How many drummers does it take to change a lightbulb? Four. One to change it & the other three to tell him how much better Neil Peart would have done it.
Grew up in Toronto during this era and when this hit the airwaves? Nothing else mattered, we ate it up like best candy ever made. And do you know what? That candy taste just as good today as it did back then...
I heard this song on the radio, had no idea who Rush was (I was pretty young), but it was instant love. I had to keep listening to the radio to catch the artist and name of the album (there was no internet in the early 80s!). I immediately went our and bought the Cassette! I later upgraded to the CD, which I STILL have (long since ripped into MP3s on all my devices.
You realize Neil paraphrased that from the Greek philosopher Heraclitus? He took lines from John Donne, Ernest Hemingway and others to use in Rush’s lyrics. I agree he was a great lyricist but Neil loved to read and I don’t think a lot of people know he lifted lines from others to use in their songs.
@@mr.e8432 All the world's indeed a stage and we are merely players, performers and portrayers, each another's audience outside the gilded cage. - Neil Peart All the world's a stage, And all the men and women merely players; They have their exits and their entrances; And one man in his time plays many parts. - William Shakespeare
@@mr.e8432and you realize if you really want to critique such things go a great deal of artists use lines from other works also movies do it a lot as well. But a good line is a good line most people just enjoy it for what it is.
As a female Rush fan, I am so happy to see you experience them and the enjoyment you convey is a reminder of how I felt when I found them in 2011. Got to see them 3 times and they were so fantastic. Keep up the good work 😄
I had a friend in high school hated them but he came across a free ticket to the Power windows Tour saw him after leaving the Stadium and he Ran up too me and Said Holly Crap I can see why Rush is your Fave Band. Next day was a Sunday and again seen him at Checkout buying every Rush Album the Store had. Even more Massive Sound live especially in Prime.
"Getting" Rush is an experience in itself. Once you "get" it, you're hooked (probably) for ever. Welcome to the club (as @friedricerocket rightfully mentioned). Rush IS something else.
Thank you for highlighting this Canadian masterpiece. One of my favourite bands live and, despite seeing it repeatedly with my own eyes, it’s hard to believe all this sound comes from three guys. They deserve all the respect.
That is RUSH hitting forth gear. You are sexy, not trying to be creepy, just sayin. RUSH is a phenomenal band! Especially live. They were famous for the 3 of them being able to reproduce their albums live with no cheating. I saw 18 of their tours over the decades! RUSH was special, that’s the easiest way to describe them, RUSH is special. See ya later sexy lady! 😁👍
RUSH is THE PERFECT EXAMPLE of the fluidity of MASTERING TIME SIGNATURES! I play drums and there are a few things that you need to know about Neil Peart’s ( pronounced PEER-T) character: First he writes the lyrics so he knows in advance what TYPE of song it’s meant to be ie ballad, driver, etc. Second he COMPOSES on the drums… like a carpenter who looks at a set of blueprints before building the object. Neil lays out a SKETCH in his mind of the VOICES of the drumset and builds the song from there. He is also a great LISTENER knowing when NOT to step over Geddy’s singing or Alex’s solos! Finally, he had perfect timing and fluidity of time changes. He said himself that it’s not about COUNTING the time signatures as much as fluid motion to change the tempo without counting: in other words it should FLOW! He hates repeating the same drum patterns in the same song meaning if he plays a fill one way the first time around he will play it differently the second time around. IE. Rolls down the toms the first time around and triplets or quads (all four limbs) the second time around. In short there will NEVER be another like him on planet earth 🌍 🌏 🌎! REST IN PEACE PROFESSOR! With heart felt admiration and sincerity! Gary
People argue as to whether he was the best drummer ever but has any drummer ever contributed so much to a group as highly regarded, as successful as RUSH? If you look at him in totality, I don't think there is a question as to whether he's the best.
Rush is that band that you've never heard of anything like them before and you never will again. They're one of a kind! Also, one of the best drummers ever! RIP Neil Peart!!!
I’m an old guy now, and was a teenager in the 70’s when they started. Lots of great music came from the 70’s and 80’s, but anyone who appreciated talent KNEW Rush was something special. Just 3 guys rocking… all 3 guys were considered ’nerds’ back then because they were extremely smart and talented, and didn’t party like rock stars. They would sit around and enjoy a great glass of wine instead… !
Mentioning that "shift" early on, and not being a "percussionist", you're starting to dial-in on the greatness of Neil Peart. His ability to initiate time shifts is legendary, and the part that throws most people off is that it's seamless and flawless. Great reaction to their signature song. A little known fact....Geddy HATED this song the first time they did it. RIP Neil.
It’s hilarious watching you fangirl so hard on Rush, I absolutely LOVE that you’ve discovered them and they’re making such a great impression on you! I’ve been a fan since I was in middle school and always felt so many of their lyrics and music really spoke to me as an angst ridden GenXer. Unfortunately Neil passed not too long ago, so Rush as we know it has ended its journey, but the music we have is so timeless and motivating, I will love it until the end of my days. Try listening to “Territories” off of “Power Windows”, or “Distant Early Warning” off of “Grace Under Pressure”. Not their big hits, but brilliant songs and lyrics. Keep up the fan-girling, and welcome to the Rush community. ❤
I love that you are re-visting Rush, this is a DEEP rabbit hole! One of the most amazing things about Rush is the way they move between time signatures; you may not even have noticed for example the bridge section into the guitar solo changed to 7/8, so effortlessly and without the listener being jolted or having to re-sync their foot tapping on the down beat... ;-)
Definitely; there's a through line in all their songs, even when they're changing times signatures, that makes it easy to follow along. That's one of the genius things about them, and why I've loved listening to them ever since I heard 2112...
I've seen this band live more than any other. Rush was great every single time, 3 man band, every one a consumate professional. I love watching your eyes and expressions listening to these ironic bands. Thank you. I remember my friend who was a drummer and I sneaking past security to get into a section before one show...directly above and behind the set. Looking down at Neil's drum kit..wow and out at the crowd waiting for Rush to come out... we were chased out, but I'll never forget that sight and the sound quality of their shows. Miss you, Neil and my friend Adam aka: " Ammo", Army Airborne Ranger.
