As a sw fan: we could use more of this. Content made in the sw universe that can tell a story without any knowledge requirement. Not everyone needs a fancy show - even though i love the mandalorian -, sometimes its just better to produce a high quality story and then fill in the parts later
I know you probably uploaded this to get reactions from people in a bad way but honestly? good on him. Andor is literally the best Star Wars we've gotten in decades
@Alex-qs2uu it does its best to imitate "prestige tv" so everyone recognizes the style and goes "yep that's good" which extrapolates to "best thing ever"
@@christinel.9742 no he wants a star wars show that RESPECTS their audience and not a Disneyfied star wars that only PANDERS to its audience like "simpletons" instead of making quality stories.
@@4ndr0m3d4nspot on. @DollyRanch is acting like the Prequels, Ewok films or Clone Wars weren’t created under George Lucas Star Wars 😂 People will ALWAYS moan
A lot of us are Disney Star Wars reluctant and Disney knows it. Bringing in some of the Rogue One people to do an anti-sequel trilogy show is a step in the right direction. I agree with Jar Jar about Disney lesbo propaganda having no place in Star Wars however.
That means he has no respect for the main audience. That's alarming. Go do something else if you want to cater to communist lesbians. Leave Star Wars alone.
@@JarJarAbrams There's nothing wrong weith lesbians in SW, so long as it is a natural, unforced part of their characters, a la Andor. And they most certainly weren't communists. That's a real-world ideology.
@@IndyDefense There's literally nothing in this show that feels other-wordly. Of course it has a pair of lesbians, it takes place on earth in the cursed year 2023.
And that's exactly why it's good. Star wars was never intended to be a set thing. George Lucas made the prequels different because he didn't want to make the same thing. New when done well is andor(though people can call it not star wars or whatever), done bad is TLJ.
I agree with you, Jar Jar. Although I don't mind the idea of a Star Wars series that doesn't focus on a force user and instead on some of the civilians, Andor still didn't feel like a Star Wars series. It felt more like they were trying to go for a feeling similar to Ron Moore's Battlestar Galactica or that of the Expanse. The problem, in my opinion, is that that type of science fiction doesn't fit with Star Wars. Star Wars is supposed to have the feeling of a grand space opera similar in style to the classical acting seen in 1930s-1940s Hollywood. There have also been cases in the original Expanded Universe where some stories didn't focus on Jedi. For example, I read one and a half of the X-wing novels a few years ago and while they focused more on non-force sensitive pilots and felt more like a spy espionage type story, they still felt like I was reading something from a galaxy far, far away. @@JarJarAbrams
@@tyrannozilla Yeah they don't understand it's King Arthur ins space. You can't make a show grounded on planet earth. Besides, the rebels in Andor are doing a communist revolution. The rebels in original Star Wars are anti-imperialists fighting for freedom. It's completely different.
Thanks for the reply Jar Jar. I also wanted to ask you something. Have you read any of the X-wing novels? if you have, does it back up what I said about them, in that they still felt like Star Wars, even though they feel more like spy espionage stories?@@JarJarAbrams
This This right here are my exact thoughts, Why this show Was Amazing As a fan of Rebels and Bad Batch, Andor was a slash of fresh air Not everthing needs to be some long colorful Battle adventure, for the story that Andor was it had to be told differently, i literally got hooked on the first 3 episodes Diego Luna's acting was amazing The antagonists were well written They brought back chracters like Guerrera, Mothma, Melshi and a Kx droid whilst making it feel natural and not forced or out of place There are stakes that make me worried for the side characters There is almost No Witty banter that honestly gets tiring in most SW shows And overall it's just great Like Imagine Blade Runner, then try to reimagine it into a star wars show and try to make it Perfect
Andor lacked the space opera feel that George intended. Star Wars is inspired off of the old heroic serials of the day it shouldn’t be gritty and dramatic like Breaking Bad.
