One thing that seems a bit dubious, is when you add the magsafe chargers, none of them seem to be charging your phone. Don't know if that makes a difference or not, but it sort of kills this test if all things are working properly.
The problem is, magsafe accessories have different magnets that may affect the S-pen. Best magsafe case I've seen with any accessories that will stick at the back is the Magbak case, I suggest you try that one.
So if I have an accessory which affects the pen when attached to one case, then if I swap the case to a Magbak case, the same accessory then doesn't affect the pen?
@BoxOfChocs the magbak case has a magnetic shielding to keep it from messing with the s-pen, other cases do not have this shielding and that's why the accessories affect it, the magbak cases prevent this.
Great info.. I only roll with Caseborne. Mainly because I'm a TX Boy. 🤟 I had the R Series Red Trim/Black Carbon Fiber on my S22 Ultra since its release & that phone didn't have a single micro scratch on it & the case still looks brand new. I did try a MagSafe Case once & had no issues w/ the S-Pen on my 22 Ultra, but now that I have the S24 Ultra? I've contacted Caseborne about another R Series for this new phone. Still waiting. I loved that case. When reviewers say, "the buttons are snappy" they are with Caseborne but, not with Spigen cases. At least the Spigen Armour case that I had. The buttons were harder to push, so to speak.
I can confirm that the Rokform S24 Ultra Magsafe compatible case works with the S Pen, so long as you use the plastic Roklock plug and not the additionally included Magnetic plug. Thankfully the internal case magnets are strong enough to hold the phone on a metal surface
Think it depends on the accessories attachment. Mine does interfere. Pitaka mag ez amd keyring holder for example. All 4 cases ive tested with ESR and Spigen and UAG interfaces with spen
All of the ESR, Spigen, and UAG cases interfered with open when no accessories are attached? Or only when accessories are attached. I think MagBak is the only one I've heard of not affecting spen because they put a shielding layer to block the magnet.
I wonder if the team making the S Pen sensors designed it for Qi2, but the guys putting the charger in just didn't put the Qi2 system in. For those who haven't heard of Qi2, it's basically Apple worked with the guys designing the Qi standard to put magnets in all Qi wireless charging devices.
Please provide your inputs on long term usage of magnetic accessories on phone hardware and performance since Samsung hasn't officially designed them Magsafe...? Thank you
This was not my experience with the Ringke case from this video! I have 4 magsafe cases for my S24 Ultra and they all interfere with the S Pen. this evening I just wanted to search RUclips to see if indeed there is a magsafe case that works without problems with the spen. I've been looking for a while and found this video as well as many others like it from different reviewers. This is not how you test for this scenario. Only the very worst magsafe cases don't register the s pen writing at all but all cases I have tested, in different degrees, misaling the s pen input line with the spen tip as you write on the screen and pass over the magnets. And in most cases it becomes unusable. Ringke is a good example of that, otherwise an excellent case, would have been my preferred one. Yet in the video a very fast swipe with the pen over the screen and this glitch is not detectable. Seems to me most tech reviews become less and less useful because of misleading info or superficial tests. This is not good for reviewers or users in the long term.
Hey, how about proving the precision of the spen, I have muy 24ultra with a cheap case with magsafe compatibility, sometimes no issues with lines sometimes yes, but always the tiny point or the cursor gets a bit off the middle position, like 1mm off the correct place... I didn't invest yet in a branded case because I don't know if this will be a persistent issue, beyond the interrupted lines alone.. nobody made a video showing how the pointer it's affected in the precision, the app I use more is "Concepts", the tip of the pencils or any tool I use goes 1mm out of right place usually to the right side of the spen, like I am right handed, that place the tip under the spen and let me with 0 precision use of it, don't sure if this happens with high branded cases like the ones you show here or dbrand, spigen or others.. I can't buy it and prove cuz here it's imposible to get those... and get them form ebay Amazon, etc makes them cost 3x with the shipping.. so for me is not worth buy to maybe not get any problem.. could you check it? I am sure a video of that can show even more detail of the quality of this cases, maybe they didn't get any line issue, but they may precision issues not so visible by drawing continuos lines across the whole screen passing by middle but draw lines starting in diferent screen zones and watch carefully how the pointer act... thank you
Hi. Thank you for your video. So I have an ESR magsafe case (1500 gf) with which the pen seems to work ok with, but as soon as I put a fingerloop accessory (by Aurox) on it (really strong N53 magnet), the spen skips like crazy. Even with my finger, it doesn't seem to work seamlessly. What do you think could be the problem? And I even have the display sensitivity up like when using a screen protector. The magnetic accessories you used, did they have a strong magnet?
