Why Jammu’s Politics Is Different from Kashmir: Senior Journalists Explain | Jammu News

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 137

  • @newslaundry
    @newslaundry  Месяц назад +1

    Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=social
    Power our coverage of the Israel-Gaza war: www.newslaundry.com/nl-sena/gaza-one-year-later-dispatches-from-ground-zero
    Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
    Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k

  • @aary9
    @aary9 Месяц назад +2

    It is a fact that the identity of the Jammu region is often sidelined for various reasons. One way for its people to reclaim their distinct identity and attract attention is to advocate for the creation of a separate state of Jammu. This demand could be justified, as states in India are often formed on linguistic and cultural grounds, and Jammu has its own unique linguistic and cultural identity.

  • @kayayvid8309
    @kayayvid8309 Месяц назад +4

    Jammu needs a leader like Sonam Wangchuk who is raising his voice for the betterment of the people of Ladakh. Jammu does not have any leader who is honest with the Jammu people. MPs like Jugal Kishore and Dr. Jatinder Singh have done nothing for Jammu instead of making false claims like Metro in Jammu.

  • @loveysjk04
    @loveysjk04 Месяц назад +27

    I'm a jammuite n da newspapers/print media are totally pro BJP..u can even see da newspapers filled wid BJP propaganda. These 2 print media reporters are echoing da pro bjp sentiment.

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад +3

      Then who should they be pro of?
      KHANGRESS or PDP/NC ULLAH'S?

    • @loveysjk04
      @loveysjk04 Месяц назад +5

      ​@@SAFFRONINFERNOofcourse NOT BJP, Andhbhakt.

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @@loveysjk04 NOT KHANGRESS, ITALIAN SLAVE

    • @allah_phaad_de_rasul_ki_gaand
      @allah_phaad_de_rasul_ki_gaand Месяц назад +2

      K2wa😂😂 triggered😂😂​@@loveysjk04

    • @shuvamgupta2236
      @shuvamgupta2236 Месяц назад

      @@loveysjk04 you arent dogra. dogras support bjp.

  • @SkyDartTech
    @SkyDartTech Месяц назад +6

    Happy to see you covering Jammu as well! ❤

  • @sayeedmalik392
    @sayeedmalik392 Месяц назад +1

    A thoroughly professional rendition. Both, the participants and the hosts made it a relishing experience to watch. A rare experience, becoming rarer with each passing day

  • @Sachistan
    @Sachistan Месяц назад +12

    Jammu is not only a jammu city but a large area of chenab valley and pir panjal range ,both of these are pro bjp persons please go doda bhaderwah rajouri poonch ..

    • @RamanSharma-cy3nq
      @RamanSharma-cy3nq Месяц назад +6

      Even people like me who are from Jammu City never supports BJP, bcz we know the truth of Gaddar BJP

    • @uzairr_wanii
      @uzairr_wanii Месяц назад +3

      @@Sachistan Bull crap. Pir Panjal did not vote for BJP even in Lok Sabha elections after BJP tried appeasing then with reservations. Keep Pir Panjal out of your Dogra nonsense.

  • @Shortlogy123
    @Shortlogy123 Месяц назад +7

    I am from District poonch of jammu region i believe that bjp have done many devlopmental work in jammu region but only in limited district samba kathua Jammu and udhampur and reasi but the pir panjal district Poonch Rajouri and chenab valley distric Dooda kishtwar and Ramban were not given much intrest

    • @SalmanQayoomRunyal
      @SalmanQayoomRunyal Месяц назад +4

      @@Shortlogy123 im from jmu main city
      Mje bhi btao jmu mai kdr development hui hai?
      Development k naam pr narwal side haryana punjab k kabadi aur mochi basa diye hai jinme majority log criminals hai

