@@i._.am-_-je 그럼 선생님도 나중에 대기업 입사했는데 상사들이 갈구고 일때문에 스트레스 받아서 머리가 다 벗겨져도 퇴사하지 말고 꼭꼭 말뚝 박으세요ㅎㅎ 그것만 조금 참으면 통장에 몇억씩 찍히는걸요!ㅜ 왜 남의 고통을 경시하시는 건가요?공감해주는 사회인이 됩시다😊
@평론가 얻다대고 반말이세요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 일단 님은 인성부터 챙기시고ㅎㅎ 남 평가 좀 작작하라는데 그 와중에 또 제 평가나 하고 아주 닉네임 꼬라지부터 난리네요^^ 제가 언제 아이돌들은 자기관리 필요없댔습니까? 영상에서처럼 기아수준으로 십몇킬로씩 뺄 필요가 없다는 거 잖아요. 아이돌의 본분은 춤과 노래를 잘 하는건데 저렇게 살을 빼면 건강하게 무대를 소화할 수가 있을까 싶어 안타까운 마음에 댓글을 달았는데 거기와서 논점 흐리는건 님이세요. 본인이나 잘 하시고 답글 달지 마세요 볼 때마다 짜증나니까😊
긁어보니 복권??? 미쳤나 이것들이 저 언니들은 13키로가 쪄도 빠져도 그 사람 그 자체다 제발 애들 허리끈 조여매지말고 먹을것도 자유롭게 먹게 해줘라ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅠ 알아서 열심히 할텐데ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠ 저키에 50키로가 넘어야 정상인데 어휴/복근인데 잘못봤네요 죄송합니다 험한 말까지 해가면서 뭐라해서요 근데 실제로 아이돌들 너무 말랐고 거식증에 몸 힘들어하는 사람 너무 많습니다 고쳐야하는 문화 중 하나라고 생각합니다 댓글로 싸우지들 마세요... 이런 문화가 형성된 것도 소비자들이 그런 방향으로 소비했기 때문입니다 지금이라도 바꿔야한다고 말하는 겁니다
살빼라고 요구하는 팬들은 당연한거임 근데 그걸로 인신공격하는게 병신들인 팬인거고 소비자입장에서 원하는거 보고싶은건 당연한건데 아이돌이라는 직업을 택해놓고 살이 빼기 싫다고? 그럼 아이돌을 하지 말았어야함 살이 빠져야 춤선이 예쁘고 팬들이 보기 좋아하는것도 사실임 살빠진걸 보고싶어하는 팬들이 많은것도 사실이고 살찐 아이돌 비싼돈 내고 소비하는 사람이 엄청나게 많을리는 없잖음? 소속사에서도 그걸 아니까 체중관리 중요하게 생각하고 독하게 말하는거고
I understand mina was a lil chubby so she wanted to lose baby fat but Seolhyun was fine the way she was. Mina honestly looks better during her ioi era where she lost a little weight. The fat makes her look cute
So you two fools tryna say she was out of shaped??? Tf she had a bangin asf body before! And y’all trippin if you think you have to be skinny to dance lol. Some of the best choreographer isn’t skinny like parris goebel she on the thick side. just gotta have stamina. But at then end of the day it her body she do what she gotta do 🚬 😗
kern x let’s stick to facts here, she did not have a “banging” body before, her belly was sticking out in some of their performances. She was nearing 60 kg. I was expecting you to mention parris goebel, but Im talking about “most” people. Mina got problem with stamina in pd101 because of her weight. And seolhyun now is fit not skinny...
NOMOlonelyNOMOhappy it is a fact with the fact she had a hot ass bangin as body shape a few years ago lmfao. Let be real in Korea their ideal of an beautiful looking person has to be “skinny and lean” which is their “in shape” term. Come on she anit out shape before if that’s what your claim is then like I said y’all fools trippin. But if you wanna talk about stamina then Mina is Mina. Some people have better stamina than others. I know people whos really in great shape for example like a buddie of mines he has great six pack abs and really lean body compare to me I have normal average body but I run a mile in 6 mins while it takes him 9 minutes even in hiking he can’t keep up with me in hiking as well so Just stating fact. FYI your not wrong by saying being in better shape we’ll help improve your stamina and stamina can be built, but when you bring up Mina? Remember she has a different body so overall it just her. Some just have better stamina than other naturally. 💯 yeyee
kern x lol we dont see eye to eye so lets just drop it. Maybe in your country what’s considered “banging af” body is someone who’s belly is sticking out. You know there’s nothing wrong with being fat tho... but filling your head with lies seems like not the right way to do it. And fyi again and again, seolhyun is the right way to describe “fit” not skinny, regardless of korean standards. Dont wanna name drop celebrities, but I know a bunch who’ll be considered “skinny” 🙄
I think AOA Seohyun is very tall, so the weight 50kg is good for her. I can't understand why she had to go on a diet although at that time she already had a perfect body. For Gugudan Mina, I don't think she was fat at the time she was jonied in Produce 101, it's just the upper body was bigger than the lower body, so the whole body was unbalenced. But after diet, Mina's body is well-proportioned and her face is smaller, so it's good for her. But I hope they are healthy even though they're thin or fat or balaned. Health is the most important thing.
That is true. Seolhyun's height is about 167-168. 50kg is totally perfect, i think she still slim at that weight. But she forced to diet till 47kg. That was too mean!!
