My opinion is that Neha Dixit is not the sort to give up. She'll come back full power next year 2025 more experience with her practice etc. I'm optimistic for her (Neha)
She is the best. A complete treat to watch. Melodious in voice and appearance as well. She is enviously pretty, intelligent and talented. While 1st two attributes are God gifted and permanent, the talent part can be honed more. Being intelligent she can improve much faster than anyone. I think she is on her way to be Lata 2.0. She just have to focus on her talent. Rest assured a legend in making. Next few decades she will be the toast of the nation. Best wishes. Just don't step in to Bollywood illusions. Work on the rare talent you have. Best wishes to Neha Dixit.
I just saw now that you are not selected in top 15 of Indian idol … please please don’t get disappointed and discouraged… you are a great singer as well as a good person… you deserve in top 5 .. but please remember that once Shreya was also rejected in saregama and see now!!! You are having an amazing voice quality… please don’t give up with one rejection… 👍🙏🙏I know you will come back stronger than ever 👍👍👍🙏
The decision was actually right. Granted she has very beautiful voice but she she couldn't make her singing alive. She sang the lyrics but couldn't convey the song.
I believe she should've chosen an easy song. Of course it was a hard song and shreya was right and absolutely right, neha is a good singer but she should chose songs she can actually sing instead of singing legendary with a lot of vocal modulations
Sirf voice quality acchi hone se hi Indian idol nahin ban jate.ganne ko samajhkar acche se perfectly ganna bhi patdhta hain.shreya ghosal judgment is 💯% correct.app sirf voice quality dekhkar mat bataon ki woh top 15 jayega ki nahi jayega,I always respect shreya and Vishal dadlanis judgment.💯
She is Shreya Ghoshal not Neha Kakkar. None can evade her judgements. Unlike earlier Indian Idols where you only need a story to get selected. Neha is a child infront of Shreya.
Kuch aur reason kya hai, ap boliye. Kyon anap shanap bol ke logo ko uksa rahen hai. Lag raha hai ap bade ustad hain. Tho Phir jakar judge ke seat par baith jaiye. As said Shreya Ghoshal ke judgement ko question na karein. Yeh Neha Kakkar nahi hain.
Neha's voice is beautiful. She should have been given another opportunity. Some songs are very typical that expert singers also make mistakes while singing such songs. She has got beautiful voice.
Neha is really a versatile singer and i promise u she will there in the industry soon like our great singer from utrakhand Nautiyal ji who were sacked by Sh sonu Nigam ji in a music competition .
Shreya is beyond any doubt and prejudice of any sort. However, painfully wonder about Neha's disqualification. I cannot think of any contemporary singer better than Neha. My love, good wishes and blessings for the dear girl, Neha. She will be the next melody queen.
All people who don't know or understand the ABC of singing and music commenting on Neha Kakkar. In today's generation of female Bollywood singers, Neha is among the top three.
Salon k baad real indian idol dekh rahe hai judges gaane k uper comment or correction ker rahe hai,nhn toh last few year ka indian idol mey toh aisa kuch nhn dekha aisa lag rha tha ki sabhi conrestant pro hai koi judgement nhn bas suno or taarif karo😂
I liked Neha Dixit voice and she has potential of becoming play back singer and shreya guided her well. Neha will come back next year or wild card this year itself
Neha don't get bogged down by the rejection. There is nothing wrong in the performance. It was sheer bad luck. Practice and practice and practice for one more year. You will shine. You have a challenge to win and prove everyone wrong. Closing the eyes I found her voice the most melodious. May be expectations of judges were subconsciously much higher.. like Lata 1.0. Aap khare utroge. For sure. 🎉
Competition is of high standard. Local competition mein cha jaane wale contestants yahan phike pad jaate hain. The judges are very good in their selection. Shreyaji aur Vishal ji ka koyi judgement galat nahin hua abhi tak.
