#3 is gorgeous, my favorite color in a rose and I like its growth habit. The flower looks similar to Abe Darby but the growth habit of the shrub is more appealing of this one. Hoping the fragrance is also strong!
J'ai toujours eu des difficultés à choisir un rosier sur site internet ou catalogue car les roses sont photographiées en gros plan. Lorsque je tombe sous le charme d'une rose pour sa couleur, sa forme, la sensibilité quelle dégage j'ai besoin d'en savoir plus. Je recherche obstinément des photos, des vidéos, pour juger du port du rosier, de sa floribondité, de la tenue de la fleur à la pluie, si elle est dressée ou tombante, sur une courte ou longue tige, je parcours les blogs de passionnés et c'est parfois un vrai combat surtout si la création est récente. Je tiens donc à vous remercier pour vos vidéos qui sont toutes un plaisir à regarder et qui sont un véritable outil de choix et de ..séduction ! Pour ma part j'ai une préférence pour la rose n°3, bien que ce coloris soit maintenant très répandu. Je souhaiterais lancer un défi à Mr Mattias Meilland qui est d'une incroyable spontanéité, il dégage une énergie et un enthousiasme qui me ferait presque oublier qu'avant de s'extasier il faut creuser ! Donc à mon tour d'être assez persuasive pour que vous portiez intérêt à ma demande. J'aimerais une rose pour les 100 ans de Madeleine Riffaud, soit une sortie pour le 23 août 2024! Cette femme extraordinaire, résistante de la seconde guerre mondiale, survivante, écrivain, poète, grand reporter de guerre, militante anticolonialiste, defenseur des droits humains, mérite une rose à son nom. Il faut une rose avec du parfum, un parfum envoûtant du Maghreb où elle a épousé la cause des peuples en lutte quitte à 'être condamné à mort par l' OAS et être victime d'un attentat. Une rose de caractère rappelant peut-être le lotus symbole de son amour pour le Vietnam, et de son engagement dans les maquis viet cong . "Comme elle retourne chaque soir en eaux troubles et ouvre ses pétales graciles à l'aube, la fleur de lotus est un symbole de force, de résilience et de renaissance." Le choix de la couleur est difficile, le rouge évoque le sang trop versé, le blanc, le deuil au Vietnam. La tradition est de rendre visite à Madeleine Riffaud avec une rose, ce qui lui rappelle les visites de Paul Eluard. Allez la voir et apportez lui UNE Rose, celle qui portera son nom ! Je suis sur que déjà vous pensez à l'une des merveilles de votre pépinière. " Si j’ai besoin de quelque chose ? Oui, je veux bien une rose. Une seule. Et aussi, puisque vous insistez, une boîte de cigarillos. » Merci pour elle.
Bonjour, message passé à Matthias, voici sa réponse: "Bonjour Véronique, Malheureusement, baptiser une rose au moi d’Aout est compliqué (sauf si on est dans le nord de l'Europe), et sélectionner une variété pour un baptême 3 mois à l'avance est quasiment impossible. Nous connaissons les noms commerciaux de nos rosiers au moins 2 ans à l'avance, c'est le temps de la production. Mais c'est une excellente idée pour le futur. Ne pas oublier que nous avons créé la rose de la paix (Mme A. Meilland en France) ;) c'est peut être un peu sa rose aussi. Bien à vous, Matthias"
All four varieties are great, first place was shared by number 3 and number 4 . Thank you for your great work and happiness to have such beauty in your garden . It would be a pleasure to shake your hand in person
I love the white, peachy, then the yellow and then the red. Nobody has a great white rose anymore, big symetric or ruffled, and pretty canes and leaf color. They are nice and healthy, great! The red one has the best shape!
#3 is my favorite! The one I least like is #4, simply due to the color - it reminds me of the Knock Out rose which is everywhere here in America and I'm a bit tired of seeing that color
Red is not my favorite color, but I do think #4 would be a great landscaping rose. Personally #2 is my favorite - the creamy white color and the fragrance got my vote.
My favourite one is number 3 , peach is my favourite color and the over all bush was fantastic and healthy, second place is number 4 the number 2 then number 1 .
Number 2 is my favorite. I liked all of them, though. If I had to choose a least favorite, it was probably number 1-not because there’s anything wrong with that rose; it was beautiful; I just feel like, out of all of them, that one looks very similar to other roses I’ve seen on the market.
Loved #2 - great shape, manageable size, very double flowers and report of fragrance. #3 is a close runner up. I least like #1 - interesting growth habit.
