Alhamdullilah thank you so much for such a beautiful podcast. Sheikh Panju has so beautifully explained the relation of knowledge of Usul-e-deem to historical aspects of Kerbala …
Those resistance fighters dying in south lebanon would have been with the imam in Karbala. Those who lose their sons fighting against the Yazid of today would have been in the caravan of Sit Zaynab (as)
You are using your own man-made analogy. How do you know? Do you know that offensive Jihad during the ghaybat of Imam Mahdi (ajf) has been explicitly forbidden?
@@imzy0173who said anything about an offensive jihad??? Did you not read the post, "RESISTANCE" fighters!!! For crying out loud, if you arent willing join the battle, at least dont get in the way of those who are in the trenches. Keep yourself busy with netflix instead.
@@imzy0173 The Lebanese resistance is fighting a defensive Jihad not offensive. The history is clear since even prior to the existence of the Zionist state. Many even Shia viallages were wiped out during the Nakba and later on as the native Shia Palestinian Population was exterminated.
Thats ilm e gayb and if they would be then Allah(swt) would have enabled to be born in that time to reach their maximum reward. The reality is we are blessed to not be born at that time because our stance would be highly different as hindsight of today leads us to 20-20.
A man Like Hussein (as) in The Present era can only be Imam Mahdi (as) .. but a man LIKE Yazid can be any Haramzada who is killing.The Twelver Shi'a Resistance Fighters in any time. That includes especially Benjamin Netanyahu & The Wahhabi Sellouts who defend him AND Yazid historicaly as their Caliphs. They're all on the same side .
Ayatollah Mohammad Asif Muhsini describes this phenomenon by saying, “Most of the details of what occurred in Karbala are unknown, though the masses ask for what causes them to weep, and the preachers seek wealth and status, and this is what caused the current matter of the storytellers.” (Mashra’at Bihar Al-Anwar 2/156)
Asif Muhsini was the biggest wahhabi agent in the guise of Shia clothing. See how he literally weakened pretty much everything that didn't fit with his strict rijaal gradings.
Asif Muhseni weakens almost the whole shia religion... Btw his gradings are the same as sunnis that's why he came to the same conclusions as the sunnis. If you take his belief and sunnis belief it's similar
@@louisdeniau8571 thats very shallow. Most hadeeth narrated in Buhkari, Muslim let alone any historical work wouldn't fall into Muhsini's criteria of saheeh..
I dont understand - when the Awaited one comes, he will establish a new civilization with a wave of a wand??? What about Dajjal and Sufiyani? There wont be a battle? But hang on, civilizations, according to this guest are not established through "military expeditions". Furthermore, he says that we should draw inspirations from our Imams in terms of political stances. Fine, and then do what with that? Remember, the Imam will establish the new civilization...I have no role in that until the reappearance. Lastly, he mentions that people are in ghaflaah because few are speaking about what happened in Oman. This is very questionable as many are speaking about it, however few are feeding into the sectarian narrative which was most likely the goal of what happened in Oman by those who want nothing more than to add fuel to the sectarian fire when there seems to be rapprochement between the ahle sunna and the shia, at least on the Palestinian front. I do agree with the guest though, be careful where you get your Islam from...especially while watching this episode! May we be amongst those who witness the reapparance, but more importantly, may Allah protect us from being amongst those who are prolonging his occultation.
Alhamdullilah thank you so much for such a beautiful podcast. Sheikh Panju has so beautifully explained the relation of knowledge of Usul-e-deem to historical aspects of Kerbala …
The most important aspect for the Ashura movement is the restoration of the Wilayah of Ameeral Momineen Ali ibne Abi talib a.s
Sheikh MAP- a true Hussaini
Sheikh Abbas Panju the goat 🐐 May Allah bless him!
Beautiful. Very well explained by the Shaikh
Absolutely fantastic discussion, long and very deep 🌸🌸 loved the points about logic too
Ahsant brothers beautiful episode as always
Those resistance fighters dying in south lebanon would have been with the imam in Karbala. Those who lose their sons fighting against the Yazid of today would have been in the caravan of Sit Zaynab (as)
You are using your own man-made analogy. How do you know? Do you know that offensive Jihad during the ghaybat of Imam Mahdi (ajf) has been explicitly forbidden?
@@imzy0173who said anything about an offensive jihad??? Did you not read the post, "RESISTANCE" fighters!!! For crying out loud, if you arent willing join the battle, at least dont get in the way of those who are in the trenches. Keep yourself busy with netflix instead.
@@imzy0173 The Lebanese resistance is fighting a defensive Jihad not offensive. The history is clear since even prior to the existence of the Zionist state. Many even Shia viallages were wiped out during the Nakba and later on as the native Shia Palestinian Population was exterminated.
Thats ilm e gayb and if they would be then Allah(swt) would have enabled to be born in that time to reach their maximum reward. The reality is we are blessed to not be born at that time because our stance would be highly different as hindsight of today leads us to 20-20.
A man Like Hussein (as) in The Present era can only be Imam Mahdi (as) .. but a man LIKE Yazid can be any Haramzada who is killing.The Twelver Shi'a Resistance Fighters in any time. That includes especially Benjamin Netanyahu & The Wahhabi Sellouts who defend him AND Yazid historicaly as their Caliphs. They're all on the same side .
Ayatollah Mohammad Asif Muhsini describes this phenomenon by saying, “Most of the details of what occurred in Karbala are unknown, though the masses ask for what causes them to weep, and the preachers seek wealth and status, and this is what caused the current matter of the storytellers.” (Mashra’at Bihar Al-Anwar 2/156)
Asif Muhsini was the biggest wahhabi agent in the guise of Shia clothing. See how he literally weakened pretty much everything that didn't fit with his strict rijaal gradings.
whats the point of shia islam if there is so much corruption. its shows that there is something wrong with the religion
@@imzy0173 having strict criteria makes him wahhabi? So should he have relaxed standards? I respect him for his consistency and having a yardstick.
Asif Muhseni weakens almost the whole shia religion... Btw his gradings are the same as sunnis that's why he came to the same conclusions as the sunnis. If you take his belief and sunnis belief it's similar
@@louisdeniau8571 thats very shallow. Most hadeeth narrated in Buhkari, Muslim let alone any historical work wouldn't fall into Muhsini's criteria of saheeh..
I dont understand - when the Awaited one comes, he will establish a new civilization with a wave of a wand??? What about Dajjal and Sufiyani? There wont be a battle? But hang on, civilizations, according to this guest are not established through "military expeditions". Furthermore, he says that we should draw inspirations from our Imams in terms of political stances. Fine, and then do what with that? Remember, the Imam will establish the new civilization...I have no role in that until the reappearance. Lastly, he mentions that people are in ghaflaah because few are speaking about what happened in Oman. This is very questionable as many are speaking about it, however few are feeding into the sectarian narrative which was most likely the goal of what happened in Oman by those who want nothing more than to add fuel to the sectarian fire when there seems to be rapprochement between the ahle sunna and the shia, at least on the Palestinian front. I do agree with the guest though, be careful where you get your Islam from...especially while watching this episode! May we be amongst those who witness the reapparance, but more importantly, may Allah protect us from being amongst those who are prolonging his occultation.