How the Beirut explosion was a government failure
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 ноя 2024
- And why Lebanon is on the verge of collapse.
Subscribe to our channel! goo.gl/0bsAjO
On August 4, 2020, a massive explosion rocked Beirut, the capital city of Lebanon. The blast occurred when sparks in a warehouse hit a stockpile of ammonium nitrate - a highly explosive material - that was stored in the city's port. It was one of the largest accidental explosions in history and it couldn't have occurred at a worse time for Lebanon.
For the past several years, the country has been sliding into an economic depression and a political crisis. The root causes began during the country's 20-year civil war and extend to the organization of the government, in which control is divided among the country's many religious sects.
After years of corruption and negligence, Lebanon's people are now stuck picking up the pieces.
Sources and additional reading:
New York Times Visual Investigations: www.nytimes.co...
Carnegie Endowment:
carnegieendowm...
Ahmad Barclay:
/ 1186967940178071552
The Economist:
www.economist....
Ziad Abu-Rish / Jadaliyya:
www.jadaliyya....
Triangle:
www.thinktrian...
Financial Times:
ftalphaville.f...
Mohamad Bazzi / Foreign Affairs:
www.foreignaff...
Dion Nissenbaum, Nazih Osseiran, Georgi Kantchev and Benoit Faucon / The Wall Street Journal:
www.wsj.com/ar...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
Nothing is more permanent than a temporary solution
freedom is not free lol
Like POK (Pakistan occupied Kashmir)
It was Gtas orbital cannon
@Sumeet tanwar agreed
@@user-op8fg3ny3j our Kashmiri pandiths don't have to worry about "chini" investments
Props to the people of Lebanon. Their government has failed them, yet they stand united and the reject corruption while being civil.
Lysergik Hmm... Lebanon has a very high corruption rate
I m lebanese. We re not united. Very divided in to religious sects
@@Jacob56644 ye and that's wrong
Lol_Q L People keep electing warlords from the civil war and idolize them while these warlords themselves to this day divide everyone and then sit on a table and cut the cake between each other, also we don’t have a government they are literally groups of mafias looking to loot tax - aid - government employee pays.. they literally depend on people being divided
@@Jacob56644 good thing now at least were united into less groups, all woke people united, and the dumbest will follow their corrupted leader likes cheeps
Poor countries don't have a poverty problem. They have a government problem.
@@johnpaulbrebonia9106 the cause is always government
@@johnpaulbrebonia9106 only the government buddy , I'm from Lebanon it's the government.
@Syed Ahmed But then there weren't any rich people either, this was when we were hunters and gatherers and barely surviving and finding food.
@Syed Ahmed Yep, but they were poor and hungry and they didn't have government then but they certainly had leaders or people who were head of the tribe
Poor countries aren't actually poor
The government made them poor
I was so interested about their government that I forgot we were talking about the Beirut explosion
Same 😂
Cause it's government failure 🙄
Me to
Same HAHHAHA
Very interesting video and storytelling.
Greed and religion mixed together into the government? Yikes.
Syria Ball sunni and shia
@Syria Ball no their equal in percentage
You talking ‘bout Turkey ?
u talk about almost ever medial east country
See what we suffer?
As a Lebanese person, this was very very well done! Highlighted all the important factors that has lead to the current catastrophe in Lebanon. Thank you for this
I agree, but the thing is that they never make a video showing how beautiful our country is, they always show the bad things like the explosions, terrorist attacks that barely happen 1 time a year, etc..
@@justakid8537 because there are so many good places elsewhere. lebanon is nice, i have been, but so are other places.
@@poddop yeah but what country has a world miracle that isn't classified in its category.
@@th_owl4500 Australia seems to be the only answer, except half the people here don't think it even exists
not until they mentioned that Saad Al Hariri was a hostage in KSA. Because that’s hilarious 😆
You know your country is done when the government is divided by religion, race or anything else .
Im curious what you think a perfect country is then?
The ruling party in Germany is a religious party.
As a religious dude i too agree on this
Sweden soon there
Political partie
My best friends dad died bc a mosque was 1 minute away from the place thay exploded and the mosques came down and nobody survived😢
That's sad :(
RIP
imagining dying in church ,it could be that you cant hope for a divine hand
Horrible.
