I think the best way to expain Rose's voice is raw talent. She did not train much compared to a alot of other idols but she loves music, and was born w a unique voice. She is not a power vocalist and she is not the "best" out there but she is very unique and that in my opinion is all that matters. I personally love her voice.
Her voice isn’t my favorite but it breaks my heart that she never received the vocal coaching she deserves and her agency never taken her talent seriously, you can see her passion and willing to improve very clearly 😢❤ also she has a sweet genuine personality that attract people to her..
Wow it was a very unbiased analysis probably one of the best I've seen on Rosé, she has potential and I want to see her utilize it. I love Rosé her voice is so smoothing to me 😊
The thing that steps her aside from other vocalist in the kpop scene is the fact that she can pour emotion into her voice and fr she has a gifted voice . Kpop has plenty of vocalist that can hit high notes (not discrediting them) but you need something that can make you stand out of the crowd
Rosé is my favorite singer ever. She's not the best singer when it comes to her singing technique but the beautiful color of her voice and the way she delivers songs so emotionally, that's enough to be the best for me. She doesn't just sing with her mouth but from her heart, that's why she's the best for me. Let's support her Guys🤍🤍
I feel like Rose hasn't developed her true potential due to Blackpink's songs, wich are more rap focused But I'm glad she debuted as a soloist, I think since then we got to see more of her vocals, plus you can see the passion she has for music, I think that's the reason she's my bias too ❤️
I'd even go so far as to say that she's wasting her vocal potential by staying within a specific vocal range so that Rosé doesn't shine too brightly vocally.
I would probably go further & say that it's not just due to BP's songs but also potentially due to the K-pop in general. While K-pop does have some unique voices I don't think that the industry really knows how [or wants] to deal with them to get the best out of them because it would deviate too far from a standard group formula. It seems the industry want to try to embrace them to add a certain vocal interest to a group but then the producers, writers, arrangers just give the standard K-pop songs arranged to meet a formulaic mould of how groups should be and sound. I mean how often do you hear low female voices featured or hear songs written in a way that optimise a voice such as Rose’s in K-pop in general. Rarely. It’s not just a BP, YG thing, it’s a K-pop idol industry.
@@katwat8682 For me, there's also a culture shock: Rosé isn't Korean, she's Australian, so she's not really suited to Kpop culture. She said herself in a Vogue Australia interview that she considered herself an outsider.
@@erickacornu774 it may well be but i guess for me its more that I look at it as a musical culture shock-as I said in a seperate comment as an Australian I feel her style has a very familiar sound reminisent of indie pop/acoustic culture that has been pretty prevalent in Australia. And yes for me her voice shines the most in the songs that song least like k-pop
I watched Rosè on Sea of Hope and I do agree that she has a very beautiful voice for Acoustic singing, she has been carrying the Tour vocally this era. Also I don’t know if you Listen to IU she’s also vocally acclaimed so I wonder if we’ll ever get a video on her. I feel like I can’t find one anywhere.
The sad thing is that we will probably never see Rose's full potential while she's in YG. That agency's priority is rap and they forced Rose to changed her voice (there are demos pre debut which her voice is deeper). It's a shame, because she has everything to be an amazing vocalist.
rosie is my favorite vocalist to listen to in acoustic settings and i also personally think she has one of the most magical tones in pop music, regardless of her level of technical skill
I love nuanced videos like this that offer actual constructive criticism! I feel like for Rosé’s case she adopted a style first before mastering technique. With the needed improvement, I’m pretty sure she can reach her fullest potential while also maintaining her signature style.
I'm not the biggest fan of Rosé's voice, but i love to see her singing acoustic songs.. i feel like fits her the most and does really looks like she enjoy that
she has a really nice voice that like a lot of comments have said, sounds fantastic in an acoustic setting with her and her guitar. That's why I think her talent is wasted on debuting her in a rap heavy group like BLACKPINK, where her real vocal talented is normally just used like Miyeon from GIDLE, as fillers hear and there. Of course they have had great usage for her voice in their songs, but the whole concept of BLACKPINK, doesn't exactly accommodate her voice well in my opinion. I think there is way too many idols getting out in groups that aren't meant for them, and they get doubled down to a prechorus singing Main vocalist
One of my favorite voices in Kpop since ever, I think her tone and style is really unique and u can really tell is HÉR when u listen her voice, its kinda unique to me, the technique can be definitely better but since she was trained in YG that part is def not her best, I really like the fact that she's improving a lot in her general singing abilities I can definitely see her passion towards music and as a singer. I hope she leaves YG so she can explore her vocal potential asap. Great video btw.
Wow she reminds me a lot of Avril Lavigne’s and Dia Frampton’s style of singing. Rosé’s voice is more grating though & not as heavy in weight. Her vocal choices (decided for her or not) don’t bring out the best in her voice. The cursive singing along with too much nasality is much too sensual. It’s too “obvious” with the slight yodel endings too. It would be nice if she cleaned up her voice more without so many ornamentations. Her voice itself is sugary sweet already enough.
There are many excellent singers in K-pop but I always value a unique style and emotional expression over technical perfection. Rose’ is one of my favourites.
I would actually consider Rosie as a singer not a typical vocalist as she has passion for music she is really serious when it comes about music. She can play many instruments as well like guitar,piano etc Its really rare to have a main vocalist in a group who is multi talented who can dance well sing well play instruments write and produce lyrics and show passion to the music. I''ve only seen Rosie who has all of it she is the only one who wrote her own solos and many songs too like u never know some lyrics were produced by her while some by jennie. Lemme tell u one thing vocal isnt all about high notes and vocal tiers it can be seen through a vocalist's eyes and voice what type of vocalist they're. I mean there must've been a reason rosie has the title golden voice of korea its not becz she is the main vocalist it because she knows very well how to use her voice even though she had a deep voice and her high notes are relly good she had to change her ovice becz of the company but now she seems to be comfortable with her changed voice and its really difficult to sing in changed voice. So Rosie is my fav singer in kpop. I'm not a blink or anything im a multistan and i know many groups and many vocalists especially wendy,ning ning winter and all sm town main vocalist they had been trained for years about vocals they were given training and about notes but rosie just got selected and she became a idol becz of the decision made by her dad as she sang all night which disturbed him. All those main vocalists have some similar voice and rosie has the most unique among all as it is recognible and it is angelic.