ㅇㅈ 가끔가다 여자한테 하는 말 보면 존나 무례함 ㅅㅂ 요즘 나혼자산다 옛날편 보고있는데 황석정 배우 나올때마다 하는 한마디한마디가 가관이더라 뭐만 말하면 트집잡고ㅋㅋㅋ 이쁜 게스트 보면 또 헤벌레 해가지고 지 면상과 몸뚱아리 생각 좀 하지 시츄상이고 나발이고 존나 비호감상
진짜 이상한 나라야 다이어트 외모강박에 미친듯이 집착하고 당장 여기 추천수박힌 댓이나 쳐보세요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저 프로 의도가 순위매기는게 정상인거 같음? 난 한국’만’ 외모지상 어쩌고 한 적 없음 유독 심하다고 했지 그리고 그건 사실인데 전세계가 그래요 다른덴 더그래요 이러고있다... 내가 그걸 몰라서 쓴거같으세요? 의도파악을 못해 왜
Seolhyun is 167, if she weights 50 kg she is already underweight, with a BMI of 17,93 which is not between the normality interval (18,50 -24'99). She was already underweight and you want her to loose even more weight?????. Weight is extremely related to height. You cannot say that a person over 50 kg is fat. I am 170 and I weight 62 kg, but my BMI is perfectly normal and my health is perfect. If I were to weight 50 I couldn't imagine how skinny I would be...
Yeees! But I'm different, I'm 1,72 and 52kg, but I'm not unhelthy, I eat well and do exercices, When I was 1,68 I haved 48kg. I'm the type of people who dont gain so much weight. Like my friend she is 1,73 and have 62kg she is healthy too. But, If my friend haved 52kg she will totally look unhelthy! What is funny, right? The same happen with Seo if she loses more, she will be unhelthy, and problaby look underweight. I hope they stop to look at the people Kg and start to think in their healthy.
@@AfraMinelly exactly. It also depends on built. I am built super slender. So i am 1.70 and weigh 52.6 right now. I tried my best to diet and gain weight.... so hard unless you add muscle... which i dont want. So i just eat what i want and live.... i never went over 54 kilo's. And i am healthy. I saw a docter for this too.
You are absolutely right. I am 1.67 and was TWICE diagnosed with anorexia. Both times I was under 50kg - with 46 and 47kg respectively. It is a pity the industry makes them so thin without thinking on health implications. BTW- muscle is heavier than fat, so if they become healthier they can even gain weight
@@hindmiley nobody said it's unhealthy but 60kg is chubby for her height. And her job requires her for a fit body but look at her body during her early debuts, she's chubby not exactly fit.
Stoooop! mina and Seolhyeon are not healthy anymore! Stop saying that looking that skinny it’s cool and better, there are people dying and getting eating desorders for that! Korean needs to change!!!
Well... They are healthy under strict yet efficient diet. Yes they are under strict diet may seem unhealthy, but most of the Korean entertainment company uses dietitian and personal trainers to keep in check of their artist's health. However, in the case of jimin from aoa, I do agree she does not look healthy.
@@jacksonmagilacuty1745 How are they healthy when during 1 period of time Seolhyun was sick all the time? She couldnt survive through any shedul without fainting or feeling sick.
Jackson Magilacuty “may seem unhealthy”, probably because they’re starving them. And no its not efficient nor healthy. Look some videos up of idols yoyoing in their diets
@@jacksonmagilacuty1745 Most Kpop companies cannot afford dieticians. And the dieticians ones do use aren't usually looking at their health as a goal but rather looks.
@@julynightowl7413 Maybe so. Are you sure she's still the same since then? I never chose a bias back then, i just appreciate her recent works. I don't want to be bias about it, since people change every year.
Ki jadaro when they were doing the position evaluation (dance), their group had 3 members who were way behind in the rankings compared to nayoung and mina and the three also had the least center time during the performance. There’s this one girl who got like 5 sec. center time but that dance step needs all of them to face at the back (that means she did not get any center time at all). While practicing, she asked nicely (and cried) if she could at least face in the front while doing the part (nayoung choreographed the dance), MINA suddenly got angry over her wanting to change the choreo for just that 5 sec step and she was like talking bad behind her back and to think that she’s more on the maknae side. Mina was the center for that performance and was very popular but after that episode her ranking fell so fast, there’s a big difference in her ranking before and after.
Denisse Tapia Don’t worry! I’m sure she’s healthy besides everyone has their own preferences as to what’s attractive. It’s ok as long as ur not hurting anyone’s feelings😅
they should switch their focus into fit & Healthy. in their line of work their body is their greatest asset. they should always be healthy. being skinny doesn't always translate to being healthy. being chubby doesn't always translate to being unhealthy either. Find the balance.
They don't emphasize enough that sure they're was diet implicated but also they went from teenagers with baby fat to grown woman and that makes a huge difference.... I really hate the way weight is perceived in Korean beauty standard, you're beautiful the way you are people don't let this bring you down !!!!
It is insulting that you say that. I'm the same bmi as seolhyun and I still say that I look sexy. The media isn't forcing you to believe that, it is true just as much as curvy girls are sexy. Don't put down other girls just to fit your worldview. It does you no good.