I think Andor should just be Andor. It doesn't have to be like every other SW show. You're comparing it to Breaking Bad as if it's something to complain about. I'll take good writing anyday over shitty, unrealistic space muppets. The first season had a variety of locations and a few scenes in space so I'm not sure what you mean by "space opera feel".
It might be better to think of the TV shows in the same way you might Star Wars novels (or video games, comics, etc), that being with varying tones and types of stories.
Andor-resistant is pretty much everyone since nobody watched the show. I don't even understand how they're making a second season. That must be contractual.
@@davidsanders5652 Not even James Mangold could keep her from meddling in his movie, you think these non name hasbeen could be independent? Why do you think it's full of woke and female leads?
@@JarJarAbrams If you remember she was occupied trying, and failing, to turn Children of Blood and Bone into a film. but she always found time to destroy George Lucas characters. So Skywalker, Solo Kenobi and Jones. As for female leads well a) why not? And b) everyone in Hollyweird is woke just now...apart from Tarantino.
@@davidsanders5652 Every Lucasfilm show or movie has her fingerprints all over it. Don't believe the rumors that Favreau or whoever is taking control of Lucasfilm. Everything is woke and stupid because of her.
Tony must have meditated Henri Decoin's filmography. How to connect storia & historia without getting à machinal and souless director ? Hard challenge !
Andor was pretty much the best star wars has been. Ever. So glad he decided not to pander to the people who still *think* they're the "main audience" when in reality they're just a hateful bunch rambling about agendas.
Yes, exactly. What has mainline Star Wars given us? The terrible sequels and a million dave filoni dumps. Again, you haven't watched Andor, and it shows. It's an excellent show that stands IN SPITE of Disney's vision for what Star Wars should be.
The truth is that the sequels and Favreau shit are guilty of the same crime. They're pandering to woke audiences and giving the finger to the fans. The only difference is that they're pretending to do fan service while Gilroy is pretty straightforward with his intentions.
Jar jar sorry to see your franchise fall like that . The best thing to do is play the part of contempt Don’t give it any attention anymore. Why not follow a new ip
@@JarJarAbrams I have not watched anything Hollywood for the past 4 years . I do read the jack reacher books some Clive cussler and some older English books . It’s all in decline mostly
The empire: Israel. The rebels: Palestine. Mon Mothma: Moderate. Luthen: Basically Hamas. Aldhani heist: October 7th. Mon Mothma to Luthen: Do you realize what you’ve started? Luthen: The empire (Israel) was choking us so slowly that we barely noticed anymore (stealing land inch by inch, apartheid, checkpoints etc), so we had to force their hand, make them show their true colors. Mon Mothma: People will suffer. Luthen: That’s the plan. Oppression breeds rebellion. Andor: Radicalized by the actions of the Empire (Israel.)
The bottom line is that Disney/Lucasfilm has no clue what to do with their IPs. So much of their Star Wars content was made "for the fans", it makes sense they'd pick an outlier lamb to place on the altar to see if something "not for the fans" could make them some money. Anyone else looking forward to Indy 5 tanking?
PEOPLE DONT UNDERSTAND THAT STAR WARS JUST NEEDS A GOOD STORY... ANY MOVIE CAN BE A STAR WARS MOVIE... EVEN SPEED RACER AND TITANIC CAN BE A STAR WARS MOVIE... THESE PEOPLE CONTROLLING STAR WARS LITERALLY DONT UNDERSTAND THAT..............
He really tried to make Star Wars into Games of Throne, with moral ambiguous Rebels who aren't worth rooting for. Lots of meandering dialogs that tried to be complex like your typical thriller movie where there's way too much talking and taking itself too seriously, but actually lacking substance.
They were definitely trying to make Game of Thrones in space, trying to tap into that audience. But the only thing they achieved was a boring office drama with characters and stories taken from young adult novels for teenage girls set in a depressing city that looks like the soviet union.
