(English) There is NO WUDHU وضوء in the Quran. Allah's msg not for toilet training. Quran 5:6
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 ноя 2022
- Let's be honest...
Why would a book of guidance for all humans, until the end of time, remind us to wash our bodies after going to the toilet?
What does Quran 5:6 really say?
Salat in the Quran series - video #1.5
#wudhu
#wuzu
#salat
#salaat
#salah
#ablution
#taharah
#quranicsalah
#Quran
#GroupThink
#MajorityRules
#Majority
#Consensus
#LiveDiscussion
#IslamicDiscussion
#EnglishLive
#slavery
#Islamicslavery
#concubine
#sexualslavery
#humantrade
#mahr
#fitna
#conditionsofnikah
#mahar
#bridalgift
#bridalmehndi
#interfaithharmony
#interfaithmarriage
#hindumuslim
#hindumuslimlovestory
#muslimhindu
#shadi
@QuranSpeaks
@OneMessageFoundation
@MuftiAbuLayth
@muftimenkofficial
@MUHAMMADSHAIKH
@SamGerrans
@qurancentric7459
@MarvelousQuran
@edipyuksel
@quranvshadith
@Drzakirchannel
@EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips
#polygamy
#4wives
#multiplewives
#pluralmarriages
#nikah
#shadi
#surahnisa
#suratnisa
#nikahislami
#nuslimshadi
#mehndi
#rukhsati
#walima
#halala
#talaq
#FemalesInIslam
#womeninislam
#zakar
#untha
#rijal
#nisa
#hijab
#genderequality
#GenderInQuran
#FemalesInQuran
#AuratInQuran
#GenderInIslam
#MultipleMarriages
#polygamy
#ViolenceAgainstWomen
#4:34
#islam
#quran
#qurandiscussion
#qurandebate
#islamdiscovery
#questionsandanswers
#quraish
#makkah
#hajj
#parda
#alhajj
#tawaf
#umrah
#almasjidannabawi
#kaaba
#almoses
#hijabers
#almasjidalharam
#masjidalharam
#qurbani2k21
#qurbanistatus
#qurban
#quranichajj
#surahfeel
#kaaba
#makkah
#mecca
#QuranVSAhadith
#LearningQuran
#QuranCentric
#QuranVsSunnah
#QuranAlone
#Kalamullah
#QuranicTerms
#QuranicMustalahat
#AbbasidIslam
#Shirk
#Al Moses
#TaqlidiIslam
#Mullah
#Mushrik
#MuhammadCharacter
#QuranTranslation
#QuranUrdu
#QuranHindi
#LiveConversation
#Live
#TheftPunishment
#CutHand
#ChoppingHands
#CapitalPunishment
#CapitalPunishmentInIslam
#Punishment
#Quran
#ShareQuran
#LaylatulQadr
#AlMoses
#NightofPower
#Ramadan
#Ramzan
#Slavery
#SexualSlavery
#Londiyan
#Laundiyan
#SlaveryInIslam
#Shirk
#marvelousquran
#TheMarvelousQuran
#mushrik
#QuranTranslation
#ReadingQuran
#UnderstandingQuran
#LearningArabic
#Arabic
#AlMoses
#QuranicArabic
#Ramadan
#Ramzan
#Fasting
#Eid
#Roza
#MarriageAyesha
#MarriageAisha
#Ayesha
#Aisha
#ProphetMuhammadandAyesha
#ProphetMohammadandAisha
#AyeshaAge
#ChildMarriage
#UnderageMarriage
#MarriageWithChildren
#Nikah
#Pedophilia
#MolanaTariqJameel
#MolanaTariqMasood
#TariqMasood
#MuftiYasir
#MuftiYasirNadeemalwajidi
#MuftiWajidi
#IndianIslam
#MarvelousQuran
#QuranvsHadith
#PakistaniIslam
#ZakirNaik
#DrZakirNaik
#Salat
#Salaat
#Namaz
#Nimaz
#Deen
#QuranicTerms
#SalatAurNamazkafarq
#EngineerMuhammadAli
#Islam
#Quran
#Barelvi
#Barelwi
#TableeghiJamaat
#MolanaTariqJameel
#TariqJameel
#MuhammadSheikh
#Parvezi
#QuranCentric
#Tuqoos
#TariqMasood
#MolanaTariqMasood
#PeghameHaqq
#Musalleen
#killinfidel
#killkafir
#kafirKon
#kafir
#debatewithmuslim
#muslimvsnonmuslim
#muslimvsexmuslim
#sachwala
#halal
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajidirefuted
#responsetomuftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
#muftiyasirnadeemalwajididebunked
#muhammadsmarriage
#muhammadsmarriagerefuted
#muhammadmarriagewithaisha
#muhammadsmarriagetozainab
#muhammadcharacter
#answeringislam
#answeringchristianity
#viral
#contradictioninquran
#quraniccontradiction
#contradictioninislam
#islamiccontradiction
#indianexmuslimsahil
#islam
#quran
#exmuslim
#indianexmuslim
#sachwala
#quran
#leftislam
#zafarheretic
#harissultan
#ghalibkamal
#mehleej
#mahleej
#aminasardar
#jaidevi
#indianmuslim
#exposeislam
#extremism
#islamicextremism
#exmuslimvsmuslim
#neerajatri
#tufailchaturvedi
#muftitareeqmasood
most subscribed channel
#muftitariqjameel
#ahlehadees
#barelvy
#sunni
#shia
#keralaimam
#apostasy
#talaq
#tripletalaq
#sudarshannews
#wasimrizvi
#indianexmuslimsahil
#Sunday
#Hijab
#ZeeNews
#IndiaTV
#MuslimWomen
#whyileftIslam
#indianexmuslimsahil
#islamic #islam #allah #muslim #islamicquotes #quran #muslimah #allahuakbar #deen #dua #makkah #sunnah #ramadan #hijab #islamicreminders #islamicpost #prophetmuhammad #love #muslims #alhamdulillah #jannah #islamicart #muhammad #instagram #islamicreminder #pakistan #madinah #namaz #madina #bhfyp
#islamicquote #subhanallah #ummah #islampost #islamicposts #art #urdu #prophet #quranquotes #urdupoetry #follow #hadith #islami #prayer #kuran #like #instagood #dawah #instaislam #pray #loveislam #m #life #hijrah #india #bhfyp #islamquotes #peace #hajj #quranverses
#indianexmuslimsahil #exmuslimsahil
#leftislam #exmuslim #IndianExMuslimSahil #Islam #kafir 
Развлечения
When I went to a Christian church, I think what made me lose faith was the lack of knowledgeable answers to the questions I had as a third grader trying to understand God and the Bible. Years passed, and I went from Christian, to atheist, to being really into demonology/Keys of Solomon, and finally, I'm here, reading the Qur'an in some way, shape, or form every day and endlessly searching for videos such as this to answer the questions that come about from reading and critically analyzing what is being said. Thank you for what you do!
