Why Tamil Cinema is FAILING Pan India Test?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 окт 2024

Комментарии • 119

  • @ajithr13
    @ajithr13 День назад +25

    tamil cinema has a lot of talent. ..It may not be pan india now..but we will come big

    • @danevij
      @danevij 20 часов назад +1

      TAMIL Cinema has Lot of Actors, in which the Top 10 are called as Stars and the rest have the potential break into the Top 10 anytime soon :
      1) Rajinikanth,
      2) Kamalhassan,
      3) Vijay,
      4) Ajith,
      5)Vikram,
      6) Suriya,
      7) Dhanush,
      8) Silambarasan,
      9) Vijay Sethupathy,
      10) Sivakarthikeyan,
      11) Karthi,
      12) Jayam Ravi,
      13) Vishal,
      14) Arya,
      15) Madhavan,
      16) Arun Vijay,
      17) Jeeva,
      18) Vishnu Vishal,
      19) Atharva,
      20) Ashok Selvan,
      21) Harish Kalyan,
      22) Pradeep Ranganathan,
      23) Kavin,
      24) Manikandan,
      25) Dhruv Vikram, etc...
      The Biggest problem with TAMIL Cinema is nothing but, the Fans. Inorder to protect one, they keep on degrading the other with negativity. Only the Unity among Fans can bring back the lost glory of TAMIL Cinema ❤❤❤

  • @vigneshwarankannan4999
    @vigneshwarankannan4999 День назад +43

    I am really happy that Pan India is not working in Tamil. So more content oriented movies would come out in Tamil. I am tired of this loud, noisey, slow motion pan india masala movies. Pan India movies may benefit only the producers but not the audience. The problem is that the actor or director try to make every movie a pan indian if one movie worked as pan indian.

    • @rajeshantony74
      @rajeshantony74 День назад +1

      True

    • @Gunvoak
      @Gunvoak День назад +1

      We have to have a mixture of everything

    • @AdiBushan-z9b
      @AdiBushan-z9b День назад +4

      Well there are good mass masala movies and bad mass masala movies. You might not like it but if majority cater to it then it must be respected. There are mass masala movies with good content with mixture of entertainment, songs and other genre. This is just an elitist mindset influenced by Western movies and imposing standards on Indian industries that follows different standards.
      I hope Atlee Kumar, SS Rajamouli, Lokesh Kanagaraj, Prasanth Neel, Prasanth Varma preserve mass masala culture that is rooted in cultures around India.

    • @exp-rg3lg
      @exp-rg3lg День назад +1

      But that's just the start eventually we'll see all kinds of pan India films. We that there won't be multiple industries anymore just one industry

    • @dopamine_mein_doobaa
      @dopamine_mein_doobaa День назад +1

      Kantara was pan India and it was not a typical masala.

  • @sachinthomas7042
    @sachinthomas7042 День назад +12

    Pan india movies and bollywood high budget a have diluted true cinema. This movies have created a general sense that movies should be high budget action pack films for audience to watch in theatres. This is why true craft like meiyazhagan and vaazhai didn’t do well in theatres. There should be a place for all kinds of movies for cinema to grow.

  • @newgen1002
    @newgen1002 День назад +8

    The BO comeback of Suriya is crucial for tamil cinema...he was the biggest star next to Rajni in the late 2000s and early 2010s after which there was a slump....its time to time he succeeds becuz he is a differnet kind of "STAR"

  • @dinesh8575
    @dinesh8575 День назад +13

    Because when they make Pan Indian movies they miss their own strength so even their own audience not liking it

  • @shojinrc8
    @shojinrc8 23 часа назад +12

    They are not interested in pan indian movies. They prioritize their audience first even though they have all the resources to do huge films. For me, the Tamil film industry is the best film industry in our country.

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 13 часов назад

      not interested really?? Haha then act like it. why do u dub your films in multiple lang? & Tamil fans claims before any big Tamil release that there films will surpass "Baahubali" blah blah N0N sense hahaha. If you don’t intend to make pan Indian films, then why r Tamil actors promoting them in the North?

