A Guide to Everything Banned in China
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- Sorting myth from fact as to what's banned in China
Follow me: / _britmonkey
Patreon: / britmonkey
Merch: crowdmade.com/...
SOURCES: pastebin.com/q...
MUSIC: pastebin.com/Z...
Credit to Hong Kong Express for generously letting me use the songs "Hong Kong 2046" and " 新宿ゴールデン街/Shinjuku Golden Street"
![Yailin La Mas Viral, @kreizyk.official - Dale 2 (Remix) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JaYHBzgqz94/mqdefault.jpg)
When he talks about a VPN and doesn’t Segway into a sponsor.
Kinda surprised me really
Same
Yup
NxxdVPN
mfs getting ptsd or sum?
I know right?
5:19 I thought this was gonna be the start of a VPN ad
Good thing it wasn't
Same
psychologically conditiond kekw
They had us in the first half
Ahah same
God knows every country could do with a ban on NicocadoAvocado
Well, SOMEONE has to replace Chris chan, now that he is in jail.
@@hyperdude144 its official, Nikocado is the new chris chan
@@duckworth9896 nobody can stand where chris stood, he's literally out of this world
@@dump6302 Nobody else can stand on Barbara?
@@hyperdude144 he can still use the internet in jail.
Haha the “grass is always less green on the other side” thing is spot on. That’s the most common way the government conditions their people in east Asia. Even Japan is guilty of it. (lived there for 16 years) I never knew how bad we had it until I moved to the US. Everyone is like “we’re missing out on personal freedoms? oh well, it can’t be as bad as outside of Japan” and no one even dares to do anything about it.
你们到了美国就有成为homeless的自由，有吸毒的自由，有被偷窃和抢劫的自由，有搞不清性别的自由，你的孩子有被枪击的自由，有从两个不能说的团体控制的傀儡中选总统的自由。
"There's no social credit score" +100 social credit score
apparently its only in certain parts, but they plan on making it nationwide. so essentially there is no social credit until they feel like its ready to take it out of testing
There is no war in Ba Sing Se
it is only rolled out in a few 3rd tier cities in china. so majority of chinese citizens are not subject to it yet.
@@nbshftr its kind of rolled out but it’s actually not really possible the way they want it.
@@DomskiPlays just rewatched this so fire
imagine being born on the 4th of June and not being able to tell anyone when your birthday party is
that's bs, you can use the phrase. context is what matters, if you tell someone your birthday is on the 4th of june it's not going to get instantly deleted
@@Fred_the_1996 people forget common sense when it comes to china
That's literally my aunt birthday o.o
I'm actually born that day lol
hey my party is on june 4th, be there or be square!
"When is your birthday?"
"4th of June"
-1000 SOCIAL CREDIT
4th of June 1989 ☠️☠️☠️
:(
What happened on June 17 1972?
Shhhhhhhhhh
Social credit deducted
7:42
I lived in China from 2010 to 2016, lived in Guangzhou for one year, Shanghai for 5, and traveled all over the country. As a foreigner living there, I only felt I was living in an authoritarian state when I used the internet. People in society are out and about, unafraid, dining, partying, having fun, shopping shopping shopping... it's capitalism on steroids. When I tried to talk to Chinese people about the government, they never seemed afraid to talk, it just didn't interest them. They reminded me of American teenagers-- talking about friends, dating, their social media, pop culture, but no interest in politics. I met people who had lived abroad, and while there, they never bothered to learn about the Tiananmen Square Massacre. It's like they didn't want to know because the truth would be ugly. And they are believers in Tibet and Taiwan being a part of China. They tow the line whole-heartedly.
I loved my China experience, but the internet really was a nightmare. Even unblocked websites would take forever to load. I'd have to click "play" on a 10 minute video and wait 30 minutes for it to load so that it would play with only a few interruptions. Every so often, my VPN would stop working. This especially happened during sensitive anniversaries and when there'd be an international summit. I never knew when I'd be able to use fast and uncensored internet. When I'd visit Hong Kong or Taiwan, it was heavenly. It was like... China with fast, uncensored internet. I literally went to Hong Kong once just for a vacation from the firewall.
And yes, WeChat.... it was so weird when I moved back to the USA and WeChat was no longer necessary. That app is EVERYTHING in China. You can't function without it. Digital life in the USA suddenly seemed so complicated, having to use so many apps to do different things, when in China, I only needed one. Americans don't even know what WeChat is. That is still bizarre for me.
Excluding one, witch is me, I do know about WeChat, since I have a bunch of Chinese friends.
I'm an American here in china,( married a Chinese woman )... I live here now .....I've learned to treat and accept the people here for how they act....they're all emotionally undeveloped, they're like 6th graders...and they dont know it because EVERYONE around them has the same teenage like thinking...its AMAZING!!....there are adults here ,but only CHRONOLOGICALLY they're adults....heres an example,....imagine as an Americanadult,say 30 years old, going to a middle school...you interact with the students ,you talk with them,laugh,joke,etc....but at the end of the day you go home to your wife,to talk to your mother,father,brother...and they ask you,how was IT IN MIDDLE SCHOOL...you say to them,,,fine,THEY ARE ALL JUST KIDS.......that's china....a country filled with teenagers....AND THEY'RE NOT EVEN AWARE OF IT!!!!!......... yeah,yeah CHINAS TECHNOLOGY,,,,,who cares,I'm talking about ITS PEOPLE...THE WAY THEY ARE.........
作为一名中国人，我不觉得天安门事件是屠杀。天安门事件更好的形容词是冲突，因为既有军人死亡，也有民众死亡，不是军人单方面无理由的屠杀，但无论什么原因，这仍然是错误的。我相信在不久的将来，天安门事件会像大跃进、文化大革命一样登上历史教科书。你谈到我们相信西藏和台湾是中国的一部分，这不只是相信，这是事实。你想了解真相，只需要花两分钟时间，看历史上中国的领土变化就好。
I’m living in China for 4 years until now, still nothing has changed
Some of us do
Plague Inc. being banned might have been the funniest shit I’ve seen all day 😂
Well since basically ALL Google Play apps are banned in China, not that surprising.