He tried to make an HBO-level show and succeeded. That's why Andor is in position to win awards like no other SW property has been since ESB. Whether the audience that was raised on the terrible writing and flashy lights of the prequels ever catches up is of no consequence because the second and final season is already in production.
@@JarJarAbrams Maybe the other shit but Andor is pretty far from Marxist, the whole of Ferrix is a free trade capitalist planet which while having strong community is pretty far from socialism.
People who saw Andor and liked it... were you even paying attention? It's made out of cropped plots from finished scripts of Star Wars Underworld that never saw the light of day, and all of these subplots don't amount to a story. It's just really good actors doing random stuff inside with blasters. It has nothing to do with Star Wars, except the fact that it is somewhat placed in an unnecessarily realistic version of that universe. It's a complete failure as a Star Wars story and product, and as a story or product on its own. It simply has more professional production than most of Filoni's absolute amateur trash.
I have mentioned this on other channels, but another thing I have noticed with Andor, and all of the other Disney Star Wars shows and movies, is that the characters do not talk like Star Wars characters. According to some interviews from George Lucas and other reports, he took inspiration from classical acting from the Golden Age of Hollywood (1930s and 1940s). Look at films like Casablanca or Gone With The Wind (or any of the Flash Gordon or Buck Rogers film serials), then watch any of Lucas' original six films and I believe you will notice the similarities. I always thought that was a genius idea to take classical acting and put it in another galaxy. However, once Disney took over and Lucas left, Star Wars no longer feels like "a galaxy far, far away" anymore. The characters talk more like people on Earth with current vernacular and swear words (the word "shit" used in Andor, for instance). Current vernacular works in shows like the Expanse because it takes place in our galaxy and most of the people come from Earth. But it doesn't work when you put it in Star Wars. Now before you say anything, I know that Han Solo said the word "Hell" in A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back. The difference between that and what Disney is doing is that Star Wars was still finding its footing in 1977 and 1980. By the time you get to Return of The Jedi in 1983 and the prequels in 1999 up to 2005, the characters stopped saying that word. Now it's commonplace for them to not say "Hell" because they are from a different galaxy, so they would not know any of our religions, thus not use "Hell" as a swear word.
Yes, they removed all the classic aspects of Star Wars, even the shooting is too modern for Star Wars. But that's what marxists do, they hate classicism.
Thanks again for the reply, JJ. Sorry for the late response. Hope you do more videos soon. Ahsoka is airing at the moment. That should give you plenty of material to rip apart.@@JarJarAbrams
Dude dont compare Andor to the rest of the Disney shows. Andor is a great take on the star wars universe that I didn't know i needed. Also the style of acting that George used in the first 6 films would be really outdated now. It wouldn't work and most people would view it as too childish now.
I would argue that Andor and all the other D-wars shows are more childish than anything from Lucas' six films. The style of acting may appear outdated to you, but to me, and a lot of other fans, it fits with that galaxy. By trying to make the characters in Star Wars talk more like the characters in Expanse or Ron Moore's Galactica ruins the point of the saga. It's supposed to have that golden age style acting and by taking it away, you are destroying part of the saga's DNA.@@vice2versa
You can't just set some garbage story in space, throw in some storm troopers and then call it Star Wars. Well, Disney can , but it's never any good when they do. The bottom line is that Disney Star Wars isn't real Star Wars. It was never meant to be an endless slog through every minute corner of the galaxy. It was meant to be a saga with a definite beginning and ending.
Disney Star Wars will never be Star Wars but they at least tried to fake it with the previous attempts. With Andor, they were very open about the fact this thing is not made for Star Wars fans. It's some stupid soap opera for liberal women piggy backing on Star Wars fans without any shame. It's literal franchise parasiting.
@@JarJarAbrams why their attempts at faking Star Wars don't have the same effort as Gilroy does? He said he doesn't take the audience for granted in the same interview and that they're never cynical about Star Wars. Honestly that's all people are asking for at this point, stop with formulaic corporate writing.
