@Emma Madison yes, this bit with Howie is so poorly scripted and boring it's cringe worthy. However Sofia is actually that funny, quick, and straightforward 😂 watch some of her interviews if you ever want a laugh
3:50 “you have all the talent, skill, range, and what this show needs but i don’t like musical theatre so it’s a no from me” what??? that’s being a bad judge! isn’t the whole point to judge FAIRLY?
Something I noticed with Simon is that he usually gives actual critisisms, hes not super rude or disrespectful and he knows a good voice when he hears it and thats something I respect about him besides there always needs to be a "mean" judge
@@BlackHayateTheThird He was a bastard in his older stuff for sure, and he still can be. The difference is that he tends to at least be in the ballpark with his insults. He might be blunt and cruel to people he thinks did badly, but he is generally right that they did bad. It reminds me of the difference between Gordon and Joe in the US masterchef. Gordon has his quirks and can be extremely abrasive, but the combination of his charisma and the consistency of his criticism makes him tolerable even when he is roasting someone. Joe on the other hand oozes sleaze and dishonesty, and his criticisms are often bizarre and inconsistent. So he is almost intolerable. Same kind of thing here. Simon commands respect with his opinions, even when they are harsh. Howie comes across as a buffoon.
This is being a bad judge. He literally stated that it’s not HIS type of music and that’s the only reason he said no. She had talent and it was obvious. Sometimes the hard part of being a judge is seeing talent in skill even if it’s your personal entertainment
@@billseron2391 Whether you like the music or not, it doesn't matter. They're on a show for TALENT, not good music (unless of course the song writing is a part of the talent that you are demonstrating, which even in that case sometimes you can still see their talent in singing and not just song writing). She clearly has talent, and that is what this show is about, not individual taste in music. This was a clear case of letting your bias cloud your judgment and nothing else. I personally am not a huge fan of the song choice or musical theater but I cannot deny that she has talent and deserves to go through.
@@roselrii of course it, every television show is. How else do you think sometimes ant and deck have items matched as the contestants. You know like sometimes they just whip out paint brushes out of nowhere, when the contestant is painting or something
@@hearts4mikeafton It's from the Grinch Who Stole Christmas. The Grinch is green, and the song says, "You're a mean one, Mr Grinch". So, Howie's a mean one.
There are so many singers on this show that it's silly to give a singer a golden buzzer because there's gonna be another singer who's at least just as good. Also it's a scripted show where they always use the buzzer for children so it doesn't matter.
@@TiredEyePilot what show do you watch? Plenty of adults have gotten golden buzzers in fact more adults have gotten it and not kids even assuming groups are 1 person. Now that being said, the golden buzzers more often than not go to people/groups with a "sob story".
"We are gonna support talent, we are gonna encourage talent" Now that's being a judge, not: "I don't enjoy it, so it's a no even if you have a lot of talent"
When Howie was covering his ears and shouting” nananana” he sure acted like a little kid. That voice was AWESOME! Who could say no to that? Hater Howie
I'm not a fan of musical theatre either, but how could you say "no" to that voice? She's got amazing talent! The show is called "America's Got Talent," it shouldn't matter the judge's personal preferences.
It reminds me of a mediocre lady singing in a frozen kids party. He didn’t say no because of Broadway, he clearly said no because she’s boring and mediocre. Yeah she’s a nice girl though.
The look on Simon's face as he listened to her sing, I don't think I've ever seen him with that much of an expression before. Truly an enchanting voice.
is it just me or did when you first saw this you thought howie dyed himself green😂😂😂😂😂 I'm laughing at my stupidity. I'm glad I'm not the only one out there. thanks for making me feel less stupid😂
@@hemuli123faithinthefuture4 how dumb founded you must be to not realize? I mean he dress as green, everytime he said anything it has the grinch background song in it, and it was christmas, so tell me isn't that obvious that they wanted him to act as a Grinch in Christmas because Howie is almost never been angry in the whole show?
I'm glad Simon stood up for that lady! Even if you don't like musicals you have to admit she was talented! She has the voice, range, power and thick skin to make it in Broadway! Good luck girl!
This is why Simon actually plays the mean role better. Not on x factor or whatever else he did I honestly forgot because that was just him being cruel. But on agt he is the more judgy one but he doesn't act cruel or like a baby and he can appreciate talent even if it's not his taste
Yeah, Simon's never mean to anyone who is talented. If a contestant has real talent, but it's in a category he's not super into, he still recognizes the talent and supports it.
