(English) Quranic Salat is NOT a series of body movements. What is Al-Salat then? ٱلصَّلَوٰة
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024
- The Quranic Salat is not a ritual. It is not a series of orchestrated physical movements. What is it then?
This series 'Salat in the Quran" explores the Quranic concept to contrast against today's mechanized prayer.
Salat in the Quran video #1
#salat
#salaat
#salah
#quranicsalah
#Quran
#GroupThink
#MajorityRules
#Majority
#Consensus
#LiveDiscussion
#IslamicDiscussion
#EnglishLive
#slavery
#Islamicslavery
#concubine
#sexualslavery
#humantrade
#mahr
#fitna
#conditionsofnikah
#mahar
#bridalgift
#bridalmehndi
#interfaithharmony
#interfaithmarriage
#hindumuslim
#hindumuslimlovestory
#muslimhindu
#shadi
@QuranSpeaks
@OneMessageFoundation
@MuftiAbuLayth
@muftimenkofficial
@MUHAMMADSHAIKH
@SamGerrans
@qurancentric7459
@MarvelousQuran
@edipyuksel
@quranvshadith
@Drzakirchannel
@EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips
#polygamy
#4wives
#multiplewives
#pluralmarriages
#nikah
#shadi
#surahnisa
#suratnisa
#nikahislami
#nuslimshadi
#mehndi
#rukhsati
#walima
#halala
#talaq
#FemalesInIslam
#womeninislam
#zakar
#untha
#rijal
#nisa
#hijab
#genderequality
#GenderInQuran
#FemalesInQuran
#AuratInQuran
#GenderInIslam
#MultipleMarriages
#polygamy
#ViolenceAgainstWomen
#4:34
#islam
#quran
#qurandiscussion
#qurandebate
#islamdiscovery
#questionsandanswers
#quraish
#makkah
#hajj
#parda
#alhajj
#tawaf
#umrah
#almasjidannabawi
#kaaba
#almoses
#hijabers
#almasjidalharam
#masjidalharam
#qurbani2k21
#qurbanistatus
#qurban
#quranichajj
#surahfeel
#kaaba
#makkah
#mecca
#QuranVSAhadith
#LearningQuran
#QuranCentric
#QuranVsSunnah
#QuranAlone
#Kalamullah
#QuranicTerms
#QuranicMustalahat
#AbbasidIslam
#Shirk
#Al Moses
#TaqlidiIslam
#Mullah
#Mushrik
#MuhammadCharacter
#QuranTranslation
#QuranUrdu
#QuranHindi
#LiveConversation
#Live
#TheftPunishment
#CutHand
#ChoppingHands
#CapitalPunishment
#CapitalPunishmentInIslam
#Punishment
#Quran
#ShareQuran
#LaylatulQadr
#AlMoses
#NightofPower
#Ramadan
#Ramzan
#Slavery
#SexualSlavery
#Londiyan
#Laundiyan
#SlaveryInIslam
#Shirk
#marvelousquran
#TheMarvelousQuran
#mushrik
#QuranTranslation
#ReadingQuran
#UnderstandingQuran
#LearningArabic
#Arabic
#AlMoses
#QuranicArabic
#Ramadan
#Ramzan
#Fasting
#Eid
#Roza
#MarriageAyesha
#MarriageAisha
#Ayesha
#Aisha
#ProphetMuhammadandAyesha
#ProphetMohammadandAisha
#AyeshaAge
#ChildMarriage
#UnderageMarriage
#MarriageWithChildren
#Nikah
#Pedophilia
#MolanaTariqJameel
#MolanaTariqMasood
#TariqMasood
#MuftiYasir
#MuftiYasirNadeemalwajidi
#MuftiWajidi
#IndianIslam
#MarvelousQuran
#QuranvsHadith
#PakistaniIslam
#ZakirNaik
#DrZakirNaik
#Salat
#Salaat
#Namaz
#Nimaz
#Deen
#QuranicTerms
#SalatAurNamazkafarq
#EngineerMuhammadAli
#Islam
#Quran
#Barelvi
#Barelwi
#TableeghiJamaat
#MolanaTariqJameel
#TariqJameel
#MuhammadSheikh
#Parvezi
#QuranCentric
#Tuqoos
#TariqMasood
#MolanaTariqMasood
#PeghameHaqq
#Musalleen
#killinfidel
#killkafir
#kafirKon
#kafir
#debatewithmuslim
#muslimvsnonmuslim
#muslimvsexmuslim
#sachwala
#halal
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajidirefuted
#responsetomuftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajididebunked
#muhammadsmarriage
#muhammadsmarriagerefuted
#muhammadmarriagewithaisha
#muhammadsmarriagetozainab
#muhammadcharacter
#answeringislam
#answeringchristianity
#viral
#contradictioninquran
#quraniccontradiction
#contradictioninislam
#islamiccontradiction
#indianexmuslimsahil
#islam
#quran
#exmuslim
#indianexmuslim
#sachwala
#quran
#leftislam
#zafarheretic
#harissultan
#ghalibkamal
#mehleej
#mahleej
#aminasardar
#jaidevi
#indianmuslim
#exposeislam
#extremism
#islamicextremism
#exmuslimvsmuslim
#neerajatri
#tufailchaturvedi
#muftitareeqmasood
most subscribed channel
#muftitariqjameel
#ahlehadees
#barelvy
#sunni
#shia
#keralaimam
#apostasy
#talaq
#tripletalaq
#sudarshannews
#wasimrizvi
#indianexmuslimsahil
#Sunday
#Hijab
#ZeeNews
#IndiaTV
#MuslimWomen
#whyileftIslam
#indianexmuslimsahil
#islamic #islam #allah #muslim #islamicquotes #quran #muslimah #allahuakbar #deen #dua #makkah #sunnah #ramadan #hijab #islamicreminders #islamicpost #prophetmuhammad #love #muslims #alhamdulillah #jannah #islamicart #muhammad #instagram #islamicreminder #pakistan #madinah #namaz #madina #bhfyp
#islamicquote #subhanallah #ummah #islampost #islamicposts #art #urdu #prophet #quranquotes #urdupoetry #follow #hadith #islami #prayer #kuran #like #instagood #dawah #instaislam #pray #loveislam #m #life #hijrah #india #bhfyp #islamquotes #peace #hajj #quranverses
#indianexmuslimsahil #exmuslimsahil
#leftislam #exmuslim #IndianExMuslimSahil #Islam #kafir
![GEEK TIMË [OFFICIAL AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ry-6RvkH880/mqdefault.jpg)
Watching this has given me peace, I will read Quran myself and be as sincere as possible, thank you
That's the best approach.