    • @Shortlogy123
      @Shortlogy123 Месяц назад +2

      @@SalmanQayoomRunyal Roads Flyover IIM IIT IIMS AIIMS BHUT HA BHI
      JO KIA HA WO DIKHTA HA
      I AM ALSO ANTI BJP BUT THEY HAVE DONE SOME THING

    • @KrishnkantSingh-qk8tk
      @KrishnkantSingh-qk8tk Месяц назад

      Will you vote for bjp or against?​@@Shortlogy123

    • @ankushgupta7398
      @ankushgupta7398 Месяц назад

      ​@@Shortlogy123that something isn't for us locals, rather vote for a good independent candidate

  • @zeenathbaig2203
    @zeenathbaig2203 Месяц назад +9

    Why not have 3 different states? Kashmir, jammu and ladakh.

    • @zeenathbaig2203
      @zeenathbaig2203 Месяц назад +1

      Those three will each be bigger than say kerala or himachal or even Goa.

    • @irfanjeelani9587
      @irfanjeelani9587 Месяц назад +2

      State hood is provided on population rather than on area …. Kutch of Gujarat is bigger than all three separately… 😂 who bechara district hai . Providing statehood has administrative and financial implications on government. Ladakh always wanted UT let it be …

    • @jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237
      @jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 Месяц назад

      @@irfanjeelani9587what about Goa,Manipur,Nagaland,Mizoram..why is UP a big state why are there 10 Hindi speaking states and not 1,why are there 2 Malayalam and Tamil speaking constituents one state and one UT
      statehood depends on National Interest nothing else..

    • @irfanjeelani9587
      @irfanjeelani9587 Месяц назад

      @@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 dear, first reorganisation of states in 1956 were done on linguistics basis also there nothing like that only “national interest “ should be there .reorganisation is a multifaceted process! For sake of argument who ever is at helms misuses power to deprive poor people of prosperity.

    • @jwala.d6156
      @jwala.d6156 Месяц назад

      @@zeenathbaig2203 nice idea

  • @kayayvid8309
    @kayayvid8309 Месяц назад

    I really like Mohit Kandhari Ji and Nishikant Khajuria Ji. They are not biased. They fairly presented the current scenario of the Jammu people.

  • @abhishek8977
    @abhishek8977 Месяц назад +14

    You should talk to real journos not these Godi fellows

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад +2

      REAL JOURNOS LIKE RUBBISH KUMAR?

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @MISHA_NARANG_SHARMA NO

    • @abhishek8977
      @abhishek8977 Месяц назад +5

      @@SAFFRONINFERNO Absolutely!! If you call Ravish kumar by this name then your views on journalism don't matter at all.

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @@abhishek8977 HE NEEDS TO BE CALLED THAT
      HE IS KHANGRESS RUBBISH

    • @kolardorpe3161
      @kolardorpe3161 Месяц назад

      Wokiest News laundry war on BJP in Jammu is a fiasco.

  • @Yeti_111
    @Yeti_111 Месяц назад +5

    Terrorist attacks, drugs rise in jammu , new reservation policy sucks

    • @ankushgupta7398
      @ankushgupta7398 Месяц назад

      Yep@@Yeti_111 , BJP is doing genocide on the people of Jammu by crossing the 50% reservation limit to 80%,..we need to rather vote for a good independent candidate 😡💯💯💯

    • @ankushgupta7398
      @ankushgupta7398 Месяц назад

      Yep @Yeti_111 , BJP is doing genocide on the people of Jammu by crossing the 50% reservation limit to 80%,..we need to rather vote for a good independent candidate 😡💯💯💯

  • @vsbhutiyal3844
    @vsbhutiyal3844 Месяц назад

    I would like you both to talk to senior journalist and political expert of j&k ZAFAR CHOUDHARY of THE DISPATCH.

  • @rajnishtuli3960
    @rajnishtuli3960 Месяц назад +6

    Jammu & Kashmir are divided into 2 communities. Like manipur.. .. So eethey syapa nahi mukna.. 😮😮

  • @sankalpswami3335
    @sankalpswami3335 Месяц назад

    great work newslaundry.