He wasn’t cruel just brutally honest, like yes he did make fun of some people but he could immediately see that they were lying to themselves that they were good and he was trying to stop that before it came out of hand
I think Simon used to play up being a dick back in the day more before these types of shows were so established because as much as people like watching talented Acts they equally liked if not more the acts that were terrible and would get ripped apart or when some awful singer was delusional and would fight back against the judges it was a big part of the show but now it's more about the talent than anything else and even back in the day Simon used to say all the time that he was very knowledgeable about pop music and knew everything about what a pop singer should be but was not as knowledgeable when it came to the other genres but either way people know when they hear Talent like this and saying no is just
I mean Howie acted amazed when a 7 year old played a violin using basic notes and I'm pretty sure he gave the kid the gold for it. Yet this girl who is one of the greatest singers I've seen on the show he says no because of the genre. I don't say this lightly but what an idiot. If I was managing a musical I'd want her on it.
“When he’s not in a good mood, he gets mean.” I’m sorry, but if i did that at my job, i would’ve gotten wrote up for my behavior towards others while working. He needs to leave it at the door the moment he walks in his place of work.
I hate when the judges say that they dont like the act just because it's not their personal preference. Theirs lots of things in the world that are amazing but may not be your personal preference and that doesn't mean that it's not worthy of being good. For example a person might think their husband or wife is beautiful but not everyone thinks their beautiful. Their are amazing cars and movies and everything else that some people dont prefer but others do so why can't they see that.
They are what audience is about...you cannot please everyone that's why they are searching for a good act what evet that is to be enjoyed by everyone even by surprise, thus, a las vegas worthy
@@manuel6740 it was though ? There’s a whole community of people that love musical type songs, enough for Broadway to be as popular as it is, and yet you still think that this was the wrong song choice ?
How tf does he not like her? That was literally amazing it was better then the actual song, like I understand if he doesn't like musical theater but her voice was amazing.
@Katelyn The whole show is a reality show. It’s all fake and scripted. They still win money and stuff but they create drama to make it more interesting
wait why was howie being such a b to her. no one cares if he doesn't like musical theater, thats a you problem if you don't. shes talented and he should've put his dislike to a whole GENRE aside to be a fair judge.
still he has a right to his opinion like everyone else, would not be nice if someone tried to quite your opinion right, because you have a right to express yourself and be who you want to be and listen to whatever music you like.
@@bigjun913 i completely agree with you, but you need to understand that he thought she was an amazing singer but just because he doesn’t like the genre he said no which isn’t that fair imo
@@bigjun913 you’re completely right. but his job isn’t to give his personal preferences. what the lady wants to do is musical theater. howie should listen to her voice and tell her if he thinks she has a shot. like you don’t say “oh this genre sucks, nope.” that’s completely immature. for howie or any of the judges you need to set aside your personal preferences and be professional. howie isn’t the only one who did this. simon too. simon sometimes gets picky about what other people are wearing. and that’s completely out of line. it’s their style. it’s their preference. if the contestants had to choose music and sing songs from the judges favorite genre the show would be so bland. this show (should) consist of different music genres because the contestants have different taste. like simon said in this video, they know where they want to go. you shouldn’t diss them because you don’t like the genre. you have to be professional about it.
Howie's behavior tonight raises a serious question about his ability to judge contestants. To not vote for an incredibly talented young woman because he does not care for the genre of music she performs, is not only ludicrous but was so rude, immature and just inexcusable. It goes against the premise of the show to advance talented people with promise to continue their journey in the competition. His taste in music is irrelevant and has absolutely nothing to do with the talent of the contestant in this instance. As a judge, he should have known better.
Simon did that too with the kids who danced to “Barbie Girl” a few years ago. They were very good but Simon voted ‘no’ because he didn’t like the song that they danced to.
I’ve followed Tory on TikTok for ages and she is so supremely talented and beautiful! For Howie to act like this just cause he’s not a musical theatre fan is disrespectful and honesty makes me question his ability as a judge. Tory is amazing!!
Howies' not "ignorant"! He has a well-informed opinion about the cheesy over wretched existence that is theatre. I find it insufferable. I find it inexplicable that people who act and are portrayed in theatre actually exist !! I have never met a person who acted like the people do in these plays. I am also not ignorant. I am a classically trained musician who has a finely tuned ear. Country music and theatre music have no soul.
@@MickLoud999 you have no soul for having such an insufferable and rude opinion about two beautiful categories of music. If you don’t like it then keep it to yourself because no one asked.
'You checked every box, but I don't like musical theatre so no." This is about recognising talent, not about things only you like. Has to be scripted right? Howie has been so nice. Don't expect this shit behaviour from him.