Che Guevara is Star Wars for people who hate Star Wars and want to feel like they like Star Wars, so that they can tell their Star Wars friends to watch it and make them just as miserable as the rest of us are when we’re watching a Disney+ show regardless of whether it’s ultra serious or stupid and silly. If you want good serious Star Wars stories learn to read.
a lot of "Star Wars-resistant" people don't know the Expanded Universe, it's like that, he didn't brought any quality that Star Wars was lacking but in the disney canon certainly was better, even if i just watch the first four episodes because i didn't see anything to kept me going forward
I enjoyed the first three episodes but they are definitely the least eventful of the bunch. The series absolutely has some massive payoffs. However if you just weren't a fan of the tone, thats fine too.
@@augusto____ the episodes work in arcs, essentially (not so short) movies. 1-3, 4-6, 7 is a sort of bridge episode, 8-10, and 11-12. If you liked the tone I'd recommend trying to push through at least through episode 6, but to each their own.
@@vice2versa when you say that Andor is amazing that's your opinion, the shows of HBO are not the same, even when the style can be similar, the reason that determines whether you're gonna watch something or not depends of each person and not necessarily a general aspect
As a massive Star Wars fan, Andor is everything I wanted and more.
As a sw fan: we could use more of this. Content made in the sw universe that can tell a story without any knowledge requirement. Not everyone needs a fancy show - even though i love the mandalorian -, sometimes its just better to produce a high quality story and then fill in the parts later
In that case, Lucas' complete 6 part saga should be enough
@@anthonygarcia8749 People like the universe though. It has a great premise; essentially the fantasy version of the Roman Republic/Empire.
@@anthonygarcia8749 The prequels needed an animated series to fix some of their problems.
I know you probably uploaded this to get reactions from people in a bad way but honestly? good on him. Andor is literally the best Star Wars we've gotten in decades
Facts
Lol
I stopped watching after episodes 6 or 7.
Incredibly boring and nothing new, just serious.
@Alex-qs2uu it does its best to imitate "prestige tv" so everyone recognizes the style and goes "yep that's good" which extrapolates to "best thing ever"
Looked good, sounded good but awful pacing and boring forgettable characters.
I’d like to see more Star Wars resilient content
yeah me too
@@PVNTHR sounds like Disney usually makes anti-Star Wars which means he wants to see real Star Wars, a.k.a. "resilient" one
Try Star Trek or Battlestar Galactica. 🙄
@@christinel.9742 no he wants a star wars show that RESPECTS their audience and not a Disneyfied star wars that only PANDERS to its audience like "simpletons" instead of making quality stories.
Andor is the best thing to come out of Disney StarWars.
A Disney-Star Wars resistant audience, perhaps. I loved Andor S1. And I love Star Wars (1977)
This is essentially that Morpheus meme: "What if I told you 𝘈𝘯𝘥𝘰𝘳 is Disney 𝘚𝘵𝘢𝘳 𝘞𝘢𝘳𝘴?"
@@4ndr0m3d4nspot on. @DollyRanch is acting like the Prequels, Ewok films or Clone Wars weren’t created under George Lucas Star Wars 😂 People will ALWAYS moan
A lot of us are Disney Star Wars reluctant and Disney knows it. Bringing in some of the Rogue One people to do an anti-sequel trilogy show is a step in the right direction. I agree with Jar Jar about Disney lesbo propaganda having no place in Star Wars however.
What’s wrong with him saying that he wants to make a show that could potentially bring in new fans?
That means he has no respect for the main audience. That's alarming. Go do something else if you want to cater to communist lesbians. Leave Star Wars alone.
@@JarJarAbrams bro… you are so delusional
@@JarJarAbrams There's nothing wrong weith lesbians in SW, so long as it is a natural, unforced part of their characters, a la Andor. And they most certainly weren't communists. That's a real-world ideology.
