Every U.S.S. Enterprise Side by Side | Size Comparison | Star Trek
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- #startrek #ussenterprise #startrekonline #ncc1701 #nx01 #startrekdiscovery
*** I mislabeled the Enterprise-J as a F on the screen supers. My apologies. ***
Ships featured:
NX-01
NX-01 (Refit)
NCC-1701 (TOS Constitution)
NCC-1701-A (TMP Constitution Refit)
NCC-1701 (Kelvin Timeline Heavy Constitution)
NCC-1701-B (Excelsior Refit)
NCC-1701-C (Ambassador)
NCC-1701-D (Galaxy)
NCC-1701-E (Sovereign)
NCC-1701-F (Yorktown Class Refit - 2418 (Not the 2409 Oddy))
NCC-1701-J (Universe)
Hi All,
Instead of looking at 2D size comparison images on Google Images, get a better perspective on the actual size differences between all the ships in the Star Trek universe that we know have been called - ENTERPRISE.
This videos has all the prime universe cannon including the Universe class Enterprise-J, the kelvin heavy constitution class and the Yorktown refit Enterprise-F from Star Trek Online.
I know some people are going to dispute some of the figures but there are so many out there that I chose the best fitting measurement based on the ship models in this video.
There will be also some that say the USS Enterprise-F is an Odyssey Class launched in 2409 in the Star Trek Online universe. Please note, the ship model in this video is the Yorktown refit after the Odyssey Enterprise and USS Yorktown were partially destroyed. The Yorktown Refit is the result of the repairs done as per this link below:
www.arcgames.c...
-----------------
I hope you all enjoy this video!
Snipey47a
"NCC-1701. No bloody A, B, C, or D." -Mr. Scott
I wish the computer would have asked him to specify pre or post refit (just for a little extra annoyance) LOL
After that Federation or Terren
...or "JJ"!
No Kelvin timeline, either.
Why’s that? It’s Star Trek is it not?
No idea why, but I've always loved the look of the Ambassador class ships. Seemed to be the perfect design to bridge the gap between the TOS and TNG eras.
Same. The Ambassador class is such an under appreciated ship. I really dig Andrew Probert's early design of the ship. The one that was displayed in the E-D Observation lounge. Since then people have made excellent orthos. As we know Eaglemoss made a small model of it. Hopefully they make an XL model.
There's a 3D printed version of the ship that I hope sometime get a 1/1400th of it.
Reminds me of car designs back in the 50's. Love it alo.
This isn’t real?
Much prefer it to the Galaxy Class!
I love making lego Star Trek ships, and my first batch of foot long starships I made all had inspirations from the ambassador class, just using tmp nacelles.
"Treat her like a lady and she'll always bring you home."
Admiral McCoy on ships named Enterprise
Daniel Haire Unless she gets in a skirmish with a Bird of Prey. Then she will blow half herself up and let Counselor Troi crash-land the other half.
That’s on Riker. He didn’t remodulate the shields. Imagine that inquiry by Starfleet Command. “You had one job.”
@@ryanspencerlauderdale687 They did remodulate the shields. Lursa and B’Etor could see the frequencies with Geordi’s visor. Riker’s failure was in not simply overpowering that ship with a massive barrage.
McCoy: "Treat her like a lady and she'll always bring you home."
Berman/Moore/Braga: "Heh heh, space ship go booooom."
In my opinion the beautiest of al Enterprises is the NCC 1701 Refit (motion picture, wrath of Kahn), the torpedo bay, secondary hull, the pylons, nacelles, just beautiful
the Enterprise from First Contact, Insurrection, and Nemesis for me
Alfredo Yañez completely agree, the refit is absolutely beautiful
I agree the NCC-1701 refit is a sexy girl
I like enterprise d the most
Sexy nice for the refit. I also like the JJA Enterprise. The Discovery Enterprise is a tie.
Always liked the E because of its streamlined design. But these days, I love the D design more. Somehow it feels more romantic.
To me the D always looked a cobra ready to strike because of how the neck fans out toward the saucer section.
Suing for intelligence Agree. When the saucer section is separated she looks like a naja.
The "E" is such a gorgeous ship. My all time favourite.
It is my favourite too :)
Mine too!
I've always loved the Sovereign class ever since First Contact.
It was a nice combination of the old long disign and the newer flat designs it was beautiful
The better by far
Honestly, NX-01 was my favourite and the show was too. Very limited technology by comparison, very fresh and new to the space scene, I just like it best.
NX-01. given warp-technology, our great-grandchildren will build her.
@Daniel Cox "limited technology"... Yes. Everything looks very 2005 in 2150.
If we ever get to the point of interstellar travel, all our other technologies at that point will be much more advanced than they even are in 31st century from Disco.