The girl that sang Into The Unknown gave me CHILLS!!! She needs to be on Broadway! Her voice was absolutely incredible!!!!! How did Howie say no just bc he doesn’t like the genre?! She has talent! That’s the whole point of the show!! To see talent!
Three words in the title: America's Got TALENT.... Talent. That's what he's there to judge. Not his personal form of art. Not his definition of entertainment. Talent. She obviously had talent. A lot of it.
He can try, but NO ONE will beat “old school” Simon Cowell when it comes to sarcastic & nasty comments. A comedian trying to be mean, nasty or sarcastic is like a politician saying they’re telling the truth.... IT JUST DOESN’T WORK ✌️😂
@@joselara-perez1997 that’s a bit far just because of one night means he should be replaced Simon has done that to literally hundreds of people and nothing happened to him, not that it should have happened to Simon he’s a legend but still
@@kylebroflovski2585 true, but still howie is a class act and that’s why there’s four judges up there the show wouldn’t be where it is without him, all the funny moments on the show are mostly him like the Hudson brothers and dustins dojo were cause if his sense of humour
Howie has been a lot more critical when it comes to his Judging contestants over the years but as a Judge on Canada's Got Talent, I've noticed he's nowhere near like that to contestants like America's Got Talent, maybe the reason why, he's Canadian. One talent Howie won't be nasty or critical judging is comedians, always gives a standing Ovation, no matter how bad.
I never knew Howie could be that kind of a jerk,that is pure talent what are you talking about,this is America's Got Talent not Howie's Preference Talent
Sofia says whatever's on her mind and Simon's lowkey proud of it 😂 "It's not like we're dying to be you or do you"
I literally died at that part
@@teuwaiseu_jjang5160 you're ded
That made Simon laugh
@Emma Madison yes, this bit with Howie is so poorly scripted and boring it's cringe worthy. However Sofia is actually that funny, quick, and straightforward 😂 watch some of her interviews if you ever want a laugh
Harry
That girl WAS AMAZING I don’t care if it wasn’t his preference this is talent, pure talent.
Ikr
Ikr I love Tory she’s such a bean
EXACTLY
Fr
Lol ya she’s pretty good
3:50 “you have all the talent, skill, range, and what this show needs but i don’t like musical theatre so it’s a no from me” what??? that’s being a bad judge! isn’t the whole point to judge FAIRLY?
It's all an act.
@@RoyDontHugMeImScared I hope
It's called being biased
he said that on purpose because he was purposely trying to sound ridiculous. He knows thats not a valid reason to say "no".
How you can say no to that
Something I noticed with Simon is that he usually gives actual critisisms, hes not super rude or disrespectful and he knows a good voice when he hears it and thats something I respect about him
besides there always needs to be a "mean" judge
Yeah howie should really let Simon keep that job lol
He's evolved as a judge too, you should see his older stuff
@@Dont_at_me After Madilyn Bailey, I think he completely took over that spot
@@BlackHayateTheThird He was a bastard in his older stuff for sure, and he still can be.
The difference is that he tends to at least be in the ballpark with his insults. He might be blunt and cruel to people he thinks did badly, but he is generally right that they did bad.
It reminds me of the difference between Gordon and Joe in the US masterchef. Gordon has his quirks and can be extremely abrasive, but the combination of his charisma and the consistency of his criticism makes him tolerable even when he is roasting someone. Joe on the other hand oozes sleaze and dishonesty, and his criticisms are often bizarre and inconsistent. So he is almost intolerable.
Same kind of thing here. Simon commands respect with his opinions, even when they are harsh. Howie comes across as a buffoon.
Unless there is a flutist then he'll tear them apart for playing flute
This is being a bad judge. He literally stated that it’s not HIS type of music and that’s the only reason he said no. She had talent and it was obvious. Sometimes the hard part of being a judge is seeing talent in skill even if it’s your personal entertainment
And Simon differently he stated his opinion in a objective way which is good
Right it’s not Howies got talent here
@@caitlingerard4161 mate, it’s scripted
It's a shitty type of music i bet if one of you listening to it.
You know this is all scripted right?
That was the WORST “no” I’ve ever seen from a judge on any talent show, completely ridiculous
I'm sure it was only done for the "drama/entertainment" side of the programme. No show will edit a person green like the Hulk and take it seriously
@@WxB2001 That wasn’t the show that edited it
@@WxB2001 It is done after by post edits because it fits in quite well with how howie was acting.
It was a good no. Crap music is still crap music. No matter how good you're at it.