@@AlMosesPhD ..PRITICALLY SALAH IN QURAN..ruclips.net/video/NpgwJSgXO3A/видео.html ..MUST WATCHING THIS VIDEO PLZ
Is not a good idea to study and interpret the Qur'an by yourself as Allah have sent a prophet to clarify it (prophet Muhammad pbh) , saying that the prayer is not something phisical is a lie as the majority of scholars have approved of that and by many many hadith we can derive that ourselves ,and here we are talking about scholars not someone that one day decided to study the Deen as he pleases or interpret the Qur'an by himself but this is knowledg from the prophet studying the seerah ,the interpretations of the companions ec and by the way a Pearson can understand this by reading the Qur'an itself some verser are clear regarding the fact that Salah is something that you do
@@bintab-nh2zg so you're saying that we need to become a scholar to approve something? then I'd sign right away so I could approve of this idea! *sarcasm
@@bintab-nh2zg so ALLAH sent a book that not clear?
Great, the only Islam that makes sense to me is Quranic Islam. Followed.
I am so glad I came across your videos. I had been considering converting but stopped my journey because I had a lot of questions that other Muslims didn’t seem comfortable answering. Thank you so much!
I am just started to re-study back everything, I started questioning, then I'm searching for a lot of answers, yours are one of those that I will saved for my reference. Reliable.
Good, but eventually go past us to your own answers
@@AlMosesPhDI want to ask you are you scholar and yes you need to be scholar to give fatwas and also when the Quran talks about salatul fajr and salutul isha it states in many ayat that Bowing is required and also when it talks about Muslims being in masjid to pray are you misguided or is the Quran wrong and also when it talks about masjid al aqua what do we do there avoid zina? And also when it talks about leaving off trade and going to salutul jummah when the adhan is called is that when they call the adhan spiritually or what I’m confused? And when it states in the Quran to go masjid al haram in Mekkah and to do piligramage is that also spiritually one thing I would say is actually Wallahi read the Quran while it’s open not random snippets you see on Facebook what you are doing here is misguiding many young muslims because you realise anyone that rejects the salah has left the fold of Islam But anyway stop misguiding people and learn the true deen of Allah not the deen of satant
Interesting and thought-provoking. Moses, do you have any plans to write an English translation of the Quran, incorporating your insights and interpretations? That would be incredibly helpful. Thank you so much :)
alhamdulliah , i am searching for this type of videos, today I got. thanks brother
Great work brother. In the same vein, there are many researchers whom have finally arrive at this conclusion that the ritual salah that many of the Muslims who are practising in large numbers, is borrowed from the Zoroastrian’s ritual. This fact is completely a shocking indeed. I am now in the frequency that Allah guides those whom seek His guidance. You have done a great work on this line.
Shuaib ( Sri Lankan - Living in Dubai)
Thanks brother
Is it possible to share the research you mentioned?
Logically, any similarities do not negate the validity of ritual prayers. Perhaps Zoroastrianism, regardless of its current status today, was founded by a real prophet. After all not every prophet was mentioned in the Qur'an.
do you realize that the masjid domes we have today are inspired by zoroastrian temples... LOL
@@mt000mp Interesting, any source? And what's the significance of that? Most of Mosque architectural elements were influenced by churches. In fact, some churches were turned into mosques.
@@kinanlaham744 i mean, as the caliphate expanded theres a high chance of cultural diffusion. there is no significance BUT it is a litmus test for syncretisation of doctrines within the muslim world.
thats why hadiths is a ground for information warfare of influence by ummayyads , khawarij , merchants , ali ghulatis , politicians and ideas such as ; israiliyat , messianism - mahdism , mazdakism , paganism , tengrism , authority by inheritance(habibs and sayeds) , 12 imams - 12 disciples of jesus , massive schisms and many more...
lies upon the name of the prophets , ahl-bayt and the sahabas is done by anonymous parties that wants chaos on the caliphate and destabilize the ummah. because they know we treat hadith like the jews, the muslim absorbed the isra'iliyat attitude to hadiths as the caliphate expanded.
Thanks 🙏 for knowledge
Thank you for this video and the others you have made. I recently read the Qur'an and as much as I loved reading it, I had a lot of questions. This answers one of them. It's almost as if there are tests of blind faith found throughout.
it:s refreshing to see who muslim who thinks and does his research
May God give you all the success, I pray 🤲🏼
So peaceful and so true. الحمدلله for this.