I am very sorry about his loss I hope u all are doing as well as you can
Moral of the story.
"Keep religion out of politics"
But if you keep it out of politics everyone will complain about not being represented, or being supersed by the majority. Plus in the US politicians talk about Christianity all the time so you don't get to tell people about that.
Moral of the story is people are the real problem and will use anything to follow their corrupt desires
Mexico learned it the hard way
@@HopeRock425 I mean we could have politicians from different religions that may represent issues that the particular religious group may be facing, but I seriously doubt that basing entire politics on regelion or dividing parties based on religious lines is even remotely a good idea..
There are plenty of non-religious countries with similar flawed systems, poverty, corruption and poor leadership. The correct ideology and economic system isn't in place, and subversive elements still infiltrates Lebanon (openly, without backlash). This is what has to be rectified. Opportunity need to be created, starting up businesses should become attractive, criminals/terrorists should be removed and a zero tolerance policy towards corruptions, negligence, misconduct, etc, must prevail.
This video is phenomenal. Such a terrific, concise explanation. Bravo.
It was a good presentation, yes. But it doesn’t even mention Hezbollah and the role they’ve played in Lebanese politics. That’s a huge omission.
@@RogerMacCallum hezbollah is just part of the system mentioned (from shia sect), sunni and maronite hold similar power in the government, not to mention syiria military stationed there.
I totally agree with you!!
Except for the horrible sound editing
Yeah somehow better than what we learn in school
Looking at history, anytime you divide people or a country up based on religious groups, it always always ends badly.
Thank God I'm atheist 🤣🤣🤣
I’m so glad I’m a atheist
cosmicwraith gamer amen... oh wait
“Thank god I’m atheist lol”
- kids who think Christianity is the same as racism
@@Funnydoc its a clear cut joke bud. This ability to seek out anything that confirms your world views is the real problem.
as a lebanese person, watching this almost 3 years later still hurts a lot till this day, i really hope lebanon can become a better place sometime soon
It's almost like a handful of people controlling the money of a whole country never turns out fair. Who knew!?
It's capitalism.
The Firminator that’s not capitalism..
@@bobbysanchezlive659 so what is it?
@@thefirminator socialism
@@thefirminator More like kleptocronyism. Any economic system without a transparent and accountable government is corrupt. Venezuela is socialist yet obviously it's government is corrupt to the point of bankrupting their economy.
It saddens everyone that so many people were affected due to this disaster and this is just due to the ineffectiveness of the government.
@Roben Bou Mansour No that's not true.
@Sultan Abdulhameed II What the heck are you talking about? Israel had nothing to do with the demolition, and are merely trying to defend themselves whenever Hizbollah or some other reprehensible Lebanese terror group attacks Israel. Don't create these made-up and fallacious scapegoats, that's despicable.
@@SerenityM54L2SAM5L5N1 you are completely wrong
@@SerenityM54L2SAM5L5N1 hizbollah has never attacked Israel, they are protecting this country better than the government
💟💜
This is why people aren't donating directly to the Lebanese Government but to the People of Lebanon through NGOs. Support the people, not the government and help stir the change for a better Lebanon. A better Lebanon means a better world for all of us. 🌲🌍
🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧
A better Lebanon must go through war.
Elias Ziad That’s how we turned from a 1st world country into a 3rd. So no
Elias Ziad hezbollah is know making one
@@eliasziad7864 sounds like what a corrupt president would say
"Hey, let's put THESE explosives next to flammable Stuff. What can go Wrong?"
Yeah you are very smart mesheil oun, i don't know how to spell his name.
Even cantina angry
Canadian *
What could possibly go wrong Answer: Everything*
HAHAH...LUXURIOUS PEOPLE HIDDEN TERROR, CROUCHING TIGER HIDDEN DRAGON BALL Z.
Meanwhile in America people are complaining about swearing masks...
True, I just wear because stores and places say you have to.
Meanwhile in America, the West coast is on fire, trapping thousands of residents in their homes and burning thousands and thousands of acres.