@@billseron2391 Whether you like the music or not, it doesn't matter. They're on a show for TALENT, not good music (unless of course the song writing is a part of the talent that you are demonstrating, which even in that case sometimes you can still see their talent in singing and not just song writing). She clearly has talent, and that is what this show is about, not individual taste in music. This was a clear case of letting your bias cloud your judgment and nothing else. I personally am not a huge fan of the song choice or musical theater but I cannot deny that she has talent and deserves to go through.
I think Simon and Howie switched personalities
Lol
So true🤷🏽♀️😭
Yes
Ikr
Lmao
Sofia: “it’s not like we’re dying to be you or do you.”
Me: OH SNAP😗
I read that right when she started saying it😂
@@jaslene3612 me too🤣🤣
I CRACKED UP ON THAT
AND THAT SMIRK SIMON DID
😭
heh
when simon is the one calling out rudeness, that means you really crossed the line.
Why is there so replies I completely agree
@@Karizzi_xxcatssame
@@Yuritulipp yup
Jesus is not God, he never said that in the bible.
@@rimhamdan7259yeah Jesus is God’s son
Atleast when Simon doesn’t like something he still appreciates the talent, maybe just not the song or genre.
You know it's all script right??
@@amanubaid3001 it's scripted?
@@roselrii of course it, every television show is.
How else do you think sometimes ant and deck have items matched as the contestants. You know like sometimes they just whip out paint brushes out of nowhere, when the contestant is painting or something
@Alexo Dubby I dunno it's just creating drama for fame maybe
Not true, don't you remember Simon on the idol telling the people they have the worst voice
The green colour disappearing and getting back is so hilarious
Am I the only one who doesn’t know why he’s green-
@@hearts4mikeafton The joke in that episode was that he was the grinch.
Probably the green is his negative side
@@hearts4mikeafton It's from the Grinch Who Stole Christmas. The Grinch is green, and the song says, "You're a mean one, Mr Grinch". So, Howie's a mean one.
Her performance was incredible, id give her the golden buzzer for that, she deserves it
There are so many singers on this show that it's silly to give a singer a golden buzzer because there's gonna be another singer who's at least just as good. Also it's a scripted show where they always use the buzzer for children so it doesn't matter.
It was good but not that good
@@TiredEyePilot what show do you watch? Plenty of adults have gotten golden buzzers in fact more adults have gotten it and not kids even assuming groups are 1 person. Now that being said, the golden buzzers more often than not go to people/groups with a "sob story".
Ikr
@@TiredEyePilot its probly not scripted
Well some of them are
it’s america’s got talent, not personal preference got talent
LMFAOOOOOOOO
Ikr? I hate when judges are subjective about their judgement.
TY! howie was just a turd for some reason...
Underrated comment!!
💀😂😂
not me thinking he was actually green and super confused
lmaooo same
Okay thank god he wasn't actually green
lmao same i was thinking if that was real
Bro
wait that was fake? 😂, I read a comment talking about him being filtered, I just thought they meant filtered=painted.
"We are gonna support talent, we are gonna encourage talent" Now that's being a judge, not: "I don't enjoy it, so it's a no even if you have a lot of talent"
Dude she looks and sounds like Elsa and she's SO talented
She doesn’t look like Elsa but she definitely sounds like her
@@deffokamquit6301 I think he meant Idina Menzel which is the one who voices Elsa.
@@jindollete4022 oh
...
@@aushiq8203 I think they were talking about the Voice actor for Elsa ( Idena Menzel idk how to spell it lol )
she was so good 😭😭 like i literally can see the musical theatre talent in her
YES!! she’s meant for broadway
Not to sound like a grinch but her clothes didn't match well or look very nice and that was off putting right off. Beautiful voice, though : D
@@ChildrensRightsFirst947 Shush, not everything needs a critique
@@ChildrensRightsFirst947 No one cares about clothes... We're judging voices...Her outfit doesn't matter AT ALL
@@ChildrensRightsFirst947 wtf
Wow, I'd argue that she's even better than the original! She's amazing! I hope she makes it to Broadway some day!
bro this is the moment that literally all of america hated howie....
Yes. He was the grinch this episode
@@bmamba2 Fr
@@bmamba2 lmfoaoo that’s why he’s green
I’m pretty sure dat was da moment the whole world hated him 🤭
I can't stand Howie anymore
When Howie was covering his ears and shouting” nananana” he sure acted like a little kid. That voice was AWESOME! Who could say no to that? Hater Howie
time?
It’s the stupid scripted part of AGT
@@johnwick3544 the judges pay the contestants?
Wait you copied another comment
@@tiktokkate6726 I don’t know if I copied or not. I didn’t read all 706 comments
You know you messed up when Simon is the voice of reason.