You are absolutely right 😢
I had these questions for years and I couldn’t ask any question because they were scared me for long time to accept and believe 😢
I really needed that , thank you sooooo much ❤
Peace and blessings
Thank you,
I loved it,looking forward to the series.
You’re a very intelligent individual,what’s not to love just your intelligence.
Peace and Blessings.
Salam. I'm simply reading out the verses. Hopefully, the message comes out clear.
Thanks
Thanks for making these videos, will now listen and comment. I like how very logical you are, I see an absence of 'logic' from many people claiming to tell us what The Quran means, will watch all your videos now, the English ones. Thanks again 👍
Hopefully, we'll all make the Quran prominent in our lives.
Thank you for this. I am very spiritual and feel connected to God. Ritual prayer was forced upon me and I never felt connected to God. It was more of an obligation and felt like a burden.
Very educative! Thanks for this presentation! 👍
Do have a link to the English translation that you used?
It's mine
I am so so glad to find your channel
there are many meaning of salat one of them is connection relationship, and other meaning together with the word Iqamat assalat, meaning the ritualic physical movement of prayer... this prayer is called sha'air in the Quran meaning symbols and they represent physical orderly action to connect to God.... like the ritual in the military where the symbol to address the senior officer is by saluting...
@@GloballyIslamic theres only one source the Quran if you go to hadith the subject gets confuse... and a mess...
May God bless you.
Alhamdulillah.
I liked and subscribed! Wonderful and very similar mechanics from Dr. Hany. Keep going man , we need you !🎉
Thank you for the video. According to 4/103, salat is decreed on believers at certain times. Quran mentions salatil-işa and salatil-fecr. What do you think believers have to do in those times?
All that is covered in the series
Islam will return as it was in the beggining, a strange thing compared to what was being practiced at the time , and when it returns give glad tidings to the strangers
Indeed
And you think this was the Islam in the beginning
Thank you very much, this series is best and most difficult I'm looking for, but now i meet with you, i must thank God very, i love may Allah bless you, ❤
Keep doing goog😊😊
Thank you very much brother Moses for all explanation & elucidation as a reverted to islam i understand you & appreciate you more than any scholiers posing as ustadz & imam bro' Moses more power to you muslim nation needs you 🙏🏻
Keep learning brother! :)
Salaam mualeikoem question what is the right way of 2 way connection
I have a question. 12:56, in the verse about the ‘hypocrites’, how can the ‘hypocrites’ ‘show off in front of people’ if salat has no form ?
Hypocrites are 99% labelled muslims who say they are muslims but do not know how to become one.
And most of them are 99% are also mushriqeen.,,
Verse 12.56 says "Yusuf 12:56
وَكَذَٰلِكَ مَكَّنَّا لِيُوسُفَ فِى ٱلْأَرْضِ يَتَبَوَّأُ مِنْهَا حَيْثُ يَشَآءُۚ نُصِيبُ بِرَحْمَتِنَا مَن نَّشَآءُۖ وَلَا نُضِيعُ أَجْرَ ٱلْمُحْسِنِينَ
English - Sahih International
And thus We established Joseph in the land to settle therein wherever he willed. We touch with Our mercy whom We will, and We do not allow to be lost the reward of those who do good." I can not find the word hypocrite here. So, my request to the who posted this comment and 6 people who liked, can you please give the correct verse?
@@ahmedroney7517 They are refereing to the timestamp not the verse
I have a question:
What about those who say that Salah as we have seen in The Believers are The Path of The Believers.
سَبِيلِ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ
[Suratul-Nisaa verse 115]
So every Muslim that prays salah is doing it wrong? Fajr, dhur, asr, maghrib, isha is all
Wrong? The imams leading the prayers in the masjid and the kaaba wrong? I’m confused here
waiting for all the other topics mentioned at the end of this lecture, one of the best channels i‘ve ever met
They have all been covered in the series
@@AlMosesPhD in english?
@@asapscapegoat yes
Makes a lot of sense thank you. What about wudu tho what is that for?
Good question. I doubt he'll answer it. He'll have to deal with wudu and it's mentioned details.
@@kinanlaham744 there's actually already a whole video on it.
@@OmarRamzi since you watched the video, what answer did you get?
@@kinanlaham744 it's quite detailed best to watch it too
@@OmarRamzi can you tell me the summary, or the main point that caught your interest at least?
Peace,
May I ask, how would you counter the argument that the sunna existed before Hadith was recorded, and it is from this sunna that we get the ritual of prayer from?
For instance, the prayer comes from how it was practiced in Madinah. This ritual predates the Hadith texted.
Peace
Peace, watch the last vid in the playlist
@@AlMosesPhD Thank you sir.
Peace and love ✋🏽♥️
Dear Moses! I appreciate you for doing the service of bringing out true Quranic meanings using Quran as reference. Btw what do the lines "o you who disbelieve"(al kafiroon) mean non-peacekeepers, idol worshippers, ascribing partners to God, ? Then what do al munafique then mean?
One day inshallah
أَمَّنْ هُوَ قَانِتٌ آنَاءَ اللَّيْلِ سَاجِدًا وَقَائِمًا يَحْذَرُ الْآخِرَةَ وَيَرْجُو رَحْمَةَ رَبِّهِ ۗ قُلْ هَلْ يَسْتَوِي الَّذِينَ يَعْلَمُونَ وَالَّذِينَ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ ۗ إِنَّمَا يَتَذَكَّرُ أُولُو الْأَلْبَابِ
These physical worship mentioned here happen in the prayer muslims do, standing, during the night “ قيام " and placing forehead on the ground “ ساجدًا " when I read it I simply think of the prayer we perform.
