Great vid - would be interested for more of these especially as it's harder to come to the store to try things out right now.. Personal (and blind tested) favs are Basimilus and Jomox here.
Jomox sounds the best to me in terms of weight and the variety of tones you can get out of a module. But its "click" part feels separate from the body/sub. I think it's a must to run it through some saturation and/or compression to "glue" all the components together. Awesome comparison video btw.
@@nym053 Kind of a pain to dial that in with modular gear though. I reckon it's feasible with the ER-301 although I'm not 100% sure how I'd go about that. A lot of eurorack users don't seem to be using EQ, or are running something pretty basic.
great video! hex BD9 gets pretty wholesome. all seem useful sounding for different applications. for my needs and desired sound, my biased love is undeniable; erica bassdrum is the truth.
Thanks for this comparison! My favorites are Mutant BD and BIA. The L.E.P. Cassa sounds kind of weird but i guess this is what you have to expect from a L.E.P. Module :D
Thanks and this was helpful. My fav is the Tiptop BD09. Tones are great. Easy to dial in a solid fundamental kick. If I want more, I can add to the sound. I cant add to a heavy transient or noisy sound. While I enjoy just playing with the BIA...its a pain to add in a mix where the other sounds are clean or more clean. All this said, I just ordered the SSF Ultra Kick. Hoping its fundamental is solid and when I want to add more, I can do that all in one place. Plus I want to use it for sub bass texture.
Für Sound Design finde ich Crater und Modbase am besten. Sind am vielseitigsten. BIA ist nicht ganz so gut wie das LIP für kicks, aber beide sind mmn. ne absolute Verschwendung wenn man sie nur für kicks benutzt, man sollte einfach resamplen und das damit machen was man damit machen soll und zwar die Module modulieren. Meine liebste kick ist immer noch die BoomTschak von AudioDamage, das mit nem tanh[³] als Waveshaper/Limiter/Feedback und Godeater zur Verzerrung und das Gebäude stürzt ein. Am besten das Signal in nen LR4 crossover filter. Die lows-lowmids in ein Desmodus Versio parallel zum Dry Signal und ne richtig dicke rumble kick draus machen, geht ab wie sau ...
Great, Can you buy all those modules in one? I like that you focussed on the sounds, Rather than what each can do =) There are A LOT of producers out there making music for the wrong reasons, Forgetting that at its core, Sound is what it is all about. great video
It does for sure, vaguely regret selling mine. It's just takes up so much rack space lol, can be quite slow to dial in the right sound as well. I might get one in the future and keep it outside the rack next time.
Yeah, any collection of more traditional modules wired up the right way and dialed in just perfectly, but like the other replies said that takes up a lot more space than any of these modules. That's just the trade-off
@@stinkymart3173 Takes up space and you lose the immediacy of a dedicated module that way. Some people are into modular because they want to design everything from scratch, others want to design an instrument that does exactly what they want, how they want it, and that can include being able to dial in a kick without interrupting your workflow. Both approaches are totally valid, and I think most modular users probably fall into the middle there somewhere with a lot of sound design capabilities but dedicated modules with a niche/specific range as well.
think all eurorack kicks sounds better though and good filter with separate controlled adsr.. That’s how I run my Boomtschak .. gets very fat and sounds more modern
WMD really making game changing drum modules, all sound great and completely unique
0:25 BD909
1:46 BD808
2:28 Hexinverter BD9
4:40 Mutant Bassdrum
6:50 WMD Crater
8:40 Basimilus Iteritas Alter
10:00 Erica Synths Bass Drum
11:33 Modbase 09 MKII
13:38 2HP Kick
15:00 LEP Cassa
16:52 Befaco Kickall
Erica all day every day
And twice on Sunday
Awesome kick setup, one can never havetoo many bassdrum options 👍🏻
Great vid - would be interested for more of these especially as it's harder to come to the store to try things out right now.. Personal (and blind tested) favs are Basimilus and Jomox here.
agree and BIA is super versatile can do more if you modulate it and Jomox is just a beast.
Jomox sounds the best to me in terms of weight and the variety of tones you can get out of a module. But its "click" part feels separate from the body/sub. I think it's a must to run it through some saturation and/or compression to "glue" all the components together. Awesome comparison video btw.
run it thru Mutant Hot glue compressor mixer
Or not use the click/noise at all :)
@@nym053 yeah but sometimes you might want some top-end on yar kick 🙂
@@piotr803 use an eq bell curve, then you don't loose the roundness of your transients :)
@@nym053 Kind of a pain to dial that in with modular gear though. I reckon it's feasible with the ER-301 although I'm not 100% sure how I'd go about that. A lot of eurorack users don't seem to be using EQ, or are running something pretty basic.
