Let's make this clear! Neha was obviously amazing and even acc to me she should've stayed! But the Genre she picked is a Lata Ji classic and obviously it wasn't Perfect per se! Shreya judged her on her level of closeness to perfection. For Ranjini she perfected her choices and did her particular song more justice than Neha did. Shreya had the justification for their respective songs as the critique. Which is how it should be.
Unfair selection of Ranjini over Neha Dixit who sang much better, Shreya Ghoshal's judgement baffles me. Ranjini who just keeps making odd sounds ( audition as well as theatre round) was selected though Neha was far superior to Ranjini😢😢😢
@@rubbersidedown7992 this Ranjini will be the first one to be eliminated also, her "emotional drama" swayed the decision in her favour. Neha, Ragini, Kritika were much better than Ranjini & Ritika Raj.
Guys of course she is shreya Ghoshal who knows the perfection of classic music even Neha is a deserving candidate to go ahead but not properly trained yet she needs training to get merge in the song
@anikmajumder-u8i bro it's about showing their talent not confidence, I respect sherya mam and she is amazing but she clearly is jealous even the same thing happened to senjtui
If she needs training then looks like we’re not ready to welcome any other singer other than shreya ghoshal, she’s just as good, I agree she isn’t confident, but that doesn’t take away how beautiful her voice is
@@AnamikaPatel-i9q hear her clearly, she has a poor breathing control. She's stopping everytime she sings the next word. She's poor at that. Voice isn't the only thing that matters. She'll take 100 yrs more to be a compatible singer. It's difficult to sing with proper breathing
It's not about copying the style of the singer or the singing timber/ texture of the singer which Shreya mam is talking about. It's about the expression of the song. First listen to the statement and then flaunt your half-baked knowledge 🥱😏
@@SVK1405bro whatever she's doing, she's giving justice to it. That's what Shreya mam told to Neha that she needs to have conviction. Doing complete justice to the song
Nearly 50% of those who made it to the top 15 are Bengalis. Shreya is determined that the trophy must be awarded to West Bengal. Neha Dixit could have upset her apple cart. Her singing and looks would have ensured that the public voted massively for her. Shreya is the dominant judge. Badshah is just a prop.
Bro neha literally underperformed, are you even serious. Jitna natkhat pan hai gaane me utna tha hi nhi , and talking about her voice which is absolute beauty but har time voice quality se nhi hota 😊
@@SVK1405 to kisne bola Shreya jaise gaane ke liye😂😂😂 usko to gaane ka bhav tak samajh nhi aaya to kya gayegi 😂😂😂 that's a basic thing and she can't even do that
Nope. Shreya's voice has a thickness and maturity in it. Her voice has expressions without even expressing. Neha is undeveloped and immature. Also, she presses her voice due to which the quality remains very far from perfection.
@@shibanasim Ritika Raj & Ranjini were selected based on their "family drama" more than their singing skills. Even a person with an ordinary musical sense will realise that Neha Dixit, Ragini & Kritika were much better than Ritika Raj & Ranjini.
Her (Neha Dixit's) sanskrit is incredible and pronounciation of hindi words are excellent. I listened her song Baahon me chali aao 10 times sung by Lata Ji (iconic song) from film Anamika. She should be selected or being World Card Entry in Indian Idol 15. She was really good. Please reconsider her performances.
It's unjust that Neha Dixit not selected, Indian Idol have groomers for correcting the contestants, then why Neha Dixit not selected. Give her wild entry atleast
Oh logo ne Anwesha or Palak ko bhi Shreya ki barabari di thi ab kaha hai wo log😂😂😂 kahi dikhte nhi😂😂 ye ladki bhi Shreya nhi ban payegi... bewakoof logo ka kaam hi hai bhokna😂😂😂 Shreya ko unse fark nhi padta use gaane ne fark padta hai😂
She really did not sing well shreya is 100% right she was too late she was like holding the flow and tone of the song unfortunately gr8 voice but badluck
@@Updateify Man tell me on what basis r u reacting? Tell me what's ur qualification in the field of music first? Matlab berozgaari ki bhi hadh hoti hai. Kaam kaaj kuch nahi hai. A man totally uneducated in music is reacting on Shreya ma'am decision?🤣🤣 Literally what can be more funny than this!?