You mentioned before that in quran its said that most people are wrong, this doesn’t have to mean the majority of muslims are wrong, because it says “ people “ no muslims. Thanks
'Sajda' is covered in the series. Keep watching brother
Awesome content.
1. How did the prophet Mohammed Pray?
2. Did the prophet show us how to pray?
3. Surely the Quran would be rather very tedious if it had to go into details regarding salaah etc.
Much much appreciation from South Africa.
Hi brother, is there any process given in quran for communication with allah according to your research. Is there any way to communicate/activate the soul? What's the point of giving this book without proper instructions? I think we are missing a lot of things.
Please watch the whole series
Salamun Alaikum you are saying Truth but hard to other butnotfor believers.
Please add topics like hajj,siyam,zakat rituals & shirk which is not forgiven.
May Allah guide us to right path Allways.
Thank you for the videos.
My understanding of your explanation of these quranic concepts is that they are just concepts.
Lack of examples of how they will be put in use and implemented leads to more confusion than clarification what they really are.
Salam. 1 question as ive noticed you didnt cover the ayahs in sura al isra from 78-81. how would you explain when it says to aqeem the salah from the declining of the sun to sunset and so on.. the word for nafl is in there also denoting the nafl prayers i assume. how would you explain this if you havent already? ive watched the whole playlist on salah but havent noticed you touch on this particular ayah. thanks.
Salam, def covered in the series.
Re look at the vids
@@AlMosesPhD
ok thanks,i will have to rewatch again. lots of information might have missed it. lol
Salaam Dr, this was. Really good analysis. I've seen a few of these and I've been reflecting on the topic quite a bit lately. One thing I can't seem to get over is how this concept hasn't enticed more speculation over the centuries since the establishment of the ritual. While I believe secular scholarship already seems to be leaning in the direction that the current popular ritual has mixture of features borrowed from pre-Quranic traditions, they still seem to assume the word means prayer, while studying the Quran gives me the impression it means much more than merely "prayer", at least the word is commonly understood in English. I have a feeling there will be more to come out in terms of the history, though I'll be checking out your whole series in my continued reflection!
PhD in philosophy and technology.
Re the ongoing academic research on the cultural pratices / way history has reached us, you'll find more in the last video on the series.
Yes, ruku & sijda does not mean only Physical bowing and prostration. I totally agree with you that the original meaning of ruku and sijda is submission to Allah. So, Physical bowing and prostration is not for everyone else. As-Salah means two ways of connection (Mental and physical) by submitting oneself through Mental and physical Ruku and Sijda are only for humans. Because Allah knows very well that there are some people who refuse to bow and prostrate both mentally and physically because of pride. So, is it not better for us to follow the teaching of Allah & His Prophet also?
Do you believe in prophets or rasul. Quran ask us to obey Allah n rasul isn't it . Rasul or Nabi Muhammad teach us how to perform as salah isn't.
I use 2:125 for salat. I take from what is being done at Mecca. Please, comment.
Continue with the series
My independent researches supports what you say. I believe what you say ...
Can you articulate the meaning of (two way) "connections". Is it zikr, as by way of reciting one of Allah's isms as some of the sufis do? But they do not necessarily abandon the 'conventional namaz, as far as I know..
If you'd continue with the playlist / series, you'll get the answer inshallah
Presentation 👍
Explanation 👍
Thank you very much, God bless!
Assalamun A'laikum Sir. As a convert to Islam and having experienced marked changes in my life due to performing salaah/rituals, let me pose these two questions:
1) I didn't hear you, during the entire presention, mentioning how prophet Muhammad did his salaah/connection for simple layman to know and follow. One need to note that Islam was a new concept to those Arbs in prophet's time, and the then converts were not expected to descern the meaning of the quran unless some explanation/guidance from the prophet was provided.
2) Ever since I started performing that ritual salaah there're marked changes in my life. The level of contentment and steady peace of mind are realities resulting from ritual prayers. The question then is are those rituals not providing an atmosphere/condition to establish that connection with Allah?
Hope for an answer Insha Allah.
Salamun alaikum
1) I will talk about this disconnect in the end of the series
2) If you find this form useful to connect with Allah and it brings other benefits as well, absolutely keep on doing it. My only contention, based on the Quran, is that this particular form is not sacred/sanctioned by Allah.
I have great empathy for your situation. My advice to you is this: stick with the Quran and use it as the criterion for whatever else gets pushed your way. ESPECIALLY if you are a woman
@@AlMosesPhD Assalamun A'laikum
For the start I'm a man.
To suggest that I stick to reading the Quran is not helpful, given that I read the questionable English translations. After having watched Dr Hany's analysis and interpretation of the Quran, I now find it hard to trust the English versions I'm supposed to use. You also highlighted some errors of some of the translator where you explained Aqimu Salah. Such being the case then, I as a new Muslim, is left to despair, be doubtful and dejected towards what was really life changing experience.
Although I've undertaken to study Arabic with the sole objective of reading the Quran in its original language. In the interim some provision to assist the likes of me should be available. The question is are you then going to provide some form of guidance for those that find themselves in my position?
I must state that the arguments you put forward for your case are plausible beyond reproach.
@@man.g2475 SA,
I understand what you're saying.