I'd love to see Archer in the NX-01 retrofit. Think that would be a great show. I liked that show the most as well. I mean Tpol is hard to miss. Probably the hottest of all the eye candy in the star trek world.
same here. Really enjoyed ENT except for the ending. Gotta talk to the writers about that.
@@leorickpccenter That ending had me more bummed out than the ending to Game of Thrones.
Star Trek The Motion Picture Enterprise is still the prettiest girl at the party. after all these years she still looks stunning.
She was my favorite for a long time as well. But (and I'm saying this as someone who loathes ST:D - don't tell me something is a prequel when it isn't) the Enterprise shown there was perfect.
The Enterprise J’s impulse drive is as big as the Enterprise NX-01 lol.
Do you mean it’s warp nacelle?
@Mr. Cool that's hard to imagine, holy shit. 🤯🤯🤯🤯
I really like the Enterprise J.
@@brianrogers7360 I personally dislike the saucer section but I like the rest of the ship
It shows JJ's (and Ruin Church's) lack of impulse control.
I hate when people hit dislike on videos where the maker has tried their best to create something for us all to enjoy.
Thanks for your comment , mate :). At a 92.8% TUP VS 7.2% TDN, and about 95% of the downs would be those who think the JJ Trek isn’t Star Trek.... you know the ones who believe in parallel clone universes as opposed to parallel alternate universes.
@@snipey47a no problem mate. Good video. Yeah lol. Those ones who think any trek made these days must be identical to TOS, crappy effects and all.
@Star Wars Clips LOL! You didn’t mention the sexist approach to women’s uniforms (which crept into the first season of TNG) and the list goes on... it’s like the wanted a modern version of a 1960’s style TV Western disguised as an Sci-FI set in space. I’m not an American but from my point of view, it’s the same folks who are in a subset of the group who probably voted for the current POTUS.
Politics! Oh no he didn’t.....!
should there only be a like button? lol i mean how does one improve without the knowledge that you last piece of work could have been better. it's not a personal attack and should never be seen that way.
prob youtube bot dislikes tho
The Enterprise D will always be my favorite followed by the Enterprise A Refit
same
Enterprise refit the 1st 3 movies, for me. More Grunty/Military Battlecruiser.
seeing all these old classic Enterprise...and then BOOM Enterprise from kelvin timeline...the big girl(quite literally) does puts the ALTERNATE reality into picture.
They are bigger in the ALTERNATE timeline.
Not only that, but the kelvin constitution class is more advanced. Including having things like saucer separation, and “Kelvin Pods”. I always thought it was interesting to see that.
The theory is that Nero's ship--being reverse-engineered Borg tech--was reverse engineered by Starfleet and being massive itself, they had to make the ships a bit bigger for the tech.
Hated that they did that. Thankfully that timeline died off due to poor box office performance.
@@480JD it was anything near to poor box office performance lmao
Enterprise J would make for an awesome series - Maybe the federation, by that time, have mostly explored the milky way and are sending Enterprise-J on a mission to the Andromeda, or Triangulum galaxy to almost start over again. My guess is by the 2600s, humanity have designed an engine that can travel to Andromeda within a year or two.
Just a little though.
The Andromeda Galaxy is approximately 2.5 million light-years away. The Federation starship USS Voyager was stated to need 70 years to travel 70,000 light-years, so at that speed, it would take 2.5 thousand years to get there..
@@masterk6571 Yes, but I'm guessing at least *some* advancement in warp travel would've been made in the 200 years since.
@@MattJohno2 I agree.
In the 230 years since the NX-01 was made there was a 92.13 fold increase in top speed.
NX-01: Warp 5 (TOS Scale) 125c
ENT-E: Warp 9.995 (TNG Scale) 11,515.56c
Assuming this trend remained constant by 2610, the top speed could be 1,060,865c, meaning it could cross 2.5 million light years in 2.36 years.
You might say they can't stay at top speed for long and this is true. However, that has increased as well. From barely an hour, at or near warp 5 being sustainable, to 12 hours at max speed by the TNG era. Thus, the amount of time they can maintain max speed would likely have increase too by 2610.
Indeed
@@abnerhayes6915 Discovery can jump to anywhere in the known universe so why not go to Andromeda or further ?
There is a slight error towards the end. The last ship, Universe class is listed as F when it should be J (bottom left hand corner). I have recently purchased NX01, 1701 - 1701J from Eaglemoss (in the UK) in a small scale and some of them in the XL scale.
Noticed that myself. Glad someone already pointed that out.
I was wondering Thanks
J's shuttlebay looks almost big enough to handle Kirks' ships.
@Shaun Ault I wouldn’t say stupid looking, if you tweaked the nacelles just a bit then it’d look more normal,
I see no reason to make a ship that large.
@@imkluu Right aside from the MANY enemies that have even larger more powerful ships. No reason at all....
