Why the Cooler Master Framework Case Could Change Everything!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 июл 2024
- In-depth review and testing of the @FrameworkComputer Mainboard Case by @coolermasteronline Could this be the most important item on the Framework marketplace? or are its shortcomings too much to overcome?
My Framework Playlist: • Framework Laptop
Framework Marketplace - frame.work/marketplace
Timecodes:
0:00 - Intro / Agenda
1:27 - Case Specs & Features
2:50 - Assembly Process
4:46 - Operating Without Battery
5:52 - Testing the Rig
9:14 - It Whistles! :o
10:57 - A Better Solution?
12:19 - The Pros
12:37 - The Cons Recapped.
13:00 - The Significance!
Find me on Social Media
Patreon: / elevatedsystems
Twitter: / elevatedsystem1
Facebook: / elevatedsyst. .
Instagram: /
Contact Me: elevated.sys@gmail.com
My Studio Equipment (Paid Links)
Blackmagic Pocket Cinema 6K Pro - amzn.to/3tA6ScP
Panasonic Lumix DMC-G7 - amzn.to/2VjqKSR
Panasonic Lumix DMC FZ300 - amzn.to/2WJnxw6
Sigma 18-35mm F1.8 Art DC HSM Lens - amzn.to/3quDgM0
Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 STM Lens -amzn.to/3uv13Of
Panasonic LUMIX G Lens, 25mm, F1.7 - amzn.to/3A9f9Vi
Magnus REX VT-5000 2-Stage Tripod - amzn.to/3GxsGJH
Neewer 72.4-Inch Camera Tripod - amzn.to/3fsRuqU
Kshioe Softbox Lighting Kit - amzn.to/3A5vZEq
Neewer Camera Slider Motorized - amzn.to/3ltX54e
Sennheiser MKE 600 Shotgun Mic - amzn.to/3fziRPv
SAMSON Q2U Dynamic Microphone - amzn.to/3ikExBe
Sennheiser XS Wireless Lavalier System - amzn.to/3ilSIpA
PreSonus Eris E3.5 Studio Monitor - amzn.to/3CcVx4d
Behringer U-Phoria UM2 USB DAC - amzn.to/3ZmyOOO
Gator Frameworks Deluxe Boom Stand - amzn.to/3fs7Os3
Glide Gear TMP100 Teleprompter - amzn.to/3CdgIDy
GLEAM Microphone Stand - amzn.to/3A4dth5
Davinci Resolve 17 & Speed Editor - amzn.to/3fsECRG
AVerMedia Live Gamer ULTRA - amzn.to/3CCH5nV
Apple 2022 Mac Studio - amzn.to/3GXW6mS
LG 40WP95C-W 40” 5K2K Display - amzn.to/3ZtiiN6
INNOCN 15.6" OLED Portable Monitor. - amzn.to/3jEOqgu
BenQ ScreenBar Halo - amzn.to/3XpUZ52
Audio file(s) provided by Epidemic Sound
www.epidemicsound.com 
Наука
It appears the video has big audio sync issues on the TV app. Sorry, not sure what the problem is but the video is working fine on mobile and desktop.
Sorry to the first 2k viewers for the double intro. It's fixed now.
Cooler Master is not a niche seller, the fact that they have done this means so much for the prosperity of framework! I hope they get more confident are more open to things in general, they already are very open, but there are still some stiffness in some things, but i'm pretty sure that with time and experience that will be solved.
Agreed, I was thinking the same. Framework is building a really cool ecosystem, and it's great to see a really big maker jump on board. What I'm looking forward to is seeing people build cyberdecks with the mainboard. It's unfortunate the more common 3D printing materials have some issues with shrink and heat, but the creativity in that scene is amazing so I'm sure they'll get it figured out.
I bought my wife a Framework because she kept dropping her laptop (so I can now replace parts she breaks lol) and I love that there is something to do with the parts down the road. I have a good laptop and want to upgrade to the 16" when I can but then I have the issue of what to do with the old laptop. I hope Framework stays around for a long, long time
she kept dropping her laptop?