I'm not a fan of musical theatre either, but how could you say "no" to that voice? She's got amazing talent! The show is called "America's Got Talent," it shouldn't matter the judge's personal preferences.
IKR, she was awsome!
It reminds me of a mediocre lady singing in a frozen kids party. He didn’t say no because of Broadway, he clearly said no because she’s boring and mediocre. Yeah she’s a nice girl though.
You know it’s just a bit right? That’s not actually his opinion it’s just a bit for a RUclips video.
How can you take this seriously when he's looking like the Hulk lol. It's a work to add a bit of drama to the show
@@WxB2001 yea
The one singing frozen is literally Elsa’s voice
Exactly what I was thinking
She hit the night notes soo good
exactly like i bet if i played that anyone would think thats the original its so good
@@vicky6398 I know she like bombing 💣
Ik
Her voice was like sleeping on a fluffy cloud of happy thoughts It didn't sound strained at all even on the highest notes and I loved it 🥰
3:59
“I actually don’t think we’re booing loud enough”
- Simon
Coming from someone like Simon, that says everything
Looks like Howie and Simon switched up their school bags ..😅
Yeah!thought it too!!!🤣🤣🤣
yea lol
That's what the show wanted. They do as they're told.
The singer girl deserved a golden buzzer. Her vocals was on another level.
Producer: how scripted you want this to be?
Simon: Let Howie be me for today but a little worse
Howie: 👁️👄👁️ (in green)
OK BUT WHY IS HE GREEN
@@Sophie-kk2lx they added a filter on him to fit the Grinch role
@@Elias-rr7nq bruh thank you cuz I actually had no idea why he was green😭 i thought I was trippin or sum BAHAHAHA
Oh i thought he cosplayed as hulk
@@Wing_ML SIBSIEHSISBE HAHAHAHA
Howie is drinking Simon's Hatorade
BQHAHAHAHHAAH THIS IS THE BEST COMMENT “HATORADE” ☠️💀☠️💀
@@amongusgalz9303 lmao ikr 😂
THIS IS SO UNDERRATED BAHAHAHAIDNSONDJSNS
He’s not just drinking it he’s chugging it
@@amongusgalz9303 lmfaooo thnx
The look on Simon's face as he listened to her sing, I don't think I've ever seen him with that much of an expression before. Truly an enchanting voice.
is it just me or did when you first saw this you thought howie dyed himself green😂😂😂😂😂 I'm laughing at my stupidity.
I'm glad I'm not the only one out there. thanks for making me feel less stupid😂
SAMEEE 😂
same i was so confused 😂
Wait, ig I am just stupid…is it just editing?
Yeah the editing is so good
He isn't green on the show?
I don’t like musical theatre either but her voice is like an angel! THAT is what he’s there to judge, not whether he likes musicals or not🤦🏻♀️
Need a monster from time to time to create a hero, and people always love the set up. They buy it every time
I think it was selfish he said “No” just because he didn’t like the type of music she was singing. All that matters is that she had a great voice
Yeah exactly that's what matters
@@sarahsan5946 I’m not a fan of some music; however, if I hear someone singing it with an amazing voice, I’d say “yes”
I’ve seen this girl sing on TikTok before and she is unbelievable talented
What's her tik tok?
@@OversteerRacingChannel Candice
Unbelievably*
@@godofeurope6768 who’s Candice?
@@Clipcentral117 candice deezna, yes?
“There’s no mistaking you have a powerful voice, but I don’t enjoy that music, so NO”
Yeah that just sounds soooo scripted and staged xD
When she sang, it actually gave me chills, that doesn’t happen
You should start listening to better music then, if you never get chills lol
@@Sacred_Silence it’s not the music that gives you chills it’s the voice
@@Sacred_Silence eh- thats not my type of things im into-
He put his preferences before her talent. So unprofessional. She is amazing and I hope she is doing well
@Veronica Osuna Uribe was it actually??
@@hemuli123faithinthefuture4 how dumb founded you must be to not realize? I mean he dress as green, everytime he said anything it has the grinch background song in it, and it was christmas, so tell me isn't that obvious that they wanted him to act as a Grinch in Christmas because Howie is almost never been angry in the whole show?
Need a monster from time to time to create a hero, and people always love the set up. They buy it every time
@@bradowen8862 is that your way of saying "it's scripted"
I'm glad Simon stood up for that lady! Even if you don't like musicals you have to admit she was talented! She has the voice, range, power and thick skin to make it in Broadway! Good luck girl!
This girl put so much emotion into her song. It is not just vocals!
