Mohammed Hijab "Refutes" Shaykh Albani
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 мар 2021
- Mohammed Hijab "Refutes" Shaykh Albani
Please support Ilmstitute 🤝:
❤️ Patreon: / ilmstitute
GoFundMe: www.gofundme.com/f/ilmstitute...
PayPal: www.paypal.me/ilmstitute
CashApp: cash.app/$BrotherSaajid
RUclips Membership: / @saajidlipham
📚 Islamic Classes: courses.ilmstitute.com
👕 Merch! (shirts, hoodies, etc.): teespring.com/stores/ilmstitute
🔗 Social Media:
📱 Facebook: / brothersaajid
📱 Twitter: / saajidlipham
📷 Instagram: / ilmstitute
💻 Website: www.ilmstitute.com
🔈 Soundcloud: / user-1260072
🔈 Podcast: itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/i...
I'm a lay muslim but I listen to a lot of Shaykh al Albani's tapes on youtube, and maa shaa Allaah I can sense that he's a man of taqwa (and Allaah knows best). He's one of the strictest scholars that I know of, and he didn't even claim that he's a scholar, he said he's only a student of knowledge. May Allaah have mercy on him. I love him for the sake of Allaah ❤.
May Allah keep you steadfast upon Islam and trusting the right scholar. And may Allah protect you from waswasa against a scholar.
For knowledge won't be taken back from the land, but by death of scholars.
May I ask what really happened?
I wish I knew Arabic so I could listen to The Sheikh's talks
@@mohammadkhan2101 you can still listen to english subs tho
@@ziasmailbox It's not waswasa ya akhi, either you do your own research or at least listen to both sides or you simply keep quiet and not accuse anyone ... May Allah guide us , bless us and have mercy on us all ....
It's important for the likes of brother Muhammad Hijab to remain in their lanes as public speakers not to indulge in the matters of complex Islamic jurisprudence that require mastery and understanding of the classical Islamic literatures.
Agreed. InshaAllah he learns and grows from this
Its important sheikh bin baz stays in his lane and doesnt speak science and say the sun goes around the earth
@@discoveringtruth594 how can you seperate "worldy" knowledge from religious knowledge . When religion is practiced in the world . Thats like saying being versed in quantum mechanics is segregated from physics and mathametical calculus and logarithms
@@discoveringtruth594 science is the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of something . Thus religious sciences can never be seperated from so called natural sciences since all science is via process systematic study. And religion only exists due to the world existing becayse its only humans who need it . There both intertwined together . The Quran will never contradict things we can observe empirically . However things like human evolution is not able the observe empirically due to it happening "apparently " 25 million years ago .
so then why is saajid speaking about it
He is not a great scholar of Saudi Arabia He is a great scholar of Islam.
This shows these people understanding of Islam.
@@hhhhh-kj8dw Your love for Mohammed Hijab has blinded you, to the point you're giving him accolades and massively exaggerated praise. Subhan'Allaah.
He is great scholar of balkan too
@@hhhhh-kj8dw calm down no one is multiplying his good deeds by 0, u don't have to certify him what good he has done for the Ummah its Allah(swt) who will decide u being certifying him will not do any good or harm to him on the day of judgement so it would be better if everyone thinks of themselves and rectify their affair and think of defending themselves(with their deeds) in front of their Lord.
Also no one is belittling him as well they are just saying do a proper research before commenting on any matter otherwise it might lead to a fitna.
Imagine if everyone starts speaking without proper research what will be the result.
@@hhhhh-kj8dw 28:15 , 18:45
You've made an excellent point my brother.
Mashallah
Saajid, I’m thankful for your videos, brother. As a new Muslim you are helping me immensely. May Allah continue to guide you.
Watch sheikh uthman ibn farooq, khaled green, nasseha sessions, Abu Ibrahim husnayn, Abu mussab akhari, efdawah, hamzas den, Tim humble kalamology
@@iimiboy i second this
@@Vincent_Law I’m sure that ustadh abu mussab would appreciate the good deeds.
@@Vincent_Law why? Is it because he is a thorn in the throats of deviant sects?
@@Vincent_Law Abu Mussab's Dawah is on point. Shut the hell up
Alhamdulliah I'm so happy that you guys made this video. I truly appreciate the level of clarity mashallah. This now makes me be more cautious about certain information presented without context. It’s so messed up to purposefully make lay muslims distrust their scholars.
The biggest problem in the ummah, is bad character by All of us.
We have a horrible characteristic of needing to prove ourselves superior/ correct. We cannot allow differences in opinions to coexist. When the information that we have is not clear cut, then it's ok for opinions to differ.
Surely we don't need to pick fights.
May Allah guide us.
Aameen🙏
Even if an ulama or amir set the ijtima n wrong he still get a half of reward from Allah. If he becomes right with the ijtima/fatwa he will get two
@@skyinuri8868 brother, it’s not always that we want to be correct or superior, some of us want to verify and understand the “truth” as so much fabrication, weak Hadiths, opinions and what not has been entered into our deen. It is our duty to verify every information we get. Speaking of which, I would like to know where do you get this information from that even if an Alim or Amir is wrong they still get half the reward ? I have heard this before, but I want to verify this information from authentic resource. Please and thank you.
@@skyinuri8868 You mean Ijtihad brother?
@@gul139
Here's the Hadith
حَدَّثَنَا يَحْيَى بْنُ يَحْيَى التَّمِيمِيُّ، أَخْبَرَنَا عَبْدُ الْعَزِيزِ بْنُ مُحَمَّدٍ، عَنْ يَزِيدَ بْنِ عَبْدِ، اللَّهِ بْنِ أُسَامَةَ بْنِ الْهَادِ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، عَنْ بُسْرِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ، عَنْ أَبِي قَيْسٍ، مَوْلَى عَمْرِو بْنِ الْعَاصِ عَنْ عَمْرِو بْنِ الْعَاصِ، أَنَّهُ سَمِعَ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ " إِذَا حَكَمَ الْحَاكِمُ فَاجْتَهَدَ ثُمَّ أَصَابَ فَلَهُ أَجْرَانِ . وَإِذَا حَكَمَ فَاجْتَهَدَ ثُمَّ أَخْطَأَ فَلَهُ أَجْرٌ " .
'Amr b. al-'As reported that he heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:
When a judge gives a decision, having tried his best to decide correctly and is right, there are two rewards for him; and if he gave a judgment after having tried his best (to arrive at a correct decision) but erred, there is one reward for him.
Sahih Muslim, 1716 a
In-Book Reference: Book 30, Hadith 18
USC-MSA web (English) reference: Book 18, Hadith 4261 (deprecated numbering scheme)
Bad people are more than good ones
I like Hijab, but he is an arrogant man, he will mention big names but when it comes to him he doesn't like it :) Good on You Saajid Keep calling him to good whether they like it or not.