The game suggests you start in China as a tutorial. Being banned there is strangely ironic.
@@cyber_dragon_123 ah yes, china start for the win!
WELL GET READY FOR
N
PERSONALITY
DISAGREE
@@sendersnivy6698 i do't get it, ever mid, -from CHIA
The word “disagree” being a banned word is just so perfect. Like the very concept itself is wrong, which is of course the case.
Genuinely surprised its not banned in the west
Literally 1984
Yeah... That never happened. But it is so comforting for insecure Westerners, watching their own slow decline, to believe that all virtue lies only in the West. So perfect! You really think that Chinese can't disagree on movies, restaurants, vacation plans, clothing, music, cars, who takes out the garbage, TV channels? Hatred makes people stupid.
@@iliashdz9106 Yet another commenter who doesn't know what "literally" means. It is a word to distinguish between literal and figurative speech when there is ambiguity. "i could eat a horse" means you are hungry. "I could literally eat a horse" means you could, in fact, eat an actual horse.
@@stonetrouble5053 It’s kinda true though. This situation truly is 1984.
“phrases like Tank Man and 4th of June are banned”
rip to the one Newgrounds user who was born on June 4th
the fact i get the joke is weird considering newgrounds feels like an age ago
I don't get it ._.
@@APNifty
there’s an animated series on Newgrounds made by JohnnyUtah called Tankmen. there’s also an unidentified man who was nicknamed Tank Man after he stood in front of some tanks in protest after the Tiananmen Square massacre. the massacre also happened on June 4th, which could very well be someone’s date of birth
@@lankyboi2521 ah
China when a child is born on June 4th:
They banned the word disagree. 😂
And they lived happily ever after, never disagreeing on anything.
"China is ranked last place"
Turkmenistan and North Korea: **Laughs in distance**
My country in everything is no data available
To enter into that list you first need to have internet and like 3 or 4 people have internet in north Korea
Whats so bad about Turkmenistain? I've never heard about it
@@usernametaken017 all I know is that their leader eradicated korona in his country by prohibiting people and media to talk about it.
@@jalimhabeikoforsa8189 bas- oh that's terrible
A wise man once said “how strong is this national pride if you have to stop people from joking about it on the internet?”
- Ruben Sim (probably)
@@rand0mguyontheinternet yes indeed, he’s been focusing a little bit more on the situation in China
pride, fear... same thing to communist leaders.
Why tf is ur name oil
@@-01x Maybe he has a thing for lubricants?
Fun fact: Typing "June 4th Tianamen Square massacre" in Chinese in an in game chat causes any Chinese people in the server to be disconnected.
I've heard that before as a joke but I highly doubt it's true
More like fun lie
If the Chinese is live, his live broadcast room will be banned immediately, so the Chinese live streaming platform will mosaic the player ID and chat area to prevent this.
New strat:
false i tried it i didnt get banned
“Now, all of this could be avoided by using a vpn…”
Me: *skips 30 seconds instinctively*
Surprisingly, he was not advertising. I really thought he was going to hit us with 3 minutes of vpn talk.
@@lemonsqueeze5147 yea xD
Same
Same lol
@@lemonsqueeze5147 and it's never a good VPN either
Fun fact: this video is banned in People's Republic of China
Funfact youtube is banned in china
So is the rest of RUclips
@@EXPLISITemcee i very much doubt the CCP would torture foreign content creators.
@@downey2294 If they could, they would.
@@tentacledood5784 probably yea
Regarding the talking animal ban, that one isn't true. Ever heard of Journey to the West? You may know it as Monkey King, but it's China's most famous tale. A tale that features...talking creatures. For the 2008 Summer Olympics, when the mascots were revealed, the Chinese government released cartoons showcasing them where they talked. The mascots, known as the Fuwa, represent, you guessed it...different creatures from China. Kung Fu Panda is also insanely popular in China. The book Alice in Wonderland was banned in one province for putting talking animals at the same level as humans, but that was back in 1931, so before the PRC was a thing.
"Winnie the Pooh is NOT banned in China" and while Disney World has the Hall of Presidents showcasing an animatronic of every president in US history up until the current, Shanghai Disneyland's Hall of Presidents is.... *The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh* (yes, this ride is at the park). Funny thing you mention Avatar in China, in 2019 Endgame took the title of highest grossing movie of all time from Avatar. However in 2021, Avatar was able to re-claim its title because it was re-released in China. Though it's just Disney...beating Disney. The embodiment of the Obama awarding Obama meme
Its a video from 2 years ago
@@AgeraRS7its a useful update
@@AgeraRS7i mean one year ago mate from when he wrote the comment? Don’t know drastic change you expected one year to have, all the points he mentioned still hold very true.
@@AgeraRS7I watched TV shows and Animations of the Journey to the west when I was 6 in China. I also watched every movie(except for the latest one) of Kungfu panda when they are presented in movie theatres in China. So, even though this video is made 2 years ago, he is still laughably wrong regarding the talking animal bit. Goes to show how little does westerners really know about China.
@@fred8691 nice try shill
I'm surprised that the social credit score system was not implemented. My psychology professor even showed us a video in class suggesting it was implemented and we held a debate about it. Not to mention all of the memes and general internet commentary on it.
For my knowledge it's kind of implemented locally, or on curtain platforms, like ali, but not centrally. Some people was restricted on using hi speed trains or planes.
Don't belive everything the Internet says , we don't want to go back to the times where if a lie is repeated enough times it becomes the truth
I am pretry sure it is implemented. For example a famous example that comes to mind is that mma fighter that beat the crap out of "traditional chinese martial artists" and got punished through that sistem because of it
I remember something about it being tested on specific minor regions, but was determined to not be ready. So nobody in China has this social credit score... yet.
I've heard serpentza and his friend talking about it, i also thought it had been implemented, it's good to know that it wasn't, Chinese people don't deserve it
Whenever I learn more about China, I realise how lucky we are to live with the freedoms we actually have.
