I’ve been feeling it since “The Flare and the Spare” was mentioned. Voldy telling wormtail to get rid of “the spare” in the original text is too memorable.
Honestly, if the Death Eaters are smart, they keep Ron alive and use him as a bargaining chip or hostage, so that Harry has to get him and fall into the trap for Voldemort´s revival
I got it don't know if it will works but Ron grabs harry ward not his in the maze and then touch the cup and face Voldemort Priori Incantate Ron survives
It would be funny for April Fools if you uploaded a video that was like "What if Harry was sorted into Gryffindor" or something and presented it like a theory but just proceeded to recite the actual Harry Potter books
I think that although viktor notices ginny at the wedding, in GoF she is still too young for that age gap not to be weird. 13 & 17, possibly even 18, idk if he would still ask her
Ron took Harry's wand so he will be able to fight off Voldemort due to the twin cores! Voldemort will take Ron's blood to come back because he doesn't want to delay his return further, and when he will try to kill Ron, the twin cores will come into play
@FantasyLegend-z7w Yeah he'll probably die. They've had this happen in a few other what ifs where only Cedric goes to the graveyard and Voldemort comes back with his blood and Harry eventually dies when its time
A few issues I have. 1. I find it hard to believe that Ron would beat Krum to the punch of asking out Hermione. I find it even more unlikely that Krum would then immediately go with Ginny. 2. Why would Barty Crouch have Krum attack Ron in the Black Lake? He didn't do that with Cedric in the main story. 3. Aren't the Unforgivables unblockable? Ron's Protego shouldn't have worked. 4. Why would Harry and Ron not just take the cup together?
Can't answer the first 3, but for 4 it's just harry being noble and wanting to give Ron the win since it's only fair as he's the actual hogwarts champion (and also for the plot)
Ron and Hermione aren't house friends in this one therefore he's more likely to actually ask her similar to how in the original he managed to ask fleur earlier, they don't have that almost sibling like relationship that makes him not consider her for a long time. As for ginny, yeah that one says them riding their own relationship fanfics lol And I agree that the shark incident is a bit random however Ron is not exactly Cedric they're not following the same plot I think Moody is just trying to take Ron out of commission cuz he's more of a threat than Cedric was in the original tie until after the second task originally and these two are going in having already tied in the first task which is why he's starting the sabotaging early because the tying happened early,
@@anvos658 possibly but that's a thing people take younger siblings and relatives to dances sometimes and we know she was desperate to get into the ball so she probably if you even have not the other way around
I feel like it was always a little weird that krum goes with hermionie with the age gap and he technically being an adult in the wizarding world, but going with ginny is going another year younger
Prior to watching this I just happen to be having a conversation (with a British friend) about the differences between US and British schools. Based on our conversation Krum is a high school senior and Ginny is in eighth grade. So middle school!
Ginny's birthday is very late in the school year, and Hermione's is very early in the school year, so the gap between the two is nearly two years. This alternative series further confirms my thoughts that Krum is a creep
Grow up. He went on _one_ completely platonic date with them, he's not smashing them. The fact that you think it's "creepy" says more about _you_ than anything else.
@@thefandombard4774I doubt it. Petunia would probably poop on magic to him until Dudley showed his magical ability. I think Vernon’s opinion is defined by Petunia’s jealousy of Lily (he wouldn’t know magic existed without her hating on it and Lily); he doesn’t have his own true opinion on magic and nothing Duddykins does is bad so he wouldn’t really have a reason to divorce Petunia.
1:18 As someone from the UK it's so interesting to me that you didn't know Harry Kane until this video seeing as anyone here with even a passing knowledge of football (I guess soccer for you) would know his name at least. I guess it works both ways though cause 95% of people here couldn't name a single NFL team/player, including me. Great video as always!
really? no one there can at least name tom brady? and as far as harry Kaine goes anyone who still has a passing knowledge of soccer (apologies im american lol ) knows who he is. it's just that is not the most dominant sport over here, so more people don't know anything about it at all.