At first I thought howie painted himself green or something 😅😂🤣
wait he didnt?
@@van-os5hs it’s a filter
yeah i saw at the end lol
😂😂😂 i thought he did lmao
😂😂😂i was looking for this comment
Nobody:
Absolutely nobody:
Me: “hey! how did howie turned into shrek ?!”
YEAH WHAT-
Guys the editors turned him green for being the grinch
@@justjillianing Yeah, but you can also see him as Shrek.
I just see hulk. Angry
Turn**
I LOVE SOFIA VERGARA “ it’s not like we’re dying to be you” 😂 lmao 🤣
This is why Simon actually plays the mean role better. Not on x factor or whatever else he did I honestly forgot because that was just him being cruel. But on agt he is the more judgy one but he doesn't act cruel or like a baby and he can appreciate talent even if it's not his taste
Yeah, Simon's never mean to anyone who is talented. If a contestant has real talent, but it's in a category he's not super into, he still recognizes the talent and supports it.
I think he's become a better, nicer, human being now he's a father.
He wasn’t cruel just brutally honest, like yes he did make fun of some people but he could immediately see that they were lying to themselves that they were good and he was trying to stop that before it came out of hand
Usually he criticised the overconfident ones, and when they don't reach the level they boost themselves up.
I think Simon used to play up being a dick back in the day more before these types of shows were so established because as much as people like watching talented Acts they equally liked if not more the acts that were terrible and would get ripped apart or when some awful singer was delusional and would fight back against the judges it was a big part of the show but now it's more about the talent than anything else and even back in the day Simon used to say all the time that he was very knowledgeable about pop music and knew everything about what a pop singer should be but was not as knowledgeable when it came to the other genres but either way people know when they hear Talent like this and saying no is just
SOMEONE REALLY SAID “howie is drinking Simon’s hatorade”
We can read
@@gtrbarceder1454 ok
it was @Noah Jackson 20
I am in tears listening to this girl sing. Amazing voice.
I mean Howie acted amazed when a 7 year old played a violin using basic notes and I'm pretty sure he gave the kid the gold for it. Yet this girl who is one of the greatest singers I've seen on the show he says no because of the genre. I don't say this lightly but what an idiot. If I was managing a musical I'd want her on it.
It's just scripted.
woah woah, dw its in the script..
Don't get personal its jst a scripted act
This show has turned into a "you'll only win if you are an under 13 year old white girl"
If the guy who killed Glen says this about you that's when you know you must be a horrible person
“When he’s not in a good mood, he gets mean.” I’m sorry, but if i did that at my job, i would’ve gotten wrote up for my behavior towards others while working. He needs to leave it at the door the moment he walks in his place of work.
Couldn't agree more as someone currently still in customer service 4 plus years .
mate it’s scripted
It’s scripted by agt. They genuinely tell the judges how to act.
First of all, it's scripted, second of all, you're not Howie Judge of America's Got Talent.
His job is to show off his personality. Good & bad.
He should get a rise for performing to his description at high level.
3:45 Top 10 Anime plot twists
I mean what did he expect her to sing if she wants to be on Broadway? Lmao
I hate when the judges say that they dont like the act just because it's not their personal preference. Theirs lots of things in the world that are amazing but may not be your personal preference and that doesn't mean that it's not worthy of being good. For example a person might think their husband or wife is beautiful but not everyone thinks their beautiful. Their are amazing cars and movies and everything else that some people dont prefer but others do so why can't they see that.
They are what audience is about...you cannot please everyone that's why they are searching for a good act what evet that is to be enjoyed by everyone even by surprise, thus, a las vegas worthy
You do realize that whole part was scripted right as well as the whole show
Bro chill, she was ok, we have seen better, just wasn't a good song choice
@@manuel6740 it was though ? There’s a whole community of people that love musical type songs, enough for Broadway to be as popular as it is, and yet you still think that this was the wrong song choice ?
@@TheDevos1 yes
How tf does he not like her? That was literally amazing it was better then the actual song, like I understand if he doesn't like musical theater but her voice was amazing.
I almost died from laughing when he turns back green 😂😂😂
Poor Howie. They’re forcing him to act mean for the script.
Wait reali
Cuz I’ve been watching AGT forever and Howie was never mean
@Katelyn
The whole show is a reality show. It’s all fake and scripted. They still win money and stuff but they create drama to make it more interesting
wow really? Can I have more info on that, I thought this was real-
They are not forcing him to do anything but he can be mean.
4:03
Crowd booing: BOOO LET HER GET A YES
Grinch Howey: LA LALALALALALAALLA
Me: laughing my ass off for him being a child
Howie is acting like a damn 5 year old geez.
