Please no, him and Bhanu should have a restraining order from the show. One of the few moments I've wanted to break my tv just listening to them, came close to giving up on Survivor all together.
That Kaleb comparison with Boston Rob is lowkey perfect. Charismatic dude who despite being on a losing tribe was the big star. A great challenge competitor gets hella lucky in the game that allows him to make it further in the game and is heavily remembered in his szn despite goin out so early.
They should have a surprise twist of a 19th survivor. Let it be Jelinsky and have the three tribes compete to see who gets him as the “severalth” member of their tribe.
I wish they would've chosen to do S48 an All-Stars only featuring people from the new era (a little nod to the fact S8 was the original all-stars) and then do S50 an All-Legends. I know it woulda been two all-star seasons almost back to back (i mean, they did s31 and s34 two returning player seasons), but i feel that, with season 48, we could put these new players to the test before labeling them legends. A lot of the survivor legends only got this title after their second appearence (Parvati, Boston Rob...)
Plus having season 48 be new-era all-stars gives more spots for new-era players to prove themselves, while allowing for more spots for pre-41 legends for season 50. Having season 50 be the only returning season since 40 is a bad idea because it's too many new players to choose from across the 9 recent seasons, while also trying to squeeze in an additional 40 seasons-worth of past players. Producers reallyyyy dropped the ball on this one.
Yeah agree but it should have been 47 new era all stars and 50 for legends so there would be a few seasons between but that would have required forethought and planning. 🥲
The 'guys' guy can shove it, yes I am this petty about nostalgia, especially since the reason for changing it is beyond dumb, it never meant only 'guys' even in the ancient, less PC ages of the show.
yea i was really surprised you included tori and jonathan over him -- is it bc of him leaking the drea ponderosa stuff n cbs maybe not wanting him back v
More like an evil approach. In Heroes vs Villains JT was aggressive and liar which was the opposite of his golden boy game. So hes sayin Maryanne will prob play more aggressive
Love the tori pick. Everyone saying players like kellie and emily, well they are the same kind of player. Survivor is best when the fans get to see different styles clash. Emily’s story also was perfect for a one season arc, focusing on her self journey after starting off poorly. I’d love to see someone like tori get a shot with a different cast
@@tonesantoro, Hunter’s ability to close out challenges through sand bag/ball tossing, slingshot aiming, puzzles, ball mazes, etc. makes up for any gap there is in physical strength. They would balance each other out in a hypothetical returnee season on opposing tribes in my opinion.
I think they will bring back charlie. People like charlie and he almost won so i hope survivor gives him a call. I also hope that they add players from 35-39 players back to. I wanna see devins victoria laruen christan davie and dk chillen back. (Ik its not likly but i hope)
Season 49 and 50 should be returnees. There are just so so many New Era players already worth making a full cast, so 49 would be a great Second Chances II. And then 50 be a series-wide historic season.
Fun video, thanks. Cody and Emily were missing on this list in my opinion. I would also love to see Tiffany (s46) and Omar. And I think Ellie would be fun to watch play again
Imagine them bringing back 39 days, but keeping the pace of the modern era with 24 (if they do 3 tribes; hell 25 players, split into 5 tribes-two tribal councils per immunity challenge) total players. A guy can dream.
I think Maryanne could ABSOLUTELY win again. Out of all the winners she's the easiest to underestimate, but she is a phenomenal speaker. She can sell you on her ideas as well as anyone
I would like to say that it’s told that carolyns on a show called the traitors. We can definitely study her gameplay without ride or dies on that show.
Personally, I don’t like including past winners on seasons with non-winners, so I wouldn’t include them even though I wouldn’t mind a couple of them. Off the top of my head I would consider people like Shan, Ricard, Naseer, Omar, Jonathan, Lindsey, Hai, Zach (I can dream), Jesse, Cassidy, Karla, Cody, Owen, Frannie, Carolyn, Carson, Jake, Katurah, Kaleb, Sabiyah, Emily, Venus, Q, Charlie, and Maria.
I hope Shan and Ricard will be considered a package deal for all star casting. They’ve got the makings of a complex multi-season arc like Spencer/Kass.
@@aleczavala5010I didn’t forget that, I very nearly wrote “ . . . like Spencer/Kass or even Jerri/Colby,” but decided that comparing them to a legendary pair from the mists of time might be laying it on too thick.
Love every name listed here, notably hyped for the Tori mention! If it's only new era so no Angelina, Tori HAS to play in her stead. I'd be very sad to see no Emily or Omar though, which feel like near shoe-ins for me as well.