Wait you skipped over the family visit which is where you have harry set molly weasley straight about rita skeeter! That was such a fun scene within the context of hermione and mollys relationship. Given that rita skeeters angle was changed to being critical of harrys upbringing with the weasleys itd have been good to include a scene of him interacting with them again in the same context but with the added awkwardness of them being there for ron and him having sirius there.
I have a what if for you. What if the ministry expelled Harry? They would take his wand and it would be snapped in half. How does that impact the story. And what will Harry do as he no longer attends school? Will he become a member of the order and get another wand? Does he stay with Sirius?
@@JitteryJackanape kind of agree, i will not agree on that Harry would stay idely by and have it Snapped but the ministry would have the recurces to track him down and subdue him quickly. The only senario there i see harry to be ok with it if he get's a letter from Dumbledor saying something that he will care for harry if he lets go of his wand. So 3 routs? Harry outlaw with wand, Harry outlaw with out wand, and harry without wand but in Dumbledors care and still practessing magic (i can't belive Dumbledor would not still educate Harry even if he gets expelled)
@abraham2172 that's why it's a what if. In theory Dumbledore could've been away because he found a horcrux or fighting some other matter too. Or he simply didn't arrive early and they immediately snap his wand before Dumbledore gets there as he shows up 3 hours early. But it's possible he could've missed it, in theory, of course.
The people talking about the possibility of Voldemort using Polyjuice to transform into Ron and getting at Harry that way are missing a much easier, much quicker way of making it happen... the Imperius Curse. Voldemort could Imperius Ron to kill or kidnap Harry, eliminating the need for one of his servants to conveniently have some Polyjuice on-hand, or to wait for Crouch to sneak away unnoticed with a fresh batch. I, personally, don't see either scenario happening in part 7, but of the two options, I think the Imperius scenario is more plausible. It's not infallible, but would have a much greater chance of succeeding than the Polyjuice scenario, in my opinion.
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?" I think I've come up with a way she can get sorted into Slytherin: Charlie catches her sneaking into the quidditch supply which makes him train her and it fuels her ambition to be a professional quidditch player, so she's even more determined and ambitious so she gets sorted into Slytherin.
I don't think they can cast spells underwater. Harry wasn't able to do more than sparks and couldn't speak. Neither of the boys have had nonverbal training since they aren't in 6th year.
18:45 Not really a cliffhanger tbh. Based on your past videos, Voldemort will still instruct Wormtail to kill Ron. Then Voldemort will use Polyjuice potion to disguise himself as Ron and reenter Hogwarts Edit: Not Wormtail, I meant another Death Eater
Wasn't wormtail arrested though? It was Barty that found Voldemort in this version. Based on the first part of the Goblet story, I would assume it to be Lucius.
Wait wait wait wait I just realized, if Carl's Junior is still moving in the scenario then who's nursing baldy baby back to health? Originally that was wormtail's job and wormtail was the one who found him if junior did that and found him wouldn't he have to babysit him in which case how is he also Moody
My recent realization that Fleur Delacour’s name translates from French to Flower of the Heart. Flower (Fleur) of the (de la) heart (coeur). It seems intentional.
I always thought it was so out of character for Hermione (in the movie) to mock Fleur's accent while already dunking on her for her failure at the lake. Just so mean-spirited and unlike her. It's Book Hermione that dislikes Fleur; in the movie she seems pretty neutral towards her.
Thrilled to be here! I love the Triwizard Tournamnet - Ben, why are you starting with an apology??? There’s no way Cedric Diggory is going to die right??? 😮
6:27 You forgot (in this and in the "What If Harry was sorted into Slytherin video") about the fact that in Cedric Diggory wasn't a sixth year, he was a seventh year.