If it helps, remember that Allah is the best of judges and knows our weaknesses / challenges we face. Issues with translations are NOT your problem. So long you are honest and want to keep learning, the matter is between you and your creator.
How could I help others in your situation? Keen to hear your thoughts.
Refer to the real ulama (scholar).
Islam was not a new concept to the Arabs at the time of Muhammad … the religions and prophets of Judaism and Christianity were well known there were even Jewish tribes living among the Arabs who neighbored the Quraysh and they regularly traded with Jewish and Christian merchants in addition to living among polytheists.
You are factually and historically incorrect.
So how can we perform salat?
Continue with the series
asak. please explain me about surah furqan ayat 64. i am confused.
Sajda wali vid dekhain
?????asak. i didnt understand sir. little bit explaination is highly appreciated@@AlMosesPhD
ok sir. i got it. thank u. i will watch the video@@AlMosesPhD
so i have seen some argument for what ٱلصَّلَوٰةَ means :
"following closely"
"two way connection"
"contact"
which is it?
It's the same mafhoom.
The ma7na / shade of the term is still the same mafhoom
Sir verse 41:37 ke baare mein kya kahenge? Usme الشمس and القمر ke lie sajad ka use ho rha hai? Kya wha pe physical prostration hai matlab sajdah ka? Samjhaie...😢
spam na karain
@@AlMosesPhD sir jawab dijie...Us ayat mein kaha ja rha hai ki "wo na to shams ko sajdah karte hain aur na qamar ke lie..fir kaha ja rha hai ki ajudu lillah...Allah ke lie sajdah kro jisme unhe banaya...ab bataie...ki kaisa sajdah (obey) koi shams aur Qamar ko kr rha hoga? Wazeh krie...pleeeeeeeeeeeeease...🥺.sajdah se related yhi ayat phansi hai bs...
@@its_hammad_vloges980 kabi live baat hogi is pe inshallah
Please follow the question. The question is what is Salah and not how to perform the Salah or what are the different meanings of Salah or what are the variations in the meaning of Salah. Can you please define Salah? Thanks,
Assalammualaikum. Brother please enlighten me on the part nusuki in the verse "inna solati wa nusuki wa mahyaya wa mamati lillahi rabbil alameen". We now know Salah means more towards act of associating to somebody, and what is nusuk?
SA, salat = two way positive connections.
Nusuk = soon in the hajj video
Omg, this another topic i need to know.
Excellent video and all points made clear. ❤
Salamun Alaykum brother Moses. I've been reading Surah Maida. I wanted to know your views on ayah 57 onwards. Why is Allah asking us to respond in such a severe way? Why not just ignore people when they take it as jest? Why would the believers even call the disbelievers and the people of the book to salah? If they mocked or ridiculed the believers for calling to salah, what's the big deal? Why get so upset and tell them off like that? Can you please explain?
Great research work dear
thanks
Please explain 3/31 and 3/32
Very interesting going to look into this more
SA brother Al Moses, there is another Brother Dr Hani Atchan who follows a similar path in terms of the Quran. However both of you have highlighted with evidence based knowledge how not to pray Salah( in its current commonly known guise amongst majority of Muslims(ritualistic bowing and prostrating))Can you please have the courage of your conviction and show the people how to actually perform Salah ? Obv. With evidence based knowledge or irrefutable evidence from the Quran. Forgive me if this is an unfair question. I find there are too many who point out a problem but few who provide tangible solutions. Perhaps if you have the answer you will kindly reply.
SA
It's a fair observation.
Have you seen the rest of the series? I'd like to think you won't be asking me this question once you do.
I think someone is star-struck and is hero-worshipping!
Do you understand what is the definiton of knowledge?
So what is "evidence based knowledge" supposed to be?
If there were such a thing as "evidence based knowledge" then the opposite must also be true... but what is _"hearsay based knowledge?"_
Is it knowledge?
Is a fairy tale a knowledge?
Try using your own _"aqal"_ and not get carried away with hero/idol-worship.
salam.
Thank you so much
Salamun Alaikum!
Allhamdulila, The earth ist Shacking and IT bring's His heavy load.👍🤲🌋 The Most people dont know
SA, indeed.
@@jaweedpatel This is a 'series' :)
@Sufi Smart SA , what do you mean exactly with this sentence (verse) ? 🙏🌸
If I have a question can I send it here? Or is there an email address?
SALAM. MIND BLOWING.
The main point of prayer is reciting the quran. Importantly to know and understand that. Rest is just exercise and ritual, and also, if one reads the Quran and don't know what is reading, the prayer is pointless, of no use. Salah means commitment also.
@@GloballyIslamic Commitment to all we do. You read salah you recite the Quran. There are instructions in the Quran, as it is not just ritual. The instructions needs to be followed and committed. Hope it is understood.
@@GloballyIslamic You fulfil your commitments according to your capacity. What matters is to do the commitments. Surely, we sometimes cannot commit when travelling, such as dropping kids to school, etc etc...Comon sense...please, with sugar on top:)
@@GloballyIslamic Are you sure you don't know where Allah say "don't pray unless you know what you are praying". Seriously?
Peace! What does mean His Malaika? Not angels?
Plz just a curiosity, plz tell Abt urself, shia, sunny or what?
Muslim.
Just muslim.
@@AlMosesPhDWow, MashaAllah you are a real Muslim 👍 You are right. We shud say only Muslim and nothing else.
Assalamualaikum brother how to worship AllAh??