Love ❤️ this video Rosè has a very special voice amongst powerhouses - what makes her stand out is her folksy, singer-songwriter style of singing amongst more gutsy vocalists. Do I think she is the best vocalist⁉️ NO But she does manages to stand out with her recognizable ornamented instrument ‼️‼️ Maybe not the Golden Voice of Korea (that will be Wendy maybe) but more like the ROSE 🌹 of Korea 😉 Especially how her voice sounds like she carefully Is plucking notes - it’s beautiful It’s a careful gift, very delicate ….
the thing is korean general public is the ones who named rosie as the golden voice of korea, not even blinks that's why i think international fans should step back and let it slide that title for rosie
I wanted to start this comment off by saying this analysis was beautiful. I wanted to add something to this: As KPop idols sing and dance, Stability is a needed skill and that usually shows control and breath support. Due to Rosé's stylistic choices, she often has shallow breath support that leads her to become pitchy and out of breath. You can notice that the most in On The Ground. She seems to always be gasping for air when using her lower register and struggles to hit the higher notes. Whereas with Jisoo and Jennie, because they don't force themselves to sing a different way, they sound much more stable when singing their solos.
@@r-recordbreaker947 it's not because of loud backtracks. Jisoo's solo is incredibly difficult to sing for her vocal range but because she's not modifying her voice and is focusing all of her breath and air flow into singing and dancing, it comes out much better. Jennie's solos are both comfortable in her register and she overpowers the backtrack, just like Jisoo. Jennie also doesn't modify her voice which is why it sounds so easy when she sings her solo. Rosé's solo should sit comfortably within her voice but because of her style of singing, she struggles to hit the notes. Instead of focusing her air flow into an even Distribution of breath support and oxygen for her muscles, she's focusing on narrowing her airways so that a squeakier, more high pitched voices comes out. This makes her breath support extremely shallow and she ends up doing the same thing as TWICE Mina - going nasal and off-pitch.
We know that Rosè is not the best singer on the planet. I'm an Adele's fan. I don't need to be a musician or a vocal coach to acknowledge that Rosè isn't technically perfect. On the other hand she sings with her soul and many many people find her singing soothing . I personally love love love her voice.
To be honest, Rose stylistic choices as a vocalist don’t really appeal to me, but I came away from this video with a much greater appreciation of her talent. ☺️☺️
I think for me, her voice is wonderful and she has a beautiful tone, but I don’t know how to describe it. I don’t think she is improving or moving forward, and the situation has become boring and it does not attract me to listen to her new songs. I think she has a certain style and does not depart from it . I think she didn't have a chance to improve and they don't even release many songs, and I see this problem with all the members.
Rosie is one of my favorite singers and you pointed out why in the last part. The way she puts emotion in her voice moves me so much. When I started listening to BP I always instantly recognized her voice as opposed to other members. She has a very unique voice and it is very raw in terms of sound. She can make herself sound overjoyed or like she's about to cry in a flash because of how she sounds singing. I do agree there's better and more refined singers, but she will always be my favorite vocalist in K-pop.
Shes got undeniable talent and some solo/acoustic performances of hers are really lovely but for the most part, that shakey nasal delivery style she does to escalate or hold a note often bothers me. Sounds like a little lamb. I would love to see her explore her voice and solo music further. She has good potential.
Been obsessed with your videos after I found your channel! As someone who love kpop and wants to learn more about music and become better at singing myself these are awesome! Thank you so much! ❤
I really appreciate an honest and well considered opinion, it so hard to find in K-pop fandom these days. personally I think its more to do with the fact that her vocal style does not particularly match the style of songs that are so prevalent in K-pop. Her style and diction-with what I would refer to as lazy vowels-have a definite australian twang/affect to them. To me there are elements that are reminisent of indie pop/acoutstic artists that became popular in Australia in the 1990s such Missy Higgins, Sarah Blasko, Ben Lee, and Kate Miller-Heidke (when she would have been growing up here). It's also a vocal style that still seems really prevalent in a lot of indie rock pop music circles in Australia even now. To me as an Australian its a familiar sound so I'm not overly bothered by it or wowed> I will say though because its a style that I associated more with acoustic and stripped back songs I like her more and her voice shines more when she sings those styles. I can see however why it could be a bit polarising for a lot of people in k-pop though.
You are THE channel I come to for vocal analysis and when I saw you were doing a deep dive into Rosé’s voice I was so excited. As usual, you did not disappoint! Thank you once again!
She is such a sweet girl and she has good vocals but yg should've invested more in fully developing her vocals to top tier. She should've debuted with SM entertainment.
In this comment section I'm gonna be praising Rose as an imperfect yet brave human being, a woman who works hard to be in her place right now as a K-Pop Idol. Biased? Sure, because I love her. And the truth is, as a fan of Rose and Blackpink, being in love to them especially Rose for 7 years made me realize that my love is blind. I love everything about them, including their imperfection. One thing that I'm sure of, with their kind heart, even after their job is done being an idol, if they decide to be a youtuber later, they're gonna take a different path from people who take advantage of their name into contents for youtube. In this world, good or bad is only a matter of perspective - not a way to judge others. I love the imperfect Rose and Blackpink. Period. Goodbye. See you in hell.
I like her voice, it is polarizing which is not everyone's cup of tea... But I personally really like it. Her head voice sounds beautiful by the way! She has really nice tone in general. I hope she'll develop healthy technique. I think she really could be up there with some of the greatest vocalists. Because not everyone naturally has beautiful tone. But Rosé does imo.
Rosé is my bias wrecker she has a high, soothing, and breathy voice. Rosè isn't a Korean version of any female pop stars she's her own star. I never thought I can watch a unbiased video and I love it. There are other vocalists who are high voices: Ningning from Aespa, Sua from Pixy, Sieun from StayC, and Songsun from Tri•be.
i think having unique style is very important as an artist.. like billie could for sure belt and sing in a more open voice but its her artistic choice to use her voice the way that she does. i think roses voice is so unique and expressive and of course i hope for her to keep improving as a vocalist, but i think she should stay true to her artistic instincts on how she prefers to use her voice. i know nothing about singing so this is just how i feel as a fan
It's good when she gets enough air when she sings; Especially considering that she tends to have a nasal voice. Belting refers to using proper opera-training-belt breathing. She does not use classical/pure vowels because she sings with her Australian accent.
ain't no way u said rosé has the same development in mix as winter😭 winter Bb4/B4 r much bolder and fuller . not shallow like rosé u need to be srs any trainned ear can tell this
@@petucals rose is not even near to be consistent with Bb4, she had good moments but shes messy and still not fuller there like someone like sullyoon that actually has Bb4 in her consistent range cuz she has time without mess up a Bb4
thats what i said, he really doesnt like aespa girls cuz we just need to hear winters A4(in her confetti cover), Bb4(in girls before the dance break) and her B4 IN SPICY CHORUS to know roses mix-belts are not near to winter and the way he implicate that sullyoon has better mix-belts than winter when winter is clearly better 😭
I think the golden voice pertains to the stylish quality of epse voice. Technically, she isn't the best vocalist in kpop, however, she can perform and sing w/ low, middle, high note songs, albeit her range isn't that great like wendy, strong like ailee or jihyo. Gold is timeless, classic. Rose herself isnt the best vocalist but w / her vocal color & quality , she can actually sing different type of songs. If she can be trained more or if taught more effective & safe techniques to utilize the full potential of her vocal abilities, she can actually be better than other main vocalist. At the end of the day it's all abt preference. Some may hate her voice even if she had mastered the best techniques already, while some will still love her voice as it is.