Question: If disarming your opponent automatically gives you their wands' allegiance, doesn't that mean Snape is Lockhart's wand's master, and Harry is Snape's wand's master? And wouldn't everyone in the DA be constantly swapping wand allegiances?
wand lore is complicated and it's all about 1) intention of the wielder doing the disarming 2) disposition of the wand (in other words, it works whenever the writer needs it to work 😁)
@Dookieryan That's not nearly as interesting as her being in Slytherine. Malfoy and the others and how Slytherine House is seen. You'll get a lot more out of that. Plus Slytherine and Grrinnydor rivarly
The biggest what if you haven’t tackled yet is what Harry had been born a girl. Who looked just like Lily but had james eyes? Would the dursley’s still bully her if sue was the spitting image of a young Lily? would snape favor her for obvious reasons? Would Ron still be her best friend? Just for the record i think the obvious name swap would be Harriet but i think sticking with the flower theme of lily and petunia ,Hyacinth Potter the girl who lived would be my pick.
I have been asking for this for a while now. People keep saying that the prophecy references a "he" but honestly, I say just write around that just for the sake of this what if. There are so many things to explore in a scenario where female-Harry is the spitting image of Lilly.
@@olandir The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches, born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies" "And the Dark Lord will mark them as his equal, but they will have power the Dark Lord knows not" "And either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives" fixed it lol
This might be my favorite What If from you guys,, the writing has been spectacular and it's been so great seeing Ron come into his own right alongside Harry
I just LOVE how people tend to "forget" that Ginny is only 13 in Harry (& Ron's) 4th year . . . & Krum is 17 (or 18??) . . . So, Ginny & Krum? No . . . Considering Ginny is still a CHILD . . . Just NO . . . 🙅🏽♀ Can we stop putting GROWN adults with CHILDREN in books & shows, PLEASE!! 🙏🏻 (Even made up ones!) BUT, not gonna lie, though . . . #PatBottom is pretty good!! 😂
On the one hand, I love these videos... on the other hand, i hate that years are being divided up. I really want all of each year in it's own video (mostly because the cliffhangers are killing me!)
I’m gunna have to bet Ron is still holding Harry’s wand, and he is able to master it due to disarming him in training and therefore causes priori incantartem with voldemorts wand. But now Voldemort won’t have taken Harry’s blood into himself which means while he maybe can’t touch Harry, he can kill him and Harry won’t be tethered to life.
What if Harry was in Slytherin, Ron was in Hufflepuff, Hermione was in Ravenclaw and Neville was still in Gryffindor but was a more active player, turning the trio into a quartet? But Harry isn't adopted by the Weasleys. In the same story, not separate.
After 12 years of SCB, bound to have some really loopy jokes. Also, was hoping to see the "In the face, In the face" from the Hangover for the conjunctivitus curse to Krum. He would deserve it.
Sorry in advance...
oh god😅😂😂
I’m scared
I’m going to come back to this comment and be like oh my god!!!
You scared me.
@@TrentonWeiss-c5xme too
At the graveyard, Ron: You took everything away from me.
Voldemort: I don't even know who you are.
You will.
Ben starting by saying ‘I’m sorry’ heightened a fear I’ve had since Ron’s name came out of the goblet.
So true. I'm so scared 😭😂
I’ve been feeling it since “The Flare and the Spare” was mentioned.
Voldy telling wormtail to get rid of “the spare” in the original text is too memorable.
Honestly, if the Death Eaters are smart, they keep Ron alive and use him as a bargaining chip or hostage, so that Harry has to get him and fall into the trap for Voldemort´s revival
He has Harry’s wand though, so the twin cores will keep him safe 🙌🏻
“Potter boy? At last we meet. You truly have your mother’s hair.”
WILD 😂
😂😂
spoiler alert much 🤣
It's too bad he met Harry in the first year though so he knows what Harry looks like. Cause that would have been such a great line.
@@Mary_Studios yeah 😔
Having Hermione, Ginny, Cho, and Cedric all in the water, this is just Harry's Harem from fanfics.