@@tongtong8801 really? Well too bad you felt insulted cause it wasn't really an insult and you're feeling all butt hurt over nothing. Actually yes the media is portraying that thin is sexy, have you seen actresses on the screen? They're all trying to be thinner by dieting not by exercising. Bragging about being models and being a size zero. Versus making 50 reality shows about curvy people and making them lose weight. Sorry all your points are invalid. Try again next time 🙄
Did you watch the video? They quite literally showed Seolhyun exercising, but go off I guess. I understand that the models are often skinnier, but the phrase "being all bones" in inherently an insult, but good try in gaslighting me. I'm not "butthurt" I'm just pointing out that you bring down others just to boost yourself.
@@tongtong8801 how am I boosting myself? Lol just cant admit your oversensitive and butt hurt over nothing. Also being 50kg is fine but I guess you people think thats too fat and thats your problem. Idgaf as long as she looks healthy. Sorry try again.
If you ask me. She looks great!! She still had a great body and ate what made her happy. But as long as she is healthy and living her best life that's what matters.
I lose 9kg in 3 months and i've stopped it for a month now and gained 2kg back 😭 but my goal is to lose 15kg 😭😭 watching this make me wanna go on diet again, thankyou mina and seolhyun 😭😭❤️ (I was 67kg and 155cm, now i'm on 59kg😭)
@Ki jadaro i lost it when ramadhan too, eventough i didn't fasting because i'm not a moslem but the environment made me kinda fasting too so that's good actually 😂 You guys did really great, i don't think i can last a day without drinking 😳😳
@@nanar0d i tried a lot of diet plans, but the one worked out the most for me is Intermitten fasting, you can search it, and i calculate how much calorie i consume everyday, and doing HIIT workout (but i stop in 2 weeks because it's really painful for me 😂😂)
![[ENG sub] Mnet TMI NEWS [8회] 청순 이란 단어가 사람으로 태어난 수지&조이의 감량 비법은? 190807 EP.8](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NpAgPegCJxk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG sub] Mnet TMI NEWS [8회] 청순 이란 단어가 사람으로 태어난 수지&조이의 감량 비법은? 190807 EP.8](/img/tr.png)
![[직캠] 20241111 두시 탈출 컬투쇼 비투비 은광 출근길](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wcMiH49DZN0/mqdefault.jpg)
장도연이 같으샾 다닌다니까 전현무가 체중의 변화를 느꼈어요? 라고 질문했는데, 아니요? 늘 이쁘던데요? 라고 말한거 너무 센스있다..
+ 웜마...좋아요가벌써 840개가 넘었네요..!
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ 합니다
근데 진짜 이뻣음 회사 이사가 왜 살빼라는지 몰랐음 ㅎㅎ
ㅇㅈ
이쁘다고? 여혐하노
hop J 예?
0:23 이거 ㅈㄴ 멋있는데 질문 탁 잘라 버리고 늘 예뻤다고 하는 거
긍까여ㅜㅜ
인정 ㅜ 멋있어
님도요
역시 장도연ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아 진짜 개멋있다
도연언니한테 저딴 대본 주지마라 언니 진심으로 하는 말 아닌거 다 보임 언니 힘내요 싸랑해요
ㄹㅇ 장도연도 ㅈㄴ이쁘고 몸매좋아서 남자들한테 인기 오지게많을텐데
@@ekekek7527ㅇㅈ 공부도 개잘했는데 그냥 개그우먼 한거라서
@@ekekek7527 머리 기르면 존나 이쁨
@@김밥볶음밥 기르면 더 이쁘겠지만 지금도 충분히 이쁨ㅜㅜ❤❤
@@김지민-u3p 개잘까지는
통통이 아니라 날씬에서 존나날씬으로 변신....
이민하 인정.... 저건 날씬이야....
존나 날씬도 ㅇㅈ 이젠 아예 너무 말라서ㅜㅜ
맞아맞아!!!!!
ᄉᄋᄋ 미나는 아님
dkakq djvhb 아 설현만봐써요
우리나라 여돌들은 진짜 극한직업이다... 엄청 말라야 하는데 또 잘 먹기도 잘 먹어야 해ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 살찌거나 깨작깨작 먹으면 안 좋게 보니까... 후,.. 승희랑 아린이도 공감돼가지고 표정 울상인거 진짜ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 속상해ㅠㅠ
그거 좀 참으면 통장에 몇억씩 똭똭인데 다이어트 안 하고 베기겠냐ㅋㅋ
@평론가 아... 아이돌은 살을 빼는 직업이군요😮... 그렇군요...😶
@@i._.am-_-je 그럼 선생님도 나중에 대기업 입사했는데 상사들이 갈구고 일때문에 스트레스 받아서 머리가 다 벗겨져도 퇴사하지 말고 꼭꼭 말뚝 박으세요ㅎㅎ 그것만 조금 참으면 통장에 몇억씩 찍히는걸요!ㅜ 왜 남의 고통을 경시하시는 건가요?공감해주는 사회인이 됩시다😊
@@xsh_12 대학 어디 나왔어?ㅋㅋ
@평론가 얻다대고 반말이세요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 일단 님은 인성부터 챙기시고ㅎㅎ 남 평가 좀 작작하라는데 그 와중에 또 제 평가나 하고 아주 닉네임 꼬라지부터 난리네요^^ 제가 언제 아이돌들은 자기관리 필요없댔습니까? 영상에서처럼 기아수준으로 십몇킬로씩 뺄 필요가 없다는 거 잖아요. 아이돌의 본분은 춤과 노래를 잘 하는건데 저렇게 살을 빼면 건강하게 무대를 소화할 수가 있을까 싶어 안타까운 마음에 댓글을 달았는데 거기와서 논점 흐리는건 님이세요. 본인이나 잘 하시고 답글 달지 마세요 볼 때마다 짜증나니까😊
긁어보니 복권??? 미쳤나 이것들이 저 언니들은 13키로가 쪄도 빠져도 그 사람 그 자체다 제발 애들 허리끈 조여매지말고 먹을것도 자유롭게 먹게 해줘라ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅠ 알아서 열심히 할텐데ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠ 저키에 50키로가 넘어야 정상인데 어휴/복근인데 잘못봤네요 죄송합니다 험한 말까지 해가면서 뭐라해서요 근데 실제로 아이돌들 너무 말랐고 거식증에 몸 힘들어하는 사람 너무 많습니다 고쳐야하는 문화 중 하나라고 생각합니다 댓글로 싸우지들 마세요... 이런 문화가 형성된 것도 소비자들이 그런 방향으로 소비했기 때문입니다 지금이라도 바꿔야한다고 말하는 겁니다
레모네이드 긁어보니 복근 입니다!! 다이어트 하고 복근이 생겨서 복근이라고 표현한거 같아요!