Hi,I have ESR case with magsafe and doesn't affect s-pan but affect camera when you zoom in after past 5X zoom the image become blurry and doesn't come clear. Doesn't camere you use or Which mode you are video or photo, try this.
can you make a video on how to fix your S24U if the magnetic case (ring embedded inside case) has interferred with the S Pen and the touchscreen capabilities on the front screen of the phone, help!! how do I fix this? mu can't turn my phone off and the side button setting are all messed up.
No dude it doesn't work... you had your s pen outside the slot all the time so it was already connected to the phone... try putting the pen in the socket.....put on the magnetic cover and then try to use s pen... it will not be detected/connected to the phone... so there is an issue after all...
![Diggy Graves - Red Vineyard [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Ro085T0mnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
It works with the spigen magsafe armor. It has a linen inside that helps the magnet not affect the spen even when accessories are connected
Hi there, could you share the link of the spigen case.
Have you used S-pen with Magsafe Popsocket attached to the case?
Yes! You made just the video I was hoping for. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Subscribed!
One thing that seems a bit dubious, is when you add the magsafe chargers, none of them seem to be charging your phone. Don't know if that makes a difference or not, but it sort of kills this test if all things are working properly.
The problem is, magsafe accessories have different magnets that may affect the S-pen. Best magsafe case I've seen with any accessories that will stick at the back is the Magbak case, I suggest you try that one.
So if I have an accessory which affects the pen when attached to one case, then if I swap the case to a Magbak case, the same accessory then doesn't affect the pen?
@BoxOfChocs the magbak case has a magnetic shielding to keep it from messing with the s-pen, other cases do not have this shielding and that's why the accessories affect it, the magbak cases prevent this.
Great info..
I only roll with Caseborne.
Mainly because I'm a TX Boy. 🤟
I had the R Series Red Trim/Black Carbon Fiber on my S22 Ultra since its release & that phone didn't have a single micro scratch on it & the case still looks brand new.
I did try a MagSafe Case once & had no issues w/ the S-Pen on my 22 Ultra, but now that I have the S24 Ultra?
I've contacted Caseborne about another R Series for this new phone. Still waiting.
I loved that case. When reviewers say, "the buttons are snappy" they are with Caseborne but, not with Spigen cases.
At least the Spigen Armour case that I had. The buttons were harder to push, so to speak.
What about Mous - MagSafe case ?
I can confirm that the Rokform S24 Ultra Magsafe compatible case works with the S Pen, so long as you use the plastic Roklock plug and not the additionally included Magnetic plug. Thankfully the internal case magnets are strong enough to hold the phone on a metal surface
Think it depends on the accessories attachment. Mine does interfere. Pitaka mag ez amd keyring holder for example. All 4 cases ive tested with ESR and Spigen and UAG interfaces with spen
All of the ESR, Spigen, and UAG cases interfered with open when no accessories are attached? Or only when accessories are attached. I think MagBak is the only one I've heard of not affecting spen because they put a shielding layer to block the magnet.
I wonder if the team making the S Pen sensors designed it for Qi2, but the guys putting the charger in just didn't put the Qi2 system in. For those who haven't heard of Qi2, it's basically Apple worked with the guys designing the Qi standard to put magnets in all Qi wireless charging devices.
Doesnt work with ESR cases or ESR Accessories.
I second this. I have an ESR Boost case and it seems like all the magsafe accessories I have, cause line breaks pretty bad.
I got the esr boost flickstand with halolock as I really wanted both the magsafe and a stand but the spen breaks even without acessories.
@@mdk124 Me tol have this case can confirm this, S pen I broken without any accessories attached with this case
YEP!!! my ESR Case with Halolock interferes really bad. GONNA BE SENDING THAT BACK!!
Yes...I have the same issue. It is a stylus bender..