I am in shock and in awe…. I have been praying God to give me access to the profound meaning of the Quran. To God be the glory.
Keep reading. Keep pondering.
Since you understand it now. Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :)
😂indefinite leave from going to masjid
@@levelearthhanifa9121I asked him similar question. I mean ok suppose no more ritual prayer then what to do instead?
@@7346908 I think the important point is to connect with God. I comprehend shukur and salat as about seeking connection. Allah doesn't need our thanks, we need connection with Allah.
However, I still follow the ritual salat as a means of connecting with Allah (SWT), seeking "iyyaka nabudu wa iyyaka nastain" and "siratul mustaqim" (self correcting methodology).....learnt some interpretation from other channel. Also trying to avoid saying certain expressions as I learn their deeper meaning.....but the intention is reconnection.
Of course, no more masjid khutbas.....could easily spend a lot if time here and study the Standard translation to identify, reflect and ponder upon some of the concealed ayats.
I am glad I am able to seek knowledge from such channels and comments section. And I am glad to see such channels sprout from every corner of this Earth.
Alhamdulillah! I love this. Goodness is on the rise with thinking men and women.
Since you understand it now.! Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :)
A profound Quran indeed. May God increase my knowledge and guidance.
Salam, an excellent presentation and all points explained in logical way. Not easy for those who follow ancestors and clergy blindly, but easy for all those who are willing to explore the Glorious Quran without any biases.
Unlearning is way harder than learning by blind copying
@@AlMosesPhD so true
Beautiful explanation .Thank you
Thanks. Very informative. I don’t speak Urdu and would love to listen to your other videos in English
Going forwards, I'll try and talk in English and Urdu both
Just discovered your channel amazed by both the knowledge and the way it is presented. Allah bless you. I am yet to watch your following videos however just wanted to say that I appreciate your work and please continue on delivering these type of eye-opening, educating videos in English. I pray to Allah to bring us all who question, with the right intention, to discover the truth in/with Quran.
the amount of research you've done really impressive and eye opening. I am already planning to watch all videos insha'Allah
WOW , truly an eye opener, n very informative, pls continue to do in English.
Since you understand it now. Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :)
@@levelearthhanifa9121level yr head on the ground n seek Mercy n Guidance fr God Almighty.
@@iesa9556 The translation doesn't make any sense. But you peoples don't really care about that as long as it's not wudhu.
Gr8 vid thoroughly enjoyed listening to it 👏
Alhamdulillah
Alhamdulilah
SubhahanAllahh
Salamun alaykum Brother Musa, indeed you are a blessing for truth seekers and alhamdulillah I am from Kerala, India, where Quran Manavam Research Foundation RUclips channel in Malayalam language gave the exact same explanation that you are giving now about Salath, wudu, siyam, Al-Haj, etc., about 10 years ago and still enlightenment us. I was in desperate search to translate the knowledgeable and thoughtful videos into English language so that the true message of Quran reaches the entire world and here I have found your channel by chance while browsing RUclips and alhamdulillah I thank Allah for his blessings in the form of you brother Musa, maasha Allah. I would also be grateful if there is a Urdu channel from your or any other brother explaining all your videos in urdu so that only urdu speaking people can too benefit from this Truth and Enlightenment of Quran. I feel pain seeing the human massacre going on now between jews and traditional Muslims in Israel and Palestine and all places where this hatred is spreading, and I hope when the Quran Al Fajr or The Sunrise of Enlightenment treats the diseased hearts of people with the medicine of Truth of love of Allah, then all bloodshed will immediately stop. May that Sunrise come soon.
SalaamunAlaykum
Alhmdllh..thank you. I think your translation of this ayah fits for whole universe and time.
This is formidable. It make sense in all times and spaces. So spiritual and profound. How we have been cheapening the Word of God … how many of these none senses are out there that we just accept out of blind faith?
Since you understand it now :) Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :) .
These new Quran alone followers are throwing the baby out with the bath water. They are trying too hard to find new meanings. They add their own meanings to words without any proper evidence or justification. Their versions of the verses with their “translations “ are full of their own conjecture in paranthesis
Peace be on to you Brother, all praises be to the Creator of the universe for guiding us to the age of awakening as more people are breaking out from the traditional indoctrination and seeking the path of truth. I will keep following, please speak more in English, God bless you.