너무 마른 건 예쁜게 아니고 어디 아픈거임
평소엔 50넘을거에요 40대에 저몸매 잘 안나와요 아마 최대로 굶고 줄여서 올린게 프로필 몸무게일거에요ㅎㅎ 너무 걱정하지 마세요
@@카페라떼-d3b 하지만 가능한게 연예인들ㄷㄷ
@@흐잉흐에-e9o ??긁어보니 복권이라는 말 몰라요? 아님 드립인가요?
살빼라고 몸매 공격하는 애들 진짜 개웃긴게 정상 몸무게 나가고 조금 통통하면 살 빼라고 하고 그렇다고 죽어라 다이어트 해서 빼면 살 좀 찌라고 그럼 뭐 어쩌라는건지
연예인들 불쌍함
ㄹㅇ...이래라 저래라 ㅈㄹ임
자기들 체중걱정이나하지 정작 살 빼라고 하는애들부터 정상체중인지 좀 봐야댐
몸무계아니고 몸무게,,,,
살빼라고 요구하는 팬들은 당연한거임
근데 그걸로 인신공격하는게 병신들인 팬인거고
소비자입장에서 원하는거 보고싶은건 당연한건데 아이돌이라는 직업을 택해놓고
살이 빼기 싫다고? 그럼 아이돌을 하지 말았어야함 살이 빠져야 춤선이 예쁘고 팬들이 보기 좋아하는것도 사실임
살빠진걸 보고싶어하는 팬들이 많은것도 사실이고 살찐 아이돌 비싼돈 내고 소비하는 사람이 엄청나게 많을리는 없잖음? 소속사에서도 그걸 아니까 체중관리 중요하게 생각하고 독하게 말하는거고
미나진짜 눈이 두배가 됐네...그래도 통통한축에도 안꼈는데 더 날씬해지기 위해서 어린나이에도..그 고생을 했을 거 생각하니까 너무 안타깝네...그 자체로 이미 예뻤었는데 참 혹독하다 사람들
이사한테 엄청 구박받았던거 기억난다... 비즈니스니까 어쩔 수 없다지만 실제 프로그램에서 엄청 서럽게 대했음..
그래도 살빼서 저렇게 뜨면 오기로 계속 뺄거 같음.. 힘들어 죽을꺼 같긴한데
서러운거 ㅇㅈ인데 구박 말고도 뭔가 이사가 설현을 주목하는 느낌이었음 다이어트 전에도 비주얼이었어서 그런지
진짜 이렇게까지 성공 못 했으면 멘탈 다 털릴꺼 아니야 죽을듯이 다이어트 해서 성공이라도 했으니 다행이지
it's so sad how seolhyun apologizes for her weight.
Kadek Alan right:(
불쌍하다 데뷔하려고 다이어트했을텐데 그래도 살집있다고 괴롭히는게 나라냐. 실제로 병원치료가필요한 거식증 있는 아이돌 예쁘다고 올려치는게 한국. 느그들은 얼마나 마르고 탄탄한지 프로필까고서나 말해봐라.
Dohee Kim 옴걸 진이 생각나요 ㅜㅜ 안타까움
야 살좀빼고 100억벌었는데 그깟살빼는게 대수냐? 설현 어디사는지 검색해보고 와라ㅉㅉ살빼서 대박터진거맞지
20억짜리 아파트에산다
너같음안하겠냐? 오바좀떨지마라
날
@@user-kt2tr8lv2q ㅋㅋ 악플과 훈수로 인해 설현이 바뀐거라고 생각하세요? 악플 쓰셨나봐요 저때ㅋㅋ 자의식과잉봐 우리 와이프도 듣고 웃겠다
@@jacknolan435 말투가 여자같은데 남자인척 하려고 와이프얘기?
@@강태헌-r6h 지랄하지 말래이
0:23 장도연 ㅈㄴ멋있다ㅋㅋㅋ 안 예쁜 날이 없었다고 말해주는거 너무 좋아
I understand mina was a lil chubby so she wanted to lose baby fat but Seolhyun was fine the way she was. Mina honestly looks better during her ioi era where she lost a little weight. The fat makes her look cute
Koreans should stop obssesing so much with diets, both of them looked well and healthy before
I hope you know that they sing and dance a lot... to be able to do that, you need to be fit or else you’ll be out of breath fast.