  • @umerfarooq-e2k
    @umerfarooq-e2k Месяц назад

    Lovely journalism.....

  • @sayyidadilhassanshahbaghda5573
    @sayyidadilhassanshahbaghda5573 Месяц назад +23

    4 lac Muslims were killed in Jammu, to change the demography.

    • @XT-999
      @XT-999 Месяц назад +13

      Man what a lie

    • @lazzateaatiraafekasoor1502
      @lazzateaatiraafekasoor1502 Месяц назад +5

      @@XT-999 this is true in 1920s

    • @llawliet57807
      @llawliet57807 Месяц назад +13

      Talking about demographics ? Well let's talk about demo graphics of kashmir valley then especially 1400 on wards 🤣

    • @able864
      @able864 Месяц назад +1

      What 😮

    • @MikaeilShah
      @MikaeilShah Месяц назад +2

      It happned I 1947 ​@@XT-999

  • @IncognitoSahil
    @IncognitoSahil Месяц назад

    7:50 Last i heard VDG haven't even been given their stipends yet.
    18:55 😅😅
    I really appreciate Jammu reports.

  • @zahoorsheikh6560
    @zahoorsheikh6560 Месяц назад

    They awakned late but already time is lost

  • @truthalwaysprevails662
    @truthalwaysprevails662 Месяц назад +1

    The choice of words clearly indicates which party they sympathize for. People can also say they are patriotic but seems BJPwalas are allergic to this word.

  • @abhishek8977
    @abhishek8977 Месяц назад +7

    It is unbelievable that BJP or any bjp stooges get elected in j&k. I'm sure these jammu journos are godi media

    • @pinkithakur1515
      @pinkithakur1515 Месяц назад +3

      Ha ha lol kashmir Kashmir karte ho media prr toh problem nhi
      Jammu kii baat hue toh Godi ho gya yeah double standard kaha se aata h
      Kashmir idealistic different Jammu different
      Jammu peoples Dogra full support nationalist party congress or BJP
      But congress jammu issue km baat karte thee isliye bjp prr hope bnna last 10 yr se
      15 years phela BJP thee nhi jammu and kashmir mai

    • @abhishek8977
      @abhishek8977 Месяц назад

      @@pinkithakur1515 ruclips.net/video/cuZTtbQ2eWY/видео.htmlfeature=shared

  • @ishanishan1406
    @ishanishan1406 Месяц назад

    BJP empowered the only single Jammu District in Jammu Division mein... For better understanding compare JKSSB district wise selection list of nearby districts of Jammu and compare pre Abrogation selection list with post 370 Abrogation selection lists.

  • @Educationkids-d6h
    @Educationkids-d6h Месяц назад

    When a journalist talks in one direction, ultimately people feel biased

  • @kaeshurphysicist
    @kaeshurphysicist Месяц назад

    Sad that NL couldn't be brave enough to sit with some Kashmiri journalists. Anyways sensible discussion. And Man! The people of Jammu are jealous of us. Lol.

    • @Ario55-cc
      @Ario55-cc Месяц назад

      Jealous of what?
      Berozgari and dr_ug addiction ???

    • @kaeshurphysicist
      @kaeshurphysicist Месяц назад

      @@Ario55-cc I don't know why! Maybe they feel obliviated by the fact that Kashmir is always in focus. Since you've mentioned, yes there has been increase in drug abuse (especially since 2019), partly we are to blame; but, as some would argue, it is also due to the systematic negligence in order to disenfranchise Kashmiri youth. Anyways, salam!

