Savarkar College Showdown Debate: Patriot Or Polarising Figure? | BJP Vs Congress | India Today
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 янв 2025
- Prime Minister Modi announced a new Delhi University college will be named after Veer Savarkar, sparking controversy. Congress and some historians argue it should be named after former PM Manmohan Singh instead. The debate centres on Savarkar's contested legacy as a freedom fighter and Hindutva ideologue versus Singh's academic background. The debate over Veer Savarkar's role in India's freedom struggle continues to spark controversy. Historians and political commentators discuss Savarkar's early revolutionary phase, his mercy petitions, and his later political ideology. The discussion touches on his time in Cellular Jail, comparisons with other freedom fighters, and his stance during key moments of the independence movement.
#savarkarcollege #delhiuniversity #congressvsbjp #itwebvideos #savarkarshowdown #cellularjail #educationdebate #quitindiamovement #pmmodi #savarkarcollege #indianfreedomstruggle #politicalideology #hindutva #manmohansingh #savarkardebate #freedomstruggle #indianindependence #nationalheroes #historicalcontroversy #revolutionaryfreedomfighters
Subscribe to India Today for NEW VIDEOS EVERY DAY and make sure to enable Push Notifications so you'll never miss a new video.
All you need to do is PRESS THE BELL ICON next to the Subscribe button!
India Today TV is India's leading English News Channel. India Today RUclips channel offers latest news videos on Politics, Business, Cricket, Bollywood, Lifestyle, Auto, Technology, Travel, Entertainment and a lot more.
Stay tuned for latest updates and in-depth analysis of news from India and around the world!
WhatsApp Channel: whatsapp.com/c...
Download App: indiatoday.lin...
Follow us: Official website: www.indiatoday...
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
Why was Vikram Sampath not invited to this panel?!
Rahul ka aur other vipaksh chooooootyonka fake lier so called historian ir fan ji hadhi ka debate mey nanga karadethey Vikram sampath ji ney isley nahi bulaya
Because it will hurt ITALIAN FRAUD GHANDY PARIWAR which puri doesn't want
गांधी जी द्वारा चलाए गए कौन से आंदोलन सफल रहे? Quit India आंदोलन कुछ ही दिनों में कुचल दिया गया था। नेहरू का अंग्रेजों से आज़ादी के बाद क्या संबंध रहा, आज सबको पता है।
गांधी और नेहरू जेल में कब रहे? आगा खान पैलेस और अहमदनगर फोर्ट को क्या जेल कहा जाएगा???
Every time I see Sanjay Jha sitting in front of his webcam debating, he reminds me of a ghost 👻
But he his your father
Whether you like him or not he's more educated than us.😂
@@EnricNykEDUCATED IN WHAT?
DYNASTY SLAVERY?
Nothing should be named after people. Be it Ambedkar, Savarkar, Nehru, Indira, Rajiv or anyone at all! No person can be bigger than an institution.
Savarkar spent 11 years in cellular jail, 3 years in Ratnagiri jail and 13 years in house arrest. This speaks volumes of his commitment for the nation.
But he naver uttered a word against the British government .He was a coward
@@prakashparanjape9459 and what did Gandhi and Nehru do? Utter only words?
@@bronxbullthey were always speaking against British...... their all the movment against was british unlike savarkar who begged mercy 😂
All the institutions, projects, stadiums, railway stations and even cities should be named after Nehru and it's stooges.
Calling Gandhi " MAHATMA " is highly CONTROVERSIAL
Rakesh Sinha has very poorly represented Savarkar , Sampath should be in the panel ...
Is Netaji controversial too!!!omg lets accept n respect them all ,Savarkar was a great freedom fighter
Nice joke
*gandhi was made mahatma and larger then life by Nehru congress since he made him PM and then took Gandhi surname* 🙏🏻🙏🏻 *तभी गांधी की दुकान अभी तक चला रहे है* 🙏🏻 *but now internet has open history for all* 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Anti national bhakt
Savarkar was first one to realize that what Gandhi and colonial were conspiring. Technically colonials can't decide partitions of Bharat but Gandhi allowed to happen and stayed away in kolcutta to show he wasn't responsible for disharmony..