Omg. I never realized that! All the ships are there aren’t they? Harmione, Hinny, Charry and Hedric 😂
@@ShriyaditaSSbut where's Drarry?😂
@@scottcharlietodd7380 Dang it. Don’t know about Drarry but I’m sure Drapple is watching the 2nd task with great interest 🤣
how dare you keep us in suspense, you better complete the entire story! This is my favourite what if series so far!
Same, I love this ❤
Mine too. 😂❤
Voldemort be like: Wait a minute....who tf are you?!
At this point whenever I hear 'Expelliarmus' I'm like "yayy we're gonna do more wand mechanics. How exciting, more wand allegiance shenanigans"
I got it don't know if it will works but Ron grabs harry ward not his in the maze and then touch the cup and face Voldemort Priori Incantate Ron survives
@@Dbzwrestlefan727 exactly what I was thinking
@@Dbzwrestlefan727 so then harry would have to die as his horcrux will have to be destroyed and voldemort wouldnt have his blood
@danbruh33 yes unfortunately in this turn of events he would have to
I think it only works if you have intent, not just dueling practice.
9:21 I'm inserting a clip of Dudley saying "not Cedric"
Fleur's person in the lake should be her sister, no need to change that imo
ikr, I was gonna comment that, in the original book it's gabrielle not roger davies
Yeah! Sisterly love, you guys!
It would be funny for April Fools if you uploaded a video that was like "What if Harry was sorted into Gryffindor" or something and presented it like a theory but just proceeded to recite the actual Harry Potter books
+
Genius
Cannot BELIEVE you would leave us in such a cliffhanger. I’m stunned! (Not as stunned as Krum but still!)
You won
"Before we begin, I just want to say I'm sorry."
::closes video and backs away::
I think that although viktor notices ginny at the wedding, in GoF she is still too young for that age gap not to be weird. 13 & 17, possibly even 18, idk if he would still ask her
yeah 13 and 18 is kinda weird..... Little bit more than kinda.... Very weird
Heve you ever heard about Diddy?@@nervshmrv1245
Remember he’s from a different country so age difference is different for him
That's what I thought too.
@@loki009fong5age of consent in Bulgaria is 14, and even if Ginny was 14, Krum is still legal adult and Ginny is still a child, it’s wrong either way
Ron took Harry's wand so he will be able to fight off Voldemort due to the twin cores! Voldemort will take Ron's blood to come back because he doesn't want to delay his return further, and when he will try to kill Ron, the twin cores will come into play
@FantasyLegend-z7wHarry will have to die and I believe Ron will somehow gain mastery of the Elder wand and defeat Voldemort in the final duel.
Just have Ron die and hermione can be with who she should have ended up with...Harry potter
@@BrandenH420 thats if he lives
@FantasyLegend-z7w Yeah he'll probably die. They've had this happen in a few other what ifs where only Cedric goes to the graveyard and Voldemort comes back with his blood and Harry eventually dies when its time
If Ron dies , Do they continue the series?
It’s late October. J and Ben better be preparing for the Goblet of Hot Wings!!!
18:22 fleur comes out of nowhere and grabs the cup.
A few issues I have.
1. I find it hard to believe that Ron would beat Krum to the punch of asking out Hermione. I find it even more unlikely that Krum would then immediately go with Ginny.
2. Why would Barty Crouch have Krum attack Ron in the Black Lake? He didn't do that with Cedric in the main story.
3. Aren't the Unforgivables unblockable? Ron's Protego shouldn't have worked.
4. Why would Harry and Ron not just take the cup together?
Can't answer the first 3, but for 4 it's just harry being noble and wanting to give Ron the win since it's only fair as he's the actual hogwarts champion (and also for the plot)
Ron and Hermione aren't house friends in this one therefore he's more likely to actually ask her similar to how in the original he managed to ask fleur earlier, they don't have that almost sibling like relationship that makes him not consider her for a long time.
As for ginny, yeah that one says them riding their own relationship fanfics lol
And I agree that the shark incident is a bit random however Ron is not exactly Cedric they're not following the same plot I think Moody is just trying to take Ron out of commission cuz he's more of a threat than Cedric was in the original tie until after the second task originally and these two are going in having already tied in the first task which is why he's starting the sabotaging early because the tying happened early,
@@lahlybird895 I'd say Ginny is more Ron asked out Hermione, so Krum decided, fine I'll ask out your sister.
