Really great. Love the attempt to put vibrato on a piano with the pinky in the right hand sometimes when hitting the "A". And I swear sometimes it works. That's when you know you're really feeling the music.
Paul, this is marvelous! I just started learning this piece today, and with your screen setup I can see exactly how to play it, even the fingering! Thank you, thank you!!
JS Bach was way ahead of his time. It would have been interesting to see how his keyboard works would have sounded 100 to 150 years later. Even though this was a transcription it is absolutely a beautiful piece. Great job.
There is not much passion there- only he tried to be as accurate to help those who want to learn the piece and those pianists have to be experienced in order to benefit from him
Very beautiful. I don't think I knew this arrangement, or at least you made it new to me :D One thing, if I may, at 0:45, and similarly in the repeat ai 1:48, the A you play with the left hand ends the phrase you have been playing with the right hand. However you make it sound like it is harmony, so, to me, the phrase is left hanging.
Hermoso tema de Joan Sebastian Bach, y la forma de tocarla con la partitura, en la pantalla, que gran idea, gran música y gran pianista, atentamente Fernando Rojas Lima Perú
Good morning, Paul Barton - Thank you so much for sharing this great opportunity to listening to you ! Excellent and Beautiful Performance , Injoy listening to music ! ♪Date 1/31/2019♪
Lovely rendition Paul, Bravo. This I probably won't get read but I was wondering whether you would look at Chopin's Nocturne op 15 no 2. It's a wonderful piece in F Sharp Major in ABA form. Again, great performance.
It's a beautiful piece and arrangement. I think this could do with some more attention to tone, balance and voicing, especially when played this slowly, to prevent it from falling apart. It could very well do with a bit more speed. The left hand is more supporting non legato (portato) but that disappears when you don't change the pedal at every note (or at least at every dissonant) , especially with the added effect of the harmonic pedal. Thanks for uploading, there are not many renditions of this piece around om youtube unfortunately.
Paul you've been my reference point for soooo many pieces over my year and a half of learning. All of your bach pieces have me mesmerized by the way your hands move and look. The expression with the "vibrato" almost looking hand movements is stunning. thank you for all you do
Here is the score. imslp.eu/linkhandler.php?path=/imglnks/euimg/1/1b/IMSLP09510-Siloti_-_Transcription_of_Bach%27s_Air_from_Suite_for_String_Orchestra_No.3,_BWV_1068.pdf
Yes ! Well done indeed ! I don't know what to add to all that has already been said below. When clicking on the above link the displayed IMSLP page doesn't seem to be the right one ...
See in "Arrangements and Transcriptions" then scroll down. It's quite far down in that section, and you'll find one marked "A. Siloti." (This includes only the Air and not the entire suite).
I am sorry for my inadequate English. When this music started to be popular again 100 years after Bach's lifetime, the knowlegde how to preform baroque music was almost forgotten. People asked for the sheet music, and the publishers faced a problem: There wasn't any information at all about tempo, dynamics, ritardando and so on, a common practise back then. So the publishers write their own opinions, like "Adagio (quaver = 63-66) melodia sempre cantando e molto espressive". Later on some musicans wanted to restore this old music and went to old sources. Therefore we know that this tempo is too slow.
Paul, can't seem to locate this arrangement (by Siloti) on the link you've provided. Please check and advice. Many thanks and BRAVO for this lovely Bach piece. One of my favourites. cheers, Carol
The name of this piece is not "Air on the G string". The name of the piece is just "Air", or "Air from Orchestral Suite No. 3 in D major" (BWV 1068). It's the second movement of Orchestral Suite No.3, although a lot of people don't know that nowadays. The "on the G String" part was added by some violinist who made a popular transcription where the piece is transposed into C Major from D Major and the melody is played down an octave, entirely on the G-string, which is honestly just silly from a musicality perspective. Clearly he intended to make this beautiful piece into some sort of a show piece for violinists, but most people don't play it that way anymore, preferring Bach's original version. However, for some reason, the name has stuck.
From where they are placed, I would assume that the + denotes when to use the damper pedal and the P denotes when the release it. I’ve personally never seen that style of notation for pedal before, so it is very possible I may be mistaken.
Paul, I'm a huge fan and love all your videos but it sounds like your piano needs some voicing work. The tone for me has become a bit too brittle, especially for such a serene work.
Both being music usually play in wedding, air on the G string is way better than Pachelbel’s Canon in D in my opinion. Perfect interpretation as always👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻, playing as accurate as you do is my goal
Both being music usually play in wedding, Air on the G string is way better than Pachelbel’s Canon in D in my opinion. Perfect interpretation as always👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻, playing as accurate as you do is my goal
Really great. Love the attempt to put vibrato on a piano with the pinky in the right hand sometimes when hitting the "A". And I swear sometimes it works. That's when you know you're really feeling the music.
This to me is one of the greatest ever peaces of music, and I love how you have played it here.
You’re on such another level Paul. Thank you for existing in this realm.
ruclips.net/video/M7RcFFUk06A/видео.html
I agree, Paul is one of the greatest classical pianists of the modern age.
Nice transcription, and layout for the interior voices. Well played.