Yeah we all take it for granted here in the US. Now we have people complaining about fatphobia and trying to take away the freedoms we already have.
Australia seems to be trying to beat China when it comes to which country is less free right now.
@@joelcrafter43 Yeah I am genuinely concerned for people in Australia.
@@SeanKula nah it’s fine here, at least where I live.
@@MadeUpNoun Umm both I guess.
"Hey look! They are even building a copy of the holo-" Good job man. That earned a sub.
Wow … As a chinese person i'm surprised how accurate and your content is.And even some content is too localized, it is difficult for foreigners to understand…Thank you for introducing our bad situation to the audience in westworld from a fair and objective perspective
Are u using a vpn ?
@@redaassiakhi7788 He won't answer, they got him
@@d_spies048 Maybe he moved out of China?
@@limbo6259 So the social credit system just doesn't exist?
@@limbo6259 Of course it doesn't! Good answer Chen 👍
(+5)
Chinese here. This video is perhaps one of the most insightful and accurate description of the Chinese Internet’s ecosystem. I’d be impressed if you got this done without any help from a Chinese guy. Job well done!
战忽局来啦
@@smartwong7023 where? It's quiet in here.
@@nuclearwarhead9338 战忽局 It is mocking people who deliberately degrade the strength of mainland China.
@@wi9547 he not mocking anything though
You still alive my man?
I had a chance to talk to a TV producer from Japan a few years back. Because of the fact that TV is slowly dying as an entertainment in a traditional sense, one of the ways producing companies in Japan, and I would guess other (East) Asian countries, earn money is by selling IP's and rights to Chinese production companies which then create their own versions of films and series. Guess that's a way of making sure not much foreign stuff comes in.
Unfortunately most of the IPs are ruined when they're sold to Chinese production companies, so bad that fans would rather seen it dies and not revived in such a way.
Dude. Half murican shows are murican versions of other countries IP. EVERY country makes their own versions for locals
Toddler: “Mommy I wanna big yellow duck”
The mom: “shit”
The mom? What mom? There was never a mom! Don't attempt to search for the mom or the toddler.
-9999999 social credit, genital privileges lost
have childrens? 😔👎👎👎👎👎👎👎 -3,000,000 social credifs
@@shonsenjaime177 how else can we keep the Chinese race nice and strong 💪 🇨🇳
@@tentacledood5784 memetic agents oh no
large fan of how kung fu panda breaks so many of these rules yet it started an animation craze
Fun fact: a chinese subsidary of DreamWorks Animation (Oriental DreamWorks, now Pearl Studio) actually worked on the Kung Fu Panda movies.
I'm surprised they haven't banned Zootopia in Hong Kong x3
@@thezootopiahusky china dont have so much control on hong kong because it was of the british. Until 2047 china wont be able to control hong kong so much.
@@securityguy9992 It already is controlling HK. Who will actually stop the CCP from doing whatever they want there?
@@_blank-_ hong kong inst 100%comunist. But china is at least trustful whit some of theit words
The VPN part would’ve been perfect for a sponsor missed opportunity
Sponsors don’t just wait for someone to to ask if they can be sponsored
@@JimboJuice yeah but don’t they go to someone and ask if they would like to be sponsored? I think the only thing the person does is say yes or no and sign some sort of contract right?
@@JimboJuice huh never knew that.
I was fully expecting him to say "thankfully this video is sponsored by nord vpn"
That said though, if you _did_ advertise a VPN on this video, it would be "ironic" (to say the least) if it wasn't able to bypass the GFW restrictions. Someone could make the case that it's misleading advertising, in that there's an implication that whatever mentioned service would work in that situation...
im vietnamese and hearing that VPN in china has a slang as Vietnamese Pho Noodle is absolutely hilarious to me 😂
yeah Vietnamese could access western media freely we could also use VPN easily poor Chinese lmao
@@jirou6228 That's because Chynah failed to turn us into another Xinjiang or Tibet and therefore their stupid Great Firewall can't do shit. But Vietnam is thankfully trying to distance themselves from the so-called "peacekeepers" that wanted Russia to win the Ukraine invasion, "liberate" Taiwan, Korea, Japan and Vietnam. In retrospect, Vietnam has slightly better civil liberties than Chynah as it is now.
It’s completely BS, I asked my Chinese friend and he said those exact words
@@economicapple2609 Mainland Chinese friend or Chinese from elsewhere?
@@ranjanbiswas3233 mainland
Talking animals are banned? But I grew up with 熊出没 and 猪猪侠 (when I was in mainland) which one has two talking bear bros and another one pigs who have superpowers.
之前有人谣传说广电规定建国后动物不能成精，可能就传到国外了
same lol
As someone who used to live in China I can confirm a few things:
The average person of China is in one of 3 categories:
1. Unaware of the "outside" internet
2. Using a ladder to access the internet (various purposes)
3. Content, they know about the outside but see no need to climb the wall
就我而言，还真是这样，要不是为了学英语我也不会看RUclips。b站和贴吧就挺好的，而且还有弹幕，比看RUclips爽多了😂。身边爬梯子的基本都只是为了看porn
没错捏
@@Allen.Z28 你有梯子吗？
bing chilling
I’ve been to china and I can say 3 is the best way to describe how chinese people react to the outside world’s internet. Most young people know almost anything about the internet but they seems to do not care, they would use VPN to play games, watching entertainment,… other than that they literally enjoy their own domestic social internet more.
Went to China after 5 years to see my grandparents, and since I’m more aware now, it was quite frustrating that I couldn’t access outside internet. As long as you’ve experienced the internet on the other side, the internet in China was just very weird. Most people in China are actually quite aware that there is a firewall, especially the younger generation, but they don’t care that much about it
事实上，我也是年轻一代，访问了这些网站后更令人沮丧❤
why your grandparents is in china?
@@justinz3612what an odd question.
@@justinz3612 Because they went to China
Instagram and Whatsapp has nothing to compared with wechat
I was learning chinese at a Confucius Institute in Mexico City. We had an author visiting the school, Mai Jia. He was presenting his newest book, which was about espionage.