Tom Sawyer did not get the jab. He was busy driving his Red Barchetta, which the jabbers want to ban, just like in the song. How is that free health care and open borders working for everyone?
You cant go wrong with analyzing a Rush song. I still get amused watching you react to Closer To The Heart, your first time with Rush. A couple of great Rush songs for vocals are The Trees and Spirit Of Radio. Another great video, Bethany
@@mattdye2870 Absolutely. I was trying to think of songs where the vocals stand out. If we are talking about the music then nothing beats La Villa Strangiato or some of their more epic early stuff like 2112. However, 2112 is a very long song with lots of instrumental sections so maybe not the best for vocal analysis. Same with Xanadu, a real masterpiece but it's only got vocals for about 2 minutes of the 8 or 9 minutes of the song.
@@fishermanmitch1I was lucky enough to see them on five different tours starting with Moving pictures. They did The Trees for that tour, Signals and Power Windows. I miss seeing them live
These guys had a career unparalleled in scope, covering 4 + decades. They evolved their sound constantly with each studio album and song. You could spend the rest of your life finding new ways to appreciate what these guys made and shared so expertly.
As usual I loved loved your analysis along with the vocals/bass/synth of Geddy and that guitar of Alex. But, watching the young Neil Peart at work on those drums brought a genuine tear to my eye. Missed so badly.
As a Rush fan, i marvel at your enjoyment of this track. I don't get to see enough women finding something to value in their music. The joy i got in watching a female geekout over a Rush tune is the most amazing part of this video. I will be watching this video once a week, until i leave this world. Thank you very very much!!
Neil Pert is the GOAT (Greatest of all time) of all drummers ever. RIP Neil. Rush is a great band. They have so many more songs. I look forward to more RUSH
Wow! A female Rush fan and one that actually refers to their music as "beautiful" !! I was just browsing around RUclips and there you were. This video popped up in my feed, likely because I'm a huge Rush fan (and from their home town - Willowdale Ontario (Go Canada!), a drummer, guitar player and singer - singer third as I'm by no means as pro as you. I loved all you said about this song and the band and I ended up staying up most of the night watching your channel. Yes, hours and hours. I love how emotional you get watching and listening to music that gets me emotional! I got double slammed emotionally because of your emotions. John Farnham, The Voice, you with tears in your eyes and me sobbing here like a kid! Your videos are great GREAT!. I don't know you but you somehow feel like a long lost friend all of a sudden. I'm a fan - Thanks Bethany, I'll keep watching. Oh and while you're on your Canadian kick, check out Kim Mitchell - his solo stuff and his old band Max Webster.
This song was my "gateway drug" into Rush right after this album came out when I was in high school! After hearing this, I went out and got into everything they'd done to that point, and have been a huge fan ever since. Rush became my spirit animal and still is!! Saw them live 3 times in around 2010/2011. Wish I had seen them more!
Your reaction to Rush at first time got me hooked and this reaction was also great to watch and great to experience your reaction. Thanks and keep it going, greetings from Finland!
That "sound" you heard the drummer make was on an open high hat (closed quickly) with a simultaneous kick bass drum (which coincides with the open high hat note). For those who've not tried Neil Peart's high hat/bass drum technique, it looks like it should be simple, but it's devilishly hard for all but the best drummers (I'm not great, so it's a struggle), and it was one of his numerous innovations in the way he composed and performed accents for the music.
Sure this is a "vocal" channel but never feel bad about reacting to music! A vocalist, bass player, percussionist etc is nothing without responding to the sonic landscape around themselves. So we LOVE when you appreciate the music!!! I've watched this several times just because it's an intelligent true reaction that makes me feel good! lol
Now that is how you start a Monday! I love watching your video deconstructions. Being able to learn new things from a song I've enjoyed since its release in 1981 was a real treat. Thank you!
Three of the most talented musicians. Alex is a superb guitarist and In Neil they had one of the best percussionists of all time. And Geddy has a unique and instantly recognisable voice that was made for the music and vice versa. I love how irreverent they could be with time signatures. One of my favourite bands. Thanks for an invested and involved reaction
There can’t be many bands where all of the members have won readers polls in instrument specific magazines (such as Guitar Player, Modern Drummer, Bass Player). Maybe Yes. Maybe The Police. I can’t think of anyone else (Zeppelin?)
@@tomfabozzi5353 I agree 100% . Led Zeppelin, for sure, are another stand out band. It's in the live arena where these bands truly come to the fore. Masters of their art indeed
so im 39 from uk when i was 13 14 i played drums in school a teacher there told me about a band called rush told me i might like the drummer now 20 odd years on i listen to rush everyday i love them ive seen in once in Manchester uk in 2007 seeing mr peart play drums was unreal if u see this mr jones from school thanks for showing me the best band ever
the production of this record is flawless, the producer, terry brown is a genius. I was 13 when this record came out which really put rush on the center stage. they've been the soundtrack of my life. great job on your part :)
Supreme musicianship and a message to boot. Painting a picture. Describing the ideal world, a better life for all. And you are right. There’s a lot to take in with Rush. The melodies and rhythms are a mesh of time signatures and counterpoint that is hard to imagine. And yet so very beautiful to hear.
Neil is my favourite percussionist, the bass from Geddy is incredible, it’s very difficult to hear a bass play this strong in many songs, Rush’s songs bring out every instrument involved so you hear it. Alexis guitar takes you on a journey. 3 man band sounds like a 5 man band, so talented and loved everywhere they go. Such great people who love what they do and the fans that love it as well.
I first saw Rush on the 2112 tour, having already bought 'Rush', 'Fly by Night', and 'Caress of Steel'... and have been an avid (or rabid) fan ever since. I watch a lot of 'reaction' videos and you are one of my first stops. My three favorite bands of all time are AC/DC, Pink Floyd, and RUSH !!!! I absolutely adore your reactions to the really exquisite music that I was raised on throughout the 70s and 80s. When you listen, and we see that beautiful authentic smile.... it warms my heart, knowing that there are generations that will keep this 'old rock and roll' music alive for centuries, not unlike Beethoven and Mozart... Thanks Bethany... :)
5:16 I think the most hilarious thing about Geddy Lee is that since RUclips started I have seen dozens of vocal experts praising Geddy Lee , when ironically people who say they hate Rush state that it’s his voice they hate.
