Taliban the new Ghani, ISIS the new Taliban-Tolo TV Head Makes Case for Engaging New Afghan Regime
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июл 2024
- In an interview that uses both perceptive broad-brush analysis as well as detailed and specific pinpointing to comprehensively create an accurate picture of the state of Afghanistan 12 days after the victory of Taliban, the owner of Tolo Television, Afghanistan’s internationally acclaimed and domestically most popular television channel, has said Thursday evening’s bomb-blasts have created “Afghanistan’s Ground Hog Day”. This is a reference to a famous American movie where the hero keeps re-living the past and nothing changes and improves. Underlining this point, Saad Mohseni said “now Taliban is the new Ghani and ISIS is the new Taliban”. Mr. Mohseni also said the Taliban lacked the capacity to respond adequately to the challenge from ISIS and they urgently need help from the world. Mr. Mohseni added that the world has a window of opportunity, which may not remain open for more than a week, to help the Taliban establish administration, policing and effective governance. Otherwise, he added, “The Taliban could become like the Khmer Rouge”. This is a reference to the brutal Communist Party that captured power in Cambodia in 1975 and reportedly killed millions of people, a story forcefully captured by the Hollywood film ‘The Killing Fields’.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
This is one of the most eye-opening interviews that I've seen on the general current situation in Afghanistan! We get one of the best situated insider's observations, analysis and perspectives rather than yet an another Afghanistan expert who is on the outside looking in! Well done!
Long Live The Wire .
A Trustworthy News Agency.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
This is good journalism. We need such standards in india to strengthen media
This is journalism.
This is the clearest and most positive talk after Aug. 15. Thankyou Mr. karan Thapar and thr WIRE.
Karan Thapar sir comes thoroghly prepared and goes deep into the issue. Wonderful mind.
Karan thapar I know you are the most intelligent and logical person isis work for US
You should know US want to stay even after August 31 US playing a game again as you are expert in media do you saw any one dead body of US soldier they are lying as they did in case of 9/11 but this time they are going to pay big price you watch.
Love Karan Thapar's Pointed Direct questions. The boss of Tolo news is honest to share reality of situation. Nice work, wish you success!
Nuanced interview by the Tolo TV leader/CEO. I wish him, his staff and people of Afghanistan the best.
Ditto!
My prayers are constantly with Afghanistan.. Heart breaks every time I read/see the news.
Substantial and specific. Realistic projection of ground situation and its emerging projections.
I was surprised with the guest's intellectual acuity. Did a quick read on him to satisfy my curiosity. Nice.
The monarchy should have continued in Afghanistan rather being overthrown by Communists.
In that scenario Afghanistan would not have faced today's problems.
I guess you would have supported the British rule of India as well. I can see where you’re going with this thread
@@antaryaami
For a person who has lived in middle east that too a one which is governed by the king i.e. UAE.
I can say that a country ruled by a king is more stable than a democratically elected govt were the policies of the govt change on the basis of elected govt.
Even in middle east the countries governed by monarchies are more peaceful than elected govt.
Check how peaceful Saudi, Oman & UAE is when compared to the likes of Yeman, Iraq or Lebanon.
Even Afghanistan was peaceful until it was governed by the king. Even the father of nation of Afghanistan is it's former ruler King Zahir Shah
@@antaryaami
Also i have not experienced how life in British India was hence i cannot comment
@AG 2021
Hadn't it been ruined by the communists
@@npd9758 cool story bro
Excellent interview. Thank You!
Wow....awaited interview
A man of charm, intellect, sophistication. We wish the Afghan people well.
After seeing Karan Sir of the Wire talking about journalism with Mr. Mohseni of Tolo news, it just gives me the vibes that they are the soldiers of democracy. It takes a lot of courage to carry out journalism in today's day and age. Godspeed Mr. Mohseni.
Excellent interview!
Very interesting interview indeed
Very important interview, I hope our government is listening.
😂
@Harmony yeah, man they don't get it.
@Harmony yeah let Wion n India continue their nonsense, Taliban will not tolerate ( unlike China who hasn't done anything when criticized nonstop n Indian pple stepped on Chinese flag n burnt Chinese president's photo).
Every interview,you surpass yourself by Sharp, pointed questions. I salute your preparedness for each interaction!!
Excellent, timely and honest.
There is always a level in questions of Karan Thapar Sir and there is clarity in everything
No government in Afghanistan as of yet but after listening to this interview we can go to the news from other parts of the world.
Excellent interview. 👍
Extremely good interactions!!!
Excellent interview. Karan is the best interviewer I’ve come across anywhere - intl media included. Breadth of subjects and the depth with which he can interview is by far the best.
When the underground comes overground and tackle the new underground!
Thanks
Excellent Interview.