  • @danevij
    @danevij 20 часов назад +4

    TAMIL Cinema has Lot of Actors, in which the Top 10 are called as Stars and the rest have the potential break into the Top 10 anytime soon :
    1) Rajinikanth,
    2) Kamalhassan,
    3) Vijay,
    4) Ajith,
    5)Vikram,
    6) Suriya,
    7) Dhanush,
    8) Silambarasan,
    9) Vijay Sethupathy,
    10) Sivakarthikeyan,
    11) Karthi,
    12) Jayam Ravi,
    13) Vishal,
    14) Arya,
    15) Madhavan,
    16) Arun Vijay,
    17) Jeeva,
    18) Vishnu Vishal,
    19) Atharva,
    20) Ashok Selvan,
    21) Harish Kalyan,
    22) Pradeep Ranganathan,
    23) Kavin,
    24) Manikandan,
    25) Dhruv Vikram, etc...
    The Biggest problem with TAMIL Cinema is nothing but, the Fans. Inorder to protect one, they keep on degrading the other with negativity. Only the Unity among Fans can bring back the lost glory of TAMIL Cinema ❤❤❤

  • @sivasailamark
    @sivasailamark День назад +4

    Huge Star salary is eating in to budget of the Tamil movies, hence producers are forced go on a limited budget compromises on quality of the movie. So big budget movies are not good but small budget are superb...

  • @vamsiavi
    @vamsiavi День назад +7

    one reason is they want to spread their ideology ...which won't fit into cinema...and kills cinematic experience....

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад +2

      What ideology is present in lcu bro

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      And cinema is for entertainment political movies are present in every industry audience only go for entertainment not for ideology recent movies are examples

  • @nandhakumarnk8938
    @nandhakumarnk8938 День назад +4

    Correct me If I am wrong. Kannada "Kantara" worked all over India same as Hebrew/Aramaic "passion of christ" worked in US right?
    Currently there is a wave among the population that their religion is attacked and they need to support movies that portray their religion in a good way.

  • @AdiBushan-z9b
    @AdiBushan-z9b День назад +6

    PS 1 and PS 2 were disliked by many Tamil audience as well. I feel the screenplay and narration were slow.
    Also many Tamil audience although not all don't want to go pan india for some reason because they want movies based on their culture and roots which is understandable but should push pan-india as there are many fans in the north who will atleast watch the tamil movies.

    • @ananddeena7642
      @ananddeena7642 22 часа назад

      PS1 was liked by most of the audience and did well in Good in theatre. I was working as a JR in a hospital in Dindigul and saw PS1 more than twice within. The theatre was packed till the end of the month I saw few repeat audiences. But PS2 was a complete disappointment not true to the novel not history. Death of Adhitya Karikaalan was dramatic n good but that wasn't the one in the book. A lot of wasted characters.

  • @mirugamx
    @mirugamx День назад +2

    So glad you touched on this. 🙏🏾
    And well said ❤️

  • @juliegoldman6778
    @juliegoldman6778 6 часов назад

    Luckily they don't get cancelled in the US if there are not enough sales. Maharaja and Meiyazhagan two of the best Indian films of the year !

  • @zangetsu_cr7737
    @zangetsu_cr7737 4 часа назад

    You missed out on Amaran, though they may have failed to promote it outside Telugu-Tamil-Malayalam...it can strike and pave a way for SK in North belt with this one through word of mouth

  • @anjaannenjans8531
    @anjaannenjans8531 20 часов назад +2

    Maharaja become a pan ott success in netflix

  • @wazirziad
    @wazirziad День назад +2

    As a long time Nona Prince follower, this is one of the worst analyses yet. You don’t need Pan Indian Releases in Malayalam or Tamil cinema because of the good content coming out and it will eventually reach even if it isn’t promoted widely. They don’t depend need star value at all. Content is the king

  • @iamnotfinished
    @iamnotfinished День назад +1

    Tbh Tamil cinema should stop trying to compete with Telugu and Hindi films. They've got their own unique vibe, just like Malayalam movies. Malayalam is crushing it because they stay true to themselves and don't compromise on originality. Tamil can do the same...