I mean why even he take that topic to refute syekh albani. Does islam really set "haya" for muslim females only???? He is a man n choosing "breastfeeding adult" as his important debate! Astaghfirullaah..
"It is not for a believing man or a believing woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decided a matter, that they should [thereafter] have any choice about their affair. And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has certainly strayed into clear error." Surah Al-Ahzab
Don't act as if you heard it from Muhammad (SAW) mouth.
@@laymansexperience7195 what you mean
@@laymansexperience7195 it's in the Quran!!!!! WHAT YOU ON ABOUT
MashaAllah, the exact ayah I was thinking of
@@abbysheyba8421 I advise you to remove that profile picture
All those who are commenting without even watching the video, you will be asked about what you say by Allah on the day of judgement.
I saw the video. @14:40. Can you imagine a 30 year old breastfeeding from a 35 year old woman?
And why are there waaaaayyyy tooooo many cutss in the videos.
@@slkslk7841 so are you now going to attack Imam An Nawawi, Imam At Thawri, Imam Ibn Hazm? What about Aisha (RA)? They all had the same interpretations. Are you now going to start cursing at Aisha?
@@hereweare9096 ruclips.net/video/bg1s1r-7vnk/видео.html
@@slkslk7841 OF COUUUURSE THAT IS NOT THE CASE
Brother Saajid forgot to mention one point is that: even before Muhammad (SAW) became a Prophet, he was well-known for his truthfulness in Makkah, and now it's not easy to imagine why Abu Bakr (R.A.) easily believed what Muhammad (SAW) said, besides the fact that he of course was the Prophet's close friend
Abu Bakr believed what the prophet said because he believes he is a prophet. Very simple.
When you read a lot and know some things and you start to think of yourself as a person of knowledge, ego can creep up on you.
People pumping you up on social media and saying only good things will eventually get to you, and you will think that everything you read youve understood and that your opinion matters even if you dont have any experience in the particular field.
اللهم علمنا ما ينفعنا ونفعنا بما علمتنا
As a Muslim from Saudi Arabia who studied Islam from the youngest age, I understand a couple of things. One of the most important ones is knowing that Fatwa should be made by Mufteen, and Hadeeth should be interpreted by Muhadetheen. Al Albani is an outstanding Muhadeth, but a normal mufti who might get some stuff wrong. If you're looking for a Fatwa, check Outstanding Mufteen like Ibn Baz or Ibn Uthaymeen. There can be scholars who are outstanding at both or more, but Al Albani has a couple Fatwas that lot of notable scholars disagree with.
Ali dawah went crazy on Dawah man for this type of behaviour yet he’s excusing MH. 🤦🏿♂️
subhanAllaah the double standards and hypocrisy is too much to list
MH will kick him out of the squad. maybe thats why. hes a clever man..
@@reXdbz I advise you to remove that profile picture
Muhammad Hijab needs to drop the theatrics and he needs to deal with his infinitely inflating ego. I've been following him for a few years now and he's getting worst as time goes. He needs to take some time off, hit the reset button. May Allah guide him and us.
Yeah he does kinda need to cool off a bit. I know he’s capable of being better than this. We need that 2017 Mohammed Hijab back. I’m happy about the David Wood debate and the growth of his channel in these past 3 - 4 years but since then it’s been going downhill for him.
@@TheGloriousQuran6236 even the way he laughs at people shows how inflated his ego and arrogance have become maybe this blunder is a sign from Allah to humble him.
May Allah guide me him and you to stay humble and accept the truth when it comes to us.
Yes, I agree. Arrogance is what drove devil out of paradise and we need to protect ourselves of that.
@@helmetband Exactly brother May Allah give brother hijab more patience and hidayah of
@Karim Hussein Muhammed hijab misrepresented a great scholar.
1 he has no right to with the issue he brought up.
2 his apology wasn't an actual apology
3 he needed this to put him down a peg this is the best form of humbling if he takes it in the correct manner
4 we can't be a fan of any individual.
Some illiterate people who mistakenly think that they are scholars, insult the pious like Al-Albani, this is really outrageous.
@@somebody700 read it again
@@somebody700 The fact there wasn't actually problem other then Mohammad Hijab's lack of understanding and critical thinking.
Who you calling illiterate,is that the way of a believer?shame on you
The adaab and mannerism in which this response was done is exemplary. Over the last year refutation fever has taken over youtube channels, which has been distressing especially in the way they've been done. This video was necessary and a breath of fresh air.
I hope the likes of MH and others learn from it and others look into themselves to recognise their own cognitive biases which lead to their videos in the first place. May Allah protect Saajid and Omar
a year later and its still getting worse. Gone are the days where scholars contact one another privately to address matters such as these, gone are the days where scholars are polite with one another. Wait, in all honesty, true scholars still represent that, muslim youtubers not so much.
What is the context of the context of the context? Its called Jalebi
Who is he compared to Ash Shaykh al Albani? This guy is out of his league and should just shut up and leave the dawah to a real da'ee or Shaykh.
Hijab even compared shaykh al Albani with a sufi al Dadow, he said al Dadow is better.
@Mynameis Myname its hijab the ikwani liar that teaches blind following groups like dadu the sufi kariji violent devil...
@@abdulibnabdul1666 Don’t insult the brother when he’s not here to defend himself that’s Gheebah(Backbiting), so don’t fall in to this sin brother. It may also be slandering if it isn’t true.
Mohammad Hijab is a pseudo talib al ilm. He doesn't really have the qualifications to speak on most of the topics he delves into
@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud it doesn’t matter. The scholars today will never compare to the likes of Imam Malik or Imam Shafi’i
I honestly wasn't going to watch this long video but that be insincere of me considering the fact I wanted to have light on this topic but I'm glad for giving it a chance and you all need to do the same, watch this full video thoroughly to understand the topic.
@Dan H Well said.Most if not all the negative and hate comments are covering these comments section because no ones willing to listen the full way.
@@youtubeowl9544 Really? What video were u watching?Watch the full thing.Overall they did say they aren't here to force u or support and immortalise the Shaykh but they are reminding us of the honour and manner in which we should approach a scholar of Islam.They are inheritors of the prophet(SAW) positions in Islamic knowledge and Islamic leadership.Be greatful for these people before Allah takes them and we r left with the ignorant and barely knowledgeable leaders and teachers.
After the prophets and khalifa we have left true dreams and the rightly guided scholars whom Allahs messenger(SAW) said will be well guided by Allah but of course doesn't mean they will be free from human mistakes but,overall just think about the fortune and gift of that one thing having inheritors of such a thing that ties us to Allah and his messenger,people who went out of there way to learn such knowledge all over so many parts of the world.What have we done in comparison to them to sit on our little keyboards and complain against such people without full knowledge?
@@mohammedsha1 💯💯💯
Sub7anallah same with me, watched the whole thing
@@xavixnake U don't understand the hadith and the fatwa that was passed. Just like you would kill the disbelievers because the Quran says it. Allah guide u.