❤ I adore number 3 with the pink apricot flowers - the foliage looks beautiful and the shrub structure looks fantastic. I would buy it in an instant. I do think the second one looks really nice too, even though white roses are less my favourite - I would have to see that one in real life before buying it. The yellow one is my least favourite even though I do like a yellow rose, but it's a bit too classical for me. Thanks for this fun opportunity! You tempted me into giving my 1st comment ever to a RUclips video after 100s of gardening videos 😊
"You tempted me into giving my 1st comment ever to a RUclips video after 100s of gardening videos " that was the idea ;) and it is so fun to read all those ;)
@@Meillandroses The boss said she prefers to get cut roses and not garden rose 😁. The plans will still continue. In the next 2 years we plan to start a green house in Garut. Try to find a place which has 1600 m from the sea. 🤭
Eden Rose comes in Soft pink (original), Strong pink (Pretty in Pink) and White/Cream (Blushing) depending on where you are in the world, not all of them are available.
It is very difficult to choose because liking a colour is so subjective, they are all beautiful but I would vote for the white one and the peachy one second. My garden is small (150 m2 approx) and the peachy one is wide, but has beautifully shaped flowers. It is also good to see their natural shape. Thank you, Irene (Netherlands)
I would rank them #3, then #2 (looks to me like Top Cream. I smelled that one in the garden center and it was incredible.), then #1 and #4 (the last 2 look like Knock out roses, which I really don't like that's why they are on the bottom of my list) 😊
I think I vote for #1 because I love how prolific it is and I’m always looking for good yellows. But I can’t pick one I don’t like because what’s not to like!
Favorite: #3 - gorgeous color (those reddish stems are handsome too) and you mentioned it's fragrant. Honorable mention: #2 - it's a lovely shrub and seems a smaller stature too (a lot of white HTs and shrubs like to get big) No dislikes - we all like different colors, or look for different things for our yards. Seems unfair to down vote a rose that may be exactly what someone else is looking for ;-)
#1 I love the compact size for growing in pots, please release in Australia #3 is too big for pots interested in the orange rose behind number #4 :) please tell us more
J apprécie beaucoup la 3 surtout si elle est parfumée. La 4 est spectaculaire aussi
6 месяцев назад+1
Fave: #3 (my favourite colours for flowers are in this colour family) Not a fan of pure white or red/hot pink flowers, so my least favourite would be #2 and #4 but i still think they are beautiful for what they are!
Sorry about it but we don't work with India as the law on Plant Breeders Rights is not protecting our creations. We did work a couple of decades ago, but sadly the intellectual propriety legal environment is not up to our standards.
@@Meillandroses oh sorry to hear that, I was searching for meilland roses here in India and every plant on sale was grafted,looked very unhealthy, anyways I will get them when i will be in US
Love #3 for its blooms and disease Resistance is key along our Gulf Coast. I didn't dislike any but I would have to say #2, the white, was my least favorite just based on color, or lack thereof.
Didn’t really care for any of them. I like stripes, brownish colors or other unique characteristics, really big flowers, scalloped petals, etc. I am SO DONE with buying unexciting roses that breeders concentrate on disease resistance as their main breeding objective. Yech to all four.
So it is 100% dislike ;) that's a great choice. Disease Resistance is not our only philosophy, if it was, you would get our HT's and Floribunda (Bolero, All American Magic, California Dreamin', Candy Cane Cocktail, Cherry Parfait, Dark Night, Enchanted Peace, Loves Me Love Me Not, Nicole Carol Miller, Pinkerbell, Polynesian Punch, Romantica Ball Gown, Romantica Moonlight, Yves Piaget). But a good plant, healthy and not requiring lots of work is actually our main aim. California is a pretty easy place to grow roses, and yes, we focus on Californian roses as well as for the rest of US that has much more difficulty to grow rose without pesticide and fungicide ;) we work for 64 countries in the world and our selection are done locally in order to be sure that the performance are always better for each novelty. As we say in France : "Il faut de tout pour faire un monde" ;)
They are all absolutely gorgeous! But #3 is special - it's incredible.
Love no.2, very classic. After that, no.3 is wonderful. Reminds me a little bit of Colette
#4 is incredibly floriferous. Superb.
#3 is gorgeous, my favorite color in a rose and I like its growth habit. The flower looks similar to Abe Darby but the growth habit of the shrub is more appealing of this one. Hoping the fragrance is also strong!
Love 1. We all need a very good yellow rose!