Thanks Thapar and the Wire for very informative and a very balanced conversation. Saad please take all cares for yourself and your organisation.
Love from Ladakh, China 🇨🇳
Very enlightening & in depth discussion indeed on the ground reality of today's Afghanistan. Buy I missed an expert's view on the overtures of China & Russia in this much talked about changed geo political scenario...
How many of you think Saad Mohseni looks like older version of John Abraham?
Thank you for this direct practical and informed interview with Mr Saad Mohseni. He very clearly can foresee isolation of the present regime going the Khmer Rouge way which was a political purists created human disaster. The window of a week must be used if not by govts then by the people but how? Respect Mr Mohseni for being in Kabul. Thank you Mr Thapar for bringing this conversation to us.
Very good interview. Well done, Karan Thapar
Wonderful
The way he is opening speaking without pandering to Taliban, seems like Saad is mentally prepared to take his operations outside. That will be sad, to see jobs and staff go. Excellent work, Saad and Karan.
Very interesting discussion, an insiders point of view.
afghan will work either in govt or abroad (illegally) recently saw picture of former information minister delievering pizza in Germany.. now its upto them. they want to rebuild their country or become refugee in west.
Good to see high quality journalism from India. I found the truth, uncovering of facts, analysis of possibilities and hope for future. Afghans will once again stand with owner and achieve their glory.
Thank you for this fascinating conversation. You are right that people listening to this interview will learn what's good for India but are those policy makers listening and deciding about what's good for India?
You are the only one who are thinking 🤔
Mr. Thaper seems to be a very perceptive interviewer and Mr. Mohsini equally pragmatic, with good understanding of the varied forced at work. Mr. Thaper’s interview with ex gentleman from RAW was equally good. Between all these pragmatic wise people, we hope the Problem of Kashmir would be brought to an acceptable solution according to the UN Resolutions prndong from 1948, so that all the people of the Rainbow colours and Himalaya and Hindukush, Indus, Sutlaj, Ravi, Chenab, Ganga-Jamuna, Saraswati, Muslims, Hindus, Sikh, Isai, of one thousand vsrious beautiful linguistic backgrounds can again breathe together in peace, Amn, Sukh, and Shanti. Not inviting Fireign European-American plunderers to come and put us in bu Ghraib, Bagram, and Guantanamo prisons and disgrace with Titles of Terrorism.
My humble thoughts for all the Humble Peace Loving People of this this Indus Gabdhara, Iran-Iraq lands of Plenty and Blessings. We have had enough of Bushes Blairs, Obamas, Trumps and Bidans
Wassalam: Shanti, Peace, Sholom
Muhammad Umar Chand
Thank you, brother, Bless you the One who created you, whatever His Name, Naam, in your language!
Two brave person
300 mn Muslims in India and not a single protest against the fascist Taliban victory in afpak!!
Hey Wire, ndtv can you unravel this mystery????!!!
Why should they protest? Could you give me one logical reason?
An Afghan pronouncing Ashraf Ghani and Shariah in western style.
This is like the fifth wire interview on Afghanistan in 3 weeks, come on now, there must be other important things to discuss than this
In the interview Mr Saad Mohseni states that India is one of the three countries most trusted by Afgans. I would like to know the names of other two countries.
" BRILLIANT " as usual.
If Indians can live under RSS rule surely afgans can happily live under Taliban. BJP 1,0 (Atal time) vs BJP 2.0 (The Gujarati Reign of terror)- what a great progress!
Karan, an you ask this man what did Karzai disclosed in 2017 about descent if Daesh in Afghanistan after Trump wrapped up the Syrian operation.
is it Benazir Bhutto on wall behind you?
I wonder if Mr. Mohseni is planning to go back to Afghanistan. If he is, there is more freedom of speech in Afghanistan than there is in India.
Absurd and exagerrated statement
So clear he is on which side probably holding European passport!
Karan seems quite satisfied with the Taliban's media policy 😂😂
Now for fun tunning in to Republic TV.
You must work with Taliban govt first.
Mohseni was born in London, United Kingdom, where his father, Yassin Mohseni, was serving as an Afghan diplomat. Yassin Mohseni served in Kabul, Washington, DC, London, Islamabad, and Tokyo during his 25-year career.
After the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Yassin Mohseni, then serving in Tokyo, resigned from the diplomatic corps and sought asylum. The family relocated to Australia in 1982.[1] Mohseni has two younger brothers, Zaid and Jahid Mohseni, and younger sister Wajma.
Mohseni began his banking career as an apprentice at an Australian funds management entity, and later became a commodities and derivatives trader in Melbourne, Sydney, and London, culminating in the management of a trading desk of an Australian investment bank.
hahahahahahah!!!! this explains the relaxed approach and the indication that all is not so bad with TALIBAN!!!!
Thank you sharing this information.