@@JarJarAbrams what about Andor made you feel disrespected?
@@IndyDefense There's literally nothing in this show that feels other-wordly. Of course it has a pair of lesbians, it takes place on earth in the cursed year 2023.
Based Tony Gilroy
And that's exactly why it's good.
Star wars was never intended to be a set thing. George Lucas made the prequels different because he didn't want to make the same thing. New when done well is andor(though people can call it not star wars or whatever), done bad is TLJ.
yup, Star Wars started unique and was always meant to be unique
So THAT'S how they got my attention! Well played
extremely funny to see everyone dunking on op. please keep it up
If this account ever hates on Star Wars Visions or any of the Jedi games, they’ll just confirm that they’re racist as hell.
Good go away from the force and any memberberrys as possible
and it worked both ways
Don't know if I expected someone with the username JarJarAbrams to actually have an ounce of media literacy but it sounds like you don't
Star Wars to me is episodes 1-6 and the original EU legends, excluding Filoni’s Clone Wars series. 1977-2012
And this is related to the video how?
@@kungolaf4499 Awkward to reply to a 10 month old comment.
He wound up making a better show than Obi-Wan and set a bar for shows like Mandalorian to meet or exceed
All Disney Star Wars TV shows are dogshit, and Andor is no exception. It's just a different kind of bad.
@@JarJarAbramsno one’s going with you on this one lil bro
I agree with you, Jar Jar. Although I don't mind the idea of a Star Wars series that doesn't focus on a force user and instead on some of the civilians, Andor still didn't feel like a Star Wars series. It felt more like they were trying to go for a feeling similar to Ron Moore's Battlestar Galactica or that of the Expanse. The problem, in my opinion, is that that type of science fiction doesn't fit with Star Wars. Star Wars is supposed to have the feeling of a grand space opera similar in style to the classical acting seen in 1930s-1940s Hollywood. There have also been cases in the original Expanded Universe where some stories didn't focus on Jedi. For example, I read one and a half of the X-wing novels a few years ago and while they focused more on non-force sensitive pilots and felt more like a spy espionage type story, they still felt like I was reading something from a galaxy far, far away. @@JarJarAbrams
@@tyrannozilla Yeah they don't understand it's King Arthur ins space. You can't make a show grounded on planet earth. Besides, the rebels in Andor are doing a communist revolution. The rebels in original Star Wars are anti-imperialists fighting for freedom.
It's completely different.
Thanks for the reply Jar Jar. I also wanted to ask you something. Have you read any of the X-wing novels? if you have, does it back up what I said about them, in that they still felt like Star Wars, even though they feel more like spy espionage stories?@@JarJarAbrams
This
This right here are my exact thoughts, Why this show Was Amazing
As a fan of Rebels and Bad Batch, Andor was a slash of fresh air
Not everthing needs to be some long colorful Battle adventure, for the story that Andor was it had to be told differently, i literally got hooked on the first 3 episodes
Diego Luna's acting was amazing
The antagonists were well written
They brought back chracters like Guerrera, Mothma, Melshi and a Kx droid whilst making it feel natural and not forced or out of place
There are stakes that make me worried for the side characters
There is almost No Witty banter that honestly gets tiring in most SW shows
And overall it's just great
Like Imagine Blade Runner, then try to reimagine it into a star wars show and try to make it Perfect
Andor lacked the space opera feel that George intended. Star Wars is inspired off of the old heroic serials of the day it shouldn’t be gritty and dramatic like Breaking Bad.
I think Andor should just be Andor. It doesn't have to be like every other SW show. You're comparing it to Breaking Bad as if it's something to complain about. I'll take good writing anyday over shitty, unrealistic space muppets. The first season had a variety of locations and a few scenes in space so I'm not sure what you mean by "space opera feel".