@@moonman2051 She places it halfway on tables and desks so it's hanging and then they tend to fall (especially since we have 4 cats)
kinda seems like you should have bought a rugged laptop like a panasonic toughbook or something.
@@majinshinsauh I have 5 cats I know the feeling lol
then she should have a desktop.........and lucky to have it.
I hope Framework sets up a new standard for laptops and the MoBos and their laptop become standard for most if not all laptops. Would love to see a Frework-cimpatible HP Elitebook, a Razer Blade with better cooling, a watercooled monstrosity by Alienware and maybe even a Framework Tablet produced in cooperation with MS.
YES YES YES
Lmao no these companies want to enforce their proprietary standards.
Frankenwork... :P
That tablet idea has my attention.
Honestly, the stock 13" model is fairly well cooled out of the box. Unless Intel or AMD allows mobile overclocking, or allowing an increased power limit, there's not much of a benefit for improved cooling.
This is great news. If CoolerMaster made an enclosure close to the one you did - with the place for 3D card, I would be obtaining it about now.
Id love to see ability to attach a battery to the case which would make this the perfect little home assistant/mini server with protection from blackouts.
You could fit get a battery bank with passthrough and just use that as the USB power brick.
This is really exciting. One of the reasons I was so keen on framework was the ability to repurose old main boards as servers. With the Ryzen and off the shelf case announcements, it was finally time.
BTW, your content has just been getting better and better over time. I'm excited to see what's next for the channel!
I remember 'DIY perks' was one of the first persons to repurpose a framework motherboard in a big project months back.
I just like this as a concept. Many of us have been "upcycling" for years. It's good to have a formal solution. I hope they do more of it. It horrifies me the ammout of tech junk I own that could have been upcycled but the manufacturer thought it best to screw the consumer.......Top of that list the Remix Mini
I love it. I don't need anything Framework sells yet, but I desperately want them to succeed so they are still around when I'm back on the market.
I'm in the same situation... I really want to buy the 16 just because it's awesome but I really really don't *need* it for probably at least 4-5 more years. I would love to have a reasonable excuse to buy right now though 🤞🏻
Standardised laptop motherboard formats would be really amazing, could you imagine? Like the way we have ATX, mATX and ITX in desktops
Wow the most anticipated review ever since I heard about Framework Laptop, thank you very much, this is a very good direction in my opinion, Kudos to Framework and CoolerMaster, a great secondary computer tucked behind a TV/Monitor while at the same time upgrading to a newer mainboard, what would be great to know is the overhead costs for a full working secondary system setup, say if a person upgrades from the 11th gen to 13th gen mainboard and uses the 11th gen mainboard as a secondary computer what's the total cost one could incur?
The whistling can be due to the evenly sized vents on the surface. Taping few shut at some intervals mights make things better, so will breaking few vent spacers at intervals.
I've always been a fan of cooler master, great to see them working together with framework
Thanks for the rundown on this Cooler Master case. For Framework to already have a partnership like this in a short time since they've existed means they're on the right track.
If framework survives long enough, I wonder if purchases for their bare boards will increase for hobbyists. It seems like the same crowd interested in raspberry pi, Latepanda, and maybe the erying boards would ALSO be interested in retrofitting a framework PCB for other tasks.
That would be amazing!
I envision a future where we ditch Anti-Consumer companies and just give all our money to framework as far as laptops go.
@@jeremydale4548 I think one of the problems with laptops is that by the time the user finds the specs obsolete, the rest of the laptop is usually falling apart anyway.. so it's one of the situations where it 'makes sense' to just replace the whole thing every few years. Also, because everyone just defaults to the Thickness War as the only priority, cooling is always a problem. So we get laptops that cook themselves to death.
I would like to have a 'chunkier' heavy duty laptop chassis.. something capable of supporting 40-50mm exhaust fans on the back.. maybe it could be marketed today as more of a 'portable desktop' than a 'laptop'. I used to imagine mini ITX could somehow find its way in to a situation like that, but that never materialized.