SA, continue with the series brother
I'm interested in the use of the term system. In one verse the word الدين is mentioned which to me means the debt. This word is not mentioned in the other examples. Does this mean that الله is the system?
Al-deen is Allah's system that has obligations as dain/debt.
Please also explain how the traditional prayer or namaz came to existence
Invention of the hadith
@@sumgue4964Your so misguided it’s ridiculousl
@@sumgue4964Prove it LOL. No haditists could show me til now about where in the hadiths says how to pray from the beginning to the end. Lmao
During Salat, Why do they greet the Prophet (S) as if he were sitting right in front of us? Salat is supposed to neither loud or too soft but a middle tone is advised. Why do we then go through Salat quietly during two Salats in the Masjid and during all at home? We are not supposed to attend Salat if our minds are messed up and we don’t know what we are saying. Other than Arabs most Muslims recite memorized verses of the Quran and not even aware what they mean!
Seems to me during the life of the Prophet, Salat meetings were held where Quran would be shared. In those days they did not have printed Qurans all over besides Quran was being revealed in stages and shared with the community.
The Salat meetings of unbelievers were described as such where whistling and clapping was done (having no substance)
Good questions
Allah says Quran is fully detailed
Hadithists say no its not😮
So, normally we would believe God😊
Quran:
(Some of) your people have rejected the Quran, although it is the Truth. Tell them that you are not their guardian (En’âm 6:66)
Have you translated the Quran in Urdu and English and is it available for downloading?
Salam, this is the 3rd video I have watched where it is explained what Salat really means. But how should we pray, I can't imagine that the prayer is something that we can just leave.
Salam, please continue with the series
This is great for starting to understand core concept of salah however ONE method has been provided in the way muslims currently pray. The video makes it seem there is no basis for this (and there isnt in the quran) but it isnt totally fabricated either since its sources are reliable. If your intention is sincere and this is the way you know to connect, what more can you do. Especially if you feel the symptoms of connection after prayer as mentioned in the video. I know I do.
In my opinion, as quran is meant to be for humanity there will never be a single way it will specify. A man from a village should be able to pick it up and begin learning.
@@Sullytaan A way is not the point. The issue is when 'a' way is pushed as 'the' only religious way sanctioned by God.
@Al Moses PhD - Quran Student Everyone who is on your videos already understands that id think. His question was what does he do now, if he knows no better way to connect with God, the one he knows or has been endowed with is the best until and unless he learns otherwise. Through intention, study or reflection.
I saw in free-minds an amazing meaning for sala when it comes to ritual sala. Sala is INTEGRITY when joined with Zaka.. Other verses like 11:114 etc are Quran revelation Session. I really agree with him. Salat is revealing the by Mohamed to his people especially believers at the two end of Nahar. Even new verses plus repetion. So it was the believers duty of that time to attend this Quran Revelation Session. That's Salah.
1. Surah al baqarah verse 238 about performing 5 obligatory prayers?
2. Read somewhere online about the 5 daily prayers was started by the mother of the Caliph Harun al Rashid, a very influential woman.
3. I AM SO CONFUSED. HELP!
No it doesn't say that.
That ayah is covered in the series
thanks for this series.
thanks
can As-salaah mean the Ecosystem?
conclusion after the video. If you want to understand the Koran, you have to learn Arabic. there is no other possibility. right? and Is there a complete translation of the Koran with this type of translation, if so where can you get it?
assalamualikum brother, i want to know that how to understand the quran , first thing is i dosnt undstand in arabi ,please tell us to how to learn arabi in easy way to understanding the quran . i am from india and i am belonging to andhrapradesh state
SA, if you speak Urdu / Hindi, watch our vid 'Quran kese samjhain?'
Salam. Hope u r doing well.
Can you plz exapln that in surah jumma how it is a two way communication.
Surat No. 62 Ayat NO. 10
And when the prayer has been concluded, disperse within the land and seek from the bounty of Allah , and remember Allah often that you may succeed.
I mean why to disperse after establishing communication? And with whom do we have to communicate? And one can make communication anytime why particularly on friday?
Salam, see the vid re 'friday' prayers in the series
@Al Moses PhD - Quran Student can u give me one liner here?
@@howwhyandwhat9277 brother the video is there for a very good reason
Nice catch.
Good work.
Dhikr means Reminder, Admonition and it is the Quran/Reading of Allah/The Absolute Authority and of course Salat is NOT a prayer/to ask, but the connection between the Quran, Allah and the people.
Connection is a relationship in which a person or thing is linked or associated with something else and a means or channel of communication and the Book of the Quran is the Connection that connects us.
Al-Quran/The Reading 29:45
ut'lu mā ūḥiya ilayka mina l-kitābi wa-aqimi l-ṣalata inna l-ṣalata tanhā ʿani l-faḥshāi wal-munkari waladhik'ru l-lahi akbaru wal-lahu yaʿlamu mā taṣnaʿūna
Thou follow what He was revealed to thee from of the Book, and thou observe, stand upright and keep straight to the connection; indeed, to the connection prevents from the excessiveness and the disliked, and surely Reminder Admonition of Allah/The Absolute Authority is greater; and Allah/The Absolute Authority He knows what you are performing.
I found this comment from a “non muslim” on YT. “I’ve always found the Islamic prayer quite bizarre. Even though they say they are prostrating to god I thought what they’re really doing is prostrating to the rear end of the person infront”. that left me quite shocked because that’s what I literally did in the mosque. Also it reminded me of the verse ‘ if you follow popular opinion or the majority, you will lose your way’.