She has the attribute of a singer but is too hesitant to deliver in her singing..she has to come back stronger and firmer..she'll surely have a great future in music.
Wo behtareen singer zaroor thi. But Shreya ma'am ne jo bola wo bilkul correct hai. Unhone Neha ko bilkul accurately judge kiya. Jab aapko singing samajh nahi aati kyon aise controversial reaction videos banate ho? Aapko pata bhi Shreya ma'am ki potential to not only song bt also judge true singing? Pls next time se don't do this. Also ppl who are telling this song was difficult and all, did u notice she had made mistakes in her last performance also? (Badmash dil) And shreya ma'am had pointed out to that as well. Voice quality is not everything. U have to work on your talent to attain success.
@HasanReels why are u commenting on singing when u dont even know the S of singing haan? Also u r supporting ppl who are speaking shits about Shreya ma'am and all these. U think Neha is better than Shreya ma'am. Tum log jo gana sunte ho based on voice dumb ho full. Abey gana bas sweet voice se nahi banti. It need proper notes, emotions, drama, etc which is very much lacking in Neha. IT WAS NOT A BIASED DECISION ATALL!!! Also what do u ppl think here. Tum logo ka yaha non sense bakne se Shreya ma'am affected hongi? Haan? Matlab ppl here are simply speaking whatever they like. "Neha is not selected becoz shes not from WB", etc. Abey if u know atleast something about singing u ppl would understand why she's eliminated. Neha needs more training and i am sure she'll come back bettr next yr.❤
@iamdebu1994 who said ? WB candidates ok, one or two people are talented. Not more than 6 to 8 candidates. What about other states ? what about south states ? If WB candidates are talented, why no one candidate won the previous season Trophies. Wb singers are highly recommended candidates. Indian Idol audition conducted only north state cities not south. Why audition they didn't conduct in South cities ? They didn't like South states. Its not Indian Idol, its West Bengal Idol.
Sir last mei jo apne kaha ou thik hei, lekin ek judge sab kuch notice karte hei, sirf good Voice hona, that's not a mandatory... They are judges, unke parakh hum audience se 100 gunaa better hei...
नेहा ने जो हरकतों ली वो कमज़ोर रह गईं । voice projection और strong चाहिए था। थोड़ा less in feel... नेहा can make it..she has the potential....but wonderfully blessed voice quality!
Guys stop judging wrong way he has good quality of singing doesn't mean she is good singer 2 of her performance there were mistakes happened indian idol is not joke you need to be perfect
Shreya is on the dot about Neha. Sound quality is great of Neha... but she doesn't sing openly with expressions. Her facial expression is not there at all, though she looks pretty, Neha is nervous or shy we have no idea. I believe someone should train her on expression and to sing with confidence. Hope she gets one more opportunity ❤
Shirf voice achcha hone se achcha singer nahi ban pati koi ,..... Neha ki gaiki me Kami thi , Jo Kami thi Shreya ne achche se samjha di use . Ab use mehnat karna Pedega. Lol winner banne ke kabil avi tak nahi hua . Fact , She has golden voice but she is not enough ready. @@DurgaThapa-u4o
Judge ko sab kuch notice kartahai unko blame mat kijiye bhai aur behnon awaaz mithahai manta hun lekin ek voice power hotahai woh jo power milnatha woh nhi hai yeh notice ki judgenebhi
very good voice and singer but very sad to know that she is not in top 15. the other girl singing with her was given 15 minutes and all judges talking too much with her unnecessary.
I m very hearted or vo dar gayi bechari pahle vali ka performed dekh kr me bhi esi hi hu😢 mene relate kiya or ha me bahut dukhi neha ko nikal diya but i hope vo wildcart me fir aaye muzse bada khush nhi koi hogi🥲
Neha looks like Swarup Sampat from naram garam.... She needs little bit acting in her song.... She is a quiet shy girl.... bit that doesnt help her singing
I think sg is just jealous of neha. Because, when the previous video got viral every one praised neha than her. One day, neha will be the Queen of Bollywood.