I’m probably in the minority saying that I love that you included Tori from 42. She was hands down my favorite player on the blue tribe and she was the cat with nine lives fer sure.
41 is severely underrepresented on this list for my taste. My two picks would be Evvie and Tiffany, for a lot of the same reasons as you picked Owen. They seemed like great players who got undercut situationally, as Xander, who they worked hard to save at the merge, was totally unwilling to work with them afterwards just because he got spooked by Deshawn talking about how he was the other potential target on the Voce vote.
Ofc Idoled out has to talk about **Spoilers for the vid** His glorious queen Tori. If she is casted tho, she'll def be the random or less well known survivor player that could become a legend like parvati, amber and andrea
I NEED Emily back on my television screen asap I also wouldn't be surprised if they brought back Jelinsky atp he has to be one of the most iconic first boots next to Francesca
My predictions: 1. Bruce 2. Bruce 3. Bruce 4. Bruce 5. Bruce 6. Bruce 7. Bruce 8. Bruce 9. Bruce 10. Bruce 11. Bruce 12. Bruce 13. Bruce 14. Bruce 15. Bruce 16. Bruce 17. Bruce 18. Bruce
He bumped his head into that wooden bar and hence stole the spot of another innocent man. That is so evil, by far the most villainous move ever on Survivor. He should be on the new era villians tribe with Sami.
Not have Cody is crazy!!! I loved watching that man on tv and no one expected him to be strategic but he was pretty solid. Jesse definitely over shadowed him on the strategy portion though.
I'd add Ricard, Omar, Carson, and Emily to this list. Although honestly there are too many stars to fit all of them, especially considering Seasons 1-40 and 47-49.
Omar not being considered is a crime. He played a master class game from behind the scenes, and Maryanne is the only player who recognized his threat level
I’d probably add Ricard to this, just to see how him and Shan fare again. And you know what? I kind of what to see Jelinsky redeem himself; although I guess I’d rather see him on a first boots season.
Top from each season: Shan, Mike, Noelle, Carolyn, Emily, Q. Others I'd like to see: Maryanne, Omar, Cassidy, Jake, Tiff and Charlie. Obviously only one or 2 from the second list could make it on.
i would LOVE to see jake from 45 get a second chance, he is innovative and had great game sense imo, just wasn't able to pull the moves off. i don't know if he'd make it far because he plays so hard, but i don't care i love to see it!! (and emily flippen would be a great returnee but i know that's a long shot)
15:15 Yes please! Girl was TV gold, and regardless of how abrasive she was to others, the fact nobody seemed to consider her for a move was honestly their fault as much as hers. It cuts both ways in my opinion, and I'd love to see a season where people are willing to work with her more. Whether because they're a more savvy player like a Kaleb looking for an Emily or because of her own personal growth. Either way.
here's my list: two men and two women from each season 41: ricard, naseer, erika, liana 42: jonathan, omar, maryanne, lindsay 43: owen, jesse, karla, noelle 44: yam yam, carson, carolyn, frannie 45: austin, kaleb, dee, kellie 46: charlie, hunter, kenzie, tiffany
41: Shan 42: Tori, Omar, Johnathan 43: Jesse, Cody, Noelle, Owen 44: Carson, Carolyn 45: Kaleb, Julie, Austin, Katurah 46: Hunter, Tiffany, Venus, Tevin I would prefer no winner returnees, but if there had to be one, i personally would say Kenzie
I don't want winners on the roster. Firstly, because they have already won, and secondly, because they would occupy a slot that could go to a player who deserves a second chance more than them.
Venus is 100% not a lock. She had the producers sweating about whether she would break her NDA during her constant twitter rants and they are not gonna want to go through that again
i am so glad you mentioned tori. i feel super bad for her after her tribal council debacle. she is needlessly funny and i think she is kind of an underrated player
this is my list of people I think have a good chance and would be great on an all star reason. there's a star next to those I really would love to see. Survivor 41: 1. Shan* 2. Evvie 3. Tiffany 4. Ricard Survivor 42: 1. Tori 2. Maryanne* 3. Jonathan 4. Omar* Survivor 43: 1. Elie 2. Jesse* 3. Cassidy* Survivor 44: 1. Frannie* 2. Carolyn* 3. Carson 4. Yam Yam* Survivor 45: 1. Sabiyah 2. Kaleb* 3. Kellie* 4. Emily* 5. Dee* Survivor 46: 1. Charlie******** 2. Q******* 3. Venus* 4. Hunter I know there still are 3 more seasons until survivor 50 and there will probably be good characters in the next seasons, but so far, this is the pool I would select from. the locks for me should be Charlie, Q, Venus, Jesse, Carolyn, and Dee
Evvie is my number one for season 41. Underrated quiet strategic game and has said they have learned a lot since playing. Personally I think we saw Shams game, but I'd be fine seeing her back.