The audience was given the word. I asked him what he thought about the Tian An Men massacre... I didn't know where I was until I saw the audience's reaction that I understood where I was, I was at a place where everyone was on the CCP's side... Saw a bunch of facepalming and just shunning in general... That's when I got scared at how big is the CCP's influence
Even in Mexico???
So how did he reply? :D
Lol if this happened in America I would call the cops on them for being spy’s
Ñ?
Then it means you must bring it up!
“Social credit isn’t real”
Should’ve put a yet at the end.
Yeah I don't think he's correct on that, they've been testing and implementing it in Rongcheng, Whezhou, Chengdu and many others for 2 years now, and it's stopped transport of 13 million people. (Wired article, How the West Got Social Credit Wrong, Jan 2020).
It hasn't been established as a nation-wide system yet. Currently only some provinces and some companies use it.
@@geospliced of course. Doesn't mean it's i) not real or ii) not supported by the CCP
It fucking is tho this guy got it wrong its already established in most first tier cities in china its just not yet fully nationwide
@@Михалыч-е2у Well as of now there is no one single social credit system. But local governments have their own interpretations of it in their local regions.
I remember talking to a kid on Fortnite who was in China, he wanted to add me on “WeChat” and when I jokingly said screw the president he got extremely scared. Kept saying “no no no don’t say that!” I wonder if they’re always being watched? He made it sound like he was gonna be dragged away by the government for even having heard me say that.
i mean why would you want that
I have thousands of texts chatting with my friends on WeChat screwing our president or our whole government yet not been caught🤣. Those topics were forbidden for a period of time in the last century, maybe his parents were influenced by that and subconsciously pasted the fear to their little boy.
Bro you wanted the kid dead or what 😂
Just wanted to correct two mistakes regarding the banned things: 1) While Winnie the Pooh is not banned by itself, itis banned when it’s mentioned together with Xi, any searches containing the two names will not return any results on the Chinese internet. 2) Time travel AFAIK is allowed in movies/media as I’ve watched a couple of mainstream Chinese shows/movies with it as a theme.
Yeah I’m pretty sure Big Bang Theory is allowed, I’ve seen it on the Chinese internet
this video is American anti-China propaganda in its purest form. I can’t even count lies per minute.
@@cssstylescommand4 This channel is based in the UK
@@cssstylescommand4 explain and debunk to me points made in this video. Idk about you, but knowing how strict Chiba is, this doesn’t seem too far off of from the truth
@@cssstylescommand4
Still less lies from him than from the chinese government
"Hey look! they're even building the copy of the holocaust-"
I felt bad for laughing but its so true
@@kamikazefilmproductions yeah i laughed too.its just too funny of a joke to not laugh
If he don't stop abruptly...I might not laughed because it is a serious matter.
That part had my dying lmao
Holo-what now?
I used to work for a NZ web host. We were constantly shuffling sites around for our exporter customers, as their node was added to the great firewall because of one social justice site sharing the host IP.
I've lived in China and left in 2019. While some of what you said is correct a couple things stand out as being very wrong. The English wikipedia article of Tiananmen square IS blocked in China. Why? Because the entirety of wikipedia as a website itself is blocked in China.
Another claim that is very wrong is that China doesn't have a social credit system. Yes it absolutely has it. It just hasn't been rolled out in all of China and only about 40% of the Chinese population (Still more than a half billion people) live under some level of the social credit system. It's been active in all big first tier cities and while the rule and point system is different based on local government tuning it's usually a system where everyone scores a 1000 points that can go up to 1400 for good behavior and down to 600 points for bad behavior. I personally had a score of 1138 at the time of leaving China in the city of Shenzhen.
Just out of curiosity, how hard was it to get those points?
the social credit system is probably the most dumbest thing i've ever seen
Holy shit are you serious
@@marcopeterson805 if you were higher up,it was easy.If lower,hard.
I think the social credit thing was a sarcastic joke
I was expecting this video to come from a channel with 1000 times the size. Well done, keep at it.
Yeah he's good at making western leftist propaganda isn't he
@@Ahmedkhaled-ev1jw well now it's 10x the size it was when I made that content so... Keep at it. Also, I'll have to rewatch to see how it's leftist propaganda if at all.
@@Ahmedkhaled-ev1jw it's good that no one cared about that :))))
@@Ahmedkhaled-ev1jw not even leftist
@@toast2980 anime pfp
As a chinese who live in Austrlia，I really agree what you talking about the situation, when I was in china, I have to spend a lot of money and time to get tons of different VPN(some time they just don’t work in china) to get something what we should deserved. The wall is not just exist on internet, but in people’s mind, a group of people what we call them “little pinks” would trust everything that their government told them, what ever it is crazy or not. When you trying to tell them the truth, they will refuse to believe and abuse you, judging you and call you traitor, they refuse everything that is different than their education, they are crazy, madness(they will celebrate the US has over 100k people died in Covid-19 plague) . sometime it is so hard to believe we are same species, we live in the same planet, it is so hard for me to tell other guy I come from china.(forgive my broken English, I’m still learning it)
Your English is quite good
Excellent English ! Good comment. Where in Australia do you live ?
I'm from Australia. My ex-girlfriend is Chinese. She did not like the restrictions either. She is very kind and intelligent, very unique. A good person. Her family is still in China. She used Facebook, but she also had a Chinese version of Facebook too. That's where, about 4 years ago, she showed me the "Winnie the Pooh/Xi Jinping" memes. I first heard of them there. They weren't banned then. She was sharing these memes with her friends.