This is absolutely horrible. He is starting to sound like Yasir Qadi after Yale. The amount of blunders, with his interviews, may show allegiences are being formed. Allahu Alem. May Allah keep us on the straight path.
Many of these people I don’t know about this Hijab guy in particular but there’s many who hired to look like sheikhs have a following and intentionally distort Islam to other people. They only distort them selves at the end. Allah protects this religion. The haters plan a plot against Allah and his religion but Allah also Plans and he is the best of the planners.
@@HonestLady you're right lets be fair. He slandered many people. He uses double standards when it comes to his friends. He is someone that is (to be fair) very strong with philosophy and explaining secular ideas but when it comes to the deen he has a lot of misunderstandings.
May Allah guide us.
@@HonestLady He shouldn’t speak of what he knows not. What good is the good he does if he distorts what Scholars say. It’s not about being hood or bad. But he should stick with what he knows and leave that he knows not of.
Don't know man, things are getting weird and scary. We MUST learn the deen ourselves so we will not be misled, and that learning of the deen should start with learning arabic.
@@shankaroont4959 he’s not that bad. Made a mistake
Barakallahu feekum dear brothers. I appreciate your defending our scholars with knowledge.
Barrakallahu feek For this beneficial video, shaykh Albani served the ummah with his life, he was attacked by the enemies of the Sunnah, he was such a noble Hadith, the likes of Mohamed hijab and his ikhwani crew won’t come close to his ankles. May Allah guide or silence hijab. Ameen
@AI lol, his Asl is ikhwanism. هداه الله
@AI Thank you so much for this. People throwing these labels on scholars who spent years studying the religion and helping a lot of people is so wrong. He publicly repented and they are humans as well.
@AI
Ikhwani does not mean he is kafir but He is a follower of a hizb/party manhaj and he is misguided and if you watch his videos you will find he promote for their ways.
He has been close to yasir qadhi and they both "blame scholars" by misrepresenting them
He doesn’t align himself with Yasir Qadhi at all tho
He goes to fix the Sheikh’s blunder in a video
@@themercifulguard3971
He keeps on entertaining and praising yq despite his blunders in the past
Clearly MH should not discuss fiqh, not his area of expertise. In his hating of the ‘madakhila’ he is exposing himself.
That's true
Not only Fiqh!
No such thing as a madakalhia if you ask brother sajid himself he will tell you what a great scholar sheik rabee is enemy’s of Islam and other misguided sects make this names up such as wahabi to scare people away from the truth when in reality they are the most deviant people
True,he is a reformist,a kid, a boy,he calls himself an ortodox but he is nothing but an arrogant reformist
@@AlbertRei3424 since when MH claimed that he is a reformist... source please---
My brother Saajid Lipham, I’m thankful for these videos, brother. it really helping me immensely. to understand things that i wouldn't have thought.
jazak Allah khair. may Allah reward you abundantly and the other brothers
We wish well for brother Hijab, but he should not be fooled by his online presence as giving him a bona-fide confirmation bias of his understanding of islam. He is barely a student of knowledge (Allahu Alam) and the fact that celebrity RUclips speakers can take the place of scholars is entirely misguded they are misguiding their 'followers'. We should all seek knowledge from the scholars.
He has reached out more non-Muslims than Sheikh Albani, Sheikh Albani has reached out more Muslims than Hijab.
They will be rewarded as due, and no need to compare the two.
He made a mistake, and accepted it. He did not slander (which needs an intention), he made a mistake.
But not to worry, we will soon here sounds of wild beasts tearing one another apart, and David Woods with unstoppable laughters.
@@autumnicleaf may Allah guide you, do you seriously think Mohamed Hijab has benefitted mankind with the religion than shaykh al Albani رحمه الله in any way lol by saying he’s reached out to more non Muslims lol that’s a bit of a stupid comparison really.
@@autumnicleaf M.H Debated with David Wood by begging information from Shamsi's Ustadh Abu Iyyad.
Sheikh Al-Albani is one of the greatest scholars of hadith in our last era. Anyone who speak about him badly is ignorant of His knowledge that he should not evaluate from his audio recording. The evaluation is done by his book and his reviewing
Albani was jaahil and a deviant innovator. Inshallah may Allah SWT forgive his innovations and give hidayah to his fanatical blind followers
Ma Shaa Allah brother Lipham, very sharp brother. I pray to Allah s.w.t to preserve you and safeguard you brother. I would be very happy and protective if I have had a brother/friend with knowledge, wisdom and courage like you near me. May Allah s.w.t make it easy for us to see the truth and courage and wisdom to detect and tackle falsehood, ameen.
Brother lipham spent years in madinah seeking knowledge. Of course his point of view will be very different from Mohamed Hijab . I am sad that muhammad hijab hastened towards this issue without using a proper contemplation .
I like Muhammad hijab but what is point refuting the scholar when he is not one.
I thought a scholar can only refute scholar
no thats not true as Rasullullah saw said in the hadith : this religion is knowledge so be careful who you take it from. just because someone is scholar that doesn't mean he is always right ! and you dont have to be a scholar to refute one. there are scholars that think horrible stuff is ok despite none of the Sahaba did it. and whats a scholar today? a mp3 player of the ahadith or a light for the nation? whenever bad things happens in İslam it always because of people think scholars cant make mistakes and they follow them this is same problem with Shia and their imams.
@@evilmelez ibn Sirin said that I believe.
@@danielj7958
theislamissue.wordpress.com/2019/02/15/breastfeeding-adults-in-islam/
imagine a scholar giving fetwa about breastfeeding grown man so we can see them as mother before long journey and fails to talk about basic human fetishes and if you say this Albani s dumb fetwa is clearly wrong and people starts stoning hijab for talking about this. whoever defend this fetwa I want their mother to breastfeed me than I can confirm they are truthful about albani without bias opinion. look at comment section all of stupid people starting hatred comments but they cant even agree on the fetwa of Albani to begin with. noone of people here have done anything good I recon they cant even dress good to get on with the public debates. but noo hijab is this and that lmao this is why imams of the past were smart and they lived golden age but scholars of today are just mp3 players of ahadiths.
@@evilmelez ?
The statement “This religion is knowledge, so look to who you take your knowledge from” - was the saying of ibn Sirin, not Muhammad.
Also is Aisha a “MP3 player of ahadiths” ?
Also the page you link criticises Islam ? I’m confused
@@danielj7958 his full name is Muhammad bin Sireen yes. Im not talking about mother of believers. Im talking about scholars of this time. and yes the link is non muslim and that whole page is was thanks to Albani s fetwa. everytime non muslims attack İslam its because of one imams fetwa.
Omar+saajid=great vid
Farid+saajid=great vid
Now, I propose an idea,
Farid+saajid+omar soon. Literally even if it's an hour long I'd still watch it
me too
Oooooh yes!
