Maybe, but I think it's a pretty good list and the qbs are all where they should be relative to each other. Madden just won't give these overalls because that's not how their ranking system works, even though I think these ratings would be almost perfect for Madden given the current state if affairs
Back in the day, a high 70s overall was considered TERRIBLE, and it’s decent today. So he is being generous for how they do ratings today, but on the older maddens that he grew up on these would be accurate
5:27 - They changed the system almost entirely for Jake. Our offensive system has been “good luck Joe” where we go shotgun almost every play and air it almost every play. Defenses recognize this and play for the pass. This causes everything for the plays to happen between Joe’s ears. For Jake (while he played exceptionally) we ran the ball sooo much more. We went under center, into pistol, had multiple TE sets, etc. This forced the defense to respect the run and no longer made us extremely predictable. Jake was good, and I’d love to see him get a chance somewhere… but it was not even close to the same system 😂
@GoBucs0221 I was being sarcastic, I know Wyatt doesn't like carr 😂. Bucs fan, I see. This is good now. We can all make fun of the falcons together. Carr will go to the sb
@@kevinuchiha6830😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 It’s so funny seeing how hard you try. Faints vs Los Angeles Mahomes,🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Faints are nothing without Brees, Chargers can’t get it done with all these stars on their team😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Howell will start over Geno eventually and his talents will be realized once he has a line that isn’t bottom 5. Also I don’t think Lamar led in a single QB stat (could be wrong) and hurts is painfully average surrounded by one of, if not the best supporting cast. 😬
I agree with all those points Hurts has a great team kinda like jimmy but people act like it’s all him when he can’t do what Mahomes did Sam Howell has been solid!
I don’t know a single person who doesn’t kiss Josh Allen ass for everything Besides his turnover problem he’s praised for everything Unless I missed something
I still remember from a couple of seasons ago when everyone was saying it was criminal to say that Josh Allen was a better quarterback than Jalen Hurts, and now here we are in 2024 where that isn’t even an opinion anymore, it’s just a fact. Not only that, but Lamar will still never be as good as Josh Allen no matter how many shiny awards the league gifts him. It’s all within the details, and obviously ones at that.
Top 10 QB Madden Ratings 1. Mahomes 99 2. Allen 97 3. Burrow 95 4. Dak/Herbert 94 5. Goff 92 6. Lamar 91 7. C.J Stroud 90 8. Purdy 89 9. Cousins 87 10. Hurts 87 I can already see the Lamar pitchforkers incoming. Lamar got MVP sure. But he really shouldn’t have. That ravens defense was absolutely filthy this past season. If anything Lamar drastically underperformed considering how many times that defense got him the ball back. Lamar got the MVP solely off of W/L record. Not an Allen or Dak fan but one of them should’ve won the MVP.
100% agree on the Lamar take. I know this may seem biased but as a team that plays them twice a year, he is pretty inconsistent and some of his amazing stats are a result of stat padding or facing shit defenses. Not saying that's bad or anything but his stats are very inflated. Bengals and Browns fans can prolly also see this as well
Regular season wise, Lamar is pretty consistent. Stat wise you might say he’s inconsistent but actually watching the games the impact he has is impressive it’s just Gus Edwards got all the tds last year
In terms of MVPs, Lamar’s MVP this year was one of the weaker MVPs in recent memory. Stats compared to almost all other recent MVPs were incredibly mediocre, and it really did just feel like the “QB on the best team” award this year. I’m a Chiefs fan, and I thought Allen deserved it way more, if not Allen, then Dak
Lamar carries his team without a legit number one receiver his whole career, Still won two mvp's. People wanna bring up his playoff record and stats, yes it's not the best, took Peyton Manning year 9 to win one. But at the end of the day Lamar and Josh Allen have the same amount of rings 0. Both are great quarterbacks but Allen before Diggs was pretty average, let's see how he does without a legit number one receiver.
