I didn't think I'd see Asian boss become a propaganda channel. Asian boss has an agenda. Hong Kongers are manipulative racists and it amazes me anyone would take what they say at face value.
Why is everyone ignoring the fact that a girl got murdered and the man who did it went to hongkong and he's leaving the prison soon? This was never mentioned on the news in my country.
Because they are all anti-China propanda video to weaken China and Hong Kong people fell for it. Remember the opium war which brought famine to China by the British?
There had been multiple crimes already in recent years, same story, boyfriend takes girlfriend to Taiwan to murder her, then go back HK live on happily forever. This law is really necessary in my point of view, but the politicians made the whole thing political and relate it to China wanting to kidnap people from HK. This is what they fear for themselves. The young people are influenced by them.
Because Taiwan already told HK Government that it will not accept the arrangement. So even if the bill passed, the man will not be extradited to Taiwan.
What happened is just an excuse for China to do something it’s been wanting to do for a while, it’s not because of the murder at all, just a happy coincidence as far as China is concerned.
There are a tonne of people who always cry "bias" on every video regardless of country. They seem to miss the whole point about street interviews and a 13 minute video done by volunteers. smh
"We believe having meaningful discussions with people with different opinions is extremely important." Okay, then where's the video for the other side?
The teenage girl and mom hit me so hard when they were saying that everybody likes the police back in the day and now they cannot trust them and dont feel safe anymore.....
I' ve seen a video that a riot try to grab a police's gun. And he got shot by the police. However someone distorted the true and said the teenager got shot for nothing. They edit the video by deleting the first couple of second, so the people only see the picture while the police firing and ignore the fact that the police have no choice at all, because if the potester grab his gun, god know what would happen. I am pretty sure in any country, especially in USA, trying to grab a police's gun will be shot to death. These riots deserve it.
I agree on the idealism of democracy, however, something is wrong about this protest or riot.. Pushing kids to the front line, burning a man only because he does not agree on the protester, Using a brick to kill a cleaner who try to clean the barricade.....The rioter even threaten to kill the police's family.. If you guys see more news, you can easily realize that it's not only protest any more. This is not justice, this is evil, using democracy as its mask.
Jiayu He okay but why did the officer have his gun out in the first place??? literally no immediate threat and he pulls his gun out??? if you really did see all the footage you would notice that and there’s countless of evidence of police threatening rape and death on protesters, as well as hurting innocent civilians. you alright over there??
I am a Chinese Singaporean. I do not wish to comment on Hong Kong politics because I have no knowledge and no right to do so. Your interviews appear to be objectively conducted and reported compare to some other news agencies. However, other than the interviews of the ordinary citizens that were too briefed and too few in numbers, it will be good to also interview parties from the other sides, namely the Government, Police, the people who work in the public transport system, etc. From many other news reports and videos, I can see that many so-called peaceful protesters are damaging - and also set fires upon - government buildings, MTR stations and its facilities, blocking roads, disrupting the normal operation of its airport, attacking police with many types of weapons, and also attack others who express different opinions from them. Further, accusations about the Police brutality and oppressing the protesters with extreme excessive force, and the rumoured death of many protesters must be substantiated with evidence, lest it can continue passing it as real incidents and it can be prejudiced against the authorities. Finally, I believe the interviewees ought to be made known about how other nations’ police force handle their own protesters and rioters, especially those police force in the supposedly democratic western world, like the USA, UK, Germany, and France, etc, so that the interviewees can interpret - and appreciate - more accurately the notion of police brutality.
This isn't the BBC or CNN etc. This is a RUclips channel run by civilian volunteers. Those expectations are more appropriate for news organisations that are established with an abundance of resources and networks to gain access to those kinds of sources. AB make short 13 minute videos. It's not Panorama. There are street interviews so it is purely opinion based. Furthermore, knowing about how other countries treat people doesn't mean you shouldn't expect certain things from your own. Just because police may be worse elsewhere in comparison, certain behaviours shouldn't be excused just because it's not as bad as elsewhere. That's just ridiculous. If you are looking for a more in-depth report covering more sources from all sides, I recommend you look at more established and popular news organisations.