Every period, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, is a reflection of the music they were listening to. The music that inspired them influenced the music they created. By this point, it was The Police, Ultravox, Talking Heads, etc. "All this machinery making modern music ..."
"All this machinery making modern music", reminds me that Bethany should listen to and react to Spirit of Radio by RUSH. The musicianship, time signature changes and lyrics are sure to blow her away
2024 and you had not listened to Rush!???? This is one of the most badass songs ever. Fell in love with them in 1982 high school electronics class, with the rest of the nerds. Still nerding out and loving it. Thanks for bringing this to the (ahem) younger audience. Love your videos--great work!
I don't remember what I said in my comment on your "Limelight" reaction from maybe a year ago (!), but I do think I remember using the word "effortless." There is an apparent ease in his transitions and this gorgeous sonority in his midrange. Another thing, which I never see or hear mentioned by anyone, is the effortlessness (that word again) in his vibrato during this period - and the fact that he always seemed to be able to use it in just the right places (""His reserve a quiet defense," "The river," "What you say about society," etc.) There is a prime example of that instinct and ability on "Vital Signs." When he sings the phrase, "Can only be worn by persistence," he kind of accents the word "persistence" with this beautiful trilly vibrato, which adds so much - to the extent that, when I heard the song live and he sang the phrase without that vibrato, I was disappointed, because I felt that it was so integral to that vocal performance. Also, he is the frigging Prime Minister of diphthongs, but that's another topic altogether. These are things most people probably don't think about, even Rush fans. But I do, because, though I'm not a "singa" (as Owl Jolson might say), I do so love vocals and vocalists. Glad to have heard an analysis of this track from you. I felt this was Geddy's voice at its best. It still had range and flexibility, but by this point, it also had a richness and maturity which came with age and experience. A legitimately great vocalist who was somehow never recognized as such by the masses. Oh - and that "tiny shift" into verse two was a hihat "bark" - Neil Peart doing his best Bernard Purdie. Anyway, thanks again!
Sounds effortless, but is anything but. Probably the least appreciated thing about them. Many of their peers in the biz have commented over the years that they're probably the hardest working band in rock music. We all like to sit back and enjoy and profess their talent, but Neil even commented on this saying; "I wasn't talented, but I was relentless". ..modesty for sure, but their effort of perfecting their craft can't be understated.
Rush is one of the greatest if not the greatest rock trios ever. Masters of their instruments. I've seen them live several times and that was the proof of just how talented they are. RIP Neil!
I as a Rush fan , feel very glad that someone that just know and heard bout rush turns into a fan . Congratulations !!! Now you know the best rock you can ever listen to .
Notice how the bass drum hits right on the vocals in the verse and pre-chorus. Peart, the drummer, wrote the lyrics and waxes (waxed, RIP) eloquently on how rhythmic and percussive good vocals are.
I've never gleaned anything from a reaction video before, but you brought a different ear to Rush, your comment on Geddy's diction, I've never realized that before, but it brings so much to the way the words sound. More than that, you adore Rush the way I do! A joy to watch you experience this song for the first time, wish I could go back and do the same.
So glad you've become smitten by the Rush bug! Welcome to the family! The song Tom Sawyer is their most universally popular. Brilliant lyrics, precise and powerful musicianship, an incredible mix and wonderfully structured. Yes, Geddy, as well as the rest of the band, made the practically impossible seem effortless. Geddy somehow managed to pull off the vocal intonations, range, and phrasing while playing the most compelling and complex bass lines and movements. Oh, and he did it while simultaneously playing keyboard parts. Greatness. All of it. Enjoy!
I grew up listening to Rush but didn’t really get into the album Power Windows and newer. Last year I started listening to the entire collection of Rush songs while driving. Surprisingly I can’t stop playing Rush when I drive. I tried putting on other music, but I’m finding most other music boring now. I keep going back to Rush and never get tired of it. The music is so complex and multi-layered, you can focus on different parts each time you listen. There is so much there and I just don’t get tired of it. Neil’s drumming is so incredible. I love the constant timing changes through out the songs.
Same as you, I quite drew a line at Power Windows but recently for the recommendation of a younger fan I listened to the album again and I was really surprised. There's a lot to love there too!
Great review! It is so gratifying to see someone have the same reaction that we had some 40 years ago when this music came out. That is what makes RUSH such masters of this music.
WOW! What a fantastic way to start a new Monday & workweek……you enjoying & breaking down likely the most listened to (and attempted to properly play on drums) song of mine from the band & music I have most adored for my entire life(.) Thank you, Bethany, I think I love you! 🥰
I 😍😍😍 how enamored Bethany has become with RUSH! As a Canadian fan I'm a bit biased, but Rush is fairly universally recognized as one of the greatest 3-piece bands of all time, with arguably the greatest rock drummer of all time. (RIP Neal Peart) I could (and possibly have 😁) watch this reaction video a dozen times, and still enjoy every genuine reaction. This is music appreciation at its best!
Watching this video was pure fun! Your face, your eyes said it all! I know, they're great, aren't they! This song is awesomely great, ever since I heard it back in the '80s!! Rush is pure virtuosity, they're legends!!! Good thing their music is still listened to and admired by new generations! All the best!
I'd like to suggest your next Rush song, when you do get aroud to more, "Losing It", from my second favorite Rush album, "Signals". This is a song with an incredible electric violin solo, never played live until Rush was on their final tour, absolutely brilliant song!
I was just thinking the same thing. There aren't many songs from Rush that I do not like...but that is absolutely one of my favorites and definitely a got to.
@@michaelzilkowsky2936 Really? Well, to start, the lyrics, they touch on no longer being able to do the things from youth, or no longer having the drive/inspiration. Then there's the electric violin solo, building from a melodic start to a blistering frenzy while Neil up's the complexity of the drum part. Finally, Alex taking up the violin melody on guitar, extending it until it finally drops off with the foreshadowing line, we all will face, "the bell tolls for thee" outro...
One of my all time favorite bands. I bought tickets to see them at the Topeka Municipal Auditorium in 1979, and as much a fan as I was there was no convincing me that they could reproduce their intricate sound in a live environment, when I walked out of the auditorium that night I was a fan for life. To this day when I watch the interviews and studio sets I am in awe of their craftsmanship.
honestly, what I love about this videos is watching you got sucked down the same “rabbit hole” that I did with Rush and Exit Stage left that made me a super fan.
