비긴어스보니까 바람이 분다는 부르기 어려워하는것같았는데 유희열이랑 윤도현이 여러번 설득해서불렀음. 그 어렵다는 뜻이 음을 충분히 못낸다는게 아니라 이소라씨에게 이 곡은 자신이 겪은 경험을 그대로 쓴데다가 노래는 음을 내는것이아니라 생각이라고 말 할 정도인것을 보면 ...아무래도 내 생각엔 이소라씨가 이 노래를 주저하는게 가사속의 그 가슴시린경험을 떠올리면서 감정을 잡고 불러야 하기때문이라고 느낌. 그때 그 이별의 경험으로 시간여행처럼 가서 생생하게 아팠던 감정에 잠겨야만 하니 이소라씨가 표정이 어두울수밖에없고 화음을 넣는다던지하는 "기교"는 상상도 못할듯. 비긴어스를 통해 본 이소라씨는 슬픈척 이별한척 항구다 없고 이 노래를 부르려면 이별당시 힘들고 아픈 일을 떠올려야만 음을 낼수있는 사람이었음. 왜냐면 노래는 생각이라고 했기때문임
아무래도 이소라님 만의 감성과 깊이를 따라잡을수는 없겠지요.. 저도 참 좋아하는 곡인데.. 들을때마다 따라부를때마다 가슴저리는곡이예요.. 세분 다 잘 부르시지만.. 잘 부른다는 느낌이 크지.. 저 곡을 잘 해석한다는 느낌은;;;게다가 저 곡은 기교를 넣기엔 조심스럽고 미안함마저드는걸요;;
The sailor guy (Mingwan) was so underrated. Loved his performance so much, appreciate him moreeeee. But then again, Hwanji (Bogumi in Green) was incredibly talented, full of emotion and charisma. And don't forget Jungsu's (Andong Musician) range was breathtaking. Huhuhu. They're all great!
The guy in green shirt got the best emotion and interpretation. He was like a story-teller. The sailor guy had the best technique among them three. He even supported or maybe resonanced that B4 omg. And the guy in white outfit reached as high as D5 on his belting and arguably got the widest vocal range.
Everyone is talking about the Green and White people. While i was impressed by the Sailor dude. That 3:22-3:29 is not easy to do. And that long note with consistency is very beautiful 4:06-4:17. This dude is very underrated. He deserves more praise.
lee mingwan's voice is so resonant. his notes were so free and he didn't sound like he had any tension. he's very talented and i hope he continues singing!
Thank you. Yes, I'm from NYC. This is the second song I saw performed with a song of hers and was BLOWN AWAY without knowing the lyrics in English. I will Google her and listen to more of her songs. I will also try and find the lyrics in English. I recently have been exposed to these beautiful artist on youtube, and I have to say that I am excited to hear more, of all these BEAUTIFUL, CLASSY, and TALENTED artist that are coming from KOREA!!!! Wow, smh😊
Lee Sora is a very famous singer who sings from the heart. She's a very delicate, sensitive, and vulnerable singer. I'm surprised you know her! Some of her signature songs include Application, The Wind Is Blowing, Remember Me, and I'm Happy. She also sang several songs on a program called Biggest Gain (where she travels around the world busking). I'm not sure if it's available in English, but if you paste in "비긴어게인 이소라" you'll see several videos. Have a great day!
I really like Andong musician and I personally think his voice suits her voice more, not to mention the way he sings is very emotional!!! It's so bad he didn't win as I think he is better than Bo Geum's best friend.
The title of this song is 'The Wind Is Blowing'. It is a song about the absence of a person who she loved. Everyone who sang on the stage deserve more praise!
He's definitely a excellent singer, but I feel like he was straining his voice a little bit... maybe it's just his timbre, a little raspy, throaty... I think he would be a perfect rock/metal singer, not a balladeer... I don't know if he's a natural tenor just straining his voice a bit, the volume of his voice seemed to strain his voice a little, or if he's a baritone forcing a high falsetto... nevertheless, I think he should train professionally to perfect the technique, he has an amazing potential, even without being able to hear on one side, Beethoven was deft when he made his greatest compositions...