Hong Kong Chinese here those violence are true claim for sure, but don't forget that the government are refused to hear the huge voice from protester to withdraw the bill since MAY until SEPTEMBER and police outbreak the excessive forces FIRST on 12 JUNE, before that it's still peace and only outbreak some physical conflicts The fact is after 12 June incident, the bill is still in the pending list while Carrie Lam said "suspend" "bill is dead", it gave no mean to response the 1 demand "withdraw the bill", and protesters keep suffered by the polices' excessive forces, these factors let protesters have no choice but to make the worst scenario happens----occupy the LegCo and add 4 more to let her realise how bad the situation is. moreover, police forces keep claim that incident as riot and refuse to apologise every excessive force they use, even try to avoid the law by covering their identities and arresting innocents and why the violence elevated, it's mostly began from July when police start indiscriminate attacking to the crowd indoors, tolerate and even allowing triads attacking innocents, keep misusing riot control weapons, arresting innocents, undercover infiltrated in illegal protests, suspected torture, dehumanising protesters as cockroaches, unreasonable cancelling protect while making legal protests etc as an advanced city, could those unprofessional and illegal action be tolerated? surely not, and most of the Hong Kong People has no military training for their whole live, and Hong Kong has gifted for having very high level of freedom of protest and speech as well, and they ranked very high compared to other countries' police, they are actually ruin the society more than protester themselves, especially social security. even though there's quite a lot of evidence that Chinese central government has a hand on it, especially treating MTR and Cathay Pacific in words or proposing sanctions, 50 Cents, CCP-based media fake and biased news, and pro-beijing lawmakers and parties, who have quite a lot of relationships to China liaison office, funded triads to operate pro-beijing marches and flash mobs, especially Junius Ho, one of the most radical pro-bejing lawmakers who made Yuen Long incident. that's why protest desperately need government to accept those 5 demands, as it suffer too much on those false claims and the structural problem on both police force and government those violence are more likely an reaction to those incidents and unreasonable claims, and tardiness of response the demands, although it impacts infrastructures and some kind of industry, but I'm sure they deserved that violence, when police can't protect citizens, only vigilances could solves if you think violence can't solve everything, the reality is no matter violence made or not, pro-beijing stakeholders and government still keep its point or even harder to suppress the huge voice, as they have the dominance of the whole political system and backed by Beijing government. that's why the quote “It was you who taught me peaceful marches are useless.” has shown in the damaged LegCo you might think protesters need to make some conversations to the government, sorry, no one believe that, as Carrie Lam has a very bad record on fulfilling promises after agreement created during conversations and making compromises each other, and she's one of the origin for outbreaks umbrella movement, there's no hope to make compromises with her but make compromises by herself to show her sincerity on stopping the protester's madness, she's the only key to stop the rage. why protesters want American assistance is they need a power to balance the power distribution between Chinese government(incl. Hong Kong gov't) and protester themselves, as they have no hope on Beijing to solve but keep flaming them as rioters or making independence, American has the power to give threats to China to truly protect the "one country two system, highly autonomous, rule by Hong Kong people, unchanged for 50 years" promise, as this is the promise of China to Britain, and even the whole world, and also the real universal suffrage with a truly promotion from population and elect themselves, which is promised in the Basic Law itself Lastly, I respect your opinion, and you have enough knowledge to analyse the whole situation, but I'd like you to sincerely accept my points, I have much more information than you got, perhaps mediacorp might not give you too much information about this movement, those reason above might be the core idea of whole protest, and give you another view of the protest instead of vandalism and assaulting other-opinion person
@CuracaoChic Whatever views and decisions you make, you are always right. Therefore: You are right to accept opinion-based reports and not fact-based reports. You are right to apply only subjective test to all situations in life, and disregard and ignore objectivity in all situations, especially in so-called police brutality. You are right that, in order to access to “more in-depth reports covering more sources from all sides”, we should look at more established and popular news organisations. Otherwise, we will have to accept whatever news reports from less established and less popular news organisations. I hope you are happy that I have commented that whatever your views and decisions are, you are always right.
when the girl started to cry... it was like we saw the moment she realized that her whole world got turned upside down. just imagine how many people must feel like her..