Kuch bhi..viral hone se bhi kya hota h?? Dono ki singing me zameen aasman ka fark h... Shreya Ghoshal ki jesi similar texture hone se hi log Shreya Ghoshal nahi bn jaate.. Shreya ki singing me unki command expertise effortlessness sb sunta h..bs awaz mithi hona hi kaafi nahi hota...
My opinion is that Neha Dixit is not the sort to give up. She'll come back full power next year 2025 more experience with her practice etc. I'm optimistic for her (Neha)
Rejection means she will come in Bollywood as a playback singer 💯% guarantee
She is very beautiful and will get role in ekta kapoor and big boss...dont worry neha
Those who can't afford Shreya will surely take her.only thing she needs is confidence
She deserved to be there. 😨
She is the best. A complete treat to watch. Melodious in voice and appearance as well. She is enviously pretty, intelligent and talented. While 1st two attributes are God gifted and permanent, the talent part can be honed more. Being intelligent she can improve much faster than anyone. I think she is on her way to be Lata 2.0. She just have to focus on her talent. Rest assured a legend in making. Next few decades she will be the toast of the nation. Best wishes. Just don't step in to Bollywood illusions. Work on the rare talent you have. Best wishes to Neha Dixit.
I just saw now that you are not selected in top 15 of Indian idol … please please don’t get disappointed and discouraged… you are a great singer as well as a good person… you deserve in top 5 .. but please remember that once Shreya was also rejected in saregama and see now!!! You are having an amazing voice quality… please don’t give up with one rejection… 👍🙏🙏I know you will come back stronger than ever 👍👍👍🙏
Shreya ji is very strict in her profession and not baised to anything
The decision was actually right. Granted she has very beautiful voice but she she couldn't make her singing alive. She sang the lyrics but couldn't convey the song.
SG is absolutely right.
My hearing the 1st note I would've also done the same thing .
I believe she should've chosen an easy song. Of course it was a hard song and shreya was right and absolutely right, neha is a good singer but she should chose songs she can actually sing instead of singing legendary with a lot of vocal modulations
You are right ✅️
Shreya Ghoshal was spot on with her judgment. Neha has an extraordinary voice but lacks confidence and sings as if someone is holding her back.
Neha Dixit is sanskriti ladki🎉❤ I like 🎉❤❤ Neha dixit
Sirf voice quality acchi hone se hi Indian idol nahin ban jate.ganne ko samajhkar acche se perfectly ganna bhi patdhta hain.shreya ghosal judgment is 💯% correct.app sirf voice quality dekhkar mat bataon ki woh top 15 jayega ki nahi jayega,I always respect shreya and Vishal dadlanis judgment.💯
What an analysis by Shreya.... Superb.. Respects from Pakistan
She is Shreya Ghoshal not Neha Kakkar. None can evade her judgements. Unlike earlier Indian Idols where you only need a story to get selected. Neha is a child infront of Shreya.
Kuch aur reason kya hai, ap boliye. Kyon anap shanap bol ke logo ko uksa rahen hai. Lag raha hai ap bade ustad hain. Tho Phir jakar judge ke seat par baith jaiye. As said Shreya Ghoshal ke judgement ko question na karein. Yeh Neha Kakkar nahi hain.
@@shamyobanerjee2986 Bhai pahle jo bola uska matlab toh samaj lo...
@souravsaha193 mainay jo likha hai usko matlab Pehle ap samjho. Hindi Mein kachhe lagthay ho.
Neha is a best beautiful voice...... Rong judgement of Shreya ghoshal
@@shamyobanerjee2986 who is questioning shreya ghoshal's judgement? My comment was for those who were saying Shreya did wrong judgement.
She was my favourite contastant.😢
Shreya Mam is the best judge for Indian Idol...
Neha's voice is beautiful. She should have been given another opportunity. Some songs are very typical that expert singers also make mistakes while singing such songs. She has got beautiful voice.