  • @srivishwas5378
    @srivishwas5378 День назад +4

    The trend of producing masala commercial films in the industry may not be beneficial for the future, but it remains popular right now. In contrast, Tamil cinema is increasingly embracing art form films, which is promising for the industry’s future. Many directors are coming forward with strong scripts that focus on artistic expression, contributing to a healthier environment for Tamil cinema.

    • @AdiBushan-z9b
      @AdiBushan-z9b День назад +3

      I disagree. Jawan, RRR, KGF 1 and 2, Maaveeran, Hanu Man, Master are all commercial masala movies and also have artistic expression but do really well. I believe there are good masala movies and bad masala movies and you cannot stereotype them as all being bad. Elitism isn't the solution.

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 12 часов назад

      Don't act like 100% film's made in industry r masala commercial film's it's just made in small amount with large production value. There are still numerous classic films created across every industry.

  • @tyagarajakinkara
    @tyagarajakinkara День назад +3

    Yes the new generation stars of Telugu cinema are ready for big leap, kiran abbavaram, naveen polishetty, and others.

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад +1

      Kiran is star😂 kuch bhi

    • @newgen1002
      @newgen1002 День назад +1

      Molugu uncle is the biggest star in Telugu cinema

    • @Sweetxy-wc4ei
      @Sweetxy-wc4ei День назад +2

      @@dheeraj009.1 kyu problem kya hai? hr ek tamil actror ko troll kiya gaya tha for many yrs they eventually improve themselves it's not big deal.

    • @ahmedzeeshan3727
      @ahmedzeeshan3727 18 часов назад

      And Balayya 😂😂

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 12 часов назад

      ​@@ahmedzeeshan3727haha he's talking about new generation actor's.

  • @darkguardian787
    @darkguardian787 День назад +3

    Coolie will be an answer to this video💥

  • @bkit5
    @bkit5 20 часов назад

    A Tamil movie producer explained it. It is because of Tamil producers unwilling to delay OTT release for 2 months, which is a standard practice for all Theater chains in North India. If the producers release in 1 month’s time, they get more money from OTT. That’s the problem, producers want to pull more money from OTT to offset potential losses.

  • @GomathOffice
    @GomathOffice 11 часов назад

    Tamil is undergoing best phase ever... As a tamilian we are very much happy about it.. small budget and new face technician movies are doing great... Once festival movies are now getting very good reception among mainstream audience...
    This is the time where Tamil cinema is completly out of stardom... Like Vijay is resining, rajini is retiring , Ajith retired , and all other leading actors need content & story for their sucess.....

  • @ahmedzeeshan3727
    @ahmedzeeshan3727 18 часов назад +1

    Except for KGF and Kanatara, Kannada films doesn't have any identity

  • @SunnySinsEntertainment
    @SunnySinsEntertainment День назад +5

    Lokesh kanagaraj laughing in corner 🗿

  • @praveen1620
    @praveen1620 21 час назад +1

    Boss you dont know anything about Tamil Cinema. Not all Pan India movies are good. Its just overhyped and over the board movies masala movies. Tamil cinema like Malayalam cinema is making great content movies that needs to be appreciated.

  • @krishniarumugam
    @krishniarumugam День назад

    Great topic. Agree on Tamil Cinema on lack of pan-India hit. Poor marketing, dubbing, subtitling etc are part of the issue. The annoyance for me is the budgets are actually quite high and could benefit from a wider release especially with actors like Vikram, and Vijay Thalapthy who have huge followings in the Hindi belt. This is a weird situation. Look at Hanuman as an average presentation they put alot of effort in dubbing and music. Tamil cinema its ok to keep it in our community....but at the risk of being left behind and made obsolete. There is no doubt interest....look at the interest in OTT release of Maharaja , Vikram, Master etc....all eyes on Kanguva
    But at the same time neither does Hindi Cinema have a pan-india hit. Stree 2, Gadar, Jawaan and Pathaan are not Pan-India Hits. The SRK ones are North Belt and Global hits. Stree 2/Gadar 2 are Hindi Cinema hits.
    I feel Telegu cinema has had that boldness - but at the same time from a State Cultural perspective...Telegu is in between cultures of Tamil and Hindi and ergo creates a perfect zone of interest. And they are making movies with that mindset.

