Reactions of North Korean audiences on this performance were surely different compared to others in the concert. This is North Korean song. They knew and had been very familiar with this song. Of course they were very glad that a singer from the south sang this song very beautifully. Good job Seohyun!!!
I saw the concert and it was alright I guess. They had a lot of rock and kpop which I don't think was a very good idea. This performance is one of the few that will be remembered by the audience. A classy song sung by, arguably, the epitome of south korean beauty.
Obnoxious, but Consistent YB also got great reactions in my opinion. A lot of the songs were also sad songs, so you can't expect much reaction, especially since the people were confronted to this style of music for the first time.
they can't cheer and sing the songs that are not from NK,that's a rule. Seohyun sang a song from NK so that's why they gave reaction only to her.. also he deserve it, she was sick and still looked and sounded grrat
Good point But that would become different with the original nine-member lineup. because the North Koreans are going to dislike Americans that would mean Jessica Tiffany & Sunny.
For me it's really not about how well she sang. It's about her sincerity in wanting to be part of this cultural exchange occasion. The way she handled everything from relations with the sk and nk performers, the interviews etc, really showed her maturity and good heart. She's really beautiful inside out. At least for me, it seems like that.
Jonathan Megan she was the perfect member out of all girls in SNSD to be the North -South Korean kpop idol diplomat. She’s naturally formal, very respectful, well postured and really musically well rounded. I could imagine Hyoyeon feeling extremely awkward if she had to be a Kpop representative...I don’t think her body popping and locking moves would be well received....
@Brandon Wijaya nope as a korean i can tell the fandom and influence of snsd in kor is much bigger than today's other girlgroups' including bp rv n tw
Kari Haruka I bet her unnies are all feeling very proud of her, not long ago she’s so shy and seldom talked, I guess her unnies groom her to become what she is today.
Original 9 is no good up in Pyongyang because if you watch CNN reporting by Will Ripley he's going to tell you that there is heavy anti American propaganda. Basically aimed at Jessica Sunny & Tiffany.
Most of the new kpoppers say this era is big and get more sales and so on. Little did they know, 1st and 2nd generation kpop idols are making a path for 3rd generation to be successful. They sometimes compared their groups stan to the legend groups. See right now this video is an example for a legend girl group only which is maknae of girls Generation Seohyun. Given the title as icon for cultural exchange in both korea.
marauders map she does have a point tho the groups rn are only riding on the coattails of their seniors' success. But dont get me wrong ofc i love the new gen and it's undeniable how successful they are, new fans just forget who paved the way and it's sad to see them disrespect the older groups (aosh im ranting again haha have a good day 😂)
in my opinion this type of k-music is more fitting to be exhibited in pyeongyang. you see the north korean audience reacted so well and enjoyed it better. it was a right decision to bring seohyun there
Johan Adan how did u know this is important song to them when u dont even know the title of the song 😂 or u just read the comment from other “group fan” who also perform at the same event haha
I have been saying that, too! That would be crazy if the president of SK was also singing and dancing in the world's best ever girl group! Please Korea! Have the Legendary President and Queen of the Earth at the same time! Make history with the power of Love and Girls!
This is an old comment , but you just reminded me of how Seohyun is back then😂 I remember when she would read a lot of books about political stuffs( I’m not sure)
To some people who are misunderstanding, This lyric is a popular song that expresses emotionally about Green Willow. This has no political meaning at all./Dear people who wish for world peace, Music has neither an enemy nor an ally. Music exists equally for all people. And music sometimes moves people's mind. Music has the power to bring peace. I am a fan of Seohyun for many years and I am familiar with her ideas more than people other than her fans. So, what I can say with confidence is that she is one who wants world peace.