2. Time will tell, but I am not sure it is barty at that vertion.
3. No. Only the killing curse is.
@@anvos658 possibly but that's a thing people take younger siblings and relatives to dances sometimes and we know she was desperate to get into the ball so she probably if you even have not the other way around
Y’all realize that if Voldemort takes Ron’s blood, ole Tom Riddle will finally be a pure blood!
18 year old Krum asking 13 year old Ginny to the ball is waaaaaaaay worse than the cliffhanger
This bit is pretty messed up, yo
17:36 ...looking at a CLUELESS Harry. "No CLUE!" Harry responds
Loved that lol
Jumpscaring me with the "my eyes" gif always make me laugh
I feel like it was always a little weird that krum goes with hermionie with the age gap and he technically being an adult in the wizarding world, but going with ginny is going another year younger
Prior to watching this I just happen to be having a conversation (with a British friend) about the differences between US and British schools. Based on our conversation Krum is a high school senior and Ginny is in eighth grade. So middle school!
@@hufflepomKrum is also over the British age of consent and Hermione isn't sooo
Ginny's birthday is very late in the school year, and Hermione's is very early in the school year, so the gap between the two is nearly two years. This alternative series further confirms my thoughts that Krum is a creep
@@alexroberts771 A British term for "creeps" would be 'Nonce'. Remember, Krum is over the age of consent in Britain and Hermione and Ginny aren't
Grow up. He went on _one_ completely platonic date with them, he's not smashing them. The fact that you think it's "creepy" says more about _you_ than anything else.
Ah, it's Arthur's time to shout "HE'S MY BOYYYYYY!!"....well...
Love this What if. Now then, back to my streak of asking "What if Dudley was a Muggle Born?"
oh yes!!! this next!!! would love to see if Petunnia's love for diddykins is bigger than all her bigoted resentment and envy
Would Vernon duvorce pitunia if dudley was magic?
Harry Potter Folklore did a great version of that
@@thefandombard4774I doubt it. Petunia would probably poop on magic to him until Dudley showed his magical ability. I think Vernon’s opinion is defined by Petunia’s jealousy of Lily (he wouldn’t know magic existed without her hating on it and Lily); he doesn’t have his own true opinion on magic and nothing Duddykins does is bad so he wouldn’t really have a reason to divorce Petunia.
1:18 As someone from the UK it's so interesting to me that you didn't know Harry Kane until this video seeing as anyone here with even a passing knowledge of football (I guess soccer for you) would know his name at least.
I guess it works both ways though cause 95% of people here couldn't name a single NFL team/player, including me.
Great video as always!
really? no one there can at least name tom brady? and as far as harry Kaine goes anyone who still has a passing knowledge of soccer (apologies im american lol ) knows who he is. it's just that is not the most dominant sport over here, so more people don't know anything about it at all.
From far away above his head he heard a high cold voice say, “KILL THE FLARE!”
😂
Kill the spare!
Umm... my lord, he's the Flare.
Wait you skipped over the family visit which is where you have harry set molly weasley straight about rita skeeter! That was such a fun scene within the context of hermione and mollys relationship. Given that rita skeeters angle was changed to being critical of harrys upbringing with the weasleys itd have been good to include a scene of him interacting with them again in the same context but with the added awkwardness of them being there for ron and him having sirius there.
I like that Krum (moody (B. Crouch Jr.) ) tries to set Ron's flaming red hair on fire
My first thought when I heard Ron took Hermione was 'at least Krum won't be dating a 14 year old at 17 now.' Oh Ginny is so much worse
hermione is 15 here actually
@@brony4869and ginny is 13. So, they made it worse
And going to a dance together does not mean you're dating @@RMills646
Yes, 13 with 17/18 starts to be weird, but 14/17 or 15/18, they are a reality and not weird depending on the level of maturity.