@Jedley01 Sure, but that's asking for a miracle.
Let me guess you think the mandolorian is star wars
It might be better to think of the TV shows in the same way you might Star Wars novels (or video games, comics, etc), that being with varying tones and types of stories.
Yes! Andor is not a space opera. You finally understand.
Star Wars is Episodes I-VI, the 2003 Clone Wars and the various books and comics that George Lucas approved of prior to selling the company in 2012.
And it worked it cant all be the typical heroes cant do any wrong type thing in star wats its more black and white than that
too bad they didnt make it for the andor-resistant
Andor-resistant is pretty much everyone since nobody watched the show. I don't even understand how they're making a second season. That must be contractual.
@@JarJarAbrams Andor is the best Star Wars since episode 5
@@lordrichtofen8266 SHH! He feeds off of negative content. Whether the show is good or not doesn't matter, you leave him alone!
Andor is sooooooo gooooooooddd
And the irony is KK's "Star Wars" projects have been NOT Star Wars whereas Andor WAS Star Wars.
All Star Wars material since 2015 is KK Star Wars.
@@JarJarAbrams On paper yes but Andor, Rogue One and The Mandalorian Seasons 1 and 2 she was, by all accounts, very hands off.
@@davidsanders5652 Not even James Mangold could keep her from meddling in his movie, you think these non name hasbeen could be independent? Why do you think it's full of woke and female leads?
@@JarJarAbrams If you remember she was occupied trying, and failing, to turn Children of Blood and Bone into a film. but she always found time to destroy George Lucas characters. So Skywalker, Solo Kenobi and Jones. As for female leads well a) why not? And b) everyone in Hollyweird is woke just now...apart from Tarantino.
@@davidsanders5652 Every Lucasfilm show or movie has her fingerprints all over it. Don't believe the rumors that Favreau or whoever is taking control of Lucasfilm. Everything is woke and stupid because of her.
Tony must have meditated Henri Decoin's filmography. How to connect storia & historia without getting à machinal and souless director ? Hard challenge !
Andor was pretty much the best star wars has been. Ever. So glad he decided not to pander to the people who still *think* they're the "main audience" when in reality they're just a hateful bunch rambling about agendas.
Yes, exactly. What has mainline Star Wars given us? The terrible sequels and a million dave filoni dumps. Again, you haven't watched Andor, and it shows. It's an excellent show that stands IN SPITE of Disney's vision for what Star Wars should be.
The truth is that the sequels and Favreau shit are guilty of the same crime. They're pandering to woke audiences and giving the finger to the fans. The only difference is that they're pretending to do fan service while Gilroy is pretty straightforward with his intentions.
Jar jar sorry to see your franchise fall like that . The best thing to do is play the part of contempt
Don’t give it any attention anymore.
Why not follow a new ip
Andor was an absolute chore. I won't watch season 2.
@@JarJarAbrams I have not watched anything Hollywood for the past 4 years .
I do read the jack reacher books some Clive cussler and some older English books .
It’s all in decline mostly
@@omiorahman6283 You didn't miss anything. It's really bad and cheaply made.
@@JarJarAbrams agreed .^_^
Good writing for star wars
The empire: Israel.
The rebels: Palestine.
Mon Mothma: Moderate.
Luthen: Basically Hamas.
Aldhani heist: October 7th.
Mon Mothma to Luthen: Do you realize what you’ve started?
Luthen: The empire (Israel) was choking us so slowly that we barely noticed anymore (stealing land inch by inch, apartheid, checkpoints etc), so we had to force their hand, make them show their true colors.
Mon Mothma: People will suffer.
Luthen: That’s the plan. Oppression breeds rebellion.
Andor: Radicalized by the actions of the Empire (Israel.)
Andor is about Palestine. If pitched today, It would be considered subversive and would get cancelled in pre-production.
“ I want to sell fridges as cars at our sushi restaurant”
They got what they asked for cos no one watched the show.
