@@triccele all the players have known since ep 18, Liam told them to go ahead and watch the scene afterward (Travis talks about it in the Talks Machina for ep 19). I think most of the one-on-one scenes are not super secret, the players seem to usually watch them after the episode
@@mrsiwtv yeah, I realised that after, when Sam jockingly sings about it on one of the DnD Beyond sponsor thingies. I started watching not that long ago, I haven't even watched the episode this clip is from, I don't know why I thought they wouldn't watch the secret parts afterwards
Ashley and Sam play off each other so well. Pike and Scanlan were the same way, just going back and forth together, Sam going a mile a minute and Ashley just reacting like she heard every third sentence.
@@Tesoro1996 Yeah, and Nott and Yasha hearing it and going like "What was that?!" but then deciding "Eh, it was probably the wind" and then going right back to talking.
Well, Fjord did chase her for awhile in nothing but a towel, did that mind charming truth thing with Molly, not flirting right with all the lady types Nott sees for him (including Jester), sailing over water for an arc, having to go under the ocean repeatedly for his deity, not being allowed to cannon whenever she wanted thanks to her captain, and his general gruff masculine proving of himself... Nah. No idea why Nott thinks that about Silent J.
Toa Tahu remember when Fjord wrote off Nott’s extremely valid fear of water and proceeded to make fun of her collections????? That’s why Nott sees Fjord as mean (Also Travis called Nott expendable at one point, and Sam probably got that confused with in-game, resulting in Nott getting angrier with Fjord)
@@Mitochondribruh Fjord realised that it was a valid fear of water and apologised. Not sure when and not sure how it went but I _am_ sure that it happened.
I love how Ashley just kept stringing Sam along and drawing it out to torture him a little. *chef kiss* I think my new favorite Yasha moment is now "I killed my whole family, I'll throw you under a bridge. I'm learning how to people." Gah, I love her.
I'm imagining Liam off camera after the show saying in his signature nasally drone, "I've been crafting this dark dramatic storyline around my past and how and when I reveal that information to our party members and you just SHAT ALL OVER IT! YOU SHAT ALL OVER IT SAM!!"
@@doomerbloomer6160 he toldo Beau and everyone else left but he told I think Fjord and Jester about it and at this point (I mean this episode) Yasha and Cad didn't know yet lmao
I love the cuts to the cast's reactions. Travis, Marisha, and Liam dying of laughter and sharing confused looks, then Taliesin is just completely done. And that "Hahahah!" Was great
Funny how it could easily be an hyperbolic intimidation thing, but Sam went for a "Oh well" interjection It becomes way more hilarious, since it is sounds so unnatural
There's a pretty good actual play podcast called Rude Tales of Magic, one of the cast members slipped up in _episode one_ and said that phrase and one of the other party members responded "who exists in this world, you know!" and now it's a running joke in the series that Roman Catholicism exists in the world of Cordelia (despite Jesus' miracles being far less impressive in a world where healing magic and resurrection spells exist)
I saw the title and thought it was a huge spoiler and when I actually watched the video and realized what it actually was it made me laugh like 30* harder lol
You know as much as this was a slip on Sam’s part (most likely) you could easily chalk this up to Nott being strung out and in the throes of withdrawal after cold turkeying for days. Regardless, it’s still hilarious.
i just love the look on sam's face when he accidently says that, instantly you see him thinking, what did i just say?! how am i gonna talk my way out of this one?!
I dont like how taliesin laughed when sam said cad is a nice guy. I mean it does seem off to have him play a good character but we could all hope for it to be true
Well, he is a grave cleric who makes tea out of dead people. He also has a bunch of siblings who he learned to play practical jokes on, and he worships mother nature (and nature is brutal as fuck).
I would like to point out that Sam says "Do you have that money I owe you" 4:20 and everyone is just too caught up in how funny this whole thing is to notice. Edit: He also keeps saying "over" instead of "under" when referencing the bridge tossing.