Actually anyone know who make ISIS who is the biggest saporter of ISIS why you didn't ask this question
Turkey qatar
It's a project of isi to keep taliban on its place. They are playing bothe ways.No wonder America lost...
एक सवाल
यदि अफगानिस्तान में "इस्लाम " नहीं होता तो क्या जो आज हो रहा है । वो होता ? 🧐
Shameful!!! Kisano pr lathi chali, Ek kisan shahid ho gaya.
The wire kuch nahi bol raha kyu?????
Wire is sophisticated form of WhatsApp university
Please send karmela harris to Afghanistan to work on the root causes.
Thapar's fake accent is so irritating, if he can be bit normal we can watch whole video.
Tolo news off air on RUclips /only previous day news onlive*
LEMER segment by Tolo news uploaded 2 hours ago
Taliban approached India. They were snubbed. Your guest did not mention China and Russia, the concept of safe cities, and how the players will change to improve life in Afghanistan once the occupiers are fully gone..shortly. PM of Pakistan has indicated full support of any governance arrangement in Afghanistan so long as there is no interference in any other country from the Afghan soil. That should take care of TTP, the remnants of NDS and their handlers including India. Simple!!
Hi Karan half the time you are just repeating what the guest is saying ....
One terrorist group needs help to fight another terrorist group, you couldn't make this up.
Guidelines interview 4 Goi*
First let's stop mob lynching in the country, let's protect women/ girls and let's safeguard democracy in the country. Let's talk about religions politics which is destroying nations image internationally. After this we will talk about Afghanistan
@Karen Wilson you are quoting out of context and your interpretation is erroneous, this is how hatred is spread. Please stop texting/ commenting on topics which you don't have knowledge. Please don't mislead people. Take an example of Afghanistan where humanity is suffering irrespective of religion. Please stop this hatred politics.
@Karen Wilson we can share knowledge with a person who is willing to learn true meaning. If a person mind is already filled with hatred then it is useless to spend time explaining to such a person. Such a person already has preconceived ideology which is full of hatred. If a person is really interested and willing to gain knowledge then he/ she will go to the real authentic sources. Such a person will not raise meaningless questions. Questions which you have mentioned are useless and only a lunatic will raise such questions.
@@asvocasvoc2226 Tell all this to the Islamic scholars in Saudi Arabia and Iran, they are seriously in need of this advice.
@Karen Wilson you are a shameless creature who is spreading religion hatred
Mr Thapar , I will pay for your air ticket . Please go and talk to Taliban directly. I am sure Khangress, Sonia , Pappu , desi Jihadis ... will be extremely happy to see you visiting Afghanistan.
Talaban has defeated the most powerful country of the world.Are you not underestimating them?
It is not quite the taliban, it is just a name. Afghans have defeated the most powerful nations if they were called talibans or not.
Taliban defeated the Afghan Government and Afghan Army who were not willing to fight. Americans and Nato soldiers just left. If taliban were capable then they would have tried years ago. Talibans just did one smart thing they just waited and followed the old Afghan phrase "YOU MAY HAVE THE WATCH BUT WE HAVE THE TIME".
Karan is the man..
Thts not an attack..
its a rajeev gandhi narshanghar yojna..
It is a secular killing so voice should not be raised..
#KabulAttack
Saad seems to be on love with west and rightly to do so but is unable to realize that he is expecting a different result from the same formula used for past 20years.
2. He is calling out India for help who betrayed them, than dumped them and now sidelined them.
3. His loss clear showed when he threatened Pakistan in his last words yet not recalling history. Cause those who betray never see the dawn rather run circle for there own tail.
In my opinion until the Afghans come up with there indigenous Govt structure and idea of inclusiveness for politics, economy and governance a few elite will play them around for there interests and then fly back to there masters with bags of money leaving behind masses to try and jump on to the wings of planes that carries them to death and not prosperity.
Mr Saad Mohsini , as name suggests, is clearly from Farsi speaking Iranian Shia minority community.
Known in Afghanistan as brutal, opportunistic , unreliable group of people.
Big questions about his views on Taliban , take them with pinch of salt.
Kabul is overwhelmingly non Pashtun city of Tajiks Uzbeks Hazaras Turkmen people , traditionally anti Taliban.
Wonder , if their views matter in new power equations.
West should supply arms to Taliban to control ISIL... 1st commenter 😀
This Guy seems like an apologist for Taliban. Karan is either naive, or being played here, or blind in his BJP hatred to take all the goody goody depiction of taliban.
u mean he need to be apologist for hindi taliban[RSS bjp] and mulla modi hahahahaha
He's been anti Taliban all along...he's speaking the truth here
@@drzakir123 don't know what you are grateful for, but your sentence above vividly displays your mental capabilities (or lack thereof). Wish you the best.