You need to take off those ear buds and experience Rush or any rock band with 5.1 or a decent stereo system. The bass booming in your head and Neil’s. Kick drum 🥁 thumping in your chest is something to experience next😊❤ keep the great reactions.
Yes they did this live and in concert. 3 guys. Time signature changes and on and on...Extremely talented! ALL OF THEM. Blows me away that so many people dislike Rush. Dullards!
So funny that you are finally listening to the true gateway drug for most Rush addicts! I was a fan before this song/album, but the majority of Rush fans I know came on board with Moving Pictures and, specifically, this song. Welcome to our club, you are a most welcomed addition. I am going to suggest two songs for you. Not so much for analysis, but just because the voices are so good and the songs so emotive. Foreigner's Two Different Worlds has Lou truly emoting and showing some good range. ruclips.net/video/PV35YHQ13CM/видео.html&start_radio=1&ab_channel=Foreigner-Topic As to Holly McNarland, since you did the Cranberries the other day, there is something about her voice.somewhat reminds me of Dolores and Alanis mixed together. ruclips.net/video/Khuj8cU831g/видео.html&ab_channel=HollyMcNarland-Topic Thank you again for your wonderful content.
I love 💕 when people who never heard this music before hear it for the first time. I kinda envy you. I'm 66 years old now and I have seen these guys twice. Amazing!
" I feel like I need a nap after that one " ... how appropriate . Your broad vocabulary along with your dreamy characterizations are ...like RUSH ... CLASSIC .
I’ve watched a few of your reactions to some of my favorite songs starting with toxicity, one, down in a hole, cemetery gates and this one! Appreciate your reactions. I have a whole list of songs like these from the 80s and 90s that you probably haven’t heard that are gold!
Their musicianship is of the charts. This song isn't the most complicated because there are tracks way more difficult to proces. I listen to Rush since I was 8 years old and I can still remember when I heard the trees for the first time. Not only the music but the lyrics have so many layers. Loved you reaction! ❤
The drummer is known as one of the best ever to play drum. RIP Neil
The favourite drummer of your favourite drummer
And an even better poet and lyricist.
No, he IS the best, GOAT! He's your favourite drummer's drummer.
Yes. The professor was the GOAT.
How many drummers does it take to change a lightbulb?
Four. One to change it & the other three to tell him how much better Neil Peart would have done it.
Grew up in Toronto during this era and when this hit the airwaves? Nothing else mattered, we ate it up like best candy ever made. And do you know what? That candy taste just as good today as it did back then...
the best Canadian band in the history.
Hands down. No doubt about it.
Every song on Rush Moving Pictures is pure awesomeness and worth checking out for those who are new to Rush 😊
The whole album is absolutely amazing.
@@NoneYaBidness762 💯 % Agree 👍
Rush has such a unique style and sound that I can’t listen for hours and hours
@@EHudson1961 Same here 😀👍
I heard this song on the radio, had no idea who Rush was (I was pretty young), but it was instant love. I had to keep listening to the radio to catch the artist and name of the album (there was no internet in the early 80s!). I immediately went our and bought the Cassette! I later upgraded to the CD, which I STILL have (long since ripped into MP3s on all my devices.
The Professor on drums. Life lessons I learned from him . #1 be humble. #2 never let praise go to your head .#3 do the best you can
❤
And #4 skip the interviews and go for a bike ride.
And try to read every great book that's ever been written
That's why he's number 1
Good for you man..Cosmic Man🐝🌹🌈
"He knows changes aren't permanent, but change is" - brilliant! ❤
You realize Neil paraphrased that from the Greek philosopher Heraclitus? He took lines from John Donne, Ernest Hemingway and others to use in Rush’s lyrics. I agree he was a great lyricist but Neil loved to read and I don’t think a lot of people know he lifted lines from others to use in their songs.
@@mr.e8432 All the world's indeed a stage and we are merely players, performers and portrayers, each another's audience outside the gilded cage. - Neil Peart
All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players;
They have their exits and their entrances;
And one man in his time plays many parts.
- William Shakespeare
Not bad for a drummer
@@mr.e8432and you realize if you really want to critique such things go a great deal of artists use lines from other works also movies do it a lot as well. But a good line is a good line most people just enjoy it for what it is.
@@mr.e8432 Of the things you'll see or hear in this life - how many, in some way, aren't 'borrowed'?
As a female Rush fan, I am so happy to see you experience them and the enjoyment you convey is a reminder of how I felt when I found them in 2011. Got to see them 3 times and they were so fantastic. Keep up the good work 😄
I know, as a woman, none of my other female friends love rush, so this makes me really happy. 😂❤
Same here...I have always loved RUSH...one of the best rock bands, ever!!! 💗💗💗
I love seeing someone "get" RUSH. Welcome to the club!
That was exactly what I was thinking!
I had a friend in high school hated them but he came across a free ticket to the Power windows Tour saw him after leaving the Stadium and he Ran up too me and Said Holly Crap I can see why Rush is your Fave Band. Next day was a Sunday and again seen him at Checkout buying every Rush Album the Store had. Even more Massive Sound live especially in Prime.
"Getting" Rush is an experience in itself. Once you "get" it, you're hooked (probably) for ever. Welcome to the club (as @friedricerocket rightfully mentioned). Rush IS something else.
Well Said, once you get it you're in a new world.
Rush is absolutely incredible.
'Red Barchetta' is one of my personal favourites.
Thank you for highlighting this Canadian masterpiece. One of my favourite bands live and, despite seeing it repeatedly with my own eyes, it’s hard to believe all this sound comes from three guys. They deserve all the respect.
This was phenomenal when it first came out. I’ve listened to this song hundreds, maybe thousands of times over the years and I enjoy it every time.
Well said my friend 🤘🏼
That is RUSH hitting forth gear. You are sexy, not trying to be creepy, just sayin. RUSH is a phenomenal band! Especially live. They were famous for the 3 of them being able to reproduce their albums live with no cheating. I saw 18 of their tours over the decades! RUSH was special, that’s the easiest way to describe them, RUSH is special. See ya later sexy lady! 😁👍
Only Canadians would bring up Canada. Seriously are you tgat threatened?
