The Final Comparisons! Freedom Ranger vs. Cornish Cross Meat Chickens...Just the FACTS!!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- This is week 10.5 for the Freedom Ranger Chickens on our homestead. This week we process them and do our final comparisons of our experiment to determine the best breed of meat chicken for our family farm.
To see the products we use and recommend from Amazon visit our Amazon Store at: www.amazon.com...
Etsy Shop
www.etsy.com/s...
Also check out our Etsy Store for handmade items from the homestead: www.etsy.com/s...
Our new rabbit cookbook can be found here:
Printed Copy: bit.ly/rabbitco...
Amazon Kindle Version: amzn.to/2zelDTu
***** Connect with Us! We'd Love to get to know you! *****
Website: www.LivingTraditionsHomestead.com
Facebook: livingtraditionshomestead
Instagram: living_traditions
***** Email Us *****
info@livingtraditionshomestead.com
Send Snail Mail to:
Living Traditions Homestead
PO Box 323
Ava, MO 65608
***** About Living Traditions Homestead *****
Living Traditions Homestead is all about living a simple and sustainable way of life. We believe the world has gotten too “busy” and that people are missing out on many of the true blessings this world has to offer. We started as a small urban homestead in Gilbert, AZ and after the city grew up around us, decided it was time leave corporate America and take a big leap of faith by moving our family to the Missouri Ozarks.
We put out 5 new videos every week! Tuesday through Saturday. We hope you will become part of our homestead family by subscribing to our channel and watching as we transition from city dwellers to full time homesteaders!
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
![[DOKKAN BATTLE] Worldwide Campaign Announcement Video Part 2!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JpT5Voak6WA/mqdefault.jpg)
I know that doing this comparison has added to your work -- thank you for taking the extra time. It has been very interesting.
based on your average carcass weight, that's an extra 38.75 lbs of meat in the freezer based on 25 birds. Seems like the Cornish Cross are the most economical bird to raise.
WOW! That's a lot of lbs difference! I wish they would have let three of the Cornish Cross go another 2 1/2 weeks to see how much heavier and the fat layer developed Next to the Freedom Rangers! That would have been interesting!
@@kathybluxome5514 If they had let the Cornish Cross go another 2 1/2 weeks thaye would not have been able to walk at all. They are bred for large breast meat and their little legs would not have been able to carry them.
You are so correct Jack! I got busy and did not dress my Cornish in a timely manner. Their legs started breaking :-O. I had to stop everything and dress out those wounded birds. I would raise Cornish again, but would be more careful about when to process....
Buying the chicks, Cornish are cheaper too. Didn't seem like they added that cost in here...
@@kmundwiller3936 , we paid 1.98 per chick at Tractor Supply...based on how many you buy, from hatcheries, it can be cheaper...so far I am very happy with what we bought and the cost and work to feed them.
This was THE BEST comparison series I’ve seen to date!!! Excellent job and thank you for going to all the trouble.
Yup...that Freedom Ranger better have golden nuggets to convince me it’s a better bird!! Hahahahaha Thanks again! God Bless you and Happy Thanksgiving 🍽🍁🦃 to EVERYONE! ~Lisa
I think I’ve already decided for me! But the taste test will be interesting!!! Our Cornish taste so much better than store bought already!!
That's all you need to know!
I love that you did this experiment! I was considering doing the Freedom Rangers next year. I think I will stick with the Cornish crosses.
The rangers are a healthier choice while the Cornish Rocks are diseased ....
When we raised Cornish Cross we normally kept the for at least 12 weeks and depending on the number I had to process we could keep them an additional couple weeks. At that time there was a lot of fat. It never bothered us since the chickens were the size of small turkeys, Soli Deo Gloria!
Praying that you and your family will have a wonderful and blessed Thanksgiving!
That’s a really good real world comparison I think. Thanks for that. Thanks for what I took as a very impartial experiment. You did a good job of showing both sides of the fence.
I would love to see you guys do the exact same comparisons with Cornish Cross Males vs Females, in two separate chicken tractors. :)
Then whoever wins, males or females, split two batches using dry food vs 3 day wet food.