That's why savarkar recruited sepoy for british army 😂😂😂....... savarkar boot licker of british
Uday Mahurkar's obsession of Muslim Appeasement is a laughable view. Mr. Irfan Habeeb's reply to him was really a fact based.
In the nutshell, Whatever the past philanthropics done goes waste once the loyalty switches to the enemy.
Anyone who is staunch Hindu is loved by all Hindus.
In light of all the sides of history now available - it’s safe to say that there were a lot of freedom fighters who made it possible. Unfortunately Nehru whitewashed every other individuals’ contribution. And his cabal then started villainised anyone who had a different approach to independence. And it’s safe to say that Gandhi & Nehru are the joint fathers of Pakistan and not India.
Did Ambedkar and Periyar participate in Quit India Movement ?
Will Cong dare oppose Ambedkar and Periyar
Veer savarkar ki Jai
Veer Tilak ki Jai
Veer Gopal Krishna Gokhale
change india to adani
Veer Savarkar was a great freedom fighter and a visionary. It is despicable that some people play dirty politics.
We need to disassociate from the movement by Bapu and Chacha , the so called non violent protest (collaboration )only ensured continuing of British Raj without any trouble . The rewards were the country was handed over to them . Veer Savarkar ideology of development with robust military , will ensure India remains independent . We all have seen what is happening to Hindus is Pakistan Bangladesh Kashmir , as well the riots taking place in Sambhal .
FIRST DISMANTLE THE CASTE SYSTEM 😂😂😂....then speak of Hindu unity 😂😂😂
@ Hindus are reforming fast . However both Muslim and Christian religions have multiple sects who are at each other throats since the inception of their religion .
Habib wants college has to be named as Hafiz Sayeed.
How easily he scuttled Nilanjan's most balanced view. No double Nijanjan was speaking with facts
MMS was not a leader, he was Prime Minister.
It would be disgrace to name a college after Savarkar who was one of the conspirator of assassination of Mahatma Gandhi and was acquitted only because of technicalities.. Kapoor Commission clearly mention his role in killing of Gandhi..
calling him Veer is a joke as it was a self proclaimed title of the only man from Kala Pani , who kept on writing letters of apologies and promised British Raj of his loyalty..
Apart from all these he has divided India and Indians. With coming up with two nation theories and his hate communal ideologies are something to condemn rather than glorify like right wing hateful communal extremists politicians try to do!!
I’m not congress but I am upset too🤬
कृपया दो व्यक्तीयोंकी तुलना मत करो।
स्वातंत्र्य वीर सावरकर स्वातंत्र्य सेनानी है और मा . मनमोहन सिंग जी एक विद्या वाचस्पती और माजी प्रधान मंत्री है तो दोनो की तुलना करना अच्छा नही है ।
India Today must stop calling Habib in such debate ..He is not a historian of Independence of India…..
स्वातंत्र्य सावरकर जी नाम से मतदाता प्रभावित होते है क्या ? आज तक के चुनाव का अनुभव क्या है ? तो दिल्ली चुनाव सामनेरखकर स्वातंत्र्य वीर सावरकर के नाम से कॉलेज का शिलान्यास किया है ऐसा कहना योग्य नही है ।
जो आंदमान निकोबार जेल मे थे उसमेसे कितने व्यक्तियों को याद किया जाता है ? और कब कब याद किया जाता है ? कृपया स्पष्ट करे।
Why not Dr Manmomhan Singh in his name for the colleage?
कांग्रेस के पास कोई नहीं है जिसने सावरकर की तरह यातना सही हो कालापानी में….उस सेल को देख कर ही दिमाग बड़े से बड़े देशप्रेमी का…
How is Dr. Manmohan Singh who did and what he become under Sonia Gandhi?