He's not acting like a 5 year old. He's acting like a spoiled baby that just whines and complains.
@@joselara-perez1997 Nono he’s acting like a fetus kicking its mother’s stomach from the inside
“This is my self expression!” Like stfu 😂😂😂
scripted
Its scripted
You know even if Howie didn’t like the song he still could have said yes bc her voice was magical
He must not like Disney. :/
I don't get it too
people said it was likely scripted, even a little bit
the way we covered his ears like a kid doesn't feel real to me either
The way they dropped him back into the green made me lose it lmao
wait why was howie being such a b to her. no one cares if he doesn't like musical theater, thats a you problem if you don't. shes talented and he should've put his dislike to a whole GENRE aside to be a fair judge.
This shit is all scripted
still he has a right to his opinion like everyone else, would not be nice if someone tried to quite your opinion right, because you have a right to express yourself and be who you want to be and listen to whatever music you like.
@@bigjun913 i completely agree with you, but you need to understand that he thought she was an amazing singer but just because he doesn’t like the genre he said no which isn’t that fair imo
@@bigjun913 you’re completely right. but his job isn’t to give his personal preferences. what the lady wants to do is musical theater. howie should listen to her voice and tell her if he thinks she has a shot. like you don’t say “oh this genre sucks, nope.” that’s completely immature. for howie or any of the judges you need to set aside your personal preferences and be professional. howie isn’t the only one who did this. simon too. simon sometimes gets picky about what other people are wearing. and that’s completely out of line. it’s their style. it’s their preference. if the contestants had to choose music and sing songs from the judges favorite genre the show would be so bland. this show (should) consist of different music genres because the contestants have different taste. like simon said in this video, they know where they want to go. you shouldn’t diss them because you don’t like the genre. you have to be professional about it.
Because it's scripted. It wouldn't be that entertaining and exciting if all the judges liked it now would it?
That girl's performance gave me goosebumps. World Class.
The thumbnail makes Howie look like he's spiritually transforming into the hulk
her voice is literally amazinggg!!! she DEFINITELY DESERVES TO BE ON BROADWAYY!!!
THAT GIRL WHO SANG INTO THE UNKNOWN ABSOLUTELY KILLED IT ❤️❤️❤️
The Personal Preference Got Talent lmao
She should be Eliza in Hamilton l can imagine her being good at the solo Burn! She is incredible
Right! I completely agree
Yeaaa
mhm
Yes, and she would be incredible at Take a Break!
100%
we not gonna talk about how he's literally green?
The editor made him greeen because he was being the grinch lol
@@justjillianing thank you for clarifying bc I was confused
@@justjillianing I was so confused, thanks for clearing it up !
@@justjillianing thank you for clearing it I genuinely thought he was green-
Simon: "We aren't gonna listen to people like you anymore, we are gonna support talent and encourage talent."
Heidi: *Says no*
She deserves every dream of hers to come true
She was incredible
She sounded just like Elsa 😆
yeah she was amazing
@@steph82957 you know her in person?
I’m not going crazy right? …Howie Mandel is GREEN right?
no hes red
The editors made him green like the Grinch for well yj
I see green
@@xflowerssx7603 bruh sarcasm
@@yeduanunya9970 Oh okay. Lol. I was wondering if I had a problem with my eyes. LMFAO.
You know, Howie makes a pretty good cartoon villain
Howie's behavior tonight raises a serious question about his ability to judge contestants. To not vote for an incredibly talented young woman because he does not care for the genre of music she performs, is not only ludicrous but was so rude, immature and just inexcusable. It goes against the premise of the show to advance talented people with promise to continue their journey in the competition. His taste in music is irrelevant and has absolutely nothing to do with the talent of the contestant in this instance. As a judge, he should have known better.
I agree
The show is so scripted and staged that The point isn’t really to find talented people as much as to produce an entertaining show
Simon did that too with the kids who danced to “Barbie Girl” a few years ago. They were very good but Simon voted ‘no’ because he didn’t like the song that they danced to.
YES
I argee as well
Literally got goosebumps from the girl singing Elsa’s song. She sounds so much like her.
Thats very true
I love how howie turned back to green again 🤣
I’ve followed Tory on TikTok for ages and she is so supremely talented and beautiful! For Howie to act like this just cause he’s not a musical theatre fan is disrespectful and honesty makes me question his ability as a judge. Tory is amazing!!
Hey ignorant Howie , it is ok not to like a certain kind of music but do not penalize an outstanding voice because of it .