I’m surprised you didn’t mention Emily from S45. I also don’t think Venus will ever return due to how she played a part in having contestants attack Maria after the finale.
@@lolabush2201 So when Maria voted for Kenzie to win instead of Charlie, Venus said in a Cameo that her theory was that Maria was bitter and didn’t want anyone in her alliance to win if she wasn’t going to win because Maria had a huge ego. Venus also said that Maria was campaigning hard against Charlie at Ponderosa. Somehow, Q got involved and I’m not sure what he did, but a lot of Survivor fans called Maria out and the threats and harassment got so out of hand that Survivor’s IG had to make a post reminding the fans that these players are still people and to consider kindness on social media towards these contestants. It all started with Venus. For as much as I like her as a character, I don’t think production wants a repeat incident of this so that’s my doubt on why she would be on S50.
@anthonymendez1997 okay, to be fair though - the theory that maria voted for Kenzie because she was bitter definitely did NOT start with Venus. It’s what many people were thinking and saying anyways lol. Not saying that it’s right for Venus to spread stuff but like…come on now. It’s not really a “theory” when it’s kinda just the first thing that comes to your head after watching the season finale
@@jaykay1899 It’s one thing for the fans to speculate and another thing entirely to have a castaway give their perspective. At the very least, all what Venus did was confirm what the fans were thinking if that’s the case. I like Venus as a character, but I’m giving you my doubts as to why production might not cast her again for S50.
Kaleb and Maryanne would be nice to see on the same season given one is an early jury boot and the other is a winner and the they’re both from Canada. Dammit, I just want another Canadian to get farther than f6 which we haven’t had since, well, Maryanne. Plus Maryanne has become kind of a meme on RHAP so if Rob C is part of the cast they can bring in Stephen Fischback and be unstoppable.
If Q is a lock, then I think Liz is as well. The amount of drama between the two was crazy and I would love to see them on a season together again where they could potentially patch things up, or allow for more drama to form between them. Also, hot take, but I think Xander would be an interesting choice for a returnee season as well. It would be interesting to see if he would be his same cocky self without any agency or if he would actually develop into a good player and go in a deep run.
Nice vid. Don’t agree with 3 choices: Jonathan, Owen and Dee. Not enough charisma on screen to warrant a callback IMO. I’d replace them with Omar, Cody and Emily.
Great list. I love that you have Tori on, I'm a huge fan and I, too, believe that she is a better player than what we've seen on 42. Here are players I had on my list that I didn't see in the video: Ricard Foyé (41), Omar Zaheer (42), Cody Assenmacher (43), Emily Flippen (45), Kellie Nalbandian (45)
I wouldn't be surprised if they steered clear of Carson, due to some of his post-season activities. Quick summary being that he's involved in lawsuits that allege he did some shady things with potential business partners who make/sell some mini-Survivor challenge puzzles/etc. just like ones in the show that you can buy.
Tbh even though I love the new era winners I don’t really want to see them back as much as other people. I think they are more likely to bring back Carson, Cassidy, Charlie, Ricard, etc.
I sincerely hope we get a mix of pre-40 (ideally only one-time players with a good amount from 35-39 who never got a second chance) and post-40 players
I love this list, I do think Cassidy should also be considered for 50. I feel like she has a LOT of unfinished business and would be eager to turn up the heat to prove to everyone that she can play a riskier game. I also agree with Venus’ assessment, she definitely has a lot to learn but I think she can be a great returnee player if she was given the chance too.
From the New Era Seasons I’ve Watched (41,45,46) Here’s who I think should be back 41: Shan Liana 1 of either Ricard,Xander,or Danny 45: Kaleb Emily 1 of Kellie,Dee,or Drew 46: Q TIFF 1 of either Hunter or Tevin (Kellie,Tevin,and Maria don’t need to come back for 50 but they need to comeback in A Season)
Your cast looks good, I would add Ricard, Cassidy, Charlie and Xander but if they do something like old school Vs new school it will very difficult to cast 9/10 players from each time, plus we could also get people from 47-49 on the cast
My picks would be: 41 - Naseer and Ricard 41 - Omar, Tori and Maryanne 43 - Jesse and Cody 44 - I don’t dislike any of the Tika 3, but I’m not too excited for any of them to return and I can’t remember anyone else from that cast that was super memorable. Maybe Danny ? 45 - Financial Analyst Emily Flippen and Dee 46 - Q, Jelinsky and Venus
18 Jelinskys
I would unironically want to see that
Please no, him and Bhanu should have a restraining order from the show. One of the few moments I've wanted to break my tv just listening to them, came close to giving up on Survivor all together.