Crater + Jomox + Tiptop 909
Basimilus sounds great
great video! hex BD9 gets pretty wholesome. all seem useful sounding for different applications. for my needs and desired sound, my biased love is undeniable; erica bassdrum is the truth.
Jomox ModBase MK2 or WMD Crater are my winners
Thanks for this comparison! My favorites are Mutant BD and BIA. The L.E.P. Cassa sounds kind of weird but i guess this is what you have to expect from a L.E.P. Module :D
Great! Jomox, Crater really kicking, and clicking. Mutant 9 and Basilimus nice variety
Extremely helpful. Thanks for making video.
this case is my dream
Thanks and this was helpful. My fav is the Tiptop BD09. Tones are great. Easy to dial in a solid fundamental kick. If I want more, I can add to the sound. I cant add to a heavy transient or noisy sound. While I enjoy just playing with the BIA...its a pain to add in a mix where the other sounds are clean or more clean. All this said, I just ordered the SSF Ultra Kick. Hoping its fundamental is solid and when I want to add more, I can do that all in one place. Plus I want to use it for sub bass texture.
An analog Oscillator Comparison would be great in the future as i'm searching for a replacement for my Doepfer A-110-1
Für Sound Design finde ich Crater und Modbase am besten. Sind am vielseitigsten. BIA ist nicht ganz so gut wie das LIP für kicks, aber beide sind mmn. ne absolute Verschwendung wenn man sie nur für kicks benutzt, man sollte einfach resamplen und das damit machen was man damit machen soll und zwar die Module modulieren. Meine liebste kick ist immer noch die BoomTschak von AudioDamage, das mit nem tanh[³] als Waveshaper/Limiter/Feedback und Godeater zur Verzerrung und das Gebäude stürzt ein. Am besten das Signal in nen LR4 crossover filter. Die lows-lowmids in ein Desmodus Versio parallel zum Dry Signal und ne richtig dicke rumble kick draus machen, geht ab wie sau ...
I'm also curious how that sounds! Any sound demo?
l like the crater also
Sampling time !!!!!
Jomox sounded the heaviest followed by Hexinverter Mutant Bass Drum
WMD Crater and then Jomox IMO, BD9 was solid too.
Thank you
Super helpful!
Interesting 👍
Great, Can you buy all those modules in one? I like that you focussed on the sounds, Rather than what each can do =) There are A LOT of producers out there making music for the wrong reasons, Forgetting that at its core, Sound is what it is all about. great video
Can you make a gabber kick on the BD909 tho?
And boomtschak wins! Fatality! Yeah I know it’s discontinued just sayin
Hi, did you use sample, kick drum,
thanks.
crush on mutant bass drum
ok i want the crater
love mine super fun and don't forget about fracture and chimera those are superb unique percussion modules as well
@@GuitarsAndSynths hey Boiler Room
A matter of personal taste. Got my Jomox today, will send it back an keep my ssf entity bass...-
Just my personal opinion but I think a Moog DFAM sounds more rich an deep than all of these.
It does for sure, vaguely regret selling mine. It's just takes up so much rack space lol, can be quite slow to dial in the right sound as well. I might get one in the future and keep it outside the rack next time.
DFAM+Subharmonicon would be great portable setup.
Agreed. I sometimes just tune it to a sound and trigger it externally w/o the internal sequencer.
Yeah, any collection of more traditional modules wired up the right way and dialed in just perfectly, but like the other replies said that takes up a lot more space than any of these modules. That's just the trade-off
@@stinkymart3173 Takes up space and you lose the immediacy of a dedicated module that way. Some people are into modular because they want to design everything from scratch, others want to design an instrument that does exactly what they want, how they want it, and that can include being able to dial in a kick without interrupting your workflow.
Both approaches are totally valid, and I think most modular users probably fall into the middle there somewhere with a lot of sound design capabilities but dedicated modules with a niche/specific range as well.
ok basilimus also
bit where is the mfb and cwejman kick???
come oooooon 😭😭😭
Hey Serdar, we didn't include them because both modules are not available anymore. But MFB and Cwejman both are nice options!
ok jomox...
They all sound pretty crappy
True
you really need to run them thru a compressor to clean them up
you should hear them on a PA, specially the jomox.. it doesn't need ANYTHING, sounds like a tank coming through the walls
think all eurorack kicks sounds better though and good filter with separate controlled adsr.. That’s how I run my Boomtschak .. gets very fat and sounds more modern