Peace. Inshallah I will try and keep a balance of content between Urdu and English
Good work
I came to a similar conclusion regarding salat, masjid, zakat and hadsch.. They are more of spiritaul nature than localities or physical
Thanks so much. I initially thought I should stop listening to you but I am know learning a lot from you. May God bless you. I am kindly requesting you to explain surah 30 verse 17 to 18.
Alhamdulilla... for I have learned something true today. I have been stumped by that "tayammum" bit for ages... until today.
salam, brother.
Since you understand it now. Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :) How have you applied this verse in your life over the last two months
@@levelearthhanifa9121 Methinks... the more pertinent question is how YOU think I am supposed to understand it! 🤔
Logically, I do not have to explain anything further because the explanation by Al moses phd here suffices for me... but, obviously, not for you, eh?
salam
Sukran brother.
My full hearted praise to the sustainer of all realms. I was searching for a conformance answer. It was a huuuge relief.
Imagine; torn between no salat and ablution verse.
U put it eloquently. Argument accepted.
Sukran, sukran, sukran.
alhamdulillal
@@GloballyIslamic tq for asking. I am student of marvelous quran.
May u find enlightment thete.
Nice
Thanks
Very much appreciated. Greatful for your work.
Interesting, logical and beautiful interpretation! Allah bless you!
Alhamdulillah
Since you understand it now. Why don't you explain practically what the verse is asking us to do and how we can apply it in our lives :) :)
@@levelearthhanifa9121 I think that part is yours to ponder upon.
Excellent....😊 Watched twice...will write down the complete translation of the ayah....i am so releived now 😅
Alhamdulilah....i am so happy and thankful to learn from this channel.
Salaamun Allaikhum, thank you for that clear explanation of Aya Q5:6. I would request you to give us a practical application of the beautiful translation of the aya so that we relate it clearly to our toiling in this life. I believe with an example of application we shall comprehend it better and apply it in all our challenges. Once again thank you.
Salamun alaikum
All types of Salat require this 'wuzu'.
I've got more videos of Salat coming up so hopefully they'll help clarify 5:6 even more.
I am so glad that people are waking up. Phew! The ignorance of the people left with the book has just started progressing 1400 years later. Allah forgive us for being this foolish all these years and thank you for your patience and allowance for this new generation to correct your Word.
interesting. the logic and the meaning make perfect sense.
Do you have a published translation based on this approach?
Feels so good to not be the only one who has a probkem with hadiths after literally reading the quran saying only read quran and bible nothing else
Follow 'only' the Quran brother.
The Bible is a collection of human tales
This is true wadu. A great purging!
Selamün aleyküm, Can you explain the real meaning of wudu to me? I can't understand because I don't speak English, I'm just translating.
Salam brother Moses, your translation is certainly potent, though there are parts I'm still not totally clear on. What's sticking to my mind especially atm (as I've been working on these verses alongside the video), is specifically the difference between "aydīkum" and "aydiyakum". My understanding was that one is in the genitive and the other is in the accusative, and that this explains their different form. Are you suggesting these are just different words? Aren't all grammatical cases ( listed separately in the muṣḥaf?
Salam, a good question.
According to the 'rules' of Arabic grammar: what would you expect ayadihim to look like in 24:24?
Should it be ayadiYUhum or even ayadiYAhum? Why isn't it so?
This is a stunning and beautiful verse. No wonder they tried to disguise it heavily with such filth.
Ati Allah Ati Rasoolullah.
Surah Al-e-Imran v 32
If you have a concern, refer to the life of RasoolAllah sallallahu alaihi wa sallam PBUH.
This channel (www.youtube.com/@MarvelousQuran ) is also trying to explain the Quran by the Quran .
I have a question:
Does The Commandment
یآ أيها الذین آمنوا
also mean The Prophet?
Salamun Alaikum! Brother, you did an amazing job! Do you have any interpretation of Surah Feel? Please kindly do it.
SA, if you understand Urdu/Hindi, then there is a vid on the channel on Surah Feel.
Long story short: there is no elephant there
@@AlMosesPhD I always wondered what could it be? What does Ashabul Feel mean?
@@AlMosesPhD Could you please elaborate more? I don't know Urdu nor Hindi.
Salam, thank you very much for the breakdown brother Moses. I have been on the path of trying to shake off what I've been taught and instead following and trying my best to understand what I know and believe God has commanded in his book of guidance, thank you for sharing and may Allah guide you and increase you in knowledge. I'd like to ask brother, how do I shake off the 'what if' in the back of my mind when it comes to concepts like ritual prayer, the last point you mentioned in your first video in the series of "how is it possible that people have gotten salat wrong all this time" is one i'd like to hear soon if possible. Jazaak Allah khair and may He forgive our shortcomings and lack of effort.
Don't rush and let your heart become satisfied with the evidence.
It'll come.
Exactly no wudu no ghusl go to the bathroom wipe yourself w a paper and wala your clean you can start praying oh sorry I mean stand and think
It is clearly given
And yes it is not physical only. It is spiritually cleaning. Which I agree withu
A.aleykum my brother may Allah bless you and put his Hikma. My question is im still learning Quraan and i have a bit of learning disability so maybe i didnt understand. How do we pray and how many times. Thank you sorry if i ask something that you already answered
SA, please start the series from the beginning until the end
Assalamu alaikum. This is quite alarming for me brother as i wish to follow allah as best i can, how can i properly study and understand what is going on the quran and myself when i have no knowledge of arabic. So i can come to the right understanding of god, what are the steps you took to start translating it yourself, as im very alarmed by all this and both translations of yours and 5:6 original do make sense, i feel, but what steps would you advise so i can find it myself with allah?