@@ajsparty Just for you, I’ll change my dream 50 cast to a tribe of 9 Jelinskys and a tribe of 9 Bhanus. Throw in Liz on both tribes for good measure.
@ajsparty Just say you don't like entertaining TV and move on, they were on the show for 1 and 4 episodes
not 18, just several
Brandon and the ladder should be on opposing tribes. Imagine the post merge drama between those two!
I’m in
@@BrandonFromSurvivor45 😂😂😂 Love ya, man. I hope you get a second chance, with or without the damn ladder.
@@BrandonFromSurvivor45It would be special to see you vs ladder one more time!
@@BrandonFromSurvivor45 loved you and Austin being silly on the game master remaster
Wendell, dee, Austin and Michelle should be on the same tribe
PLEASE
ur messy😭
I think that’s a different show 😉
survivor ex on the beach edition
Poor Austin. Dude threw his game after he got eyes for a woman who ends up with a cheater/potentially being a homewrecker
That Kaleb comparison with Boston Rob is lowkey perfect. Charismatic dude who despite being on a losing tribe was the big star. A great challenge competitor gets hella lucky in the game that allows him to make it further in the game and is heavily remembered in his szn despite goin out so early.
They should have a surprise twist of a 19th survivor. Let it be Jelinsky and have the three tribes compete to see who gets him as the “severalth” member of their tribe.
OMG THIS WOULD BE SO FUNNY
I wish they would've chosen to do S48 an All-Stars only featuring people from the new era (a little nod to the fact S8 was the original all-stars) and then do S50 an All-Legends. I know it woulda been two all-star seasons almost back to back (i mean, they did s31 and s34 two returning player seasons), but i feel that, with season 48, we could put these new players to the test before labeling them legends. A lot of the survivor legends only got this title after their second appearence (Parvati, Boston Rob...)
Plus having season 48 be new-era all-stars gives more spots for new-era players to prove themselves, while allowing for more spots for pre-41 legends for season 50.
Having season 50 be the only returning season since 40 is a bad idea because it's too many new players to choose from across the 9 recent seasons, while also trying to squeeze in an additional 40 seasons-worth of past players.
Producers reallyyyy dropped the ball on this one.
Yeah agree but it should have been 47 new era all stars and 50 for legends so there would be a few seasons between but that would have required forethought and planning. 🥲
If Broccoli Brad is not on season 50, we riot. Genuinely my favorute new era player for no reason
Cuz he rules
Brad is my #1 choice
Out of the entire new era, his fumbling of the broccoli line is the only time I laughed out loud watching
Bhanu too
The new era has some all time iconic premergers. Brad, JD, Danny, Elie, Claire, Bruce, Matthew, Brandon, Sabiyah, Bhanu, Jem, so many good picks.
I completely agree, but I would absolutely add Ricard and Emily
The 'guys' guy can shove it, yes I am this petty about nostalgia, especially since the reason for changing it is beyond dumb, it never meant only 'guys' even in the ancient, less PC ages of the show.
@@atufbrandbusiness3581womp womp
Emily yes. Ricard? He// nooooo
Emily has said in the past that she isn't interested in playing again, so she'd have to change her mind first.
@@shadowninja6689 didnt know That but i really love her character arc That season thats why i Say yes to her.
I want them to do a rivals season for 50 - Babygirl Jake vs Queen Katurah, Evil Overlord Shan vs Evil Overlord Ricard, Bhanu vs God, etc
Bhanu vs God woulda made me spit out my water if I were drinking some
Brandon vs. the ladder
Q and anyone whose name isnt Maria
Phillip Sheppard vs Self Awarness
Venus vs the world
would love to see jake return, a player that took big shots but had all of them miss id love to see how he does on a second chance
Omar has to be there
yea i was really surprised you included tori and jonathan over him -- is it bc of him leaking the drea ponderosa stuff n cbs maybe not wanting him back v
"Maryanne would take the JT approach." so, she's gonna give the idol to Russell?
More like an evil approach. In Heroes vs Villains JT was aggressive and liar which was the opposite of his golden boy game. So hes sayin Maryanne will prob play more aggressive
Remember, Maryanne hasn’t seen the last six episodes of Tocantins.