Once again I am stocking my oppa with the white shirt hehehehe. Wow hes so dreamy. I really enjoyed it. Very romantic and emotional performance by these singers, but oppa stood out the most when he sings. Oppa can you sing me to sleep everyday ♥♥♥
![이수지 - 바람이 분다 [불후의 명곡2 전설을 노래하다/Immortal Songs 2] | KBS 231216 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PT_AG3U32Xk/mqdefault.jpg)
시험준비할때 고시원으로 돌아가며 이노래 들으며 많이 울었는데 나만 혼자 동떨어져 있는 기분, 시린 마음을 너무나 잘 알아주는것 같아서 ㅠㅠ 이소라 팬분들 감성 최고네. 일반인이 감정선을 건드리네
힘내세요
과거형으로 말씀하시는거 보니 지금은 잘 되셨을 듯하네요^^
저도 참 고시원 독서실에서 많이 울었네요
새벽에 책상에 앉아서 원없이 울고 ㅎㅎ
붙음? 아니면 찐따같이 포기함?
비긴어스보니까 바람이 분다는 부르기 어려워하는것같았는데 유희열이랑 윤도현이 여러번 설득해서불렀음. 그 어렵다는 뜻이 음을 충분히 못낸다는게 아니라 이소라씨에게 이 곡은 자신이 겪은 경험을 그대로 쓴데다가 노래는 음을 내는것이아니라 생각이라고 말 할 정도인것을 보면 ...아무래도 내 생각엔 이소라씨가 이 노래를 주저하는게 가사속의 그 가슴시린경험을 떠올리면서 감정을 잡고 불러야 하기때문이라고 느낌. 그때 그 이별의 경험으로 시간여행처럼 가서 생생하게 아팠던 감정에 잠겨야만 하니 이소라씨가 표정이 어두울수밖에없고 화음을 넣는다던지하는 "기교"는 상상도 못할듯. 비긴어스를 통해 본 이소라씨는 슬픈척 이별한척 항구다 없고 이 노래를 부르려면 이별당시 힘들고 아픈 일을 떠올려야만 음을 낼수있는 사람이었음. 왜냐면 노래는 생각이라고 했기때문임
ㅇㅈ 3:56 기교듣고 이소라 살짝 짜증남ㅋㅋ
이노래는 기교없이 맑고깨끗한 목소리로 불렀을때 더 와닿는 노래라고 생각
돈에 팔리는 느낌 들었을 것 같아요.
아무래도 이소라님 만의 감성과 깊이를 따라잡을수는 없겠지요.. 저도 참 좋아하는 곡인데.. 들을때마다 따라부를때마다 가슴저리는곡이예요.. 세분 다 잘 부르시지만.. 잘 부른다는 느낌이 크지.. 저 곡을 잘 해석한다는 느낌은;;;게다가 저 곡은 기교를 넣기엔 조심스럽고 미안함마저드는걸요;;
그랬군요
이 노랠 들을때마다
걍
침묵이~~
걍
이노래에
흠뻑
빠지는
매력이
있어요
@@pawn4840 ㅋㅋ 노래가사 생각하면 도저히 나올수 없는 기교였음 오오우예 ㅋㅋ 이별감정나락찍고 체념의 단계인데 오우우예 라니
The sailor guy (Mingwan) was so underrated. Loved his performance so much, appreciate him moreeeee. But then again, Hwanji (Bogumi in Green) was incredibly talented, full of emotion and charisma. And don't forget Jungsu's (Andong Musician) range was breathtaking. Huhuhu. They're all great!
I literally cry when sailor guy did a duet with lena park 😭
He was technically the best
Indeed! All of them are great like if i were there i'll choose 3 of them for the finals! Lol
@@atiqahh8049 where i can watch it ?
@@itajuliani589 ruclips.net/video/hDJ7zjNjk-s/видео.html they win this episode
This lady, her reaction to the singers is truly humbling. She looks so deeply touched by them.
The guy in green shirt got the best emotion and interpretation. He was like a story-teller. The sailor guy had the best technique among them three. He even supported or maybe resonanced that B4 omg. And the guy in white outfit reached as high as D5 on his belting and arguably got the widest vocal range.
These 3 needs to debut as one group asap. Andong celebrity is really talented. 😨
Yes Andong celebrity verry talented
They are killing me 😭😭😭😭😭😍😍😍
이소라 목소리 진짜 좋구나
그냥 저 셋을 묶어서 그룹을 만들면 되겠는데
초록 티셔츠 입고 계신 분은 뮤지컬 배우 조환지 님입니다! 데뷔한지 3년 정도 되셨는데 벌써 주연 맡고 계세요.
어쩐지..
딱 뮤지컬에 어울리는 창법이긴해
팬텀싱어에 나오신분 맞나요?
@@dracoluciusmalfoy0905 네, 맞습니다.