@@DanielaDormiaru-ih9xfnah that’s still weird that’s like a senior dating a freshman
I have a what if for you.
What if the ministry expelled Harry? They would take his wand and it would be snapped in half. How does that impact the story. And what will Harry do as he no longer attends school? Will he become a member of the order and get another wand? Does he stay with Sirius?
I mean, harry never intended of willingly having his wand snapped, he would probably be an outlaw on the run protecting his wand
@@theprinceofawesomeness okay. So then there's two routes they could explore
@@JitteryJackanape kind of agree, i will not agree on that Harry would stay idely by and have it Snapped but the ministry would have the recurces to track him down and subdue him quickly. The only senario there i see harry to be ok with it if he get's a letter from Dumbledor saying something that he will care for harry if he lets go of his wand.
So 3 routs? Harry outlaw with wand, Harry outlaw with out wand, and harry without wand but in Dumbledors care and still practessing magic (i can't belive Dumbledor would not still educate Harry even if he gets expelled)
Dumbledore wouldve never accepted that. And he is powerful enough to enable Harrys escape or straight up dispossess Fudge as a last resort.
@abraham2172 that's why it's a what if. In theory Dumbledore could've been away because he found a horcrux or fighting some other matter too. Or he simply didn't arrive early and they immediately snap his wand before Dumbledore gets there as he shows up 3 hours early. But it's possible he could've missed it, in theory, of course.
Patbottom
J cackling in the back
I appreciate ben calling Harry Kane a "footballer"
The people talking about the possibility of Voldemort using Polyjuice to transform into Ron and getting at Harry that way are missing a much easier, much quicker way of making it happen... the Imperius Curse. Voldemort could Imperius Ron to kill or kidnap Harry, eliminating the need for one of his servants to conveniently have some Polyjuice on-hand, or to wait for Crouch to sneak away unnoticed with a fresh batch. I, personally, don't see either scenario happening in part 7, but of the two options, I think the Imperius scenario is more plausible. It's not infallible, but would have a much greater chance of succeeding than the Polyjuice scenario, in my opinion.
what if hermione was in ravenclaw
I was thinking about that
Yes yes yes
That's gotta be coming, right?
They gotta do that
That is the next series they are doing the trios secondary houses
Not only does Ron have Harry’s wand
He has mastery over it
I cannot wait for the next episode!
1:20
The Americans used footballer instead of soccer player, finally they understand the true way
I choose to believe that in this au Harry Kane is secretly a world class quidditch player
Ron goes to Voldemort alone? this could end up bad, but also very good
and hey, Cedric survives
Don’t forget, he may still have Harry’s wand. The twin cores could still react and help protect Ron.
@@kristinemacdonald7818 that's a good point. but that would mean Voldy gets revived with Ron's blood
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?" I think I've come up with a way she can get sorted into Slytherin: Charlie catches her sneaking into the quidditch supply which makes him train her and it fuels her ambition to be a professional quidditch player, so she's even more determined and ambitious so she gets sorted into Slytherin.
4:14 Isybelle this is one of the funniest edits you made so far in my opinion 😂
teehee tyty
I 100% thought the Harry Kane Halt was a reference to the player
So did I, I assumed they knew lol
to complete the trilogy we just need to see what would happen if hermine is in ravenclaw
13:26 I like the yellow time bar for the self placed ads.
I’ve really enjoyed the whole series with Harry and Ron being cotagonists, but last week putting them both into the tournament got me all in
Ron has Harry's wand, he has the twin core👀
I am LOVING the editing on this one
thank you 🫶🏻
I don't think they can cast spells underwater. Harry wasn't able to do more than sparks and couldn't speak. Neither of the boys have had nonverbal training since they aren't in 6th year.