Sajid+Uthman Ibn Farooq+Farid=Brain Left the chat .
Arrogance over ignorance, self praise and over estimation that the hole where mohammed hijab dropped in. He praise yasser qadhi and down grade shaykh Alalbani.
Yasir qadhi > Al Albani
@@basnation7769 you are lost
May Allah guide you
@Amir Shah Wallahi all the salafiyya in the comments who speak like you have lost their way. Follow the Sunnah of the Prophet pbuh. Tell me one time he declared a Muslim a murtad!! One time ya himaar!
Fear Allah! The Prophet pbuh told us to never call a Muslim a non Muslim. Do you remember the incident when Usama bin Zaid ra was about to kill somebody and they declared Shahada on the spot but Usama still killed him, not believing his Shahada. What did the Prophet pbuh say when he heard this? The Prophet pbuh was seething in anger and yelled at him, "did you cut out his heart to know the truth?"
Ya haywaan, fear Allah! When you call him a murtad know that he will take his Haqq from you on the day of judgement.
Making takfeer is very dangerous. However there is no doubt that he is a deviant heretic.
@Amir Shah I agree that these things would take a person out of islam but takfeer shouldn't be so quick. Have any of the scholars made takfeer of him as of yet? Would be interesting to find out
When someone wants to put shame on schoolars Allah put shame on him
@@999.9Ghosting its in the desert wonderer channel on speaking about the imams in the description.
End Times
People need to stay in there lane.He should stick to debating Christians, Atheists and Liberals.
It sounds like he's been influenced by YQ talking down about "Saudi Scholars" and saying this discourse is "extremely problematic".
What's next? Him calling this hadith a "problematic hadith".
He has the guts to sit there and refute a many decades old fiqhi issue and calls it a "big blunder" but doesn't dare to refute the clear and blatant aqeedah issues of Yasir Qadhi who he actually invited on his podcast and gave him a platform to speak on. Which "fault" of each is more likely going to take you to the hellfire???
This is the dangers of sitting with the people of innovation.
Yeah Hijab is excellent at debating Christians and atheists but he should learn wisdom from people, fix his angry nature and stop listening to
Yasir Qadhi
He did not call Saudi scholars problematic, rather centering strictly around Saudis like the Madhkalis only consider a handful of Saudi scholars as ulama, and for them all others are not to be taken knowledge from.
@slashZ890 can you debate the atheist if you can do better than him then let’s see you don’t respect him for his effort so that you look idiot and btw if he makes mistakes correct don’t you’re better than him ok 👌 know your place
@slashZ890 oh you they are misleading people would like to clarify to the people
@slashZ890 ur taking it out of context, he said it as a joke when Julia said atoms are independent if I'm not mistaken not as Allah has body parts
*MashAllah brother's on how you guys are approaching the whole issue interms of the hikmah and the soberly manner in which you are dissecting and deliberating to refute the biased opinion that mr hijab is purporting against our renowned and famous sheikh Albani رحم الله*
Learned a lot from this, wallahi
@@abunusaybah4165 true.
@@abunusaybah4165 why don’t you go and do something else rather than coming here and giving your unlogical comments
@@fakharkhan5412
But it does contradict the Quran 2.233.
Also the Arabic word referred to actually (both literal and metaphorical) means to *suckle*. There is no other meaning.
@@abunusaybah4165 - I don't have the patience to watch 50 minutes of 'to make a short story long' discussion on a topic less discussed the better. Any one ready to accept his mother to be doing the same (through actual, physical contact)? Let them, whoever feels attracted to his mother, allow another person to do the same!
Why would anyone suspect that a mother of the believers would allow such a thing, unless it's given without exposure?
How do they have extended time, to discuss these stuff?
@@justCommando What are the bases of your claim? if it's your own limited and flawed logic, then I suggest that you think again. This is an authentic hadeeth. It's better to know your place unless you're knowledgeable enough and have the academic credentials to analyze the science of hadeeth and Isnad and present proof to your claim.
MH doesn't want to learn from the scholars. He doesn't have the humility and sincerity to learn the deen the correct way. He doesn't want to oblige himself to scholars. He wants to read the books his own and come up with his own understanding of what Islam is. He undermines the scholars everytime they are mentioned. He says, "there are more scholars than these", but then more problems arise as he mentions who he thinks are scholars.
I agree. Brother's ahklaq need some work. He seems extremely persistent to be correct but Inshallah he becomes wiser in his approaches especially on matters within and of the Deen. But, i still think he does good work we all benefit from. So, not sure if you're writing him off but I think it's fair to say the brother hopefully realizes this and reflects upon it.
i get it scholars are important in our understanding of Islam sure but why are we pretending or limiting our scope of understanding of the religion to these scholars especially 4 schools of thought ?? it is not like they have divine understanding of the religion .
@Karim Hussein
Yes. Spend your time listening to more trustworthy people who are following ahlu-sunnah wal-jamaah. MH is a person of opinions.
@@dontgetmewrong4317 So mistakes can't be made? He is the one who blundered in this case no doubt...speaking from a place of misunderstanding and acting knowledgeable. But he made a mistale and insha'Allah next time he researches before speaking on such matters. You can't rule a person out completely. If that were the case, first mistake you do Allah will send you to hell. But it's not, people should grow and improve themselves. insha'Allah he and us are guided.
Mohammed Hijab is hizbi I heard him once belittle saudi olama and calling salafi brothers "wahabi"or "madkhali". see when brother shamsi talked to him in the park you will see his real color and how weak and miss guided he is. I really don't hate him but if he was a little bit humble and not arrogant he would be more respected in my opinion .
@@SIGSEGV1337 which taghut are you talking about now? Have you been listening to bro Hajji lately? Hmm
@@SIGSEGV1337 Well I guess Imam Ahmed and Al Hasan Al Basri and the like are al "madakhilah"? LOL. Wallahi bro please read the books of aqeedah
@@lilekoe1 NO only Muslim/Sunni follow al Quran and Sunna.
@@intekabalam7340 is calling yourself a Salafi not a bid’ah/innovation?
@@user-ys7oh6eu8m no its not
Ma Shaa Allah. Beautiful brothers with beautiful adaaab. Muhammad Hujab please pay attention.
Subhanallah may Allah protect the scholars of islam from such smear campaigns from the new age ignorance.ameen
This Hijab guy is not worth one hair of Shaykh Al-Albani... He wasn't emotional when YQ spread his nonsensical confusions, but suddenly loses his mind while misunderstanding Shaykh al-Albani's speech... that guy needs to quit internet altogether...
Because Yasir Qadhi is one of the greatest scholars of the last century.
@@basnation7769 i hope you are being sarcastic. Yassir Qadhi is an innovator
@@basnation7769 who??! I hope you're kidding 😂
@@falsehoodrefuted So quick to slander. First go learn what bid'a is. Then show me how Sheikh YQ innovated the religion. I'll wait.