@miami3234 right... like Americans aren't letting everyone know every 5 seconds that they are American.
RUSH is THE PERFECT EXAMPLE of the fluidity of MASTERING TIME SIGNATURES! I play drums and there are a few things that you need to know about Neil Peart’s ( pronounced PEER-T) character: First he writes the lyrics so he knows in advance what TYPE of song it’s meant to be ie ballad, driver, etc. Second he COMPOSES on the drums… like a carpenter who looks at a set of blueprints before building the object. Neil lays out a SKETCH in his mind of the VOICES of the drumset and builds the song from there. He is also a great LISTENER knowing when NOT to step over Geddy’s singing or Alex’s solos! Finally, he had perfect timing and fluidity of time changes. He said himself that it’s not about COUNTING the time signatures as much as fluid motion to change the tempo without counting: in other words it should FLOW! He hates repeating the same drum patterns in the same song meaning if he plays a fill one way the first time around he will play it differently the second time around. IE. Rolls down the toms the first time around and triplets or quads (all four limbs) the second time around. In short there will NEVER be another like him on planet earth 🌍 🌏 🌎! REST IN PEACE PROFESSOR!
With heart felt admiration and sincerity!
Gary
Excelente aporte estimado. Gracias.!
Oh, yes!!!! 💗💗💗
People argue as to whether he was the best drummer ever but has any drummer ever contributed so much to a group as highly regarded, as successful as RUSH? If you look at him in totality, I don't think there is a question as to whether he's the best.
This is the best reaction I have been a Rush fan 45 years and seeing your smile while your listening in awe made my day
Her smile is fabulous, isn't it? I'm sure it lights up huge rooms just as Rush's music brings to the same room's ears.... Wow!!!
Isn’t she just so full of life❤
And know you know,pass it on...your never the same
I love how a 3 piece band like Rush can make so much sound there’s so much going that you need to listen over and over to take everything in
Triumph were right there with them. 3 piece with a whole lotta sound going on
I always thought this exact thing. How can 3 guys rock so fukn hard
Rush is that band that you've never heard of anything like them before and you never will again. They're one of a kind!
Also, one of the best drummers ever! RIP Neil Peart!!!
One of the best drummers/guitarist/bassist/and yes I think one of the best vocalists
I’m an old guy now, and was a teenager in the 70’s when they started. Lots of great music came from the 70’s and 80’s, but anyone who appreciated talent KNEW Rush was something special. Just 3 guys rocking… all 3 guys were considered ’nerds’ back then because they were extremely smart and talented, and didn’t party like rock stars. They would sit around and enjoy a great glass of wine instead… !
👌🤣🤣🤣
Mentioning that "shift" early on, and not being a "percussionist", you're starting to dial-in on the greatness of Neil Peart. His ability to initiate time shifts is legendary, and the part that throws most people off is that it's seamless and flawless. Great reaction to their signature song. A little known fact....Geddy HATED this song the first time they did it. RIP Neil.
Speaking of time shifts, the whole solo section is in 7/8.
Two t's
Yeah, I can imagine Geddy not liking it. lol But what a trooper!
I can’t get enough of her!!!!! Just loving her reactions
Especially her face and attention....SO FOCUSED! 😊
She's Gorgeous
Rush combines intricate craftsmanship with feeling good. There something ‘good’ about them. Nice to feel that in this harsh environment these days.
It’s hilarious watching you fangirl so hard on Rush, I absolutely LOVE that you’ve discovered them and they’re making such a great impression on you! I’ve been a fan since I was in middle school and always felt so many of their lyrics and music really spoke to me as an angst ridden GenXer.
Unfortunately Neil passed not too long ago, so Rush as we know it has ended its journey, but the music we have is so timeless and motivating, I will love it until the end of my days.
Try listening to “Territories” off of “Power Windows”, or “Distant Early Warning” off of “Grace Under Pressure”. Not their big hits, but brilliant songs and lyrics.
Keep up the fan-girling, and welcome to the Rush community. ❤
I love that you are re-visting Rush, this is a DEEP rabbit hole! One of the most amazing things about Rush is the way they move between time signatures; you may not even have noticed for example the bridge section into the guitar solo changed to 7/8, so effortlessly and without the listener being jolted or having to re-sync their foot tapping on the down beat... ;-)
Definitely; there's a through line in all their songs, even when they're changing times signatures, that makes it easy to follow along. That's one of the genius things about them, and why I've loved listening to them ever since I heard 2112...
Amazing. Good song
I've seen this band live more than any other. Rush was great every single time, 3 man band, every one a consumate professional. I love watching your eyes and expressions listening to these ironic bands. Thank you. I remember my friend who was a drummer and I sneaking past security to get into a section before one show...directly above and behind the set. Looking down at Neil's drum kit..wow and out at the crowd waiting for Rush to come out... we were chased out, but I'll never forget that sight and the sound quality of their shows. Miss you, Neil and my friend Adam aka: " Ammo", Army Airborne Ranger.
"His mind is not for rent to any god or government.."
Always really liked that line.
Tom Sawyer did not get the jab. He was busy driving his Red Barchetta, which the jabbers want to ban, just like in the song.
How is that free health care and open borders working for everyone?
Neil was a fan of Ayn Rand so some of her ideas made their way into the lyrics.
I agree.
So relevant now
The rare mix of three virtuoso musical genius' who stayed and played together for 40+ years.
You cant go wrong with analyzing a Rush song. I still get amused watching you react to Closer To The Heart, your first time with Rush. A couple of great Rush songs for vocals are The Trees and Spirit Of Radio. Another great video, Bethany
The Trees is hands down one of my favorites! As is the entire 2112 album… too many great songs to name!
@@mattdye2870 Absolutely. I was trying to think of songs where the vocals stand out. If we are talking about the music then nothing beats La Villa Strangiato or some of their more epic early stuff like 2112. However, 2112 is a very long song with lots of instrumental sections so maybe not the best for vocal analysis. Same with Xanadu, a real masterpiece but it's only got vocals for about 2 minutes of the 8 or 9 minutes of the song.