For the record, I'm almost 40 and have still never owned a laptop.
I have a preorder for the amd mainboard to run in this case as a server, replacing a raspberry pi cluster. The amd boards support av1 hardware accelerated encoding and decoding so are perfect for home servers.
Yeah it would be cool if someone made a case with a custom integrated cooling solution to replace the fan entirely. I'd go insane with the whistling sound. Good video 👍
Very cool to see it in action, the whistling noise seems a bit annoying though! I released a video on the upcoming 16" model today and just saw this vid you released at the same time haha. Hope you don't mind but I showed off one of your builds in my vid, credited you of course and linked your channel too :)
Love your review. The possible answer to your question as to when companies will produce modular components is when there is a need or a requirement to do so. If more companies ran with an Open Chassis design with standard sized modules like the raspberry pi, than other companies will tackle that mold is quest for profit.
This is a sick case. Gonna keep this case in mind when my mainboard gets replaced. Such a good use of an old mainboard
100% agree with your conclusion, this may not be a perfect product but I hope this incites competition in this sector. What a great little idea.
I've been waiting for a case like this for a very long time as I wondered if I can finally help my old AIO computer
This looks amazing!
I will buy a framework for this!
I like the ecosystem you were describing here. Imagine, you need a new laptop screen and Framework have multiple, one by LG. one by Samsung, etc. Same for if you need a new keyboard. I think the possibilities are endless.
I agree, lets hope that this is a first step to a much larger ecosystem.
This is really great news. Adoption from such big manufacturers is both very important, and a good sign of the future for Framework. One thing I would like to see though, is a mod which lets you mount a bigger cooler, with, say, a Noctua fan. If we put this board into a 'desktop' case, the whole "thin and light" thing can be negotiated a little more readily, allowing for more flexibility. There should be no reason to have to put up with such a noisy design.
I think this concept is super cool, I've been dreaming of building slim desktops with old laptop hardware since I was like 15.
The only problem I have with this is the look, if it had a cleaner, more premium look I could totally see this being a perfect home theatre pc.
Nice video as always. Maybe the board would benefit from a slim 90mm fan? Does an existing 3d print case come with that idea?
Would love to see a 1RU rack mount case for these mother boards
I like where the framework going hopefully this becomes a standard and be used by any brand. Looking forward for the main board enclosure + an egpu option from you or framework.
4:48 also to keep in mind, a lot of them have their mounting recessed. I have 3 such displays right in front of me, though they are all 75x75.
Have to say I switched to the Honeywell Phase change pads for my Framework and Dell laptops and got a 10 degree drop on the Dell and a 14 degree drop on the Framework.
I love the concept of that GPU enclosure case. I'm also wondering about the possibility of something similar but for 3.5" HDDs instead of a GPU. Could an old Framework mainboard be the heart of a NAS?
That project is on my list.
Can't wait framework going into arm, a setup like that would be perfect
I love the transparent case, and I want this to be the future of laptops
so, can you mount just the case to a desk arm? most monitors are either stand/arm or vesa, as youve said, so mounting this thing to a separate arm would be an option. but is it? i think it would look cool on an arm next to the monitor(s). btw, how are thermals when mounted to a monitor? is there any gap between the two for at least some airflow?
Beside ABS & PLA there is also PETG. Also motherboards can be screwed into wood pretty reliably. But yes, for a desktop solution, even nettop style one it needs to have a beefier cooler. So bigger cpu cooler or case with one would've been great.
You can't use PLA/PETG for this unless you SIGNIFICANTLY increase the size of the case to keep the heat away from the printed parts. Keep in mind, PLA isn't suitable for any heat at all and PETG shouldn't be taken above around 40 C. In this case, the CPU is producing more heat than PETG can handle(and it's only using 30W), while the rest of the system is producing even more due to power losses going straight to heat.