@@basnation7769 you clearly haven't seen some of his major kfri statements such as permitting the practice of calling upon others like the dead etc.. rather than Allah which is a major sin (shirk) and he made many controversial fatwas that's why the disbelievers like to use him against us because of his major mistakes! if you don't take from saajid then
I'd suggest you to watch (Abu Ibraheem Hussnayn) for more detailed proof
Check a video he made, titled "MAKING DUAA TO THE DEAD IS SHIRK! A RESPONSE TO YASIR QADHI"
May Allah reward you both abundantly for all your efforts.
May Allah reward you both for this. I did not understand this issue before but I am very pleased that both of you took time out to properly explain this in a holistic manner. It is sad that someone who presents himself as an academic did not present the issue in a proper manner. May Allah preserve and honor you both. May Allah guide us all and increase us all in beneficial knowledge and wisdom.
Allamah, Al-Muhaddith, Al-Mujtahid Shiekh Al-Albaani, (may Allah have mercy on him)
May Allāh have a mercy upon the Imam the Mujadid as said by Mufti Imam Ibn Bāz. رحمهم الله
I would like to add that what happened to Salem in the story is only a judgment of Salem and who is like Salem as mentioned by the scholars, Salem was an adopted person at that time and Islam canceled adoption long ago, so the ruling in our current time does not apply to anyone, and they mentioned accounts that Salem was breastfed using a plate and not directly, and God knows best
You got inaccurate when it comes to the adoption part, adoption is still allowed as long as you don't give the family name to the child ... Salem was adopted that way (No he wasn't , I'm so so sorry for that mistake) ... and concerning the "plate" part, well, that's exactly why this whole controversy is taking place ....
@@medsaifeddinekamoun2921 thanks for clarifying this , Actually i meant the Adoption as westerners understand it , attributing the child to himself , and this is was Salem's case
@@khaliduae-qv5ni I'm terribly sorry for that inaccuracy Brother thank you sooo much for the correction !! I have to correct it so that it doesn't mislead anyone! Jazak Allah Alf khair Brother !!!
May Allah guide us , protect us and have mercy on us !!
@@medsaifeddinekamoun2921 that’s not adopting, it’s like foster care
@@medsaifeddinekamoun2921MashaAllah it takes a real man to admit when they're corrected. May Allah reward you ameen 🤲
Has he made this attack as he is trying to undermine the carriers of the salafi da'wah for rightly coming after him for supporting Yasir Qadhi before and now staying silent on his excusing shirk?
People follow the Deen of their friend and allies. Highly suspicious, hijab could have been mesmerized by YQ.
Modern salafi dawah is toxic subhhanallah
Y'all only pick and choose from scholars you like and over look their mistakes but don't do the same for scholars you don't like
@@badalrana10 whom we don't like aren't even scholars.
Are you referring to people like YQ and imran Hossein and shabir Ally and Hamza Yusuf as scholars ???
@@ziasmailbox your changing the subject. Shaykh Yasir Qadhi on multiple occasions has said he isn’t a scholar. Now answer that guy’s question ^
@@seeyalater3510 who are you ? Did you read that guys mind ? And answered for him?
Your comment is ironic, you prefix Shaikh before the name and claim he said isn't the scholar. Lool you so hilarious akhi
I mean some people see it coming... The attitude of a student of knowledge tells a lot about the person and what errors they might fall into tbh. The Park debates, the "you have been finished" remarks, the lion's roar in video intros... What? Why? Why all this display of unnecessary things and tbh arrogance? You will pull yourself down. For us is to learn adab first and foremost from people of adab, and on English RUclips, learn from the adaab of the likes of Abdurrahman Hassan, brother Saajid, etc.
Our scholars are dying and majority of us don't know the scholars present around us! Stick to them lest we be left in darkness and hope internet is used in a better way for that if we are not capable of doing that in person in the physical world.
Allahummaghfirlana
People don't seem to be able to recognise this, dawah is not a hobby
You should lecture your salafi brothers first when it comes to arrogance
@@mrvan3491 what do you mean?
Wallahi bro, I donot know a salafi scholar through personal contact in my city. They are gem and they are few. May Allah bless our scholars
@@muhammadzamzam9915 if you want to find arrogant people,go meet some Salafees
Salafees are drowning in Khibr
We can see from the tone of hijab's speeches that he's has got scant respect for the great scholars.
This was so helpful.. low key I am ashamed to say it was unclear to me and did cause confusion. Thanks brother Saajid. May Allah reward you for this.
There is no excuse for Brother Hijab's mistake,but him apologizing is a good thing.for sure he needs to take a break mainly because he have been into so much arguments.that really affects one's mind to always be in debating mode and trying to always be right.may Allah guide us all.
What does he bring other than philosophy which is disliked and there's a deviant sect called ilmul kalam aka the philosophers
@@user-mo4mm1yn6q do I look like a kid to you? Oh are you upset coz your 2 favourite RUclipsrs are arguing?
No defense of sheikh Al albani or brother omar? As long as no one says anything to your other bestie RUclipsr huh
@Ismail ohh really ? I don't agree with that.
His apology was vague, he didn’t mention to whom he apologize or what exact words he retract.
@Ismail Get lost kid🙄
O brothers! Keep your intentions for ALLĀH's sake lest Satan deceives in clever way. Keep it pure, keep it Islam.
May Allah purify our intentions and keep us sincere. Ameen!
May Allah bless Saajid Lipham, Omar Chatila, Daniel Haqiqatjou for all they do in protecting the ummah from false knowledge and misinformation of Islam. I really appreciate your efforts. Thank you.
Jazaakumullahu khayran fee dunya wa I aakhirah.
Quickly presenting a major scholar in an inflammatory way such as a tweet showing emotional disgust at their fatwas is a major major problem. By doing so, Hijab is likely giving many people a negative association with Sheikh Albani’s (ra) name. Next time they come across his name, whether it be a Muslim reading about their religion or a non Muslim researching etc., they might have this visceral reaction that “oh Albani (r.a.) was incompetent, I won’t trust this source”.
Sadly that can happen but Albani was actually a very unique and intelligent scholar subhanallah. Hijab attacking one so called "big mistake" 😯
I was trying to say the same thing, some people was nasty towards me
@@wherethegrovesgrow you're right, I've already seen ignorant youth making comments saying that they don't know who shaykh al albani is but they are steering clear of him because of the "breastfeeding issue". Another UK da'ee has now made a video of shaykh al albani on a different matter trying to discredit him somewhat. Honestly mh keeps opening the doors of fitnah and ge cannot even see it
If we don´t trust and respect our scholars, then who are we going to trust to take the religion from? Who are we going to respect?
Subhanallah! May Allah help us.
why should we take the fringe opinions of the scholars?