Hi. I love how you support what you say about Ros€'s voice with actual recordings of her singing live. I think that is very important. Okay. To preface this next part, I am not a vocal teacher. On the other hand, I have had some vocal lessons, s... I feel like I can talk about this. By listening to the recordings, I have to agree with you on Ros€'s lower register. I can hear that the lower she gets, her voice tends to become softer and, how do I say this, fade away. Yeah... I can hear what you mean about Ros€'s belting. I do like Ros€'s voice. (On a separate note, I can distinguish her and Jisoo's voices.) Yet, I still think she can improve with the right vocal teacher and techniques. Again, I would like to say that I have been a vocal student, but not a vocal teacher.
Rose is a very peculiar case in the Kpop space, bc I have other singers in mind with similar traits to hers, but they are not that overhyped and overhated at the same time and the reason is the popularity of BP and how over the top the fandom is. Rose has passion and natural talent for music and that is something no one can deny, but truth be told she doesn't get the proper training and opportunities to improve. That being said, her color and style can sound annoying and not being liked by many people and I am one of them. I have a beef with the indie girl vocals not only with her but with many other singers. Also, I do not specifically enjoy the very high-pitched voices that K-pop loves. Winter for example is a more than decent singer, but her voice is 100% not for me, the same goes for Rose, her voice and my ears just don't work well together.
" rosé's vocals is blatantly overhyped by the fandom.. for less impressive things" Someone said it. Tho i think the golden voice is because of her vocal color but it does sound silly. I mean vocal color isn't everything in singing.
Golden Voice is a title given to her by the korean media, not blinks. the same way they call IU Nation's Little Sister. ofc its not something too serious, the "Golden Voice" is more bc of her emotional singing style, and korea likes that.
@@cWjkL8ysxOkrH66korea actually dont claim that title i believe fans ran with it and kinda pushed it down? I feel like korea likes singers like IU and Ailee. Dont @ me, rosie is my bias in bp
I think you hit it on the head! I’ve always thought she sounded lovely but there was always something that bothered me and you helped me put it into words: her stylistic choices tend to break up the vocal line of the melody. This lets us get something beautiful from her voice but not the most that we could get from the song.
As a fellow blink I loved to hear an objective take on her vocal skill! As a paramore fan I would love to her your opinions on Hayley Williams vocal skill. I have heard people go so far as to compare her to Mariah Carey but I wanted to know your opinions on her!
Her golden voice title would've made sense if blinks were just referring to her vocal color. Imagine saying she's a better vocalist than Wendy just because she's the "Golden Voice of Korea" 💀
4 months later but now that the pinks only renewed with YG for the GROUP activity , I think we could def see Rosé's real potential because she could finally manager her solo career !!
True, like i get that it isn't the standard most people want but she has that musician in her. She has room for improvement like anyone else, but people use their popularity to be harsh on her and like to downplay her ability to do things...like i get calling and using words as "weak, inconsistent, etc." But then people go out their way to say generic and she isn't capable of being a good singer..
I'm gonna add on to this because someones gonna magically become dyslexic and illiterate and say that constructive criticism isn't being harsh or seemingly downgrading, but thats not my point...people use certain phrases that comes off as some type of targeting towards her ability...it comes off as aggressive in a way. Analysisi isn't what i'm getting at
Sorry but how do you acknowledge Rosé's issues when belting, Sullyoon being better than her, but then saying she's similar to winter? Winter does better than both of them up to C5 contently... She does in fact sound light up there (assuming that's your reasoning for it) is because Winter is a high soprano... I agree that Sullyoon might do the best of them in the 5th octave overall but hey none of them have development up there to it being a factor (at least to me) I would like if you could elaborate on your reasoning for this please, so I could perhaps understand your reasoning, thank you
He underestimate aespa girls always and he has beef with aespa fans so that’s probably why he said that Cuz anyone that hear winter in her 4th octave knows she has a lot of quality, and there is enough live material to compare them and know winter mix-belt is better than sullyoon and rosé
@@Oliver-uz1fs Sullyoon is a child she barely surpasses haram from babymonster comparing her to rose is extremely delusional as a vocal coach and vocal student in a performing arts university rose has far better technique, tone, pitch control etc also support and vocal tiers barely mean shit
ROSEANNE VOICE IS JUST AN EMOTION IDK IF IT'S SCIENCE OR GOD GIFTED ABILITY BUT SHE CAN LITERALLY PRODUCE A PERFECT VOCAL TONE OR APT TONE ACCORDING TO THE LYRICS AND FEEL OF THE SONG ! ANYONE WHO THINKS ROSÉ AS UNDESERVING OF THIS TITLE KINDLY CHECK HER YT COVERS ( LIVE) ITS INSANELY GOOD ! GOOSEBUMPS ALERT
Because half of her 'vocal' performances on the born pink tour were lipped. She didn't sing she just put the mic to her mouth and mouthed the words. The MR removed shows that. The other half has her singing very poorly. That's why he didn't use it.
Hello, I really liked your videos. Can you make a vocal analysis of Morisette Amon and Stell Ajero? They're really great singers and they're from the beautiful land of Philippines. Hope you'll notice my request. Thank you!
I a blink but i am really unbiased about this aspect that she might not be the best vocalist but she is the best unique vocalist she is... I have been through a lot but her tone is really that obvious one...
I think only time u can hear Roses Natural voice in song named Without You by Gdragon she features in that song and i think that its her natural voice in there
Honestly, I don't like Blackpink music at all... But I would consider Rosé a similar singer than Halsey, as someone who prioritizes style over technique and has a bright, femenine, recognizable timber. She's an adecuate pop singer: not terrible, not great as a vocalist. She seems like a sweet girl and has a good girl vibe, her energy is pleasant and elegant. Her stage presence is not impressive though, for a kpop idol, I think she could improve both as as singer and as a performer.