남자 세 분 다 무슨 목소리가 저렇게 좋을까요..ㄷㄷ 진짜 너무너무 잘한다..이소라님은 뭐 말할 것도 없구요..그저 갓이죠..
Green sweater's facial expressions on point
박보감절친 가사 전달력이며 표정이며 발성이며 정말 완벽하다! 뮤지컬하면 진짜 잘하실것같당!! 안동분 음색진짜 좋고! 특히 고음 짱... 뽀빠이분은 이 음악과 너무 어울린다 인생을 노래하는 깊은 울림이 느껴진다..
뮤지컬 배우이세요!!!ㅎㅎ
근데 진짜 셋이 그룹으로 데뷔했어도 됐겠다
뭔가 목소리 합이 맞네
이 노래는 정말 감동적이에요, 들을 때마다 너무 아름다워서 울고 싶어요! ❤
Wow that was an amazing performance, green and white shirt guy was incredible, I think he has had classical vocal training.
He sings musical. Well done!
H Chan His vibrato and tone are perfection and so easy to the ears.
Yes. Agree. Love his interpretation and also facial expressions. 👍👍👏👏
Does anyone know "green shirt guy"'s name?
Dr Doc his name Ji Hwan
Everyone is talking about the Green and White people. While i was impressed by the Sailor dude. That 3:22-3:29 is not easy to do. And that long note with consistency is very beautiful 4:06-4:17. This dude is very underrated. He deserves more praise.
안동 시내 스타 진짜 잘했어요.
느낌와 목소리를 좋아해요.
셋다 어메이징.. 감동 폭발이다.. 누구가 더 잘한다고 말하기 어렵게 셋다 너무 너무 너무 잘한다.
감성을 재대로 건드려주는 화음에 눈물이 한없이 흐릅니다. 정말 사랑해요 판듀~그리고 이소라님 자주 보고싶어요. 감사합니다.
lee mingwan's voice is so resonant. his notes were so free and he didn't sound like he had any tension. he's very talented and i hope he continues singing!
Watched it a million times since 2018 and now 2024 excellent performance just wow.
the white and green sweater really sing with the heart...that makes him stand out
Korean songs are so very emotional and heartbreaking...Singers are also fantastic...
이소라님 서버점검하는 날에는 방송에 좀 자주 나와주세요~
I say that these three form a group together after this because gah damn their voices are amazing together
ugghh i can't get enough of this song, i'm always watching this performance for about 20x per day? my ghadd
뽀빠이 훌륭하다
노래 계속하면 좋겠다
화이팅
세명 모두 멋있어
우리나라에 노래 잘 하는 사람 정말 많다. 감동.
I AGREE ❤
영어 댓글이 더 많아서 당황한 1인....
Lee Sora deserves more recognitionnnn
뽀빠이가 젤 좋네
My personal favourite is Andong Celebrity, but whoever she chose, makes a Fantastic Duo!!
Bo Gums best friend,if she sang ''Please'' as her final song she would've won,it's such a powerful song
환지는 뮤지컬 테너네 그냥....
현 뮤지컬 배우 맞아요.
The guy in black sung flawlessly pure talent 🥰
노래를 잘해도 실력이 좋아도 이 노래에 우~예~~~~ 같은 애드리브는 넣으면 안됩니다.
니가 뭔데
@@아그작-v1g 언니 멋져 (?)
@@08_handyr 오빠다
@@아그작-v1g 오빠 멋져 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ (( 그래서 일부로 ? 이거 했습니닦
ㄹㅇ 니가 뭔데??
이 노래가 공중파 음악방송에서 불렀던 방송에서 마디마다 소절마다 다른 격한 감정이 느껴져서 놀라고 신기했던 기억이 있는데 잘못 기억하나. 원래의 원곡을 뛰어넘기 힘든 곡이 이노래가 아닌가싶다. 박효신콘서트에서 이소라님 직접나온 바람이 분다도 최애
이민관님 성장하시면 발라드계의
한 족보를 이루실 겁니다.누가 뭐래도
본인 목소리에는 혼이 있습니다.
조용필샘의 길을 참조하시길.
이소라님 노래는 들으면 괜히 눈물나는게 아님 진짜 보이스 하나로 다 표현이됨 ㅜㅜ
박보검친구분은 뮤지컬톤~ 감성이 풍부하신듯
외국 댓글들이 많이 보이는데 이소라 가수님의 시를 쓰듯 곱고 섬세한 문장들을 모른 채 이 노래를 감상한다는 게 너무 아쉬워요ㅠ
이소라 가수님의 노래가 마음에 와닿는 이유 중 하나는 노래에 엄청난 몰입도 몰입이겠지만 섬세하고 민감한 표현력 때문인데요.