So you two fools tryna say she was out of shaped??? Tf she had a bangin asf body before! And y’all trippin if you think you have to be skinny to dance lol. Some of the best choreographer isn’t skinny like parris goebel she on the thick side. just gotta have stamina. But at then end of the day it her body she do what she gotta do 🚬 😗
kern x let’s stick to facts here, she did not have a “banging” body before, her belly was sticking out in some of their performances. She was nearing 60 kg. I was expecting you to mention parris goebel, but Im talking about “most” people. Mina got problem with stamina in pd101 because of her weight. And seolhyun now is fit not skinny...
NOMOlonelyNOMOhappy it is a fact with the fact she had a hot ass bangin as body shape a few years ago lmfao. Let be real in Korea their ideal of an beautiful looking person has to be “skinny and lean” which is their “in shape” term. Come on she anit out shape before if that’s what your claim is then like I said y’all fools trippin. But if you wanna talk about stamina then Mina is Mina. Some people have better stamina than others. I know people whos really in great shape for example like a buddie of mines he has great six pack abs and really lean body compare to me I have normal average body but I run a mile in 6 mins while it takes him 9 minutes even in hiking he can’t keep up with me in hiking as well so Just stating fact. FYI your not wrong by saying being in better shape we’ll help improve your stamina and stamina can be built, but when you bring up Mina? Remember she has a different body so overall it just her. Some just have better stamina than other naturally. 💯 yeyee
kern x lol we dont see eye to eye so lets just drop it. Maybe in your country what’s considered “banging af” body is someone who’s belly is sticking out. You know there’s nothing wrong with being fat tho... but filling your head with lies seems like not the right way to do it. And fyi again and again, seolhyun is the right way to describe “fit” not skinny, regardless of korean standards. Dont wanna name drop celebrities, but I know a bunch who’ll be considered “skinny” 🙄
긁어보니 복권 ㅇㅈㄹ 저딴 분위기 때문에 여자 아이돌들이 다이어트하게 되는거 아님
오억두 뭐래
오억두 ㄹㅇ 거기서 거기인데 굳이
눈 깨끗이 씻고다니삼
@@itsyou6618 니가 ㅈㄹ하는거 같은데?ㅋㅋ
병신들아 남돌편도 있어ㅋㅋㅋ
over 50 kilos is Fat?
Jesus Christ
I know right, they are all crazy 😂😂
Ya, Asian standard, I’m 163cm and I have 51kg and it’s considered as fat for others
Yes so crazy
Sadly for any girl group member over 50 is fat
Mashiro Shiina seolhyun is 167cm Tall. Im 172 and i weight 60kg and get called thin already in germany oh myyyy she is under 50 ???
이상한 랭킹 만들어서 분위기 조장하지 마라
키 160넘고 몸무게가 40중반이면 날씬이아니라 진짜 존나마른거에요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ...
I think AOA Seohyun is very tall, so the weight 50kg is good for her. I can't understand why she had to go on a diet although at that time she already had a perfect body.
For Gugudan Mina, I don't think she was fat at the time she was jonied in Produce 101, it's just the upper body was bigger than the lower body, so the whole body was unbalenced. But after diet, Mina's body is well-proportioned and her face is smaller, so it's good for her.
But I hope they are healthy even though they're thin or fat or balaned. Health is the most important thing.
She wasn't 50kg. She was way passed 50kg nearly 60kg that's why the company made her go on a diet.
@@김다-c3d Oh really? Can I ask what is her weight now?
@@hang_207 theo profile gần nhất(Bingle Bangle era) thì là 47kg bạn nhé
That is true. Seolhyun's height is about 167-168. 50kg is totally perfect, i think she still slim at that weight. But she forced to diet till 47kg. That was too mean!!
@@nojaem2595 Cảm ơn bạn
아니 미나는... 우람한것도 아니라 겁나 귀여운거야 팔 트인 옷 입고 살좀 들어나니까 자기 눈에 안 맞나고 살 빼라고 이러는게 뭐냐... ㄹㅇ진정한 팬이 아니지;;;
Its like they want young people in korea to develop eating disorsers
50키로 나간다고 뭐라 하다니..50키로 넘는게 정상인데..
This false marketing, Seolhyun was already a CF star before her diet, and she looked happy and healthy then.
Yeees
i agree but the famous cf is after her diet.......
전현무가 계속 진행자로 섭외되고 있는게 우리나라 아직 멀었단 지표
ㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ 가끔가다 여자한테 하는 말 보면 존나 무례함 ㅅㅂ 요즘 나혼자산다 옛날편 보고있는데 황석정 배우 나올때마다 하는 한마디한마디가 가관이더라 뭐만 말하면 트집잡고ㅋㅋㅋ 이쁜 게스트 보면 또 헤벌레 해가지고 지 면상과 몸뚱아리 생각 좀 하지 시츄상이고 나발이고 존나 비호감상
1:12 전현무 말 하는거 보셈 ㅋㅋ
저걸로 우나 이럼
@@이름-k9n8l 저걸로 '혼나'야 우나 였으면 진작에 큰일났지;
어 그렇네오
아 권혁수 러블리즈 미주랑 가상결혼 했을때 권혁수 아버님집에 갔는데 미주가 저거 발견해서 미주가 칭얼칭얼대고 권혁수 아버님이 미안미안 이러시는데 너무 웃겼음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
권혁수랑 미주랑 가상결혼 했었어요..???!!?!!!! 미주 돈 벌기 힘드네...