Yeah those masks should really watch their language!
Joe Ryan < people not in the USA.. these are the people that are causing our problems in the USA
@Joe Ryan You can't be serious
This is why separation of church and state is important in a democracy.
Church and Mosques if said accurately
Religion in general basically...
Islam doesn't work like that dude....
Venkat Kamath The Lebanese president is always Christian. So church as well.
Lebanon that has no natural resources & no money.
The country has nothing to offer the world.
Lebanon is finished. Just forget about it.
it makes me so sad that people have so different possibilitys in life just defined by the place they were born :(
It's a dice roll
@Luke we ain't ! this is the reason why swathes of this planet are sweatshops still
You can make up for it by being good to the ones that escape from those places and come to your country.
The problem isn’t the place, it’s how much influence religion plays into its economy. All these different religions together are killing these people.
@@002mjr The thing is mixing religion and politics shouldn't be a thing. But the thing is, you'll see that if Lebanon was governed by an ultimate religion, then the religious fellows following that religion will have some kind of life-advantages. Although this is true, this government of ours is way too corrupt that the risks of the other anecdote doesn't sound as bad anymore.
I'm half Lebanese, and my grandparents lived close enough to the explosion for their windows to break. I am really young, and although I can help, I'm all the way in Dubai, and all I can do is spread awareness, so I hope that those of you can do more than I watch this video and help out.
Glad to know that there are still those who maintain string ties to their home country. I hope Lebanon recovers from this tragedy- An American
Hope your grandparents are okay. Spreading lots of love! ❤️
I also live in dubai!
@@suhailab3634 didn’t ask
@@474yx Verbally Vomiting of people. Oof
Imagine there are so many governments and countries like Lebanon that haven't come into limelight.
Yet.
Yet.
India is one of them
I'd say half of them
It’s so scary having a government divided by religion. I worry as Europe and other places become more diverse these kinds of government will start to take root.
"Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely" -J. Dalberg
“Power doesn’t corrupt, it reveals.” -Obama
@@vvolfbelorven7084
exacto.
el poder no corrompe a nadie. solo le da la oportunindad de demostrarte lo corruptos que son.
they are corrupt before in power... that area was from warzone on first palce... peace with corrupt just a price they had to paid to get thier life to normal.. don't mean it is.. before that bomb happen... this is too much a accident.. feeling like that resource was send then.. knowing it would stuck.. knowing that it would not able to left the country since they can reorder... left there for 7 years before it was explsion.. so to get country back to fight...
@@vvolfbelorven7084 tell that to John Dalberg, not me
Power doesn't corrupt. Power attracts those who are corrupt.
I wish VOX borders with Johnny Harris could cover this...
Sadly Borders got cancelled and Johnny left VOX :(
@@user-vu2yb1gy4l , I was really sad watching that video
@@TechoNeko me too :(
Even Johnny isn't safe from a laid off.
I don't know what really happened but Harris was a great asset for VOX, shame on you
Now I understand why my great-great-grandparents on my mother's side migrated from Lebanon ...
To Japan?
Japan? 🤨
@@blopblop8970 No that's a character from a video game series (danganronpa)
@@barryirlandi4217 No that's a character from a video game series (danganronpa)
@@barryirlandi4217 mexico 😀
One of the saddest events of 2020
I see you on every video i watched since the last two days.
Vincent Cuevas same 😭
you're everywhere
2020 is a sad event.
2020, a series of sad events
Ah yes, the classic "it's not my fault so it must be yours."
I see Hisballah saying this, no he is gonna blame it on Israel and Syria and much more. "ISwAeEl CaUsEd ThIs"
It’s what the us have Been doing for decades
@@z.6480 Hezbollah himself said they have no evidence to say whether Israel did this or not, also Syria, really?
@@maazkalim He litterly keeps on saying that, this is coming from a Lebanese. Every time I watch him talking about a situation, he atleast has to blame it on Israel. He even blamed Israel for killing the Hariri.
@@m-hellothere4167 Nah, he says it anyways even thought they aren't involved in it. It's in almost all of his speeches.