Lol😂😂😂 people said Anwesha would replace Shreya, then Palak would replace Shreya, and now they're under the bus 😂😂😂 this girl will also end up like them 😂😂😂 because she's the Shreya Ghoshal, the modern contemporary of Lata Mangeshkar. They're born once in a lifetime and are irreplaceable 😂😂
You need to have atleast some knowledge of singing bro if you think voice is the only thing required as a singer. Neha is underdeveloped in singing. It's blank for expressions and perfectionism. She wouldn't really stand with composers to sing. Her voice is immature too. She does have a beautiful voice but pretty mediocre or below singing from a professional pov. Shreya's judgement had an essence of a good judge, she explained each and every mistake to her. And well, before have been many singers with a shrill voice and ppl anticipated that shreya will be replaced. While, she still stands apart.
Why don't u understand that people are not here to watch u. We are here to watch performances and not your face. Very bad video editing. We don't want your comment about candidates.
Then you really have a rotten sense of music😂😂😂 this girl has horrible breathe control let her do that much first😂😂😂 she ain't getting anywhere close to Shreya in this lifetime 😂😂
@@Writing_freak no one is same anymore….nobody can become Lata , Asha , Alka Yagnik, Chitra, Kavita krisnamurty…. So there will not be another Neha Dixit… just practice every day.. you will be recognised surely… my best wishes always 👍👍👍🙏
श्रेया घोषाल जी बिल्कुल सही कह रहीं हैं गाने मैं नेहा ने फुक फुक के कदम रखा और म्यूजिक पार्ट थोड़ा जल्दी खत्म हो रहा हे नेहा थोड़ी लेट खत्म कर रहीं हैं इस गाने में नखरा और छेड़खानी गायब थी आवाज नेहा की गोल्ड हे ये सही हैं। सायली कांबले की वीडियो देखना इसी गाने पर फिर सही से समझ जाओगे शायद 🙏
bro please genuine reaction do aapke face se lag raha hai aap song ko jabran enjoy kar rahe ho like a fake reaction and dont make sounds between the song
Shreya ghoshal is mithi chhuri. Nobody will ever know her true face which is really dark. She destroyed the career of alka yagnik, sunidhi chauhan n others. It's the most bizzare thing that this shreya ghoshal keeps getting work while others are easily replaced. There's a whole lot politics going on behind the scenes. She was so pissed at neha for singing like her. She sent her so much hateful energy i could sense that. She clearly saw her as a threat. N obviously would never choose her. N rahi baat natkhatpan ki, those are things one can easily sing with a little practice. If voice n notes are good a singer need not be replaced because one performance alone cannot judge a singer for elimination. Singers know this very well. It was well planned by shreya to get neha out asap as she was also beautiful. A woman can never bear another woman being praised especially if she's prettier n can threaten her career.
As per your opinion, if Shreya ji intentionally eliminate Neha, so what? That's not the end of the World. And second thing, the judges have to choose top 16 based on only their performance particularly on that day. They have to take that decision by eliminating the inferior one.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Neha Dixit i stand by you,she should be selected❤
She should be selected. After all this show is like a teacher to them they learn
This show ain't a school it's a competition. People don't come her to learn they come here to fight and be the best
janbujh ke nahi lia neha ko...shreya feels she is competitor...neha dixit can be great
I never loved someone voice like as shreya ghosal.bt this girl neha dixit voice have something
Neha Dixit wow kya voice hai❤❤❤❤
its all about nervousness bro if she didn’t get nervous she can execute it Perfectly the situation was not under is favour oh that time that is it
Let's make this clear! Neha was obviously amazing and even acc to me she should've stayed!
But the Genre she picked is a Lata Ji classic and obviously it wasn't Perfect per se!
Shreya judged her on her level of closeness to perfection.
For Ranjini she perfected her choices and did her particular song more justice than Neha did.
Shreya had the justification for their respective songs as the critique. Which is how it should be.