Now that would be awesome :)
Great video :)
I would never have thought that I woulda been so engrossed in a chicken trial 😁. It’s been fascinating info whether one raises meat birds or not. I was wondering if free range could produce a slightly slimmer chicken? Do they work off a bit more of their caloric intake wandering around versus the tractor method you use? Looking forward to the final results w/the taste test. It’s been a very informative, interesting ride! Thanks so much for taking us on it!
Free range chickens consume more grasses which are much lower in protein 6%-9%. commercial feed mixes are much higher protein from 24% - 15%. Protein is what develops structure and flesh. In my experience free range meat birds are like marathon runners...lean and a little tougher.
The best kind of trial; the judges get to eat the evidence. You should host the annual chicken trials and sentencing; ending with a lots and lots of barbecued chicken (an' fixin's)!
Tulips Moran That’s exactly what I was wondering was the possible outcome w/my VERY rudimentary chicken knowledge. It does make sense. Thanks!
I'm pretty certain they did tractors for ALL the birds. Did I miss that part? We're they letting them free range? Cause here in MO, free range range can mean free meals for the wild animals. Lol
That was a very fair comparison! I wonder if anyone has ever done a nutritional analysis between the birds. Because of the extra fat on the FR I wonder if they are higher in fat soluble vitamins. Personally, we've opted for rabbits due to ease of processing and we like them better, Haha. Have you ever done this type of thing between rabbit and chicken? That would be interesting to see the feed to meat ratio.
Natasha S. Would love that
Was thinking the same thing.
Or even a rabbit breed comparison. That would be interesting. I wouldn't be able to do rabbits because the wife is allergic to them. I wouldn't mind having a few for an occasional switch up for me though.
Natasha S. Well that’s something they can aim for next season. Great suggestion as I like rabbit meat as well as chicken 👍🏻
Good morning.
Thank you so much for the work you had done to encourage and spare the rest of us from any unwanted agony in pursuing our own adventures of raising different breeds of birds and between hens and roosters.
I am thinking of raising my own meat on a minimal budget next year and this helped so much for me. Once again, thank you for ur time and efforts in bringing this important info to us. 😎👍❤💯
You two are brilliant. Very very interesting.
This was a fantastic learning experience so I can raise and butcher my own chickens hopefully one day soon. We are slowly transitioning to homesteading & have been growing our own food for a while, but never meat. This series gives me the confidence I need to start small, so thank you so much! I love watching you and your new friends over at roots & refuge😊 keep up the amazing videos! I love the country! My goal is to homestead ourselves while investing and donating most of what we grow to homeless shelters in need. Unfortunately there are way to many hungry people around here where I live. I'm just hoping to have the right tools and finances to be able to help them someday soon! Thanks for sharing!
@Zara Ibrahim Thank you so much!
Great series! Thank you for all your hard work and the info you provided to us. Thank you!
Thank you so much for this series! I know I'll choose the CC when I raise my chickens next spring!
This has been a great series. I agree with you all, you could have free ranged or had other supplemental food sources, but for someone who really wants the most accurate numbers of feed, this was the best test. I think it's worth it to get the Cornish, then incubate the eggs and not have to buy chicks, or course, that's all about scheduling too. You know what I mean, planning your chicks and hatching them out at the best time of year. Anywho, great series, really showed me what to consider for the future, having had freedom rangers but no Cornish, I'll have to try the Cornish! God bless you! Have a great week!
This was such a pleasure to watch!! Just a note to share now that the feed numbers are revealed. I have the Rangers as part of my flock and like having fresh baked chicken for meals and don’t mind processing a couple by themselves. But I have learned they are eating machines and not in a good way. I have pigs, cows, rabbits and ducks and I have to really be creative with feeding them all or the Rangers will consume their food quite rapidly. They will free range very well but only when there is no feed available. Last Spring I went back to the Brahma’s which is what my grandma had when I was young to compare them with the Ranger. I will leave a comment on that after you have done your taste test 😊 No spoilers here. lol I am so not a math geek (my accountant would LOVE you) so I completely enjoyed your labor of love to share this information with all of us!! It has answered a lot of questions for me. Thank you so much!!
Melody did you compare with the brahmas?
I'm curious about your result with the Brahmas
Sunshine, little chilly, snow, & snow melt!