Thank you. Yes, I'm from NYC. This is the second song I saw performed with a song of hers and was BLOWN AWAY without knowing the lyrics in English. I will Google her and listen to more of her songs. I will also try and find the lyrics in English. I recently have been exposed to these beautiful artist on youtube, and I have to say that I am excited to hear more, of all these BEAUTIFUL, CLASSY, and TALENTED artist that are coming from KOREA!!!! Wow, smh😊
Lee Sora is a very famous singer who sings from the heart. She's a very delicate, sensitive, and vulnerable singer. I'm surprised you know her! Some of her signature songs include Application, The Wind Is Blowing, Remember Me, and I'm Happy. She also sang several songs on a program called Biggest Gain (where she travels around the world busking). I'm not sure if it's available in English, but if you paste in "비긴어게인 이소라" you'll see several videos. Have a great day!
I really like Andong musician and I personally think his voice suits her voice more, not to mention the way he sings is very emotional!!! It's so bad he didn't win as I think he is better than Bo Geum's best friend.
I don't know... I think his voice would be better for rock music rather than for ballads... just my opinion.
이 노래를 이런 좋은 남자목소리로 불러주신 세 분 멋집니다......
No matter how many times I hear this, it it so beautiful and emotional.
Gorgeous does not begin to describe the beauty of this performance. Wow!!! 😵
The title of this song is 'The Wind Is Blowing'. It is a song about the absence of a person who she loved. Everyone who sang on the stage deserve more praise!
이소라 감성...참...
Ese don coreano es hermoso. De eso hace falta mucha exposición en América desde hace unos años. Me encantan sus voces.
Listen here these boys need to be in agroup okay because of how different their voices are and yet when they sing together its soo beautiful!!!!
Okay, I have a crush on that guy wearing that Green/White sweater. Sorry, not sorry.
same same same. i didn't think i could fall in love with someone over a video
조환지씨는 뮤지컬 배우이신가요?
가사 전달이 탁월하네요. 한편의 연극을 본 기분~
이노래.. 나는가수다 첫편 1번타자 이소라님이 나왔을 때. 이소라님 잘 몰라서 뭐 전설이라고? 어디 한번 보자! 라며 팔괴고 보다가 노래듣다 처음 울었음 이 노래는 이분들이 잘 부르는데도 이런 기교보다 이소라님 목소리가 더 어울림
Hiç bıkmadan usanmadan dinliyorum...
너무 잘부르는데 ㅜㅜ 원곡을 찾게 되네 ㅜㅜ
세명의 마음속 :: 이소라 선생님. 최선을 다해서 불렀습니다. 하지만 더 잘할 수 있습니다.
이 곡은 다른 목소리가 들어가면 안 되는 곡이다
주접 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
listening to this is one of the most goose bumping experiences I've ever had
너무다잘함 너무 진짜 가수같고 대단함
근데 듣는나는 아무느낌이없음...
눈물을 간신히 참고 사력을 다해서 부르는 모습이 보이네요.
Barami bunda
Seoreoun maeume
Teong bin punggyeongi buleo onda
Meorireul jareugo
Doraoneun girae
Nae naegeul sseongideon
nunmureul ssotneunda
Haneuli jeotneunda
Eodoun georie
Chan bitbanguli tteoleojinda
Murireul jieumyeo
Ttaraoneun bineun
Naegeseo meon geot gata
Imi geuchin geot gata
Sesangeun eojewa gatgo
Siganeun heureugo itgo
Naman honja ireohke dallajyeo itda
Barame heuteojyeo beorin
Heomuhan nae suwandeureun
Aetage
Sarajyeoganda
Barami bunda
Sirin hangi soge
Jinan siganeul dwidollinda
Yereum kkeute seon
Neoui dwitmomseubi
Chagawotdeon geot gata
Da al geot gata
Naegeneun so junghaetdeon
Jam mot irudeon naldeuri
Neoegen jigeumgwa dareuji anhatda
Sarangeun bigeugieora
Geudaeneun naega anida
Chueogeun
Dareuge jeokhinda
Naye ibyereun
Jal garaneun insado eobsi
Chireojinda
Sesangeun eojewa jatgo
Siganeun heureugo itgo
Naman honja ireohke dallajyeo itda
Naegeneun cheongeum gatatdeon
Chueogi damgyeojyeo itdeon
Meori wiro
Barami bonda
Nunmuri heureunda
Seriously, why does no one talk about the guy in all white??