I’m actually from Lebenon, and trust me nothing is perfect. But the people are always nice and help each other. Some may have arguments from time to time, but they stick up for each other. To be real the unn should just take down that government. It’s actually so corrupt I can’t explain
My dad spent a lot of time in the Irish army in peacekeeping missions there
i still remember Beirut being famous for its nightlife
Aal addd
@Karl RAHAL how is Kuwait corrupt Kuwait is good
Im from lebanon
Leb government: out here living our best life
Leb people: were literally dying or dead.
Leb gov: this ain't about you
They don’t even look at us .
If you are lebanese you will understand what im sayin : ma nkoun za3ajnehoun bi hal enfijar
that can be said for pretty much any third world country
@@ringoferrer2343 yep, sadly that's true 🤷♀️🤷♀️
I feel like we’re sitting here wondering how things can get so corrupt, while our countries are going the same way, but slower.
oh mine was already there 50 years ago
@@flosset9640 ah, you must live in the u.S
@@Idk-gn8ov when was the usa corrupt and no im on the other side of the world
@@flosset9640 1950-60 - present.
@flosset In the US, corporations donate enormous amounts of money to politicians in exchange for passing legislation that aligns with their agenda. Big pharma, oil companies, tobacco conglomerates, etc..
You forgot to mention that the Taif Agreement clearly says that all militias must be disarmed and their weaponry handed over to the lebanese military instead.
All of the militiad did indeed disarm with the exception of the shia militia, which later turned into Hezbollah
Found 4 prostitutes
@@gamingchamp6728 u mean 2 right
Dark Ester there’s 3 now
And it ruined us
None of the militias disarmed. Guns are so common there that handing over a few weapons for show won't change anything. In fact, most of these militias still exist. The reason Hezbollah is talked about more is that they're just smarter and supported by Iran.
religion and politics, what could go wrong
Worked well for Rome
Actually its humans religion and politics is not the problem the world wars weren't started on religion its human greed and cruelity that leads to this
@Tigray Adey exactly thanks I wish more people knew this cause if it's truly religions then why are some of the worst dictators atheists, its human cruelity and greed
@Tigray Adey it's the 7 deadly sin duh not just greed
@@mghq-mobilegamerzhq2533 Because Dictators are always bad? lol what kind of comaprison is that🙄
I am Lebanese and tbh this video is basically explaining the story of lebanon, this video is very true and it’s sad to see what disgusting negligence and greed has caused to my country
Solidarity with the Lebanese people. They prove humanity can do better. And so they aren't wrong for demanding better.
as a Lebanese this is a very great detailed video however there’s a still a lot missing.
Can you elaborate more please?
It's very difficult to explain the collapse of the Lebanese economy in just 10 minutes, but imo they did a good job of going over how the Ponzi scheme effectively destroyed all confidence in said system
For an 11 min video It is way above average of information
Missing Hezbollah's taking over this country and suffocating it
It’s a way to USAxplain things to the world and reduce everything to a battle between evil and good
Wow, I know my country has many problems, but these videos just make me realise how far we've come as well. A stable country really is a prized possession nowadays!
Its a Deliberate attack Perpetrated by the best at Deception, Disguised as an accident.
[Pause the video 1 second before the explosion and watch it in slow motion]
Based on what evidence do you claim this? Amazes me how a large part of the public will always believe random conspiracy theories.
webb Dont attribute to malice what you can attribute to sheer stupidity, or I guess here government corruption, which s the real conspiracy.
@@webb7903 okay, let's just try and believe what you're saying is true... Even then who would have done this?
@@grod3an many believe it is an Israeli attack, but no one is claiming this and no one will cause if they do war will be declared. But evrn Hezbollah denied having weapons in there, cause if he said that he had weapons, we would have blamed him for everything that happened, but the truth is everything happened because of him.
The Dust Filled streets remind me of 9/11. R.I.P To lives lost in beirut, And in 9/11.
Ya
You're so open minded john 🙂
You still alive?
Mister Fitzgerald's account is used by Bobby Kennedy
Nice John, Lovely president
It's amazing that you could fit something most Lebanese people fail to understand into a 10 minute video.