Excellent singing Neha ❤❤❤❤❤❤ 🙌
Unfair selection of Ranjini over Neha Dixit who sang much better, Shreya Ghoshal's judgement baffles me. Ranjini who just keeps making odd sounds ( audition as well as theatre round) was selected though Neha was far superior to Ranjini😢😢😢
Yup.. & even better would hv been ragini ..., & mansi too was far better than this hyped cr*p ranjini
This cr*p ranjini is this seasons hyped contestant
Ranjini is this seasons hyped cr*ap
Agree
@@rubbersidedown7992 this Ranjini will be the first one to be eliminated also, her "emotional drama" swayed the decision in her favour. Neha, Ragini, Kritika were much better than Ranjini & Ritika Raj.
Neha Dixit is sanskriti ladki ❤🎉🎉
Shreya ghoshal is best judge........in Indian idol ❤❤
Guys of course she is shreya Ghoshal who knows the perfection of classic music even Neha is a deserving candidate to go ahead but not properly trained yet she needs training to get merge in the song
Neha❤
She has advantage of beauty with voice.
voice was good , but Shreya said right, yes she needs more confidence , not ready for this season
@anikmajumder-u8i bro it's about showing their talent not confidence, I respect sherya mam and she is amazing but she clearly is jealous even the same thing happened to senjtui
@@anikmajumder-u8i tu ga sakta hai aisa .
@@AJAYKUMAR-jq6tv beshak ga sakta hoon,,,
Next sherya goshal❤❤❤❤ I love her vocal ❤❤❤
Shreya has such a perfect voice...Neha needs more training. She can still improve. All the best Neha
If she needs training then looks like we’re not ready to welcome any other singer other than shreya ghoshal, she’s just as good, I agree she isn’t confident, but that doesn’t take away how beautiful her voice is
@@AnamikaPatel-i9q hear her clearly, she has a poor breathing control. She's stopping everytime she sings the next word. She's poor at that. Voice isn't the only thing that matters. She'll take 100 yrs more to be a compatible singer. It's difficult to sing with proper breathing
No doubt she has a good voice...but something is still missing. Hear her well and do a good comparison. You will understand@@AnamikaPatel-i9q
first vishal dont copy the original singer, but than shreya judges the girl based on the original performance
@@kushagrabhalla7370 Arey it's not about original version, it's abt hitting the correct notes which Neha's not
Have knowledge 😂
It's not about copying the style of the singer or the singing timber/ texture of the singer which Shreya mam is talking about. It's about the expression of the song. First listen to the statement and then flaunt your half-baked knowledge 🥱😏
श्रेया जी ने सही किया
नेहा की आवाज बहोत खूबसूरत हैं लेकिन अभी परिपूर्ण नही हैं
नेहा मेहनत करेगी तो आगे आयेगी
@@RiddhiLomte absolutely right 👍
@@RiddhiLomte lol to Rajni ki kaunsi paripurn hai sirf chillati rehti hai
@@SVK1405 she is much better.... Chiilane ka bhi sur hota hai....
@@SVK1405bro whatever she's doing, she's giving justice to it. That's what Shreya mam told to Neha that she needs to have conviction. Doing complete justice to the song
Pratibha is best singer❤❤❤❤
Bhaiii she in the beginning really lost the essence of song even her voice teared in the beginning many times! Good decision of shreya
Nearly 50% of those who made it to the top 15 are Bengalis. Shreya is determined that the trophy must be awarded to West Bengal. Neha Dixit could have upset her apple cart. Her singing and looks would have ensured that the public voted massively for her.
Shreya is the dominant judge. Badshah is just a prop.
Bro neha literally underperformed, are you even serious. Jitna natkhat pan hai gaane me utna tha hi nhi , and talking about her voice which is absolute beauty but har time voice quality se nhi hota 😊
@@anujneogi6078 vo shreya jaisa thodi gaa sakti hai??