This is an outstanding presentation. Thank you for providing it in English. Your logical breakdown of the language is refreshing. Does there currently exist a non-traditional English translation that you feel more accurately captures what the Quran is saying? I particularly love the way you speak about being inclusive to women. Thank you again.
Best would be to cross-reference multiple translations and try and ignore the brackets.
I usually recommend M Asad as a good starting position
@@AlMosesPhD Thank you! I currently have The Gracious Quran by A Hammad. I will try to find a copy of the M Asad Quran as well.
The Quran a complete revealation by Sam Gerrans. Its free and I highly recommend it.
I'd really love a full analysis of "nisaa". I've heard this came a few times now, but not the evidence. 3:16 could be speaking of the general beautification, though I would agree, that interpretation is questionable. But there are so many other verses where the meaning is less clear. *That being said, if you published an English translation of the Quran, I would certainly take a look at your tafsir. I would be happy to help you produce this "non-traditional" translation, to present for critical engagement (peer review). It could be useful.
I've covered it in detail in the Urdu series.
Might do it in English one day
With great respect, I am curious about your perspective on hijab, both mens and womens. Can you please do a video on the topic in english?
One day.
There is no physical hijab that i found for women though
Interesting presentation and very insightful and hard to argue with the points raised.
How would you interpret the numerous verses telling us to obey the Messenger and to take his judgement as final, and that he is the best example for us and that if we want Allah to love us then we should follow him - and that Allah would raise his name for remembrance.
Muhammad ﷺ has been classed as the most influential and most chronicled and most successful man in history. But it seems like if you reject the tradition - then he wasn’t very successful at all and Allah has not raised his name and remembrance.
And now Dr Hany is saying all the ‘allazeena aamanu’ verses are for the Jews and earlier communities only and not for us.
It’s all very confusing - And I pray Allah leads me to the truth wherever it is
I'll cover 'rasul' one day properly inshallah.
Salamunalikum brother you should write full translation side by side as we don’t know Arabic language
Salamin alaikum, this ayaah does have it
is there this kind of translation as a whole quran in english? if so where can you get it? would of course be a great advantage otherwise you would only understand parts of the koran correctly.
Not that I know of
Another powerful reflection. I have a feeling you're going to come to similar conclusions about bowing and prostrating (if you get to it), based kn the direction you're moving. Have you considered though, the possibility that there are both literal and figurative meanings in some of these verses? Sometimes it appears to me that even if the physical washing isn't ritual, it was in preparation for an event that required a minimum hygiene. It doesn't have tonbe a reflection of intelligence as much as of living conditions in the time and place, hence many had understood, and still understood it the practice as primarily hygienic, even though I would agree that it is not (primarily). But perhaps even then it is meant to symbolize the physical act so that it becomes a kind of remembrance in itself, everytime one partakes in such acts, binding the physical to the "deeper" spiritual reality of the Most-High. This is perhaps too dense a convo for the medium, but again, there must have been some muslim in the past who had come across this, or from the early period, someone to comment on the induction of "ritual purity" in the System. Perhaps there were two corresponding understandings, and for whatever reason, one was lost to the political turmoil.
Best to start with the 'playlist' in the channel. That way you'll go through in a structured order
@@AlMosesPhD I actually did go back to the beginning of the playlist. I'm currently up to your video on Durood. I'm still having trouble understanding how your interpretation of "wudduu" (5:6) isn't esoteric. The phrasing is very unusual if we are to replace the literal words "face", "feet" ect with the synonymous meanings you are arguing in favor of. I can understand how in *wipping ones face, one could purify their focus figuratively, buy the rest of the verse seems even more confusing if we substitute the body parts for their alternative meanings. These verses were directed at the plural "you" if I'm not mistaken. Are we being directed to "wipe the movers to elevation" and "wipe the leaders"? Purifying the focus is easy to understand but then also the supporters until the dependable companions? Is it purify them until they are dependable companions? What exactly does that entail? I'm only partially getting it.
My initial assumptions regarding the "traditionalist" ritualistic understanding was that this ritual must be some kind of psychological prompting. Then, when I came to realize the Salary refers to more in the Quran, I figured in some context it was a kind of meeting between the prophet and the believers with a minimum hygiene requirement. Then I figured, well if it was a ritual, the parts of the body washed might have been touching the floor. I realized there weren't any classical sources where the ritualized reading had ever been challenged. Or none that I know of (please share if you have any). So I figured there may have been two concurrent practices, one involving the study and application of Qur'an in society, and the other, perhaps fabricated practice of ritual observance practiced by the masses and spread primarily by Islamic institutions. Now if there was not, we should be able to find at least one Muslims thinker who criticized the shift, or do you believe those who were true adherents were too small in number to produce opposition? Or is it some kind of mass conspiracy of erasing opposition (despite the fact that we are opposition and disagreement with what was established in Muslim tradition even from those countering the arguments from back then)?
To be clear, I'm sympathetic to your position but I see issues with it (obviously), and there are still parts that aren't coming together gor me. I've seen Quran-centric muslims rationalize that "salat" could be prayer, without any specified "form". I think it's more likely not prayer, even if prayer could be an expressions of al-Salat. The lack of first century AH references to a non-ritual understanding makes it hard to establish a strictly non-ritual interpretation, which is why I tend toward a more esoteric take.
I am new to this channel. Please let me know which Quran translation you are using.
I have listened attentively to what you said about wudhu. It really seems that we do as we have seen our forefathers have been doing. The question is is there any harm if we perform the udhu before every Salat?