He's definitely a excellent singer, but I feel like he was straining his voice a little bit... maybe it's just his timbre, a little raspy, throaty... I think he would be a perfect rock/metal singer, not a balladeer... I don't know if he's a natural tenor just straining his voice a bit, the volume of his voice seemed to strain his voice a little, or if he's a baritone forcing a high falsetto... nevertheless, I think he should train professionally to perfect the technique, he has an amazing potential, even without being able to hear on one side, Beethoven was deft when he made his greatest compositions...
One of his ears is also deaf.. which makes it even amazing that he can sing well..
@@mfollonier i definitely agree. Which is not the case when they sang in the first round. But nonetheless, he is really really good.
People would say she seems unbothered or not phased by their singing but you can tell she’s skirting deeply and is into it
Wonderful performance, beautiful and emotional. No matter how many times I watch it, it so powerful.
Once again I am stocking my oppa with the white shirt hehehehe. Wow hes so dreamy. I really enjoyed it. Very romantic and emotional performance by these singers, but oppa stood out the most when he sings. Oppa can you sing me to sleep everyday ♥♥♥
한국가수중
감성만큼은 이소라를 견줄가수가 없을것같다,,
그녀의 노래는 가슴이 너무아프다
the guy in white somehow slayed this performance just like the other two.
이 노래는 이소라만 불러야 된다
주접 싸네 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅎㅎ 언니랑 와우할 때 좋았는데. 입사하고 벌써 몇년이 지났지? 소라 언니는 천사야. 앞날을 축복해여~
'바람이 분다'는 감히 이렇게 부르면 안되는것 같아요.
그러게요...감정을 억제하며 부르는 곡인데 감정전달이 안되네요
주접들을 싸네 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I do not understand one word but still bring tears to my eye every time, powefull
가수하려면 저렇게 이소라처럼 감성이 풍부해야지
essa música me emociona de uma forma surpreendente e ouvindo essas vozes quase surtei...maravilhoso!!!
셋다 좋아서 나보고 한명 고르라면 나는 못골랐을듯
Petition for them to form a group! 🙌🏾
I’ve got chills... this is beyond beautiful 🤯💜
Wow... such beautiful singers and a beautiful song🎵 🎶 ❤
The sailor's voice thoughhhh. But the white one too, the green one has definitely classical training.
소라누나가 멋지네 곁에 있어주네
이소라 넘사벽이다
진짜 이노래는 들을때마다 눈물이 난다..
I hear this song in monstar the kdrama
Siwon Guevara It was amazing
Amazing voices and song,wonderful performance,I love it!!!
개지렸다.....................오백만 조회수 넘어야할 영상이다..
They're singing like in Opera. I'm amazed.
I'm late watching from NYC. I felt like I was watching a Broadway Musical. Just beautiful. I certainly enjoy the artist in KOREA. Wow...pure talent😊❤❤
voice touched my heart...thanks a lot!
Bravo! Fantastic harmony of this 3 great singer👏👏👏.
헐 안동대스타 이소라편에도 나왔었구나.. 장윤정편에서 되게 인상깊게 봤었는데 팬텀싱어2에 나와서 놀랐었음 조환지님은 팬텀싱어3에서 먼저 보고 여기서도 보네요 확실히 너무 잘함..
이소라목소리만 듣고싶다
They should have become a group
清风在微微的吹，也吹散我们微微的记忆!
The harmony of this song is really beautiful, I can feel even without knowing the meaning,, Music is really universal language 😍😍
Such a beautiful song filled with so much emotion and so powerful ❤ 💖 💗
Still don't understand a word but it is a beautiful song!
I don't understand the words either...BUT I KNOW BEAUTY WHEN I HEAR IT!
C'est une pièce Musicale et en même temps théâtrale vraiment géniale...💯👍👏❤️
오래된 영상이긴 하지만 여기 나오신 분들 정보 얻고 싶어요...노래 부르시는거 너무 좋아서요..
Absolutely incredible... Lee Sora was touched by this otherworldly performance.
Kalau mereka jadi 1 grup.pasti hebat.bisakah?????? 💖💖💖👍👍👍👍👍
i love all lee sora songs ❤️
2022년 끝나가기전 들었던분 추천~~
Kerenn banget si inii...
이 노래 너무 좋다,,,