I have always wanted to see "The Trees" live...but never did, and never will. One of my all time favorites.
@@fishermanmitch1I was lucky enough to see them on five different tours starting with Moving pictures. They did The Trees for that tour, Signals and Power Windows. I miss seeing them live
Don't forget Red Barchetta
These guys had a career unparalleled in scope, covering 4 + decades. They evolved their sound constantly with each studio album and song. You could spend the rest of your life finding new ways to appreciate what these guys made and shared so expertly.
As usual I loved loved your analysis along with the vocals/bass/synth of Geddy and that guitar of Alex. But, watching the young Neil Peart at work on those drums brought a genuine tear to my eye. Missed so badly.
I hear ya. I miss him too and I never even met him.
As a Rush fan, i marvel at your enjoyment of this track. I don't get to see enough women finding something to value in their music. The joy i got in watching a female geekout over a Rush tune is the most amazing part of this video. I will be watching this video once a week, until i leave this world. Thank you very very much!!
I upvote your comment crunchyfrog! Indeed it is refreshing.
I think I'm falling in love with her!
Huge Rush fan here!! I saw them twice back in the day, owned every album they put out, and was inspired by Mr Peart to become a drummer. ❤
I’ve never met a woman who didn’t like RUSH!
I'm a woman and Rush has been my favorite band for 40 years! I absolutely love them and will geek out over them with anyone I get the chance to!
The sound three musicians make is incredible ! Play so tight and perfect
Neil Pert is the GOAT (Greatest of all time) of all drummers ever. RIP Neil. Rush is a great band. They have so many more songs. I look forward to more RUSH
Yep!!!! 💗💗💗
Incredible when it came out 40+ years ago. Still amazing! Thank you!
Great music stands the test of time
Wow! A female Rush fan and one that actually refers to their music as "beautiful" !! I was just browsing around RUclips and there you were. This video popped up in my feed, likely because I'm a huge Rush fan (and from their home town - Willowdale Ontario (Go Canada!), a drummer, guitar player and singer - singer third as I'm by no means as pro as you. I loved all you said about this song and the band and I ended up staying up most of the night watching your channel. Yes, hours and hours. I love how emotional you get watching and listening to music that gets me emotional! I got double slammed emotionally because of your emotions. John Farnham, The Voice, you with tears in your eyes and me sobbing here like a kid! Your videos are great GREAT!. I don't know you but you somehow feel like a long lost friend all of a sudden. I'm a fan - Thanks Bethany, I'll keep watching. Oh and while you're on your Canadian kick, check out Kim Mitchell - his solo stuff and his old band Max Webster.
I'm also a big fan of Rush! ❤❤❤
There's more of us female Rush fans than you think! I've loved them for 40 years!
This song was my "gateway drug" into Rush right after this album came out when I was in high school! After hearing this, I went out and got into everything they'd done to that point, and have been a huge fan ever since. Rush became my spirit animal and still is!! Saw them live 3 times in around 2010/2011. Wish I had seen them more!
I seen this Tour age 13. My fave band from 80-88
Her face is priceless. First, enjoying the music, as the solo starts, she starts smiling, goes on wider, full teeth smile, Neil fills = mind blown
One of my all time favorite songs!....ever! Love your channel!!!
@8:14, that little pointy lip smile, _ADORABLE._ A woman who appreciates Rush's genius is rare in my world.
Your reaction to Rush at first time got me hooked and this reaction was also great to watch and great to experience your reaction. Thanks and keep it going, greetings from Finland!
That "sound" you heard the drummer make was on an open high hat (closed quickly) with a simultaneous kick bass drum (which coincides with the open high hat note). For those who've not tried Neil Peart's high hat/bass drum technique, it looks like it should be simple, but it's devilishly hard for all but the best drummers (I'm not great, so it's a struggle), and it was one of his numerous innovations in the way he composed and performed accents for the music.
Your first comment says it all, I was also swept away forever after hearing Rush. Great reaction and analysis.
Sure this is a "vocal" channel but never feel bad about reacting to music! A vocalist, bass player, percussionist etc is nothing without responding to the sonic landscape around themselves. So we LOVE when you appreciate the music!!! I've watched this several times just because it's an intelligent true reaction that makes me feel good! lol
Now that is how you start a Monday! I love watching your video deconstructions. Being able to learn new things from a song I've enjoyed since its release in 1981 was a real treat. Thank you!
I absolutely love your love of this song, and Rush. Maybe the best technical band, and the composition of their songs is unparalleled.
Three of the most talented musicians. Alex is a superb guitarist and
In Neil they had one of the best percussionists of all time.
And Geddy has a unique and instantly recognisable voice that was made for the music and vice versa.
I love how irreverent they could be with time signatures.
One of my favourite bands.
Thanks for an invested and involved reaction
There can’t be many bands where all of the members have won readers polls in instrument specific magazines (such as Guitar Player, Modern Drummer, Bass Player). Maybe Yes. Maybe The Police. I can’t think of anyone else (Zeppelin?)
@@tomfabozzi5353 I agree 100% . Led Zeppelin, for sure, are another stand out band. It's in the live arena where these bands truly come to the fore. Masters of their art indeed
@@AManCalledMooseRush and Zep were musical craftsmen!
I LOVE your reactions
Was lucky enough to see them live 3 times in Toronto they were fantastic.
so im 39 from uk when i was 13 14 i played drums in school a teacher there told me about a band called rush told me i might like the drummer now 20 odd years on i listen to rush everyday i love them ive seen in once in Manchester uk in 2007 seeing mr peart play drums was unreal if u see this mr jones from school thanks for showing me the best band ever
Keep going,good luck
Don’t apologize for stopping, Bethany. That’s why we’re here: for your insights.
I absolutely love your enthusiasm and attention to specific details! ..us fellow musicians share this same passionate love 🧡🎶
Me too! Much appreciated… and insightful.
Gotta agree with that too
the production of this record is flawless, the producer, terry brown is a genius. I was 13 when this record came out which really put rush on the center stage. they've been the soundtrack of my life. great job on your part :)
Keep up the excellent work on your channel Johnny
Supreme musicianship and a message to boot. Painting a picture. Describing the ideal world, a better life for all.