@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud Saajid is the one misinterpreting and misrepresenting Hijab. Go watch hijabs video
@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud Well then you're a bigger muppet than Saajid
@@sbasha7
What does Muppet mean?
I used to like Mhijab but I noticed his character changes so cocky and unislamic. So I stopped following him.
I also unfollowed him long time ago . He is like a child. He needs to grow up.
So before marrige it is not allowed to see the wife without hijab, but before mahram it is allowed to see the breast?
Wouldnt that mean trying to achieve halal through haram?
Very well said, May Allah keep MH and us all on the straight path. May Allah make it easy for us to overcome our ego's, and seek the Haqq regardless of anything, and maintain sabr insha'Allah.
Learned a lot from this video and thank you for this calm and collected approach 👍
I requested both Ali Dawah and Mohammed Hijabi to remove themselves from giving dawa. As they are very angry individuals and very intollarent towards people who have different views.
Saajid we love you for the sake of Allah. I like it how you elegantly put these folks in place. You do it in a nice way. Good
I am so helpless to see brothers in faith criticising other brothers who are doing a lot for our religion. Why don't you scholars just meet n sort out your differences in opinion. Stop confusing us for Allah sake.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
I am your brother in faith, I am from Libya, i learned about brother Hijab through Corner of speech. He was doing a wonderful job. However; he is completely wrong regarding to three scholars.
Honestly I submit SubhanAllah
when I hear this hadith my mind doesn’t think disgusting things
What if this hadith is a reflection of rasulAllahs Sallahualayhiwasalam command and by the permission of Allah This instance was like a special gift or miracle given to Salem and his mother
Alhamdulillah
Breastfeeding adult n the refutation n debate?
Where is haya
@@skyinuri8868 do you have more haya than rasulAllah Sallahualayhiwasalam? Astakfrillah
There are many things discussed and answered in Quran and hadith that you may not be comfortable with as an individual
There were men coming to rasulAllah Sallahualayhiwasalam telling him Sallahualayhiwasalam about how they will never marry never stop praying or never stop fasting
He refuted them all
Reference Sahih al-Bukhari 5063
In-book reference : Book 67, Hadith 1
You are not better or holier than him Sallahualayhiwasalam
A man came to Abubakr radiAllah waanhu telling him about rasulAllah Sallahualayhiwasalam and israal Miraj
It’s an unbelievable and astounding event
The kuffar knew this but when they told Abubakr radiAllah about it what was his answer?
“If Muhammad Sallahualayhiwasalam said it It’s true”
These men were with him Sallahualayhiwasalam and they were ready to DIE for him Sallahualayhiwasalam
Why? The message was becoming true infront of them
How did Islam spread? Within a 100 years Islam had taken over so much land We were outnumbered but won so many battles We were the weak but the message spread like the wind blowing the sand
How?
This is a miracle in itself Allah has promised us in the Quran If we obey We WILL WIN in the heavens and on EARTH
The kuffar are still AFTER 1400 years Are fighting against our master Muhammad Sallahualayhiwasalam
They want to spread lie or use events like this to sway us Muslims but be firm InShaAllah
Say I believe and be proud Alhamdulilah
The early Muslims experienced this and they knew
There is so much proof in islam There is no other choice but to submit InShaAllah
@@skyinuri8868 you want to start calling out Mother Aisha radhiallahu anha as well? She held the view of breastfeeding as well. You want to start cursing her?
@ya shaikha,
Exactly.......
He claims to be an Athari, but only tries to "refute" people on the minhaj of the Salaf.
Saajid you've now opened the door to an assault that won't end. Mohammed Hijab, Ali Dawah, Bro Hajji will probably start attacking as they've been attacking Dawah Man for a while now.
Not saying you shouldn't have done this, rather, I agree with you but you will now be subject to a LOT of abuse. May Allah keep you steadfast.
Who can attack Saajid, he is one of the softest people I have seen
I agree but then let them be ahki. They are the ones who will be closer on the line of the munafiqun when they do such slander because they'd rather fight for who they ride for than understand the haqq. I'm sure Saajid know what to expect seeing as he's challenged others' opinions/views before. As for Hijab, his ahklaq specifically with ulama should improve and someone who does not notice this....well, i think u might be Stanning the man. But overall alhamdulillah for the brother and his works.
Let us not assume the worst of anyone yet! If it happens, (something similar did happen 5 months ago or so) then it does. May Allah protect us from excessive pride and uncharitable assumptions about our Muslim Brothers and sisters.
i am gonna unsubscribe their channels and stop listening to them if they did something like that
Calm down everyone. It’s amazing how easily people can be divided. Don’t be emotionally driven. People make mistakes, they learn and we stay together.
Maa sha Allah may Allah ta'aala reward these brothers for defending the honor of the ulama.
Saajid Muhammad Hijab is listening to Yasir Qadi too much... To consider that Hadeeth "very problematic"
In fact I remember when my aunt gave birth to her first born my cousin, she gave me breast milk to drink from one her her son's baby bottle. I literally drank what was in that bottle. I hope the foolish amongst the Muslims don't take my words and sensationalize them also. This incident happened to me when I was a teenager and a non muslim.
Bro you hit the nail on the head
You answered both questions regarding the issue itself and regarding the reason why did he bring the issue, Jazak Allah Khair brother
I think we live in such an oversexualized era so that we read salacious meanings into what'd have been innocent in bygone eras or different cultural contexts.
@@youtubeowl9544 I think who says Shiek Al Albani problematic is problematic himself
One guy does memorize Quran and does memorize 100 Hadith then comes and give fatwa and say scholars are problematic,,, and is slandering scholars like Albani, that’s what very problematic and should be responded to
@@youtubeowl9544 I believe it’s not for you and I to judge these scholar and that level specially of we don’t have the minimum knowledge (don’t memorize Quran),,, once we have half of their knowledge we could open our mouth,,, and we should worry about slandering and putting words in scholars mouth and not let any random person even discuss these issue,,, if he is not scholar shouldn’t even attempt to talk about scholars. He talks his size these issues it’s about the religion of Allah it’s not any ignorant can talk about because he feels like it
This was so educational
Pls make more comprehensive videos like this, giving detailed scholarly views on different topics
Jazak Allahu Khairan
عزة النفس والثقة الزائدة ولو بالضحك والمزح تؤدي للغرور وبالتالي الأخطاء الغير مقصودة. لكنه يقوم بمجهود كبير للدعوة إلى الله جزاه الله خيرا .نحبه في الله
Jazakumullahu khairan. Thank you. That man seems to have a disdain for the ulama, who brought to light the darkness that was prevailing in the ummah. May Allah have mercy on them
Why arent you not inviting him and having the conversation instead of showing edited clip of him? Have the conversation with him
I don't think they have to, brother..
I feel the way our muslim brothers are talking together is not cool. We give our enemies ammunition to bombard us. Instead we should be much more understanding and much more forgiving.