It made me chuckle.
People have different perspectives
Salaamun Alaikum
Our Shahadha “La ilaha illAllahh” There is no deity or source of guidance except Allahh. Only Allahh exclusively❗
SA, indeed
@ABC 999 SA, how come you translate/explain the shahada like that? Does it not mean literally There is no diety but Allah ? Looking forward for your answer Thx 🙏
@@semracalik3040 SA,
37:35 (Those who took intermediaries), when they were told that there is no deity (i.e., source of divine guidance) except Allahh, they would insist on their conceit-driven opinions.
Allahh SWT is teaching us that no other authoritativeness is given to anyone except Allahh especially over the understanding and the interpretation of His own words, His own Book Al Quran ❗
@@AMRB-999 Sa, so you translate ilah as source of divine guidance ? The meaning of the shahada like we learned:There is no deity ( =no other ‘god/gods’ ) but the only god is Allah , is not correct then? I am trying to learn , this is all new to me. Thx for answering 🙏
Thank you, I always was wondering what to say in prayer at the end.
The meaning of As-Salat is not two way connection between Allah and the subject, rather, As- Salat is an exclusivity that only Allah have. You can try to match it up with all ayat in the Qur'an that has the word Salat in it.
And for the exact meaning? Try to work it out, may Allah give you all the understanding of the labels of the Qur'an, primarily if you are doing it within " The Hour".
Brother, if you watch the same video, you'll see al-salat is NOT just with Allah. Even 'non-muslims' do al-salat with other humans.
I don't comment argue: you're welcome to have the last word
@@AlMosesPhD what I can say to you is, As-Salat is related closely to the engaging of the Qur'an, that's all from me, Rabbi Innaka Antas Sami'3ul Alim.
salaamun alaykum brother, Alhamdullilah finally i got another brother whines referring to Quran alone without the assistance of wali/patron in between Allahh. May Allah shows us the evidence based knowledge how to perform as solah as he instructed us.
SA, well said
SALAAMUN alaykum masha allah,Allah, a we getting somewhere.Abrahamic locution is solution
@@AphmauFan786 SA, yes Quranic lisan can and definitely illimuniates the path
@@AphmauFan786 we keep be a wayfarer ti the truth... may Allahh grant us jannah in this live
Thank you sir for your reply. Actually I wrote twice replying back to your reply but I think youtube automatically deleted my replies as I mentioned the website name that provides the translation. The translation does say five obligatory prayers, hence my confusion.
Well, the ayah doesn't say that.
Another point to ponder :
I ask traditionals:
what is the punishment AS PER QURAN - if you miss namaz ?
A good question indeed
Hmm good point, also the Quran does not even have the shahadah, I could be mistaken but I find it difficult to trust the tradionalist fully
@@The-Benjamin-786You are right. And It is shirk when we say the name of the prophet (saw) in our prayers.
A muslim is always linked/connected with Allah. Every second of Muslim life is linked/connected with Allah. Linked/connected means to be conscious of Allah all the time.
And when we are conscious of Allah we can not do any bad / haram acts. So, being conscious/connected with Allah, we completely surrender to Allah by obeying Allah all the time. This surrender is internal, meaning our hearts are always conscious/linked/connected with Allah. And Salat (Ritual Namaz) is our expression of physical surrender to Allah.
Unless our hearts have surrendered / connected / Linked with Allah , the Ritual Namaz has no effect.
Salat ,certainly not the way currently we Muslims understand but as said by you ,please describe in detail the two way connection between two different entity.Is it that I am doing salat if I am talking to someone.
No 2- What about namaaz e janaza?
re 1) if you're doing any act to strengthen / correct / straighten the relationship between you and others the right way, then yes
re 2) I'll get to it in the series
Yes
Alhamdulillaah
salam brother, great explenation, just alittle input maybe dont hold the translation word of allah, we should translate all the word when translating, allah = the god, rabb = lord, so all become more clearer, because lot of those people try to hold some word translation to decieve the whole meaning, salam
So would you render Salah as an adherence?
It's the same oerall mafhoom
How do i get or search the next part of this series ?
Try the playlists on the channel
You didnt mention what quranic Salat really is...
according to your understanding
Best to keep up with the series for your answer
Meaning of salat koran alone:
Salat means "to follow something closely/obligation/duty"
God designed the Quran in such a way that it explains the meanings of certain words itself:
"For he did not ACKNOWLEDGE nor did he SALLAA (صلّيٰ)
But he DENIED and TURNED AWAY". (75:31-32)
TO ACKNOWLEDGE ---> TO DENY
TO DO SALLAA ---> TO TURN AWAY.
So the opposite of 'turning away' should be the meaning of 'sallaa' or 'salat' which is certainly to follow closely/to make it an obligation or duty.