Favorite Yasha line of all time " I'm trying to do the thing. Like, I killed my whole family, I'll throw you under a bridge... I'm learning how to people"
Me: Don't worry guys I'll call- Ah! I killed my whole family... guys, I left my phone at home. Friend who I've groomed mildly in the ways of critical role: Great, nice going. You've thrown us all under the freaking bridge. Me: I'M LEARNING NOW TO PEOPLE OKAY, I KILL MY WHOLE FAMILY SOMETIMES!
Is it bad a part of me kind of would want to know what would have happened if Yasha had just casually went "Oh darn, guess I killed my whole family on that one guys". Like how would Caleb react to that? I imagine him just freezing in place, eyes so wide, "why would you ever say it like that?" 😦
On you RUclips vod of this episode someone pointed out that Yasha says she won't judge the party's magician, but uses a sword literally called "The Magician's Judge"
What!? You didn't include Ashley's callback to it later in the episode. Harumph! Well thanks for sharing this bit at least. I think this is the best bit of improv we've seen from Yasha so far.
"So he DID kill his whole family?"
"Well......only once."
How does this not have ANY replies?
Id be more worried if he did it twice.... or three times
The volume family murderers get all the flashy records, but there's something to be said for that kind of efficiency
This was the most adorable conversation about alcoholism, property invasion, torture, genital electrocution, familicide, and murder by bridge tossing
i read this before i saw the video and honestly im scared
Welcome to D&D
Now would it be phrased as Bridge tossing or tossing under da bridge
Agreed
Without
The
Greed
I am quoting this.
''I wouldn't throw you under the b... *oh god it's dnd there are no busses* ...bbbbbridge?''
Waterdeep does actually have busses, we hijacked one in a dragon heist game I played
@@stefan_wsl3398 Even if they didn’t “throw you under the carriage” works just as well
Nott: Well Caleb has killed his own family members--
Liam: [kill bill sirens go off]
Ironside
*_Caleb would run, BFG Division playing in the background._*
straight up opened another tab and tried that along with the video.
thank you .
Charisma 7 and charisma 5 have a conversation... let’s see how that goes!
As a wise man once said, "Charm, pure charm".
@@feyefall4855 as a VERY OLD wise man said*
Alexander999901 Well, it's his character, not himself :)
Just add alcohol
i love how you think that's bad charisma. the highest in my group is 2 lmao
Nott role to bluff.
Nott: natural one
Yasha role insight
Yasha:Natural one
I don't think Liam in a million years would have imagined this being how his deep dark past gets revealed to the rest of the group lmaoooo
Not the whole group though, just Yasha
@@jpobrien2123 And now she works for literal demons! So *everyone* knows!
@@jpobrien2123 Liam, not Caleb. Sam told the whole group the dark past of Caleb, so now all the players know, but Nott only told Yasha
@@triccele all the players have known since ep 18, Liam told them to go ahead and watch the scene afterward (Travis talks about it in the Talks Machina for ep 19). I think most of the one-on-one scenes are not super secret, the players seem to usually watch them after the episode
@@mrsiwtv yeah, I realised that after, when Sam jockingly sings about it on one of the DnD Beyond sponsor thingies. I started watching not that long ago, I haven't even watched the episode this clip is from, I don't know why I thought they wouldn't watch the secret parts afterwards
When the crit fail for persuasion meets the crit fail for insight
Damn
this is the best explanation of these two
While I get your point, I have to point out that Yasha's wisdom modifier (-1) is higher than Nott's charisma modifier (-3).
@@mathybrain8 A Nat1 is a Nat1.
Not on skill check :)
A nat 1 with a -1 and -3 is only
0 inside and
-2 deceptiion
Ashley and Sam play off each other so well. Pike and Scanlan were the same way, just going back and forth together, Sam going a mile a minute and Ashley just reacting like she heard every third sentence.
Derek Garrard oh my goodness that is so accurate
Don't forget about Taryion and Pike that was funny as well too.
@@space8065 Pike coaching Taryon was everything
@@Strattus19 It really was🤣
looking back at this and seeing C3, Fearne using FCG as a flask
Yasha: “Caleb killed his whole family??”
Nott: “It’s a figure of speech.”
SMOOOTH
its utica expression
@@katie2893 funny, I'm from Utica and I've never heard the expression, "I killed my whole family" before.
