BBC Question Time election 2024 special with Sunak, Starmer, Swinney and Davey
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июн 2024
- Keir Starmer, Rishi Sunak, John Swinney and Ed Davey took questions from a selected audience from across the country in a BBC Question Time special on Thursday.
Subscribe to Guardian News on RUclips ► bit.ly/guardianwiressub
Labour significantly ahead of Tories as campaign continues ► www.theguardian.com/politics/...
How 14 years of Tory rule have changed Britain - in charts ►
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
Website ► www.theguardian.com
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on RUclips:
The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardiannewssubs
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardianaussubs
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfootballsubs
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnsportsubs
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardianlivesubs
#UKElection #GeneralElection #Politics #UK #Labour #Conservatives #SNP #LibDems
Fiona Bruce: "We are not going to interrupt your answers"
Fiona Bruce: Spends the whole time interrupting
Why does the BBC put Bruce on so much these days? Incredibly obnoxious person.
Victoria Derbyshire is infinitely better.
@nannieg7622
She is a silly person.
Why does the female person have to stand and seek attention?
She is absurd.
She doesn’t give a change to anyone. She comes across being rude
2:28 The sign-language guy going for an Oscar.
He was the best part of the whole thing 🕺
Where is Farage
Indeed where is he ....he not welco.e truth sayer...
Reform was not even on my ballot maybe next time round 👍
Sunak is a lost man.
3:08 That gulp - Sunak is having a very bad month.
😄🍿
Actually Sunak came across very well with his answers despite the drama we having with the conservatives party.
You may not like Sunak, I know I certainly don't but he certainly not 'a lost man'.
The thumbnail on this video is of a rogues gallery of the DeviI's disciples. They are part of the same political club.
Sunak is 👌
We are lost.
is it not weird that the leader of the 2nd most popular party wasn't invited?
The Tories were there along with other parties (not limited companies) with MPs
Forget all this Limited company. All parties start of some way. Its a disgrace not listening to the people again. Vote reform to get back the Norm
@@RUclipsmessedupmyhandle REFORM is regsitered as a political party with the electoral commison , so anything else I can explain to you given your limited understanding?
They're scared
@@whysa4 Reform is a limited company registered as a political party, they’re still a company at the whim of a few shareholders and not a party beholden to its members.
Why is Sunak there shouldn’t it be Starmer and Farage? The Conservatives are finished.
Why Farage and not Respect or Greens they both only have one MP and theirs were actually elected unlike 30p Anderson
@@fritzhenning1 You can't be an MP without being elected.
@@NigelfarijWhat has that got to do with Farage rather than Sunak being on the programme.
@@fritzhenning1 Because Reform are leading over the Tories according to opinion polls, that's why. Ah well you'll realise in under a fortnight, if you don't realise now.
@@fritzhenning1 You said Anderson wasn't elected.
Yep no farage, as they font want the most popular party there 😂
The crime minister is incredibly angry about the betting on the election, because he's just remembered that he has forgotten to get his bet on,
where are Reform?
All losers
Aaah shut up John.
WHERE IS NIGEL??????
The problem is the public who believes these criminals
As bad as Brexiteers who put their fingers in their ears and say la la la
Why no Farage?
Why no reform?
Sunak is the biggest mistake, Judge him on his performance, OK Your'e Fired.
Yes but his big asset to Labour.
@@garyturner5739😂😂😂
Sunak: "I'm so angry and disappointed that the political party I called corrupt less than 2 years ago turned out to be corrupt."
Total bore fest. I had to stop watching.
Who but the BBC would not include Farage. The fact he was not allowed to take part encourages me to vote Reform.
If this is the state broadcasters idea of presenting a forum to allow the public to question the main contenders then it really is time for a change..
The fascists keeping Farage out of it
What fascists? 😂
@@tomcoburn5258Wake up tomco son
Faciala?
And the racists keeping him in 😎
Oh the irony of that comment.
Yeah, Sunak is incredibly angry but, as always, does ABSOLUTELY NOTHING because he is so WEAK.
3:17 Sunak is so angry that he's gonna stomp his feet and hold his breath until he turns blue.