  • @AjmalKhan-kl5kj
    @AjmalKhan-kl5kj Месяц назад +5

    Congress will win jai congress ❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉❤❤🎉🎉

  • @uzairr_wanii
    @uzairr_wanii Месяц назад +8

    The thing is that Kashmir has a homogeneous population, even if you include the exiled Pandits still more than 90% population is Muslim.
    Jammu is divided, not only in terms of population but also very diverse geographically. There is mainland Jammu i,e 5 districts that is Dogra inhabited (Hindus vast majority of them), Pir Panjal (Pahari inhabited vast majority of PP being Muslim), then Chenab valley where both populations are almost equal. So there is a lot of friction going on, especially with a right wing Hindu party in power. And all the projects that panelists are talking about here (IIM, AIIMS, IIT) have all been allocated in the Dogra belt not Pir Panjal or Chenab.
    Also the Asifa case did massive damage to the communal fabric of Jammu. After that r*pe, Asifa being denied burial in Rathsana by local Hs, local Hindus marching in support of r*pists, Gujjars being boycotted that year in Jammu city, Dogra lawyers attacking in court. In addition to that Hindu right is emboldened in Jammu post 2014, carrying out rallies with arms in hands, raising provocative slogans and even multiple cases of lynching MusIims . Emboldenment of Hindu right wing in Jamnu post 2014 is something no media house talks about.

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад +5

      WHAT DAMAGE TO COMMUNAL FABRIC?
      COUNTLESS HINDU'S WERE KILLED IN KASHMIR VIA MUZLIM'S
      BUT NO DAMAGE TO COMMUNAL FABRIC THERE AS IT'S JUSTIFIED UNDER UMMAH SECULAR RAJ

    • @uzairr_wanii
      @uzairr_wanii Месяц назад

      @@SAFFRONINFERNO Gangoos better not meddle their nose in issues they have no idea about. Go ask any Muslim from Doda, Kishtwar, Ramban, Reasi, Jammu city (Gujjar Nagar specifically) if situation on ground is same as it was before 2014. Asifa case exposed all the existing fault lines and with emboldened Hindu right wing the fault lines are only widening with each passing day.

    • @uzairr_wanii
      @uzairr_wanii Месяц назад +1

      @@Lakshay-u8m I am not saying that everyone threw themselves behind Asifa rapists but that it exposed the existing fault lines and did damage to the communal fabric. There have been quite some lynchings as well post 2014 in Jammu as well as attacks on Gujjar shanties. The situation is definitely not the same as it was prior to 2014 on ground.

    • @llawliet57807
      @llawliet57807 Месяц назад +5

      @@uzairr_wanii your half right half wrong
      first the people and ethnicity.
      Dogra heartland (most developed area) : speak dogri (western Pahari branch ) mainly hindus
      Pir panchal : speak pahari gojri (western Pahari branch) mainly muslims with major hindu population in cities like poonch and rajouri.
      Chenab valley : well this region is more complicated than it seems. You see the native people of this region are paharis ( sirazi bhaderwahi padri kistwadi(pahadi)). All these people are mainly hindus and fall under western Pahari branch .
      However during 1700s 1800s many kashmiri muslims migrated from valley and settled in this region changing the demography to 50:50.
      Now in dogra heartland majority do support getting separated from Kashmir and sentiment is strong (90% want seperation).
      In pir panchal although they are Muslims given they are more related to dogras than Kashmiris and also jammu city serves as a main centre for this who want to get education health facilities or employment not kashmir. Given on this if they had to choose I believe around 60-70% would choose jammu .
      Now coming to pir panchal as I said earlier 50% is already reserved now add the same reasons for as pir panchal Kashmiri muslims of chenab valley would choose jammu for health education employment etc over kashmir. So if given a choice it would be around (70-80%)
      Now you said something related IIM IIT AIIMS. Brother the reason all of these are in jammu is not because of bias it's simply because jammu is far more favourable place to establish these kind of institutions. It's lies in plain area with connectivity to all areas as well as main land area. How will you set up an IIT in pir panchal ? Would you expect a student from chenab to go all the way to pp? Or vice versa ? Jammu is centre to both pp and chenab valley also has housing and pgs for students that's why it was chosen .
      Also all of dogra heartland districts are devloped not because of bias but geography.
      Jammu City : industrial base , strong economy , centre of jammu region , students from pp and chenab , gate way to Kashmir and ladakh , starting point of vaishno devi etc
      Udhampur : centre of indian army northern command , tourism places
      Reasi : vaishno devi . 1cr pilgrims visit every year
      Samba , kathua : industrial and manufacturing hubs. Close to Punjab border so have good trade and transport.
      You see dogra heartland is literally a self sufficient region due to its geographical location. Entire pir panchal and chenab depends on if. If this region got seperated pp and chensb would suffer the most. That's why jammu as a whole will get seperated not some selected areas