@jessicalee you've just been watching the news the government wants you to watch. Attack citizens ? Come on please the soo called victims you watched on TV are triads or associates and attack the protestors first. And not to mention 721, 811, 831, 911 incidents. And now all the deaths the police did and are covering up are surfacing. It seems your the one that's fast to judge on the situation before actually doing research lol. So get off your high horse sunshine
@@jujubae_ Well if they didn't wear a mask then the police will go after them,they are just trying to protect themselves. When you are having a revolution conflicts and fights are inevitable,you need to take that into account. I think they get violent because the police started it first,it's all about self-defense
Because anyone part of the police can only safely express one opinion: that the protesters are wrong and the police are right. Otherwise, they could lose their job. Even just being on camera is too much of a risk.
Kristin Wu is right. If you were a police officer, you would not risk such a thing especially as your job at stake. if you had even an inkling of a doubt of that stopping the protest is wrong, you would have quit your job and became a protester instead. Also I imagine on AsianBoss side, it's risky enough having the protester be interviewed. What's the point of interviewing the police when their action already speak their view. An anonymous interview sounds promising but it's not something many officers would take, assuming AsianBoss would even find one. I don't think it's a good thing to generalize the entire police force despite all of what I just typed, but for individual opinions it's only worthwhile to get the protesters' side in my opinion.
Asian Boss could you please interview Macau about this issue. They're a Special Administrative Region as well, yet media never shows how they feel about these protests.
HahahaDRY Macau actually loves China, every year the government gives the people a lot of 💴 now that it’s given back to China, since they didn’t when it was a Portuguese colony
let me put it this way, Macau isn't an internationalised place compared to Hong Kong. And most of Macau people have Portugal Passport. They are just opposing what Hongkongers're doing because they can go where they want in EU when they unsatisfied with PRC China. And you pointed something important here. PRC China thinks Macau is a successful example of running one country two system. This is exactly the convict arises between China and Hongkongers
@15Y6C41 LI SHUYAO Stop spinning the problem to housing and the economy!!! Red-Developers are the biggest land hoarder in Hong Kong right now. There is no doubt that trigger of the riot in 1967 is the Labor Dispute. But the trigger of this initial protest is nothing but the amendment bill which is PURELY political stuff. Go to a book shop and buy a book namely, the dictators' learning curve. And you understand everything. I sponsor you with 50 cents!
Sorry, I dont agree on what they said at last. A real report should cover all the aspects. You only asked the protests and ordinary hong kong citizens who are not biased , however the protests will never confess you everything, which means it is biased. So, for showing us your justice, please interview the police side and the mainland Chinese's views
If Asian boss wants to bring this to the world, DON'T BE BIASED. Reveal opinions from different sides. It's not that people in mainland China are completely blind by the internet censorship. It's not all Hong Kongers favor the protestors' sides. People want peace. Violence comes from both sides, but the Chinese police side is more a passive reactive side because those protestors are affecting normal life of a regular hongkonger. Shame on those who keep stimulating riots
@@Oggyoggy2833 Lmao you are basically asking asian boss to ask mainland chinese the issue of hk in china and imagine what will happen,they will be arrested if anyone even tries to side with hk,even if some mainland chinese wanna be truthful they will have no choice but to fake their loyalty to the party. You still gonna get inaccurate opinions at the end of the day because they cant voice their real thoughts.
@@Oggyoggy2833 the mainland Chinese citizens views doesn't matter as the issue originated in Hong Kong, and concerns only the Hong Kong citizens and the Hong Kong government. The police views also doesn't matter as they are just following government orders. Even if someone from the police support the protest they cannot do so as a government servant. They could have got the view of the government, but it is already known to the public.
@@maceydullas4098 the forests in parts of indonesia is burning the air quality in Indonesia Malaysia Singapore Brunei and parts of Thailand is getting worse
@@VaYomerHashem who are you referring to? I am from Hong Kong, and according to my knowledge (as a local) the majority of Hong Kong adores Taiwan and Japan.....