@@redlightmaxhe really is very cross
He’s waiting for America to tell him what reaction to give
I can't believe he does nothing about his MP's going on tv saying he's weak and should be replaced. If I told customers at work that my boss was useless, I'd be fired instantly
You take Sunak's reticence for weakness when in fact its tact and prudent to say less. Unlike like Starmer he doesn't leap in with an un prepared comment just because he has a brainless crowd baying on his behalf. As for Starmer..... that's another comment!
Four largest parties? Aren't the polls telling us reform is about 2nd? This will just make reform more popular. If the establishment is doing everything it can to keep reform out of these debates, what are they so afraid of the public seeing? We already know reform is the only way to save this country. We dont need debates. We just need to vote reform
Sigh...its the 4 largest parties based on MPs. Of which Reform have 0. The polls aren't a guarantee. Don't worry, in 2029 they will be included.
WHERE IS REFORM?!
The housing crisis.......
700,000+ a year new people and they 'promise' 300,000 houses to 'solve' it.
😂
Being built on agricultural land all around the country. More people, less food, less outdoor space, less wildlife
You do realize more than one person can live in a house…
@@fugglepik9763 🙂
@@fugglepik9763groundbreaking stuff..... add in the tens of thousands in hotels who will get housing/millions of visa overstayers who need to live somewhere.
@@fugglepik9763read again- are your maths that bad.
So where was reform
No nigel ? Thank you bbc you've just made him a little bit stronger 💪
He's on the next one mate (Friday 28th).
@@davidmccann9811 cheers mate
@davidmccann9811 really?
@danielclemence3689 yeah really.
@@darrell3716 They finally gave in after all the complaints. Bet they don't give him equal speaking time.
You wouldn't end up with a leader if you combined all four.
Schools hospitals doctors housing what a mess
VOTE REFORM!
Where is the REFORM party, why have they been excluded?
Says a lot, and might actually be helping "Reform".
because they're behind the lib dems in the polls? they're the 4th biggest party so they didn't make it to this event
They only have 1 MP, Lee Anderson, who defected from Conservatives. They are over represented in all media compared to their elected size
Because the reform party don't fit bbcs narrative
They'll be on the next episodes along with the greens and plaid cymru.
Even without Reform being there, Reform were winners on the night
Reform UK all day long
Where is Nigel?
Shaating in his trousers and waiting for you to clean it up, maybe?
Maybe in the pub
Shut down and silenced.
@@maneshipocrates2264How mature!
@@maneshipocrates2264like biden .
Where's Farage?
they wont let him on
@@cobbwebb4501good stuff, love to see it. More of the same BBC, only political parties with MPs and members not companies only held accountable to their shareholders!
He'll be on the next episode along with the greens and plaid.
@@MacrobianNomadNeed a tissue?
Farage is busy counting the money he made from Brexit at the expense of Reform voters who have made the country worse off.
Where Reform ?
Pathetic attempt at Murican politics. We all.know none of these goons will make anyones life better. A total charade for credulous.
Keeping Nigel out of the debate was a crime. They are running scared of him.
Oh yeah the like 2 seats they can even possibly get is terrifying, or maybe they didn't want to hear him say again about taking us out of the world economic forum... which we are not apart of.
Lol literally no-one is "scared" of that 🤡
@@laidbackkodiakThe revolt is happening all over Europe. Reform will shock a lot of people in this election, including you.
@@jayb7972 then they should debate him if they have nothing to fear
@@jayb7972"literally no one" while those people do actually exist. You are the 🤡
Vote Reform. Abolish the licence fee.
Boris Johnson promised that many times. It's not happening.
It will happen, maybe not this year but eventually. It is an unjust tax. Imagine Sainsbury's being paid for your right to shop anywhere. Meanwhile don't pay it. I haven't since 2003.
Once the license fee is scrapped, how will the terrestrial broadcast network be paid for? At the moment, the BBC own, operate and maintain it
@@stingersplashboris is part of the system a snake reform are not there the peoples party!
@stevec6427 could be paid for by the terrestrial channels from their revenue, in the case of the BBC having sold all or most of the infrastructure, they can contribute to the operation and maintenance of it from a subscription fee. It could be operated by a private company or owned by the terrestrial channels. I took about one minute to think of that, I'm sure heads together can sort the issue in time whatever the solution. The fact that some restructuring needs to be done when something wrong ends is not a reason not to end it.