But it's partially moot because this is a mass market case. Injection molding > 3d printing if producing at Cooler Master scale and that means ABS/PC. They're an OEM, the production run numbers are WAY past what 3d printing can do.
@@Grimmwoldds I was under an impression that it's a only PLA that should be heated above 40°с, and for PETG it should be around 80°с. Still worse than abs, obviously. But even 80°с... Can it really be achieved anywhere inside the case outside from a heatsink with a direct contact with a cpu? And even then 80°с temperature on a cpu doesn't mean 80°с temperature of an exhaust. And high inside case temperature can't be achieved without a massive heating element, like in close chamber 3d printers with a massive heatbed and deliberatly little to no ventilation.
I wasn't able to find a source, but I seems to rmeember seeing some research about actual exhaust temp of hardware and it not even close to actual temperature on a die.
@@trashviewer3521 It's not a very large nor high flow cooling solution. You'd have to check it, but I'd guess that it's the exhaust temp is high enough to soften PLA/PETG. The temps given for heat deflection are how much to soften it to bend a certain amount in a short time. When used in a computer case, you don't EVER want to use PLA or PETG. If you subject them to even 40C for a few days they will warp and sag(you're usually putting load onto them). Exhaust from cooling fins, being near an SSD, or even proximity to the power stages...
Have the Coolermaster case with the 11th gen i7 Framework board and it works great. Not having the fan sound problems.
Regarding the power supply, I'm using the standard power brick that comes with the laptop and also not having any issues. Did you disable the battery in the bios? That is recommended by Framework.
That CJ64 always makes me smile, the good old C64 days of doing stuff just because you can :')
If I wasn't hip deep in computer stuff that case and board would be really tempting to play around with. It would be fun to mount it to the back of my LG ultrawide monitor and see how it performs.
the fan is the biggest issue, there needs to be a replacement cooling system that can fit a bigger much more pleasant fan
Does anyone know the weight of the case? Or final weight of the PC when assembled? Really curious to see which is lighter, the 3d printed case or the cooler master one
I wouldn't overthink the CoolerMaster significance just yet: they're already in the custom accessory business, so for them a project like this, in terms of profile, isn't even lateral, not to mention how cheap it is to manufacture - they make Raspberry Pi cases too!
With someone like MSI or LG, you're asking a company to compete against their own products.
The high pitch noise when in the CoolerMaster enclosure is caused by the shape of the fan openings.
I’d remove every second or third strip or even remove the hole lot and place a metal mesh instead of I had this issue.
been watching this company for awhile and Ive got to say im excited, have a 16 in the cart right not. The ironic thing is all the choices, i think bare min and add as needed,,,great choices!
How is the noise profile at lower wattage, e.g. 15 W?
looks amazing
10" or 11", 1080p screen (I forgot which), would be great for turning it into a handheld PC.
What are all the parts needed to make this thing work on a TV media setup?
Can I buy the mainboard(with kit) and the case? Was planning to build one for work, my current gaming PC consumes a lot of power for the task that I am doing lol.
Good video, but yet again I am concerend about the volume of the Framework as I really want to get away from a loud laptop, lets hopy the AMD version and 16 inch version suffer less from this issue.
Would it be possible to have the M.2 port of the framework exposed? If so, having a case that could fit a GPU that would connect with occulink and thunderbolt would be sick.
I wish there was something like this that was universally compatible to any laptop board. I still have a couple of Sandy/Ivy Bridge laptops with some minor physical problems but still fully functional that are lying around just gathering dust and it'd be great if I could repurpose them by turning them into mini PC's. I've seen some DIY stuff online dealing with that kind of stuff but they're always far too complicated, expensive, and require specific tools and other bits to make them.
There will likely never be a universal version of this due to the extreme differences in various laptop boards. Diy doesn't have to be complicated but yes, if you want to make something you will need at least some tools.
I'm eagerly waiting for The update FW16, that's gonna be a game changer.