Rajni aur baki logo se achha kiya usane
@@SVK1405 to kisne bola Shreya jaise gaane ke liye😂😂😂 usko to gaane ka bhav tak samajh nhi aaya to kya gayegi 😂😂😂 that's a basic thing and she can't even do that
If anyone listen this song without this vdo then he/she will feel it's the voice of Shreya Ghoshal mam❤
I listened to this song without video and it became more and more clear that this is not Shreya's voice. Shreya's voice isn't so undeveloped
Nope. Shreya's voice has a thickness and maturity in it. Her voice has expressions without even expressing. Neha is undeveloped and immature. Also, she presses her voice due to which the quality remains very far from perfection.
Unfair selection again. I don't know why Shreya is behaving so biased? Neha was fabulous.
😂😂😂😂😂, matlab kuch vi
@@shibanasim Ritika Raj & Ranjini were selected based on their "family drama" more than their singing skills. Even a person with an ordinary musical sense will realise that Neha Dixit, Ragini & Kritika were much better than Ritika Raj & Ranjini.
Have knowledge 😂
@@shibanasim aap ganja hi NAHI samajte ho.
@@KeshavVerma-e2c he has thats why he has apoint
Is nature that is why she is....😮😂
Cuz vocal is similar that is the reason
Neha Dixit was excellent on Baahon me Chale aao sung by Lata Mangeshkar. Shreya was biaised again.
Says a music ke bare mein -ve infinity knowledge rakhne wala banda😂
@@Sree-o6k he has a point though
Unlike you blind fans
@@SVK1405 he doesn't have a point unlike you blind fans😂😂 fans of someone who can't even hold her breathe while singing 😂😂
Her (Neha Dixit's) sanskrit is incredible and pronounciation of hindi words are excellent. I listened her song Baahon me chali aao 10 times sung by Lata Ji (iconic song) from film Anamika. She should be selected or being World Card Entry in Indian Idol 15. She was really good. Please reconsider her performances.
It's unjust that Neha Dixit not selected,
Indian Idol have groomers for correcting the contestants, then why Neha Dixit not selected.
Give her wild entry atleast
Sabne kaha ki Shreya -2 hai
Shreya ne yedekha ki sab Neha ko meri barabari de rahe , isiliye nikal diya
Oh logo ne Anwesha or Palak ko bhi Shreya ki barabari di thi ab kaha hai wo log😂😂😂 kahi dikhte nhi😂😂 ye ladki bhi Shreya nhi ban payegi... bewakoof logo ka kaam hi hai bhokna😂😂😂 Shreya ko unse fark nhi padta use gaane ne fark padta hai😂
Bhai Aaj copyright nahi aaya😅
She is really good. Unfortunately she is a victim of the reality show. Sad to see that renowned singer like Shreya is part of this show
Does this mean she is out of Indian Idol this season?? Or one more round hai ??
No there is no extra round 😢
Par vishal k sir me bal kaya se ug gaya vai 🤣🤣
@@AymanTasdik-i7i aadivasi hair oil
@Exclusive_doctor899 🤣🤣🤣
She really did not sing well shreya is 100% right she was too late she was like holding the flow and tone of the song unfortunately gr8 voice but badluck
Jo woh biker hai na , bahu mai chali aavo wali uss se better hai
Next performance kiska react kare?
Laudasur aur satrughan ke yuddha par
@@Updateify the best performance of SUBHAJIT
Chaitanya
Bhai apne Chaitanya ka ek bhi performance nhi dekha
@@Updateify Man tell me on what basis r u reacting? Tell me what's ur qualification in the field of music first?
Matlab berozgaari ki bhi hadh hoti hai. Kaam kaaj kuch nahi hai.
A man totally uneducated in music is reacting on Shreya ma'am decision?🤣🤣 Literally what can be more funny than this!?
Men’s superb
Kisi bhi ek state ke jadge nahi hone chahiye ager indian idol hein to singer to sabhi ache hote hein baki ye kya sochte hame nahi pata
Sabse jyada fhaltu show hai ye..... Abhi tak sunne me sabse acchi voice aur feeling Neha Dixit ke gane me aayai
How can a singer let someone go further who has the capability to replace her
Lol😂😂😂 people said Anwesha would replace Shreya, then Palak would replace Shreya, and now they're under the bus 😂😂😂 this girl will also end up like them 😂😂😂 because she's the Shreya Ghoshal, the modern contemporary of Lata Mangeshkar. They're born once in a lifetime and are irreplaceable 😂😂
@@Writing_freak so true!