@@jimreily7538 Melbourne, love to see that, thx for the comment :)
I can only say that your words and deeds are too subjective
I've given up arguing with those little pinks
one day sooner or later, they would either realise their stupidity or be suffocated with blissful ignorance
I am Chinese, and the banned website has no impact on our lives. Because banned websites can find alternatives in China (in addition to pornography, we can also connect to VPNs privately, although this is not legal, as long as we don't use it to do illegal things, the cyber police don't care). It is not legal for us to build a VPN without permission, but a gaming VPN is legal in China, for example, Call of Duty is banned in China, so you can use a game VPN to enter the game (accelerate the specified IP) Of course this is legal in China, it is completely legal to play banned games in China, and there are also many people in China who use Steam, Epic, Xbox, Play Station, Switch..., (but game consoles we generally use Japan, Hong Kong or the United States, because China will ban the store, limited to the host, there is no ban on the website in China)We use the Internet, but we ban some websites (RUclips, tiktok...and some porn sites) So the Chinese network is the same as the world, except that there are firewalls
用VPN最多就是警察给你打个电话说两句让你在外网别乱讲话，管得越来越松了，真翻出来看看都是什么勾巴东西。。。
关于游戏，被禁主要是因为19年HK那边有帮傻逼，在动森的小岛，R6，黑魂联机的ID传播敏感信息，导致好多Up的直播间被封了，后面干脆就禁了
I have a friend who lives in beijing and i've asked about the credit score, and apparently it is kind of a thing, just in select regions for select people.
It's a trial run. Working out the kinks.
Yeah it's not fully implemented yet
It works only when you evade tax or some
Something about the June 4th censorship: I play genshin, food fantasy, demon cultivation....something, but they're run by chinese companies and every year, for more than a month before and after June 4th, they disable the change nickname or bio option. The global and guild chats are disabled too, and in food fantasy at least, the mail notifications only show the rewards to claim, no text. On some obscure chinese rpg games, they completely disable the friend and private chat system as well as everything mentioned above, probably because they're from small companies and one June 4th language transgression could get their games removed from downloads.
Words
So in Genshin, now one born at 4th June?
Oh yes i remember that time and also during the 1st anniversary they also took out the nickname and bio options
Genshin impact is a bad game
@@LavaCreeperPeople ok.
As an actual Chinese ladder user getting to see this video, I’d say it’s 99% true, the last bit is that the connection of Wikipedia site from China kept getting worse since the year 2015, as for now it's impossible for us like reddit or twitter if without a ladder.
Ohhhh now I get it. A ladder to get over the *wall*
①维基百科已经全被墙了
②这些视频有些不实内容
@@aceman0000099 yeah thats a way talking about vpn. some people say its surfing on the internet via magic XD
看一眼维基百科上关于申国网络管制的内容，就知道维基百科被禁是有原因的hhhhh本人表示长知识了，好多事情明明就发生在我身边，却在国内平台闻所未闻
hello fellow chinese pal =D
7:24 LMFAOOOOOOOO
💀💀🙋🙋
3:35 "and the letter n" the fact that you had to explain what it meant was hilarious
honestly i thought it was becuase of the N word at first
我的朋友是那个人
@@TechlordXD found the American
@@a-drewg1716 im not american, its just a joke
@@TechlordXD well color me surprise normally Americans think everything is about race/the N word. lol
Interestingly, when I was in China about 6 years ago or so, Facebook messenger does work, but only with pre-existing chats, if I tried to create a new one it'd block the app, but if I used a chat that was in place before entering China it worked. Dunno if it's still the case though.
3:29 China really banned the word "disagree". What has this world come to
*temporarily
Plus it might just be the English word. Honestly i don't think it's that bad.
@@Rice8003 wtf
Chinese people: I agreen't
@@Rice8003 I strongly [REDACTED]
I remember living in China and arguing with one of my coworkers about Tiananmen Square. He had travelled around the world and still loved China's system of doing things, going as far as to say the massacre was justified.
Blue pilled brainwashed people. Can’t be helped. Poor them.
If he doesn’t love the system he had to either hide his thoughts and be dishonest almost all the time or be prepared for jail time. Either way isn’t easy. Many of us just mesmerized ourselves to believe that our system is the best to avoid the struggle.
Your coworker is based
@@xuanchenzhou9813 Man the good old days of the struggle. could u imagine fighting each other again. How fun is that.
Read up on the Falun gong cult, they are another faction fighting for power in China. They have aligned themselves with the CIA and they ain't saints. The Tienanmen Square event in China is taught as when the Falun gong cult started an insurrection. You can argue whether or not the Falun gong are the lesser evil, however, labeling the Tienanmen Square event as an outright massacre on innocent students is a bit disingenuous given the massive effort by Western intelligence agencies involvement during the day. Go watch the full uncut video of the Tank Man, he walked away fine here in the States he would have been shot for even approaching law enforcement, or go read BBC's original account of the events and you'll notice the BBC reporters stating the difficulties the Chinese military had as they were constantly being surrounded due to the lack of arms available for them. Overall the event isn't as black and white as our Federally-approved papers ( US Operation: Mocking Bird) tells us.
Lots of this is true, but some stuff here is allowed, such as ASMR videos, movies with time travel, and the Big Bang Theory. All of these are allowed on well known Chinese platforms such as bilibili and movie/tv show platforms like Youku and IQIYI.
Damn the few things they actually should have banned…
"Talking animals are banned"
Kung Fu Panda: "Am I a joke to you?"
Kung Fu Panda was wildly successful in China and the Chinese had an official government meeting to discuss why the U.S. made a better movie about Chinese cultural themes than they had and how they could compete.
That's actually hilarious and slightly sad.
That was back in 2008. Not happening anymore.
because chinese productions is about making money with little effort to please the investors
@@kyan_ and everyone else's production is made to please Chinese consumers.
Also China have Zootopia specially the part of the news achor as an Panda in they re version
Did you know in the Chinese release of Yakuza 0 there is a Chinese assassin who is quite scary and wrinkly but it fits his character and makes his presence more impactful. But in China they make him look like a normal chinese dude and he is voice by a Chinese actor who they based the appearance off. The name of the character is Lao gui
of course they gonna correct characters that are tying to demonizing the Chinese people.
@@wulaboombeach5004 there are plenty of normal Chinese people in yakuza. This dude ejust looks scary
@@wulaboombeach5004 you don't know what you're talking about
@@wulaboombeach5004 this just makes it worse imo, them looking scary is meant to be a sign that they're scary. By taking away that for one specific race you end up unintentionally making it seem like that race is supposed to be scary by default. Replacing a monster with a regular Chinese dude doesn't reflect better on anyone, it's just pedantic.