    • @llawliet57807
      @llawliet57807 Месяц назад +2

      @@SAFFRONINFERNO oh one more. I am from udhampur and go to jammu for studies. In most colleges majority students are from pir panchal and chenab valley. I have friends from both region hindu and muslims alike. I don't see any weak fabric between us. I had talked with my friend from chenab (sirazi from Doda) he mentioned the same points.

  • @sanjayverma962
    @sanjayverma962 Месяц назад

    Kuch muddo ko inn logo ne nazar andaz kiya wo hai Mining mafiya and Liquor policy?

  • @BENHUR4U
    @BENHUR4U Месяц назад +1

    Has ‘nationalism’ made a comeback???
    Forget Nationalists, Is that even a question & should that even be a question to any self respecting & any Indian who loves his country.
    But for News Laundry Nationalism should not exist in the people in INDIA
    It is evident Manisha Pande, Abhinandan Sekhri & their lackeys does not like what people say in Jammu, they both would rather hear what people in Kashmir Valley say about INDIA

  • @suhaassharma6312
    @suhaassharma6312 Месяц назад

    N KHAJURIA SPELLS SOME BASIC AND ABOUT FREE DOM OF SPEECH IN RIGHT MANNERS ✅️ ❤

  • @Tryto.826
    @Tryto.826 Месяц назад

    Shetal devi and urfan malik both are both ethnically Kashmiris (by race) political divisions doesn't mean they are not Kashmiris....poonch,rajouri, doda, kishtwar, ramban are ethnically Kashmiri dominated districts....even in other districts like kathua, udhampur, jammu have Kashmiri population....

    • @Tryto.826
      @Tryto.826 Месяц назад

      @@Lakshay-u8m in bani basoli...many people are ethinic Kashmiris...may be they don't speak Kashmiri...

    • @bhanu9725
      @bhanu9725 Месяц назад

      @@Tryto.826sheetal devi isnt a kashmiri, her father’s name is maan singh
      A pahadi rajput!

  • @Feelmotivated-nk9ex
    @Feelmotivated-nk9ex Месяц назад

    Hindu are with going away of 370(mostly) muslim are against it

  • @suhaassharma6312
    @suhaassharma6312 Месяц назад

    Er Rashid get one or two seats maximum That's to by default 🤔

  • @suhaassharma6312
    @suhaassharma6312 Месяц назад +1

    N C will touch max 35

  • @ziaullah8406
    @ziaullah8406 Месяц назад

    Everything developed in and around the jammu city
    Not in jammu region

  • @PawanSharmaBaru
    @PawanSharmaBaru Месяц назад

    National media ney 10 saal Jammu province ko ignore kiya
    Isko koee challenge karey

  • @ariphg5869
    @ariphg5869 Месяц назад +1

    Congress can do best

  • @ziaullah8406
    @ziaullah8406 Месяц назад

    BJP will get 30 seat because jammu people will vote on religious lines

  • @PawanSharmaBaru
    @PawanSharmaBaru Месяц назад +1

    Jammu k jitney b akhbaar hai, yeah sab kon sey doodh k dooley hai

  • @leisingh20011
    @leisingh20011 Месяц назад

    They know how to pick people. All of these need help

  • @Mdtanbir-ih8jv
    @Mdtanbir-ih8jv Месяц назад

    🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤🎉

  • @DrNayeem1835
    @DrNayeem1835 Месяц назад

    This is shocking….these are nt journalists….they are IT cell or whtspp university uncles