@@spaceemperorkarl121 Well, to be fair "big" doesn't automatically mean better, but a bigger ship does provide significantly more space for phaser arrays, torpedo launchers and superior armor plating. On the other hand it provides a bigger target as well. So as with all things- pros and cons.
@@imkluu Enterprise-J is to be a "multi-generational" ship. If are spending your entire life on one ship, you would want it to be that large.
I always loved the Enterprise-E the Sovereign class was always my favorite design, the Enterprise-F looks pretty slick as well.
i love the odyssey class, its still one of my all time favorite feddie starship classes: right next to the Nebula, Luna, and Ambassador classes. im so glad that picard is going to make the odyssey class canon
For the Registry of the Enterprise J, you put Enterprise F, just saying...
The Great Bootleg it says J, I don’t see an F
@@mrbrandtastic5473 no it says F. Not on the ship on the side blurb
Father Cool oh.
This is the funniest reply section I've ever seen!
The video was immediately invalidated as soon as I saw that singular mistake.
NX-01 was just called Enterprise, no U.S.S. in the name
Knight ingale omg you’re right. Thank you
No A, B, C or bloody D either.
Yes. It was pre federation.
Depending on beta cannon. It was later updated to be S.S. Enterprise. But. In prime cannon. NX-01 Enterprise
And yet her mirror counterpart was known as I.S.S. Enterprise NX-01. Interesting.
Finally someone recognizes the Enterprise F from STO
the f is a dope looking ship
Got the class wrong though, the Enterprise F is Odyssey-class, not Yorktown.
The 1701 before the refit looks good in this video - gave me a new appreciation for it.
Harsh angles and smooth lines.
The original /refit they will always be it.
Yes. 👍
Refit is the one, more so than the A imo. I know they are supposed to be identical but something feels right about the Refit, maybe it was the slightly whiter paintjob or just the lighting in the first 3 films, that enterprise looked better from the outside.
I like the “C” better because it looks really like a simple version of the other enterprises and has one interesting history!
The first captain of the classic Enterprise was captain Robert April!
Yep, came to say the same thing! It was Robert April for the shakedown cruse, then Christopher Pike, then James Kirk. The refit Enterprise began with Captain William Decker, until Kirk came along and took that away from him.
A ship has to be commissioned to start counting its skipper. A shakedown cruise skipper doesnt count
Shakedown crews don't count
Dont forget Cpt. Spock ^^
@@demoscatpeders don't deserve their own ship.
Me: Searching up on U.S.S enterprise (Aircraft carrier) This title: USS Enterprise Me: *Seems legit*
There was someone I knew on the aircraft carrier so we talked through a online game when he wasn't working. I told him things I knew about it. A couple years before she was decommissioned. He said to me I knew enough to get put in the brig. No 1 outside the navy knew these things. I guess top secret. So it was funny. Now the new one when launched I will see it then.
It's just my personal taste, but I always liked the Constitution refit and the Sovereign class. 🙂
Ditto!
I have to admit though - I like how the Yorktown class refit, looks like an armor-clad Sovereign class 👍
My favorite two as well
proof that the JJ enterprise was badly scaled
jjprise was never meant to be the same size. I don't mind the upscale. I actually love the jjprise
It's like that bc the federation built it after nero showed up and destroyed Kelvin. In the Kelvin timeline the 1701 was built 13 years later than in the prime timeline bc they were spending more time to build the ship in the realization of the romulans.
Where else are you gonna store all those pipes?
@@devynsmith5280 then you've failed as a Trekkie. No true Trek fan would enjoy that failed nonsense of the Kelvin timeline.
Fleebie Stair nah kelvin timeline is already a different timeline before Nero showed up. The franklin is evidence of this as well as the fact that in the kelvin timeline 23rd century ships were massive compared to the prime timeline. The idea that starfleet of the 23rd century made a ship as big as the kelvin 20 some years before TOS takes place is ridiculous. Kelvin timeline is an alternate parallel universe with events mostly the same but still different(especially different in terms of technology). Nero just derailed it more than it already was compared to the prime timeline.
Enterprise D the love of my life. ❤
There were actually 5 captains of the Constitution class U.S.S. Enterprise. Robert April, (The Animated Series is now canon), Christopher Pike, James T Kirk, Will Decker and Spock. Will Decker was Captain during the refit, But Admiral Kirk took command in The Motion Picture.
Robert April ? The character's only television/movie appearance is in the Star Trek: The Animated Series episode "The Counter-Clock Incident".
@@masterk6571 It is still star trek canon though.
@@TheJustUsLeague The problem is that the fans pay more attention to canon than the showrunners do. They don't care enough, so don't be surprised if SNW completely craps all over that.
You are missing "temporary" Captains. The Episode "Doomsday Machine" (Commodore Matt Decker) and "The Deadly Years" (Commodore Stocker) took command.