J'ai toujours eu des difficultés à choisir un rosier sur site internet ou catalogue car les roses sont photographiées en gros plan. Lorsque je tombe sous le charme d'une rose pour sa couleur, sa forme, la sensibilité quelle dégage j'ai besoin d'en savoir plus. Je recherche obstinément des photos, des vidéos, pour juger du port du rosier, de sa floribondité, de la tenue de la fleur à la pluie, si elle est dressée ou tombante, sur une courte ou longue tige, je parcours les blogs de passionnés et c'est parfois un vrai combat surtout si la création est récente. Je tiens donc à vous remercier pour vos vidéos qui sont toutes un plaisir à regarder et qui sont un véritable outil de choix et de ..séduction !
Pour ma part j'ai une préférence pour la rose n°3, bien que ce coloris soit maintenant très répandu.
Je souhaiterais lancer un défi à Mr Mattias Meilland qui est d'une incroyable spontanéité, il dégage une énergie et un enthousiasme qui me ferait presque oublier qu'avant de s'extasier il faut creuser !
Donc à mon tour d'être assez persuasive pour que vous portiez intérêt à ma demande. J'aimerais une rose pour les 100 ans de Madeleine Riffaud, soit une sortie pour le 23 août 2024!
Cette femme extraordinaire, résistante de la seconde guerre mondiale, survivante, écrivain, poète, grand reporter de guerre, militante anticolonialiste, defenseur des droits humains, mérite une rose à son nom.
Il faut une rose avec du parfum, un parfum envoûtant du Maghreb où elle a épousé la cause des peuples en lutte quitte à 'être condamné à mort par l' OAS et être victime d'un attentat. Une rose de caractère rappelant peut-être le lotus symbole de son amour pour le Vietnam, et de son engagement dans les maquis viet cong . "Comme elle retourne chaque soir en eaux troubles et ouvre ses pétales graciles à l'aube, la fleur de lotus est un symbole de force, de résilience et de renaissance."
Le choix de la couleur est difficile, le rouge évoque le sang trop versé, le blanc, le deuil au Vietnam.
La tradition est de rendre visite à Madeleine Riffaud avec une rose, ce qui lui rappelle les visites de Paul Eluard.
Allez la voir et apportez lui UNE Rose, celle qui portera son nom !
Je suis sur que déjà vous pensez à l'une des merveilles de votre pépinière.
" Si j’ai besoin de quelque chose ? Oui, je veux bien une rose. Une seule. Et aussi, puisque vous insistez, une boîte de cigarillos. »
Merci pour elle.
Bonjour, message passé à Matthias, voici sa réponse:
"Bonjour Véronique,
Malheureusement, baptiser une rose au moi d’Aout est compliqué (sauf si on est dans le nord de l'Europe), et sélectionner une variété pour un baptême 3 mois à l'avance est quasiment impossible.
Nous connaissons les noms commerciaux de nos rosiers au moins 2 ans à l'avance, c'est le temps de la production. Mais c'est une excellente idée pour le futur.
Ne pas oublier que nous avons créé la rose de la paix (Mme A. Meilland en France) ;) c'est peut être un peu sa rose aussi.
Bien à vous,
Matthias"
Merci pour votre réponse, j'espère qu'elle vivra encore deux ans pour connaître sa rose, je vous adresse mes respectueuses salutations
3421 all are very nice colours and look great. Tasmania Australia
#3 is my favourite. Love the dark glossy leaves and dark stems. The pink colour rose is beautiful.
Thanks !
All four are beautiful , it's hard to choose, number four though it's the most outstanding rose for me
Idk how someone can dislike any roses.For me #2 and #4 stand out the most,even tho my garden full filled with apricot toned like #3.
Love #3 and #1. They are all beautiful.
I love #2 and #3! I do hope that they are both fragrant...
Love #3!
All four varieties are great, first place was shared by number 3 and number 4 . Thank you for your great work and happiness to have such beauty in your garden . It would be a pleasure to shake your hand in person
#3 love it. It reminds me a little of Colette. And #4 is a close 2nd
I love all 4 but no.2 White, is very special and my favourite, due to fragrance which is very important to me.
I love the white, peachy, then the yellow and then the red. Nobody has a great white rose anymore, big symetric or ruffled, and pretty canes and leaf color. They are nice and healthy, great! The red one has the best shape!
#3 is my favorite! The one I least like is #4, simply due to the color - it reminds me of the Knock Out rose which is everywhere here in America and I'm a bit tired of seeing that color
#3 I LOVE I LOVE I LOVE! Look at all the clusters of blooms and how huge, you almost got lost in that shrub. PLEASE PLEASE bring it to TEXAS!