@@wulaboombeach5004 yeah this just makes chinese people seem more insecure and scared in real life, the fact that they seemingly can't handle a videogame
"I'm gonna say the N word!"
(Chinese Spec Ops appeared out of nowhere)
7:40 Xu Xiaodong, the Chinese MMA artist banned from flying and express rail travel would beg to differ.
He exposed traditional Kung Fu and other traditional Chinese "martial arts" as being worthless for combat (as they had evolved into choreography), and for that, the CPC fucked him over.
Xu is a madlad
Social credit score set to -9,999,999
@@slosh7072 Infinite
The whole story of Xu Xiaodong is really depressing.
Everytime china bots say social credits does not exist, say this name to them
I'd love to read a book about the opinions of the people who lead China. Their philosophy behind their choices.
This extreme censorship feels like fiction in real life!
Just look to at past communist regimes.
There are books out there written by CCP officials that give great insight into their philosophy on government and geopolitics like "The China Dream".
Xi actually has published a book on his governing philosophy. I'm not sure if there is an English translated version, but there might be.
Kraut and Tea has a good video on it. Called "Trumps Biggest Failure"
Xi Jinping wrote a book called "On the Governance of China" that is available in English if you're very curious.
“they’re even building a copy of the holocaust!” i laughed so hard i almost choked on my drink in the middle of a restaurant oh my god
Now try searching for pictures of this holocaust
Ok…
Who watches youtube at a restaurant?
What is funny about that?
@@blackpearl3628 ... you said this over the internet
BritMonkey, nice video it was really entertaining
The Internet of the future will look like the Internet in GTA 4
why would it evolve backwards
@@thesummergamer7245 That's what censorship does
I love, that watching this video means, that neither of us will ever be in china ever again.
Also, the fact, that 1984 is uncensored in china is the most hilarious thing I ever heard. 😂
I wonder how China's censors would react to a film vilifying North Korea. It isn't China of course, but they ARE fellow Communists. I imagine "The Interview" wouldn't be too amusing to them.
The book still exists, just that the message was slightly bended
Big brother wins in the ending of the Chinese print...
@@henrywong668 doesnt he also win in the original
Because the citizens are literally the proles
little correction, the social credit system is running right now, and having a low score can prevent you from boarding planes or even highspeed trains.
well they have been testing it in numerous cities but there is no single social credit system
Thats like a bank thing like if you owed money and doesn't have a way to immediately pay back, they'll restrict high-end purchases.
Juice
@@chizhang2765 definitely not the same thing.
You have a source? Have you been to China?
Actually many Chinese know about that,but we don’t have the ability to change it.😢
The social credit scoring is being used in china but not throughout. Cities and communities use their own scoring system while the main social credit system is for businesses and private parties. Which are indeed being watched over by the government and encouraged by it, in the hopes that they can adopt this later. Its all link to citizens with link id’s and so forth.
That mood of not caring as long as they can live well is spot on.
仅限于有钱人
I was playing Dota 2 with my Chinese friend that I met at The International and he accidently typed "tanks man" instead of "thanks man" and I haven't heard from him since :/
I was playing Tekwar with my american friend and I accidentally typed "WMD" instead of "WDYM" and I haven't heard from him since :/
You are so right about the social credit system . My family lives there no one is ever heard of social credit system
An interesting dichotomy here...Because of the lack of substantive information, the average Chinese is left ignorant of what is going on. Because of the over-abundance of worthless information, the average American is also left ignorant of what is going on.
Factual.
Not just Americans, but Westerners in general.
True
I think finding reliable sources and information should be taught everywhere in America. I was taught that sort of stuff in my high school, but I’m not sure if it’s the same in all other states (I’m on the east coast).
@@officialromanhours It's just not westerners. Filipinos are easily fooled by fake news on tiktok. Some even relying on it as their source of information
There are numerous regional pilot programs active for the social credit system though, it's not like they just gave up on it, it's still happening.
They're playing the long game, just like the seemingly useless bridges they're building around the Hong Kong area that will make complete economic sense when Hong Kong rejoins the mainland.:)
Well, as a Chinese living in Canada right now, I have to say, the life in wall is also colourful. Most of Chinese really don't care about their government because it never change and so many people work for the government. All of them only care about their own life, working hard playing hard. And because there is huge population in China, people gathering together is easy, so there are a lot of clubs and shopping malls in big city like Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Also the problem is too many people😂people love comparing with each other. Many people love traveling to see the different world.
6:39 BTW, Tencent owns (or has shares in):
Riot Games,
Discord,
Epic Games,
Bandcamp,
Harmonix,
Roblox,
Ubisoft,
Miniclip,
Paradox
and many more.
It also held stock in Activision Blizzard prior to the Microsoft aquisition.
not even flash games are safe
Crazy how these companies are banned in China but having shares in them is totally ok
@@redbean9410 know your enemies I guess, plus I can assume this can also be use as a way to make a Chinese ver. of those applications
It happened to roblox so I wouldn't be surprised if they start a localized ver. of each of these apps.
yeah, games like Diablo Immortal, LoL, Terraria, Minecraft etc available with super interesting censorship
shares means some influence but conspiracy people think that china own the whole thing if a chinese company is in it
ah yes, VHS, my favorite format for watching Mad Max: Fury Road (2015)
To get that 80's feel
In fact, Google, X, Instagram, etc. can operate in China as long as they comply with Chinese laws, but they are unwilling to comply, so they cannot operate legally. This is the opposite of Tiktok's situation in the United States. Tik fully complies with US laws, but is forced to sell to Americans.
😂
1:05 I like how it says "Freedom is Slavery" as a reference to George Orwell's 1984.
Thank you for actually presenting factual information about Chinese censorship. There is so much baggage behind it, yet no one wants to look at it seriously without checking their biases. I see a lot of Chinese nationalists defend literally anything their government does, and a lot of sinophobic westerners exaggerate/invent things that don't actually exist. It's kind of difficult seeing someone talk objectively like this on the internet. So thank you so much. ~ A former Chinese citizen
people dont just defend the ccp for no reason, there are videos with a lot of evidence debunking anti-china arguments such as the uyghur situation, many people saw those videos and changed their stance, you dont see those videos becuz yt now censored most of them, especially the really good ones
You are terrible there’s no getting around it
@@leiuwu3965 ok why would they be censored lol.