@@RobPento Decker was unhinged; he got his entire crew killed after his own ship was severely crippled by the planet killer. Stocker was a bonehead with no command experience whatsoever; going through the Romulan Neutral Zone to reach a Starbase is something even a first-year cadet would know is a dumb idea.
To me, the NX-01 still steals my heart.
Thank you for putting this together. It really does an excellent job of showing the scales of these spectacular ships that the consumer models lack.
Glad you enjoyed it!
That's one of the good things Cryptic has tried to do in STO. Attempt to keep the starships, at least, properly scaled.
Which makes most of the KT ships even worse...
The J is such a throwaway design you KNOW they had no intention of ever using or seeing again.
A reused NX-01 Design just Bigger and upgraded LoL
"From what I understand, it was done quick and dirty, so was not really detailed in any way like a model we would use in multiple shots."
@@masterk6571 Absolutely has that feel.
My favorite is a tie between the NCC-1701 and NCC-1701-E. Love the Constitution Class and the Sovereign Class.
That universe class is ULGY, but I guess when you've got the equivalent of an entire spaceport flying around, looks don't matter much. The F was pretty good looking, but I still have to give the beauty contest to the E. That sovereign class may not have been as much the vision of peaceful exploration as the previous ships, but it just looks the most, to me, like something that would reasonably be in space and stand up to the rigors of exploration...with a mean right hook when it's needed.
hellcat1988 it's not! I love it. Hopefully the next Star Trek series will have the 1701J!
Best thing about the F IMO is that it was designed by a fan for Star Trek online
@@prometheuslxi3125 In all honesty, the first time I saw Voyager, I was excited and disappointed. I thought that they had made the secondary hull and nacelles too small. The sovereign class was a hell of a lot closer to what I thought it should have looked like, proportionally, and that's part of why I like it best.
@@hellcat1988 I love the Intrepid class . It seems the true perfect size for either military science or exploration. It is also a cool looking design. Only the Sovereign class
is better. I see them as the cruiser to the battleship in the same line of construction theory.
@@imkluu I like the intrepid too, but it's just so awkward looking with that huge saucer section paired with the tiny secondary hull and short little nacelles. It just never really felt like it was in the correct perspective. Like it was one of those pictures of dogs and cats where they zoom in on the head and make the body look small.
The Galaxy Class & Constitution II are and always will be my favorites.
same
Abrams verse Star Trek doesn't count.
Of course it does.
Fact: (Not sure if true) On the STO episode *Ragnarok*, you hear an announcement mid-battle on the Enterprise-J saying “ Captain Dax to all hands, brace for impact.” And on memory Alpha, it states the captain was...Captain dax
Well, it was Captain Dax who did the anouncing, they weren’t calling her but she called the crew too brace for impact
The Enterprise-J captain is a Dax, that is all we know
And it's an ugly ship.
Alex K it’s not really ugly. The enterprise d is ugly, for actual reasons
@@jerelo175 Woah woah woah, I'm ok with you liking the J, but insulting the D? The Galaxy Class is a beautiful ship you ignoramus.
I Believe there is a reason to build a ship like the Universe Class, and the Enterprise-D is a beauty of ship, btw.
J looks like something q came up with to slice up his galactic size pizza's....
I always appreciated how each ship is just a tad larger then its alphabetical predecessor - kind of like bra sizes. Too bad there was no Enterprise DD 😆😆😆
Or the Dolly Parton class
Riker's Enterprise in All Good Things is the Double D!
Until the G 😂
The Excelsior class B Enterprise and Constitution refit are best-looking in my opinion
My favorite remains the Constitution class NCC-1701. The cleanest design of them all and it was a tough mother.
The Kelvin Timeline or the Prime Timeline?
My all time favorites are 1701, 1701A, 1701C, 1701E, JJprise. 1701B looked like a passenger ship, as does 1701D. Haven't made up my mind about 1701F. As for 1701J, I don't like the design.
I agree, the saucer section needs to be turned 90 Degrees.
Am I the only one that's alright with the Enterprise J?
Totally Nothing No. you’re not actually. I like it.
She's just a really big retro looking ship :) The nacelles and what holds them should'nt be much of a deal, they can be that thin maybe because of the technology Starfleet had in that era
The galaxy class is definitely my favorite. But I’m good with the enterprise J. It’s damn big though.
I just can't get behind it. It's like someone took a Galaxy Class, and turned it into playdough and messed it up.
I am ok with it as it was in trek canon.
just love those 24ft high docking hatches on the jj enterprise
I will always love the 1701 refit
The Enterprise NX-01 is my fav Enterprise.
Respect and keep up the epic work.
through the years her legacy will NEVER be forgotten
Imagine how much easier Archer would of had it if he had the J back before the Federation was made.