#3 is gorgeous!!😍
Love the yello and the white!
How can one choose?? All are beying beautiful! Maybe number 3!
Well, that's our everyday work ;) now you feel the pain 😂
#2 is my favorite followed closely by #3. #4 is beautiful and #1 is nice
I love the third. The pink!
Favorite: #2 (but #3 is a close runner-up!) Least favorite: #1 (although it looks like a wonderful rose). Great idea - this was fun!
My favorites in order are #3
#4
#2
#1
They are all lovely !
Love number three. I need several.
I love all 4. Please come to Canada
We are already in Canada through our US agency
www.starrosesandplants.com/breeder/meilland/
They all very beutiful!!! It is difficult to choos only one.
That's the game 😉
Red is not my favorite color, but I do think #4 would be a great landscaping rose. Personally #2 is my favorite - the creamy white color and the fragrance got my vote.
My favourite one is number 3 , peach is my favourite color and the over all bush was fantastic and healthy, second place is number 4 the number 2 then number 1 .
My favorite is #3, least favorite is #4.
1: Like+
2,3,4 Like
And the amber/orange one behind your left shoulder on 4 is a nice looking one as well.
Number 2 is my favorite. I liked all of them, though. If I had to choose a least favorite, it was probably number 1-not because there’s anything wrong with that rose; it was beautiful; I just feel like, out of all of them, that one looks very similar to other roses I’ve seen on the market.
Number 2 and 3 are my most favorite of the lot :)..
My favorite: #3 Just can’t resist the peachy pink color.
Least favorite: #2 Our spring has lots of rain so whites don't do well in my garden.
Loved #2 - great shape, manageable size, very double flowers and report of fragrance. #3 is a close runner up. I least like #1 - interesting growth habit.
❤ I adore number 3 with the pink apricot flowers - the foliage looks beautiful and the shrub structure looks fantastic. I would buy it in an instant.
I do think the second one looks really nice too, even though white roses are less my favourite - I would have to see that one in real life before buying it.
The yellow one is my least favourite even though I do like a yellow rose, but it's a bit too classical for me.
Thanks for this fun opportunity! You tempted me into giving my 1st comment ever to a RUclips video after 100s of gardening videos 😊
"You tempted me into giving my 1st comment ever to a RUclips video after 100s of gardening videos " that was the idea ;) and it is so fun to read all those ;)
4! Тhank u, very beautiful all!
MasyaAllah very beutiful garden rose
Favorites are 2 and 3.
The white and the peach 🌹🌹🌹
Number 3, without a doubt
Which one will you bring for me ? 😂😂😂
It's hard for me to make a choose, Matt.
But I think no 2 (white) and no 3 are really beautiful
They should work perfectly in Indonesia ;) Let's ask the boss which one she likes ;)
@@Meillandroses The boss said she prefers to get cut roses and not garden rose 😁. The plans will still continue. In the next 2 years we plan to start a green house in Garut. Try to find a place which has 1600 m from the sea. 🤭
The world needs a pink version of “red eden”. Red Eden is one of the most beautiful roses in the world. 😊
Pretty in Pink Eden rose is just that deep pink Eden rose. I have added this Eden rose to collection in March this year, can't wait to see blooms.
Eden Rose comes in Soft pink (original), Strong pink (Pretty in Pink) and White/Cream (Blushing) depending on where you are in the world, not all of them are available.
@@Meillandroses I’ve had them all but I find red Eden has a deeper, fuller cup and more chalice shaped than the other two. 💙
@@rebeccamaterasso2209 Yes, the rest are mutations of the original (just color change), but Red Eden is a different breed (different parents) ;)
It is very difficult to choose because liking a colour is so subjective, they are all beautiful but I would vote for the white one and the peachy one second. My garden is small (150 m2 approx) and the peachy one is wide, but has beautifully shaped flowers. It is also good to see their natural shape. Thank you, Irene (Netherlands)
#3 is my favorite
I would rank them #3, then #2 (looks to me like Top Cream. I smelled that one in the garden center and it was incredible.), then #1 and #4 (the last 2 look like Knock out roses, which I really don't like that's why they are on the bottom of my list) 😊
I think I vote for #1 because I love how prolific it is and I’m always looking for good yellows. But I can’t pick one I don’t like because what’s not to like!