  • @RamanSharma-cy3nq
    @RamanSharma-cy3nq Месяц назад

    I am from Jammu and I always supported Art 370 and there are so many people who still supports 370, BJP is the root cause of every problem in J&K, BJP is a party of Adani and Modi is just the Remote controlled puppet of Adani

  • @Letmehaveopinion
    @Letmehaveopinion Месяц назад +1

    Anyone can live settle in jammu. It's a free country. Integration but can't allow outside to buy land. It's strange
    Anyone are free to reside anywhere. I'm sure jammu will be the first place then later kashmir.
    But jammu soon will be strange land .

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      MUZLIM'S SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO SETTLE IN JAMMU

    • @Letmehaveopinion
      @Letmehaveopinion Месяц назад +1

      @@SAFFRONINFERNO jammu already has 45% muslim population.
      Why are you scared of them? Hindu rashtra banaoge kya.

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @@Letmehaveopinion THEY WERE ALLOWED TO SETTLE BY KHANGRESS FOR VOTE BANK
      WE ONLY HATE THEM

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @@Lakshay-u8m THEN WHY CRY OF VICTIMISATION AND FASCISM CHEW TEA

    • @SAFFRONINFERNO
      @SAFFRONINFERNO Месяц назад

      @@Lakshay-u8m So?

  • @TNT-ol5tm
    @TNT-ol5tm Месяц назад

    Na jamat khuch kare gi na ER Rashid.....

  • @ExcitedPassengerShip-tz2wp
    @ExcitedPassengerShip-tz2wp Месяц назад

    Fatty Journalist from talks looks completely communal, bias, BJP supportive, and spks BJP narrative. The other one journal looks secular.

  • @sameerthakur5661
    @sameerthakur5661 Месяц назад

    Koi sense hai iski baat ka. He contradicts himself

  • @Lover14652
    @Lover14652 Месяц назад

    चोरों की तरह रिर्पोटिंग और भेड़ियों की तरह
    बाते बेवकूफ कही के 😂😂😂

  • @tauqeerrather3949
    @tauqeerrather3949 Месяц назад

    They both r godi media of jammu

  • @loveysjk04
    @loveysjk04 Месяц назад +2

    Jammuites are also against da abrogation of 370 n 35a..da abrogation has ruined r state. We need UT n 370 revoked.

  • @kdfruits4823
    @kdfruits4823 Месяц назад

    Only BJP 💪

  • @dangerousguy1635
    @dangerousguy1635 Месяц назад

    Newslaundry its not fare to put frame of Jammu region without having a wide representation of Pir panjal and Doda areas.... these are Pro BJP persons.....that means views and interpretations should be biased.

  • @saida87229
    @saida87229 Месяц назад

    Bahut dukh hai ki Newslatrine ke Paw Paw Nasrullah Sahib *72 mard hours* ke paas gaye 😂😂😂
    Sekri sahib zaroori suchna: pager, mobile,toilet seat, fridge na use karein 😂😂😂 Urgent hogaya toh Madamji ke muh mein haggde 😂😂😂

    • @maazkalim
      @maazkalim Месяц назад

      You are quite a cringe failure in creating shock-content, you know that.. No? All you succeed is simply unearthing your communalism, “Saida”.
      Regardless..
      This one is also replete with violent-threats, and therefore reported accordingly.

  • @rishuraj-t1i
    @rishuraj-t1i Месяц назад

    Jammu will be a clean sweep by bjp

    • @ankushgupta7398
      @ankushgupta7398 Месяц назад

      BJP is doing genocide on the people of Jammu by crossing the 50% reservation limit to 80%,..we need to rather vote for a good independent candidate 😡💯💯💯