Dr.Salim
Answer to that in the last vid of the series
The Sunni wudu is not even the Quran, the one the Quran describes is different
Stay objective, you cannot start by judging without proof that the ritual are there to teach people « basic cleaning »(unless you just try to mock it) ofc there is a non material aspect of all of the terms since these are concepts they don’t need to have exclusively a material aspect or exclusively a symbolic/spiritual aspect especially in the quranic language in which there is both explicit and implicit aspect merging for the same message. So your good reminder of these aspect (like wajh meaning also the being) is very important but it doesn’t exclude the physical manifestation of it unless you clearly prove it.
It is utter nonsense to think that four acts of wudu, which was mentioned in Quran is unnecessary & not correctly translated
Like what?
Brother moses can you please explain Surah maida ayah #6 Believers! When you stand up for Prayer wash your faces and your hands up to the elbows, and wipe your heads, and wash your feet up to the ankles
Did you watch the video?
I did from 6:14- the end of the video. And I'm confused
Because I'm a recently departed from sunni islam and recently started to follow only the quran I'm just a little shocked at how the chapter verse 5:6 you translated is just so different from all the English translations
Does this mean I need a lexicon or an arabic concordance?
Because the Quran in chapter 6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed
Maybe you can help me
Don't rush. Keep learning :)
Have you ever think why Allah said wash your face then your hands ? It is more logical first to wash hands then your face.
A very good question indeed!
I get the impression that , when Allah says to seek his face , some people take that as literal and some will say it's not literal
What is the nature of a face , it looks out
So we should look for the outlook he expects from us
Washing the face , is therefore to me saying, to not bring a tainted, stained, outlook when approaching the Quran , approach it with a clean non bias outlook
Washing the hands , in my opinion could be don't start studying if you're mind is not fully there if you have unfinished work that needs to be done and ones focus isn't 100% because your not content because it's playing on the mind
....
Final Book of guidance?
Have you any proof from the Book of guidance?
Rest is an excellent postmortem of traditional translations.
Mosa brother have you done wadoo explaination in Urdu?
Yes, look for the Playlist in urdu
Understood. So if it isn't prayer then please can you note down in simple explanation what it is that Allah wants from us. So what's the alternative?
Watch the series from the beginning until the end please
how do you translate Nisa as diversionary things.
The Quran is a book of clear signs. It is not a book of riddles. Face, hands, head and feet are just that. Why would Allah say one thing when He meant another? I'm afraid I'm not convinced by this attempt to "explain" what really doesn't require it.
Allah is clear.
'We' insist on making them faces, hands, and toilet training.
I don't argue. Best of luck with your learning
How about hadith or example from Muhammad SAW on wudu n solat. Can’t simply refer to Al Quran only and ignore hadith.
Always had questions about this verse with respect to washing with dirt. What then is the cornerstone and overarching theme of the Book ?
To do good to others
@@AlMosesPhD The cornerstone and theme of the Quran is only to "do good to others"? Then individuals who are not Muslim but "do good to others" have a chance to make it to Paradise?
@@QuranAlone-TheStraightPath Indeed. Muslim of a Quran is one of spreads peace, not one who utters two magical Arabic sentences
@@AlMosesPhD Let me understand you correctly...a Christian or Buddist etc., who does good to others" can attain Paradise?
@@defaultname9281 Indeed, that's my fahm
Salaam brother, in order to support your opinion, you will need to explain verse Nisa 43 "... and if you find no water, then take for yourselves clean sand or earth, and rub therewith your faces and hands..." Regards,
Salam, it's the same terms there. There is no 'soil' or 'water' one needs reminded by Allah after doing number 2
Salaamun alaykum
After listening to your explanation is there anything that prevents a person from doing the ritual washing and ritual prayer.
Salaamun alaykum, I didn't get the bit about 'preventing' people.
One can do whatever he/she wants despite what the text says in my fahm.
Do you also have any material on fasting?
There is a community post re it
@@AlMosesPhD it's not showing on my tablet. Would love your opinion on it. I believe that we should fast for the month of Ramzan and eat before sunrise and keep the fast until nightfall.
If you’re a Quran alone believer and think salaat has no physical component. I need you to explain how you establish your salat as a qa follower. Every qa believer that rejects a physical Quranic salaat doesn’t actually do anything for salaat, they chalk it up to following closely (needs to be questioned where this translation came from). Lazy 🤷♂️🤔
Don’t link any videos. If you can’t explain your point to a 5 year old you yourself don’t understand what you’re trying to convey. Don’t pass off your deen to RUclips imams without proof.
@@AsadAli-hm2vx Is the Quran for 5-year olds who only understand by blindly imitiating their elders?
You want answers? You can watch the series, or choose not to.
There is no compulsion in religion, I don't think you should be explaining Quran to a 5 year old , yes they should be taught language, grammar, etc so they can formulate their own judgement without intermediarys, we as parents can only encourage good actions and behaviour,
Urdu mein bhi video bnayen is pr
why all of this brackets (?) , could you just translate the words verbatim without these extraneous brackets?
why does water mean Quran/Al-kitab.
But I think the cleaning advices are so literal meaning... Not this much depth.. Coz Salat is Quran revelation session.. So ke 3rd who join for it be purified Irvin good state.
Please elaborate in Urdu
As a new Muslim my question then is, how do I pray? How many times? No wudu then? Do I not recite Al Fatihah then?
Watch the whole series
@@AlMosesPhD I will, thank you
Does that mean we don’t need to do Wudhu before praying ?
there is no praying in the first place , open the thin black veil that obstructs you from that true paradigm...
THERE IS NO WORD WUDHU IN THE QURAN-JUST LIKE THERE IS NO 2AND1/2 % ZAKAT IN THE QURAN.
I pray Allah grants guidance to all those who sincerely seek His guidance.