@@Aneeshtheraveyank In the last 8 games against us the Ravens are 1-7. Although 1 has been against their practice squad (injuries), what I've seen from Lamar is a lot of inconsistencies. We've also been hella injured in those games. Sure Derrick Henry is a beast but run first offenses will not work when yo are down and that's exactly what will happen to them in the playoffs.
Thanks for giving Brock a 90 Wyatt. People really sleep on his quarterback ability. I’m very happy as a niners fan to have him because it’s been a while since I was exited about a qb.
Probably but I just need to see another big year from him In order to Put him in the 90s, I for sure don’t think he’s a one season wonder I also just wanna see him put up some Good numbers against the best teams as he struggled a bit against Baltimore BUT If He can handle the pressure Again and play Really good again no doubt his in the low 90s atleast.
Oh 96 is a great rating for Lamar. Even as a Ravens fan AND a Louisville fan i can acknowledge him and Josh were pretty even last year. Lamar had bad moments, as did Josh. Both are incredible quarterbacks.
Hurts looked injured ever since the rams game last year, I'm counting on a bounce back year (also helps that we hopefully won't be throwing 15 bubble screens a game this year)
Bros is so generous 😂😂😂 if you look at 23 Madden rating he's giving qbs who had bad years like 5 overall higher than they were last year like waston and Ryan
wyatt, i agree with 99% of the stuff you say but rating dak a 91 and pointing out stats but then ranking Goff 92 point and pointing out his stats, is it just because Dak isn’t good in playoffs ?
@@storm7603 yeah I don’t agree with that either. The logic about only having the one good year kinda seems to get thrown out the window for people when it comes to Brock
hurts at 89 but herbert in the 90's is outrageous please tell me what herbert has done most overrated qb hurts had a terrible offensive coach and he wasnt fully healthy
Let's not act like Josh Allen is insanely better than Lamar in the playoffs because, besides the defense, Josh has had the better offense around him. Josh's stats also mean absolutely nothing because all those stats resulted in an L to Mahomes THREE TIMES.
I would still put Rodgers at a 90 I’d still put Brock @ an 88 Move Kirk down to an 89 I still think Matthew has to be a 90 til proven otherwise The biggest one of all: Tua is an 86 MAX
Wyatt I am a mahomes glazer. He is not a 99. Maybe a 97 but he had a career high int for him and only 27 tds. He was great in the playoffs but sometimes I wondered if it was really him on the field. He had barely any help though so that is also a factor.
True. In 2020 he led his Team to an 11-5 Record and win a playoff Game for them And then the next 2 years just kinda busted so we def need 2+ Above average years to put him in the top 15 convo
@@DebateBoyzPodcast Yep. His entire Browns career was one good year, one bad year and so on until he broke that streak with back2back bad years in Cleveland/Carolina. I do hope he can continue being a good QB from now on tho.
Wyatt you can’t give jarred goff, dak and Kirk a better rating then purdy he was the the runner up for mvp and had way better stats then all idk why he doesn’t get respect for leading the league in yards in the air distance
Wyatt went from Derek Carr supporter to Derek Carr hater faster than commenters saying “no views in 10 seconds, bro fell off”
Fr
These comments have gotten dry people really love making the same comments but you made it different i like that you get a like
Why is this so funny bruh 😭
@@vato3328Wyatt’s comment section is just filled with a bunch of 12 year old bots who copy comments
wait til he finds out about the clicked faster than comments
After madden releases their ratings, you should compare to your ratings to see the most over/underrated in the game.