Meat stay cold & No bugs! You can't beat that, except being finished & sitting in front on a nice fire🙂
I am totally into the nerdy chicken math. Sometimes it is a little hard to quantify certain experiences though... One year I had new layer birds (probably straight run, but eventually for eggs) in a chicken tractor next to cornish cross. Same age, same everything. One morning early I got there to discover they had been attacked by raccoons. The heritage breed were unscathed because they were roosting towards the middle of the tractors. The CC were missing heads, wings, etc because they weren't roosting and were near the edges. My take away is that though they provided some meat at that point (about 5 weeks), it was nearly a complete loss, so for my situation I have to up my game to take care of the CC. They don't appear to have some of the survival skills that my other birds posess. (I work on upping my game anyway, but sometimes the results seem weighted to favor survivor birds). To a lesser degree, most people I know accept that there will be more CC deaths at all ages and even though there is still more meat in the end it seems that it needs to continue to be accounted for in some way.
I am hanging tough on my opinion about the texture/flavor profile issue, haha, as it seems quite clear that the CC are the winners in the cost to raise issue. This has been a thought provoking experiment and I'm glad that I have the winter to think about it.
Excellent video. No wasted time, well presented facts and figures...no uhms/ahhhs/ or 'likes'.
5 star. Thank-you.
Based on your test results so far...
Organic birds are a lot more expensive than grocery store birds especially when they are on sale...
Makes one wonder what they pay buying bulk feed..
And how much they are cutting quality in what they're feeding their birds..
And how much, not allowing their birds to move in the cages, helps in the feed conversion...
Well we all know quality costs more...😊
It's next to impossible to compare commercial poultry to homestead poultry...the commercial operations often involve 33,000 birds to a long house, but there's also the investment into buldings, supplies, vet, staff, etc. They try to cut costs but not with the feed. Instead they try to cut costs by shipping live birds for process to China and then same day flown back to US for grocery distribution. In my opinion, homestead costs to raise food is almost irrelevant because I have control over what goes into it to produce it.
Can't wait for the taste test! This was such a great series of videos. God bless!
This was Interesting and I loved the comparisons. Cornish Cross is the least expensive way to go, but I would still raise some Freedom Rangers because Diversity in our eco system is important. Remember the potato famine in Ireland. What if something like that happened to our chickens? Just a thought. Love the channel. You guys ROCK!
Great comparison, you could kinda tell Kevin was leaning towards the CC from pretty early on. 😄 When I put the price of feed around here a few vids back it was $15.49. I bought feed last week and it was down to $10.00. So if a person knows they are going to raise birds, I would suggest buying quite a few bags when the prices lower in the fall. Could end up saving a good chunk of money. 👍🏻
You could give me the facts about a bucket of rocks and I would watch. Happy Thanksgiving 🦃🍽
P.S. Nerdy chicken math saying cracks me up every time 🦋💜
Very helpful and educational. Your attention to detail is evident in all aspects of your homesteading endeavors.
You did a great job with this comparison. Congratulations on being thorough and straightforward..
Holding out for the taste test, but the CX have always been my choice. I have done heritage roos and all the alternative meat birds. I do free range and ferment feed, makes the meat much more flavorful. Thank you both for doing this!
Love your show. I have learned so much.I have a small veggie garden. Love watching your animals.
Thanks for doing this great service for future poultry raising folks!
Very excited for the taste test! Have a good weekend!
Good morning from Magog Quebec Canada.,we got 12 inches of snow on Friday, love watching your videos .
On est rendus à 10 pouces en Ontario 😉
bonjour Magog de Rawdon nord de MTL....
Lol...When we filmed this I said to Sarah people in Canada would laugh at us for considering that snow!
@@LivingTraditionsHomestead Your winters are adorable! 😉
I love what you are doing. Thanks for the good work and the entertaining way in which you are making the comparison.
Wowza! What a huge difference. Thanks for doing this experiment - VERY informative!
Thanks, great work with the chickens and the comparison between the two. Have a great day and peace on your home, many hugs and much love, blessings.
Thank you both for doing this experiment.
good day to you Kevin and Sarah !! thanks for sharing another awesome update and adventures on & off the homestead 👨🌾🎥👍✝
Have a great holiday. There was a lot more difference in cost than I thought there would be. Have a blessed day.
We like the Cornish Cross, but we have also LOVE the Cornish Roasters a bit better. We had considered raising the Red Rangers but.....nah lol. WE HAVE LOVED WATCHING THIS VIDEO SERIES. THANK YOU SO MUCH AND GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR FAMILY.