So if I understood correctly, you get a little less performance without the battery attached (and then there's the problem of not being able to update the firmware without it). If that's the case and Framework doesn't fix that with software, I guess it would be useful to get an adapter that connects to the battery connector and to another PSU (or Maybe the same?) Right? I guess that's possible and would fix those issues, but idk if it's worthy.
is it possible to use a desktop cooler to cool it in an external case?
hmm...is there like a keyboard case combo? portable nuc with build in keyboard and put one of those mouse nip in the middle. i think that would be quite useful
I'm rooting for Framework!
I think framework should make case option to get into desktop space. Even option for 16 inch with upgradable gpu.
Note that it doesn't seem fit their amd boards. Two out of three users trying it on the forums had issues. The one in which it did work I'm not sure was even using the coolermaster case, they may have been using some other case in standalone mode.
If the torx fit isn't 100%, use a thin piece of rubber band between the head and the bit. Push down and turn slowly :)
I can't wait for a handheld gaming case for framework mobos
I love the idea that framework laptops could be like GPUs where different companies make enclosures for them. I'd be on board with that
it would mean the hardware could be severely undervolted and clocked to work in a slim enclosure but overclocked in a beefy gaming enclosure
I’d be curious if annealing the 3d print would prevent shrinking 🤔
I bought one CM Stacker 730 Case in 2006 - Still rocking my i9-13900K with a 4080 in it, cooled with a 360 AIO. At that time, CM built for the Eternity. Today not so much anymore... That whine would kill me in the Framework. But at least CM is still trying...
is it possible to make a Framwork-base gaming handheld device ?
Man, you should totally try and get an nvme to oculink adapter and pair it with the upcoming gdp g1 egpu.
The noise is what I did not like. I'll check if the whine is there too. I also forgot the audio board. If I want one now I also have to pay another €30 shipping.... I have a 11th gen in. I upgraded to the 13th gen. my wifi board clip was in the rubber stand bag.
Thanks for the case hype but still addressing the short comings of the case. Very excited for this.
Has high-frequency hearing loss due to the previous job 😢 damn.
I choose to believe that his previous job was lead guitarist in a thrash metal band.
Framework could be the new wave of trends across tech that bring the power dynamic back into the hands of consumers/end users. Anything that is antithetical to the current bullsht system we have now is a good idea
This is neat but I thought it was a GPU case or cooler. I'm in need of replacement fans for my used 1070 but I can't find the exact ones PNY used, an aftermarket cooler would also solve the problem.
For me the case makes the old boards easy to resell, which increase the price to performance for frameworks significantly.
I'd be interested in a framework dockable tablet that plugged into an external GPU/Keyboard/UPSPSU module with USB.
You could use a 3d printed part to basically bum your vesa mount and have the framework attach below
Add a couple nuts into the mix and you can still mount it on a vesa mounting plate. Putting this on a secondary vesa arm sounds like a power move.
Why plastic? Is there an aluminium/magnesium case? And it looks like it could be at least 10-20mm less high.
The high frequency whistle is disappointing with the cooler master case. I wonder if there are some modifications that can be done to stop it. I think it's still the cleanest case to get to re-home the framework board
I'm pretty sure that roughening the opening of that thing can solve it.
waiting for pre-orders to open for the 16 inch laptop.
You can't update the bios without a battery?? What that's not good. I've seen issue on laptops such as VPN not connecting due to bios update needed. Like to see if Framework fixes this. I bet theres a command line switch that will override battery requirement for bios upgrade
*I'm much more interested in the Minisforum UM790 PRO. An insanely powerful low watt APU with the graphical power of a GTX 1660. For $699 with 32GB DDR5 and 1TB SSD, it can't be beat. It's an all-in-one that fits in your hand.*
can we get a tablet case too?
Do they have one for Framework16?
I thought that they made some kind of rugged/durable case for it, given that Cooler Master has the HAF series, but this is just two pieces of plastic
Framework and Valve would be interesting.
will 17.3 notebook motherboards fit in the Framework case?
No, this is designed specifically for the Framework mainboard.
It's got quirks but I'm happy with it!