This is a great analysis of Rosé's vocal abilities. Personally I feel her vocals shine more when she sings covers of songs she obviously loves, and that she's comfortable to sing to, and this is where I believe her pronounciation is able to come to the fore and be heard more clearly. A lot of people often comment that Rosé's pronounciation is unique, and indeed it would be to most, but to me her pronounciation is not too disimilar to an Australian artist called Sarah Blasko. The majority of Sarah Blasko's music is probably more suited to Rosé's vocal style, and as with Rosé, Sarah Blasko is not by any means an accomplished vocalist, but she does have a great voice, as does Rosé.
I don't think people understand that Golden Voice OF KOREA isn't about her vocal technique, but about the emotion when she sings. People often forget that music is about emotion, not technique. No matter how good your vocal technique, no matter how high or low your notes, they don't work if there's no emotion. Because at its core, music is about freedom of expression (message, story).
I'm Sorry but calling Rosé golden voice of Korea is a little bit funny when Taeyeon, Ailee, Luna and better vocalists than her exist(I like Rosé but her stylistics choices bugs me sometimes)
Luna aillee are only good at high notes they have no impressive vocal tone when it comes to songs with soft voice maybe taeyeon deserves to be a golden voice too but Rosie deserves it more than ailee Luna jihyo…. She has angelic vocal tone that she uses mostly and she doesn’t need to reach high notes just to be a golden voice
Also for ex chan has unlistenable tone while barkhyun and d.o are much better and soft but fans decided to give him the name of ‘Korea’s voice ‘ while he is not , just because he has strong and high pitched voice
@@MynnyDelmalyanibut do you really think someone with a soft voice should be the ‘golden’ voice? For me golden is someone with a powerful and strong voice but that’s just me
i really wish idols were given more chances for vocal improvemnt because its so sad when you see idols with serious talewnt and potential have it go to waste bc their not given the proper training
We all agree,rosie is not the best vocalist,she just 'average'. but we all agree to she's a good vocalist and have unique vocal which is no one vocalist have it.
me personally i agree with the soft part. rose voice to me is sensitive and i feel like if she tries to sing out of her comfort zone shes gonna ruin her vocals. i saw this thread on twitter saying she has a soulful voice but i disagree, rose has a emotional yet soft voice. and theres nothing wrong with that. i think the fans try to hard to prove points but dont know alot about vocals , sometimes their the reason alot of singers loose their ability to sing
What I find sad is that Rosé would do better in America than in Asia, because all the producers, coaches and musicians praise her voice. As a result, she would have the best vocal coaches and great improvements on her voice. She's always being compared to Avril Lavigne or Taylor Swift.
She needs an actual vocal trainer like Solji from EXID. Her voice can get so out of tune, pitchy and screechy in the style she sings, YGE has never known to treat vocals but the main problem is BP songs don't suit her at all, it only brings out the negative qualities in her voice [which is how I feel with Aespa's Winter and g-idles Miyeon] they suit lower songs not any kind of belting. Like she has potential to be a good vocalist but not under YGE.
When I listened to kpop again back in 2018, people are always hyping about blackpink and that the golden voice of korea was Rosé, it got me thinking "Oh Korea isn't really that vocally gifted nor they can shine against other countries when it comes to singing". But men I was wrong when I heard the voices of other Korean singers! SOHYANG, WENDY, TAEYEON, AILEE, HYOLYN, MAMAMOO, EUNJI, IU.
The problem is you used little of actual BP discography, give her another kind of music and songs and she might shine more as vocalist. I think that is why people does not likeher as singer.
I think the best way to expain Rose's voice is raw talent. She did not train much compared to a alot of other idols but she loves music, and was born w a unique voice. She is not a power vocalist and she is not the "best" out there but she is very unique and that in my opinion is all that matters. I personally love her voice.
same she has that timbre that i just love🫶🏻
Her voice isn’t my favorite but it breaks my heart that she never received the vocal coaching she deserves and her agency never taken her talent seriously, you can see her passion and willing to improve very clearly 😢❤ also she has a sweet genuine personality that attract people to her..
she has tons of money and she can do it if she wants to
@@sohappyilltryand she has been improving, she did a supported c5 in the last show of the born pink tour.
@@sohappyilltryThat’s not how it works in kpop industry lmao
@@sohappyilltryomg you're so genius, omg is the most stupid thing i ever heard in my life
@@uglycow6204oh Fr that’s really good
Wow it was a very unbiased analysis probably one of the best I've seen on Rosé, she has potential and I want to see her utilize it. I love Rosé her voice is so smoothing to me 😊
Glad you enjoyed it!😊
@@aintnootherfan I enjoy all your videos they are always interesting
Yeah i love rosé I just hope she can improve more cause I know she is really passionate about her music
@@aintnootherfanRose sang the iland 2 song
The thing that steps her aside from other vocalist in the kpop scene is the fact that she can pour emotion into her voice and fr she has a gifted voice . Kpop has plenty of vocalist that can hit high notes (not discrediting them) but you need something that can make you stand out of the crowd
Rosé is my favorite singer ever. She's not the best singer when it comes to her singing technique but the beautiful color of her voice and the way she delivers songs so emotionally, that's enough to be the best for me.
She doesn't just sing with her mouth but from her heart, that's why she's the best for me. Let's support her Guys🤍🤍
I feel like Rose hasn't developed her true potential due to Blackpink's songs, wich are more rap focused
But I'm glad she debuted as a soloist, I think since then we got to see more of her vocals, plus you can see the passion she has for music, I think that's the reason she's my bias too ❤️
I'd even go so far as to say that she's wasting her vocal potential by staying within a specific vocal range so that Rosé doesn't shine too brightly vocally.
I would probably go further & say that it's not just due to BP's songs but also potentially due to the K-pop in general. While K-pop does have some unique voices I don't think that the industry really knows how [or wants] to deal with them to get the best out of them because it would deviate too far from a standard group formula. It seems the industry want to try to embrace them to add a certain vocal interest to a group but then the producers, writers, arrangers just give the standard K-pop songs arranged to meet a formulaic mould of how groups should be and sound. I mean how often do you hear low female voices featured or hear songs written in a way that optimise a voice such as Rose’s in K-pop in general. Rarely. It’s not just a BP, YG thing, it’s a K-pop idol industry.
@@katwat8682 For me, there's also a culture shock: Rosé isn't Korean, she's Australian, so she's not really suited to Kpop culture. She said herself in a Vogue Australia interview that she considered herself an outsider.