This has been a great series comparing the two breeds - thank you for doing it. Happy Thanksgiving to all.
Love these videos. Very informative, super helpful and much appreciated.
What an amazing job you two did!! 😮 Incredible!!! 👍🏻
Thank you SO MUCH for this comparison experiment 📝 You two ROCK!! 💪🏻
Wow you guys put in a lot of work doing this. Thank you so much.
Thank you VERY MUCH for the discipline and effort to track and share the comparison test stats between these two hybrids. I appreciate your efforts. I'm also into the nerdy stats that help overcome my impulse/naive homestead decisions. I look forward to the final analysis of taste. I do a similar comparison for my vegetables/canning costs. This next year I hope to compare my inground raised beds with greenhouse hydroponics for tomatoes, lettuce, strawberries. Living on a mtn is wonderful but also presents growing challenges like heavy morning mists that do burn off but leave perfect environment for fungus/insects - then there's the heat/humidity/cool nights. So the intent of my greenhouse is to control for those variables. I plan to video that series.
Thanks so much for so much detail in your calculations and information.
Great series! One of the most valuable qualities of your channel is how organized it is with your playlists. It's so easy to find what I want and helps peak interest in new areas. Great job, God be with your family
The final cost analysis is so helpful! Would you plan a year end review of hogs, rabbits, chickens, garden etc. We all have limited time and money. To know where to get the most bang for our buck would be a great video.
Have a Blessed Thanksgiving. I really enjoy watching you all.
Thank you for sticking with the experiment all the way to the end!! I enjoyed this immensely!
My husband and I prefer dark meat since it is not as dry, hence we are always fighting over the dark meat. If the white meat is more moist on the freedom rangers, I would be willing to pay more for marital bliss.
I think there is a chicken/Ginny cross now. The white meat is supposed to be more like the dark meat. That's just what I read, I have no hands on experience
Wow 😮 look 👀 at that snow ❄️
Wow! Big difference between them!
CC’s for sure 🐣🙏
I’m so grateful that you did this.
I’m on the same page as you all with the freedom rangers
Great comparison. Unless the ranger taste mouth drolling good cornish cross are the smart money(profit).
So glad you guys filmed this experiment. I have been debating which meat birds to raise (hopefully next year), and this has greatly helped my decision. I think all of the comparisons were fair, and numbers don't lie! Thank you for sharing, and I can't wait to see the taste test!
I really appreciate what you've done!
Thanks for doing this experiment, much appreciated.
WOW great final video, the cost does not include your labor. Those are some pricey chickens. But, you gain the experience of being able to raise your own if it came down to have to. BTW, that's a nice blanket of white on the ground. Y'all have a HAPPY THANKSGIVING!
$1.31 to $2.63 per pound is pricey?
@@tulipsmoran5197 Plus labor, time is money.
This was awesome..for now on I'm considering you all my living traditions almanac. What a fantastic thorough review. Who would have known?? Thank you God bless
Thank you for the information. It for sure helps us for next year. We for now have the rabbits and quail for meat. Look forward to the completion. God bless!
Great comparison! We’re getting ready to order meat birds - we only need 25 for the year, for the 2 of us. So glad you did this. Cornish Cross we’re on our list and now it’s definite! I’ll also be getting a laying flick but….for my freezer, Cornish across it is! Thank you for doing this!
Great experiment and video. Thanks Kevin and Sarah.
Chicken fat or Schmaltz is fantastic for cooking and a healthy fat.
Its not cheaper to raise your own chicken but it is SO much healthier and better for everyone. Thank you.
Wish I had your energy! Thanks for sharing this.
Thanks for helping me make up my mind for my meat birds..you guys are awesome♡
kevin...at 1:45...you didnt make sara rake up all the snow did ya?.......alll kidding aside, i know you guys worked hard on this for us, i for one am so appreciative of your work,,,,the taste test, fried, roasted , broiled , bbq...just a hint please.....love you guys
Statistician here: If you are going to compare the FR "roosters only" to the FR "mixed flock", you have to remember that the roosters are in both groups. The "mixed flock" does not give you an accurate hen weight to compare to a rooster weight. You need to subtract total rooster weight from total mixed flock weight to get the total hen weight. Then you can calculate average hen weight and compare to average rooster weight. Looks like you are right about the roosters being more than .5 lbs heavier than the hens. Great series! I can't wait to see the taste test.