Would be interesting to see pure aluminium case to throw some thermal pads drawing heat to aluminium itself.
Sounds like FW should collaborate with someone, to make VESA adapters for 50mm to 75mm, and for mounting arms and stands, with the FW case attached.
Great video. I've never bought a laptop of my own (I'm 25 already, last one was my brother's hand-me-down from '11 or so). I'm seriously considering a Framework. I plan on mainly using it for music production & editing (Heavy Metal) and possibly video editing. Was wondering if this would fit that bill, thanks in advanced yo \,,/
If you're not in a hurry, wait till I review the ryzen version and I should be able to answer that better.
the GPU enclosure idea is a good one, maybe they will add USB4 to their boards and make USB4 to PCI-e cables and reach out to you for the design for another Framework+ product.
The Intel boards have 4 Thunderbolt 4 ports, and the Ryzen board has 2 USB4 ports.
Great coverage of this product, but it was marred by the audio being so out of sync with your mouth movements.
UPDATE: The audio sync is perfect when restarting the video a day later. I don't know why it was not yesterday on the same device.
Audio sync is perfect. Might be something on your end.
I had the same issue. I usually need to turn off the tv, switch apps and then switch back to RUclips
And audio sync issue. Reboot chromecast didn't fix it
@@ShadowAssault It looks like the sync issue is just on the RUclips TV app for some reason.
The audio is perfect now on my Android tablet, the same device I used yesterday. I did not have sync issues with other videos yesterday, but now this one if fine too. Weird.
Their launch event looked like open mic night at my local pub 😂
It was pretty cringe. I think they hired a media person since then.
Very cool.
So it's aiming to do what ATX standard has successfully done for years, while being totally incompatible with it and having a soldered CPU? I can't imagine why it would flop miserably.
I'm waiting for a case for 16 inch
No graphics card yet!?
That's my dream coming true.
Funny how the old laptops used to be modular and easy to upgrade. Glad Frameworks revived the idea.
I feel like you have a misunderstanding of what shrinkage in plastic does. The shrinking and expansion only occurs when being cooled or heated respectively. Your ABS case did NOT shrink after a years time. It shrinks as slowly as or as fast as you cool it. As long as you are not impatient and toss your motherboard into the 3d printed case while it is still hot off of the build plate there will be no issues. When your ABS or other thermoplastic parts are done you should cool it to room temperature before doing anything with them for any use.
No I completely understand how thermoplastic polymer chains work, and how they continue to tighten or loosen over time based on many factors. Initial cooling rate, and temperature only bieng two of the factors. In this case it is very likely due to the below average annual humidity rate and lower air density which dosent allow for the ideal proportion of solvent molecules to evenly distribute the chains. In simple terms, the plastic is drying out.
@@ElevatedSystems What you said demonstrates you do not “completely understand”. Even if we were to humour your false assumption the shrinkage and expansion resulting from it assuming isothermal conditions would not cause any motherboard to crack as you boldly claim. Additionally, any shrinkage or expansion that occur after the initial cooling is more likely due to, as you said humidity and temperature fluctuation, which would not cause any damage to a motherboard unless you have tension on the board to begin with. In simple terms, unless you are bending your board and inserting to a undersized case, what you say is not possible.
@@XxBanziixX1 I didn't say the board will crack. However in the past year the ABS printed case DID in fact shrink by over a millimeter across the X axis. That could definetly cause damage to one or more of the board mounted UBC-C ports. They are pretty fragile and the soldier points are easily cracked. Speaking from experience. If the board bowed or twisted due to the shrinking case that could easily lead to movement of the heatsink, which is secured with leaf spring tension, causing improper cooling of the CPU or VRM. Also speaking from experience. I've been tinkering with this mainboard for 2 years, I'm very familiar with it's extremely tight tolerances.
Fyi I managed to update a 1240p based mainboard bios outside of the case with no battery.
Also on a side note, our case exhibits no whistle with said board. We are at very close to sea level for what it's worth