What are you saying Bhai Shreya ghosal is best judge she knows everything
Neha is really a versatile singer and i promise u she will there in the industry soon like our great singer from utrakhand Nautiyal ji who were sacked by Sh sonu Nigam ji in a music competition .
Neha is not ready yet. She was not able to do justice to this song. Shreya Ghoshal's feedback was completely true.
She sang this song very plain and too soft... Shreya knows the song very well...
Ghoshal ji, ek esa judge hei, jo Har kisi ko barike se samjhati hei, chahe ou select ho ye na ho.... ❤
Shreya is beyond any doubt and prejudice of any sort.
However, painfully wonder about Neha's disqualification. I cannot think of any contemporary singer better than Neha. My love, good wishes and blessings for the dear girl, Neha. She will be the next melody queen.
All people who don't know or understand the ABC of singing and music commenting on Neha Kakkar. In today's generation of female Bollywood singers, Neha is among the top three.
She got beautiful voice...she will come again...
Salon k baad real indian idol dekh rahe hai judges gaane k uper comment or correction ker rahe hai,nhn toh last few year ka indian idol mey toh aisa kuch nhn dekha aisa lag rha tha ki sabhi conrestant pro hai koi judgement nhn bas suno or taarif karo😂
Neha must have been in the top 15.
I liked Neha Dixit voice and she has potential of becoming play back singer and shreya guided her well. Neha will come back next year or wild card this year itself
Neha Dixit was quite desreving. She should hv been given a chance. Has a very melodious voice. I hope they hv a wild card entry n she comes back.
Shreya is right here....she has such a sweet voice...but nervous
Neha don't get bogged down by the rejection. There is nothing wrong in the performance. It was sheer bad luck. Practice and practice and practice for one more year. You will shine. You have a challenge to win and prove everyone wrong. Closing the eyes I found her voice the most melodious. May be expectations of judges were subconsciously much higher.. like Lata 1.0. Aap khare utroge. For sure. 🎉
She is good singer
If she is not selected in indian idol she will become superstar
She is very beautiful like a bollywood actress❤❤❤❤
Competition is of high standard. Local competition mein cha jaane wale contestants yahan phike pad jaate hain. The judges are very good in their selection. Shreyaji aur Vishal ji ka koyi judgement galat nahin hua abhi tak.
She has the attribute of a singer but is too hesitant to deliver in her singing..she has to come back stronger and firmer..she'll surely have a great future in music.
Love dancing 🎶🎶🎵 love Indian idol and music 🎵🎵🎵 lovely style
Neha will come top 16 or 17..
Need more polished, then she will be a Diamond..
Wo behtareen singer zaroor thi. But Shreya ma'am ne jo bola wo bilkul correct hai. Unhone Neha ko bilkul accurately judge kiya. Jab aapko singing samajh nahi aati kyon aise controversial reaction videos banate ho? Aapko pata bhi Shreya ma'am ki potential to not only song bt also judge true singing? Pls next time se don't do this.
Also ppl who are telling this song was difficult and all, did u notice she had made mistakes in her last performance also? (Badmash dil)
And shreya ma'am had pointed out to that as well. Voice quality is not everything. U have to work on your talent to attain success.
Jinko gaane ka G bhi pata nehi hai woh bhi aaya hai Shreya ki judgement pe ungli karne 😂 wah bhai wah. Hey jagannatha premanande yeh kya hua 😂
Yes,...Ghar Ghar Pe Lata Ji , Kishore Kumar Baitha Haina 😅,.... Good Voice Hone Se Koi Acha Singer Nahi Ban Jata . Yeh Public Kiu Samajh Nahi Raha 🤡
Real jujment ho raha hai Shreya great singer hai
It was electrifying performance 🎉
Neha ki voice aachi ek mauka milna chahiye tah
Koi bat nhi dekhna aane wale time me wo famous hogi 🤗💞
voice of himachal ki winner hai wo
@HasanReels why are u commenting on singing when u dont even know the S of singing haan? Also u r supporting ppl who are speaking shits about Shreya ma'am and all these. U think Neha is better than Shreya ma'am. Tum log jo gana sunte ho based on voice dumb ho full. Abey gana bas sweet voice se nahi banti. It need proper notes, emotions, drama, etc which is very much lacking in Neha.