Kevin noted that in the video.
Hmmm, I just rewatched the video to make sure. My comment is really only intended to help them and all of us. I love this series. :)
Very informative video. I look forward to seeing if there is a difference in taste and texture. I have noticed with store bought birds sometimes they have a weird texture. Happy Thanksgiving.
Y’all just keep getting better...👍
Thank you so much for doing this!!!! Butchering my Red Broilers at 12 weeks. One more week to go. I'm shooting for 5 lbs.
Even though I do not have the space to have chickens, I found this comparison to be very interesting.
I’m really enjoying all the effort put into gaining these chicken facts. I’ve been leaning toward the Cornish Cross throughout the series. Hopefully the taste holds up.
Your videos just keep getting more and more interesting. Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
What a fantastic job you guys did
God bless
Fantastic nerdy chicken math experiment. What a great series. You guys rock. Soo informative..
This is a awesome experiment that you two took the time to do.. Very informational.. Can not wait to see the final reviews.. Thank you for taking the time out of your weeks to do this.. :")
WOW! What a difference between the two breeds financially! I’m pretty sure I know which breed you’ll be sticking with! Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
Very thorough review of both birds, thanks for the great info!
Very informative.. I truely enjoy your videos..I told my husband next year I want to grow some veggies in our yard..we're in California..
Love nerdy chicken math! Thanks for sharing!
John from our hodgepodge homestead here. This series was awesome. I’ve always raised the Cornish cross and often thought about trying the rangers. Not now I’m sticking with the cross.
This was a great series! If only one could/would farm the majority of the feed...what a cost savings that would be. NICE JOB !
Excellent !
Excellent video series. I have been waiting for this episode to see how the freedom rangers compared to the cornish cross. I always wondered about the rangers, so now I know. Thanks for all of your hard work, and sharing your information with us.
Fat is flavor, but the FR would have to taste like tenderloin in every bite to be my pick lol!! That is a big financial difference!!
If I had to guess, you are probably going to stick with the Cornish cross from here on out.
However there may be a slim chance that the taste test could change everything.
Thank you for this video, this will help me a lot, I am from Guatemala and I will just adjust the prices. Blessings to you.
Hey Sarah and Kevin
Thanks you for all the work you both did on the chicken and roosters.. We think we do cc next year . Have a bless Thanksgiving with your family and family .
Love ‘ll and stay warm..
Great fire in the wood heater ..
Blessing
👩🌾
thanks for this information. it is helpful in future decisions of flocks for meat. GOD Bless
Awesome job, lots of info, cant wait. God bless
Awesome experiment. I had thought there was no way the Cornish cross could be the best choice. I can’t wait to here about your taste test!
It would have been nice if you could have projected all data of the cc out over 10.5 weeks.
Maybe you can on your next video.
This was super nice of you both to do all this work. I feel incredibly blessed and informed to be able to follow along.
Thank you both so much.
You both are so incredibly transparent about what you show us and it's really refreshing and informative.
Thank you!
That nerdy math can definitely get me drowsy, but the answer is absolutely eye opening. Been great to see the results and progress. Would love to see the same comparison with rabbits. I have no clue about rabbits and what breeds are best for meat, but I loved this series about chickens. Love you guys. Love watching every video.
Thank you for all your work I have been thinking about raising a batch of freedom rangers so this has been very good info. I only raise hens as we don't like the bigger chicken we do get the 3-4 lbs dressed weights at 8 wks with cornish cross Again thank you
Wow smaller for more. Thank yall for the numbers. I know yall have gotta be tired by now😂have a nice weekend
Great job on the comparison, there is a endless rabbit hole to go down on chicken comparisons, so ones like this give a good facts based approach to have solid info to make a choice. I would like to see what really happens when you hatch CC eggs, because that's important to me to have a sustaining source. I will still raise CC for meat, but will also have a additional flock to hatch from as that's important to me.
We raise the meat birds while we can get them and also keep an egg laying flock so we can hatch our own when wanted/needed.
Good morning. I really enjoy your channel and WOW!! You are growing 10,000 subscribers in less then a month 🤗
I so! throughly enjoy your videos thank you.
Ty guys, great info