@@dartagnan9094 So in your opinion everyone that agrees with anything China says is a Wumao and the 50 million Chinese that lives overseas are all wumaos as well? lol.
i dont think theyd be allowed to. its such a sensitive topic so to get authorities to talk at all to them on this topic would be shooting themselves in the foot.
Yes a Hong Kong police officer's perspective will be well-added. I'm sure {as I watched this video from Sydney Australia} that there are police in Hong Kong who are abusing their power and attacking the protesters and committing crimes {like making murder of suspected off duty protesters look like suicide} + participating in corruption before ALL these protests started. I remember watching on the NEWS the image of *THAT ONE* police officer who was ambushed by protesters and beaten with a long stick and held in a head-lock. Good *HONEST* police anywhere deserve to feel safe and have the right to know they won't die on duty. I agree with the protesters that Hong Kong needs an independent commission against corruption to investigate police that can be reported safety and anonymously by honest police OR by their citizens *JUST LIKE IN AUSTRALIA* . 🙋♂️🗣💬🔮🎭👮♂️
Please feel free to go on the HK Police's Facebook Page. They hold "press conference" every day which they tell lies blatantly, e.g. this week they claim their staff was just kicking an "yellow object" in the back alley... and they don't know what the "object" is. While in reality it was a middle aged man in yellow vest who got dragged away from the reporters and got kicked by a dozen of police in his head.
Asian boss, there's a Massive student rally from all over Indonesia regarding the new controversial Bill by legislative & executive. Please do a video about them.
@@lizbennet90 this people called *cebong* in Indonesia. All negatif thing about government is *hoax* for them and Mr. Zo ko Wie is like holy human that never wrong.
I would recommend you send an email or reach out them through other methods rather than just leaving a comment here. You know how difficult to spot a comment in RUclips, eh?
Abigail Yang that’s the point, the government won’t listen.. i remember someone describe HK as a crying baby, because the *mother* doesn’t care, and what happens? the baby’s cry will become stronger and louder
zGBz BIoT Yes. One policeman almost got his neck chopped off. The youths in the riots look very similar to the story “Lord Of the Flies” by William Goldings. Whatever you try to beautify your lawlessness and criminal acts, these are criminal offences, young protesters, what you are doing is to injure your own future. No country will accept you even if you migrate. Not Malaysia, not Taiwan, not Singapore, not Germany, not Australia, not the United States (they are particularly against Asian immigrants who are taking their jobs) and last of all your beloved UK (you must decide which part to go to England, Scotland or Northern Ireland. After Brexit, they might not be one but if you migrate early you might be able to participate in their protests. Chère the Police do not tolerate violence and they use live firearms). Of UK is keen to take you in, they would not only offer six-month BNO instead of full passports which Portugal have to Macau which will allow them to go to any part of the EU, including the UK, until Brexit. And yet not many people in Macau take up the offer. Trust me,’the best place for Hong Kong for Hong Kongers is Hong Kong and ironically, GuangZhou and surroundings because you can continue to speak Cantonese. Hong Kong is an odd man out in terms of Chinese speaking ex-colonies are concerned. In Singapore, they are happy to be able to speak English in first language, Mandarin, Cantonese and Hokkien as a second language and Malay as a third language. In Malaysia, their first language is Malay and the others are at second language level. They can go anywhere they want to. Even Taiwan has a dialect and Mandarin. They can find the best part of China to go to or Singapore or Malaysia. Hong Kongers are funny creatures. You do not like places who welcome you but you rather go to places who despise you. Who would want to take in as citizens modern versions of the Red Guards?
The protesters conveniently forgot to mention the destruction and trouble they caused to innocent civilians, and the verbal abuse and physical injury they inflicted on civilians who disagreed or showed signs of physical opposing them, Eg the old man on the street and the young man outside JPMorgan. And the vigilante justice they are meting out, Eg, the taxi driver who knocked down 2 protesters in his way.