When we discuss Savarkar, Sanjay says that Savarkar being the president of Hindu Maha Sabha was vicariously responsible for the murder of Gandhi. Then the corruption during 10 years of Manmohan Singh should be attributed to Manmohan Singh. I don't hold Gandhi as a person who brought independence to India let alone calling him a Mahatma. Why did Nehru collude with Gandhi to give Feroz Khan the title Gandhi. Irfan Habib, you have lost all respect for your credentials which were sold to Khangrass. Irfan, we are aware of Gandhi, Nehru's role in independence. You don't have to teach us.
Comedy
Next time plz invite vikram samapth he wiil definitely open everyone's eyes
Sawarkar was a Desh Bhakta preriod
Poor panel selection. Vikram Sampath should have been put against Ramchandra Guha....tabhi maza ata na viduu
सेपरेट इलेक्ट्रोलेट देना राष्ट्रीय हित मे था क्या ? चुनाव होने के बाद सरकार स्थापन करना गलत क्यूँ है ?
There is plenty of leaders, why naming someone who always asked for mercy? It's not about Congress opposing they are also same as Savarkar. These coward 3% and their enemy 14% are ruling the 80% unprivileged.
Was Indira Gandhi a traitor??
Irfan habib forefathers voted for pakistan but decided to stay back to enjoy sickularism and he is questioning Savarkar
Dude, Savarkar spent time in Jail and sacrificed his life for the country. Unlike Gandhi and Nehru and Muslim League/Congress that was negotiating for transfer of control and power with the British. He sacrificed more than these VIP freedom fighters. Nehru-Gandhi and Muslim League/Congress have built a narative post independence and portrayed themselves as freedom fighters. Name me one thing they did that endangered their lives? They were mostly negotiating with the British!!! In the end the British imposed a condition of partition which they accepted. Which country that is trying to get self rule will go with the colonizer dividing the country? That should tell you all you need to know about Gandhi-Nehru. They were basically negotiating for power for themselves. Gandhi for a permanent name for himself as a Mahatma. Nehru power for him and the product of his semen.
Why is Irfan Habib even opining on this?
Gandhi was Nehru's proxy in the negotiations with the British. He basically got the power transferred to Nehru. That a narrative has been created and people brainwashed over the years does not change the facts on the ground. Muslim League/Congress was negotiating for transfer of power to them. They even discussed Autonomy and not full control.
Infact siding with Muslim League/Congress party would be to agree with Partition. To agree with bigotry. They were the ones that wanted transfer of power more than a single nation based on Human values. Any sane man would choose Savarkar any Day over Gandhi-Nehru.
Are you a qualified trained historian? Provide facts instead of whatsapp "knowledge" and 1000s of people were in jail during the freedom mvmt, none of them have a record of asking for pardon from the British.
Yes gomuthra nagpur half knickers RSS you are right, how many nagpur half knickers you have
@@ipshitachanda7434HOW DID NEHRU BECAME PM AFTER WRITING APOLOGY LETTER TO BRITISH FROM NABHA JAIL?
CAN YOU TELL THE FORMULA FOR THIS MIRACLE?
Collect MILK POWDER SACHET tomorrow
@@ipshitachanda7434 LOL!!! What do you think historians do? Interpret and give opinions. Only morons that do not understand strategy that do not get why some one would ask for a pardon!!! LOL!!! Speaks a lot about IQ. Looks to me the narrative being spread is somehow his request for PARDON was change of heart. Yet he is blamed for Gandhi assasination and contacts with revolutionaries. Be consistent man!!! Which is it? You cannot have the cake and eat it too. Most Historians are biased opinionators trying to build a political narrative. Especially in India, and especially Irfan Habib. There are jails and there are VIP jails. And Muslim League/Congress just neogtiated transfer of control.