Tellement beau, merci pour ce partage Monsieur Paul Barton
Siloti's arrangements are completely incredible.Paul has played it very fluently
Are you familiar with his arrangement of Saint Seans ‘the Swan’? Another jewel.
Ah so happy to find your tutorial Paul. Thanks very much for your work, all the best,
ruclips.net/video/M7RcFFUk06A/видео.html
I needed help falling asleep and this did the trick. You play so peacefully and calmly. Good night all.
I love this piece; it brings me a chill vibe and relax my soul.
Love the right hand "vibratos". Good job, mate.
Amazing music from heaven and best interpretation. Thank you, Paul for bringing peace on earth.
Paul, this is marvelous! I just started learning this piece today, and with your screen setup I can see exactly how to play it, even the fingering! Thank you, thank you!!
3:28 Perfect vibrato... could be heard through the screen
JS Bach was way ahead of his time. It would have been interesting to see how his keyboard works would have sounded 100 to 150 years later. Even though this was a transcription it is absolutely a beautiful piece. Great job.
That piece is absolutely awesome especially because you perform it with sooooooo much passion I really admire your work 🖒
It doesn't seem very difficult, cus' a beginner can play it: ruclips.net/video/wLJluJQWX9U/видео.html
You can evoke passion without great techinical ability (of course Mr. Barton has both).
@@dylandecker_music I agree. I'm following that guy. He is improving fast.
There is not much passion there- only he tried to be as accurate to help those who want to learn the piece and those pianists have to be experienced in order to benefit from him
Superb transcription and playing. I love your rhythm feel, it's so firm and smooth and the same time. Listening to this almost feels like dreaming.
I love you touch and your singing. I find it very difficult to sing it so well like you do.
Very nice! Thank you! I am going to start learning this transcription !
Thank you for this wonderful birthday gift for me at my birthday
Great performance! Can’t wait to hear the other transcriptions of this piece.
Superb ! One of my favourite versions brilliantly played!
loved how you shaked your hand on the high notes
I love Siloti's arrangements! Great performance as always Paul
Gently gorgeous. Good for the soul . . .
Very beautiful. I don't think I knew this arrangement, or at least you made it new to me :D
One thing, if I may, at 0:45, and similarly in the repeat ai 1:48, the A you play with the left hand ends the phrase you have been playing with the right hand. However you make it sound like it is harmony, so, to me, the phrase is left hanging.
Thank you - wondervul ❤
Delicious performance! Thanks
I love this version
Hermoso tema de Joan Sebastian Bach, y la forma de tocarla con la partitura, en la pantalla, que gran idea, gran música y gran pianista, atentamente Fernando Rojas Lima Perú
The only thing that could make this channel better would be if you would upload some Chopin Mazurkas.
Paul, our repertoire is very similar, but I must admit you really make this piece sing. Thank you!!
Hi sir tnxs for making tutorial...its great...and im really enjoying while watching you how to play....Good job and more power...
never thought this would sound so good on a piano lol
Hello Barton, I really love your drawing and I was wondering if you could make tutorial about drawing and also how you got into drawing thank you
Thank you very much 😀
Spettacolare, davvero bravo !!!
Beautiful piece. Please record Bach/Siloti's Chaconne, it is a great piece too, both musically and pedagoguely .
Thank you ❤ It was very touching performance 🪔
Paul it's a beautiful performance on Bach. Thank you ✨🌟🌠
Good morning, Paul Barton - Thank you so much for sharing this great opportunity to listening to you ! Excellent and Beautiful Performance , Injoy listening to music !
♪Date 1/31/2019♪
Beautiful!!!!
Siloti's arrangements were always successful. Thank you Paul for your deep interpretation ☺
1, 2, 3, beautiful sad song
Please do a video of a piano arrangement of swan lake
I always listen your channel when I need to focus on studying.
LOVE ❤ from South Korea 🇰🇷
Magic!!!
I love your music, I love what you do, I wish I could be like you... How does one become as successful as you? I am struggling...
I have been waiting for this for a long time.
Lovely rendition Paul, Bravo. This I probably won't get read but I was wondering whether you would look at Chopin's Nocturne op 15 no 2. It's a wonderful piece in F Sharp Major in ABA form. Again, great performance.
Så vakkert 💙🎵🎶🎵🎹🎹
Nice. I simply enjoy listening
It's a beautiful piece and arrangement. I think this could do with some more attention to tone, balance and voicing, especially when played this slowly, to prevent it from falling apart. It could very well do with a bit more speed. The left hand is more supporting non legato (portato) but that disappears when you don't change the pedal at every note (or at least at every dissonant) , especially with the added effect of the harmonic pedal. Thanks for uploading, there are not many renditions of this piece around om youtube unfortunately.
Mr. Barton really has got a lot of teachers.
@@pianistjustforfun No wonder he is so good! He gets advice from so many experts! ;D
@@bobomber Aw, yes, envy has no bounds. Next, shall we critique his painting abilities?
@jl5555ls yes same arrangement. It's a good performance. Also I see Alessio Bax has a recording online which is good.
@jl5555ls ah thank you, I did not know of this recording. It sounds very good indeed, slow but still whole.