You mean the old man who was trying to beat protesters with a bottle? Yeah I'm not sure why the banker was beat-up aside from his pro-China affiliations, that did seem overkill. I mean when you can't trust the police to do their job, and there's been more than one taxi driver case. You have one where they just plowed into people intentionally.
@@ronochow I don't think problems can be satisfied solved after 5 demands are met since this politic movement is being out of control and more and more outside politic powers are involved under the long term propagating of anti ccp(including ytub). I don't object all kinds of non violent protest but I really don't want to see the tragedy happened as similar as arabi spring movement. HK people should think higher and further instead of blackmailed by politician plot. China is already very open on everything except politic system, this could be a new door of activator on CH gov. reform rather than attack and hatred.
Take off your masks and stop the crimes of violence. STOP doing STUPID thing. Help the family of the HK's girl who have been killed to catch the murderer as soon as possible. Otherwise you are not qualified to say that others are rude.
@@nicolesit4330 Rudeness is mutual, people say rude things to you because they are offended. Don't always expect other people to agree with you when you yourself are not informed of both side of the story, and insult others because they won't change their mind
Asian Boss, please cover about HAZE caused by forest burning in Indonesia. For almost two decades now, every single year the livelihood of neighbor countries such as Singapore, Malaysia and Brunei suffered from haze. Edit: I want to hear real people's opinion on real issues and that's what Asian Boss does best. For example, why is haze happening in Indonesia every single year, affecting neighbouring countries. How they feel about the haze. What exactly the authorities have done to curb this. The people's opinion for the best solution to stop the open burning/haze etc. etc.
as usual Malaysians are always complaining about smoke & blaspheming Indonesia ... but when Indonesia's forests are not burning why don't you give praise or at least gratitude because our forests provide the oxygen you breathe?
you indonesian always like this when thing got bigger trying to get away and throw thing at us where are your sanity?lack of intelligence to think of others isnt just malasyia got into the trouble but other neighbour country as well
@@hetzatheofany2235 Complaining were mostly aimed to the person responsible/related with the haze (the farmers/company/the authorities disregarding their nationality). We don’t have anything against the unrelated innocent by-standers as many countries including yours are affected and suffered from the damn haze. FYI, last week Indonesia refuse to accept Malaysia's offer to help fight the fire 🤔 Praise and be grateful to Indonesia for the oxygen provided for us? Enough with the ‘proud’ ‘takbur’ ‘high and mighty’ mentality. Ain’t nobody got time for that.
I'm Singaporean , thanks to Hong Kong rioters now Singapore has replaced Hong Kong as a safe haven to do business and live in, for Westerners and Asians. Hong Kong economy has also fallen and currency value dropped , Singapore has over taken Hong Kong. Thank you HK rioters.
Hence is bias cause other non protester never got the chance. Not the whole of Hong Kong are protesters. Most people in chat believes that the police are some sort of monsters when they are far from it.
Was waiting on this to come about but I thought it might also be too dangerous to cover at the same time. Great insight. Thanks Asian Boss. Also finally get to understand something without subtitles ahaha
hi asian boss, first of all, thank you so much for always giving people more insight about current affairs in Aisa, especially now that you're covering the protests in Hong Kong. However, if you guys are gonna make another video about this issue in Hong Kong, I would really love to see you guys interview other parties as well, because on social media these days, we are mainly bombarded by the opinions of the protesters, but we rarely see information/ opinions from e.g. the police (not just their official representatives on the news lol) , the shopkeepers in affected areas, the residents in certain places, or maybe even the family members of the police/protesters as well. It would be nice if we could gain a more comprehensive understanding of the whole situation as well from multiple parties :D But again, thank you so much for covering this, I hope that you guys can still be a source of unbiased and comprehensive news for viewers all around the world!!! :D
@ beside the police this guy has raised mamy interesting opinions. I think is only to give the audience a comprehensive look into the effect of the protest as it has effected many not just the protesters.