@@erickacornu774 it may well be but i guess for me its more that I look at it as a musical culture shock-as I said in a seperate comment as an Australian I feel her style has a very familiar sound reminisent of indie pop/acoustic culture that has been pretty prevalent in Australia. And yes for me her voice shines the most in the songs that song least like k-pop
@@erickacornu774 Dual citizenship, Korean/New Zealander*
Her voice is about the style and vibe. Her tone and delivery is very unique and special. She isn't an Ailee but iconic in her own right.
I agree
as if she has the only unique voices in kpop her skills is weaker than subvocalist yuqi sorry not sorry
@@sohappyilltry weaker than Yuqi? Lol
she is nowhere near ailee, so weird to compare them. ailee is levels more iconic than rose.
@@ryvulet8639do you lack comprehension skills?
I watched Rosè on Sea of Hope and I do agree that she has a very beautiful voice for Acoustic singing, she has been carrying the Tour vocally this era.
Also I don’t know if you Listen to IU she’s also vocally acclaimed so I wonder if we’ll ever get a video on her. I feel like I can’t find one anywhere.
The sad thing is that we will probably never see Rose's full potential while she's in YG. That agency's priority is rap and they forced Rose to changed her voice (there are demos pre debut which her voice is deeper). It's a shame, because she has everything to be an amazing vocalist.
Change her voice 💀 she just using higher register now, she has wide range you know. The only problem is her style.
her voice didnt change, singing in a lower register doesn’t mean her voice is suddenly different
rosie is my favorite vocalist to listen to in acoustic settings and i also personally think she has one of the most magical tones in pop music, regardless of her level of technical skill
I love nuanced videos like this that offer actual constructive criticism!
I feel like for Rosé’s case she adopted a style first before mastering technique. With the needed improvement, I’m pretty sure she can reach her fullest potential while also maintaining her signature style.
I'm not the biggest fan of Rosé's voice, but i love to see her singing acoustic songs.. i feel like fits her the most and does really looks like she enjoy that
She really shines there!!😁
rosé has a lot of potential, she also improved a lot in this tour and era
This tour made me love her voice more
@@wandeesthoughtsyes!! she sounds way fuller and has more depth
@@petucalsyeah and better belts
And less nasal than ever
she has a really nice voice that like a lot of comments have said, sounds fantastic in an acoustic setting with her and her guitar. That's why I think her talent is wasted on debuting her in a rap heavy group like BLACKPINK, where her real vocal talented is normally just used like Miyeon from GIDLE, as fillers hear and there. Of course they have had great usage for her voice in their songs, but the whole concept of BLACKPINK, doesn't exactly accommodate her voice well in my opinion. I think there is way too many idols getting out in groups that aren't meant for them, and they get doubled down to a prechorus singing Main vocalist
One of my favorite voices in Kpop since ever, I think her tone and style is really unique and u can really tell is HÉR when u listen her voice, its kinda unique to me, the technique can be definitely better but since she was trained in YG that part is def not her best, I really like the fact that she's improving a lot in her general singing abilities I can definitely see her passion towards music and as a singer. I hope she leaves YG so she can explore her vocal potential asap. Great video btw.
Wow she reminds me a lot of Avril Lavigne’s and Dia Frampton’s style of singing. Rosé’s voice is more grating though & not as heavy in weight. Her vocal choices (decided for her or not) don’t bring out the best in her voice. The cursive singing along with too much nasality is much too sensual. It’s too “obvious” with the slight yodel endings too. It would be nice if she cleaned up her voice more without so many ornamentations. Her voice itself is sugary sweet already enough.
There are many excellent singers in K-pop but I always value a unique style and emotional expression over technical perfection. Rose’ is one of my favourites.
I wish yg believed in proper vocal training because she has/had so much potential and has such a unique and interesting vocal color and tone.
I would actually consider Rosie as a singer not a typical vocalist as she has passion for music she is really serious when it comes about music. She can play many instruments as well like guitar,piano etc Its really rare to have a main vocalist in a group who is multi talented who can dance well sing well play instruments write and produce lyrics and show passion to the music. I''ve only seen Rosie who has all of it she is the only one who wrote her own solos and many songs too like u never know some lyrics were produced by her while some by jennie. Lemme tell u one thing vocal isnt all about high notes and vocal tiers it can be seen through a vocalist's eyes and voice what type of vocalist they're. I mean there must've been a reason rosie has the title golden voice of korea its not becz she is the main vocalist it because she knows very well how to use her voice even though she had a deep voice and her high notes are relly good she had to change her ovice becz of the company but now she seems to be comfortable with her changed voice and its really difficult to sing in changed voice. So Rosie is my fav singer in kpop. I'm not a blink or anything im a multistan and i know many groups and many vocalists especially wendy,ning ning winter and all sm town main vocalist they had been trained for years about vocals they were given training and about notes but rosie just got selected and she became a idol becz of the decision made by her dad as she sang all night which disturbed him. All those main vocalists have some similar voice and rosie has the most unique among all as it is recognible and it is angelic.
damn you’re only at 50k ? you’re really one of my favorite analysis channels
She’s a great pop singer for sure
Love ❤️ this video
Rosè has a very special voice amongst powerhouses - what makes her stand out is her folksy, singer-songwriter style of singing amongst more gutsy vocalists.
Do I think she is the best vocalist⁉️ NO
But she does manages to stand out with her recognizable ornamented instrument ‼️‼️
Maybe not the Golden Voice of Korea (that will be Wendy maybe) but more like the ROSE 🌹 of Korea 😉
Especially how her voice sounds like she carefully Is plucking notes - it’s beautiful
It’s a careful gift, very delicate ….
the thing is korean general public is the ones who named rosie as the golden voice of korea, not even blinks that's why i think international fans should step back and let it slide that title for rosie
I think the general Korean public names IU as the Golden Voice of Korea.
I wanted to start this comment off by saying this analysis was beautiful. I wanted to add something to this:
As KPop idols sing and dance, Stability is a needed skill and that usually shows control and breath support. Due to Rosé's stylistic choices, she often has shallow breath support that leads her to become pitchy and out of breath. You can notice that the most in On The Ground. She seems to always be gasping for air when using her lower register and struggles to hit the higher notes. Whereas with Jisoo and Jennie, because they don't force themselves to sing a different way, they sound much more stable when singing their solos.
It because you hear their loud backtrack while rosé is is louder than the backtrcak. And yeah sometimes she use her deep voice live.
@@r-recordbreaker947 it's not because of loud backtracks.
Jisoo's solo is incredibly difficult to sing for her vocal range but because she's not modifying her voice and is focusing all of her breath and air flow into singing and dancing, it comes out much better.