Good video idea o think
Feel Like Wyatt’s being a big generous with his ratings honestly
Yeah madden does not give these type of ratings
Maybe, but I think it's a pretty good list and the qbs are all where they should be relative to each other. Madden just won't give these overalls because that's not how their ranking system works, even though I think these ratings would be almost perfect for Madden given the current state if affairs
Back in the day, a high 70s overall was considered TERRIBLE, and it’s decent today. So he is being generous for how they do ratings today, but on the older maddens that he grew up on these would be accurate
He's always generous with his ratings but sometimes if he doesn't like a guy he'll heavily underrate them
Damn Wyatt not gonna lie these ratings felt really really generous 😬😂
Putting Zach Wilson at a 99 is a bold take but I respect it
Totally man Zach Could probably Take on Brady Head to head and win And put up Devious Numbers 💀
@@DebateBoyzPodcastway better than brady
@@spidamitchell8311Your a casual. Zach Wilson is not just better than Brady, he's so good that he doesn't even have to play, GOAT fs
the browns started probably around 34 qbs last year, which is the amount of days i’ve been asking for the gfeul shake to return
5:27 - They changed the system almost entirely for Jake. Our offensive system has been “good luck Joe” where we go shotgun almost every play and air it almost every play. Defenses recognize this and play for the pass. This causes everything for the plays to happen between Joe’s ears. For Jake (while he played exceptionally) we ran the ball sooo much more. We went under center, into pistol, had multiple TE sets, etc. This forced the defense to respect the run and no longer made us extremely predictable. Jake was good, and I’d love to see him get a chance somewhere… but it was not even close to the same system 😂
Wyatt’s videos right after school always hit different, one of my favorite RUclipsrs🔥🔥🔥
real
real
I'm glad to see Wyatt not hating on Derek Carr. It's very nice to see 😂😂
When he said 81 overall I think he meant 18 overall😂. Apparently he’s gonna lead the Faints to a superbowl against the Los Angeles Mahomes😂
He called him garbage 💀💀💀
@KDGBSS1523 This guy, the saints will make the sb whether you like it or not. Panthers with no sb can not speak 😂. Fanthers are not good.
@GoBucs0221 I was being sarcastic, I know Wyatt doesn't like carr 😂. Bucs fan, I see. This is good now. We can all make fun of the falcons together. Carr will go to the sb
@@kevinuchiha6830😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It’s so funny seeing how hard you try. Faints vs Los Angeles Mahomes,🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Faints are nothing without Brees, Chargers can’t get it done with all these stars on their team😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m loving the ranking series. need more of these🙏🏾
"Buffalo fans call themselves the Bills mafia, how are you the mafia???, at least the mafia has a ring to kiss"
- Tom Brady
I love how u said jared goff, great speech for him ong
Howell will start over Geno eventually and his talents will be realized once he has a line that isn’t bottom 5. Also I don’t think Lamar led in a single QB stat (could be wrong) and hurts is painfully average surrounded by one of, if not the best supporting cast. 😬
I agree with all those points
Hurts has a great team kinda like jimmy but people act like it’s all him when he can’t do what Mahomes did
Sam Howell has been solid!
seahawks line had potential but gotta see how abe lucas health is and if the rookies can hold up
Petition For Wyyat To Give Backup QB’S There Madden Rating???
You should do Linebackers next :)
Finally someone give’s respect to my boy Josh Allen. Go Bills!!
I don’t know a single person who doesn’t kiss Josh Allen ass for everything
Besides his turnover problem he’s praised for everything
Unless I missed something
Giving Bo Nix a 99 is interesting but I’m alright with it
I still remember from a couple of seasons ago when everyone was saying it was criminal to say that Josh Allen was a better quarterback than Jalen Hurts, and now here we are in 2024 where that isn’t even an opinion anymore, it’s just a fact. Not only that, but Lamar will still never be as good as Josh Allen no matter how many shiny awards the league gifts him. It’s all within the details, and obviously ones at that.
Goff went from being a bust to a good 88+ overall.
In terms of his statistics and making it to a Super Bowl I don’t he was ever considered a bust
Love your video Wyatt and keep up the great work you are awesome
I can’t wait for burrow to prove himself this season, he needs a chip on his shoulder.