You need to have atleast some knowledge of singing bro if you think voice is the only thing required as a singer. Neha is underdeveloped in singing. It's blank for expressions and perfectionism. She wouldn't really stand with composers to sing. Her voice is immature too. She does have a beautiful voice but pretty mediocre or below singing from a professional pov. Shreya's judgement had an essence of a good judge, she explained each and every mistake to her. And well, before have been many singers with a shrill voice and ppl anticipated that shreya will be replaced. While, she still stands apart.
None of the 2020 idol candidates would have been selected if she was a judge
That's called real judgement
@@anujneogi6078 biasedness
The voice the serious show. not serious indian ideol
These Lata ji songs one mistake and lack of feeling you are out.. that's the issue.. judgement is fair
react shubh sutradhar new song❤😊
Bengali biasness
She could be a problem for sneha Shankar so they threw her out
Why don't u understand that people are not here to watch u. We are here to watch performances and not your face. Very bad video editing. We don't want your comment about candidates.
Neha sang so much ch better... One day I feel she will be even better singer than Shreya ghosal
Then you really have a rotten sense of music😂😂😂 this girl has horrible breathe control let her do that much first😂😂😂 she ain't getting anywhere close to Shreya in this lifetime 😂😂
@@Writing_freak no one is same anymore….nobody can become Lata , Asha , Alka Yagnik, Chitra, Kavita krisnamurty…. So there will not be another Neha Dixit… just practice every day.. you will be recognised surely… my best wishes always 👍👍👍🙏
Ager koii dusra song choose kiya hotta to kuch ho skta tha
But one day she will be resign though
श्रेया घोषाल जी बिल्कुल सही कह रहीं हैं गाने मैं नेहा ने फुक फुक के कदम रखा और म्यूजिक पार्ट थोड़ा जल्दी खत्म हो रहा हे नेहा थोड़ी लेट खत्म कर रहीं हैं इस गाने में नखरा और छेड़खानी गायब थी आवाज नेहा की गोल्ड हे ये सही हैं। सायली कांबले की वीडियो देखना इसी गाने पर फिर सही से समझ जाओगे शायद 🙏
J
Acchaa nahi laga...
Ye log fake hn partial selections krte h she sounds like koyal n so pure b'ful
Bas koyal jaisa sound karne se koi singer nhi ban jaata...koyal jaisa ku ku har koi kar leta hai
bro please genuine reaction do aapke face se lag raha hai aap song ko jabran enjoy kar rahe ho like a fake reaction and dont make sounds between the song
Bhai ek murkh kya reaction dega isse zyada😂😂😂
@@Sree-o6k sahi kaha😂
@@Sree-o6k aur tu mahamurk jo ise dekh raha hai fir
@@SVK1405 Actually
Shreya Goshal may have not selected Neha Dixit because she sounds some what like her .... insecurity much😂😂😂
unfair with this girls.. Bad selection ;
She is singing very well. Baised judgement.
Neha ; she didn’t miss any convection. Faltu lady judge
Poor people with no knowledge 😂
Exactly
Shreya ghoshal is mithi chhuri. Nobody will ever know her true face which is really dark. She destroyed the career of alka yagnik, sunidhi chauhan n others. It's the most bizzare thing that this shreya ghoshal keeps getting work while others are easily replaced. There's a whole lot politics going on behind the scenes. She was so pissed at neha for singing like her. She sent her so much hateful energy i could sense that. She clearly saw her as a threat. N obviously would never choose her. N rahi baat natkhatpan ki, those are things one can easily sing with a little practice. If voice n notes are good a singer need not be replaced because one performance alone cannot judge a singer for elimination. Singers know this very well. It was well planned by shreya to get neha out asap as she was also beautiful. A woman can never bear another woman being praised especially if she's prettier n can threaten her career.
As per your opinion, if Shreya ji intentionally eliminate Neha, so what? That's not the end of the World.
And second thing, the judges have to choose top 16 based on only their performance particularly on that day. They have to take that decision by eliminating the inferior one.