In my headcanon of this headcanon, Cedric probabaly got him started on the idea of non-verbal spells while teaching him the bubblehead charm
Ron could, the bubble head charm would allow speaking
Yes but sometimes adrenaline can help in the use of nonverbal magic
Ron can, his head wouldn't be in the water
This style of videos very quickly became my favourite SCB content
"the five best friends that anyone could have~ and Nevile!...... Is dead!😃"
When you said Krum takes Ginny to the ball it say "WHAT?" LOL
18:45 Not really a cliffhanger tbh. Based on your past videos, Voldemort will still instruct Wormtail to kill Ron. Then Voldemort will use Polyjuice potion to disguise himself as Ron and reenter Hogwarts
Edit: Not Wormtail, I meant another Death Eater
Wasn't wormtail arrested though? It was Barty that found Voldemort in this version. Based on the first part of the Goblet story, I would assume it to be Lucius.
@@countcr33per Right, thanks for pointing that out
@@AkhilNagulapalli-f5k no problem.
The problem is ron has mastery of harrys wand so hes protected from voldermorts wand.
Wait wait wait wait I just realized, if Carl's Junior is still moving in the scenario then who's nursing baldy baby back to health? Originally that was wormtail's job and wormtail was the one who found him if junior did that and found him wouldn't he have to babysit him in which case how is he also Moody
My recent realization that Fleur Delacour’s name translates from French to Flower of the Heart. Flower (Fleur) of the (de la) heart (coeur). It seems intentional.
It’s late October. J and Ben better be preparing for the Goblet of Fire!!!
18 year old Krum and 13 year old Ginny, honestly what could go wrong, right?
I always thought it was so out of character for Hermione (in the movie) to mock Fleur's accent while already dunking on her for her failure at the lake. Just so mean-spirited and unlike her. It's Book Hermione that dislikes Fleur; in the movie she seems pretty neutral towards her.
Thrilled to be here! I love the Triwizard Tournamnet - Ben, why are you starting with an apology??? There’s no way Cedric Diggory is going to die right??? 😮
more like ROn
@@kianbakker3691 Yup 😬 but still not a ZERO chance Cedric won’t die. Although it would be great if no one dies but you know…
i haven’t started this yet but THANK YOU for posting this so fast!
So glad the next part is here! Love all your what-if scenario
17:35 A clueless Harry shouting "No clue!" has to be intentional 😂
#PatBottom is awkwardly awesome, I love it :)
2:25- those are ADORABLE!!!!!!!
Also: well played sirs!
Could you eventually do "What If Ginny was sorted into Slytherin?"
The Neville/ Parvati ship should be "Parville" 😅
If an adult asking a child on a date wasn’t gross enough, let’s pick an even younger child instead. 🤦♂️
that always creeped me out massively. krums like 18 and hermione was 14, they kissed aswell. now lets have a 13 year old
6:27 You forgot (in this and in the "What If Harry was sorted into Slytherin video") about the fact that in Cedric Diggory wasn't a sixth year, he was a seventh year.
Ron was never loyal enough for that.
Now we need Hermione was in ravenclaw
Also bet Ron and Harry plotting to kill krum if ginny feels mild sadness
Krum and Hermione (18 & 15) was borderline but him and Ginny (13) is just wrong
Question: If disarming your opponent automatically gives you their wands' allegiance, doesn't that mean Snape is Lockhart's wand's master, and Harry is Snape's wand's master? And wouldn't everyone in the DA be constantly swapping wand allegiances?
wand lore is complicated and it's all about 1) intention of the wielder doing the disarming 2) disposition of the wand (in other words, it works whenever the writer needs it to work 😁)
Sweet it’s back.
Any chance we can get a “What if Hermione was in Slytherine?”
Nah that would be if hermione was in ravenclaw. Each of the trio represents a different house
@Dookieryan That's not nearly as interesting as her being in Slytherine. Malfoy and the others and how Slytherine House is seen. You'll get a lot more out of that. Plus Slytherine and Grrinnydor rivarly
slytherin*
The biggest what if you haven’t tackled yet is what Harry had been born a girl. Who looked just like Lily but had james eyes? Would the dursley’s still bully her if sue was the spitting image of a young Lily? would snape favor her for obvious reasons? Would Ron still be her best friend? Just for the record i think the obvious name swap would be Harriet but i think sticking with the flower theme of lily and petunia ,Hyacinth Potter the girl who lived would be my pick.