@@aperson22222She probably has by now.
just watch she's gonna give her idol to jesse lol
Love the tori pick. Everyone saying players like kellie and emily, well they are the same kind of player. Survivor is best when the fans get to see different styles clash. Emily’s story also was perfect for a one season arc, focusing on her self journey after starting off poorly. I’d love to see someone like tori get a shot with a different cast
I’m begging for Jonathan and Hunter on opposing tribes. 2 of the most dominant premerge challenge beasts ever
Hunter was great but wasn't on the same plane as Jonathan physically. I guess puzzles make up some of that gap, but Jonathan was one of a kind.
@@tonesantoro, Hunter’s ability to close out challenges through sand bag/ball tossing, slingshot aiming, puzzles, ball mazes, etc. makes up for any gap there is in physical strength. They would balance each other out in a hypothetical returnee season on opposing tribes in my opinion.
Venus broke so many NDA rules that I'd be shocked if they asked her back
Which rules did she break? Just curious
I think they will bring back charlie. People like charlie and he almost won so i hope survivor gives him a call.
I also hope that they add players from 35-39 players back to. I wanna see devins victoria laruen christan davie and dk chillen back. (Ik its not likly but i hope)
Charlie is one of the best players to not win in the new era… but he was so boring to watch. I don’t really wanna see him again
@mr.pencilsharpener8004 he was kinda boring but in the game of survivor I hope people aren't worried about being boring instead of winning
I’d love to see Devins and Charlie back!
Lauren’s eyebrows are too distracting.
Season 49 and 50 should be returnees. There are just so so many New Era players already worth making a full cast, so 49 would be a great Second Chances II. And then 50 be a series-wide historic season.
I was thinking along the lines that you were thinking.
Fun video, thanks. Cody and Emily were missing on this list in my opinion. I would also love to see Tiffany (s46) and Omar. And I think Ellie would be fun to watch play again
Imagine them bringing back 39 days, but keeping the pace of the modern era with 24 (if they do 3 tribes; hell 25 players, split into 5 tribes-two tribal councils per immunity challenge) total players. A guy can dream.
I think Maryanne could ABSOLUTELY win again. Out of all the winners she's the easiest to underestimate, but she is a phenomenal speaker. She can sell you on her ideas as well as anyone
I would like to say that it’s told that carolyns on a show called the traitors. We can definitely study her gameplay without ride or dies on that show.
Personally, I don’t like including past winners on seasons with non-winners, so I wouldn’t include them even though I wouldn’t mind a couple of them.
Off the top of my head I would consider people like Shan, Ricard, Naseer, Omar, Jonathan, Lindsey, Hai, Zach (I can dream), Jesse, Cassidy, Karla, Cody, Owen, Frannie, Carolyn, Carson, Jake, Katurah, Kaleb, Sabiyah, Emily, Venus, Q, Charlie, and Maria.
bro, your sense of humour never ceases to amaze me. please never stop making videos, and get on survivor!
I hope Shan and Ricard will be considered a package deal for all star casting. They’ve got the makings of a complex multi-season arc like Spencer/Kass.
You forgot the OG complex multi-season arc: Colby/Jerri
@@aleczavala5010I didn’t forget that, I very nearly wrote “ . . . like Spencer/Kass or even Jerri/Colby,” but decided that comparing them to a legendary pair from the mists of time might be laying it on too thick.
Love every name listed here, notably hyped for the Tori mention! If it's only new era so no Angelina, Tori HAS to play in her stead. I'd be very sad to see no Emily or Omar though, which feel like near shoe-ins for me as well.
I’m probably in the minority saying that I love that you included Tori from 42. She was hands down my favorite player on the blue tribe and she was the cat with nine lives fer sure.
41 is severely underrepresented on this list for my taste. My two picks would be Evvie and Tiffany, for a lot of the same reasons as you picked Owen. They seemed like great players who got undercut situationally, as Xander, who they worked hard to save at the merge, was totally unwilling to work with them afterwards just because he got spooked by Deshawn talking about how he was the other potential target on the Voce vote.
Ofc Idoled out has to talk about
**Spoilers for the vid**
His glorious queen Tori. If she is casted tho, she'll def be the random or less well known survivor player that could become a legend like parvati, amber and andrea
I 100% agree!
I think Drew is a solid lock for season 50 too. He was a hell of a narrator for the show
I'm ready for Q 2.0
2Q, 2Qurious
jelinsky 🐐
I NEED Emily back on my television screen asap
I also wouldn't be surprised if they brought back Jelinsky atp he has to be one of the most iconic first boots next to Francesca
Venus, tori and Carolyn on a tribe would be so much fun.