Very good episode. Well done! The interview with the mother and young women was particularly touching. She is a good mother to stand by and allow her daughter to express herself, and work through some very difficult emotions. The young women's poise and thoughtful analysis is proof of excellent parenting and education. It is amazing, and challenges my grasp on reality, that it is possible for a government to ignore so many people; to press ahead with an agenda that so many of its citizens are overtly against.
You know what? Have you seen how those rioters keep on using violence to destroy the city and attack innocient people? You know nothing but just being misled by this so called episode? STUPID!
For the girl who is considering to immigrate, my suggestion is to do it right now. HK is part of China and mainland will never allow HK to be separated. This is a fact no matter if you accept or not. So if you are unsatisfied with HK police or current HK situation, please immigrate to another country you like, maybe UK or US. Just a question for you. For the same situation happened in UK or US, how will their policemen deal with it? Will you satisfied with that?
That isn’t exactly true however Asian boss did show the true intentions of the young protestors whether it is right or wrong. Notice how most of them that were interviewed were young. Again I still applaud Asian boss for tell us the true concerns of these youngsters not all the BS western media likes to frame it.
100 Videos And No Subscribers well to understand the truth, you have to go see yourself. A lot of ‘the other parties’ are we’re not present and did not see what the police/ government did. There are a lot of recorded evidence but no other media seem to dare to put it into their accounts. And most of these evidence gets deleted very quickly.
there already is an equity conclusion. hong kong remains a democracy and china leaves it alone. the only long-term solution is for hong kong to join taiwain, us, uk, or another democratic country.
A mistake everyone is making the extradition bill has not been officially withdrawn. You should correct that. ALSO protesters are ordinary Hong Kong citizens. In Carrie Lam's press statement on Sep 04, she said it will be withdrawn once parliament reopens in October.
Andi Cee it has been officially withdrawn on the 4th of September you dumbass. ALSO the protestors are beating up citizens who are against their opinions.
Did you not watch the news that the proposed bill had been officially withdrawn? This is why the protests do not end, the riotors are running out of legitimate excuses. Yesterday there wer news that they are attacking shops and restaurants. On what grounds do the mobs have to exert such violence on ordinary citizens and normal businesses? Even if we hold different political views, this does not give anyone the super authority to override the laws and basic civility. Really shameless mobs!
Well the article I saw set that it has been officially withdrawn. So do you have any other information that it hasn't? I mean like a link or something?
Regardless the reasonable intentions of these protestors, does not justify their violence and adverse impact on other people living in Hong Kong. Crime is crime.
Is there going to be one called "We talked to the Hong Kong Police" or "We talked to the everyday Hong Kong people who are not protesters (rioters)" because this only shows one side of the whole story.
@@dxelson how do you know they didn't? maybe the interviewer did ask or some interviewees mentioned about waving flags buy they excluded that part of the video. I was just curious because I have watched it and saw the scence that they waving western flags (but didn't know someone is stupid enough to not understand my simple question or you just act dumb. I have no idea 😉)
@@cattcatt6795 must be sad liking your own comments and stalking users 😂. P.s I don't even know how I'm subbed to him since he doesn't even appear on my feed lmao. Even if they did you expect them to reply saying they did but decided to exclude it hurting their reputation? Who's the dummy here lmaooo
Many people on mainland China seem to die from the most ridiculously supposed suicide or from the daftest accidents. The excuses are more stupid that ‘the dog ate my homework’ and I think because they’re so far fetched, people aren’t questioning them. Obviously the mainland police are butting into Hong Kong. They all share ideas and use the same tricks. I feel very saddened for the people of Hong Kong. I have a hospital appointment tomorrow and shall be wearing my ‘free HK 🇭🇰 ‘ t shirt!
Those suicides are suicides lol...I was there at the Pacific Place one, the emergency people set up an inflatable thing and the person jumped and missed the inflatable. Idk whether the person did it on purpose or by accident but you can’t blame that on anyone else. Also why would they need to ‘disappear’ these people? These are not important instigators, if they really wanted to fake a suicide they’d do it to someone more important
@@AbsoluteMiniacGena Yes it's horrible. There're more than 10,000ppl die everyday in China. What an evil government. Why don't you come and save us? Don't you have mercy?