IT WAS NOT A BIASED DECISION ATALL!!!
Also what do u ppl think here. Tum logo ka yaha non sense bakne se Shreya ma'am affected hongi? Haan? Matlab ppl here are simply speaking whatever they like. "Neha is not selected becoz shes not from WB", etc. Abey if u know atleast something about singing u ppl would understand why she's eliminated.
Neha needs more training and i am sure she'll come back bettr next yr.❤
Attendance Indian songs lover
So sweet voice
Neha bahut achha gati thi
This is Shreya Ghoshal madam.
She looks like pooja sharma❤
She can come back in Wild Card entry maybe…her voice is very sweet…
Neha just wow ❤❤❤❤
God desison by Shreya
Anyone from Kolkata
It was a good decision by shreya mam. Her voice quality is too good but this performance was normal. With this performance she was not fit for top 15.
Neha digital and prativa were my most favourite but both are out.
I think Neha Dixit not a West Bengal girl that's way she didn't selected. If she is a West Bengal girl then she will be selected.
😂 why are so jealous of west bengal all the singers from wb are selected based on merit
@iamdebu1994 who said ? WB candidates ok, one or two people are talented. Not more than 6 to 8 candidates. What about other states ? what about south states ? If WB candidates are talented, why no one candidate won the previous season Trophies. Wb singers are highly recommended candidates. Indian Idol audition conducted only north state cities not south. Why audition they didn't conduct in South cities ? They didn't like South states. Its not Indian Idol, its West Bengal Idol.
Very nice voice ❤❤
Yarrr es lrki.ki Awaz bht achi hy
Sir last mei jo apne kaha ou thik hei, lekin ek judge sab kuch notice karte hei, sirf good Voice hona, that's not a mandatory... They are judges, unke parakh hum audience se 100 gunaa better hei...
नेहा ने जो हरकतों ली वो कमज़ोर रह गईं । voice projection और strong चाहिए था। थोड़ा less in feel... नेहा can make it..she has the potential....but wonderfully blessed voice quality!
Absolutely sahi decision.....wese koi baat na ....Arijit ko hi dekh lo..... winner na hone k wabozoot Aaj wo kahan h...
Guys stop judging wrong way he has good quality of singing doesn't mean she is good singer 2 of her performance there were mistakes happened indian idol is not joke you need to be perfect
S who is good and rejected they will be shining like a star like arjithsing
Speech less
Are ye sab iski editing ki wajah se Out ho gyi chiii iski video editing Chutiya editing ek number 😂😂😂
Idol 14 was failure because of vishal n shreya become emotional but back vishal
Shreya is on the dot about Neha. Sound quality is great of Neha... but she doesn't sing openly with expressions. Her facial expression is not there at all, though she looks pretty, Neha is nervous or shy we have no idea. I believe someone should train her on expression and to sing with confidence. Hope she gets one more opportunity ❤
Neha deserves to be in this competition to prove herself . Her voice quality is really good.
This is a competition bro.
@@k.m.alaminbaqee If she gone in SAREGAMAPA she could have been winner. FACT
Shirf voice achcha hone se achcha singer nahi ban pati koi ,..... Neha ki gaiki me Kami thi , Jo Kami thi Shreya ne achche se samjha di use . Ab use mehnat karna Pedega.
Lol winner banne ke kabil avi tak nahi hua .
Fact , She has golden voice but she is not enough ready.
@@DurgaThapa-u4o
@@Sb-th2bg I'm Talking about SAREGAMAPA and their standard not IDOL.