It is very comic to see bjp people defending savarkar
Yeh congress wale abhi tak modi ji ko 2002 ka haat hai bolte hai but ek evidence court me diye nai 20 year court me case chala
Kapoor commision was a puppet commision formed my Mrs Gandhi just keep this matter live
What does this joker knows about Sawarkar ji
Sanjay Jha is attempting to be certified as the Congress Asslicker.
You mean gomuthra nagpur half knickers RSS form the commission is good correct gomuthra?
The problem with some of the arguments are- Gandhiji supported British in both world war 1 and 2. It wasn’t India fight but lot of Indians lost their life. All have contributed and a call taken at that time by people based on circumstances. No point berating anyone in 2024. Be Savarkar or Gandhi
“Dr. Ambedkar believed that if Savarkar wanted to achieve his goal of creating a Hindu nation, he would have to break down the barriers between the untouchables and the rest of Hindu society.”
This conversation will not ensure India gets its 6th gen fighter aircraft, jobs for the unemployed youth, lower LPG gas price, stop the violence in Manipur or keep us better prepared to tackle the new virus in China that may spread to India.
Nor going to Bangkok every month will ensure any of the above
@@VictimHood-qv1hx abosolutely 😄😄😄😄😄
@@VictimHood-qv1hx you guys appear so envious.
@@happyanand9909YES HE SHOULD BE ENVIOUS OF A FOREVER PUDIYA MAAR YUVA NETA
@@happyanand9909 perhaps he will bring the new new virus as he hates Hindus
Prof. Habib, have u done any research on the prisoners at Andaman Cellular jail….?
Polarising figure..without doubt.
Same for them.
Mahurkar is being haunted by congress
No jobs, economy is going though a crisis, we are debating whether Savarkar was Veer Nostradamus. Ridiculous
Do you keep information about the global crisis and then try to understand where do we stand in terms of economy or economic growth! Stupid, retarded man.
When gomuthra nagpur half knickers RSS rule our country they will pull our trousers 👖
Yo Enienstein, there are a whole bunch of jobs is MSME shop floor. I personally referred few known associates to TASL who also has a lot of jobs. Other than that there are jobs in traditional logistics like DHL as well as quick commerce like Zepto. U just have to look around. Its an another thing that it may not be to ur liking. But then I can't say there see no jobs as it's totally different from having likable jobs. Oh by the way almost nobody likes his job, Yet he just does it never the less.
ATLEAST ITALIAN PAPPU HAS A JOB THANKS TO SOROS TOOLKIT SERVICES 🤣🤣🤣
एक व्यक्ति के अयोग्य बर्ताव के कारण पूरी संघटना को जिम्मेदार करार देना योग्य है क्या ? कानून इसकी इजाजत देता है क्या ?
Sanjay Jha go to Andaman and see the sell, Savarkar was put in isolated cell for years….
Sorry varkar
Vikram sampath has good knowledge about life of savarkar
All,especially habib and sanjay jha,should read two books on Vir Savarkar by Vikram Sampath, he cleared everything with solid proofs
Savarkar was better than even Gandhi 😊. Manmohan was the worst PM.allowed plunder of national resources in his 10 years as Monmohan kept his jameer girvi with Bar dancer 😢
Nirangan Takale, Dwadashiwar has very serious allegations on Savarakar you should involve them in the in such debate. Niranjan Takle presented him as pro British supporter and made aligation that he was involved in Gandhi assassination with the help of Godse and Apte this is just to support British and not because Gandhi agreed for partion. where as Mr.Dwadashiwar is saying Savarkar was recruiting of people for British army.
Last 10-11 years we r listening media houses crap about hindu muslim nehru ji congress gandhi ji RG .Now these days an unregisterd organisattion who had no faith in indian constitution
Making hero a british agen̈t, followed this mafiveer savarkar poisinous ideology
The godi anchor .Rahul konwal. He is trying to confuse.
Reality is that in Indian independence struggle that Savarkar was conspicuous by his absence. Savarkar has no positive contribution towars. Non cooperation movement . Savarkar was not seen in historic "'Quit india * movement. . Savarkar had penned a clemancy petition
Every writ petitions had same format. Same format was used by Mahatma Gandhi and Nehru and all other freedom fighters.