Surprise surprise the bbc not having farage on
they all scared reform lol
Whats Reform?
@@nimzgaz7049 Is it?
These are a complete waste of of time as the so called leaders NEVER answer a question that is asked
Snp calling the Tories a disaster? Labour solving everything easily, Tories trying to clear up their own mess, too late. What a bunch!
Keeping Farage out of the Starmer/Sunak debate will have huge implications for the BBC license fee.
....or not.
It really won't
@@carrauntoohil86 Many people who vote for him will take it out on the BBC.
Where's Nigel?
terrified to debate Farage - vote reform!!!
Reform are a PR con which will likely win less than 10 seats.
Sorry am i just not seeing Nigel Farage?
Correct. Well done. Very astute.
You also obviously didn't see Fiona Bruce saying he will be on next week.
Had to keep him away from Starmer, just incase he made him look inept.
The only person who performed worse than Sunak was Fiona Bruce, who contrary to her own statement regarding no interruptions insisted on interrupting.
In fairness to her she had to do something when dealing with people who refuse to answer the question asked and instead answer a question from their script. I utterly despise all those lying weasels.
Excluding nigel farrage from this doesn't mean he will go away
REFORM
Where were REFORM and why did BBC news mis quote by editing the conversation with Sunak?
Where's Nigel Farage?
The BBC won't acknowledge him. They are trying to demonise Reform.
Counting his money from the reform potless brigade
Shut out and silenced because they are scared.
@@rb1062 Tory’s might be scared labour love reform ….
@@Gary-le7dzthey take more voters who were formerly Labour than formerly Tory. Look at the stats.
Where was Reform ?
Hope you all heard Starmer say he would have no issue lying to get his way.
Oh, did I miss it? What a shame! 😅
Where is the reform party? You know that one party that actually likes England and it's own citizens!!
Wait where was Farage is this system a joke? Take away peaceful means doesn’t end well in history
lol bring it on thicko
@Gary-le7dz he's a thicko is he 😅
It was a debate between the leaders of four real political parties. Why would that ever include Farage, he is the leader of a public limited company.
@@raycook6952 along comes thicko no 2 ….
@@Gary-le7dz Typical Lefty...
Pity I won't be voting for any off this swamp
The British people won't a patriotic leader and reform is guna take elections by storm.
British.
They want someone who can type properly too. Farage isn't patriotic by the way.
Whatever you want to say about farage he definitely is patriotic. Starmer has stated on camera he's more interested in davos
@@stingersplash What are you talking about? He's more patriotic than the other leaders. Stayed at D Day (having fundraised for veterans) and kept his poppy on, while Starmer removed his poppy and hid his wife while meeting a 'certain demographics. Nigel doesn't kneel, either. You find out just how much Starmer loves the UK, and little you, after the summer.
@@stingersplash "Farage isn't patriotic by the way." WHAT?! Can you provide any evidence for this claim? Where did you copy and paste this idea from?!
@@StuartNevin-ip1wg patriotic? He blathers in a lot about patriotism but destroyed this country with Brexit. He goes to D Day but has policies and opinions more like those we were fighting against than the values we were fighting for.
This is a pointless debate without Reform.
REFORM??
🗳️ Reform UK 🇬🇧
Where's the real opposition? Vote reform
Reform pls 🙏 ❤
Reform uk for me. Nigel is the best speaker and i cannot trust starmer. The man defended Terrorist after the london bombings. I could never back a man who defended Terrorist for money. Just think of the pain and hurt to our people and he wanted to help. 😢 its awful he is in this position.
"Snake Starmer" sums him up.
Yeah but you don't understand... his dad was a tool maker.
@@ionlyfearphobophobia😂😂😂😂. Well play fair he has created a right tool.
@@derc12561hahahaha 😂
Sir Starmer is now coming across as slimy. Sunak broke the law way is he there.
He's always been slimey he was a liar for a living and still is.
@@Clansman63 yes your right sunak is slimy
@@Clansman63 Starmer is the man who makes the scandals go away.
Totally UNELECTED! How did this happen?
You will be judged.
Why isn't reform represented?
Why aren't The Greens? They actually had an elected MP after all. Reform haven't done anything yet.
They don’t want the opposition to have a voice. Reform for me 🇬🇧
Why were REFORM not allowed to have a representative
The video thumb was a portrait of of the DeviI's disciples.