The bottom line is that Disney/Lucasfilm has no clue what to do with their IPs. So much of their Star Wars content was made "for the fans", it makes sense they'd pick an outlier lamb to place on the altar to see if something "not for the fans" could make them some money.
Anyone else looking forward to Indy 5 tanking?
I sort of disagree. They've been catering to non-Star Wars fans since TFA. They just happen to be very open about it with Andor.
PEOPLE DONT UNDERSTAND THAT STAR WARS JUST NEEDS A GOOD STORY... ANY MOVIE CAN BE A STAR WARS MOVIE... EVEN SPEED RACER AND TITANIC CAN BE A STAR WARS MOVIE... THESE PEOPLE CONTROLLING STAR WARS LITERALLY DONT UNDERSTAND THAT..............
"I know it takes a lot of energy, but can you make a lie for me?"
That's why Disney plus looses billions of dollars
People who don't care about Star Wars didn't watch Andor. Shocker!
@@JarJarAbrams is Andor the only thing on Disney plus? Cause the whole streaming platform is bleeding money and subscribers, not just Andor you clown
He really tried to make Star Wars into Games of Throne, with moral ambiguous Rebels who aren't worth rooting for. Lots of meandering dialogs that tried to be complex like your typical thriller movie where there's way too much talking and taking itself too seriously, but actually lacking substance.
They were definitely trying to make Game of Thrones in space, trying to tap into that audience. But the only thing they achieved was a boring office drama with characters and stories taken from young adult novels for teenage girls set in a depressing city that looks like the soviet union.
@@JarJarAbrams Glad that you get it and are calling it out.
He tried to make an HBO-level show and succeeded. That's why Andor is in position to win awards like no other SW property has been since ESB.
Whether the audience that was raised on the terrible writing and flashy lights of the prequels ever catches up is of no consequence because the second and final season is already in production.
OK jar jar you got my sub only because of the name, it's my favorite name that ruined every franchise that I loved.
It almost feels mean. We made a Star Wars show for not Star Wars fans. We made the Star Wars fans pay for it though 😂
Yeah, that comment of using the down payment of hardcore fans to finance their marxist shit.
@@JarJarAbrams Maybe the other shit but Andor is pretty far from Marxist, the whole of Ferrix is a free trade capitalist planet which while having strong community is pretty far from socialism.
@@StickNik It''s literally a bunch of greasy communists fighting the patriarchy to allow gay marriage.
@@JarJarAbrams I think you might just be a little paranoid this time around.
@@JarJarAbrams who are the "greasy communists" in Andor and what describes them as such?
Also, same question with "patriarchy".
People who saw Andor and liked it... were you even paying attention? It's made out of cropped plots from finished scripts of Star Wars Underworld that never saw the light of day, and all of these subplots don't amount to a story. It's just really good actors doing random stuff inside with blasters. It has nothing to do with Star Wars, except the fact that it is somewhat placed in an unnecessarily realistic version of that universe.
It's a complete failure as a Star Wars story and product, and as a story or product on its own. It simply has more professional production than most of Filoni's absolute amateur trash.
I have mentioned this on other channels, but another thing I have noticed with Andor, and all of the other Disney Star Wars shows and movies, is that the characters do not talk like Star Wars characters. According to some interviews from George Lucas and other reports, he took inspiration from classical acting from the Golden Age of Hollywood (1930s and 1940s). Look at films like Casablanca or Gone With The Wind (or any of the Flash Gordon or Buck Rogers film serials), then watch any of Lucas' original six films and I believe you will notice the similarities. I always thought that was a genius idea to take classical acting and put it in another galaxy. However, once Disney took over and Lucas left, Star Wars no longer feels like "a galaxy far, far away" anymore. The characters talk more like people on Earth with current vernacular and swear words (the word "shit" used in Andor, for instance). Current vernacular works in shows like the Expanse because it takes place in our galaxy and most of the people come from Earth. But it doesn't work when you put it in Star Wars. Now before you say anything, I know that Han Solo said the word "Hell" in A New Hope and Empire Strikes Back. The difference between that and what Disney is doing is that Star Wars was still finding its footing in 1977 and 1980. By the time you get to Return of The Jedi in 1983 and the prequels in 1999 up to 2005, the characters stopped saying that word. Now it's commonplace for them to not say "Hell" because they are from a different galaxy, so they would not know any of our religions, thus not use "Hell" as a swear word.