Ali Dawah has left the chat
Salamu alaykum, I hope you see this comment, firstly you're wrong on some issues :
1) RADA'AH (breastfeeding) according to the fuqaha' is not the action of sucking the breast only, rather it is the milk reaching the stomach, that is why if the woman gave a baby milk through a bottle or even through his nose for five time, she would be his mother, whereas of she gave him the breast as a baby without milk, this doesn't make him her mahram, so we conclude that (tahreem) is related to the milk and not to the breast, and therefore according to the fuqaha (giving milk in a bottle without sucking directly is considered (breastfeeding)
2) you made it seem like salim was only a teenager who just reached puberty, which is not the case, because he was already married and he was a man with a beard
3) you said the words of sahla when she said ( how can I breastfeed him when he is a grown man) indicates that she understood that she has to give him her breast directly and this was the reason for her question.. this is not necessarily the case because it is called in Arabic (wasf nisby) meaning it is a description relative to what is known to be the age of breastfeeding which is done while the baby is small, and sahla in this case wasn't questioning how she would give her breast to a grown man, rather she meant he is not in the age of breastfeeding.
4) don't forget that there is no way sahla breastfed salim directly for the following reason :
Abu hidhayfah (her husband) was super uncomfortable just from the fact that salim might see his wife without a veil and he used to get angry and this was the reason why sahla came to ask the prophet for a solution, so there is no way abu hudhayfa who would not tolerate salim to his sahla unveiled and he would just accept her to give him her breast directly, so it is absolutely out of the equation, keeping in mind that after sahla did what the prophet said , abu hudhayfah became comfortable and happy.. and this would not be the case of his wife's breast was sucked .
5) don't make it seem like there no (athar) of how sahla breastfed Salim) the jomhoor of scholars didn't just out of the blue said it was done through a cup or something, and you should ask yourself why would the majority say so if there was no evidence for it ..
The answer is there is an evidence and a hadith :
عن محمد بن عبد الله ابن أخي الزهري عن أبيه قال "كانت سهلة تحلب في مسعط أو إناء قدر رضعته فيشربه سالم في كل يوم حتى مضت خمسة أيام فكان بعد ذلك يدخل عليها وهي حاسر رخصة من رسول الله صلى الله عليه
وسلم لسهلة
"Sahla used to squeeze milk in some cup or a container the amount a single time breastfeeding, so salim used to drink each day until five days passed, and by that he used to enter upon her while she is unveiled as a permission from the prophet peace be upon him"
(الطبقات الكبرى8/271 الإصابة لابن حجر7/716)
6) the majority of scholars said this was a special case for salim because he was raised with this woman and was like his mother, and also they were the only people who were affected by the prohibition of adoption therefore the prophet solved their issues as a special case .
The other scholars who say this might not be only for salim they also say, if all the conditions are similars then this fatwa might be applied, but since there is no way that another verse would be revealed and no way adoption is allowed makes this incidence (a specific case) and cannot possibly be repeated or have a similarity in any time or place,
So therefore as the jormhoor of scholars have said, this was a special case for salim only and it was done in a container not directly as the hadith mentioned, and it cannot be repeated to do qiyass on it nowadays and the issue is easily solved, moreover, knowing what I have mentioned, makes talking about this story not beneficial really, because there is no ruling that would be derived from it since it was only an exception to solve Salim's problem with mother., so focus on more important things inshallah.
Wallahu a'lam.
Great points. Should be pinned. 📌
🤣🤣🤣 mental gymnastics
@@thestig7679
You fail too keep up with logic let alone gymnastics, if you can't use your mind due to your backward ideology, all you gott do is laugh like you do, and blame others for surpassing your mental capabilities.
@@AbdelbarrMalki a muslim lecturing someone on logic 🤯 and accuse me of following a "backward ideology" Really? The defense for muhamad marrying and sleeping with a child is that in those days (7th century) it was not uncommon to marry kids. Ok. No problem. Explain to me then why in 2021 it is still being practiced under sharia law? Who's backwards now?
@@thestig7679
You are not in the level of having a conversation, a western pro gay defender should be worried about his women becoming prostitutes, and the 50% of kids out of wedlock and the raped women every 40 seconds, and the highest rates of drug use and suicide, as for marriage, islam does not state any specific age, because it changes from person to another and from time to time, therefore a person as allowed to marry when they are physically and mentally ready and when there is no harm in either side (the husband and the wife) and these rulings in particular are based on the well being of the individual and should be followed any time, and thus you can never bring the standards that were fit for a particular time and judge them based on the standard of your time, just knowing that islam doesn't define age of marriage is enough to smash you with your weak minded arguments, because you have no clue of what you talk about, you had to run to something that neither my comments not the video was talking about, this shows if we were talking about rocks, you'd be here like a moron talking about (marriage and jihad and the rest of typical crap that your little mind is filled with) but since you brought child marriage, I as a Muslim can oppose it, from your paradigm you can't, and you have no evidence against it except the harm principle which is a weak argument and someone could easily tell you who the hell are you to define what's harmful and what is not, but as a western gay, you know better than me, so explain to me how could your governments only a few decades back allow girls to marry at the age of 7 and the age of consent in most western countries was between 7 and 12, take the state of Delaware in United States as an example. If you say they were wrong, what's your proof?, your morality is defined by society like the seculars believe, meaning you need to shut up since those societies according to you had the right to determine what's right and what's wrong, and if you attack them you only violate your own standards, so here I had to break it down to you to realize that whatever your moronic mind would tell you to criticize muslims it only shows how contradictory you are, so if you got no objective morality, you can never force your subjective beliefs on others especially since your liberal ideology says they are absolutely right to determine their own morality unless you are such a racist maniac with a nazi type stupidity that you want to mock others and force your lifestyle on them .
Nowadays Hijaab is turning into what he hated from pipo like Abu khadeejah
He even opened a special channel with his friend Ali Dawah just to be going back and forth with his opponents
True.
ruclips.net/video/291IcZ0OEOM/видео.html
Here is a better vedio on the explanation of this matter.
I used to support Hijab, but not anymore. For him to cast aspersions against a mountain like Albani! Wow, just wow! One motivation I see is that Hijab has issues with Saudi bc of his opponents like Shamsi who take from them. However Albani wasn't even Saudi!
Thank you both for the clarification. May Allah bless both you and reward you with Jannah 🌹
And my Allah guide Mohammad Hijab. He is a good person but who doesn’t make mistakes
Can a stone go against a mountain? Pick on somebody your own size
@Bzy he's comparing MH (pebble) to Al Albani (mountain)
Brother Saajid, I would love some more context at the beginning especially if it is such a long video. Thank you.
18:00
Other scholars have never said "black and dark nipples are unattractive."
At this point it seems that he is infatuated with disproving the salafi's in the UK. So he is going after the scholars to strengthen his stand point.