Reform for me
Farage is main contender
Shame on you lot protecting swamp
Didn’t watch once I new The Reform party were not represented
They're on the next episode.
@@18BlackMagic18it would have made sense for the Lib Dems to be on the next episode to debate against the Greens, those parties are clearly more similar. The Reform Party will take most of their voters from the Labour and Tory parties. What's the point of having Farage to debate against the Greens, as if there are voters sitting on the fence debating which of those two parties to vote for lol.
@@Dimera09 it's probably by design. Flips fewer voters to reform that way. Classic media with agenda.
@@Dimera09
Nobody is "debating against" anyone here. The format is that the leaders come on one at a time and take questions from the audience. Did you watch it?
Where is Nigel.
But people don’t vote for you Rishi, they vote for your party and by your own admission, the Tories have f’ed up
These are no longer the four biggest parties. Irrelevant debate unless farage is there.
This is a joke. No Nigel?
Dunno why Nigel Mansell would be there…
Nigel is a joke! Fixed it for you
Don't think Farage would like this non sound bite format?
Ignoring the fact it explicitly said the UK’s four largest parties?
@willhann19 If he is a joke, why is slimy Starmer to scared to debate him. Nigel has asked.
Where's Nigel? .
The exclusion of Nigel Farage tells you all you need to know .
100% true.
No, it tells us 'all we need to know' about many Farage fans, as he's on the next one, along with the Green Party.
Shameful that Farage was excluded!
Complain to the BBC!
Total BS from all of these politicians... The audience was full of middle class people I would say.... Tony cuenca
BBC politically keeping Farage away. Farage is far and away the best politician, speaking for most people….
59% vote for left partys.
So no he does not…just weak minded bigots.
Obviously not as reform polling only 15% …. Mind you to a reform voter that’s a majority
@@Gary-le7dz You believe polls?
@@Gary-le7dz Reform are polling well ahead of Lib Dems and SNP on all the polls, and a couple of polls they're ahead of the Tories. Farage not being in this debate is not justifiable no matter what way you slice it.
He's literally on the next episodes along with the greens and plaid.
The four horseman of the apocalypse.
This wasnt the four largest parties.
This was the top four largest parties by seat share in westminster at this moment. They were the four largest parties.
Reform UK was not included, so it was not fair or balanced.
Never heard of Swinney or Davey! But Farage-yes. Strange that Farage is not in the line up.
Reform have ZERO elected MP s
Not strange, it's the BBC doing it's establishment job.
@@JohnDavis-ed5sg anyone think an elitist privately educated establishment person like toff farage had appeared on question time 38 times , much more then any elected MP ….. oh sorry he has
@@Gary-le7dz Lee Anderson MP. For Reform.
@@Philthy_UK ELECTED !! That bloke defected from the Tory’s
REFORM PEOPLE the rest are a shower like the England team 👍🇬🇧
Bruce promised no interruptions and proceeded to interrupt numerous times.
Wheres Farage?
In his million pound home crying about immigration trying to con people into voting for him
Vote Reform funny how they wouldn't let Nigel in
The rules here are pretty simple: no mention of Reform or Nigel Farage or you’re out.
What was the point of this debate. The people's opposition party reform uk was excluded because the establishment is rattled and doesn't want him getting in parliament... waste of time if nigel farage is missing ... they're all the same there
Why isnt Nigel Farage here?
Oh sunak so
Humble and contrite dont mak me laugh
Why is nobody asking Starmer about his policy of privatizing NHS and how long will it take the public energy entity to reduce energy bills for the tax payers.
What???
The only ones privatising the NHS are the CONS and the far-right Farage CONS
Didn't you hear him?? 👂👂👂👂👂
He wants an insurance based health service
Durrrrrrr
This debate was pathetic they all lost nigel won because there scared of debating him.
There was no debating, as each leader came on alone and answered questions from the audience. Did you even watch it mate? Anyway, Farage is on next week.
Vote REFORM
Anyone ask Davey how his postmaster constituent is?
Don't bet on Sunak keeping his seat.
Where is REFORM? !!!
Vote Reform to abolish the TV licence.
Why doesn’t somebody somebody ask? How did he get conservative leadership?
Weak men create hard times- vote reform