It's basically a mobile battle station
Did Archer even know how big the J was ? Didn't seem to react much to it's size.
Built for dimensional incursions, so it would need to be a battle station
I think I'm in the minority when I say my favorite is actually the NX-01 feels more possible and like the first voyages to explore the artic.
Quite possible. The SpaceX concept shuttles look very similar to the 'Enterprise' intro vessel OV-165 which is meant to be a future descendant of the space shuttle Enterprise (OV-101) and is listed as a hypersonic vessel, all tech being designed right now. The following ship, Ganges-Class SS Emmett looks like something we could definitely see in about 75-100 years if not sooner so I don't think it's an outrageous leap to say we may very well have vessels looking similar to NX-Class in the next 150 years, warp drive or not.
I love the NX class but her refit? Boy thats just awesome.
If that scaling were correct, then the captain's yacht on the enterprise F (can be seen on the underside of the saucer) would be as big as Kirk's entire ship.
Flying anything smaller than a Ambassador class feels like being the smallest fish in an ocean of leviathans in Star Trek Online.
The Ambassador class is hands down my number one all-time favorite Trek starship. It is a beautiful design, much more proportional, symmetrical and balanced than both the unevenly proportioned, awkwardly bottom-heavy Excelsior and the overly exaggerated, strangely top-and-forward-heavy Galaxy. I see in it a somewhat 'retro Connie' look, like a much heavier, more massive, super beefed-up Constitution class on steroids.
I never liked how "older" ships from "newer" movies were some how bigger than their predecessor namesakes.
They're not tho, the only ship for which this is the case is from another universe with a much more militarized Starfleet.
@@limburgishmapping7166 Well, first the NU-1701 was 1200 ft/366 m, and then it was doubled in size, so it is bigger.
@Mr. Cool Dude's way of saying the Kelvin timeline Enterprise
That's JarJar Abrams for you: "If it's bigger, it must be betterer!" Just look at the hot mess he made of "Starkiller Base" in that abortive Force Awakens garbage. "It's bigger! It's the Best!" Right... steals the name from a SW game to boot. He's about as original and talented as my left foot.
@@Iluvantir Jar Jar… he ruined my favorite villain too….
KHAAAAAAAAAAAN
I think he ruined Star Trek more then he did Star Wars
I would say that the USS Excelsior/Enterprise B, would be a highly formidable opponent against the Kelvin Enterpise.
I wonder if Enterprise J has some Borg tech in it 🤔
Michael Barnes at the time of the enterprise j the borg are all probably long defeated
@@capgangchannel6309 I wouldn't be surprised if Starfleet had already reverse engineered there Tech already.
And then some... You might have some voth or iconian technology in there as well. Definitely has transwarp capabilities for sure.
@@DeathBYDesign666 yeah imagine if we could reverse engineer some Undine tech and begin to apply it to Federation ships.
According to Lower Decks the Borg eventually join the the "Federation" of the future.
I wish we had has a series with the enterprise b and one with the enterprise c.
Future enterprise d with 3 warp nacelles is my favorite followed by the e
I honestly love them all, except the J. The J just looks goofy to me.
The A refit, B and D just seem to have the most class to them.
I'm really starting to warm up to the Enterprise-F. The Enterprise-J, though... I will say that the interior set that we saw in the Enterprise episode looked pretty good.
My favorite will always be the one from movies 1-6. Ever since I saw that opening scene of it in the motion picture.
If the Enterprise J is gigantic compared to past Enterprises, can you imagine how big Enterprise Z will be?!
Death Star size
You know it's weird that every Federation Starship that has carried the name Enterprise in the Star Trek universe has been of every Starship class seen on the show and in the movies.
It's because Starfleet traditionally names the flagship Enterprise, and being the flagship it has to be top of the line, cutting edge technology.
Always loved D the most. Its the one that feels most like a big capital ship that hangs there in space being huge and intimidating. It doesn't maneuver very fast but it doesn't really need to. The other ones just don't have the same vibe.
My favorite was the Constitution-class refit. Never cared for the ones that came after, certainly not the reboot versions.
Good comparison, missed the Odyssey variant of the F though before it was refit into the Yorktown
Visually they aren’t very different except for the resolution of some of the textures that came as part of other graphical life cycle improvements and never attributed to the refit.... well almost essentially a rebuild of the original 1701-F Odyssey class.
1701-F’s original sister ship the was USS Yorktown. The Yorktown was significantly more damaged than the Enterprise-F at the climax of the Iconian War requiring the Yorktown to be almost completely rebuilt as well as incorporate all advancements in technology that were achieved since it was launched.
Since the Yorktown rebuild was essentially a 80% all new ship it received a new registry denoting this change. The Odyssey Enterprise-F, while less damaged, benefitted from what was happening to the Yorktown and received the same enhancements resulting is slightly different external dimensions but entirely new offensive, defensive and operational systems.