You are absolutely right! I do quite enjoy their AU's and this one should be on their to-do list.
I have been asking for this for a while now. People keep saying that the prophecy references a "he" but honestly, I say just write around that just for the sake of this what if. There are so many things to explore in a scenario where female-Harry is the spitting image of Lilly.
@@olandir The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches, born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies"
"And the Dark Lord will mark them as his equal, but they will have power the Dark Lord knows not"
"And either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives" fixed it lol
Ron has Harry's wand still.
This is either very good or HORRIBLY BAD
Voldemorts laugh will never not be funny.
This might be my favorite What If from you guys,, the writing has been spectacular and it's been so great seeing Ron come into his own right alongside Harry
Happy spooky season! Can't wait For the SPICE 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Umm ... Krum, 17, asks Ginny, 13, to the dance ..?
Fanfiction being told or read on YT is getting more popular.
I just LOVE how people tend to "forget" that Ginny is only 13 in Harry (& Ron's) 4th year . . . & Krum is 17 (or 18??) . . . So, Ginny & Krum? No . . . Considering Ginny is still a CHILD . . . Just NO . . . 🙅🏽♀ Can we stop putting GROWN adults with CHILDREN in books & shows, PLEASE!! 🙏🏻 (Even made up ones!) BUT, not gonna lie, though . . . #PatBottom is pretty good!! 😂
Krum and ginny is... No... Krum is 17 and shes barely 13 😭😭😭
saw voldemort pop up on the screen for a milisecond there
On the one hand, I love these videos... on the other hand, i hate that years are being divided up. I really want all of each year in it's own video (mostly because the cliffhangers are killing me!)
I’m gunna have to bet Ron is still holding Harry’s wand, and he is able to master it due to disarming him in training and therefore causes priori incantartem with voldemorts wand. But now Voldemort won’t have taken Harry’s blood into himself which means while he maybe can’t touch Harry, he can kill him and Harry won’t be tethered to life.
I don’t think I have ever seen a Clueless clip in a SuperCarlinBrothers video 😂
This what if series feels more like Ron Weasley book rather than harry potter
I am all for it. Time ron weasely got some love. The earlier eps in this series did a good job building him up for it.
I mean its basically fanfiction so its not going to be exactly the same as the og story
Ronald Weasley having more trophies than Harry Kane is crazy
What if Harry was in Slytherin, Ron was in Hufflepuff, Hermione was in Ravenclaw and Neville was still in Gryffindor but was a more active player, turning the trio into a quartet? But Harry isn't adopted by the Weasleys. In the same story, not separate.
Amazing episode, finally ron and hermione.
Please dont kill my boy ron!!!!
Hes got harrys wand right? Surely the cores still clashhh.
Are you only just noticed that in the SCB logo sequence, J's design has been updated to include his moustache! Cool!
That ginny-crum age gap is 🤨📸
15:27
I feel like there are gonna be some shenanigans about wand ownership in the aftermatch of this little story detail.
Ron: *Chuckles* I'm in danger
we pray that ron didnt give harry back his wand before going to the cup and has the twin core
Can we just shoutout that Ben said “but having successfully saved all the hostages.” 🎗️🎗️🎗️🎗️🎗️
Krum is not beating the allegations with this one
NO. Ben saying I'm sorry is killing me!
So fun though! Excited for the next part! I love how extended Goblet of Fire is
Paused at 1:55... is Ron about to die in the graveyard....
I feared this since last episode
Oh no
Theories is an amazing series! Thanks For this ❤❤
After 12 years of SCB, bound to have some really loopy jokes. Also, was hoping to see the "In the face, In the face" from the Hangover for the conjunctivitus curse to Krum. He would deserve it.