Sam/Nott: Cadueces wouldnt do that. He's a nice guy.
Taliesin: short burst of maniacal laughter.
That got me good 🤣
This is why i like Tal's characters. And Taliesin. He's so chaotic and it leaks into his characters in ways you don't expect.
I like to imagine it was actually Caduceus laughing in his sleep. xD
@@Tesoro1996 Yeah, and Nott and Yasha hearing it and going like "What was that?!" but then deciding "Eh, it was probably the wind" and then going right back to talking.
"I'm learning how to people." Well, put that on a shirt
Yeah, i think you just found their next CR T-shirt slogan.
I'll buy one
I would buy that shirt
Travis looks so taken aback when Sam says his character is mean. Poor Fjord.
Pjoor Fjord
Well, Fjord did chase her for awhile in nothing but a towel, did that mind charming truth thing with Molly, not flirting right with all the lady types Nott sees for him (including Jester), sailing over water for an arc, having to go under the ocean repeatedly for his deity, not being allowed to cannon whenever she wanted thanks to her captain, and his general gruff masculine proving of himself... Nah. No idea why Nott thinks that about Silent J.
@@Undomaranel To be fair, like 85% of that was Nott's fault... Not that Nott would see it that way...
Toa Tahu remember when Fjord wrote off Nott’s extremely valid fear of water and proceeded to make fun of her collections????? That’s why Nott sees Fjord as mean (Also Travis called Nott expendable at one point, and Sam probably got that confused with in-game, resulting in Nott getting angrier with Fjord)
@@Mitochondribruh Fjord realised that it was a valid fear of water and apologised. Not sure when and not sure how it went but I _am_ sure that it happened.
I love how Ashley just kept stringing Sam along and drawing it out to torture him a little. *chef kiss* I think my new favorite Yasha moment is now "I killed my whole family, I'll throw you under a bridge. I'm learning how to people." Gah, I love her.
Maybe Veth blocking Beau and Yasha's date is Sam's payback for THIS moment. Lol.
"Caleb killed his whole family"
"He did WHAT?!"
*_HE_*
*_WHAT_*
Caleb is the real Orphan Maker
I don't think making yourself an Orphan counts
Oneil Gunn a self made man
He's self taught
The living embodiment of Orphan Obliterator
Liam's expression shift at 3:13 was peak silent panic
Something about the way Sam says "They're all so shifty" fucking sends me
Killed my whole family, Nott dropped the ball on Caleb. He won't be happy. At least if Liam manages to stop laughing.
Kazad I just love it because you KNOW Caleb’s going to flip but Liam’s loving it.
Yeah in talks they talked the Liam wants everyone to know but Caleb as a character doesn’t
One of my favorite parts is when Nott uses it in a sentence the first time and stutters "I, uh, killed my F-.... killed my whole family...."
I'm imagining Liam off camera after the show saying in his signature nasally drone, "I've been crafting this dark dramatic storyline around my past and how and when I reveal that information to our party members and you just SHAT ALL OVER IT! YOU SHAT ALL OVER IT SAM!!"
Liam is addicted to conflict. He loves this
I honestly think they talked about it first. Like, Liam wanted everyone to know but didn't know how to bring it up and asked Sam to have Nott do it.
Didn't the group already know? I remember Caleb telling it to beau in the first few dozen episodes, and everyone was present at the table
@@doomerbloomer6160 they weren't. He actually asked them all to leave the table for that.
@@doomerbloomer6160 he toldo Beau and everyone else left but he told I think Fjord and Jester about it and at this point (I mean this episode) Yasha and Cad didn't know yet lmao
I choose to believe that Cad was awake @3:33
* Cut to the following day, where Nott throws herself off the bridge multiple times *
telling the foreign kid wrong sayings as they are learning the culture. that's what Not is doing.
I love the cuts to the cast's reactions. Travis, Marisha, and Liam dying of laughter and sharing confused looks, then Taliesin is just completely done. And that "Hahahah!" Was great
Funny how it could easily be an hyperbolic intimidation thing, but Sam went for a "Oh well" interjection
It becomes way more hilarious, since it is sounds so unnatural
why is Starscream trying to decieve us by wearing an Autobot shirt
He's a shifty one, that Starscream...