THANK YOU Wyatt for Giving Jared Goff a lot of Respect!!! I appreciate you for it.
Ngl it felt a little low he’s been statistically a top 5 qb the last 2 seasons and is top in almost every important qb category other than running
@@UrKidsMyVan1 Running Qbs don't last that long So you know what.... Im glad he's not a running qb because i don't want to get injured all the time.
He’s already got everything he’s wanted in life. Hot girlfriend, decent QB.
THE DISRESPECT FOR NOT EVEN RATING THE ITAYIN STAYIN IS FUCKING WILD
Video idea: Giving every first round rookie their Madden ratings. Maybe even do a few second rounders like our boy Keon Coleman
That Jared Goff thing had me dying 😂
Mahomes is way to high but thank you for the Goff respect
do offensive tackle , guard , and centers
Good list, but you should swap Justin Herbert and Brock Purdy
Top 10 QB Madden Ratings
1. Mahomes 99
2. Allen 97
3. Burrow 95
4. Dak/Herbert 94
5. Goff 92
6. Lamar 91
7. C.J Stroud 90
8. Purdy 89
9. Cousins 87
10. Hurts 87
I can already see the Lamar pitchforkers incoming.
Lamar got MVP sure. But he really shouldn’t have.
That ravens defense was absolutely filthy this past season. If anything Lamar drastically underperformed considering how many times that defense got him the ball back.
Lamar got the MVP solely off of W/L record.
Not an Allen or Dak fan but one of them should’ve won the MVP.
Goff over Lamar? What are we doing
im not even a raven fan, lamar at 91 is just ignorant
Lamar and allen at the same level is very good. was thinking you would put allen ahead but im happy that they are on the same level.
Another great video from WyattsGOAT
100% agree on the Lamar take. I know this may seem biased but as a team that plays them twice a year, he is pretty inconsistent and some of his amazing stats are a result of stat padding or facing shit defenses. Not saying that's bad or anything but his stats are very inflated. Bengals and Browns fans can prolly also see this as well
Regular season wise, Lamar is pretty consistent. Stat wise you might say he’s inconsistent but actually watching the games the impact he has is impressive it’s just Gus Edwards got all the tds last year
In terms of MVPs, Lamar’s MVP this year was one of the weaker MVPs in recent memory. Stats compared to almost all other recent MVPs were incredibly mediocre, and it really did just feel like the “QB on the best team” award this year. I’m a Chiefs fan, and I thought Allen deserved it way more, if not Allen, then Dak
This is literally biased. Watch Lamar average 40 points on ur team. Also ravens are a running team so Lamar doesn’t even need to do much on his own.
Lamar carries his team without a legit number one receiver his whole career, Still won two mvp's. People wanna bring up his playoff record and stats, yes it's not the best, took Peyton Manning year 9 to win one. But at the end of the day Lamar and Josh Allen have the same amount of rings 0. Both are great quarterbacks but Allen before Diggs was pretty average, let's see how he does without a legit number one receiver.
@@Aneeshtheraveyank In the last 8 games against us the Ravens are 1-7. Although 1 has been against their practice squad (injuries), what I've seen from Lamar is a lot of inconsistencies. We've also been hella injured in those games. Sure Derrick Henry is a beast but run first offenses will not work when yo are down and that's exactly what will happen to them in the playoffs.
Love gotta at least be a 90 now cmon
Madden will give love an 84 next year
Good vid as usual
Wyatt be like: Ehh, he just wasn’t all that great last year, I’m gonna have to give him a 94.
Wyatt gonna be pissed when Kirk is like an 89
Thanks for giving Brock a 90 Wyatt. People really sleep on his quarterback ability. I’m very happy as a niners fan to have him because it’s been a while since I was exited about a qb.
I feel wyatt's ratings are always pretty on par except theyre 3 overalls in either direction
Rare L for Wyatt, these ratings are absolutely horrendous😂
Still love your videos though🔥🔥🔥
we just not rating anthony richardson?