이때 감기걸려서 목소리 상태 안좋았는데 노래 넘넘잘불렀다는ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 한국와서도 계속 목상태 안좋아서 가수들 중 혼자 후보정 녹음도 못하고 당시 라이브 그대로 내보낸거ㅠㅠㅠ 엠씨 볼때 목소리 들어봐도 평소 서현이 목소리 아닌 많이 안좋은 상태였다는ㅠㅠㅠ근데 넘넘 잘해준 👍👍👍
Seohyun were having very high fever while at North Korea. I wouldn’t know 😰 because she sounds so perfect! Seohyun and her professionalism must get the credit ✅
How could I find a perfect girl like Seohyun in K-POP industry now?! She is absolutely flawless in her soul, her personality, her voice, her talent and her face and her body as well
North Korean audiences are fairly well known to be quite respectful and staid (not too much clapping or expression). But you can really tell that they LOVED Seohyun's performance of "Blue Willow" at the April 2018 "Spring is Coming" concert in Pyongyang. Four clapping breaks and a very loud applause with outstretched hands at the end.
Stan her. You won't regret! She's indeed multi-talented and smart. Aside from being a lead singer in SNSD back then, she can play various instruments, (but her forte is piano and guitar) and she's a musical actress, too.
she’s improved her breath control so much compared to when she first started in snsd! In fact, she’s worked hard and improved basically every aspect of her voice. She sounds and looks gorgeous here 💙
Seohyun is truly my pride as SONE. Yet ONCE said Seohyun is just average compare to Naeyeon. I almost got my self into a fight but im sure many people dissagree. Seohyun has many talents and skills than other idols. She is a pride of snsd
Wtf.. I have nothing against the groups but I really don’t like new generation kpop fans! They’re so annoying and don’t respect senior groups. Kpop was not this toxic before these 2017 fans came a long. Seohyun can outsing Twice whole group!
Seohyun's voice is just out of this world... It's mind blowing... It gives me goosebumps and chills because it's heavenly perfect... Her voice is soothing my soul...🥰😘😍🤩❣️❤️ So proud of you Maknae Seohyun 🥰 PRIDE of SNSD ...yes you are ...you truly proves it...😍🥰❤️❣️🤩😘💗💓💕 Our Queen 👑 A Sound Goddess 🤩😍😘❤️🥰 worth stanning 😊
No fancy clothes No outstanding choreography No stage effects Just PURE VOCAL And a WELL-TRUSTED Singer 🌸🌿 That’s our Girls’ Generation member That’s our Pride Seohyun 🕊🤍
There’s a reason she is performing in pyongyang. Pyongyang is a high class place in North Korea. Which means that they knew bright lights and singing and cameras exit
To Solehah Sohae, mbc is not uncommon. If you are a good person, if you work with Seohyun for a certain period of time not short, you will want to work with her again. From very young age she has accomplished all the work perfectly in good faith. So, all her skills have improved year by year. She was not always in the most prominent position, but she is a person who can help her group and even the nation’s peace to lead to success. I've never seen a person beyond her in that she can do her best in good faith against everything over the past ten years.
What can I expect? MEMBER OF A #1 GIRL GROUP IN ASIA... GIRLS' GENERATION👏 years have passed but still, the group and the members keep slaying and dominating the world, Im proud of this gays🙌👏👏👏👏
As a sone, I am really proud of her and admire her from the bottom of my heart; I'm sure the rest of the SNSD members do that too. Those who are shocked about how the audience swayed by Seohyun..... Just Imagine the whole group performing.... you would've no idea.
![[HARMONY] Baek Ji Young - 'Please, Don't forget me' @Spring is Coming20180405](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YGXFS0cMZtU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HARMONY] Baek Ji Young - 'Please, Don't forget me' @Spring is Coming20180405](/img/tr.png)
![[무삭제 풀버전] '우리는 하나'...남북평화협력기원 평양공연 / 연합뉴스TV (YonhapnewsTV)](/img/1.gif)
Reactions of North Korean audiences on this performance were surely different compared to others in the concert. This is North Korean song. They knew and had been very familiar with this song. Of course they were very glad that a singer from the south sang this song very beautifully. Good job Seohyun!!!
I saw the concert and it was alright I guess. They had a lot of rock and kpop which I don't think was a very good idea. This performance is one of the few that will be remembered by the audience. A classy song sung by, arguably, the epitome of south korean beauty.
do you know what the lyrics are about?