He's more than meets the eye.
Fuck, Sam did play starscream, didn’t he?
Which Starscream did he play?
@@camnunes8847 the War for/Fall of Cybertron version, he was the Starscream to Fred Tatasciore's Megatron
ashley has so many good one liners. "time is a weird soup", "jazz is chaos"... i love her
The build up for that ending, "I killed my whole family, I'll throw you under a bridge", wow that was hilarious.
I was really hoping Yasha would say it to a bunch of Halflings.
RIP
I miss Ashley so much, she is such a great presence at the table and the game feels just less without her!
I love her characters, but she WAS gone like half the time anyway.
I love that Matt’s like “Okay Nott and Yasha on first watch” and Ashely’s face is just “what am I in for?”
That look on Travis's face when Nott said Fjord is mean. Such betrayal.
Nott: Caduceus wouldn't do it he's a nice guy.
Taliesan: *evil laugh* oh sh- almost gave away my characters true intentions.
watch two sub -2 CHA characters interact like how the sheet says to is magical.
The comedic timing of this entire exchange is impeccable
Nott: Jesus Christ!
Me: Nott just invented Christianity - Canon.
bleachbleachBLEACHER he’s the nice carpenter kid they met in nicodranas
I hear he’s into wedding planning at venues too
Actually vax has a line (I don't swear but) he says the name then goes "whoever that is"
There's a pretty good actual play podcast called Rude Tales of Magic, one of the cast members slipped up in _episode one_ and said that phrase and one of the other party members responded "who exists in this world, you know!" and now it's a running joke in the series that Roman Catholicism exists in the world of Cordelia (despite Jesus' miracles being far less impressive in a world where healing magic and resurrection spells exist)
@@Sammie1053 He's just a dude everyone is forced to remember.
His name is a memetic curse.
I saw the title and thought it was a huge spoiler and when I actually watched the video and realized what it actually was it made me laugh like 30* harder lol
I want Nott to just adopt Yasha. Also, petition that the phrase “I killed my whole family” is now slang.
3:14 Definitely a surprised Pikachu face if I ever saw one XD
You know as much as this was a slip on Sam’s part (most likely) you could easily chalk this up to Nott being strung out and in the throes of withdrawal after cold turkeying for days. Regardless, it’s still hilarious.
Ashley johnson: deserving of that 7 charisma.
i just love the look on sam's face when he accidently says that, instantly you see him thinking, what did i just say?! how am i gonna talk my way out of this one?!
3:32 Taliesin: Whoops, let my dark side slip out a little.
Props to Nott for managing this while sober.
"Caduceus- he wouldn't do that"
The eldrish god taliesin: "HA HA HA HA- op!
"Where are you from?"
"Uhh... Upstate New York"
"Well, I'm from Utica and I've never heard the phrase 'I killed my whole family.'"
holy crap yasha is my favorite "i was trying to do the thing" "I'm learning how to people"
That moment when your biggest secret is revealed on accident
Possibly one of the most awkward conversations in the history of human communication. I loved it!
"Cad wouldn't do that, he's a nice guy" "PFFHAHA-oops"
Nott: Caduceus, he wouldn’t do that, he’s a nice guy
Talesin: hAhaHaHAA
Liam's face there: priceless
Liam's face there after getting fully caught up and coming back to it: still priceless
She is an absolutley amazing role player. The two of them made for a fantastically hilarious scene.
3:25 I love that Travis looks genuinely hurt here
I dont like how taliesin laughed when sam said cad is a nice guy. I mean it does seem off to have him play a good character but we could all hope for it to be true
Well, he is a grave cleric who makes tea out of dead people. He also has a bunch of siblings who he learned to play practical jokes on, and he worships mother nature (and nature is brutal as fuck).
I thought it was because Sam was dragging the other characters and Cad is just a nice guy and Talesin enjoyed that
Molly was good
I thought it was Cad laughing in character
"Do we die?" "Roll a d20."
Of embarrassment, yes
A burning dumpster rolling down a hill into a field of dry grass!