@@노유리-s4v 아찔한 사돈연습이라고 가상커플로 나왔었어요. 뭐 소속사가 시키니까 한거죠..
@@노유리-s4v 권혁수 정도면 매너있고 괞찮은 남자지 ㅋㅋㅋ 외모때문인가
김선영 뭘 묻냐.... 와꾸 차이 나이 차이지 미주 개안쓰럽네
김선영 그리고 괞 ㅋㄱㄷㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 괜입니다
진짜 이상한 나라야 다이어트 외모강박에
미친듯이 집착하고
당장 여기 추천수박힌 댓이나 쳐보세요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저 프로 의도가 순위매기는게 정상인거 같음? 난 한국’만’ 외모지상 어쩌고 한 적 없음 유독 심하다고 했지
그리고 그건 사실인데 전세계가
그래요 다른덴 더그래요 이러고있다... 내가 그걸 몰라서 쓴거같으세요? 의도파악을 못해 왜
전세계가 그런데요..
ㅈㄴ웃김 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 우리나라는 병역하게 마르고 싶은거고 다른나라는 건강하게 마르고 싶은거지 외모강박은 둘다 똑같음 그리고 연예인인데 당연한거아니냐; 그럴려고 뽑은애들인데
pindle sky 걔네는 원래 필러 넣기 전부터 엉덩이 컸음 걔네는 서양인이잖아 ㅋㅋ
그럼 나가 살아~
4567890 123 ㅇㅇ 그래서 나와살고 있어 한국이 유독심한건 사실임
다 너무 이쁘고 너무 귀엽다 그냥,,
설현은 살쪗을때도 일반인기준 보통에서 마름인데 실제로는 얼마나 마른거냐;
1:00 말도 안 되네 키 160에 55키로도 정상체중임 근데 170한테 50키로가 넘어!!??!! 이러네
설현 167인데......
나도 13킬로 빼면 복권 당첨되나? ㅋㅋㅋ 근데 살 빼기 전에도 이쁜데 너무 다이어트때문에 힘들것같아 안쓰럽기도하고. 또 근데 보여지는 직업이다보니 어쩔수없을것같기도하고. 뭐 어쨌든 몸건강 정신건강 챙겨가며 다이어트하길...
She should have asked the manager how much she weighed....
Savage 😂
Seolhyun is 167, if she weights 50 kg she is already underweight, with a BMI of 17,93 which is not between the normality interval (18,50 -24'99). She was already underweight and you want her to loose even more weight?????. Weight is extremely related to height. You cannot say that a person over 50 kg is fat. I am 170 and I weight 62 kg, but my BMI is perfectly normal and my health is perfect. If I were to weight 50 I couldn't imagine how skinny I would be...
Yeees! But I'm different, I'm 1,72 and 52kg, but I'm not unhelthy, I eat well and do exercices, When I was 1,68 I haved 48kg. I'm the type of people who dont gain so much weight. Like my friend she is 1,73 and have 62kg she is healthy too. But, If my friend haved 52kg she will totally look unhelthy! What is funny, right? The same happen with Seo if she loses more, she will be unhelthy, and problaby look underweight. I hope they stop to look at the people Kg and start to think in their healthy.
@@AfraMinelly exactly. It also depends on built. I am built super slender. So i am 1.70 and weigh 52.6 right now. I tried my best to diet and gain weight.... so hard unless you add muscle... which i dont want. So i just eat what i want and live.... i never went over 54 kilo's. And i am healthy. I saw a docter for this too.
@@hadjokhan6576 Wow Happen the same with me, I gain muscle 😂😂
花樣年華 BMI is irrelevant/inaccurate/wrong. Only relevant if you are middle age Caucasian male.
You are absolutely right. I am 1.67 and was TWICE diagnosed with anorexia. Both times I was under 50kg - with 46 and 47kg respectively. It is a pity the industry makes them so thin without thinking on health implications. BTW- muscle is heavier than fat, so if they become healthier they can even gain weight
근데 미나도 설현도 워낙본판들이 예뻐서..굳이 저렇게 다이어트를 꼭해야하나요?ㅠ
골드비 다이어트한 만큼 또 화제성이 생기고 미모가 좋아지니까요... 강제성이 있으면 안되지만 보여지는 직업이니까 날씬하길 바라는거죠
00:20 장도연님 대답 센스 굳이당
*정신건강에 무리 올 만큼의 체중을 날씬으로 미화시키지 말자*
50kg is too much for her height?? i think not
Facts lol. 5'5" and 50kg and they say she fat 🤦♂️
She wasn't 50kg when she was forced to go on a diet. She was nearing 60kg.
50 kg is after diet
@@김다-c3d 60 kilos is healthy for her hight 50 is underweight
@@hindmiley nobody said it's unhealthy but 60kg is chubby for her height. And her job requires her for a fit body but look at her body during her early debuts, she's chubby not exactly fit.
데뷔후 어디가 통통..
이런 주제의 방송이 다이어트를 해야한다는 강박증같은 상태를 조성하는데에 한 몫한다는걸 모르나 이런 주제 그만 방송해주면 좋겠다..