And Gardner trying to to get a sack😂😂
Yes sir rating videos are 🔥
You could do Linebackers as well
Do edge rusher Myles garret, Tj watt , etc
Joe was only healthy for a few games and he was elite… I get it though, availability is the best stat. Praying he stays healthy for a full year
Yo whyatt can we get more frequent videos?
Aaron Rodgers: 84
Baker Mayfield: 85
Will Levis: 75
Bryce Young: 74
Dak Prescott: 90
Derek Carr: 80
Daniel Jones: 73
Geno Smith: 83
Jared Goff: 89
Justin Herbert: 92
Jalen Hurts: 87
Deshaun Watson: 75
Josh Allen: 95
Justin Fields: 76
Joe Burrow: 94
Kirk Cousins: 85
Kenny Pickett: 70
Kyler Murray: 81
Lamar Jackson: 96
Jordan Love: 87
Gardner Minshew ll: 78
Mahomes: 99
Brock Purdy: 89
Russell Wilson: 84
Sam Howell: 74
Matthew Stafford: 84
CJ Stroud: 89
Ryan Tannehill: 72
Trevor Lawrence: 82
Tua: 87
Aidan O’Connell:71
Joe Flacco: 75
Mitch Trubisky: 68
Jameis Winston: 73
Jake Browning: 74
Desmond Ridder: 67
Mac Jones: 66
I’ll end it there 😂
CJ is 90 +
Probably but I just need to see another big year from him In order to Put him in the 90s, I for sure don’t think he’s a one season wonder I also just wanna see him put up some Good numbers against the best teams as he struggled a bit against Baltimore BUT If He can handle the pressure Again and play Really good again no doubt his in the low 90s atleast.
Mac had no weapons
And Goff probably should be higher and Carr lower
Stafford 85😂😂
This is much more realistic Wyatt always has ratings 3 or so higher than they should be
Anthony Richardson?
You should give each team their madden ranking
Good rankings but like last year maybe a bit too high for everyone. I would bop most down at least 1 or 2
Oh 96 is a great rating for Lamar. Even as a Ravens fan AND a Louisville fan i can acknowledge him and Josh were pretty even last year. Lamar had bad moments, as did Josh. Both are incredible quarterbacks.
3:18 😭
Rodgers is gonna go back up to 90 after this year.
No
29 tds 9 ints
Why yall over hyping him hes washed
Do punter rankings next
Giving Hurts an 89 is fair, but now we got better coordinators he should be a lot better
Where’s Anthony Richardson?
Since Anthony Richardson wasn’t on this list, what would you rate him?
I agree with the takes that Wyatt said, but if it’s madden, Lamar is a higher rating than Josh 11 times out of ten
Hurts looked injured ever since the rams game last year, I'm counting on a bounce back year (also helps that we hopefully won't be throwing 15 bubble screens a game this year)
What you didn’t like the almighty bubble screens
So what happened with Friday’s video?
Kirk cousins in the 90s is crazy
If you take all your ratings and subtract 4 that’s what madden will put them as
Bros is so generous 😂😂😂 if you look at 23 Madden rating he's giving qbs who had bad years like 5 overall higher than they were last year like waston and Ryan
People forget hurts had a knee brace on for 3 quarters of last season😂😂😂
Tanner at 81 is wild ngl
Bro hasn’t been good in 2 years
wyatt, i agree with 99% of the stuff you say but rating dak a 91 and pointing out stats but then ranking Goff 92 point and pointing out his stats, is it just because Dak isn’t good in playoffs ?
Wyatt can you do more ranking whatever before knowing the next it can be sports or non sports related
Also maybe even Some nba rankings Cuz I do think that we could have some possible hoop fans in these comments.
