The Right Kind of Jew (with Jenny Manson)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024
  • Co-chair of Jewish Voice for Labour Jenny Manson joins Alexei to discuss Palestine, her visits to Israel, what it costs to be an pro-Palestinian Jew, anti-semitism and her pretty impressive life story.
    Support Palestine Action by visiting palestineaction.org (www.palestineac...)
    Help those in need in Gaza by visiting map.org.uk (www.map.org.uk/)
    Send your fan art, thoughts and questions to alexeisaylepodcast@gmail.com
    Please consider leaving us a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
    Become a Patron here to support the show and get access to live episodes of The Alexei Sayle Podcast and more - / alexeisaylepodcast .
    Subscribe to Alexei's RUclips channel here ( / alexeisayleofficial ) and join him for his Bike Rides.
    The Alexei Sayle Podcast is produced and edited by Talal Karkouti (www.linktr.ee/t...)
    Music by Tarboosh Records ( / tarbooshrecords )
    Photograph from the Andy Hollingworth Archive (www.andyholling...)

Комментарии • 93

  • @PeterMaranci
    @PeterMaranci Год назад +29

    So good to know that there are still sane people in the world.

  • @davidcampbell4647
    @davidcampbell4647 Год назад +23

    Jenny Manson is such a wonderful human being.

  • @DiarmuidOhibicin
    @DiarmuidOhibicin Год назад +12

    It is wonderful people such as you an Jenny, Alexei, give people like me hope for the future.

  • @minniemoocake
    @minniemoocake 11 месяцев назад +3

    I have listened and re listened to this 4 times, Alexei and Jenny, thank you both so much.

  • @kevinlaing8712
    @kevinlaing8712 Год назад +11

    Thank you for this sane discussion and for letting us hear the voices of anti-Zionist Jews.

  • @antondalemma5484
    @antondalemma5484 Год назад +8

    Read your first book and stumbled into this podcast. Good to see your voice is still around, Alexie.

  • @DougieJohnson-l5w
    @DougieJohnson-l5w Год назад +7

    Mr Sayle you are a life-saving force of humour.

  • @HistoryofConflictShorts
    @HistoryofConflictShorts 11 месяцев назад

    I've had the pleasure of meeting Jenny a few times. One of the kindest and most principled people I've ever met

  • @mickcarpenter2963
    @mickcarpenter2963 Год назад +5

    Well said Alexi, very moving, your voice is sorely needed

  • @strumbadstroller7350
    @strumbadstroller7350 Год назад +8

    Thanks for being the voices of reason . I am so ashamed of our so called leaders. Where is their Humanity?

  • @DarkDeadSanta
    @DarkDeadSanta Год назад +20

    Alexei, you are, and always have been, one of the rare voices of intelligence and reason in this very baron landscape.

    • @nonindividual
      @nonindividual Год назад

      I think you misspelled Boron.

    • @DarkDeadSanta
      @DarkDeadSanta Год назад +1

      @@nonindividual Barren.

    • @annenunney9907
      @annenunney9907 Год назад

      @@nonindividualI don’t think they did

    • @ppetal1
      @ppetal1 9 месяцев назад

      Sacha is a racist scumbag, anyway.

  • @billyjo1148
    @billyjo1148 Год назад +7

    I suppose we should find comfort in such individuals aknowledging the brutal injustice in the world around them.

  • @TheMadmacs
    @TheMadmacs Год назад +5

    as a white scottish guy, the narrative of the media and governments made it very difficult to think anything bad about israel, goodness knows how hard it is to hear the truth for a jewish person, and for an israel jew it must be near impossible to hear the truth.

  • @petermanuel5043
    @petermanuel5043 Год назад +11

    thanks for sharing this. 👍

  • @ianwellens3169
    @ianwellens3169 Год назад +8

    Fantastic stuff. Very perceptive - thank you!

  • @ericalang
    @ericalang Год назад +2

    A brilliant podcast that reflects how we got to this terrible situation and trauma. Fractures that the false antisemitism accusations made to long personal friendships is something anypro Palestinian activist will have experienced and it is very isolating. But the pain of people in Gaza is so horrific so vast we have to keep going and each play our small part in speaking truth to power.