Thank you, from me and from all my Lebanese brothers and sisters. We appreciate you talking about our country, I learned things I wouldn't have known otherwise. One of these things being the sheer extent of the banking scheme.
Thank you for making this. I'm from Lebanon and it saddens me to want to leave this place, I just want to work in peace. But thank you for making this it really helps us a lot.
It’s an absolute shame such a great country is suffering so much. I have a Lebanese girlfriend and she is terrified to go back to Beirut. We live in London
This has been the best, in depth analysis of the event happening in that country that I found. You earned yourself a like AND a new suscriber
I have been subscribed to them for a few years now. Lovely news insights and inputs.
a new like and subscriber !?!? 😱😱😱
And this doesn't even mention the immense strain the Syrian refugee crisis has put on Lebanon.....
tobeylee18 yeah now go ahead and blame the Syrians for the crippling Lebanese economy and the inadequacy and corruption of its government, I’m not going to even mention the extreme sectarianism that exists in Lebanon. “Immense strain {...} on Lebanon”, what strain are you even talking about? Economical strain? Social strain? It’s like Lebanon is helping the refugees financially in any shape or form (And I’m not suggesting they’re obligated to but that’s just worth mentioning).
@@antoniowardeh4772 knir antonio. Wallah 3eb 3aleyna ka lebneniyyeh kif 3amalna e5wenna lsuriyyeh
lifeisshortdon'twasteitreadingmyname if only they were given the right to do so legally and not pushed down and denied the basic right of working legally, which would have eliminated the enslavement and ridiculous salaries given to those people working illegally, which is also at the same time harming the working class Lebanese citizen by creating an unequal competition, but yet again profiting the rich businessmen..
@@antoniowardeh4772 personally i blame both our politicians for corruption and sectarianism ...and syrian refugees because thay came in huge numbers lebanon can't handle especially that this country was already in a crisis
@ZA WARUDO lol what does the revolution have to do with that
Imagine if this happened in London or New York, they would treat it bigger than 9/11
Fact
Probably go to war with another made up enemy over it too.
@Anonymous Umm, what?
@Anonymous US deserves this, karma
@Anonymous hahaha
This is a whole history textbook
It is
sussy
You cant let a few people be in charge of so much money. Theyre just gonna keep it for themselves. Imagine thinking people will be honest when you hand them a billion dollars for electricity.
No one in lebanon thought they would be honest, but you had no other choice
to grasp the misery of the Lebanese people, there's a famous quote that's being revived... "عايشين من قلة الموت"
which roughly translates to "the only reason we're alive is because we aren't dead yet"
Another way to phrase it is "we're living from not dieng"
You guys made a brilliant short summary of Lebanon's failed system.
Syria and Israel getting into Lebanon also shows how historically Lebanon was so poorly governed. Assad thought he could gain more control over what he sees as "greater Syria". Israel got in because Palestinians settled in the south and started using Lebanon as a launchpad of terror into Israel. This wouldn't happen in a well managed sovereign country.
Sending love to the people of Lebanon! I hope this time you get rid of corruption for good. 🙏
@The Killer That's not a fact but an opinion
@The Killer In my opinion both sides are wrong, and it's not a fact, it's my opinion
- syria was supposed to be our good neighbor but it turns out to be as bad as Israel
- lebanon a small peaceful country ... lebanon have been through a lot
@The Killer All Israel was litteraly doing since it was established is protecting itself. The palestinians and arab neighbours are litteraly the only agressors in this conflict and a small independant research everyone can do will show it. There is no peace-loving country more then Israel- that gave up the majority of the land it legally won only for peace agreements.
If the palestinians ever actually wanted peace and co-existance, the conflict would have been long forgotten already.
@@HillelSe they are technically still at war, so why would they accept help.
Imagine not mentioning hezboullah
because hezbollah has nothing to do with this you islamophobe?
