This looks like quite a lively debate and this video may not be GMM's best work but they not just Gave Us Dust, they gave us a lot of outstanding stuff, from Garbage to The Filthy Tongues, playing across Scotchland this year and better than ever...peace!
Just as well I kept all my Mackenzies vinyl..it's gone shooting up in price..£15 plus I've seen it go for. One of the best album tracks here..bit of a blast from the past here..
@@jdee8407 In 1992 and 1993 he worked as a backline and guitar technician for the band Nirvana and played guitar with them during their concert in Roseland Ballroom, New York City on 23 July 1993. The Exploited were one of Kurt's influences.
Well, she's singing harmony. That's pretty much how you mix band vocals. That being said, the vocals are getting drowned out by the drums and guitar anyway.
Nearly! This is from1989 with all songs from the Good Deeds era. They went out on tour with DH a year later and included a couple of songs that would later feature on Hammer and Tongs (Diamonds and Blacker Than Black).
yeah I was in teh front row for this, during the tube strike of that summer and everyone was leaving before teh main act to try to get home.. wasn't the other support Del Amitri?
This band were excellent; should have done more outside Scotland, where they were pretty huge. Shirley is quality but I personally still don't think Garbage have done a song to match The Rattler, Blacker Than Black and well, quite a few MacKenzies tracks. 'Special' is the only track I'd rate near the MacKenzies' best stuff. Just my opinion.
Trainwreck....they were well respected in their day. The planets just didn't align for them to make it. Big John played with Nirvana ffs. They did some great tracks. Most of the band are still playing Isa and the filth tongues.
Some amazing tracks a much underrated band. Well done to Shirley but I’m afraid Goodbye Mr Mackenzie leave Garbage in the Dust artistically. Love them. Check out The Filthy Tongues.
completely agree - too many fan boys love-struck by Shirley (who is decent and surely hot) to see how amazing GBMM really was and yeah the tongues are imo even better
in the 4 years since you made this stupid fucking comment have you yet realised that the large stumbling fellow was in the exploited, toured with nirvana and is a legend in the music scene. that goodbye mr mackenzie has cult, almost god like status as one of the most under appreciated bands of the 20th century and that the least talented member of the band was embraced by America as any kind of talent at all. Or are you still tone deaf, stupid and musicaly ignorant of anything that's not mainstream
one of life's desperately underrated bands with one of their absolute masterpieces
Just spotted myself in the frront row of the crowd!
Just such awesome choruseseses.
What a fantastic band
Loved this band
Big John great guitarist and pure metal too!
It's because Shirley has immortal beauty ;)
This looks like quite a lively debate and this video may not be GMM's best work but they not just Gave Us Dust, they gave us a lot of outstanding stuff, from Garbage to The Filthy Tongues, playing across Scotchland this year and better than ever...peace!
Suknaboby
Just as well I kept all my Mackenzies vinyl..it's gone shooting up in price..£15 plus I've seen it go for. One of the best album tracks here..bit of a blast from the past here..
From the Exploited to GMM to Nirvana. Big John certainly had an interesting career!
dont forget steve aoki, the edm star !
He was in Nirvana, really!?
@@jdee8407 In 1992 and 1993 he worked as a backline and guitar technician for the band Nirvana and played guitar with them during their concert in Roseland Ballroom, New York City on 23 July 1993. The Exploited were one of Kurt's influences.
@@jdee8407 I’ve the alternative/Attack single on constant Display
Shirley was backing singer to the boy Metcalfe in the band along with Rona Scobie; of course her mic is lower than his.
Well, she's singing harmony. That's pretty much how you mix band vocals. That being said, the vocals are getting drowned out by the drums and guitar anyway.
whatever.... this guys were really good and I love!, I LOVE! SICK BABY SONG
The Stoccos, a father and son on the run, were recently seen at a petrol station in Gundegai (1st line). Just thought I'd tell you that.
That bass tone 🕵
Nearly! This is from1989 with all songs from the Good Deeds era. They went out on tour with DH a year later and included a couple of songs that would later feature on Hammer and Tongs (Diamonds and Blacker Than Black).
GMM are on twitter now with new shows in may 2019 also check out their new band the filthy tongues
I feel blacker than black 😂😂😂
When I see this vidéo because it was a beautiful work and its over now
yeah I was in teh front row for this, during the tube strike of that summer and everyone was leaving before teh main act to try to get home.. wasn't the other support Del Amitri?
Big John; I believe was also guitarist in the punk band The Exploited. Wee Shirley, what a scrap. Like a match stick with the wood shaved off....
This band were excellent; should have done more outside Scotland, where they were pretty huge. Shirley is quality but I personally still don't think Garbage have done a song to match The Rattler, Blacker Than Black and well, quite a few MacKenzies tracks. 'Special' is the only track I'd rate near the MacKenzies' best stuff. Just my opinion.
Cur Tail ...shirley you jest
Completely agree, nothing garbage has done can live with half of the mackenzie catalogue, check out the Filthy Tongues new stuff.
face to face
Was there ever any doubt that Shirley Manson would be the breakout star from this trainwreck?
Trainwreck....they were well respected in their day. The planets just didn't align for them to make it. Big John played with Nirvana ffs. They did some great tracks. Most of the band are still playing Isa and the filth tongues.
whatever you say Dick, that he is still putting out top-notch new music while Shirley tours on her back catalogue tells me all i need to know
Shirley has a lot more stage presence that why she became famous. Some people just have that. A lot of people consider her an alternative rock legend.
there are two peavey kb300 amps!!!
lolz martins scream at 2:36
Is the crowd dead?
how many people like me went to see them because of fat john out of exploited
Some amazing tracks a much underrated band. Well done to Shirley but I’m afraid Goodbye Mr Mackenzie leave Garbage in the Dust artistically. Love them. Check out The Filthy Tongues.
completely agree - too many fan boys love-struck by Shirley (who is decent and surely hot) to see how amazing GBMM really was and yeah the tongues are imo even better
That’s just a bit silly mate…GMM had a few good tunes but Garbage are light years better with a huge catalogue of brilliant music!
Imagine if Garbage had hired the male singer instead
geezus, no wonder Shirley left this band
Hugh Jass She's sounds too good to be a back-up vocalist.
Is it me or does the guitarist look like Phil Jupitus?
please... shirley manson sang better in this song and they made her microfone sound softer so she doesn't overpower his voice... Sad Crap!!
that is the job of a backing singer ffs
Hope the large stumbling fellow doesn't fall on someone. BTW, Shirley moved on to better things thank God.
in the 4 years since you made this stupid fucking comment have you yet realised that the large stumbling fellow was in the exploited, toured with nirvana and is a legend in the music scene. that goodbye mr mackenzie has cult, almost god like status as one of the most under appreciated bands of the 20th century and that the least talented member of the band was embraced by America as any kind of talent at all. Or are you still tone deaf, stupid and musicaly ignorant of anything that's not mainstream
Yeah, you stick to your s club sevens as well pal😂😂😂
Better then the trashy terrible band she joined later on; Garbage; their name says it all really!
Samuel Hinchliffe you sir are hopefully being sarcastic cause if not, you may be slightly off in the head
this should be interesting - more creative how?
Garbage is awesome bawbag
Screw u dude garbage is awesome