Dang. I really thought Pike Trickfoot was peak cute!Ashley, and I was wrong. I killed my whole family
I would like to point out that Sam says "Do you have that money I owe you" 4:20 and everyone is just too caught up in how funny this whole thing is to notice.
Edit: He also keeps saying "over" instead of "under" when referencing the bridge tossing.
Love that Liam isn't even mad about it, even reminds Ashley that Yasha didn't know about it.
I like how Nott's voice has kinda just turned into Sam's/Scanlan's.
Favorite Yasha line of all time " I'm trying to do the thing. Like, I killed my whole family, I'll throw you under a bridge... I'm learning how to people"
3:13. Liams reaction is just priceless.
I love this conversation so much and thank you for posting it but does her fucking shirt say ‘daddy’
it does.
Me: Don't worry guys I'll call- Ah! I killed my whole family... guys, I left my phone at home.
Friend who I've groomed mildly in the ways of critical role: Great, nice going. You've thrown us all under the freaking bridge.
Me: I'M LEARNING NOW TO PEOPLE OKAY, I KILL MY WHOLE FAMILY SOMETIMES!
This is completely besides the point but it needs to be said... Taliesin looks absolutely stunning here
If this conversation isn't in the Mighty Nein animated series verbatim I'm rioting
I'm so happy Ashley is back!
And she's gone in like a couple weeks :( ... silver lining: it's the last season.
0-o yeah she sure left a lasting impression
well this aged badly :-o
Caduceus over hearing the conversation and accidentally laughing is killing me
Liam is tearing himself apart and I love it.
Having not seen this episode yet, I thought the phrase was supposed to be a threat, but this is just great
Is it bad a part of me kind of would want to know what would have happened if Yasha had just casually went "Oh darn, guess I killed my whole family on that one guys". Like how would Caleb react to that? I imagine him just freezing in place, eyes so wide, "why would you ever say it like that?" 😦
Omg Caduceus laugh
I want Kanekuo to animate this so much.
On you RUclips vod of this episode someone pointed out that Yasha says she won't judge the party's magician, but uses a sword literally called "The Magician's Judge"
3:33 Mwuahahahaha!!!! I truly have fooled them all!
4:16 Sam internal thoughts "What can I say to fix this?! "
3:58
Nott starts explaining "I killed my whole family"
because of this title (i havent gotten to C2 yet) i thought yasha betrayed the group at some point holy shit. finally watched this, thank god im wrong
Ha.. ha ha ha... that would be TeRRibLe
"It's a figure of speech" I diiieeeed
Mondays right ?
Killed my whole family! Lol
Nott you’ve poisoned yasha
I was dying when I first time I saw this. Yeah that effect doesn't go away.
I like how they both ruled out Jester
Funny thing, later that episode, Nott WAS the 1st one thrown under the bridge...
4:21 “Do you have that money I owe you?”
You gotta love the fact that Ashley has a shirt on that says Daddy
Probably the most foot in mouth momment of critical role lol
"I'm learning how to people." was the better quote from that scene.
I still wanna know where Sam got that Autobots shirt. I love it.
I think from LootCrate a while back
Ashley's wearing a shirt that says "Daddy" and you wanna know about the autobots shirt? I kind of want to know who's calling Ashley daddy.
Lilith2014 Probably Brian W Johnson.
Michael Bell I feel like Ashley is the Daddy in that relationship
it’s been almost a year and i’m still waiting for this to come back up in a game
Gosh I love this band of disasters XDDD
What!? You didn't include Ashley's callback to it later in the episode. Harumph! Well thanks for sharing this bit at least. I think this is the best bit of improv we've seen from Yasha so far.
Sam is probably the funniest person I've ever seen in my life. He is hilarious
Edit. Thank you for the literal Joy and laughter.
This was my Favorite part of the Episode, lol. Great job Nico.
Familicide and depontification. This was the best scene so far this season.
this. this was one of the best watches ever. it was HILLAROUS (idk how to spell)
hilarious
_non-english speakers unite!_
i dont think i've ever seen someone with such a high passive intimidation score...
When your mom says something embarrassing you told them not to tell, to your friends when you go to the bathroom