Paul you've been my reference point for soooo many pieces over my year and a half of learning.
All of your bach pieces have me mesmerized by the way your hands move and look. The expression with the "vibrato" almost looking hand movements is stunning.
thank you for all you do
Vv beautiful!!
Here is the score.
imslp.eu/linkhandler.php?path=/imglnks/euimg/1/1b/IMSLP09510-Siloti_-_Transcription_of_Bach%27s_Air_from_Suite_for_String_Orchestra_No.3,_BWV_1068.pdf
Thank you Angel :)
Can you do a recording of Schumann/Liszt's Widmung?
Yes ! Well done indeed ! I don't know what to add to all that has already been said below. When clicking on the above link the displayed IMSLP page doesn't seem to be the right one ...
See in "Arrangements and Transcriptions" then scroll down. It's quite far down in that section, and you'll find one marked "A. Siloti." (This includes only the Air and not the entire suite).
excellent!!!
I particularly remember the famous cigar ads that used this ... I wonder how far outside the UK they were used?
I am sorry for my inadequate English. When this music started to be popular again 100 years after Bach's lifetime, the knowlegde how to preform baroque music was almost forgotten. People asked for the sheet music, and the publishers faced a problem: There wasn't any information at all about tempo, dynamics, ritardando and so on, a common practise back then. So the publishers write their own opinions, like "Adagio (quaver = 63-66) melodia sempre cantando e molto espressive". Later on some musicans wanted to restore this old music and went to old sources. Therefore we know that this tempo is too slow.
Your English is better than my own.
Strongly prefer the original orchestral version,but your performance was excellent.
Try with Gulda's version
Lovely performance. So you are also a strings player?
I want to learn how to play piano and read piano music, I know how to read music but only limited, for I only know how to play the trumpet 🎺.
Perfect
Paul, did you just try vibrato at 1:40? Lol I've been watching your videos for such a long time but that's a first :P
Хорошая работа.
If I use the same fugue in repertoires does it become a refugee? 8>)
Paul, can't seem to locate this arrangement (by Siloti) on the link you've provided. Please check and advice. Many thanks and BRAVO for this lovely Bach piece. One of my favourites. cheers, Carol
There is it : imslp.eu/files/imglnks/euimg/1/1b/IMSLP09510-Siloti_-_Transcription_of_Bach%27s_Air_from_Suite_for_String_Orchestra_No.3,_BWV_1068.pdf
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Great
The name of this piece is not "Air on the G string". The name of the piece is just "Air", or "Air from Orchestral Suite No. 3 in D major" (BWV 1068). It's the second movement of Orchestral Suite No.3, although a lot of people don't know that nowadays. The "on the G String" part was added by some violinist who made a popular transcription where the piece is transposed into C Major from D Major and the melody is played down an octave, entirely on the G-string, which is honestly just silly from a musicality perspective. Clearly he intended to make this beautiful piece into some sort of a show piece for violinists, but most people don't play it that way anymore, preferring Bach's original version. However, for some reason, the name has stuck.
And thats why I don't want to learn it as a beginner piano player who loves classical music.
6:07 - hmm, weird... A "b" is heard even though the key has not been pressed. Was it recorded in post-production?
Could be an edit after filming. I have seem quite a few instances of this in his other videos.
Very Nice!
can you put ABCD note and figure number on?
gratidão
Great performance !! What +P mean ?
I'd like to know as well
From where they are placed, I would assume that the + denotes when to use the damper pedal and the P denotes when the release it. I’ve personally never seen that style of notation for pedal before, so it is very possible I may be mistaken.
Bravo!!!🙄😳👍
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Paul, I'm a huge fan and love all your videos but it sounds like your piano needs some voicing work. The tone for me has become a bit too brittle, especially for such a serene work.
1:51
I guess even pianists use vibrato.
must be published by Carl Fischer!
Both being music usually play in wedding, air on the G string is way better than Pachelbel’s Canon in D in my opinion. Perfect interpretation as always👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻, playing as accurate as you do is my goal
What these "+P" markings mean? Is just alternate way to write "* Ped"?
i think it's pedal markings
Where could I find that exact transcript?
right on this video! funny question!
imslp.eu/files/imglnks/euimg/1/1b/IMSLP09510-Siloti_-_Transcription_of_Bach%27s_Air_from_Suite_for_String_Orchestra_No.3,_BWV_1068.pdf
you're wlecome
@@unnamed_boi Thanks a lot
The old Hamlet cigar tune.
Omg I have that note same that thing I read it I play it like crazy 😂😂😂😅
i played that on my violin. very relaxing
Very "relaxing"?
And now replay 10 times faster bacause this piano sheet seems kinda rag arranged to me LOL
today is February 1
Piano vibrato
no se escucha la segunda voz
Up
E Piero Angela muto
yesssssssss
Assolutamente non eseguito bene. Non trattiene le note legate
Uiinnuy
too bumpy
Sorry, but no
Both being music usually play in wedding, Air on the G string is way better than Pachelbel’s Canon in D in my opinion. Perfect interpretation as always👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻, playing as accurate as you do is my goal