원래도 말랐잖아 ㅠㅠㅠ 그냥 다 예뻐
Stoooop! mina and Seolhyeon are not healthy anymore! Stop saying that looking that skinny it’s cool and better, there are people dying and getting eating desorders for that! Korean needs to change!!!
Well... They are healthy under strict yet efficient diet. Yes they are under strict diet may seem unhealthy, but most of the Korean entertainment company uses dietitian and personal trainers to keep in check of their artist's health. However, in the case of jimin from aoa, I do agree she does not look healthy.
@@jacksonmagilacuty1745 How are they healthy when during 1 period of time Seolhyun was sick all the time? She couldnt survive through any shedul without fainting or feeling sick.
Jackson Magilacuty “may seem unhealthy”, probably because they’re starving them. And no its not efficient nor healthy. Look some videos up of idols yoyoing in their diets
@@jacksonmagilacuty1745 Most Kpop companies cannot afford dieticians. And the dieticians ones do use aren't usually looking at their health as a goal but rather looks.
@@jacksonmagilacuty1745 I mean eating almost entirely one type of food is NOT healthy!
뭐야 장도연님 오늘 완전 예쁘다 아니 원래 예뻤는데 못 느낀건가
아니 설현 키가 168 거의 170인데 50키로 넘는건 당연한 거 아님? 살빼기 전에도 마른 걸텐데 지금은 얼마나 마른거냐….
아 아린님이셨구나... 장발도 너무 이쁘신데.....?? 완전 피치피치하시구만🍑
Kang Mina is so underrated.
Kang Mina 💖💖💖
Yiusyeng have you watched her in pd101? She has a nasty attitude. After that episode, her ranking fell so fast.
@@julynightowl7413 Maybe so. Are you sure she's still the same since then? I never chose a bias back then, i just appreciate her recent works. I don't want to be bias about it, since people change every year.
Yiusyeng I really hope she has a better attitude now and learned how to be modest.
Ki jadaro when they were doing the position evaluation (dance), their group had 3 members who were way behind in the rankings compared to nayoung and mina and the three also had the least center time during the performance. There’s this one girl who got like 5 sec. center time but that dance step needs all of them to face at the back (that means she did not get any center time at all). While practicing, she asked nicely (and cried) if she could at least face in the front while doing the part (nayoung choreographed the dance), MINA suddenly got angry over her wanting to change the choreo for just that 5 sec step and she was like talking bad behind her back and to think that she’s more on the maknae side. Mina was the center for that performance and was very popular but after that episode her ranking fell so fast, there’s a big difference in her ranking before and after.
지랄하누ㅜ
I'm the same as her before , Struggling to lose 13kg
와..진짜설현은 찐건찐데로이쁘고 뺀건뺀데로이쁘다..미나님은 화면빨이안받는건지 많이통통하게나온거같긴한데 실제로는 그렇게 보기싫지않을거같은데 그래도다이어트하니까 자신감상승되고더당당해보이는거같아서 보기좋네요ㅎㅎ
They were perfectly fine before😅
True!! Sorry but i don't like Seolhyun's body now 😢
Denisse Tapia Don’t worry! I’m sure she’s healthy besides everyone has their own preferences as to what’s attractive. It’s ok as long as ur not hurting anyone’s feelings😅
나만 썸넬 보고 혼자 ' 니가 설현이냐.' 라고 중얼거렷냐
갓도연 사랑해요
설현 키가 좀 있는 편 아닌가?근데 50이 넘어서 욕을 먹어...?
설현 늘 예쁘다고 해준 장도연 쏘스윗❤️
아니 50키로라니 ㅜㅜ 키가 있는데…‥‥-。 50넘은 게 좀더 남자들이 좋아하는 상인듯??? 아닌가 ㅜ.. 근데진짜 저키에 50키로 초반이면 마른건대 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠ
와 아린ㅈㄴ이뻐
OH MY GIRL＆AOA !?!?!?
I love them🥰🥰🥰🥰
Gugudan & AOA
설현은 진짜 타고났음. 부러웡
Their standards are CRAZY !!! Thank god I don't live in Korea.. Mina is so gorgeous
장도연 넘 좋아
센스가........♥
장도연언니 도망가요.
흔들려 부를때 설현씨 체형이 더 이쁘네요
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ설현 먹는거 왤케 기엽냐 ㅠㅠ
미나님 너~~~~~무 좋아요!!♥
여돌중짱!!!♥
they should switch their focus into fit & Healthy. in their line of work their body is their greatest asset. they should always be healthy. being skinny doesn't always translate to being healthy. being chubby doesn't always translate to being unhealthy either. Find the balance.
2:56 아 개귀엽네....
몇번을 돌려보는지
2:54 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저세상 애교>
Too me, Seol Hyun looked perfect before. Same thing for Mina!
우와 설현은 그냥 비슷한데 . 미나는 원래통통하면서 귀여운매력이였는데 이미지가 확 바뀌었네. 둘다 좋다. 그냥 적당히 하길
떠려니언니 항상 예뻐용💖💖
Original beauty of idol
미나 진짜 귀엽당ㅎㅎ
They don't emphasize enough that sure they're was diet implicated but also they went from teenagers with baby fat to grown woman and that makes a huge difference.... I really hate the way weight is perceived in Korean beauty standard, you're beautiful the way you are people don't let this bring you down !!!!
와 미나 ㄷㄷ 진짜 와 ㄷㄷㄷ 대단해 ㅠ
Talking about lost weight, I miss Umji GFRIEND too.