My predictions:
1. Bruce
2. Bruce
3. Bruce
4. Bruce
5. Bruce
6. Bruce
7. Bruce
8. Bruce
9. Bruce
10. Bruce
11. Bruce
12. Bruce
13. Bruce
14. Bruce
15. Bruce
16. Bruce
17. Bruce
18. Bruce
Hell no. He is just so anyoing. I was with Katura get rid of him.
@@popmans9999 : He also blew up his entire tribe's game by targeting Kaleb at the merge.
He bumped his head into that wooden bar and hence stole the spot of another innocent man. That is so evil, by far the most villainous move ever on Survivor. He should be on the new era villians tribe with Sami.
please no
@@khaanhnguyenle2354 and with Q, big mistake. We should also have Ciera because she voted off her own mother
I don't want winners taking up spots when there's other players that played amazing games that came up just short (Carson, Mike, Emily, Charlie etc.)
Not have Cody is crazy!!! I loved watching that man on tv and no one expected him to be strategic but he was pretty solid. Jesse definitely over shadowed him on the strategy portion though.
He mentioned Cody as a package deal with Jesse.
i absolutely need emily, carson and charlie. they along with jesse are easily my favorite new era players and some of my favorites of all time
I'd add Ricard, Omar, Carson, and Emily to this list. Although honestly there are too many stars to fit all of them, especially considering Seasons 1-40 and 47-49.
Omar not being considered is a crime. He played a master class game from behind the scenes, and Maryanne is the only player who recognized his threat level
What you were saying about Tori but for Kellie from 45. The Wentworth-factor with her is INSANE (and it’s not just because she’s another Kelly lol)
I’d probably add Ricard to this, just to see how him and Shan fare again. And you know what? I kind of what to see Jelinsky redeem himself; although I guess I’d rather see him on a first boots season.
41 - Shan Ricard
42 - Tori Omar
43 - Karla Jesse Cass
44 - Frannie Danny Yam Yam
45 - Sabiyah Kaleb Kellie Emily Katurah Jake Dee
46 - Tevin Hunter Tiff Venus Q Charlie
Top from each season: Shan, Mike, Noelle, Carolyn, Emily, Q.
Others I'd like to see: Maryanne, Omar, Cassidy, Jake, Tiff and Charlie.
Obviously only one or 2 from the second list could make it on.
I feel like People want see Charlie and Ricard back as well
i would LOVE to see jake from 45 get a second chance, he is innovative and had great game sense imo, just wasn't able to pull the moves off. i don't know if he'd make it far because he plays so hard, but i don't care i love to see it!!
(and emily flippen would be a great returnee but i know that's a long shot)
Non winners only. Would like to see Hunter from season 46 get another shot.
No thanks. He was good at challenges, but nothing else.
My season 50 list
Shan
Ricard
Xander
Omer
Tori
Jesse
Carson
Yam yam
Carolyn
Kaleb
Charlie
15:15 Yes please! Girl was TV gold, and regardless of how abrasive she was to others, the fact nobody seemed to consider her for a move was honestly their fault as much as hers. It cuts both ways in my opinion, and I'd love to see a season where people are willing to work with her more.
Whether because they're a more savvy player like a Kaleb looking for an Emily or because of her own personal growth. Either way.
here's my list: two men and two women from each season
41: ricard, naseer, erika, liana
42: jonathan, omar, maryanne, lindsay
43: owen, jesse, karla, noelle
44: yam yam, carson, carolyn, frannie
45: austin, kaleb, dee, kellie
46: charlie, hunter, kenzie, tiffany
41: Shan
42: Tori, Omar, Johnathan
43: Jesse, Cody, Noelle, Owen
44: Carson, Carolyn
45: Kaleb, Julie, Austin, Katurah
46: Hunter, Tiffany, Venus, Tevin
I would prefer no winner returnees, but if there had to be one, i personally would say Kenzie
3 questions:
where?
is?
Jake?
They need hunter from 46 and Carson from 44 to be a it and fish back duo
I want to see Cody back so bad
I would love to see both Owen and Jake come back but they both kinda fit into the Charlie Brown role
I'm curious as to why you didn't include Omar
Lindsey and omar of 42 too, sabiyah's wax idol saga on 45, as well as Jake and Emily
Yessss Lindsay was so good!
Funny how the day Jeff made this announcement, was also the same day Ulterior Motives aka EKT was rediscovered!