Fax
100 percent sure its staged
Howies' not "ignorant"! He has a well-informed opinion about the cheesy over wretched existence that is theatre. I find it insufferable. I find it inexplicable that people who act and are portrayed in theatre actually exist !! I have never met a person who acted like the people do in these plays. I am also not ignorant. I am a classically trained musician who has a finely tuned ear. Country music and theatre music have no soul.
@@MickLoud999 you have no soul for having such an insufferable and rude opinion about two beautiful categories of music. If you don’t like it then keep it to yourself because no one asked.
It’s staged, everyone was in on it and he was supposed to act like that because he was the “grinch”
“It’s not like we are dying to be you or do you” OHHHHHH
2:28 whel simon gives u that smile u know she is very good
it's not about what YOU enjoy Howie, it's about the talent
His reactions are fake the producers most likely told him to do it
Heidi with the death stare at 0:42
'You checked every box, but I don't like musical theatre so no." This is about recognising talent, not about things only you like.
Has to be scripted right? Howie has been so nice. Don't expect this shit behaviour from him.
Don’t worry, it is scripted, he was supposed to act like the grinch this episode, that’s why he is green, the other judges were in on it too
Apparently I've been using the word 'lashed out' wrong. Simon really lashed out here.
LMFAOOOAOO
Her voice was so pretty and amazing, I would give her the golden buzzer! I loved it!!
The girl that sang Into The Unknown gave me CHILLS!!! She needs to be on Broadway! Her voice was absolutely incredible!!!!! How did Howie say no just bc he doesn’t like the genre?! She has talent! That’s the whole point of the show!! To see talent!
That girls voice keeps giving me chills! I'd pay to watch her on Broadway.
Simon's subtle " I will fire your ass" got his attention
When Simon Cowell has to say chill u should probably chill that’s like Gordon Ramsey saying stop insulting someone
lmfao this is gold
Its not “Only say yes to singers if the judges like the song itself got talent” …
Your editing killed me when it looked like the ‘spell’ has been lifted 🤣
✨ Awesome job 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
3:51 The “green monster” is back.
Three words in the title: America's Got TALENT.... Talent.
That's what he's there to judge.
Not his personal form of art. Not his definition of entertainment. Talent.
She obviously had talent. A lot of it.
Terrible judgement Howie. Not about your preference
Howie is trying to become the next Simon Cowell 😃😂
He can try, but NO ONE will beat “old school” Simon Cowell when it comes to sarcastic & nasty comments. A comedian trying to be mean, nasty or sarcastic is like a politician saying they’re telling the truth.... IT JUST DOESN’T WORK ✌️😂
LMAO
So, basically Howie is trying to be the knockoff version of Simon.
Howie needs to not be a judge anymore….
It's about time that he needs to be replaced. Either Howard Stern or Piers Morgan are good choices for replacing Howie.
@@joselara-perez1997 that’s a bit far just because of one night means he should be replaced Simon has done that to literally hundreds of people and nothing happened to him, not that it should have happened to Simon he’s a legend but still
@@isaiahkennedy2096 Simon never said no because he doesn't like a type of music he only says no when they literally have no talent
@@kylebroflovski2585 true, but still howie is a class act and that’s why there’s four judges up there the show wouldn’t be where it is without him, all the funny moments on the show are mostly him like the Hudson brothers and dustins dojo were cause if his sense of humour
@@isaiahkennedy2096 ok but it still doesn't look good for him to make this shit all about himself
I remember when I was at my grandmas and my grandma was watching this and called me over to show how Howie was green. I miss her so much ❤
how did that girl not get a golden buzzer she was AMAZING 🤩
1:00
YES
We need that theatre kid representation!
YOU GO GIRL!
I recognize ur pfp I love Hamilton 💕
Howie has been a lot more critical when it comes to his Judging contestants over the years but as a Judge on Canada's Got Talent, I've noticed he's nowhere near like that to contestants like America's Got Talent, maybe the reason why, he's Canadian.
One talent Howie won't be nasty or critical judging is comedians, always gives a standing Ovation, no matter how bad.
I never knew Howie could be that kind of a jerk,that is pure talent what are you talking about,this is America's Got Talent not Howie's Preference Talent
It’s staged, he’s acting like that because he is the “grinch” for Christmas, the other judges were in on it and that is why he was green
HEY DISNEY, HEADS UP. CALL HER NOW! SHE AWESOME! SHE GOT TALENT AND A POWERFUL SINGER! OR A MUTANT NAMED DAZZLER ‼️
Everyone has bad days but no need to take it out of the poor people on the stage
2:37 The most shimmering part of all. 🤣