Luneala I’m a Muslim
Luneala I’m sorry but you really dont know the middle east you shouldn’t impose ur western Standards on our problems
That way you’ll lapel AlQaeda as freedom fighters
What's hezboullah?
bin bin
one of the many terror groups that use the prophecies of the end of time to their political gain or use the fight against israel as a legitimate cause
This is where South Africa is headed if corruption in government system is not stopped
Videx Sicarii I really love comments like this. You think Africa is the only place with food shortages? 😅
K
look at brazil economy after the car wash stop corruption is not eazy
Wait till you meet Indian government officials, the currouption is so high that you can pay judge money and win case, politicians built statues using taxpayers' money, they are stealing land from poor people to. Help multimillionaires business, well they give people basic amenities, like 24 hour water and electritricy and and they have solved open toilet problem too with 100% toilet coverage but curroption is just saddening, and sometimes we wonder how our country is still running, India will collapse and divides in pieces if governments were not clever enough to commit crimes perfectly
@@blopblop8970 sadly India already collapsed before (British colonization dropped it from the best economy of the world to the worst) and also divided into 3 (Bangladesh, India, Pakistan).
الله يرحم من مات في هذا الانفجار الكبير والله يشفي المصابين ويصبر أهل لبنان 😔💔💔على هذا الحدث نتمنى لكم كل خير تحياتي من السعودية🇸🇦💕💕
ما يستاهلون
As a Syrian refugee who was forced to flee the country due to Syrian Civil War, it's a very horrifying experience to relive the same catastrophe all over again while my prospects of ever having a decent future slowly fades away into the Abyss. I keep hoping for some intervention to rescue me from the shackles of this Corrupted country so that i can at least enjoy some of the privileges people in most countries don't think twice about.
Then go back to syria, Lebanon doesn't want you
I hope you have found peace or have found hope.
I am also Syrian refugee me and my parents fled to Saudi Arabia
I live in Lebanon and update : Still the country didn't recover from it and we have like 1000% inflation, $ used to be = 1500 LBP now its $= 18 000 LBP pain
Yikes, and I thought inflation here in the states was bad
@@Rami358able worse, since we cant recover politically and economically from it
I’m Lebanese, from beirut to be exact ,but a couple years ago i moved to Canada, and almost my whole family lives there(cousins,aunts,uncles,grandparents,etc) and I’m so glad i moved, although I wanted to live there when I was young because everyone I loved was there but now that I’m a bit older, I’m glad I moved
@@user-eb6vc2gs9e yep second one :)
this is THE BEST journalism, if they still call "explaining actual situation" journalism
So why didn’t they explain Hizballa part on the explosion? This terror organizations’ control over the public services? I feel like I got only part of the truth (which is worst than a lie)
Makes me a lot more grateful to be living in a country without a weird political system, but at the same time, I wish I could help out the people affected by the blast.
This is one of the few resources I have seen that talks about the events leading up to the explosion, instead of other potential disasters in wealthier first-world countries. Great job spreading awareness with this accurate and concise video 👏
Thank you for drawing light on our situation in Lebanon❤️❤️🇱🇧🇱🇧
inshallah things will get better....
Hope. It is the only thing stronger than fear.
- President Snow
Ah, I see you're a man of culture as well
@@aayushagarwal4138 😂😂
Dude how does it feel to be a bot and how can I make a bot for my self?
What hope? my country was blown up, a woman nearly died in front of me, old people lost the homes they've had for decades and my government is still playing tag.
@@LVE-xr5or bro what?
When you use religion to mask your failings of your ruling, you have failes both your religion and rule
I remember Christopher Hitchens criticizing the Lebanese government for having this bizarre system of reserving seats in government for certain religions.
R.I.P to all that have died and keep their families in your prayers
Where does Vox get it's soundtracks for these videos??
They are big enough now to hire people to do music for each video if they want.
You can find lots of non copy righted music in youtube
Media often licenses music from commercial libraries for this purpose.
@@ashish00007 I suppose. They do have the money
@obsoleteUbiquity I just realized 😅 thanks!
It is sad when politicians don't do their job.
no politician has done his or her job in the history of human civilization , what makes you think they will do now
@I don't want to be anybody well capitalism won in the last century 😂
Wait, They have jobs?
it is Saad when politicians don't do their job.