@@hiratorsam6869 I sincerely hope so ... Rationalizing or normalizing abhorrent social practices and the medieval justice system is not the way to go. Are Afghanis OK with the change?
.
Tolo news was funded by America so what else do u expect from him other than criticising Taliban. For good’s sake let the time pass and see how Talibans govern the country. I wish the people of Afghanistan best of luck.
Mr Thapar , Let’s call all Maulvi of Deoband. All Talibanies follow Deobandy Quran .
What do you mean to say
@@smtouheed3863 Wahabisim & fanatic teaching originat from Deoband UP . Taliban are students of Deobandy Quran . The whole world is suffering from Fanatic islamists .
@@mukulsingh1330 get well educated. This is what I can say. 😂
No human rights Sir.
Be free from ideologically obsessed hypocrisy, dear channel. Be pragmatic, without resorting to goal post exchanges, along with modified goals, which is a favorite practice of journalists, and many juvenile thinkers fall prey to it. As 'senior' journalists be truthful & pragmatic Mr Karan.
Also, don't target persons you dislike. Instead address processes pragmatically, without having persistent enemies, whom. Do you address or justify directly or through twisted tongues.
Is honestly that impossible for senior journalists and 'liberal' intellectuals and those boxed in academic tunnel vision? Be truly liberal Karan.
It’s likely the bright sparks in GOI are listening to this analysis. Guess they’re still wondering how to align the potential positive outcomes into delusional-world-of-vishvaguru & yug-purush
थापर तेरी जॉब वहा लगेगी
Karan Thapar tu to pahale se barewale
He guna lose his job mark my words lmao hahahahaha disgraceful
How come no one's noticed that this Tolo TV guy lives in Melbourne, Australia. No wonder he's talking about "the Taliban" instead of calling them our government. Sly chap.
He's talking about 'the Taliban' and not 'our government' probably because there's no government there, at present.
Why can't Afghans fight their own war.
300k army.
That was an exxagerated claim by the US. Most of the soldiers were ghost soldiers, ie; deserters who's salaries were being paid to their bosses. In reality the military was around 40-50k strong. Though no one has verified these claims completely.
Abe ye kisko pakad k laya hai..baal dekh iska😂😂😂😂
Aisa lagta hai baal me fevicol laga diya hai......
It’s toooooo early to understand what is happening. Milk is on the boil, changing every second. Wait for 3 months at least. These both are too vain to think this is the right time to assess the situation. Intelligent fools.
i dont think it will be too much touble for indian taliban[oops RSS/bjp] to speak and cooperate with thier own kind in afganistan!! oh karan sorry to hear u been gagged in asian age by hindi taliban and mulla modi doing nothing hhahahahaha
Talibans IMO have learnt a lot of lessons from Modi
Black Flag of ISKP (ʾilāha ʾillā -llāh (There is no deity except God), and muḥammadun rasūlu llāh(and muhammad is prophet of Allah. In
Round Seal it's written Allah Rasool Muhammad. Kabul suicide blast took place in name of Allah Rasool and Muhammad. It's not the terrorist fault it's the fault of literature which makes human a suicidal terrorist.
If the literature teaches this then why less than 1% follow it
You sound like a RSS Goon.
@Karen Wilson
You are quoting the verses out of context
And Islam can never be defeated
Not even in your dreams
We are more than a billion and half 😊
@Karen Wilson This is after Jesus second coming and after whole world embracing islam so
This hadis refers to end times after the eesa kills anti christ.
So infact islam will keep growing and expanding 😊
@Karen Wilson Islam is the saviour of humanity and it's problems in the 21st century
Just take a look at statistics
Muslims are the least depressed community on the planet today.
Do some research Dude.
@Karen Wilson There is no verse in the Quran which says the Earth is flat and there are a lot of scientific miracles in Quran not like your x rated Bible. Go and read the book x rated Bible written by your christian brother not by any Muslim alhamdulillah this book the Quran is revealed by the Lord of the Universe.
So you will never find in it any error.
Unlike your Bible which has hundreds of different versions.
Kabul fell to Taliban on 15 August endia`s independence day (bhagwan`s
curse on endia ???) Srinagar and Delhi to follow in coming weeks months
and years.
Taliban are well aware of Islam and they know the region and about Afghanistan too, they are very reasonable people.
Soon Afghanistan will be a corruption-free country in the world. In Sha Allah
How shameless of mohseni not to mention Pakistan as the largest host of afghan refugees but mentioned names of ‘frnds’ of afgh (usa,uk,france,india) all of which have recently abandon his ‘country’ n its people. What a sad little puppet
Please do not invite such biased people to your program as it will damage the image and credibility of your network
Kashmir Banega Pakistan - Arunachal Pardesh Banega China - Aur - India Banega Kabristan - Inshallah