To Al Moses and anyone who ignorantly agrees with what is being said in this video and others like it from other individuals who completely try and change Allah’s religion which He has completed/perfected during the time of our Prophet Muhammad, (peace be upon him)
I ask, do you not believe that our prophet who received revelation i.e. The Quran, acted on what he received?
Do you not believe he made wudu, and fundamentally prayed as we pray today?
Or do you believe that he didn’t make wudu and he didn’t pray?
I implore you to, have reverence for Allah! Have reverence for Allah! Have reverence for Allah!
Do you believe in Allah? I assume that you do.
If you say yes, yes you do believe in Allah, who is All Seeing, All Hearing, and All Knowing. If you say yes, you do believe in Allah who has created us to worship Him as He mentions in the Quran. If you say yes, you do believe in Allah and you understand fully what that means, then do you really believe that Allah, would allow billions of Muslims who strive and have striven to worship Him, which is our purpose for being created, to be wrong for over a thousand years on such fundamental things which are integral to worship, like wudu and prayer?
Do you believe Allah, would allow something so fundamental to be misunderstood by billions for centuries?
Do you believe no one would know how to fundamentally worship Allah until you came along over a thousand years later?
Do you believe that our Prophet did his job?
If you do believe that he did exactly what he was commanded to do, and if you are a rational individual, you would understand that what he did was witnessed by thousands of people who were around him at the time, and they followed him in that.
EVEN WITHOUT HADITH, some things, especially those fundamental things which are mentioned explicitly in the Quran, like prayer and wudu, even though you try with some verbal gymnastics, to reinterpret what is literally being said, something so fundamental like wudu and prayer would be passed down from generation to generation, as it has been.
In short, people saw the Prophet, who received revelation and understood it best, do a thing and they did it, people saw those people who saw the prophet do a thing, like make wudu and pray, and they did it, and it naturally would continue like this from generation to generation, EVEN WITHOUT HADITH.
I’m not sure what your aim is with the videos you post, but I implore you, if you really believe in Allah, desist from making a mockery of His religion, His Prophet, and His Book, by posting videos which completely contradict what ALLAH HAS ESTABLISHED within His religion and the community of believers, because you will be questioned on That Day.
Salam, you sound sincere so am making an effort to respond.
First, you should notice that you’re appealing to emotion and precedent only. Not "once" have you mentioned an ayah of the Quran or critiqued any of the Quranic terms mentioned.
If you wish to unlearn the cultural religion and learn the deen of Islam = risala of Rasul Muhammad and other messengers, a few pointers for you:
- We are not made to ‘worship’ Allah. Ibadah doesn’t mean worship (video in Urdu on the channel)
- Appeal to majority / past generations is rejected outright by the Quran (vid in English on the channel)
- Just because a practise becomes associated with a Quranic term does not mean it’s sanctioned by Allah (did you know that terms like tasbih, salat, zakah, qatal, jihad, muslim, jibal, samaa, al-kitab are different in Quran vs fiqhi / cultural Arabic / religion islam)
I do not argue brother, especially when there is no Quran being presented for weight.
You can stay where you are, or continue to unlearn to learn.
@@AlMosesPhD I appreciate your reply. First, If you read the message I posted for you and anyone else who reads it, I am not appealing to emotion, I am appealing to one’s intellect.
I am asking you and anyone reading to think deeply about what you are saying in your videos, and what is implied either intentionally or unintentionally.
What you are saying without saying it, is that our Prophet did not understand the revelation he received and or you understand it better than he. And what you are saying, without saying it, is that Allah has sent down a book, i.e. The Quran, that is not clear, in fact you are implying that it is so unclear that billions of muslims over thousands of years have got very fundamental and basic things all wrong, until you came along.
This makes no rational sense. So again, I am not appealing to emotion, I’m appealing to intellect. And I hope you and anyone reading will think deeply, about what has been said.
Regarding mentioning ayah from the Quran, I alluded to a few. For example, Allah has completed the religion Surah 5 Verse 3, and the prophet is our best example to follow, Surah 33 Verse 21, and we were created to worship Allah, Surah 51 verse 56, for example. And I intentionally didn’t mention the verses specifically, because, one, that was not the point of my post, and two, from the videos I’ve watched of yours it’s clear you’re not interested in the apparent meanings of the arabic words in the Quran.
Case and point, you say ibadah, doesn’t mean worship. Either you do not know arabic, or you are being dishonest to say such a thing, in order to prove some point.
Are you really saying that worship can not be implied in any shape form or fashion by the Arabic word ibadah?
If that’s what you’re saying, then centuries of Arabs, and every arabic dictionary would disagree with you.
The same with Ghasl to ‘wash’ or wajh for ‘face’. Are you saying that these apparent meanings in English can’t be implied in any shape form or fashion by their respective arabic translations?
Again, if that’s what you’re saying, then centuries of Arabs, and every arabic dictionary would disagree with you.
If that’s not what you’re saying, and you admit that the apparent English translations of those words can be implied, then why try and confuse the people by saying that’s not what they mean. That’s being dishonest. Be truthful and say they can mean exactly what is apparent, but you choose to interpret them by some of their other meanings. To say they don’t mean what is apparent at all is dishonest.
Allah has made His book clear. I’m sure you can find the many ayat which support that statement.
I also did not make these post to argue, I simply wanted to caution you and anyone else who may be misled by YOUR interpretation of Allah’s book.
You can take heed or not. Our affair is with our Lord.
I pray Allah grants guidance to those who sincerely seek His guidance.
@Talibudeen Peeples these discussions are fruitless if one imposes the religious Arabic of 9th century Baghdad on the Quran even when it clashes.