Game within the game NEEDS a revival 😭
Yeah, that was fun.
I don't want winners on the roster. Firstly, because they have already won, and secondly, because they would occupy a slot that could go to a player who deserves a second chance more than them.
More than _they._
Venus is 100% not a lock. She had the producers sweating about whether she would break her NDA during her constant twitter rants and they are not gonna want to go through that again
i am so glad you mentioned tori. i feel super bad for her after her tribal council debacle. she is needlessly funny and i think she is kind of an underrated player
this is my list of people I think have a good chance and would be great on an all star reason. there's a star next to those I really would love to see.
Survivor 41:
1. Shan*
2. Evvie
3. Tiffany
4. Ricard
Survivor 42:
1. Tori
2. Maryanne*
3. Jonathan
4. Omar*
Survivor 43:
1. Elie
2. Jesse*
3. Cassidy*
Survivor 44:
1. Frannie*
2. Carolyn*
3. Carson
4. Yam Yam*
Survivor 45:
1. Sabiyah
2. Kaleb*
3. Kellie*
4. Emily*
5. Dee*
Survivor 46:
1. Charlie********
2. Q*******
3. Venus*
4. Hunter
I know there still are 3 more seasons until survivor 50 and there will probably be good characters in the next seasons, but so far, this is the pool I would select from. the locks for me should be Charlie, Q, Venus, Jesse, Carolyn, and Dee
Charlie, Omer, Emily, Cody, Ricard, All of those ppl have a shot at returning as well.
The only ones of mine, that you missed from the ‘New Era’ are: Ricard Foye, Emily Flippen, and Omar Zaheer.
I need Tiffany from 46 and Lindsay from 42!
Needs more Jake O’Kane
Lulu and Yanu members on stronger starting tribes?
Evvie is my number one for season 41. Underrated quiet strategic game and has said they have learned a lot since playing. Personally I think we saw Shams game, but I'd be fine seeing her back.
I’m surprised you didn’t mention Emily from S45. I also don’t think Venus will ever return due to how she played a part in having contestants attack Maria after the finale.
She did what now?
@@lolabush2201 So when Maria voted for Kenzie to win instead of Charlie, Venus said in a Cameo that her theory was that Maria was bitter and didn’t want anyone in her alliance to win if she wasn’t going to win because Maria had a huge ego. Venus also said that Maria was campaigning hard against Charlie at Ponderosa. Somehow, Q got involved and I’m not sure what he did, but a lot of Survivor fans called Maria out and the threats and harassment got so out of hand that Survivor’s IG had to make a post reminding the fans that these players are still people and to consider kindness on social media towards these contestants. It all started with Venus. For as much as I like her as a character, I don’t think production wants a repeat incident of this so that’s my doubt on why she would be on S50.
@@anthonymendez1997 interesting post thank you!
@anthonymendez1997 okay, to be fair though - the theory that maria voted for Kenzie because she was bitter definitely did NOT start with Venus. It’s what many people were thinking and saying anyways lol. Not saying that it’s right for Venus to spread stuff but like…come on now. It’s not really a “theory” when it’s kinda just the first thing that comes to your head after watching the season finale
@@jaykay1899 It’s one thing for the fans to speculate and another thing entirely to have a castaway give their perspective. At the very least, all what Venus did was confirm what the fans were thinking if that’s the case. I like Venus as a character, but I’m giving you my doubts as to why production might not cast her again for S50.
So basically with Venus, she'd either win the game or be first-boot. There is no in-between.
I'd add Emily to the pick list, and Carla. Overall a solid list of contenders, although I could take or leave Q.
Kaleb and Maryanne would be nice to see on the same season given one is an early jury boot and the other is a winner and the they’re both from Canada. Dammit, I just want another Canadian to get farther than f6 which we haven’t had since, well, Maryanne.
Plus Maryanne has become kind of a meme on RHAP so if Rob C is part of the cast they can bring in Stephen Fischback and be unstoppable.
If Q is a lock, then I think Liz is as well. The amount of drama between the two was crazy and I would love to see them on a season together again where they could potentially patch things up, or allow for more drama to form between them. Also, hot take, but I think Xander would be an interesting choice for a returnee season as well. It would be interesting to see if he would be his same cocky self without any agency or if he would actually develop into a good player and go in a deep run.
Not sure if they ever have a season with winners in it unless it is a theme, like Winners vs Second Chances, with an early tribe swap.
Nice vid.
Don’t agree with 3 choices: Jonathan, Owen and Dee. Not enough charisma on screen to warrant a callback IMO.