I really liked mohamed hijab, i still like him, but not as much as before, he has became proud and arrogant, his fans are not helping too, they like that attitude, ever since he became friends with ali dawah, he changed ... may allah guide him and us to the straight path.
@@sammaj2731 actually, you should check out his disguting response on sp-files channel, waw, i'm really chocked .. may allah guide him back to the straight path ..
May Allaah bestow His mercy in tremendous abundance upon shaykh al Albani.
May Allaah guide us all
جزاكم الله خيرا
This is a great video, especially for people involved in Dawah work!
Thank you akhi for calling out these cancers
Salam
Brothers
What was the age of Salim?
As in my understanding in Islam the adult age is when you are able to marry while in modern world man made laws say its 18.
By Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and Salah saying adult doesn't mean he is 18 or above he might be 10, 11 or 12 (may be even younger and Alhamdolillah Salah first even showed hesitancy out of haya, subhanAllah)
Kindly advise and clarify.
Jaza k Allah khair
Note: what ever the age is the Prophet said and its done. Alhamdolillah.
On the light side, there was a ridiculous Morccan (non-Islamic) tradition where if an individual was being pursued by angry members of a particular tribe, he needed no more than to burst into one of their homes "another crime" and grab one women's breasts and "feed", yet another crime. Supposedly this would resolve the issue in a win-win situation as the pursued individual would have become a dear family member and a celebration rather than a lynching would be in order, complements of those same pursuing tribal members. Needless to say, this constituted a gross distortion of Islamic tradition.
Quran 3:103 And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided.
May Allah protect us and guide us and please brothers before we make public statements always be carefully inshallah
Love you all for the sake of Allah
Informative & beneficial.
But he didn't refute Sheikh Albani. He was merely making the point that every person is fallible.
Judging by your accent I am not sure if you know what goes on here in the UK, maybe you should look into that first.
Nobody said shaykh was infallible. He did that to show dedew is better than Imam Albani. Hidden Ikhwani agenda
@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud
We should ask MH to refute Ikhwanis & YQ. Then, We'll see whether he truly adheres to the way of the Salaf.
BarrakAllahoe fikom for inlighting us and keeping the honour of the scholars high in ranks bi idhniAllah.
That story is about an adopted son before it was canceled, later when adoption is canceled, the adopted son is no longer a son, and he can't see his adopted mother and interact with his family as he used to do, so the solution was she breast feed him so he became her son again. This was a specific ruling for a specific case that can't be applied now, because no one in our age can witness before and after the canceling of adoption.
I don't understand the benefit of this entire discussion to be honest. Even if we say al Albaani made a mistake here: so what? Scholars do mistakes - ooh what a surprise! Of course they do. No person is free from them - no scholar is. Is Mohamed Hijab free from them? Of course not. So now? What are we gonna do? Discredit a scholar who has spoken the truth and the sunnah for the vaaast vast majority of time because of a few mistakes he made? We gonna act now like the words of the scholars can be easily discarded, disregarded and questioned as if this was some 50/50 matter?
Scholars make mistakes. So what? Their mistakes aren't the reason we respect them and love them - but the vaaaaast vast vast majority of the time where these major scholars actually spoke the truth.
May Allah have mercy upon our shaykh - Nasir-ad-Deen al Albaani.
May Allah bless you akhi - this is what makes this entire issues mindblowing .. these ppl are desperately creating arguments to simply save face and try to make this a "good vs evil" type of dichotomy
If you check their videos, their entire audience are compliantly re-emphasizing the concept of "scholars aren't infallable"
and the question begs, WHO MADE THAT ARGUMENT !?
it truly appears to be a smokescreen to discredit and make the people lost trust in trustworthy scholars, whether they intend to do so or not.
Muhammad Hijab can't digest it. If it's an authentic Hadith then it's authentic. Maybe he doesn't know that. Let him know.
Maybe he listen to Qadhi too much.
@@youtubeowl9544 I did, all the fatwas allows is what Muhammad Salalahu alayhi wasalam allowed. It doesn't mean anyone can succkle from a woman. It's more detailed than that... Hijab understanding of it is that anyone can according to his tweets lol.... There's a deeper understanding behind it than just black and white.
@@youtubeowl9544 okay I'll watch it
There's a new trend the people of innovation have started, which is they take short audio recording out of context to misrepresent the scholars.
jazakallaahu khair brothers, i needed that, we all did, even though i love Muhammad Hijab for the sake of Allaah, he understood wrongly of shaikh alAlbaani and got excited to get one over on the UK super salafis i.e. salafi publications, but he didnt realise he was going to hurt the non 'madhkhalis' as well in the process
it was a great clarification and may Allaah swt raise you both and guide you even more to what is correct and good, including for our brother Muhammad Hijab - aameen
This is so dangerous.. honestly.. this kind of behavior could bring down our ummah more rapidly,we just can not openly said this ulama n tht ulama is doing blunder,its not the right way.we as a layman can not attacking our ulama freely ,even though many benefits could be applied through the informations from muslim's videos but when it become open to everyone, things like this could happen especially regarding fekh. I'm not aiming this comment to someone specificly but to all muslims who indulging in RUclips.. people will take side, some one will get hurt emotionally and hate could be spread and the islamic ummah as a whole will take the heat.
@javier May allah keep you on the straight path and aid you in becoming a good Muslim.
@javier i'm sad to hear tht but i understand the feeling because sometimes muslims words n actions hurt me deeply.. bro just hold tightly on the sunnah of Rasulullah S. A. W n keep on making doa.. May Allah Ta'ala keep you,me and the muslims on the straight path
I'm only a few minutes into the video but I've noticed for a LONG time that Mohamed hijab is NOT someone to take knowledge from.
He is full of hate towards SPUBS and this hate is something he cannot hide and it is ruining his character and manners. Also I've noticed he never speaks about tawheed in dawah...he uses philosophical arguments and everything about him just seems off. His followers also express a lot of ignorance in their comments.
Jazakallah khair to Sajid and the other brother for making this video, may Allah reward you both immensely with good in this dunya and the hereafter ameen.
SPUBS doesn't deserve hate? Their leader is continuously slandering others with zero retractions.
@Saajid Lipham Ahki how could i reach you i wanted to ask you your take on a couple things and get your outlook if you could help me ahki i would greatly appreciate it hope to hear from you inshallah
May Allāh (SWT) bless us with unity. May those whom have crossed the line be forgiven and become better and more beneficial to all. ʾĀmīn - آمِينَ
Watch Mohammed hijab one day will try having ago at Ibn Taymiyyah. If he's carrying on this way
he already has bro Lol
He already did! He did tabdi on people that follow him.
Search Hijab, Taymites.
He literally made up a new name for people that take knowledge from him.
Why not find and study the Hadith that teach us how to treat each other properly instead of trying to understand things of those times