@@DebateBoyzPodcastpistons made me hate the nba
@@Immanuel481 well if your a fan Obviously ur gonna hate them cuz They were Absolutely trash this ydar
These ratings are valid
People saying last year that Geno was better than Dak lololol cowboys haters are such casuals
You just know Kirk Cousins will be somehow a 79 ovr with normal dev even though he was balling last year
Tua doesn’t have a good deep ball ? Okay 😂
Fr bro Threw Like Hundreds of 40-60+ Yard TDS last year like wtf is bro taking bout 🤣
89 for Hurts is super fair. I think if he’s healthy the full season he can get up over 90 but you can’t with the season he just had
Brock Purdy over hurts tho ? Jus no
@@storm7603 yeah I don’t agree with that either. The logic about only having the one good year kinda seems to get thrown out the window for people when it comes to Brock
@@mistermanage9278 exactly 🙌🏾
🎉
8:54 stroud should be 92 but 90 is good but ik madden hates the Texans so I wouldn’t doubt he’ll be 88 or lower lol
I think Wyatt should have finished, I was really curious where he was going to say about Mason Rudolph
You talking about tds and yards yet Lamar got 2 mvps and him and allen got the same amount of super bowls so i wanna know how allen is better??😂😂
Ima give burrow a 95 or 96 just because every season he has been healthy resulted in a Afc Championship and a Super Bowl.
you gotta keep some people lower rated ngl Putting tanny anywhere above 75 is an insane take
Do cornerbacks plsssss
Its crazy that Goff is an 82 in Madden rn 😭
tua has a good deep ball
Wyatt what would u Rate Bo Nix?
hurts at 89 but herbert in the 90's is outrageous please tell me what herbert has done most overrated qb hurts had a terrible offensive coach and he wasnt fully healthy
Where's anthony richardson?
Fr, I know he’s hard to rate right now but at least include him
I'd say at least 74 max 82
Post season stats don’t matter if you can’t make it to the Super Bowl. The bills are chokers just like the ravens.
I would give goff a 88 and watson a 78 max other than that i agree
aidan o connell gonna be a 90 by the end of the year , *im not delusional *
Let's not act like Josh Allen is insanely better than Lamar in the playoffs because, besides the defense, Josh has had the better offense around him. Josh's stats also mean absolutely nothing because all those stats resulted in an L to Mahomes THREE TIMES.
What about AR?
Derek Carr should be a 12 overall no cap.
i'd put stafford at a 95, that's not a joke
I think Tua is a 90 but 89 is good as well
I would still put Rodgers at a 90
I’d still put Brock @ an 88
Move Kirk down to an 89
I still think Matthew has to be a 90 til proven otherwise
The biggest one of all: Tua is an 86 MAX
Some of them players are way too high lol. Goff 88-89 Herbert 87-88 Cousins 87-88 Allen 92-93 Fields 75-76 Wilson 78-79 Stroud 84-85
Fr why everyone always rating Herbert so high
Wyatt I am a mahomes glazer. He is not a 99. Maybe a 97 but he had a career high int for him and only 27 tds. He was great in the playoffs but sometimes I wondered if it was really him on the field. He had barely any help though so that is also a factor.
Jordan love and Ryan tannehill need to be at a 90
Imo Baker hasn't revived his career until he has back2back good seasons.
True. In 2020 he led his Team to an 11-5 Record and win a playoff Game for them And then the next 2 years just kinda busted so we def need 2+ Above average years to put him in the top 15 convo
@@DebateBoyzPodcast Yep. His entire Browns career was one good year, one bad year and so on until he broke that streak with back2back bad years in Cleveland/Carolina. I do hope he can continue being a good QB from now on tho.
Goff over Dak is ridiculous
Wyatt you can’t give jarred goff, dak and Kirk a better rating then purdy he was the the runner up for mvp and had way better stats then all idk why he doesn’t get respect for leading the league in yards in the air distance
Of course you’re gunna glaze your guy and put Allen ahead of me but I should expect this from a delusional bills fan😂