@@Bella-rz5vh The police hasn't killed anyone. In 1967, under British rule, British police killed more than 10 people and arrested more than the Hong Kong Police.
@@liqiller seem like you know history but not the present. Uyghurs re dying in china's camp. Number of uyghurs talking here is a MILLION people. they killing they own people and then u talking the police did not kill anyone, did you watch the new the hk police did the interview with korea news? oh sure the police did not kill anyone :)) FYI: if you like to learn some history here is some "tiananmen square 1989 ".
@@Bella-rz5vh Of course I know about that 1989 incident. You probably just know some of "facts", such as the military killed a lot of students and stuff. I am telling you, it is made up by the Western media. On the way to Tiananmen square, the military did countered some students and there were conflict. Some students were killed on the way, and some soldiers were being burned. At the Tiananmen Square, there is real footage that the students and the military had a peaceful agreement, then the students marched out of the Tiananmen Square peacefully. After a few years, even some student activists admitted it. I believe that the students were controlled by Western countries like USA. Cuz right after the incident, so many students fled to America, holding an American passport (it was very hard to leave China as a citizen at that time). So? What do you think?
@@liqiller peaceful agreement with tanks inside the city?? they re real footage. How can you say it a incident?? its a massacre.That's why people called Tiananmen square massacre. You can not even talk or mention about that massacre in china or you can not even search pooh bear because its been banned. Whos care about economy worse when you dont even have basic human right. Human right is which you should be learn in school or maybe they dont even teach that.
its not safe... lol my friend is currently working in HK.. him and his wife are considering moving back to mainland. someone just got beaten up straight for speaking mandarin under his building.
カリム HKer speaks Cantonese, but mainlanders speaks mandarin. Because a lot of HK protesters hate the mainlanders, anyone who speaks mandarin may be in danger of getting cursed or even beat up. That includes Taiwanese and some overseas Chinese, although they speak mandarin with slightly different accents. I know, it’s crazy!
It'd be tough to get an interview with the police, due to their job security and personal safety, but I think that would make this a more balance and complete reporting. The police, for the most part, are following order from the government, as it is their profession. They have been trained to follow order, so when the government defined certain protesters action has broken the law, it is their professional duty to take action. But, as many of the protesters mentioned, they are now being blame for the abusive of power. Hong Kong police are also Hong Kong's citizen with ordinary family, and many of them have young children who perhaps have view similar to, or align with the protester's view. in other words, many of them are being caught in the middle between their family and their professional duty. Their view/ their perspective would give this reporting another dimension that is unique, and perhaps, provide some insight that are missing from almost all other reporting.
Although I agree that most of them are there for their jobs, many of them have been recorded to be doing things that far exceed what they're expected of their jobs. Just recently there had been an incident where a man was arrested and dragged into an alleyway to be beaten up by a large group of cops, concrete video evidence showing this. The next day the cops twisted it and said that the police were actually kicking "a yellow object", not a person by any means, which is a very blatant lie. Moving away from the individual level the police force as an institution is also highly flawed, with many of the officers refusing to show their warrant cards when making arrests, nor wearing their ID badges when in uniform. This removes the accountability that is absolutely essential in checking the power of a group that is enforcing the law. So yeah, HKPF is super flawed in its current state.
Sounds like you know the situation of some of the police members quite well. Close friends or family perhaps? They could well be interviewed under anonymity, they just need to show their badge or staff card without revealing the ID/serial number.
I totally support you guys. Freedom is what we all fight for. So many revolution in the past were for this reason. Fight before it's too late. And as the guy in the video said, revolution can be violent and can upset the economy but for the future of your younger generation, it is inevitable. I dont think anyone globally should condemn protesters in any country because it is not us who are living in the hell you are in right now. So 加油! But please also look after the hong kongers who are innocent by standers.