Is it a North korean song???
Nk audience while watching red velvet : 👁👄👁
Nk audience while watching seohyun : 😊👏👏
@@nininabam6032 yes it is.
The audience didn’t really give much of a reaction to the other performers but I’m glad that Seohyun was able to connect to the audience
Obnoxious, but Consistent YB also got great reactions in my opinion. A lot of the songs were also sad songs, so you can't expect much reaction, especially since the people were confronted to this style of music for the first time.
This is North Korean song. That's why audiences were very glad to watch Seohyun singing this song.
they can't cheer and sing the songs that are not from NK,that's a rule. Seohyun sang a song from NK so that's why they gave reaction only to her.. also he deserve it, she was sick and still looked and sounded grrat
Good point But that would become different with the original nine-member lineup. because the North Koreans are going to dislike Americans that would mean Jessica Tiffany & Sunny.
EpicThe112 as long as this was the same song probably they would have enjoyed too. never forget the power of snsd.
Okay but I find it so beautiful how everyone looked genuinely swayed by Seohyun 😍😍
I just read today that the song she's singing is a North Korean pop song!
octopu5ie is North Korea even have a pop song?
I once met Seohyun, and surely as you can see, she is a humble and genuine lady.. 👍👍👍
i think they prefer this kind of song..a pop ballad
리아나 the first time I see North Koreans smiling tbh lmao
SHE SOUNDS SO BEAUTIFUL! I can't believe she was sick during this performance!
So glad the audience's reaction was very positive ❤
Yuri Sakura she’s got a back injury that’s why she didn’t have any problem singing
Camila Matamoros, She’s not quite ok because she has sore throat she said it when MBC interview her.
Her under-eyes seems a bit darkened though
Because North Korean are familiar with this song. It’s actually a North Korean song. So their reaction were positive
Yeahhh true her voice sound so beautiful 😍
For me it's really not about how well she sang. It's about her sincerity in wanting to be part of this cultural exchange occasion. The way she handled everything from relations with the sk and nk performers, the interviews etc, really showed her maturity and good heart. She's really beautiful inside out. At least for me, it seems like that.
Jonathan Megan she was the perfect member out of all girls in SNSD to be the North -South Korean kpop idol diplomat. She’s naturally formal, very respectful, well postured and really musically well rounded.
I could imagine Hyoyeon feeling extremely awkward if she had to be a Kpop representative...I don’t think her body popping and locking moves would be well received....
Seohyun did us proud! It's really nice to see that she got a warm reaction as well
This is the main proof that no girlgroup will ever replace snsd.
Chayma El no one is aiming for that so stop acting like others want to snatch their title
Blackpink, RedVelvet, Twice, Itzy does
@Brandon Wijaya nope as a korean i can tell the fandom and influence of snsd in kor is much bigger than today's other girlgroups' including bp rv n tw
@@dxexnny yeah I know that, SNSD is the Grandmother of all girlgroup there, all hail the queen
@@brandonwijaya4757 no one is saying that someone is going to snatch their title, stop being so pressed. 🧚🏻✨
The pride of SNSD
Kari Haruka I bet her unnies are all feeling very proud of her, not long ago she’s so shy and seldom talked, I guess her unnies groom her to become what she is today.
They passed 10 years.. Time will really take care of everything.
Kari Haruka Pride of SK too👏👏 I can't believe Im stanning a walking Legends💓
+Buang Hassan What I wouldn't do for OT9 to reunite and share the stage again.
Original 9 is no good up in Pyongyang because if you watch CNN reporting by Will Ripley he's going to tell you that there is heavy anti American propaganda. Basically aimed at Jessica Sunny & Tiffany.
Most of the new kpoppers say this era is big and get more sales and so on. Little did they know, 1st and 2nd generation kpop idols are making a path for 3rd generation to be successful. They sometimes compared their groups stan to the legend groups. See right now this video is an example for a legend girl group only which is maknae of girls Generation Seohyun. Given the title as icon for cultural exchange in both korea.