The rasul followed the Quran only.
Ask an Arab. Quranic terms aren't what we use today. It's not a secret.
Last comment to you: look who else apart from Rasul Muhammed is uswa Hasanah for us all. The answer you think you know is against the Quran. Same for the other ayahs.
Wasalam
Do AhlaeBaet & Ashab follow Quraan like this ? How can we be known by history ?
What matters more? Quran or alleged actions of people?
Wudu is clear in the Quran. Not sure what you mean. It is clear in the quran. Instructions are clear, as people dont even know on hygine. Allah did say that.
Did you watch the video?
Wouldn't it be nicer if one was to contend based on solid arguments?
@@AlMosesPhD I don't disagree with you. It is just the title suggesting there is no woodoo in the quran.
Also if wjh is only face to be taken what is qibla 🤔😂😂wjh also direction qibla is face 😈
Could you please make a full translation of Quran, May God give you the possibility to do so , InshaAllah.
Sorry I have no intention for that at present
Which quranic translation would you choose as the most correct translation known to you ?
Best to cross-reference quite a few.
One I usually recomend is M Asad minus the brackets
O ye who believe! when ye prepare for prayer, wash your faces, and your hands (and arms) to the elbows; Rub your heads (with water); and (wash) your feet to the ankles. If ye are in a state of ceremonial impurity, bathe your whole body
Did you see the video?
R u trying to say the prophet dud not perform ablution or wudhu .hus compan9uns learnt all that he taught and thsts hiw it has been to date .
I was born into Islam but I'm a very very rational person. On top of all tHe hardships in life I had to deal with a God which cares when did I go to the toilet and did I entered with right, or left foot and did I use my right or left hand to wash myself.
Eventually I concluded this is a joke religion which only cares about toilets, sex and impurities which have to be washed away in a procedural way.
I declared my family that I denounce this religion as fake but that I'll maintain faith in God only and nothing else.
I want to thank you for opening a new Islam to me, one of miracles, equality and focus, not one focused on toilets, sex, misogyny and whether to use right or left hand.
May God almighty reward you for your work, for you are the answer to all my anxiety with Islam which I had already abandoned.
I certainly can't become Christian nor Jewish for they betrayed Issa Al Masih, and other religions were simply out of the question because in my heart I know there's only one God.
I thought either Unitarian Christian or be agnostic as I am, but you opened my eyes to something new. Which I have contemplating myself, though I had to learn Arabic. Which now I will.
Thank you. Thank you.
Greetings from Europe!
do you have discord or telegram?
Pls...make video on... purpose of life ...what is being expected by our creator ALLAH swt ??? Prove with ayahs..
It's really simple.
Do 'abd' to His system. Do good. Don't do bad.
If you understand Urdu, watch our video on 'Ibadat'
@@AlMosesPhD jazakallah khair
And mean to say Allah here is talking metamorphic and not in literal. So by that logic everything should be only metaphor and nothing in literal. Now do think with open minded ness❤️
No.
Allah speaks to the nafs. Not the body. That's how we should read the Quran
@@AlMosesPhD yes to the spirit. But the question was not that. Do we take the literal meaning of the written word or make a meaning that suits better for our ideology 🤔well then the so called clerical will have clean chit to say nonsense 😂😂
U never ever give references by hadith n sunnah, means u dont believe, the sunnah..
Did you listen to the Quran? Was it not enough for you?
JUST TODAY I COME ACROSS YOUR VIDEO. SEEMS A LEARNED PERSON. BUT THIS NARRATIVES OF YOURS EMBARRASSED ME. IT SEEMS YOU FORGET THAT ALLAH SAYS... I SEND IT TO YOU IN YOUR TONGUE O MOHAMMED. SO WE SHOULD PREFER THE LANGUAGE OF THE MECCAN AND MADINAN AND DERIVE THE MEANING. LOGIC AND COMMONSENSE CLAIM IT. BUT YOU MAKE THINGS SIX AND SEVENS. VERY SAD MY DEAR. MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU. FROM BANGLADESH.
Take a breath brother, listen to the Quranic verses, and if you content something, use the Quran
Why Allah didn't teach how do sex?May be Allah is ignorant about sex but just says do sex with right hand posses
Alhamdolliah everything is mentioned in detail by our last messenger of Allah, so we ought to only n only follow him, u r details r urs u r misguiding the muslims.
Allah has clearly order3to follow Allah n his final messengers (saw).
This every thing practically done by the holy prophet.
Brother - How do you reconcile the verse 6 surah 5 - Al - Maida with No WUDU that you claimed.
O you who have believed, when you rise to [perform] prayer, wash your faces and your forearms to the elbows and wipe over your heads and wash your feet to the ankles. And if you are in a state of janabah, then purify yourselves. But if you are ill or on a journey or one of you comes from the place of relieving himself or you have contacted women and do not find water, then seek clean earth and wipe over your faces and hands with it. Allah does not intend to make difficulty for you, but He intends to purify you and complete His favor upon you that you may be grateful. (6) And remember the favor of Allah upon you and His covenant with which He bound you when you said, "We hear and we obey"; and fear Allah. Indeed, Allah is Knowing of that within the breasts
Did you watch the vid? The very ayah has been talked about
Good job brother-MashAllaah! Are the slides (in English) available? Which dictionary was used for the translation?
Along with Qur'an we should have to follow the activities of Nabi(s.a.s) which applies at the time of salah according to Qur'an In the light of (53:2-7) etc.then only we have no doubts for salah and wuzu, tayammum.
To those who say the Quran (Rasul Muhammad's only risala) is not enough for guidance, I say Salamun alaikum.
This is my last response to you.