Jennie's solos are both comfortable in her register and she overpowers the backtrack, just like Jisoo. Jennie also doesn't modify her voice which is why it sounds so easy when she sings her solo.
Rosé's solo should sit comfortably within her voice but because of her style of singing, she struggles to hit the notes. Instead of focusing her air flow into an even Distribution of breath support and oxygen for her muscles, she's focusing on narrowing her airways so that a squeakier, more high pitched voices comes out. This makes her breath support extremely shallow and she ends up doing the same thing as TWICE Mina - going nasal and off-pitch.
We know that Rosè is not the best singer on the planet. I'm an Adele's fan. I don't need to be a musician or a vocal coach to acknowledge that Rosè isn't technically perfect. On the other hand she sings with her soul and many many people find her singing soothing . I personally love love love her voice.
With better coaching she’s without a doubt can be one of the best vocalist
To be honest, Rose stylistic choices as a vocalist don’t really appeal to me, but I came away from this video with a much greater appreciation of her talent. ☺️☺️
I love her voice so much. She is my bias. She is the one for me because of her angelic tone.
I think for me, her voice is wonderful and she has a beautiful tone, but I don’t know how to describe it. I don’t think she is improving or moving forward, and the situation has become boring and it does not attract me to listen to her new songs. I think she has a certain style and does not depart from it .
I think she didn't have a chance to improve and they don't even release many songs, and I see this problem with all the members.
Rosie is one of my favorite singers and you pointed out why in the last part. The way she puts emotion in her voice moves me so much. When I started listening to BP I always instantly recognized her voice as opposed to other members. She has a very unique voice and it is very raw in terms of sound. She can make herself sound overjoyed or like she's about to cry in a flash because of how she sounds singing. I do agree there's better and more refined singers, but she will always be my favorite vocalist in K-pop.
her voice is very distinct... I love it. Her tone is very attention demanding I understand why some people don't like it or thinks it's too much.
Shes got undeniable talent and some solo/acoustic performances of hers are really lovely but for the most part, that shakey nasal delivery style she does to escalate or hold a note often bothers me. Sounds like a little lamb. I would love to see her explore her voice and solo music further. She has good potential.
Been obsessed with your videos after I found your channel! As someone who love kpop and wants to learn more about music and become better at singing myself these are awesome! Thank you so much! ❤
Honestly, I would like to see this kind of deep dive for Jungkook too, I’m not a professional singer so I would like to hear some pro’s opinion
I really appreciate an honest and well considered opinion, it so hard to find in K-pop fandom these days. personally I think its more to do with the fact that her vocal style does not particularly match the style of songs that are so prevalent in K-pop. Her style and diction-with what I would refer to as lazy vowels-have a definite australian twang/affect to them. To me there are elements that are reminisent of indie pop/acoutstic artists that became popular in Australia in the 1990s such Missy Higgins, Sarah Blasko, Ben Lee, and Kate Miller-Heidke (when she would have been growing up here). It's also a vocal style that still seems really prevalent in a lot of indie rock pop music circles in Australia even now. To me as an Australian its a familiar sound so I'm not overly bothered by it or wowed> I will say though because its a style that I associated more with acoustic and stripped back songs I like her more and her voice shines more when she sings those styles. I can see however why it could be a bit polarising for a lot of people in k-pop though.
You are THE channel I come to for vocal analysis and when I saw you were doing a deep dive into Rosé’s voice I was so excited. As usual, you did not disappoint! Thank you once again!
She is such a sweet girl and she has good vocals but yg should've invested more in fully developing her vocals to top tier. She should've debuted with SM entertainment.
Amazing analysis! Thank you for this video, I really love videos like this
In this comment section I'm gonna be praising Rose as an imperfect yet brave human being, a woman who works hard to be in her place right now as a K-Pop Idol. Biased? Sure, because I love her. And the truth is, as a fan of Rose and Blackpink, being in love to them especially Rose for 7 years made me realize that my love is blind. I love everything about them, including their imperfection. One thing that I'm sure of, with their kind heart, even after their job is done being an idol, if they decide to be a youtuber later, they're gonna take a different path from people who take advantage of their name into contents for youtube. In this world, good or bad is only a matter of perspective - not a way to judge others. I love the imperfect Rose and Blackpink. Period. Goodbye. See you in hell.
I like her voice, it is polarizing which is not everyone's cup of tea... But I personally really like it. Her head voice sounds beautiful by the way! She has really nice tone in general. I hope she'll develop healthy technique. I think she really could be up there with some of the greatest vocalists. Because not everyone naturally has beautiful tone. But Rosé does imo.
Rosé is my bias wrecker she has a high, soothing, and breathy voice. Rosè isn't a Korean version of any female pop stars she's her own star. I never thought I can watch a unbiased video and I love it. There are other vocalists who are high voices: Ningning from Aespa, Sua from Pixy, Sieun from StayC, and Songsun from Tri•be.
i think having unique style is very important as an artist.. like billie could for sure belt and sing in a more open voice but its her artistic choice to use her voice the way that she does. i think roses voice is so unique and expressive and of course i hope for her to keep improving as a vocalist, but i think she should stay true to her artistic instincts on how she prefers to use her voice. i know nothing about singing so this is just how i feel as a fan
It's good when she gets enough air when she sings; Especially considering that she tends to have a nasal voice. Belting refers to using proper opera-training-belt breathing. She does not use classical/pure vowels because she sings with her Australian accent.
ain't no way u said rosé has the same development in mix as winter😭 winter Bb4/B4 r much bolder and fuller . not shallow like rosé u need to be srs any trainned ear can tell this
Biased and kind of shady to others i guess
i mean winter does have a better mix but rosé is Bb4(B4)
@@petucals rose is not even near to be consistent with Bb4, she had good moments but shes messy and still not fuller there like someone like sullyoon that actually has Bb4 in her consistent range cuz she has time without mess up a Bb4
thats what i said, he really doesnt like aespa girls cuz we just need to hear winters A4(in her confetti cover), Bb4(in girls before the dance break) and her B4 IN SPICY CHORUS to know roses mix-belts are not near to winter
and the way he implicate that sullyoon has better mix-belts than winter when winter is clearly better 😭
@@afeliz2642 she is consistent, literally 1/10 Bb4s of her are unsupported
I think the golden voice pertains to the stylish quality of epse voice. Technically, she isn't the best vocalist in kpop, however, she can perform and sing w/ low, middle, high note songs, albeit her range isn't that great like wendy, strong like ailee or jihyo. Gold is timeless, classic. Rose herself isnt the best vocalist but w / her vocal color & quality , she can actually sing different type of songs. If she can be trained more or if taught more effective & safe techniques to utilize the full potential of her vocal abilities, she can actually be better than other main vocalist. At the end of the day it's all abt preference. Some may hate her voice even if she had mastered the best techniques already, while some will still love her voice as it is.