God says in the Quran that we should 'UPHOLD (Aqimuu/اقيموا) the Salat'. To 'uphold' something cannot be simply to do a ritual prayer, it is to keep something steady/alive. The word 'aqimuu al ...' besides 'aqimuu al-Salat' occurs in 2 other instances as far as I've found:
● "...You shall UPHOLD this deen (Aqimuu al-Deen/اقيموا الدين), and do not divide in it..." (42:13)
● UPHOLD the weight (Aqimuu al-Vazn/اقيموا الوزن) with equity, and do not fall short in the balance. (55:9)
And lastly as it should normally be translated:
● "And you shall UPHOLD the Salaat (Aqimuu al-Salat/اقيموا الصلوٰة), and be in prudent fear; and to Him you will be gathered." (6:72)
So God wants us to uphold our obligations/duties/close followings of him/the messenger/the message in the broader context: "As for those who ADHERE TO THE BOOK and UPHOLD THE SALAT ; We will not waste the reward of the reformers. (7:170)
BONUS - Even the usage in the hadith books of the sunnis proof the meaning of salat/sallaa:
Musnad Ahmad: 895
Book: 5
Hadith: 324
Look what word is being used there:
حَدَّثَنَا شُجَاعُ بْنُ الْوَلِيدِ، قَالَ ذَكَرَ خَلَفُ بْنُ حَوْشَبٍ عَنْ أَبِي إِسْحَاقَ، عَنْ عَبْدِ خَيْرٍ، عَنْ عَلِيٍّ، رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ قَالَ سَبَقَ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ وَ صَلَّى أَبُو بَكْرٍ وَثَلَّثَ عُمَرُ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ ثُمَّ خَبَطَتْنَا أَوْ أَصَابَتْنَا فِتْنَةٌ يَعْفُو اللَّهُ عَمَّنْ يَشَاءُ
The Prophet (ﷺ) came first, FOLLOWED ( SALLAA ) by Abu Bakr, and the third omar
I understand that you try to explain that Salat is not what traditional muslims believe it is. But when I read your explanation I don't really understand what Salat is supposed to mean. To not turn away ok.. But why is Salat supposed to be at specific Times? Do you need to not turn away at specific times of the day? And how could the prophet shorten his prayer during the war time?How could he shorten the Salat while he was trying not to turn away? sura 4.103
When the prayers are over, remember Allah-whether you are standing, sitting, or lying down. But when you are secure, establish regular prayers. Indeed, performing prayers is a duty on the believers at the appointed times. I don't know but maybe people should consider Salat as Ritual prayer as well. I could agree it could have various meanings. But what are Salat at specific times at the day. For example how do you not turn away at the time of fajr or Night when you do Salat? That are things you should explain. For me someone who has no clue, I need to know what Salat really is. Beating around the Bush doesn't help me. Iam not against Quran alone people but I need more explanation :)
Everything you've raised has been covered in the series.
@@selina-yn2be salat means duty girl..in the context of 4:103 salt means jehad/rescue mission..
You should also watch series on marvellous Quran by dr hany. He ha excellent explanations on different topics from Quran .
Yes, I know him
It cannot be that what is virtually accepted by all the sects in Islam and historically through time can now have a " new " interpretation of what is a basically a formal act of worship
BEHOLD, THE RIGOROUS SCIENCE OF HADITHS Allah's Messenger (s) said: و Dajjal is blind of left eye [Sahih muslim 2934a ]
Allah's Messenger )ﷺ( said: Dajjal is blind of one eye [ sahih muslim 2933c]
Allah's messenger said: Al-Masih Ad- Dajjal is blind in the right eye [Sahih Bukhari 7407
Surah ROM 17 &18 talk about 5 daily prayer
It definitely does not
If prayer wasn't a ritual at the beginning, then how did we get this ritual that all Muslims perform?
If, at the time, Muslims didn't perform their prayer as a ritual like today and someone changed that to a physical and there was no objection or if there was an objection how did they allow it to change, this is where I have doubts.
I think there is a possibility that there is some form of ritual in prayer, but what matters more in the end is how good of connection do you have with God and are you a good person, not doing what God prohibited from you, being grateful to God, and so on.
Who with hold assistance in this context in Surat Ma'un?
Salam Sir
I guess your next topic would be on Sujud or sajda
we do find two types of Sajda physical and allegorical (surrender) in Quran.
I request you to Please share your insight on the below mentioned verses when you talk about sajda
These verses talk about physical sajda
An-Nahl 16:48
Ar-Ra'd 13:15
An-Naml 27:24
Al-Fath 48:29
68:42,43
Salam--video on sujood coming soon
Brother Abdur Rahman, Sajda and sabbaha both quranic terms basically means "To Obey"
@@syedabdullahmujtehdi1534 Salam brother ... But for obey there is an equivalent word in Quran, Atee'yu
@@AbdulRahamanKarunakar wa alaikum salaam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh AR bhai, beshak ita'ath (compulsory willful obedience to Allah, Ar Rasool, Ulul Amr - Quran) and itteba (willful obedience to Allah or blind obedience to our own Hawa and Shayateen)...
Sabbaha (tasbeeh - means to do full efforts in obedience of Allah on the seerat e mustaqeem)
Sabr (perseverance in protecting Miskeen from corrupt authorities, protecting Momineen from tyrants and evil doers, collective work to support Yateem without any expectations/ monetary goals/ verbal thanks from saliheen as an obedience to the commands of our Rabb)
Sajada (encompasses willful obedience to all the do's and don'ts in the *Quran*/ Deen e Islam/ System/ Nizam of Peace & security). Aise peaceful nizam ke ahkamon ko obey karne utmost aajizi (humility/ khushu) ko Sajada kahte hain.
Everything in the skies and on Earth and whatever is in between them performs Tasbeeh or Sajda is mentioned throughout Quranic ayaath.
@@syedabdullahmujtehdi1534 Syed bhai.. interesting ... Mai jo verses quote kiye hain usme obedience toh aata hai also action ki baat bhi usme milti hai for example their shadows do sajda, inclining to right and left isliye mujhe ye verses pe detailed analysis chahiye tha .... Ek baar wo verses dekhiye .. aap Moses Sir ke sath kabhi discussion me aaye the ?