  • @alwaysjai
    @alwaysjai 10 часов назад

    Tamil cinema have destroyed the Tamil people culturally and politically. As a Tamilian I feel good when the Tamil Movie industry lacks new big stars. It's good for the Tamil people actually.

  • @unnipaul8944
    @unnipaul8944 19 часов назад

    I have a different opinion. Many may disagree. Let's look all the Non bollywood Pan India hits. The directors are S S Rajamouli, Prasanth Neel, Nag ashwin. Look at all their initial works. They didn't go Pan India from the word go. These directors with their initial films with compartively smaller budgets did go Pan India at least through television and Internet. Say for eg: Eega, Magadeera, Ugram, KGF1, Mahanadi etc. All these films are not small budget films, but were not heavy budget films like Bahubali, KGF2 or Kalki. For me the key is the director or a real Super star. Not the budget. Let them prove their potential to go Pan India with smaller budgets. Lets come to Tamil films, with films like Bombay, Muthu with Rajini's international audiences, Muthalvan, Enthiran 2 etc Tamil films were the first from South India to go Pan India. (Malayalam did go Pan India with Chemmeen and My dear Kuttichathan. But other than these films I mentioned that was not a regular case.) But they had Directors like Maniratnam, Shankar at their peak, Superstar Rajinikanth. But when the new generation Pan India came those directors and Superstar have already passed their prime. With the younger directors and stars I see only a Vijay or a Lokesh Kanakaraj who have proven their potential to go Pan India with lower budgets. Stars like Ajith, Vikram etc have potential but they does only smaller number of films. There are many Tamil directors and stars who can go massive in South India. I am talking about the other areas. No point in commenting about bollywood Pan Indian films, because their market is much bigger.

  • @KeyboardAbhishek
    @KeyboardAbhishek 22 часа назад

    It’s interesting to me that this obsession with Pan-Indianess has also coincided with the wave of hypernationalism we’ve seen over the past decade. At the end of the day, Tamil cinema does not need the validation of North Indian audiences to succeed and grow - movies this year like Lover, Vaazhai, Lubber Pandhu and Meiyazhagan are all evidence enough.

  • @harsha1043
    @harsha1043 День назад +4

    just need promotions none of the top actors promote their films

  • @roshinvincent4223
    @roshinvincent4223 День назад

    Unique new and different , engaging.. These are pan indian mix.... But it is very difficult to make

  • @ishaanbhattacharya9405
    @ishaanbhattacharya9405 День назад +4

    Hey i would love for you to speak about bengali cinema

  • @abhimanyusalil2993
    @abhimanyusalil2993 День назад +2

    Well technically due to their not much good marketing strategy
    Same goes to Malayalam Cinema

    • @iamnotfinished
      @iamnotfinished День назад +1

      Dude, Malayalam films total budget is 30 times lower than a huge Tamil star's salary! Yet, Malayalam cinema still manages to get a decent Return on Investment (ROI) from their films, plus extra bucks from OTT, satellite, and music rights. Meanwhile, Tamil cinema is struggling to break even and boasting about the 'crore club is just laughable. Comparing Malayalam to Tamil is the real irony

    • @abhimanyusalil2993
      @abhimanyusalil2993 23 часа назад +1

      @@iamnotfinished well I am just saying both industries can't reach pan Indian level that's it not comparing the collection , budget stuff of both industries

    • @iamnotfinished
      @iamnotfinished 22 часа назад

      @@abhimanyusalil2993 Malayalam films don't need a pan-Indian release; they're thriving in their own league. Despite not opting for wider releases, they'll continue to excel in their current space.