@@AlMosesPhD then can you tell us how to actually pray and what if our mama don't like what we doing cause she already things that i am having mental issues as i told her we pray the wrong way
@@AlMosesPhDi don't understand many people also says we should also follow Prophet bu hadees books and i also found that when people say that Quran itself mentions to Obey Allah and obey messenger but they don't put too pressure on the word messenger it's not prophet meams we should only obey his message
There’s a lot of stuff made up here. Wajh can mean direction, meaning face yet in some contexts like “turn your face towards” it indicates direction. Yet when it’s within the context of wash and other orders to wash or wipe corporal limbs it is more than stretching the imagination to divert the dhahir of the word wajh. This is a very strong distortion of the Quran Text.
Why would Allah be talking about washing up after number 2?
Read the other comments
Salam… I think you are following your own desires. You keep appealing to us that why would Allah tell us how to wash and say why do you think He would do that? Quran is not a bathroom book. I believe this is a dramatic condemnation of Quran. You can’t assume to know the mind of Allah, the words of Allah reveal that. It is simply saying wash before prayer. You seem to believe a lot of things in Quran are symbolic, so why wouldn’t you look at the washing as symbolic instead of totally retranslating an entire text no translator agrees with you on? You seem to be making a new religion for yourself not based in Quran alone. Why not look at the water as purifying your face and hands which Quran mentions will testify against us on judgment day? There are also two verses on washing before salat in Quran. I am not sure why you have a problem washing before prayer.
Salam, do you think that the ayah talking to Men "AND" women both talks about them both having sexual intercouse with women?
I don't argue. You're welcome to your views
muslim with logical problem.... they are not belieave on logic, but they call them self as a finding the truth... imagine...
I was happy when 😂came across ❤lectures. But your method of teaching is beginning to appear to me as if you are a hired enemy of Islam. You pretend to defend the words of God but logically you are trying to bring down the religion of God
Listen to the Quran.
Investigate.
Don't throw accusations.
No brother, the cleaning of FACE, HANDS, HEAD and FOOT are the RITUALS before THE QURAN is recited upon you (THE RITUAL SOLAT). No matter if you are alone or in a congegration, after Surah AlFatihah, THE QURAN will be recited, hence YOUR PHYSICAL CLEANLINESS is a must and GOD is giving you a specific instruction (spiritual - cause you can only carry out the instruction AFTER you understood it) for you to carry out BEFORE you stand and do the RITUAL. It is very specific, if you just came from a toilet, DO THAT. it does not mean you LEAVE the toilet and only wash face, hand, head and feet leaving the feces not washed. LIKE YOU SAID, only stupid people do that. in Q10:100, God place THE FILTH upon those who do not think (STUPID PEOPLE).
No one said it is for TOILET TRAINING.. it is the SHAITAN who throw it in your head. NO BODY have said that. But, you are on the right path, keep thinking.
You have to look at the ayah about SOLAT. Not just in Q5:6. Its starts with Q2:125, then it is Q4:43 and Q4:142, then Q5:6, then Q11:114, then after that Q17:78 and lastly the LAST five ayah in surah AL-Isra. Q17:111 (The Recitation before TAKBIR), Q17:110 (The Calling of Ar-Rahman (Al-Fatihah) and Recite Al-Quran must be audible), Q17:109 - The Rukuk (not mentioned sajda), Q17:108 (The iktidal - what you say in between rukuk and sujud), and lastly the Q17:107 (THE SUJUD).
It is clear that DO NOT BE TOO LOUD nor SILENT, but find a way in between (Q17:109). Dont shout or dont be silent. What does it mean?, you can refer back to the Q2:125 taking the imam in makkah (whoever is the IMAM in makkah is standing on the MAQAM of IBraheem, so TAKE from the the ritual solat / musolla). What they are doing, only TWO RAKAAT is audible. It is in FAJR, MAGRIB and ISYA. this confirms the TIMING in the QURAN. Two ends of a day (FAJAR ad MAGHRIB) and near part from the LAIL (ISYA). so there is no ZUHR prayer and ASR. but if they want to do it, DO NOTSTOP THEM. ONLY GOD can CLARIFY it TO THEM. so ALL the SOLAT that is being done today, is only TWO RAKAAT (audible). whether it is Jummah, Eid, or TARAWEEH. ALL in two rakaah. and to confirm, it is said that THE SEVEN oft repeated - AlFatihah (Twice) and The Quran were given to US.
All these are RITUAL. IF YOU DONT DO IT.. to me its not a BIG PROBLEM. BUT THE SPIRITUAL one YOU HAVE TO DO. IT IS the COMMANDMENT that is the MOST IMPORTANT solat. What is it? It is stated clearly in Q2:21 and Q2:22. The first and second commandments. 1.SERVE YOUR LORD, and 2.DO NOT MAKE ANY COMPEERS for GOD. How to implement this? DO the RITUAL SOLAT first. read and use your aqal. HE WILL LAY for you YOUR FOUNDATION. NO ONE ELSE CAN. He laid the FOUNDATION for IBRAHEEM, and HE LAID the FOUNDATION for AHMAD. Muhammad is not EXCEPT a Messenger.
Brother, take a breath and read the whole ayah.
Talk is with men + women.
Then which women are being told to wash up after these women have 'touched' other women?
I don't text debate. Feel free to leave the last word.
@@AlMosesPhD MEN + WOMAN, I totally Agree.. asked any women, do they understand this ayah is just for men? ask them again, do they understand like you do? that in their case/context, it's the same? that they touched other/their women? Brother, even your mother/sisters/aunts know this. Do you not think?
I'm sorry..but not impressed enough to warrant deep research..as a researcher..vague topic..