Yaha se jitne Wale ki bhi baad me koi aukat nahi hogi to ye kya hai😂😂
Judge ko sab kuch notice kartahai unko blame mat kijiye bhai aur behnon awaaz mithahai manta hun lekin ek voice power hotahai woh jo power milnatha woh nhi hai yeh notice ki judgenebhi
Waoo... Neha ❤
very good voice and singer but very sad to know that she is not in top 15. the other girl singing with her was given 15 minutes and all judges talking too much with her unnecessary.
She is playback singer
I m very hearted or vo dar gayi bechari pahle vali ka performed dekh kr me bhi esi hi hu😢 mene relate kiya or ha me bahut dukhi neha ko nikal diya but i hope vo wildcart me fir aaye muzse bada khush nhi koi hogi🥲
we hope so
Noooo doubt ... She has soulful voice .... But singing is not that good ..... Even beginners like me can notice .
Yr sabhi logo ko nhi kiya ja sakta na , so yahi hai ki ek dam perfect hona pdega
Neha looks like Swarup Sampat from naram garam.... She needs little bit acting in her song.... She is a quiet shy girl.... bit that doesnt help her singing
She wrong song in theatre round. That's etc. Don't worry guys she will rise to the top one day with conviction
Bilkul sahi decision. Shreyaji ne perfectly Nehaji ka khamiyan Bayan ki hai.
So sad 1 din Neha Dixit Shreya se bda name kmayegi
She sang song well. Shreya is sounding a little arrogant and showing attitude . Sad she was given a chance despite great voice and talene t
It isn't reality show pre planned ye sab aage ja ke super star banate kyo jinhone indian idol jita uska future khatm ho jata h it is real
Point 👉
Bro sb phelee se. disaid kiya hua h ino ne asea lgta h neha good voice shujha is good bt out why??
Nehe ka awaj bohot mithi hain lekin timing nehi mila pa raha hain,to eliminate to hogai,next time or better karega.
Kuch bhi kehlo bhai shuja was must deserve in top 15
Isme koyi doubt hi nahi hai ke decision sahi hai ya galat.. shreya maam ne sab clearly bol hi diya ke kya kamiya reh gayi iss gane mein
I think sg is just jealous of neha. Because, when the previous video got viral every one praised neha than her. One day, neha will be the Queen of Bollywood.
point
Kuch bhi..viral hone se bhi kya hota h?? Dono ki singing me zameen aasman ka fark h... Shreya Ghoshal ki jesi similar texture hone se hi log Shreya Ghoshal nahi bn jaate.. Shreya ki singing me unki command expertise effortlessness sb sunta h..bs awaz mithi hona hi kaafi nahi hota...
@@HasanReels idiot point kali dimag hai abka
2.0 shreya nahi chahte thhe joori
jusges give more importance to Bengali singers
Voice achchi h.. but singing average h.... Sahi judgement diya
Peso ka khel h bhai sara
Shreya KO apna future dobta howa nazar Aya to reject kr dya ....... Both he kamzarf katoon hai Shreya . Heat you
Uncle ji yeh dialogue outdated hai 😂
wo acchi singer hai Jo cheej ki Kami hai usko aaplog hi baithe ho bahar laneke lie uska confidence samajhme nahin Aya usko kyu nahin select kiye
Correct judgment , tumlog gala sunke ludge krne lagte ho. But sur , situation, perfection is needed. Is season sabse zyada acha hai
Wrong dessition sab tamasha hai
Wrong judge dont looke like shows
Shreya has shown the flaws in Neha's singing, could you not see that? Then what do you want, judges should have selected her despite the flaws?
Bolo tum kya he
Ab fir se mai ye show nhi dekhunga
ache Kalakar ko bahar nikal reh hai ye log so sad
Wild card entry denge.....bcoz koi khoobsoorti nahi hai abhi
Are. Bhai seting h sab pehle se sab hojata h kisko rakhna h