All of this was done under the YORKTOWN REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT with the rebuild USS Yorktown being the lead ship of that class and the repair and refitted Enterprise-F changing from Odyssey to Yorktown Class.
Yorktown (Block 2) Stats (vs Odyssey (Block 1))
Mass - 6.8732 million metric tonnes (vs 6.6221 million metric tonnes)
Length - 1.041.5 metres (vs 1,061.1 metres)
Beam - 385.32 metres (vs 371.88 metres)
Draught - 150.84 metres (vs 147.92 metres)
Minimal Crew to Operate - 900 (vs 1,800)
PROPULSION
Yoyodyne 47B M/ARC Warp Core (vs 46A)
Two Keenser/Pegg Heavy Impulse Engines (vs Two Charon Yards Hyper Impulse Engines)
Two Inline Flux Secondary Impulse Engines (vs 10 Zhiv/Ren SR83 Impulse Thrusters)
SENSOR ARRAY
Twelve DYN-90 multi band linear sensor suites with four omniwave passive sensors and one JAWS active directional array (vs four DYN-75 multi band linears, four omniwave passives and one J-DOME Omni-directional sensor array)
WEAPONS
Twenty-one Mark 14 phaser arrays and 6 variable payload torpedo launchers (vs 18 mark 12 arrays and 4 variable torpedo launchers)
In STO, is there not a line of dialogue from the Battle of Procyon 5 that mentions a Captain Dax for the Enterprise-J?
A few foot notes about these ships named Enterprise..
The J.J verse Enterprise is not actually as big as claimed by the studio. There's actually some really awesome well made scale comparisons made based off of in movie scenes that actually makes the ships appear to be smaller then those claims made.
Also official sources and even in movie scenes. Plus simple logic. All point to the "Sovereign Class" U.S.S. Enterprise 1701-E is actually smaller then that of the "Galaxy Class" U.S.S. Enterprise 1701-D.
The largest reason for the Sovereign Class being smaller then a Galaxy Class Class the Galaxy is meant for Federation colony support and long term exploration and scientific missions and to rarely return to earth.
Hence why it was so large and also Saucer separation function to allow the civilian personal to remain in safety while the star drive section deals with the threat.
While the Sovereign Class is a pure military role ship and has no civilian population on board and is meant to reflect a more stripped down pure military ship.
Hence the reduced size of the ship.
who claims the kelvin timeline/jjverse Enterprise? CBS? Bad Robot?
@@FLAME4564 I can't find the video that does a scene by scene breakdown of the JJ Enterprise size comparison.
But I did find this website that does a break down of how the JJ Enterprise dies change size in the movies.
www.ex-astris-scientia.org/articles/new_enterprise_comment.htm
Yeah the studio really screwed the pooch with the JJ-prise. It originally was the same size as TOS Enterprise, everything re: decks windows match. The ONLY reason they claimed that ludicrous size was because JJ wanted a shot of dozens of space shuttles simultaneously leaving the Kelvin, which based on the TOS Enterprise shuttlebay was impossibly small to depict, so they just waved their hands and magically doubled the size of the shuttlebay on the Kelvin, and in doing so doubled the size of the ship, and as their is a similar shuttlebay to the Kelvin seen on the JJ-prise, it to got magically scaled up to ridiculous proportions.
Except all official records show the length of the sovereign as longer than Galaxy. The Galaxy could carry more as it had more volume. (More decks and huge saucer) the sovereign was built as a military only ship. So it's utilitarian over the spacious Galaxy.
The Galaxy class is fatter and possesses more internal volume, the Sovereign class is longer... so the Video is still correct.
Galaxy Class #1 of all Enterprise
Nicely done. I like that you included the Kelvin-Enterprise. If Star Trek Online ever includes Discovery-Enterprise in the game do you plan to make another video with it?
That ship is coming and yeah I probably will :)
Enterprise D...most beautiful ship in entire sci-fi
As they say. Beauty is subjective. Cause to me it looks ugly as shit😂
Glad to see the B & C included, they're often left out due to not having much known about them
Nicely done video. The 1701-J looks GREAT here! As for Fate, didn't most "ships named Enterprise" get destroyed? :-)
Yes but most of them had at least 9 lives first...
The Kelvin time line Consition Class Enterprise isn't pretty enough to be called Enterprise!!
@DemonSlayer ByKnight I would beg to differ.
Looks are not always everything.
Was the typo intentional? You're missing a few letters in constitution class.