I’d replace them with Omar, Cody and Emily.
Great list. I love that you have Tori on, I'm a huge fan and I, too, believe that she is a better player than what we've seen on 42.
Here are players I had on my list that I didn't see in the video: Ricard Foyé (41), Omar Zaheer (42), Cody Assenmacher (43), Emily Flippen (45), Kellie Nalbandian (45)
Ngl I think Carson being on this season could/would make for a good story
I wouldn't be surprised if they steered clear of Carson, due to some of his post-season activities. Quick summary being that he's involved in lawsuits that allege he did some shady things with potential business partners who make/sell some mini-Survivor challenge puzzles/etc. just like ones in the show that you can buy.
Ngl Carson was boring
@@shadowninja6689 I doubt he doesn't get cast most casuals don't know about that
@@shadowninja6689 well if this is true I hope Carson redeems himself in some way. I’m sure he will someday, again if true
Too many more interesting white males to take his spot
Tbh even though I love the new era winners I don’t really want to see them back as much as other people. I think they are more likely to bring back Carson, Cassidy, Charlie, Ricard, etc.
I sincerely hope we get a mix of pre-40 (ideally only one-time players with a good amount from 35-39 who never got a second chance) and post-40 players
Thank you for doing this video! Your predictions are usually better than mine lol 😂
I could see them try to bring Ricard and Shan back as well as Jessie and Cody.
I don’t think there should be winners on season 50! Bring back second chance
Jonathan is one of my favorite new era players. along with Q, Bruce, and Emily
I love this list, I do think Cassidy should also be considered for 50. I feel like she has a LOT of unfinished business and would be eager to turn up the heat to prove to everyone that she can play a riskier game. I also agree with Venus’ assessment, she definitely has a lot to learn but I think she can be a great returnee player if she was given the chance too.
What about Cody from 43?
Men
1. Gabler
2. Yam Yam
3. Drew
4. Austin
5. Jesse
6. Cody
7. Jonathan
8. Q
9. Charlie
10. Omar
Women
1. Maryanne
2. Kenzie
3. Shan
4. Karla
5. Noelle
6. Carolyn
7. Julie
8. Maria
9. Frannie
10. Emily
where is Noelle for season 43, Heidi, Lauren from 44, Emily for season 45 and Charlie and Kenzie from46?
Generally asking, did the news of returnees become before or during 46?
From the New Era Seasons I’ve Watched (41,45,46) Here’s who I think should be back
41:
Shan
Liana
1 of either Ricard,Xander,or Danny
45:
Kaleb
Emily
1 of Kellie,Dee,or Drew
46:
Q
TIFF
1 of either Hunter or Tevin
(Kellie,Tevin,and Maria don’t need to come back for 50 but they need to comeback in A Season)
Your cast looks good, I would add Ricard, Cassidy, Charlie and Xander but if they do something like old school Vs new school it will very difficult to cast 9/10 players from each time, plus we could also get people from 47-49 on the cast
My wishlist would be 20 players
- Devens
- Dominik
- Frannie
- Maryann
- Xander
- Carolyne
- Q
- yam yam
- Kaleb
- Maria
- Dee
- Cody
- Omar
- Jessy
- Shan
- Bruce
- Carson
- Emily
- Tevin
- Drew
Honorable mentions: Ricard, Austin, Devon, Christian H. , Venus and Charlie
My picks would be:
41 - Naseer and Ricard
41 - Omar, Tori and Maryanne
43 - Jesse and Cody
44 - I don’t dislike any of the Tika 3, but I’m not too excited for any of them to return and I can’t remember anyone else from that cast that was super memorable. Maybe Danny ?
45 - Financial Analyst Emily Flippen and Dee
46 - Q, Jelinsky and Venus
Wowwww no Charlie?
Rick Devens, Elaine, Janet, Christian! We need them back
Will you be making an video for old era players? I think Jeff said survivor 50 is open to everyone including pre 40 players
Yo you forgot the good players
1. Gabler
2. Bruce
3. Sifu
At least 2 of these 3 have to be back for survivor 50 or I’ll scream
Also you forgot tevin and hunter
@@harryplor9796Sifu. Really?
I’m offended that Emily didn’t make the list. I know she said she’d never play again but she was polarizing.
Q and Bruce, legends
Agreed
I never want to see Q. He should have quit.
@@mienafriggstad3360 So true, he should quit on day 1 in Survivor 50
I would love to see Ricard back too
i wanna see Omar again. he was so awesome, underrated tbh. i think he woulf be more confident if he were to play again