Baby Umji ahhh, I love you whenever
They should include umji in it.. She lost a lot of weight
다이어트를 하든안하든 둘다 이쁘다 너무 하면 무리가 올수도 있으니까 ㅠㅠ조금씩만하세요
0:39 편집자분도 어지간히 찔리셨나보지.........
통통 옆에 (?) 달아주심.... 미나는 진짜 귀엽고
살도 진짜 몰랑몰랑할것같이 생기셔서 인기
많았는데 이제는 그 귀여운게 없어져서 아쉽기
만 한데이걸 여기에 써먹네욬ㅋㅋㅋ 하......
--걍 다 이쁘니까 뭐라하지 말았으면 좋겠 *선* --
❤️👍
Reading all these comments, I don't understand why the media is still trying to force us to believe that being all bones is sexy 😕
It is insulting that you say that. I'm the same bmi as seolhyun and I still say that I look sexy. The media isn't forcing you to believe that, it is true just as much as curvy girls are sexy. Don't put down other girls just to fit your worldview. It does you no good.
@@tongtong8801 really? Well too bad you felt insulted cause it wasn't really an insult and you're feeling all butt hurt over nothing. Actually yes the media is portraying that thin is sexy, have you seen actresses on the screen? They're all trying to be thinner by dieting not by exercising. Bragging about being models and being a size zero. Versus making 50 reality shows about curvy people and making them lose weight. Sorry all your points are invalid. Try again next time 🙄
Did you watch the video? They quite literally showed Seolhyun exercising, but go off I guess. I understand that the models are often skinnier, but the phrase "being all bones" in inherently an insult, but good try in gaslighting me. I'm not "butthurt" I'm just pointing out that you bring down others just to boost yourself.
@@tongtong8801 how am I boosting myself? Lol just cant admit your oversensitive and butt hurt over nothing. Also being 50kg is fine but I guess you people think thats too fat and thats your problem. Idgaf as long as she looks healthy. Sorry try again.
Queen Chanmi uh oh sensitive Karen browsing the comments section again looking for people to correct and force her ideas on
찌든 안찌든 다 아름다운 사람들이다.
AOA Kim Seol Hyun
여전히 통통하다니! 얼마나 귀여운뎁!!
Mina is so cute chubbier
미나 살 빼기 전에 실물 봤는데 그냥 마른 애기였다고ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
Seolhyun is always pretty
아린 씅 넘 예뻐
2:03 장도연도 몸매 죽이고 비율 죽인데
얼마나 노력한거야. 저 몸 만들려고 눈물 꽤 흘렸겠다. 먹는걸로 뭐라고 서럽던데.
결국에는 승리자 됀거 멋있다.
If you ask me. She looks great!! She still had a great body and ate what made her happy. But as long as she is healthy and living her best life that's what matters.
미나 장난아니다... ㄷㄷ
To me Seolhyun looked better before she lost her weight....I like the way she was before, healthy and happy
난 개인적으로 미나는 통통할때가 더 귀엽고 매려있는거 같음
1:20 다이어트 식단 확인
내가 좋아하는 두명 ㅋ 너무 이뻐
I lose 9kg in 3 months and i've stopped it for a month now and gained 2kg back 😭 but my goal is to lose 15kg 😭😭 watching this make me wanna go on diet again, thankyou mina and seolhyun 😭😭❤️
(I was 67kg and 155cm, now i'm on 59kg😭)
Make a plan first.. but don't push your self with starving.. Change your diet meal.. U can do it.. Fighting.. 😜👍
@@rivercloud77 yeah but i'm really lazy to work out that's why i basically just dieting.. i know it isn't good but my laziness just.... Ugh
@Ki jadaro i lost it when ramadhan too, eventough i didn't fasting because i'm not a moslem but the environment made me kinda fasting too so that's good actually 😂
You guys did really great, i don't think i can last a day without drinking 😳😳
@@nanar0d i tried a lot of diet plans, but the one worked out the most for me is Intermitten fasting, you can search it, and i calculate how much calorie i consume everyday, and doing HIIT workout (but i stop in 2 weeks because it's really painful for me 😂😂)
@Saki Vyshnia Thankyou! I'm starting again this week, since i've failed 😳😳 can't resist so many delicious food my mom&dad made 😭
나 : 아 진짜 자야겠다
유튜브 : 설현 보러 와
아니 13키로 빼기 전도 통통이 아닌데..? 카메라라 그렇게 보이는 거일 거 아냐ㅜㅠ 떠려니 맛있는 거 많이 먹고 건강챙기자ㅠㅠㅠㅠ늘 예쁜데..
그래. 설현은 예쁘기'만'하지 하하하
설현 키가 거의 170인걸로 알고있는데 ,
50 넘으면 당근 정상임 ㅇㅇ
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
살찐 설현은 귀염
설현비포 에프터 옷차림차이 밖에 없는데요 처음소식들었을때 뚱띵이어서 살뺀줄알았다능 어려서 살 잘빠지는것임 사진도 비포는 줌으로 찍고 에프터는 풀샷이냐
우리 미나언니랑 설현언니가 어때서요!우리 언니들은 1g 사라지는 것도 아까워!!그리고 충분히 말랐는데,도대체 뭐가 부족해!
"She always looked gorgeous to me" she is the kind of a person we need in society... i stan this lady.. will someone say her name.. she is positive