And you are right. There’s a lot to take in with Rush. The melodies and rhythms are a mesh of time signatures and counterpoint that is hard to imagine. And yet so very beautiful to hear.
Neil is my favourite percussionist, the bass from Geddy is incredible, it’s very difficult to hear a bass play this strong in many songs, Rush’s songs bring out every instrument involved so you hear it. Alexis guitar takes you on a journey. 3 man band sounds like a 5 man band, so talented and loved everywhere they go. Such great people who love what they do and the fans that love it as well.
I first saw Rush on the 2112 tour, having already bought 'Rush', 'Fly by Night', and 'Caress of Steel'... and have been an avid (or rabid) fan ever since. I watch a lot of 'reaction' videos and you are one of my first stops. My three favorite bands of all time are AC/DC, Pink Floyd, and RUSH !!!! I absolutely adore your reactions to the really exquisite music that I was raised on throughout the 70s and 80s. When you listen, and we see that beautiful authentic smile.... it warms my heart, knowing that there are generations that will keep this 'old rock and roll' music alive for centuries, not unlike Beethoven and Mozart... Thanks Bethany... :)
"That", I love that little drum transition too. Very observant. Smart lady!
5:16 I think the most hilarious thing about Geddy Lee is that since RUclips started I have seen dozens of vocal experts praising Geddy Lee , when ironically people who say they hate Rush state that it’s his voice they hate.
Every period, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, is a reflection of the music they were listening to. The music that inspired them influenced the music they created. By this point, it was The Police, Ultravox, Talking Heads, etc. "All this machinery making modern music ..."
YES
"All this machinery making modern music", reminds me that Bethany should listen to and react to Spirit of Radio by RUSH. The musicianship, time signature changes and lyrics are sure to blow her away
2024 and you had not listened to Rush!???? This is one of the most badass songs ever. Fell in love with them in 1982 high school electronics class, with the rest of the nerds. Still nerding out and loving it. Thanks for bringing this to the (ahem) younger audience. Love your videos--great work!
I don't remember what I said in my comment on your "Limelight" reaction from maybe a year ago (!), but I do think I remember using the word "effortless." There is an apparent ease in his transitions and this gorgeous sonority in his midrange. Another thing, which I never see or hear mentioned by anyone, is the effortlessness (that word again) in his vibrato during this period - and the fact that he always seemed to be able to use it in just the right places (""His reserve a quiet defense," "The river," "What you say about society," etc.) There is a prime example of that instinct and ability on "Vital Signs." When he sings the phrase, "Can only be worn by persistence," he kind of accents the word "persistence" with this beautiful trilly vibrato, which adds so much - to the extent that, when I heard the song live and he sang the phrase without that vibrato, I was disappointed, because I felt that it was so integral to that vocal performance.
Also, he is the frigging Prime Minister of diphthongs, but that's another topic altogether.
These are things most people probably don't think about, even Rush fans. But I do, because, though I'm not a "singa" (as Owl Jolson might say), I do so love vocals and vocalists.
Glad to have heard an analysis of this track from you. I felt this was Geddy's voice at its best. It still had range and flexibility, but by this point, it also had a richness and maturity which came with age and experience. A legitimately great vocalist who was somehow never recognized as such by the masses.
Oh - and that "tiny shift" into verse two was a hihat "bark" - Neil Peart doing his best Bernard Purdie.
Anyway, thanks again!
Sounds effortless, but is anything but. Probably the least appreciated thing about them. Many of their peers in the biz have commented over the years that they're probably the hardest working band in rock music. We all like to sit back and enjoy and profess their talent, but Neil even commented on this saying; "I wasn't talented, but I was relentless". ..modesty for sure, but their effort of perfecting their craft can't be understated.
@@Nanooky Agreed, but I was saying that aspects of his singing *sounded* effortless back then. I believe that Bethany also said as much.
@@sethcashman1011 No refute.. I just wanted to add to what you already said.
Welcome to the Rush rabbit hole. There is so much more of their brilliance to discover
Rush is one of the greatest if not the greatest rock trios ever. Masters of their instruments. I've seen them live several times and that was the proof of just how talented they are. RIP Neil!
I as a Rush fan , feel very glad that someone that just know and heard bout rush turns into a fan . Congratulations !!! Now you know the best rock you can ever listen to .
Notice how the bass drum hits right on the vocals in the verse and pre-chorus. Peart, the drummer, wrote the lyrics and waxes (waxed, RIP) eloquently on how rhythmic and percussive good vocals are.
I've never gleaned anything from a reaction video before, but you brought a different ear to Rush, your comment on Geddy's diction, I've never realized that before, but it brings so much to the way the words sound. More than that, you adore Rush the way I do! A joy to watch you experience this song for the first time, wish I could go back and do the same.
So glad you've become smitten by the Rush bug! Welcome to the family! The song Tom Sawyer is their most universally popular. Brilliant lyrics, precise and powerful musicianship, an incredible mix and wonderfully structured. Yes, Geddy, as well as the rest of the band, made the practically impossible seem effortless. Geddy somehow managed to pull off the vocal intonations, range, and phrasing while playing the most compelling and complex bass lines and movements. Oh, and he did it while simultaneously playing keyboard parts. Greatness. All of it. Enjoy!
It's an indescribable treat to hear you say "golly" while reacting to Tom Sawyer. Thank you.
Thank you so much for your reaction and analysis!! They are my favourite of all the channels.
She’s so beautiful with such a pleasant voice.
I grew up listening to Rush but didn’t really get into the album Power Windows and newer. Last year I started listening to the entire collection of Rush songs while driving. Surprisingly I can’t stop playing Rush when I drive. I tried putting on other music, but I’m finding most other music boring now. I keep going back to Rush and never get tired of it. The music is so complex and multi-layered, you can focus on different parts each time you listen. There is so much there and I just don’t get tired of it. Neil’s drumming is so incredible. I love the constant timing changes through out the songs.
Same as you, I quite drew a line at Power Windows but recently for the recommendation of a younger fan I listened to the album again and I was really surprised. There's a lot to love there too!
It took me a little while to finally get PW too. It was Hold Your Fire for me. Their worst album imo, but I like all the other albums
Great review! It is so gratifying to see someone have the same reaction that we had some 40 years ago when this music came out. That is what makes RUSH such masters of this music.