Its even sadder when we vote them
I've heard a lot of random bits and pieces about Lebanon's situation from the news and friends but this put everything into context in a really concise way. Bravo
The factual representation and the explanation of the collapse through the graphics is on point! Quality video production as always.
this is one of the most depressing and heart clenching video i've ever seen.
As someone from Lebanon, it's even more depressing in real life 😞
@@bayXSonic
Unless he is from Syria, Afghanistan or Iraq cause those places are... well we all know. Going through a lot
@@mirzahamzabaig5667 trust me lebanon aint any better. currently syria is way better than lebanon. id move there.
Never in my life have I seen buildings literally evaporate.
The world is in an eternal chaos
It's called entropy
you mean humans..
we didn't start the fire...
@Ocen Lian i hope so.
always has been.
love to all lebanese people 🇱🇧 ❤️ we are with you guys
"For the fault of evils, innocents pay the price"
-(I don't know if someone said that)
when innocent pay the price, they will be looking for revenge and they will be evil
They deserve a government who reflects their shared belief in democracy over old religious segmentation. The Lebanese people are clearly more circular than their fallen government and they deserve much better.
Well said, sir.
As a Lebanese citizen, I want to thank you for making this amazing short clip summarizing our situation because more than half of our population still doesn't understand half of what's happening and are still following their political parties.
Lebanon needs change and if its not now its never going to happen.
Im soo sad because im from lebanon evrytime i see a poor guy i started crying
They made the biggest mistake you could ever make:
Assuming politicians will care about the country
It's because people always change the system, and forget to change the people running the system.
If the old people run the new system, the problem always prevails.
Nope .......if your system is under any influence then its totally corrupt system
@@gaurangpatel8234 kind of what I said. Even if the system is good, if you don't take away the people running it, it's no use.
@@noha3875 yeah ....if system does not allow good new guys to handle it .....its totally corrupt .......it doesn't matter its been running by new or old guys or system is new or old.
I got the impression that the system was the problem to begin with
@Noha Underrated 💯
It's so sad this happened, cause that ship was there for seven years just waiting to cause an explosion
There is a story about a couple and their young son who were there as part of a business trip for a few weeks, and when the explosion happened, the large view window shattered and sent a shard of glass into their little boy's chest. The little boy died, and the family is haunted by the entire event, the fact that they weren't even suppose to be there, since their flight out was delayed by another day. So horribly heartbreaking
5:00 : What is that Y-Scale? It's a bar graph so it should start from 0, which it does, but than it goes on with 135,150,145. That seems to me a bit confusing.
Yeah, it's confusing; nothing wrong with having your y axis start from 130, which is what I think they meant?
It's ironic since Vox were the ones who made that video about graphs a few years ago.
Scale is taken as 1 unit=5%
Aww u confused?
i think they want you to focus on the 140+ and the comparision through out the years.
i think they want you to focus on the 140+ and the comparision through out the years.
Love from Taiwan, I hope Lebanon achieve their goals, the people helping each other after the explosion is really beautiful it gives hope to a better country
As a lebanese, I thank VOX for this objective analysis of the beirut explosion, it highlights the pains of my people from this corrupt system that uses religion to hold on to power.
Lebanon : corrupt politicians that brought the debt to gdp a lot higher during
Greece : hey I have seen this one
At least you are in better position than them!!
"All power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely."
― Lord Acton
he was wrong. power doesnt cause corruption, it merely reveals the corruption that was already there.
sabin97 ??
@@systeminvalid6906
which part did you not understand? copy-paste it and i will try to rephrase it.
sabin97 Or Reveal they're true Self.
No wonder you have 8 million subscribers, all of your videos are detailed and direct to the point. ❤️ More subscribers coming.
In 2020 religion should be clearly divided from the government.
Well, unless you can make everyone atheists or religionless (or something like that), that will be not impossible but extremely difficult.
Warren Lam that would be the dream. But you still can divide religion and government. You don’t force your beliefs into others via the power of your position. But here in Lebanon they firstly need to remove this structure
Religion will always be used as a vote bank.
@@warren5037 it would be impossible unless you have a genocide against 90% of the population
blackappleslo forcing everyone to be atheist is kinda cruel.