Yes, they removed all the classic aspects of Star Wars, even the shooting is too modern for Star Wars. But that's what marxists do, they hate classicism.
Thanks again for the reply, JJ. Sorry for the late response. Hope you do more videos soon. Ahsoka is airing at the moment. That should give you plenty of material to rip apart.@@JarJarAbrams
Dude dont compare Andor to the rest of the Disney shows. Andor is a great take on the star wars universe that I didn't know i needed. Also the style of acting that George used in the first 6 films would be really outdated now. It wouldn't work and most people would view it as too childish now.
I would argue that Andor and all the other D-wars shows are more childish than anything from Lucas' six films. The style of acting may appear outdated to you, but to me, and a lot of other fans, it fits with that galaxy. By trying to make the characters in Star Wars talk more like the characters in Expanse or Ron Moore's Galactica ruins the point of the saga. It's supposed to have that golden age style acting and by taking it away, you are destroying part of the saga's DNA.@@vice2versa
You can't just set some garbage story in space, throw in some storm troopers and then call it Star Wars. Well, Disney can , but it's never any good when they do. The bottom line is that Disney Star Wars isn't real Star Wars. It was never meant to be an endless slog through every minute corner of the galaxy. It was meant to be a saga with a definite beginning and ending.
Disney Star Wars will never be Star Wars but they at least tried to fake it with the previous attempts. With Andor, they were very open about the fact this thing is not made for Star Wars fans. It's some stupid soap opera for liberal women piggy backing on Star Wars fans without any shame. It's literal franchise parasiting.
@@JarJarAbrams why their attempts at faking Star Wars don't have the same effort as Gilroy does? He said he doesn't take the audience for granted in the same interview and that they're never cynical about Star Wars. Honestly that's all people are asking for at this point, stop with formulaic corporate writing.
Andor is star wars.
Andor is NOT Star Wars.
Che Guevara is Star Wars for people who hate Star Wars and want to feel like they like Star Wars, so that they can tell their Star Wars friends to watch it and make them just as miserable as the rest of us are when we’re watching a Disney+ show regardless of whether it’s ultra serious or stupid and silly. If you want good serious Star Wars stories learn to read.
@@lukeskywalker6809 It's not your TYPICAL Star Wars, but it's still Star Wars.
a lot of "Star Wars-resistant" people don't know the Expanded Universe, it's like that, he didn't brought any quality that Star Wars was lacking but in the disney canon certainly was better, even if i just watch the first four episodes because i didn't see anything to kept me going forward
I enjoyed the first three episodes but they are definitely the least eventful of the bunch. The series absolutely has some massive payoffs. However if you just weren't a fan of the tone, thats fine too.
@@shadowtrooper3764 i enjoy the tone, but the fourth resulted boring to me and didn't make want to continue
@@augusto____ the episodes work in arcs, essentially (not so short) movies. 1-3, 4-6, 7 is a sort of bridge episode, 8-10, and 11-12. If you liked the tone I'd recommend trying to push through at least through episode 6, but to each their own.
@@augusto____ Andor was amazing and if u couldn't watch ep 4 then i guess HBO style storytelling isn't your thing then.
@@vice2versa when you say that Andor is amazing that's your opinion, the shows of HBO are not the same, even when the style can be similar, the reason that determines whether you're gonna watch something or not depends of each person and not necessarily a general aspect