and has done really doesn’t help its case either.
JRs is just boring mechanically. It's basically FNAF among us.
Honestly I would say the same for JR'S, not because of gameplay, but by how ''The Pear'' stole assets and ideas from Popgoes: Arcade
One of my problems with JRS is the issue I have with what we've seen for FNAF+. The designs are trying to hard
FNIA may be weird and a bit gross but at the end day it’s nothing harmful and the game’s creator likes HOGGGGGG RIDAAAA. Dormitabas is…you get it,and the creator of Dormitabas doesn’t like HOGGGG RIDAAA so instant L
its funny how most of the games in this list are the sequels to original games
Love how you went from loving dormitabis to absolutely despising it
Honestly, I want to see you play Project Readjusted 3 and hear your thoughts about it.
You can talk shit about the Creator all you want.
Dormitabis was one of my favorite fan games back in the day, but now it's hard looking at it.
Or thinking about it.
Honestly I found dormitabis to be kinda fun just wish Garvey wasn’t a self insert
Your thoughts on Jrs are very similar to mine, the only thing that differs is our opinions on the main nights. I personally loved the Guess who idea behind the gameplay. Never finished the game because of how annoying night 6 was so I don't know if that crap gets any better post main story.
I'd honestly have to agree on Jr's, it is highly overrated
Gameplay is dull, the story is poorly written, and while it may sound scary on paper, the execution was just, well, a horror game that tries to be scary but fails
I used to love Dormitabis when it was realesed i loved how the game had gore wich i personally think what fnaf should really have but now I can't even play the game anymore after I find out what Nicchi did and thinking that Garvey the main antagonist of the game was a self inter of Nicchi imself it's just disguting
I 100% agree with the number one spot
Dormitabis can burn in the fiery pits of hell
Still remember Taste Gaming (a kids youtuber) played Dormitabis and said it was one of the best fangames he’d ever played
Uh ooooohhhh
Seriously though, when I learnt what happened I was done with Dormitabis. It was always a guilty pleasure fangame of mine and I’d even had permission to use some chars from it in a (now-cancelled) fangame. But now that I know what really happened… yikes.
Even though FNIA is just weird (or bad to certain people despite remakes being a thing along me and my twin bros planned one aswell), yea.......... these fan games are just downright terrible.
Dormidabis is way worst for litteraly hidding the weird stuff.
Specially for the dev for not changing his minds.
9:43 how Tyler became one my favorite RUclipsrs
I'm happy you have Tyler as one of your favorites
Just genuinely curious...
What is your favourite five nights with Mac tonight game and why?
Mine is fnwmt 1 remastered, I think simplicity goes a long way.
Mac Tonight 3, it's been a while but I really like the gameplay and atmosphere
Oooh you had some hot takes, I can feel the gamer rage emanating from the masses
I din’t think Post-Shift 2 is a bad game. If the rng and difficulty was balanced, and if the movement animations were sped up, Post-Shift 2 would be a solid game at least for Part A.
Great video! It's nice to hear ur opinions on these games. Hopefully there will be a part 3 for this series. Ohh and also. Dormitabis and nicchi sucks!
Im glad Dormitabis got a remake
I'd assume the ghost girl is able to be hit by the knife because its a weird purgatory knife because theyre in purgagory at that time??? idk I'm just trying to think of a logical reason
Jrs is only popular because it has amazing visuals. We all wanted the FNAF characters to actually look like old animatronics from the 70s and 80s.
tylerland264 have you hear the jr's dlc is coming this year it planes on fixing the story and gameplay also it has the toy animatronics so yea what do you think of it so far.
Here is my rant on Dormitabis
This has the MOST uglyist Gamejolt graphics I've ever seen and just lazily attaches a bunch of fan models and shapes together to reference Mangle also the voice acting is trash lines like "there was this hot 15 year old" doesn't add horror it just makes it gross now time for the main problem with this game and why it's hated. Like I've said about Chica by Mandopony I know that there are "hints" at love or sexuality i FNAF but it was always sub-texted like in Toy Chica's High School Years or in the background like Phone Dude talking about "making out in the corner" here they take away Springtrap's child and night guard murder aspect and just make him "the other guy" like Me and Cody Leach have said we go for the killers and the villains in these horror games,shows,and movies they are the main marketing it's impossible to turn someone into a beloved icon when he or she is "doing thing to kids" also I hate how Blackout just got off scott-free for commiting crimes like this in real life
Honestly for the original Dormitabis, the only real compliment I can give is golden calls design, I remember really loving his design, but his design in the remaster is just a lot better with glowing eyes and he has a better walk cycle, while the original wasn’t the worst (especially compared to cakebear) it didn’t seem very robotic.
Im really think that the gril that garvey you know,was shadow bonnie,because her was killed in fredbear,so hide her body in springbonnie
Susie is literally chicas canon child name.
So you’re wrong. Shadow Bonnie does not have a canonical child name. Further disproving your point.
Im saying molten evil its the girl and not havoc chica
Im saying the shadow bonnie that is in dormitabis named molten evil
Im saying this from dormitabis,not fnaf crazy lore
I honestly love dormitabis I don’t see much wrong with the game (besides the developer)
I actually really like Dormitabus but I will say that developer and story story is awful
I do remember another game with some sort of dog and 2 wolves, it was free roam and had aesthetics like the final hours games
jrs is alright but you can barely tell when the lights are flickering which sucks
9:37 well the remaster now exists, and unlike the original, the remaster is more fun and isn't so offensive
Fun fact: I was able to practically cheese the final boss of jrs by just mask camping… on my second ever attempt.