@@BerryFin because youtube dont like it its that simple
@@BerryFin because it goes agaisnt the narrative that western capital (who undoubtedly has ties to youtube stockholders) want you to believe about the ebul gommunism
Chinese here. Mostly true. But VPN is way more popular than I thought actually, not very difficult for younger generations to access the international Internet.
The VPN I use now is built by Chinese and costs ￥128 per year for 168GB each month, which is about $18. Affordable for the majority. Accessible in PC and mobile devices.
有一说一，就算用VPN我也不会用多长时间😅大多数时间还是用国内的网络
那生活在国内的环境里，大多数时间用国内网络不是很正常嘛@@brandtianliyu
As a chinese i agree with this.
You know what, when people talk online they do not even dare to put the word 'blood' ,'kill' , 'police' etc in the text, they will simply just put the first letter of the word to represents the actual word, for example, the word 殺(sha) means to kill, and they will only type S to represent the word. Netizens in china always joke about if the government continue to ban whatever word they like, Chinese language will become dots and symbols. coz we have no more Chinese word to use.
You should read 1984. Especially the part about "New Speak". The purpose of New Speak in the book is to make it impossible to conceptualize illegal thoughts. There simply will not exist a word to describe it, and so you will be incapable of conceptualizing it.
That seems to be what the CCP is doing.
杀
RUclips ADS ARE CANCER I agree with the username
cmon bro, I lived in China and know truth.
@@leopanda4209 cmon bro u live in china and u r browing RUclips that's illegal , u traitor of Communism
Years ago, a client of mine was invited to China for a business deal for his manufacturing company. I told him that before he goes, he should do some research on privacy concerns before going. After finding out that it's highly recommended to take a burner phone and nothing else electronic he then became worried about his patents and intellectual property. I asked him, "Have you already made contact with this Chinese company? Don't worry about it, they stole your product designs within 10 minutes of contacting you."
Yes, we stole thins, so don't come to China
I think you should tell you friend to not sell in china, or import from china
7:03 In the Japanese title Mother 3 that's actually what happens in game, I am guessing they've read about things that happened in China which helped fuel major aspects of their creativity for the game's storyline.
In fact most of the things happening in China is used as a story element of inspiration.
2:51 RAHHH TALLY HALLS INTERNET SHOW (T.H.I.S) MENTIONED RAHH WHAT THE FK IS A ACTIVE BAND RAHHHH
WTF IS A BAD SONG ‼️‼️
Alright, legitimate question: Are people allowed to be born in June 4th? If so, what do you tell people when they ask you for your birthday?
Internet maintenance day of 1998?
@McBoyLeo jeez
@McBoyLeo wtf 💀
FYI if u type 六月四号/六月四日/6.4.(all meaning June 4th) it is not a problem at all. I have friends born on that day. U think they are not allowed to say their B-day or what lol
I personally haven't encountered any erasing issues typing these dates on any Chinese apps. So I am actually doubting the leigitimacy of the statement made in the video.
@@华李-i1s it's all western propaganda lmao, i mean the OP is literally an anglo saxon
@@beamyshark It's no exactly, I don't know about in China but almost every Chinese game that have a global server they banned "June 4th" when it's near this day. So, i cannot say that inside China is like that, but anyone that play Chinese games know that CCP anniversary and June 4th are days that the censorship in games just reach the maximum
Hi, im on vacation in China right now and I can confirm that i saw 1984 being sold at a foreign books store in shanghai, I didn't pay much attention to it since it was in a sea of other books that i was forced to read in middle school like lord of the flies, but its pretty cool to see it in this video.
VPN?
@@vibe9120 i'm using letsvpn, i tried nord and expressvpn before because both claim they work in china, but they dont, so spare yourself some dollars and dont make the same mistake as me :^)
This is a fake account. Chinese ropaganda bot. You can tell by how formally it is typed and a few other things
@@OkaydenMusicyeah… his exactly? This looks absolutely nothing like a bot? This is NOT formal typing, and even if it was, this is just how some people write. There is literally NO, ZERO, reason to believe this is a bot. Thanks 😊.
@@OkaydenMusic wtf thats just the way i type :sob:
Highly doubt 29% of people have access to vpn. I would say maybe 2.9% lol. I'm chinese.
Agreed, no chance 29% people, many Chinese people don’t even know vpn exists
2:49 Seeing that clip from the Tally Hall Internet Show gave me whiplash
I started kicking my legs all excited
SAMEEEE
This was the last place I expected to see a Tally Hall clip
i had to double check myself with the timed comment feature
Two more thing: the translation for "Narrow neck bottle" is "細頸瓶" instead of "窄頸瓶", which is almost identical with Xi Jinping in Chinese pronunciation.
Also, despite this video shows a lot of clips from hong kong, we are not inside of the great firewall yet. Maybe it would change in the future( I surely hope not)
A lot of the douyin content that makes it to RUclips comes through Hong Kong. So I hope you never go behind the Great fire Wall...
This was incredibly fascinating. Sad, but fascinating.
7 years in Tibet is one of my favorite movies. Fun fact: Brad Pitt was banned from entering china due to his role in the film
2016 in china ruclips.net/video/mzrZAE2es30/видео.html
good, its a propaganda piece for a monarchic dynasty of slave owners
3:18: ok, but all those people clapping in unison is creepy.
When you started talking about VPN it triggered me expecting the video to be sponsored and I was ready to skip ahead.
Imagine my surprise to see no sponsor.
Watched this vid mostly to see if you countered the myth about Winnie the Pooh lmao. there’s actually a Pooh ride at Shanghai Disneyland & merch for sale all over the place, this has always annoyed me sm lol.