THE ENTERPRISE'S LOOKS ARE NOT ALWAYS THE SAME! IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT KIND OF LOOK THE ENTERPRISE HAD, IT DOESN'T MATTER! YOU CAN MAKE IT DIFFERENT THO, BUT YOU CAN'T SAY THAT THE LOOK OF THE ENTERPRISE IS UGLY!!! IT CAN BE DIFFERENT LIKE ENTERPRISE-D AND ENTERPRISE-E, BUT YOU DO NOT SAY THAT THE LOOK IS NOT MATCHING FROM THE 1900S STAR TREK! JUST LET THE SHIP'S LOOK BE DIFFERENT FROM HATING ON THE ENTERPRISE'S NEW LOOK!!!!! OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The Enterprise B is my favorite. It should've been given its own show. Or at least a miniseries.
It's mine too but as films go I wish it had more budget because a refit Excelsior is just lazy!
Agree.
Enterprise B looks like a beautiful sailing ship.
A great show would have been Harriman is removed and replaced with another captain.
Be great TV.
Then at the end the same captain gets Enterprise C and that could be movies.
Then the ship is turn over to Captain Garrett and the rest is history. 👍
I’m very fond of The Excelsior class design of vessel! I would love it if they did a proper run of seasons of shows themed around the Adventures of John Harriman’s Enterprise B.
Isn’t he replaced at some point by Demora Sulu? Although I’m sure I read somewhere that John Harriman goes on to be a very exemplary captain of The Enterprise, almost the equal of Archer Kirk and Picard. Even Rachel Garret and Robert April
Enterprise D has always been the best looking to me-
D like a cobra to me but it is beautiful. The sauce disc can separate!
Hopefully the next Star Trek series will have the Enterprise J!
awesome vid, always wanted to see the diff Enterprise next to another, canon and beta cannon alike, tho i noticed 2 small errors: the NX-01 and NX-01 Refit cant both be launched in 2151, as Archer was on mission for years with the original NX-01 before it was refited, and the other is the Enty-J is listed as NCC-1701-F in the info text in the lower left corner (not to criticise, not at all, just thought i point it out * ^^ *) thx for the awesome vid =)
the refit would have been in the 5th season so approx 2155 or 2156
Fitting music, may I ask what it is
Very good job on this.
Although you should have included the 1701 refit. As we know the refit was launched 18 months after the 5 year mission under Captain Kirk. BTW the NX-01 Refit would have been launched 5 years later after the original configuration. So the launch date would NOT be the same 2151 but rather 2156.
Just a little annoyance of mine I do not care too much for the Kelvin U.S.S. Enterprise. I just will never accept that ship being freaking BIGGER than a Galaxy class. I know their reasonings behind the larger ships. I just can never accept it. I also despise the overall shape of it, especially the design. The Kelvin Enterprise-A (seen at the end of ST Beyond) on the other hand that was MUCH better in terms of shape and design. Although I still don't like the way how the lower part of the secondary hull like it's predecessor.
Yeah, the Kelvin Enterprise has irked me from the first time I laid eyes on it. It's just so weird looking. I remember thinking to myself in the theater, "Who the hell thought that THIS was a good idea?!"
Wow, you managed to make the J look a little less stupid. Impressive.
The Enterprise D is my favourite of all the Starships named Enterprise
Yes me too
@@FedericoTiberi74 Cool
same ,I was always confused that in the dominion battles the galaxy classes never separated the saucer sections, don't ya think
@@danielbyrne5402 Yeh I mean if they had separated the star drive section with the battle bridge could have fought the Dominion a lot better & it would have looked so cool
thought star drive was called saucer section @@ussakira7294
Hello, May I ask, why did you stop making videos? You have such an AWESOME talent!
Thank you for your kind words. Simple answer is Real Life that required me to put a lot of things I was doing to be put on hold. Ive been thinking more and more lately about coming back.
My favorite is actually the smallest one, Enterprise NX-01. My second favorite is NCC 1701-F, that ship is gorgeous! Awesome video, I didn't really like the music though to be honest.
Would be nice to include OV-101 and CVN-65.
If I had accurate 3D models of them, I probably would have.
Great video! I loved it! Great job! I love all of these ships, but my favorite is the USS Enterprise from the Kelvin Timeline. It just has this really sleek and futuristic look. Lol, it has the vibe down. That being said, they are all awesome :)
@Michael Dinneweth Sir, it's a opinion. Your not a true fan if you can't respect others opinion.
@Michael Dinneweth I can respect your Opinion, But don't be a jackass and Just say that He's a fake fan. It's his opinion.
Never took a liking to the Kelvin model or the Galaxy class as they looked too bulky. Also the Kelvin interiors looks like it got its inspiration from a Pachinko parlor while D from an 80s Rolls Royce.
I feel like I'm the only one in this comments section that is okay with the Enterprise from the Kelvin timeline. I actually like it.
You're not alone
Same as well. Have you seen the new version of the enterprise from Discovery, basically take all the shiny elements from kelvin and place them over on the TOS ship design. So good!
The 1701 looks like designed be engineers, the later ones like designed by designers. That makes the 1701 the most realistic and after all, the most beautiful one for me.