RIGHT!
lmao just enjoy the performance 😂😂😂😂
marauders map she does have a point tho the groups rn are only riding on the coattails of their seniors' success. But dont get me wrong ofc i love the new gen and it's undeniable how successful they are, new fans just forget who paved the way and it's sad to see them disrespect the older groups (aosh im ranting again haha have a good day 😂)
Well said
jaemi g It doesn’t matter if you’re ranting. You’re 100% right though.
Snsd were not wrong when they aimed for WORLD DOMINATION
INDEED
i think World Peace seems a more appropriate term, she seems like the Peace ambassador or the White Dove of Korea.
Tse Hong Ling
It was called "girls n peace" for a reason
Awww, that's so graceful...our Seohyunnie, the White Dove of Korea!
WORLD PEACE DOMINATION, THAT'S IT!
in my opinion this type of k-music is more fitting to be exhibited in pyeongyang. you see the north korean audience reacted so well and enjoyed it better. it was a right decision to bring seohyun there
Hambaga The song she sang is a important north korean song, but I do not remember the name
Johan Adan how did u know this is important song to them when u dont even know the title of the song 😂 or u just read the comment from other “group fan” who also perform at the same event haha
Mieza yxnxs Of course she doesnt know the name of a famous NORTH Korean song. Are you forget that North Korea is so closed?
This was a North Korean song hence, it received a warm reaction from the audience.
Johan Adan isn’t the name of the song in the title of the video?
the "larararara" part killed me
lucas yes same! I always close my eyes at that part, her voice is just... wow
Me too 😍😍😿😿😿
Me too it is just so soothing and peaceful 🥺🥺🥺
Thank you God for Seohyun.
gotchu lol
Yessssss
Future president of South Korea right here
I have been saying that, too!
That would be crazy if the president of SK was also singing and dancing in the world's best ever girl group!
Please Korea! Have the Legendary President and Queen of the Earth at the same time! Make history with the power of Love and Girls!
Wtf-
This is an old comment , but you just reminded me of how Seohyun is back then😂 I remember when she would read a lot of books about political stuffs( I’m not sure)
Seohyun is so graceful and beautiful 💖👏🏽
yarsm *
Agree shes becoming even more beautiful now
My Girls Generation bias.
"Nation's Representative" everyone! 👏👏
kim gim agramon YES SIR
Even she get sick that she still did a good job
Seo Hyun ㅜㅜ ㅓ
she is so beautiful!!
Queen Maknae👑
Proud of her everything....💗
Voice skills😱🌼
SafiyeONE BYHN Her voice, no wonder she’s one of SNSD best vocalists.
She is making history. This is such an amazing performance and she looks and sounds perfect. I’m so proud☺️💗
HEY SWIFTIES
My queen be slaying the whole nation of North Korea
2010-2018 stand at the DMZ🇰🇷🇰🇵 you'll hear snsd Genie Way to Go possibly party on a loop
Do you even understand the meaning of nation? There is only one Korean nation divided into two states.
She is just breathtaking. And her voice? Perfection.
Seohyun is a literal QUEEN 💝💝💝👑
To some people who are misunderstanding, This lyric is a popular song that expresses emotionally about Green Willow. This has no political meaning at all./Dear people who wish for world peace, Music has neither an enemy nor an ally. Music exists equally for all people. And music sometimes moves people's mind. Music has the power to bring peace. I am a fan of Seohyun for many years and I am familiar with her ideas more than people other than her fans. So, what I can say with confidence is that she is one who wants world peace.
This! Well said
1:22 they clap clap and seem so happy when listen Seohyun sing different from other singers. so proud. (in my opinion)
Seohyun also sings differently than the DPRK's singers. They were really captivated with her, and they also knew of Girls Generation.
이때 감기걸려서 목소리 상태 안좋았는데 노래 넘넘잘불렀다는ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 한국와서도 계속 목상태 안좋아서 가수들 중 혼자 후보정 녹음도 못하고 당시 라이브 그대로 내보낸거ㅠㅠㅠ 엠씨 볼때 목소리 들어봐도 평소 서현이 목소리 아닌 많이 안좋은 상태였다는ㅠㅠㅠ근데 넘넘 잘해준 👍👍👍
Perfect as expected by SeoHyun ♥
beautiful ❤❤
As expected of our Maknae😍😍
Great performance she did a great job despite her back injury. 💖👏
glittershinee As I know, she had a soar throat.