I can't honestly say I agree with you with you're jr's. Though I see why and can understand.
As a guy who used to like the game that you put on number one I hate the game now not because of the game itself the game itself is actually not that bad it's not terrible but it's not great but it's because of its story and how it's tainted by the artist idea
There is a thing called separate the artist from the game but I can't separate the artist from this game when literally one of its cutscenes is the purple guy dragging a girl into a storage room and we know what's probably going to happen because the guy who made the game is also one of those people so no I like everyone else in you I can't separate the game from its artists because the artist literally has his sick thoughts in this game screw number one like that game can go burn in hell.
You really can’t separate the art from the artist when the artists views and actions n such are baked into the text or whatever medium they make. Because then the art supports the artist. Which if you’re trying to separate then it shouldn’t do.
@@fritzy8318 that's what I meant like sometimes you can but in this case you can't the game is literally featuring things. He's into like well P******** like I would be able to separate it from the artist if it didn't feature things that are straight-up alluding to what he did it's sick and I can't enjoy a game that featured a thing that he enjoys in a sickly tone.
The JR’s models look good, the gameplay is just not fun lol
You wanna know what's the worst fnaf fan game? (Or well, Rip-off) All the FNAF games made by digi-chain games
I loved Jnrs and Dormitabis,only fan games aside from TJOC to genuinely give me terrifying nightmares,they are 1 of the best fan games i've ever played
The one thing I kinda like about dormitabis is how the game handles the amount of animatronics in a night where some animatronics are on while others are not I'm not saying this game is good or anything like that I'm just saying the one thing that's decent about it
Real i only like in jr's the animatronics Appearance but rest is overrated and gameplay is very borning
You know, i don't really understand why people say that the jumpscares in JR's suck. I mean, for me they actually work.
I mean, the fact that they scream straight in your face rather than just attacking you in diferent ways according to their designs and other stuff is actually a really cool and creepy idea for the jumpscare animations in this kind of games. They just look way too realistic to me because of how they're made, it actually feels like they're screaming at you for real, and then proceed to murder you in cold blood, which is something that i kinda adore.
Also, about the jumpscare noises. They're actually good!
What the heck were you saying when you said that the jumpscare sound was bland? (I mean clearly you were referring to the previous jumpscare sound before the patches but still) The jumpscare sounds for me are fantastic, and they fit with the animatronics perfectly. And the fact that during Night 6 the jumpscare sound turns into the Fnaf 2 jumpscare sound but BETTER, is perfect!
So. In summary, the jumpscares of this game are actually goo. Contrary to what you say, these jumpscares aren't bad!
Now... This is just my opinion. And i'd kindly like to hear why you think the jumpscare animations in this game are bad for you. Be honest.
Atleast Emil macko made a good 1st game
Man. Jr's had so much potential. If it had the same visuals, but it had different gameplay and an improved story, it would go so hard!
I thought Jr's was actually a pretty good game. It was just the developer.
I have to agree with Jr's, when I first played it, I had to search a guide on how to find the ghost, after learning and making a strat, nights 2-5 were way too easy and I felt bored just playing, and night 6, while I found it fun, the ghost mechanic the was very confusing and too hard to balance with all that is happening that night, but past that, the game is good, overrated, but a b- game.
why was there's no content warning for Dormitabis like your Iceberg video like no warning that your gonna talk about subject matter that ether people don't want to hear about or worst might trigger or put stress on people that MIGHT been effected by those crimes you talked about
forgot about this one, also wouldnt it be A FACT if the creator of dormatibis's real name was garvey?
To be honest, I never understood the appeal of JR's
I feel like for a fan-game or a game in general I don’t mind if it has a dark theme about a character if it’s handled well and is written like the character is the bad person and in the wrong but the problem with Dormitabis is first the creator is a disgusting creep and literally told himself off with his game and second the game implies that is valid to do shit like that irl and kinda romanize it which he just expose himself
Damn The Dormitabis Lore Slaps Hard
can I still love dormitabis I hate blackout and the story but I love the graphics.
I like how the first 3 are sequels
dormitabis lore 💀💀
Putting Jr's on this list will give you 7 years bad luck
No
He's right jr's is overrated
Bruh it's just his opinion
This just got recommended to me off a random non fnaf video lmao idk who u are but this video is on blowup watch
I agree that JR's is overrated but it's that bad I mean yeah the story doesn't make sense in a few places and yeah the mangle boss fight is terrible to say the least but the games normal gameplay it's not that bad at least give it credit it a brand new idea instead of the survive to 6 AM shtick
So yeah it's not the best game but it's not the worst to be this high
😐
I don’t like dormitabais it is the worst fanf fan game of all time in my opinion
Dormitabis? More like, DorMIDabis! Gottem!
Tyler you are good RUclipsr
I didn't know that the last fnaf fan game was about a disgusting creator thanks for that and he's disgusting
wait...WHAT??!?!?!?!? this is best fnaf fangame is FNAF JR but WHY THIS IS WORST FNAF GAME!!!!!