WOW! What a fantastic way to start a new Monday & workweek……you enjoying & breaking down likely the most listened to (and attempted to properly play on drums) song of mine from the band & music I have most adored for my entire life(.)
Thank you, Bethany, I think I love you! 🥰
I 😍😍😍 how enamored Bethany has become with RUSH! As a Canadian fan I'm a bit biased, but Rush is fairly universally recognized as one of the greatest 3-piece bands of all time, with arguably the greatest rock drummer of all time. (RIP Neal Peart)
I could (and possibly have 😁) watch this reaction video a dozen times, and still enjoy every genuine reaction. This is music appreciation at its best!
Yes Rush🤘. You’ve opened the worm hole now and I hope to see a reaction video to 2112!
Bethany, I have been a Rush fan for 45 years. To see you "getting" them and to hear your analysis brings a tear to my eye! Thank you for sharing.
Watching this video was pure fun! Your face, your eyes said it all! I know, they're great, aren't they! This song is awesomely great, ever since I heard it back in the '80s!! Rush is pure virtuosity, they're legends!!! Good thing their music is still listened to and admired by new generations! All the best!
Another Rush fan is born ❤
Geddy's bass play on Tom Sawyer is badass , these guy's are tight . I found them in the 70's & rite off the VOLUME went MAX .
RUSH....One of A Kind 🎸 🥁 🎤 🌟 ⭐ 🌠
Watching you experience Tom Swayer for the first time is a joy to behold. One of rock's greatest songs by a band that were so tight.
I'd like to suggest your next Rush song, when you do get aroud to more, "Losing It", from my second favorite Rush album, "Signals". This is a song with an incredible electric violin solo, never played live until Rush was on their final tour, absolutely brilliant song!
I saw FM open for them in 1980 or 1981; what a great opening band…no one should have to follow Rush on stage 😏
I was just thinking the same thing. There aren't many songs from Rush that I do not like...but that is absolutely one of my favorites and definitely a got to.
"absolutely brilliant song"
what is brilliant? Be specific.
@@michaelzilkowsky2936 Really? Well, to start, the lyrics, they touch on no longer being able to do the things from youth, or no longer having the drive/inspiration. Then there's the electric violin solo, building from a melodic start to a blistering frenzy while Neil up's the complexity of the drum part. Finally, Alex taking up the violin melody on guitar, extending it until it finally drops off with the foreshadowing line, we all will face, "the bell tolls for thee" outro...
One of the best reactions i've seen... love your interpretations comment and vibe
Bethany, level with us. You just wanted to listen to some Rush today!😂
One of my all time favorite bands. I bought tickets to see them at the Topeka Municipal Auditorium in 1979, and as much a fan as I was there was no convincing me that they could reproduce their intricate sound in a live environment, when I walked out of the auditorium that night I was a fan for life. To this day when I watch the interviews and studio sets I am in awe of their craftsmanship.
Fly by night...Please, can't wait...Todd from Ohio...
honestly, what I love about this videos is watching you got sucked down the same “rabbit hole” that I did with Rush and Exit Stage left that made me a super fan.
You need to take off those ear buds and experience Rush or any rock band with 5.1 or a decent stereo system. The bass booming in your head and Neil’s. Kick drum 🥁 thumping in your chest is something to experience next😊❤ keep the great reactions.
Yes they did this live and in concert. 3 guys. Time signature changes and on and on...Extremely talented! ALL OF THEM. Blows me away that so many people dislike Rush. Dullards!
I'd like to hear your thoughts on The Camera Eye by Rush
The greatest drummer to ever live on planet earth. RIP Neal Peart
next one from Rush - Red Sector A ( with lyric ) song about holocaust . Geddy Lee parents was survive to holocaust . Neil Peart deep lyric . 😎👍🎶🎶
She’s so sweet. I hope Geddy and Lerxt are sitting back listening to this. All the intricacies of play is now finally being appreciated.
So funny that you are finally listening to the true gateway drug for most Rush addicts! I was a fan before this song/album, but the majority of Rush fans I know came on board with Moving Pictures and, specifically, this song. Welcome to our club, you are a most welcomed addition.
I am going to suggest two songs for you. Not so much for analysis, but just because the voices are so good and the songs so emotive.
Foreigner's Two Different Worlds has Lou truly emoting and showing some good range. ruclips.net/video/PV35YHQ13CM/видео.html&start_radio=1&ab_channel=Foreigner-Topic
As to Holly McNarland, since you did the Cranberries the other day, there is something about her voice.somewhat reminds me of Dolores and Alanis mixed together. ruclips.net/video/Khuj8cU831g/видео.html&ab_channel=HollyMcNarland-Topic
Thank you again for your wonderful content.
Welcome to the club! 😊 RUSH is an ever-changing, ever reaching search for something more or different. Awesome indeed!
I love 💕 when people who never heard this music before hear it for the first time. I kinda envy you. I'm 66 years old now and I have seen these guys twice. Amazing!
" I feel like I need a nap after that one " ... how appropriate . Your broad vocabulary along with your dreamy characterizations are ...like RUSH ... CLASSIC .
I’ve watched a few of your reactions to some of my favorite songs starting with toxicity, one, down in a hole, cemetery gates and this one! Appreciate your reactions. I have a whole list of songs like these from the 80s and 90s that you probably haven’t heard that are gold!
Everyone loves this Godess, talking about one of our favorite bands❤ Gotta luv it !!! Just can’t scroll by !!!
I saw Rush live 4 times , they were one of those bands that sounded exactly like the studio recording. You nailed this!
Thank you Bethany, it is a complete joy to watch your videos. I have gotten more and more into Rush myself and can't stop.
You’ll never hear a better Drummer than Neil Peart. RUSH is Magnificent!
As a Rush fan for over 40 years I'm just so happy to know their music will always reach the youth. Also.......RIP Professor 🥁
Their talent is overwhelming!! I am so fortunate to have grown up on their music.
Their musicianship is of the charts. This song isn't the most complicated because there are tracks way more difficult to proces. I listen to Rush since I was 8 years old and I can still remember when I heard the trees for the first time. Not only the music but the lyrics have so many layers. Loved you reaction! ❤
The most beautiful new fan for rush. Thanks for that one.