Both
ㅐㅑ
glittershinee
SNSD members aren't wrong when they said Seohyun is SNSD's pride😍
Seohyun were having very high fever while at North Korea. I wouldn’t know 😰 because she sounds so perfect!
Seohyun and her professionalism must get the credit ✅
SNSD I MISS YOU
Tam Nguyen they'll be back
How could I find a perfect girl like Seohyun in K-POP industry now?!
She is absolutely flawless in her soul, her personality, her voice, her talent and her face and her body as well
Yes love the facts that she played piano, guitar and violin. Maknae jjang
I can feel her warmth from her voice ❤
I Stan legends only... Seo legend
Seohyun sounds amazing, so soft, so soothing! Can't believe she was sick while she performed this, what a legend indeed. So proud of her
#snsd'spride
서현 진짜 곱고 예쁘네요. 노래 잘하고 세상에 키도 크고 진심 여신삘...
Love you Seohyun💓
and love SNSD Forever💓💓😙
Not only the pride of SNSD but also the pride of Korea.
Her parents must be so proud of her. If i were them, i would definitely flexin about my daughter performing in north korea🥺
This is the first time I heard Seohyun sang live as a solo and I can say she did really great💜✨
North Korean audiences are fairly well known to be quite respectful and staid (not too much clapping or expression). But you can really tell that they LOVED Seohyun's performance of "Blue Willow" at the April 2018 "Spring is Coming" concert in Pyongyang. Four clapping breaks and a very loud applause with outstretched hands at the end.
you know what? SNSD Queen always slays wherever they perform
i need more song like this from seohyun oh my lord
the audience has such a great reaction 👏🏼
Wow couldn't understand a word but this is beautiful,music is an universal langauge and should be celebrated by all.
Pemilihan Lagu Seohyun di Korea Utara ini tepat, dan membuat penonton bertepuk tangan juga ada yg tersenyum.
Seohyun~♡노래넘잘한다~목소리맑고예뻐~♡단아하고아름답다~
the performance was perfect.
perfect vocals & her beautiful self
I'm in love. Seohyun is the true definition of grace
Im here because of "time" controversion, here i am end up admire her, she is so talented, i think i start to love her
Me too 😭
Same
Stan her. You won't regret! She's indeed multi-talented and smart. Aside from being a lead singer in SNSD back then, she can play various instruments, (but her forte is piano and guitar) and she's a musical actress, too.
Seohyun have a great voice 😍
서현이호응 젤좋아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
북한인 인줄알고 호응 좋은거임
Good job, Seobaby!!!
Ray Đặng i was looking for the true seofan comment!!!😂 Seobaby forever!! She did amazingly!!!
she’s improved her breath control so much compared to when she first started in snsd! In fact, she’s worked hard and improved basically every aspect of her voice. She sounds and looks gorgeous here 💙
"The medicine of the future will be music and sound."
-Edgar Cayce
She is an Angel in real life.. I see the peace in her eyes, also a beautiful face and aswell a very beautiful soul. I always love Seohyun ❤️
Seohyun is truly my pride as SONE. Yet ONCE said Seohyun is just average compare to Naeyeon. I almost got my self into a fight but im sure many people dissagree. Seohyun has many talents and skills than other idols. She is a pride of snsd
Lol Seohyun is even better than Jihyo , their Main Vocal 😂haha and they say Seohyun is average ,Omo , one of the cringiest sentence 😂
@@requaldebbarma3383 the very reason I hate TWICE AND THEIR FANDOM DAMN IT. GOTTA RESPECT LEGENDS.
Wtf.. I have nothing against the groups but I really don’t like new generation kpop fans! They’re so annoying and don’t respect senior groups. Kpop was not this toxic before these 2017 fans came a long. Seohyun can outsing Twice whole group!