  • @roshinvincent4223
    @roshinvincent4223 День назад +1

    Tamil cinema not discovering new everytime clesheeee.... Expect lokesh kanakaraj... Other heros are not selecting different content and unique story... Every time they are trying to recreat old films

  • @muralikrishna8051
    @muralikrishna8051 20 часов назад +1

    Kanguva 💥

  • @mightypicaxeanimations6058
    @mightypicaxeanimations6058 23 часа назад +2

    bruh you have zero knowledge how Tamizh cinema works...

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 12 часов назад

      Then why not try to explain it to him?!?

  • @theanunnakicollective
    @theanunnakicollective 20 часов назад +1

    Self claimed guru's 😂 zero knowledge as a cinema critic and doesnt know what is success. Just because the cinema makes 1000 crores that doesnt mean the movie is good. If u want a pan indian movie go watch hey ram. Before rajamouli kamal haasan had it in his finger tips. There is one thumb rule : the more local u go the more international you go. Idhellam unakku enga da puriya podhu

  • @madhurz557
    @madhurz557 День назад

    Tamil movies biggies are a disappointment, but medium budget and small budget films are real gems, most of the good contents small and medium budget films are not even promoted in TN and overseas Tamil markets. If the movie can created buzz with trailer, teaser are songs and the content lives upto the hype, no spl promotion needed for the film, but u promoted very well but it doesn't create any buzz among audience it won't work in Tamil mkts, even before Pan indian movies, Tamil actors never promoted thier films apart from audio launch, actors like suriya, Vikram, dhanush promoted thier films in Telugu states but never promoted here in TN. Kamal hassan, Karthi, Vijay sethupathy, jayam ravi only these actors promote thier films. Irrespective of being failure in pan India films, Tamil cinema is quite successful, Vikram, PS 1 &2, Leo, Jailer, Goat are doin phenomenal business in Tamil mkts..

  • @reald3d23
    @reald3d23 День назад +1

    Tamil cinema is in its own cocoon because of subpar filmmakers.

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 23 часа назад

      ​@@dheeraj009.1what's this??
      Why the heck r u dragging tollywood or Telugu in every conversation?? Replying to every single comment & dragging tollywood u r just a l0w life.

  • @DaarShnik
    @DaarShnik День назад +6

    I watched a movie called annapoorni last years for first 30 minutes and then I was like I don't want to see this kind of shit and my friends told me this is normal in tamil and malyalam movies... Because of this I and many people I know prefer Telegu Movies...
    That's the reason these movies have too much propaganda like a malyalam movie called minnal murli in the first 5 minutes of the movie you will see a brahmin suppressing a dalit and than romans come to save them... Funny part Romans came in 300 BC before there were any christianity and they never crossed Punjab. I have no problem with a christian Hero I was grown up reading Raj comics and Anthony was a good Hero too...
    But this kind of pure propaganda will not work now... Public is aware of this and thus Tamil and Telegu movies don't make too much money while Rajamauli and Telegu movies do... And this is the primary reason why Bollywood doesn't make money now either...

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      😂lol bro even tollywood is same left film makers have dominated it 😂and secondly what kind of film lover you are good films bad film propaganda films are present in every industry 😂you have to make a line between them and watch content cinema and religion are completely different cinema has no religion caste or language

    • @tyagarajakinkara
      @tyagarajakinkara День назад

      It's Telugu, not Telegu!

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      And 😂 secondly old Telugu movies are full about communism 😂

    • @vamsiavi
      @vamsiavi День назад +1

      true...

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад +1

      ​@@siddubk1tollywood remade omg movie and pink movie 😂lol every industry is same 😂if your movie lover you have to draw a Line between good and bad film's recently we have seen karthi movie which has no politics more about life and philosophy 😉 politics are everywhere and don't involve politics and cinema

  • @saleeluser7240
    @saleeluser7240 21 час назад +1

    Money first talent is second.

  • @markivwilson2891
    @markivwilson2891 День назад +6

    Stop making everything about pan India. It's tiring. Tamil cinema is the best film industry in India (fight me) exactly because of focusing on their craft instead of running behind fads.