Also - an interesting fact - when I lived in China and attended an international school, we were allowed by the govt to use a campus wide VPN (it’s not uncommon to have a VPN built into the Wi-Fi, in fact you can buy routers like that at mainstream tech stores in major cities; though you can’t hide things like that as a large organization like a school), and generally they turned a blind eye with a few exceptions. We were always told to NEVER use school Wi-Fi to search for “the 3 Ts”: Taiwan, Tibet, tianamen. Apparently it would literally shut down our internet schoolwide lol.
Why not tibet?
It is a frickin state in there
@@mewmimo8465 you don't know, sigh
@@Dots_The_Demon_Lord Probably another Wumao. Ignore the shill.
the 3 ts thing sounds like horse shit, Tianamen is literally just a word in chinese, and tibet and taiwan are places that exist
8:00 they do, i have a friend who went to school in Canada and went back to china. It's not as much of a meme as we make it here in the west, but it is a thing. Similar to our credit system for buying/renting houses and getting credit cards, etc.
That's just a credit score.. it exists pretty much everywhere
ok, as a Chinese, i can say most are true, but i still found some of content is this video not true of lack of context.
I'm American and I've been watching a Chinese show recently, and it's super weird how things get censored. In one scene a character is reading a scientific paper titled "The Effects of Pollution on the Environment" but the word Pollution is blurred out, lol.
I clicked on your video because of that show.
The effects of on our environment are quite catastrophic indeed
China is 20% of the world's population
USA is 5% of the world's population
China emits 27% of manmade co2
USA emits 14% of anmade co2
(This comment might be outdated)
@@QUEfrang China is NOT 20 percent of words population lol, it's like 1/8th, and we all know that China isn't very truthful
@@brah9249 Have you heard of rounding
@@QUEfrang yes but rounding that much is like rounding 5'10 tp 6'
Remember guys, the group that is restricting information is usually always the bad guy.
No, We only restrict information in the United States because it's misinformation 🤡
The West is more subtle in this regard: they drown any meaningful conversation with droves of fabricated lies, moral panics, useless products and manufactured consent. It's not your usual censorship but important information still doesn't spread.
@@bretl17 +100 social credit
@@_blank-_ It's incredible how out- of- touch some people (that claim to be political activists) are here in the 1st world. Here in europe, for example, people drown in the sea or freeze in the borderlands while we talk about which words are no-no-words (which kinda change in 5- year- intervals). I am no expert, but i think i'd rather be called an insenitive word, but recieve help instead of the opposite.
@@bretl17 not all of it is misinformation. the mainstream media is a joke that probably deserves to be blocked. i’m american, and i block it so to speak. it’s ridiculous. now, what individual journalists have to say often isn’t misinformation. you just have to check several sources that don’t put their personal opinion as objective fact and make sure it adds up.
I made a website when I was 11 and it’s not banned in China
What blew my mind is the fact that I Chinese guy I met while traveling told me that the hbo show "euphoria" and the Netflix show "sex education" are not banned.
Bro We all access to the show through illegal websites conveniently. But u know main TV platforms can’t put ‘em on for censorship.
Chances are, they probably watched it through some pirate sites.
Ahh Euphoria, peak culture moment
‘Hey look they are even building the Holocaust!’ LOLLLLL
4:18 I have to point out that the Chinese education system requires you to lean one foreign language, and for 99% of people it is English. So basically English is mandatory.
Yes but however most English they taught at school is just basic grammar and how to translate Chinese text into English. They never really teach you how to communicate with a native English speaker or how to read an essay written by actual English speaker. That is the reason why most Chinese people do not have the ability to read the texts written by English speaker.
Consider how useful the average American's high school french or Spanish is once they leave school... That's what English is like for the average Chinese person.
@paprikat.6479 But after we enter University, we will be required to read English papers and take IELTS. However, my spoken English is indeed not as good as those from English-speaking countries.
It is mandatory to learn some of it, but I'm currently studying abroad and let me tell you: no one speaks English. Heck, I live in a student's apartment meant specifically for foreign students and even there the receptionists don't speak English. I had to struggle through the registration process in broken Chinese because their English was worse. The only places where I found people who could speak English were at the airport and inside the university and even then they are hesitant to do so.
Halve of these are just pure fiction
The ending is exactly what is happening in china.i worked and studied 2 years in china and even i got immersed into we chat and their internet sites because i had to, i made my family and friends back home to install we chat so that we could talk because i didnt like the ordeal to go through VPN and the issue with connectivity after joining vpn. Every colleague, friends in china were in we chat so it was natural for me to just adapt. They have their copies of western games to keep them busy, the social sites, memes and even porn are available within wechat groups to have some self time. But they dont really care because you could say they are exactly like americans in a way, they are ignorant of what happens elsewhere beside their own bubble and country and they are never taught to explore beyond their own system, culture and country. They are content and happy. Learning english is a nightmare to them and they only learn 6 to 8 years in their school when its mandatory and completely stop studying further in english and having more than 800 million people online makes it easier to have them entertained foe every single thing. So, socialism or not, restriction or not, they are happy in their own existence because they are just not aware of the foreign ideologies enmass.
Strange how much it does mirror the situation of the general public of the US
@Viktoria_k that's exactly what it is. The isolation in China is created by the government but in terms of US, it's just plain old ignorance and pride of being the center of the universe
So when i got my own life to enjoy, why the hell should i learn ENGLISH and care about things happening on the other side of planet? Dose those news make your life better? increase your salary? pay your food? It is just a way of entertainment, no difference with a cyber game. There are 1.5 billion people 1/5 of the whole human being speaking Chinese, why don't you learn Chinese? Indians are good at English, do they have better life than us?
@@gordondai2523 you don't have to learn other languages, but they can open another entire world
theres nothing wrong in learning more than what you already know
@@gordondai2523 may be it can.
2:53 “and the bing bang theory, at least they did something right”. You sir deserve a like
Well. There’s an upside. The youth aren’t having their brains rotted inside out by pornography.
Then they fell into short video platforms like Douyin or Kuaishou… Moreover, there’re tons of soft porn contents on those platforms.
inside the great firewall ,there are still some of porn websites which is just more unfindable