Hi. I love how you support what you say about Ros€'s voice with actual recordings of her singing live. I think that is very important.
Okay. To preface this next part, I am not a vocal teacher. On the other hand, I have had some vocal lessons, s... I feel like I can talk about this.
By listening to the recordings, I have to agree with you on Ros€'s lower register. I can hear that the lower she gets, her voice tends to become softer and, how do I say this, fade away.
Yeah... I can hear what you mean about Ros€'s belting.
I do like Ros€'s voice. (On a separate note, I can distinguish her and Jisoo's voices.) Yet, I still think she can improve with the right vocal teacher and techniques.
Again, I would like to say that I have been a vocal student, but not a vocal teacher.
Congrats on 50K 😭 remember us when you hit 1 million
i read the title as "roses voice aint deep" idk why
I read " ROSÉ deep vocals" hahahaha
Rose is a very peculiar case in the Kpop space, bc I have other singers in mind with similar traits to hers, but they are not that overhyped and overhated at the same time and the reason is the popularity of BP and how over the top the fandom is.
Rose has passion and natural talent for music and that is something no one can deny, but truth be told she doesn't get the proper training and opportunities to improve.
That being said, her color and style can sound annoying and not being liked by many people and I am one of them. I have a beef with the indie girl vocals not only with her but with many other singers. Also, I do not specifically enjoy the very high-pitched voices that K-pop loves. Winter for example is a more than decent singer, but her voice is 100% not for me, the same goes for Rose, her voice and my ears just don't work well together.
" rosé's vocals is blatantly overhyped by the fandom.. for less impressive things"
Someone said it. Tho i think the golden voice is because of her vocal color but it does sound silly. I mean vocal color isn't everything in singing.
Golden Voice is a title given to her by the korean media, not blinks. the same way they call IU Nation's Little Sister. ofc its not something too serious, the "Golden Voice" is more bc of her emotional singing style, and korea likes that.
@@cWjkL8ysxOkrH66korea actually dont claim that title i believe fans ran with it and kinda pushed it down? I feel like korea likes singers like IU and Ailee. Dont @ me, rosie is my bias in bp
She’s great
I think you hit it on the head! I’ve always thought she sounded lovely but there was always something that bothered me and you helped me put it into words: her stylistic choices tend to break up the vocal line of the melody. This lets us get something beautiful from her voice but not the most that we could get from the song.
I would like to genuinely ask if wouldn't Rosé's vibrato count as tremolo since its quick? I'd be more than happy to be enlightened with this
I also think Rosé's vibrato is like tremolo
As a fellow blink I loved to hear an objective take on her vocal skill!
As a paramore fan I would love to her your opinions on Hayley Williams vocal skill.
I have heard people go so far as to compare her to Mariah Carey but I wanted to know your opinions on her!
can you talk about yunjin from le sserafim? there isn't much content about her but I find her voice interesting
Her golden voice title would've made sense if blinks were just referring to her vocal color. Imagine saying she's a better vocalist than Wendy just because she's the "Golden Voice of Korea" 💀
4 months later but now that the pinks only renewed with YG for the GROUP activity , I think we could def see Rosé's real potential because she could finally manager her solo career !!
No matter how you feel about Rosé's voice you can't deny that she's a talented songstress
True, like i get that it isn't the standard most people want but she has that musician in her. She has room for improvement like anyone else, but people use their popularity to be harsh on her and like to downplay her ability to do things...like i get calling and using words as "weak, inconsistent, etc." But then people go out their way to say generic and she isn't capable of being a good singer..
I'm gonna add on to this because someones gonna magically become dyslexic and illiterate and say that constructive criticism isn't being harsh or seemingly downgrading, but thats not my point...people use certain phrases that comes off as some type of targeting towards her ability...it comes off as aggressive in a way. Analysisi isn't what i'm getting at
@@youmakemespeak3t Exactly! Maybe when she's a full time soloist they'll realize how good she is
Sorry but how do you acknowledge Rosé's issues when belting, Sullyoon being better than her, but then saying she's similar to winter?
Winter does better than both of them up to C5 contently... She does in fact sound light up there (assuming that's your reasoning for it) is because Winter is a high soprano... I agree that Sullyoon might do the best of them in the 5th octave overall but hey none of them have development up there to it being a factor (at least to me) I would like if you could elaborate on your reasoning for this please, so I could perhaps understand your reasoning, thank you
He underestimate aespa girls always and he has beef with aespa fans so that’s probably why he said that
Cuz anyone that hear winter in her 4th octave knows she has a lot of quality, and there is enough live material to compare them and know winter mix-belt is better than sullyoon and rosé
Even though this channel is somewhat inaccurate you are extremely delusional as rose could easily beat sullyoon definitely and the aespa girls
@@Multistanofkpop888 Rosé isn't out singing Sully or the Aespa girls sorry, the delusional is another
@@Oliver-uz1fs Sullyoon is a child she barely surpasses haram from babymonster comparing her to rose is extremely delusional as a vocal coach and vocal student in a performing arts university rose has far better technique, tone, pitch control etc also support and vocal tiers barely mean shit
@@Oliver-uz1fs she could barely surpass Jennie
No, that'd be Lee Sun-hee! Joking of course as there's no claims on terms like that. You should really listen to her though.
Random question, would you consider Mariah Carey to be an average to good vocalist
this analysis kinda wasn’t needed because it’s obvious she isn’t a vocalist
she’s just a singer
Her style reminds me of the vocalists of 2ne1, the girl group of YG that debuted in 2009.
I wish all Blackpink had that SM vocal training they have so much potential
❤❤❤
ROSEANNE VOICE IS JUST AN EMOTION IDK IF IT'S SCIENCE OR GOD GIFTED ABILITY BUT SHE CAN LITERALLY PRODUCE A PERFECT VOCAL TONE OR APT TONE ACCORDING TO THE LYRICS AND FEEL OF THE SONG ! ANYONE WHO THINKS ROSÉ AS UNDESERVING OF THIS TITLE KINDLY CHECK HER YT COVERS ( LIVE) ITS INSANELY GOOD ! GOOSEBUMPS ALERT
I don't understand why you rely on old videos and not on new ones? Because it's obvious that she's made huge progress since 2023 = Born Pink TOUR
Because half of her 'vocal' performances on the born pink tour were lipped. She didn't sing she just put the mic to her mouth and mouthed the words. The MR removed shows that. The other half has her singing very poorly. That's why he didn't use it.