    • @abhimanyusalil2993
      @abhimanyusalil2993 День назад +2

      Mollywood clears 🗿🗿🗿 ( and I am not talking about prime , consistency matters and considering the best scripts from both industries )

    • @AmitSingh-se2yf
      @AmitSingh-se2yf День назад +2

      Malyalam cinema is best in India. Tamil is 3rd after malayalam and telugu.

    • @abhimanyusalil2993
      @abhimanyusalil2993 День назад +5

      @@AmitSingh-se2yf 🤡😭😭
      Nah Tamil clears Telugu in terms of content

    • @Just_Another_yt_account
      @Just_Another_yt_account День назад +1

      @@AmitSingh-se2yfMalayalam ok but telugu?🤣🤣

    • @prashch5223
      @prashch5223 23 часа назад +2

      ​@@abhimanyusalil2993haha ur every other film is on castism or corporate system with bunch of cry babies.

  • @satisha5349
    @satisha5349 День назад +1

    Bro talk more about Kanguva

  • @vsansanv29101_sd
    @vsansanv29101_sd День назад

    Tamil films NO PAN INDIAN hit-PAN INDIA FAILURE
    BOLLYWOOD FILMS DONT HAVE BACK TO BACK PAN SOUTH INDIAN 500 CRORE CLUB BUT PAN INDIA HIT
    😆🤣🤣

  • @Anonymous-dw9bc
    @Anonymous-dw9bc День назад +2

    Kanguva coming 🔥🗿

  • @vvofficials3600
    @vvofficials3600 23 часа назад

    Atlee is a tamil director,Animal is telugu...its not Bollywood people made....

  • @vsansanv29101_sd
    @vsansanv29101_sd День назад +3

    Like the Tamil industry, Bollywood has also failed to achieve pan-Indian success. Films like Jawan, Dunki, and Tiger 3 did not manage to reach the 500-crore club in South India. Even Salman Khan himself questioned why his movies don’t work well in the southern market. This shows that Bollywood, much like Tamil cinema, has struggled to find widespread success across all regions in India

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      @@vsansanv29101_sd in tollywood also bahubali rrr salaar pushpa Hanuman kalki are proper hits what about remaining

    • @vsansanv29101_sd
      @vsansanv29101_sd День назад +1

      @@dheeraj009.1 The Telugu film industry boasts numerous pan-Indian hits example wich you mentioned, while Bollywood has struggled to make its mark in the ₹500 crore club in South India. even SALMANKHAN ADMITHED BOLLYWOOD FILMS NOT WORKING IN SOUTH

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      @@vsansanv29101_sd because Hindi audience with open arms have supported tollywood but tollywood still don't support other hero's the support is limited to social media even your average devara had good run in Hindi but our stree 2 is ignored that's the reason

    • @dheeraj009.1
      @dheeraj009.1 День назад

      @@vsansanv29101_sd even tollywood four families are still trying to control tollywood which will fail in coming years the tollywood will be free from four nepo families who control many theathres

    • @vsansanv29101_sd
      @vsansanv29101_sd День назад

      @@dheeraj009.1 even jawan was average is jawan oscar attempt film

  • @anojoy1
    @anojoy1 День назад +2

    Goat was one of the worst movies I've watched this year, it's better not to release a clown show in a pan indian level

  • @DanielReuben_14897
    @DanielReuben_14897 День назад +1

    kanguva is coming

    • @NonaPrince
      @NonaPrince  День назад +1

      Talked about it at the end

  • @rajwardhanpawar8819
    @rajwardhanpawar8819 День назад

    Bro plz react on yash's new interview.

  • @md.suhail8181
    @md.suhail8181 20 часов назад +1

    Indian 1996 was first pan indian movie

    • @sunnykarry
      @sunnykarry 19 часов назад +1

      It was Roja in 92. Ar rahman too went pan India right after Roja.

  • @Aaraaman
    @Aaraaman 12 часов назад +1

    Watch 1000 babies 👌👌