  • @michaelrobson3460
    @michaelrobson3460 Год назад +4

    Best wishes and thoughts for AJ, I know her knowledge and self confidence will pull her through remand.
    Hope shes back on the podcast soon. Her incite was incredible.

  • @ToCoSo
    @ToCoSo Год назад +2

    Such a brilliant and informative podcast plus you are both great people to listen to. Its so good to hear the other side of every story, its actually vital.

  • @jamesprivet
    @jamesprivet Год назад +1

    Brilliant interview and discussion. Intellectual on a much higher level than what we hear on mainstream "dog whistle" media. Thank you both for what you are doing.

  • @HalimaBrewer
    @HalimaBrewer Год назад +5

    Brilliant. Thanks for this

  • @Swat-ed5bt
    @Swat-ed5bt Год назад +8

    Love Alexei ❤

  • @raymondroberts5067
    @raymondroberts5067 Месяц назад

    First time listener and it has really uplifted my sense of justice and impartiality. We all understand the constraints that ideological peer groups can exact but to be so decent and benevolent is in itself an act of rebellion freeing ones spirits. Thank you both.

  • @royloveday4350
    @royloveday4350 Год назад +8

    Such a good interview.

  • @ibilly99
    @ibilly99 Год назад +2

    Healing stuff from the master I will worship at your temple until one of us croaks. Just re-listened to it gets better with each listening.

  • @soopajdelux
    @soopajdelux 10 месяцев назад

    just found your podcast after seeing your alternative christmas video posted on twitter and singing the doctor martin's boots song very loudly. glad I found it. looking forward to checking it out. THANK YOU!! ❤️

  • @paultrembath4131
    @paultrembath4131 Год назад +5

    I think the references to "section 29" are meant to allude to Section 28 of the Local Government Act 1988, which is summarised on Wikipedia and other places. (Probably everyone knows this, but just in case).

  • @spoonfulofdreams
    @spoonfulofdreams 11 месяцев назад +2

    Its so right that Jeremy was badly advised by those close to him. Just look at John McDonnell who, in hindsight, was never a true ally. You could count on one hand those whom Jeremy could truly trust.

  • @dogblessamerica
    @dogblessamerica Год назад +4

    The phrase "never again" can mean two very different things: you can apply it just to Jews, or you can apply it universally.

    • @HateBear-real
      @HateBear-real Год назад

      Or you can be based and actually stand up for your own people, particularly if you're European, instead of cucking 24/7.

  • @moirahyde750
    @moirahyde750 Год назад +1

    Thank you for this balanced response

  • @mediastudiesnetwork
    @mediastudiesnetwork 9 месяцев назад

    Just subscribed. Sorry I’m late. I’ve been listening since the beginning.

  • @gmonkman
    @gmonkman Год назад +4

    Thanks

  • @jamestoday2239
    @jamestoday2239 Год назад +1

    Alexei i stumbled across you on youtube a little while ago, i always wondered why people would react with hostility if i casually mentioned your name over the years, (sorry ive been living under a rock and didn't know much about you at all other than good vibes and good gags) seems i've discovered you just in time as all hell breaks loose and i have a decent human being to look to (your good self) to help explain the sheer madness of whats happening. I think you might be my hero! Ha. As for why doesnt the left get its shit together to fight the right? Maybe its inherent, if you're free thinking you're always going to all be different from each other, you need a good psychologist to shape a framework to be applied to any political movement maybe? As for the right, well i was in the armed forces once which i view as inherently right wing, a hierarchical society where you are paid to do and not think, where the instincts of the left are despised, physcopathy encouraged. Perhaps thats why Stalin came about? Without heirarchy, chaos, I dont know. Thankful to all the Jewish people like yourselves for shinning a light on all these lies. Take care. James.

  • @B.P.0
    @B.P.0 9 месяцев назад

    Thank you Alexei.

  • @LaurenceRonayne
    @LaurenceRonayne 10 месяцев назад

    Wonderful to hear sane Jewish people express humanity in the midst of all this Israeli madness.

  • @andyf2837
    @andyf2837 11 месяцев назад

    Great discussion - informative and eye opening too. One minor criticism though, Corbyn supporters chased me out of the labour party in 2016 because I disagreed with them 100% so they are not like the driven snow either. Blind support for him doesn't help get rid of the problems we have in the country which is slipping into a quagmire of lies and re-writing of the truth.