Shameful act running by India today media is this need to clear with penal discussion that who is savarkar ?
Habib type people want only Gandi , Nehra राजीव sanjay Sonia's progeny should be recognized and given name.sad affairs in this country. Two nation theory against death of Nehru & Gandi and so many....
What was the role played by sangh parivaars during indias freedom movement. They supported britishers. No douth at all.
Much More and Constructive than All the PEOPLE IN INDIA WHO VOTED FOR PAKISTAN AND STAYED IN INDIA TO ASK THIS TYPE OF QUESTIONS.
Why as a reporter you are trying to justify this ?
Jaenge kha?
Gujrat,keral,bangal,kashmir,
Kha?
That also repeat mode
Ultrasound wagerah.
Jai hind
Malhotra,batra,rajesh captains ghar jaenge
Hospital gangaram
Removed
Eggs le k?
Dr.Manmohan singh was a alumni of FMS delhi.
Ooops sorry, Oops sorry
Rahul is so sanghi that he agrres to what ever sanghi Sinha says😅😅😅
Savarkar licked the British boots and wrote apology letters to British to get pension from them.
BUT THARKI CHACHA BECAME PM AFTER WRITING APOLOGY LETTER FROM NABHA JAIL😵💫😵💫😵💫😵💫
Makhivir
Do we really need this debate?
What a stupid debate. Is there any value to common man with this!!
BJP GUY THERE U GO AGAIN
Maafi veer..angrezo ka Ghulam..Bhagat Singh ne jaan dedi magar ghutane nahi teke savarkar ki tarah
LEKIN NEHRU NE MAAFINAAMA NABHA JAIL SE LIKHKE PM BAN GAYA
YEH KYA SCENE HAI BHAI?
@SECULARBADWA ye jhut hai dost..aap jaake padho aisa koi maafinama nahi hai
@abhaySingh-lk1ri 100% SACH HAI DOST
YEDA BANKE CHACHA NE PEDHA KHAYA
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
It insulting to compare shivaji maharaj to savarkar
Mr.Niranjan Takle one of the investigative journalists having hundreds of evidence about Savarkar.
Rahulji once invite him for a debate
Savarkar if at all apologised to British, must have under extreme distress.
Veer savarkar Zindabad. Mahatma Gandhi accepted the split of the country.
Irfan is Muslim and Savarkar was against Muslims.
Rahul kanwal improved his conduct as an anchor- objective and to the point. This is how a tv anchor should conduct.
He revolves it around those speaking in favour of RSS. Irfan made some facts but he hardly gave him any chance to speak
An article in 'new india express' dtd 3rd Jan 2020 & other articles claim that savarkar was gay. Is this true ?
Ashok kr pandey along with those who can decipher history with facts should have been there.
Look at Rahul Kawal, he takes name of Gandhi ji and Sardar Patel but purposefully ignores Pt. Nehru while refering Indian independence movement. Remember Rahul Kawal we will remember YOU
Remember him masturbate and sleep
CAN YOU LIST DOWN NEHRU'S ACHIEVEMENTS IN INDUAN FREEDOM MOVEMENT?
VOTE,
kaise mangte.
Inhe
Gesture yaad dilayeye.
If Congress have so much respect for MMS, they have close to 200 places under fake Gandhi name which they can rename it for MMS.
What is Nehru's contribution for freedom fight?
Why vikram sampath not invited
Savarkar was convicted in 1911 and was sent to Andaman Around 1922 he was
released . Since ten he never uttered a word against the British Government till 1947 . How can you call such person Swntntrayavir
Daily wasting time on stupid debates
Rahul Kanvar Is a BJPig and why debate on this subject. Why aren't you debating on Adani where the US issues arrest warrant on him.
How is Dr. Manmohan Singh who did and what he become under Sonia Gandhi?