Please provide your inputs on long term usage of magnetic accessories on phone hardware and performance since Samsung hasn't officially designed them Magsafe...? Thank you
Ya I have UAG case but every accessory I have interferes with S Pen
Wonder why
@@TheAverageTechGuy not sure. Maybe accessories use different magnets and I just got the odd one. But they are all name brand.
This was not my experience with the Ringke case from this video! I have 4 magsafe cases for my S24 Ultra and they all interfere with the S Pen. this evening I just wanted to search RUclips to see if indeed there is a magsafe case that works without problems with the spen. I've been looking for a while and found this video as well as many others like it from different reviewers. This is not how you test for this scenario. Only the very worst magsafe cases don't register the s pen writing at all but all cases I have tested, in different degrees, misaling the s pen input line with the spen tip as you write on the screen and pass over the magnets. And in most cases it becomes unusable. Ringke is a good example of that, otherwise an excellent case, would have been my preferred one. Yet in the video a very fast swipe with the pen over the screen and this glitch is not detectable. Seems to me most tech reviews become less and less useful because of misleading info or superficial tests. This is not good for reviewers or users in the long term.
Hey, how about proving the precision of the spen, I have muy 24ultra with a cheap case with magsafe compatibility, sometimes no issues with lines sometimes yes, but always the tiny point or the cursor gets a bit off the middle position, like 1mm off the correct place... I didn't invest yet in a branded case because I don't know if this will be a persistent issue, beyond the interrupted lines alone.. nobody made a video showing how the pointer it's affected in the precision, the app I use more is "Concepts", the tip of the pencils or any tool I use goes 1mm out of right place usually to the right side of the spen, like I am right handed, that place the tip under the spen and let me with 0 precision use of it, don't sure if this happens with high branded cases like the ones you show here or dbrand, spigen or others.. I can't buy it and prove cuz here it's imposible to get those... and get them form ebay Amazon, etc makes them cost 3x with the shipping.. so for me is not worth buy to maybe not get any problem.. could you check it? I am sure a video of that can show even more detail of the quality of this cases, maybe they didn't get any line issue, but they may precision issues not so visible by drawing continuos lines across the whole screen passing by middle but draw lines starting in diferent screen zones and watch carefully how the pointer act... thank you
My question is more about compass use with magnets and whether all the people complaining about antenna damage, etc., are nuts.
Hi. Thank you for your video.
So I have an ESR magsafe case (1500 gf) with which the pen seems to work ok with, but as soon as I put a fingerloop accessory (by Aurox) on it (really strong N53 magnet), the spen skips like crazy. Even with my finger, it doesn't seem to work seamlessly. What do you think could be the problem? And I even have the display sensitivity up like when using a screen protector. The magnetic accessories you used, did they have a strong magnet?
Hi,I have ESR case with magsafe and doesn't affect s-pan but affect camera when you zoom in after past 5X zoom the image become blurry and doesn't come clear. Doesn't camere you use or Which mode you are video or photo, try this.
Thank you for this video. I was wondering if they affected the s-pen.
can you make a video on how to fix your S24U if the magnetic case (ring embedded inside case) has interferred with the S Pen and the touchscreen capabilities on the front screen of the phone, help!! how do I fix this? mu can't turn my phone off and the side button setting are all messed up.
Verizon told me they have not been approved yet and cannot say they won't damage the phone.
What is the model ID of your s24 ultra?
Link for the clear case?
what about supcase ub mag xt ?
I don't know but I'm going to be finding out on Sunday. I'll try to remember to get back here for the answer.
Compass ?
Can I use the apple marketed mag chargers like the qi2
No dude it doesn't work... you had your s pen outside the slot all the time so it was already connected to the phone... try putting the pen in the socket.....put on the magnetic cover and then try to use s pen... it will not be detected/connected to the phone... so there is an issue after all...
Yeah until you connect something to it you know like to hold it with then you spend don't work
My brother ❤, that line tho❤
Caseborn link is the uag link
You do realize it has nothing to do with the case itself it's when you have something attached
ESR FLICKSTAND BOOST HALOLOCK GALAXY S24 ULTRA CLEAR. it does not detect the pen in many places.Why?
get a ruler and draw a straight line
No thanks.