I would love to visit Lebanon in the near future and, as in other countries, I'll be careful to spend my currency directly helping locals - no international hotel chains - local B+B, family run restaurants etc, and most importantly making new friends.
The sects had divided the people through religion in the civil war, then united them in hatred in 2019.
Maybe a Revolution will unite the sects permanently under the banner of anti-corruption Lebanese nationalism.
Sorry, but there will never be a total separation of religion and government. Laws are rooted in religious morals. If you remove them, you fall. 100% theocracy is unhealthy, but 100% secularism is, too.
It saddens me that all these events would happen all at the same time, and of course the people of lebanon are the ones who will suffer. Much love from greece, we all hope this struggle will end.
@downsideup 0527, “All these events”? The explosion only happened once.
@@freddobbs8558 did you even watch the video? He meant the explosion, the pandemic, the political corruption, the hyperinflation, the economic collapse, etc. It's all happening over here AT THE SAME TIME and we can't catch a break.
@AJ C, oh! I get it now. Ha, ha, that IS funny! Sorry, I didn’t catch the implied humor the first time.
@@freddobbs8558 buddy sit down youre not lebanese not only the explosion happened weve been having problems ever since october 27 2019
There was already a cake of chaos in Lebanon, the explosion was just the cherry on top
Can’t believe this was two years ago. Time flies so fast now.
Religion and politics are potent mixture. It will 🔥 everything in it's path.
*cough* US China trade war
No.
Sorry, but there will never be a total separation of religion and government. Laws are rooted in religious morals. If you remove them, you fall. 100% theocracy is unhealthy, but 100% secularism is, too.
This might be my country’s 🇳🇬 fate if things don’t change
What’s your country
Grape I think it’s Nigeria
Yep Nigeria
@@RAWWESTMEDIA why is it because of boko haram?
@@אשאיש , not just that, they elected a high sch drop out to be president, the northern side of the country is in shambles and devoid of education, they keep cheating states in the country responsible for their revenue, most of the citizens worship their reglious leaders, forgetting they are flawed human .
Oh, and they finally decided to protest, the government responded by sending thugs, to beat them or blowing their brains out.
Im from lebanon and i currently live in lebanon and the information that this video gives is a 100 percent true and i agree with all the statements said in this video , sadly our country is falling apart and it cant be fixed
Thank you Vox for this wonderful reporting of my country’s problems.
Glad you raise this issue. One of the very clear explanation so far.
Kids in the future will have to suffer learning everything bad that happened this year..
thank you for educating people about what’s happening here(and why it happened). love from leb ❤️
There's a saying that says: Religion and Goverment should stay away from each other.
More than a saying, it's an actual fact.
It really is for the best for both religion and government.
Politics is a force of violence. It’s why we give the government a monopoly on violence. So when religion and government combine, the violence of the politics bleeds into religions leading to things like the Thirty Years' War.
Just as Hitchens said, "Religion poisons everything."
Absolutely.
yep
Being naive doesnt really help, we humans love to blame things on everything but ourselves
Disagree.
Tf is that statement?
There will never be a total separation of religion and government. Laws are rooted in religious morals. If you remove them, you fall. 100% theocracy is unhealthy, but 100% secularism is, too.
This is not enlightened thinking you are saying. This is just anti-religious bigotry typically findable in the western world.
This sounds exactly the same as my country Bosnia and Herzegovina especially the war and the political system.
No wonder Bosnia is a parliamentary democracy just like lebanon
Keep safe everyone!! My prayers..
Thank you God bless
Almost makes you realize how lucky we are to be apart of less corrupt countries
😂me reading your comment in Lebanon
If this video is true then i pray the citizens is able to change the gov system. That system is so wrong
I am from Syria, and because of our lake of free press and having only government media available to us, we basically grew up following Lebanese press and political drama and i can confirm this mini documentary is legit and although only scratches the surface it describes the situation well
@@mohamadalrashed9064 It doesn't mention Hezbollah but other than that I agree with you
Marc Selwan what’s hezbollah?
@@wowlizzy4039 Its a terrorist militia made by Iran which holds seats in the Lebanese parliament and cabinet