Because she wasn’t actually singing.
sometimes i don't really like how she sings but sometimes i can't get enough of her voice so i hope she hires a better vocal trainer
Can you do vocal analysis for each member of SB19..please 🥺
Hello, I really liked your videos.
Can you make a vocal analysis of Morisette Amon and Stell Ajero? They're really great singers and they're from the beautiful land of Philippines. Hope you'll notice my request. Thank you!
I a blink but i am really unbiased about this aspect that she might not be the best vocalist but she is the best unique vocalist she is... I have been through a lot but her tone is really that obvious one...
9:34 just reminded me of the agility series 😩 hopefully one day they’ll be back
I think only time u can hear Roses Natural voice in song named Without You by Gdragon she features in that song and i think that its her natural voice in there
I wonder... Will you ever do a video about IU? I'm surprised I've never seen you mentioning her...
Honestly, I don't like Blackpink music at all... But I would consider Rosé a similar singer than Halsey, as someone who prioritizes style over technique and has a bright, femenine, recognizable timber. She's an adecuate pop singer: not terrible, not great as a vocalist. She seems like a sweet girl and has a good girl vibe, her energy is pleasant and elegant. Her stage presence is not impressive though, for a kpop idol, I think she could improve both as as singer and as a performer.
This is a great analysis of Rosé's vocal abilities. Personally I feel her vocals shine more when she sings covers of songs she obviously loves, and that she's comfortable to sing to, and this is where I believe her pronounciation is able to come to the fore and be heard more clearly.
A lot of people often comment that Rosé's pronounciation is unique, and indeed it would be to most, but to me her pronounciation is not too disimilar to an Australian artist called Sarah Blasko. The majority of Sarah Blasko's music is probably more suited to Rosé's vocal style, and as with Rosé, Sarah Blasko is not by any means an accomplished vocalist, but she does have a great voice, as does Rosé.
I don't think people understand that Golden Voice OF KOREA isn't about her vocal technique, but about the emotion when she sings. People often forget that music is about emotion, not technique. No matter how good your vocal technique, no matter how high or low your notes, they don't work if there's no emotion. Because at its core, music is about freedom of expression (message, story).
I'm Sorry but calling Rosé golden voice of Korea is a little bit funny when Taeyeon, Ailee, Luna and better vocalists than her exist(I like Rosé but her stylistics choices bugs me sometimes)
Luna aillee are only good at high notes they have no impressive vocal tone when it comes to songs with soft voice maybe taeyeon deserves to be a golden voice too but Rosie deserves it more than ailee Luna jihyo…. She has angelic vocal tone that she uses mostly and she doesn’t need to reach high notes just to be a golden voice
Also for ex chan has unlistenable tone while barkhyun and d.o are much better and soft but fans decided to give him the name of ‘Korea’s voice ‘ while he is not , just because he has strong and high pitched voice
@@MynnyDelmalyanibut do you really think someone with a soft voice should be the ‘golden’ voice? For me golden is someone with a powerful and strong voice but that’s just me
@@rank1562 powerful strong just like ‘ taeyeon Wendy ‘ not ailée and Lina obviously
@@rank1562 as u said ‘ for me ‘ so it’s ur opinion And +1000 person can say that she is the golden voice so it’s abt preference not technique
Rose just needs to sit down with steve mackie or cherry the vocal coach
Love your video ❤️
Can plz do a Btob video
i really wish idols were given more chances for vocal improvemnt because its so sad when you see idols with serious talewnt and potential have it go to waste bc their not given the proper training
We all agree,rosie is not the best vocalist,she just 'average'. but we all agree to she's a good vocalist and have unique vocal which is no one vocalist have it.
Can you comment on her final love collab song?? i think she did great there
I love your vids
i have a question what do you think about Exid's Solji vocals? Because i think she is really good but i would like to have you're opinion.
4:27 every cursive singer 😩
Rosé is truly THE GOLDEN VOICE OF KOREA ❤❤❤❤❤
🤡
Hahahahha
Ailee
No...
You had me until you said she isn’t amount the best vocalist. As far as Kpop goes, she definitely is.
can you do babymonster
I even noticed that its missing an R on Theater on the "on the ground " MV
Again comparing her to Winter 😂😂😂
And saying that rosé has similar mix-belt to winter when clearly winter’s quality is a lot of better 😭
Winter 😂 she’s not even top 10 or not even close to jisoo or miyeon comparing her to rose is delusional
She deserve better. She is carrying whole blackpink on he shoulder
What is the video at 6.13 where they sing you never know sirting down? Never saw them with those clothes!! Super curious to see that performance 😊
That song in 6:13 is not You Never Know. It’s Hope Not and that is at one of their concerts during the In Your Area tour.
me personally i agree with the soft part. rose voice to me is sensitive and i feel like if she tries to sing out of her comfort zone shes gonna ruin her vocals. i saw this thread on twitter saying she has a soulful voice but i disagree, rose has a emotional yet soft voice. and theres nothing wrong with that. i think the fans try to hard to prove points but dont know alot about vocals , sometimes their the reason alot of singers loose their ability to sing
6:50 nice C5 tbh, even the others. They even sound fuller than the midbelts you showcased
Such a nice video ! What would you say about Michael Jackson vocally ??
She is the best vocalist.
What I find sad is that Rosé would do better in America than in Asia, because all the producers, coaches and musicians praise her voice. As a result, she would have the best vocal coaches and great improvements on her voice. She's always being compared to Avril Lavigne or Taylor Swift.
She needs an actual vocal trainer like Solji from EXID. Her voice can get so out of tune, pitchy and screechy in the style she sings, YGE has never known to treat vocals but the main problem is BP songs don't suit her at all, it only brings out the negative qualities in her voice [which is how I feel with Aespa's Winter and g-idles Miyeon] they suit lower songs not any kind of belting. Like she has potential to be a good vocalist but not under YGE.
When I listened to kpop again back in 2018, people are always hyping about blackpink and that the golden voice of korea was Rosé, it got me thinking "Oh Korea isn't really that vocally gifted nor they can shine against other countries when it comes to singing". But men I was wrong when I heard the voices of other Korean singers! SOHYANG, WENDY, TAEYEON, AILEE, HYOLYN, MAMAMOO, EUNJI, IU.
The problem is you used little of actual BP discography, give her another kind of music and songs and she might shine more as vocalist. I think that is why people does not likeher as singer.
except the part about where she is among the greatest vocalists in Gpop 2023