  • @RoboticPolishingBuffingDeburr
    @RoboticPolishingBuffingDeburr 15 дней назад

    Quite extraordinario. Blackrock gives it's thumbs up to remrats !

  • @tarbooshrecords8530
    @tarbooshrecords8530 Год назад +5

    🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽

  • @wagstaffphilip
    @wagstaffphilip Год назад

    A very interesting discussion. Jenny is the archetypal Corbinistra and it would have been interesting to hear a gentle unearthing of her opinion of Corbyn's Peace and Justice movement (is it a substitute political party etc,) the future of the labour party and what the left should do come the general election.

  • @bmcd9490
    @bmcd9490 Год назад +2

    I'm a non-jew who buys Palestinian olive oil and Palestinian dates. Am I anti- semetic? Will I be arrested?

    • @MarkSpan
      @MarkSpan Год назад +2

      I am disgusted by the actions of Hamas (as well as by the actions of Israël). Am I islamofobic? Am I morally guilty?
      Or maybe there is no simple stance in this....

    • @Solaar_Punk
      @Solaar_Punk Год назад

      You will probably be arrested, yes.

    • @MarkSpan
      @MarkSpan Год назад

      Why do you have four digits in your name?

    • @jimdavis8391
      @jimdavis8391 Год назад

      Anti semitic? No, just a plonker.

  • @ukcryptolondonbased2953
    @ukcryptolondonbased2953 Год назад +3

    This is really difficult for me. I don't want to be tribal, nor do I want to see my fellow human beings as the 'other'. Yet if I'm honest, I struggle to feel any empathy for or see any humanity in a... tax inspector.

    • @gepmrk
      @gepmrk Год назад

      😊

    • @michaelrobson3460
      @michaelrobson3460 Год назад

      And yet? An honest upstanding pillar of our community having the right conversations and taking the right actions.
      And all by January 31st.

    • @SofaKingShit
      @SofaKingShit Год назад +4

      Perhaps try thinking of it as someone who collects money to build and maintain schools and hospitals. Keeps the very young, the insane and the elderly from cluttering up the streets for you.

    • @ukcryptolondonbased2953
      @ukcryptolondonbased2953 Год назад

      It was intended as a bit of light hearted fun. Nothing more.

    • @ukcryptolondonbased2953
      @ukcryptolondonbased2953 Год назад

      @thecouchtripper What in your model of this situation is my need or motivation to lie?

  • @hobosmith893
    @hobosmith893 Год назад +1

    2 plus 2 equals 4

  • @analisapinto
    @analisapinto 10 месяцев назад

    🙏❤️‍🩹

  • @pirompkov
    @pirompkov Год назад +2

    Such a shame Alexei has been converted to the Islam. He used to be a very funny guy.

  • @debbielondon1809
    @debbielondon1809 Год назад +1

    Are you deaf to what Palestinian supporters are calling for? Do you have no imagination as to where all this will lead? I am not Jewish, but the calls in Australia to "gas the Jews" are terrifying. Is it just possible that Hamas are manipulating the situation?

  • @jonathansapier7574
    @jonathansapier7574 Год назад +2

    How can anyone Jewish vote for Corbyn? Unbelievable.

    • @loveulez
      @loveulez Год назад

      What's unbelievable is your pig ignorance, get educated.

    • @wibblywobblyidiotvision
      @wibblywobblyidiotvision Год назад

      You must have missed the bit of the podcast where 2 Jewish people were discussing the Corbyn non-issue and context around it. Admittedly, it was easy to miss, it started at the beginning of the podcast and ended at - well - the end.

    • @ThatGuyThanus
      @ThatGuyThanus Год назад +7

      Did you listen to it?

    • @jonathansapier7574
      @jonathansapier7574 Год назад

      @@wibblywobblyidiotvision Comedian.

    • @keithparker1346
      @keithparker1346 Год назад +11

      Because he's not anti semetic

  • @Law-of-love
    @Law-of-love Год назад +3

    Thanks Alexei 🙏🫡 - no doubt the BEST of us !