Get that JJ prise monstrosity outta there! Other than that great video👍
Agreed.
Add me to the “get it out of here” list as well!
The Enterprise-E is my personal favorite!
Yes, this is a monstrosity indeed.
I agree to a degree... All he had to do was update/ modernise the original taking it a little further from the NX instead he builds his version of the NSEA Protector lol! The size of it puzzles me mind I get that like all tech the better it becomes the smaller it becomes ie Mobile phones but would the Federation want to build such vast ships I doubt it As they're costly!
Makes complete logical sense that the destruction of a single science vessel would mean the upcoming Constitution class would receive a redesign making it twice the size no?
A true trek fan, you forgot 2 an iterations(NCC-1701 refit/A and the JJ NCC-1701-A), but that okay, it's the one that you left out that truly shows you love this franchise. You even put in the NX-01 refit! Thank you so much!
The JJ doesn't belong. That's just wrong.
@@alexmast64 what do you mean?
@@darthazgorath9570 I mean that any ship from a JJ Abrams film does not belong here. They are not canon.
NX-01 could possibly fit in the shuttle bay of the Enterprise Y if it got bigger like they did with J
How big it would be
... X... Y and Z? A galaxy size starship?
The A is my fav. Its just the refit but better and it’s probably the most iconic look of the enterprise as it was shown on the big screen for 12 years straight.
You misclassed Enterprise F as a Yorktown class refit. It's an Odyssey class. Also, it was launched in 2409, not 2418
Knight ingale incorrect. That version is the Yorktown class refit from 2418.
When was that created? I mean, since STO is still in 2410
Check out the arc link in my video description. I could be wrong about the date because I’ve seen instances of sto progressing the years from 2409 in real time but also examples where that isn’t so clear cut
Yeah they do make it rather confusing. The last story mission to give a date said 2410, but the stardate is still going normally every day. I guess when you're doing nothing in the game, time goes by normally, when you do a mission, it's sometime in the past?
Yes was launched as an Odyssey class in 2409 but In 2410 after the iconian war it was refitted into the Yorktown variation. Source from the sto wiki.
The largest ship in the 25th century looks like a sleek aerodynamic manta ray. It is beautiful!
So much hate for the Kelvin Enterprise. I think it looks great! It's modernized but keeps true to the original. People are just afraid to change it.
Evan Guthrie finally! The voice of reason!
Its not the ship its the J.J. verse it belongs to.
@@optimuscprime I also love the Kelvin timeline.
I also enjoy the look of the ship. I can’t wait for the next Star Trek to get a look at the Enterprise A.
The whole kelvin timeline and STD sux ass. Think about it... the ships are ugly and way too big for the era... Kirk being promoted to an O6 in his 3rd year as a cadet and given the flag ship of ggd federation... makes absolutely no sense at all. In this alt reality thd ships should be relatevly the same as the prime universe. That is ST lore. Everytime they screw with the timeline the ships etc asthetically stay pretty much the same... except for the Jar Jar universe. Klingons are so utterly wrong in Kelvin and STD that it pains me to even coment about it. Khan was such a total disapointment. They could have atleast fixed the Enterprise in Beyond with the new ship, but the screwed that up too.
Enterprise Refit and B will always be the best... such a great ERA of Trek Films...
"Kirk, You Do This, You'll Never Sit in the Captain's Chair Again."
The only thing out of place - for me at least - is the Enterprise J. The model really wasn't fleshed out too well and I wish Doug Drexler really fixed it - instead, everybody after him took it as "finished" and called it a day. The rest of the other ships (the Kelvin Timeline Enterprise included) had more VOLUME and seemed better "proportioned" compared to the flat pancake profile of the J. Call me entitled, but I wished Doug fleshed out the J a little more - it's the "future" setting Star Trek for the J and they're still USING warp nacelles that far out? It looked as some part of the Federation stagnated in it's forward momentum of technology and adhered to a "basic" design pattern centuries behind them. I know they were probably embroiled with the Temporal War, but seriously? I would have thought they'd do away with nacelles later on as tech should have kept on advancing past that.... however, I'm also considering the Enterprise J to be a possible alternate timeline ship belonging to it's own universe.
What always boggled my mind was when I found out just out big the Enterprise J was. I mean it makes even the Odyssey look so small is crazy
Alot of hate for the JJprise and I understand why that is, i however got my hands on the revell model kit for it and it's a beauty. This might be one of them ships you need to hold in your hands to see the best of it. Now if only they did the NX refit.
They just released for 2019 the Polar Lights NX-01, with parts to build it as the Refit.
It's too bad Captain Sulu never had his own TV Show! Great job on the graphics!
If only they had properly scaled the JJprise. (I mean, I'd still have issues with the design, but at least the size would have been on par with the original canon)