Seohyun's vocal alone can end Twice's combined vocals😂
I have to Disagree..... Not even Jihyo could pass Seohyun's Vocal range.....
Thank you Seohyun ! ♥
Coming back to this beautiful performance of the Seohyun ❤️
Seohyun's voice is just out of this world... It's mind blowing... It gives me goosebumps and chills because it's heavenly perfect... Her voice is soothing my soul...🥰😘😍🤩❣️❤️
So proud of you Maknae Seohyun 🥰
PRIDE of SNSD ...yes you are ...you truly proves it...😍🥰❤️❣️🤩😘💗💓💕 Our Queen 👑 A Sound Goddess 🤩😍😘❤️🥰 worth stanning 😊
This is such a nice song and Seohyun's voice is very pleasing too 😍
keep watching this video her voice really amazing!!!
Seohyun never fails to makes us proud at whatever she does 😢😢😢
omg look at seohyun getting happy reactions from the audience, only seo ju hyun
No fancy clothes
No outstanding choreography
No stage effects
Just PURE VOCAL
And a WELL-TRUSTED Singer 🌸🌿
That’s our Girls’ Generation member
That’s our Pride Seohyun 🕊🤍
I'm so proud of her. Truely Nation Treasure. You're so perfect Seohyun!
Despite having a terrible flu and waist pain, she still manages to show is why she is the best ❤️
There’s a reason she is performing in pyongyang. Pyongyang is a high class place in North Korea. Which means that they knew bright lights and singing and cameras exit
as a SONE, I'm so proud of my girls. As expected, SEOHYUN is SNSD's pride!! Love herrrrrrrrr!
To Solehah Sohae, mbc is not uncommon. If you are a good person, if you work with Seohyun for a certain period of time not short, you will want to work with her again. From very young age she has accomplished all the work perfectly in good faith. So, all her skills have improved year by year. She was not always in the most prominent position, but she is a person who can help her group and even the nation’s peace to lead to success. I've never seen a person beyond her in that she can do her best in good faith against everything over the past ten years.
the male audience smiled a lot, because the melody and Seohyun's voice were like a sweet angel's song inviting to unite
서현아 ! 사랑해 !
It's hard to believe that our shy maknae is now part of the reason that North and South Korea are choosing to unite, I'm so proud of her 💜
Seohyun she is quite famous
she's an angel ♥♥
She did well
The way she walks,smile and sing is so elegant . She was once our seobaby but now she has grown to a fine and beautiful woman shes now our seolady😭
What can I expect? MEMBER OF A #1 GIRL GROUP IN ASIA... GIRLS' GENERATION👏 years have passed but still, the group and the members keep slaying and dominating the world, Im proud of this gays🙌👏👏👏👏
I'm proud with sm artist!!! They always cool!!! 🤧🤧😭😭😍
I think I started love this song and listen to it again and again because Seohyun sing it very well and flawless 😍
This is beautiful Seohyun so beautiful ❤
Wow the audience response is really good! Good job SeoHyun
Beauty, brain, behaviour.. A whole package in Seohyun... 😊
I mean who doesn't fall in love with her ❤
Seohyun Korea so proud of you ❤
Pride of SNSD. I love SEOHYUN ❤❤
We are proud of you seohyun♡~~
Yes! Seohyun! You did great! Saranghaeyo 😍😚
As a sone, I am really proud of her and admire her from the bottom of my heart; I'm sure the rest of the SNSD members do that too. Those who are shocked about how the audience swayed by Seohyun..... Just Imagine the whole group performing.... you would've no idea.
The pride of Girl's Generation Seohyun 😱💖
her voice is so beautiful 😭❤
this song is so beautiful and seohyun did so well
I fall in love with this song and seohyun angelic voice
Seohyun - Beautiful in white💖💖💖
seo's voice is so soothing, i can listen to this forever♡
Seohyun you are so gorgeous, and you did so well baby.😭 I am happy you arrived safely and well back home. Get well soon unnie.❤️
So beautiful.... Goddess 💖
단아하고 고급스럽다.