Favorite: #3 - gorgeous color (those reddish stems are handsome too) and you mentioned it's fragrant. Honorable mention: #2 - it's a lovely shrub and seems a smaller stature too (a lot of white HTs and shrubs like to get big)
No dislikes - we all like different colors, or look for different things for our yards. Seems unfair to down vote a rose that may be exactly what someone else is looking for ;-)
#1 I love the compact size for growing in pots, please release in Australia
#3 is too big for pots
interested in the orange rose behind number #4 :) please tell us more
Thank you,
The orange one is not commercial ;) its habit isn't compact (meaning the size double from Spring to Fall) for us it is a problem ;)
J apprécie beaucoup la 3 surtout si elle est parfumée. La 4 est spectaculaire aussi
Fave: #3 (my favourite colours for flowers are in this colour family)
Not a fan of pure white or red/hot pink flowers, so my least favourite would be #2 and #4 but i still think they are beautiful for what they are!
Thanks !
I like 3 & 4 ❤
Number 3 is my favorite, but I love number 1 and 3. I could do without 2 and 4, but im not a fan of white at all!
La número 3 es nuestra favorita, y después la numero 1, pero todas son hermosas!
I also like the No.3
#3 is my favorite. Number 2 is least favorite. They are all beautiful.
I love all. I don't like single petals roses .Here i well pick 2 ,3,4 as I love fragrance and I love red colour more than yellow
Love #4… least like is #1 and 2. I love dark pink to red
My favorite is #3
do you guys ship plants to India??.I liked the white rose(2nd) and the peach colour rose(3rd)
Sorry about it but we don't work with India as the law on Plant Breeders Rights is not protecting our creations. We did work a couple of decades ago, but sadly the intellectual propriety legal environment is not up to our standards.
@@Meillandroses oh sorry to hear that, I was searching for meilland roses here in India and every plant on sale was grafted,looked very unhealthy, anyways I will get them when i will be in US
❤❤❤ماشاءالله ❤❤❤ 0:09
Love number 3
There can be too many blooms. Flowers need a setting.
Number 3 is my favorite, followed by # 2.
Number 3 is my choice for number 1
I love nº 3
Love #3 for its blooms and disease Resistance is key along our Gulf Coast.
I didn't dislike any but I would have to say #2, the white, was my least favorite just based on color, or lack thereof.
#3
Best rose for me is no.3 and the least favorite rose is no.4.
#1 i lake.
Thanks 😉
Number 3:👍number 2: 👎 Matthias : ❤
Ahahah thank you !
#1
No. 3
Two
Not sure if it will come to our market. Loved:2 and not a lot: 4. I dont want to say that i didnt like it
Most of them won't, 99% of our creation finish in the trash ;) that's why we made this video, so you can experience the pain of selection ;)
3
3 is my favorite!
4 is my least favorite
But they are all beautiful!
Thanks!
I love #3, I am not the fan of #1 the yellow
They are all beautiful but #3 is my “love it” and #2 is my least favorite. Order of favorite… #3, #4, #1 and #2.
🙏🙏🙏🙏 روعه 🙏🙏🙏 0:26
je préfère la 2 et aime moins la 4; elles sont belles toutes les 4!! un choix difficile; bien le bonjour de Goesnes
Merci 😉
Like 1,2 and 3
You are supposed to choose one you like and one you don't 😉 but thanks !
@@Meillandroses #1 is my choice.
#3 is my favorite. #4 is my least favorite.
Love #3, dislike #4
Didn’t really care for any of them. I like stripes, brownish colors or other unique characteristics, really big flowers, scalloped petals, etc. I am SO DONE with buying unexciting roses that breeders concentrate on disease resistance as their main breeding objective. Yech to all four.
So it is 100% dislike ;) that's a great choice.
Disease Resistance is not our only philosophy, if it was, you would get our HT's and Floribunda (Bolero, All American Magic, California Dreamin', Candy Cane Cocktail, Cherry Parfait, Dark Night, Enchanted Peace, Loves Me Love Me Not, Nicole Carol Miller, Pinkerbell, Polynesian Punch, Romantica Ball Gown, Romantica Moonlight, Yves Piaget). But a good plant, healthy and not requiring lots of work is actually our main aim.
California is a pretty easy place to grow roses, and yes, we focus on Californian roses as well as for the rest of US that has much more difficulty to grow rose without pesticide and fungicide ;) we work for 64 countries in the world and our selection are done locally in order to be sure that the performance are always better for each novelty.
As we say in France : "Il faut de tout pour faire un monde" ;)
❤#3 ❤like❤, #2 don't like