As a protesters, I also agree to interview those police as long they have good reasons and they are calm. That’s what we are fighting for, to have freedom of speech
@@fyerraCommunism is hell. No freedom of speech nor actions or else you end up locked up and even executed. We are all human beings of equal standards, who are they to execute or CONTROL us? What kind of a government are they when they cannot accept criticism? That's Hell when in your short lifetime, you cannot live freely as you want. Have you heard about the book writers and sellers who mysteriously disappeared from their Hong Kong homes because they were publishing articles about the chinese president? The chinese governments are hypocrites.
Please so listen to the police force too. I believe not just protesters are injured, police are also. Can you imagine a group of protesters beat just one police too.
Gee I wonder why a group of protesters would beat a policeman who have been throwing tear gas canisters at them, have been nothing but violent at them, have caused them harm and have treated them like dirt... wow, I freaking wonder why protesters would feel the need to beat a policeman who has done nothing but oppress them. GEE poor policeman boohoooo
The protests on Hong Kong reminds me of the protesters in Gwangju during May the 18th. As a Korean, I am currently choosing to be neutral about the protests. However, the government really needs to listen to the people, or else they would have to pay a higher price.
@@shootingguard7321 So, okay. Like a few decades ago, South Korea had to face many dictatorships. Hundreds of protests were made throughout the country. The most famous protests were the ones made in the city of Gwangju during May 1980. As the protests got bigger and bigger, then the infamous dictator, president Jun Du Hwan declared all the protesters "communists," roadblocked Gwangju to make sure nobody escapes, and ordered immediate arrest on all the people of Gwangju. (Including innocent citizens who had nothing to do with this). Then the people made their own army, armed themselves with stolen weapons, and started fighting against the government. Many were killed or arrested that day.
When we look at these protests we have to remember that as with any big demographic, their views are all over the place. Some are very thoughtful, recalling that the protests began as peaceful rallies that the government attempted to ignore, and that this is the boiling point of Hong Kong's various societal problems and goes way beyond the now-dead extradition bill. Some also recall the swift government response to past instances of civil unrest in the 1960s, and that today's HKP was caught inexperienced and unprepared for this level of discontent. Others are full of irrational hate and looking for enemies to blame for the very violence that they started, forgetting that all police actions are in fact reactions to events and environments. They talk laws and procedures, but they've lost the moral high ground by calling all police corrupt and screaming "colourful greetings" to their mothers at every confrontation. Many, especially the younger students who have not learned the nuances of fact-checking and professional journalism, are obviously influenced by social media echo chambers, spewing rumours such as police murdering detainees, with no basis in reality.
I do not agree with what some of the protesters have done (more so because they're sabotaging their own cause), but then if we look at it from another perspective we don't know just what they might have gone through to make the feel as if they've reached that breaking point. The majority are peaceful. I'm a mainlander and I fully support their cause and I hope this wave of democracy will spread to the mainland.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 Exactly. 3 of the 5 things that HKers are asking for are good things, but the fringe rioters are hurting the chances of those things being achieved (I patently disagree with the remaining 2 as they are a dangerous step towards mob rule). Also, the constant spread of fake news is counter-productive.
@@canto_v12 If by "remaining two" you're talking about the removal of the term "riots" and universal suffrage, I've got to say that I am supportive of all five demands being addressed. The HK Basic Law says that "Hong Kongers shall govern Hong Kong", but the CCP deliberately twists these words by appointing local officials but CCP sanctioned. It's a very clever use of ambiguity of language. If they really wanted universal suffrage for Hong Kong, they'd say something like "Hong Kongers elected through universal suffrage in the city shall be responsible for governance." It's this fear of a lack of clarity and the CCP's strategic ambiguity in politics and law that made HK so fearful in the first place. Mainland China has got no rule of law, the Party is the country and can dictate anything according to its will. Since it lacks a religious or at least a humanist framework, there are absolutely no moral or ethical constraints as to what they'll do. I am aware of the fact that a CCP proposal for HK's political reform was rejected by the pan-democrats a year after the Occupy movement (2015). I believe it was right for the pan-democrats to have rejected the CCP and not compromised because the CCP simply cannot be counted on their word whether towards mainlanders, HK / TW / Macau, or the world. They said they weren't going to militarize the South China Sea but now they're building bases for ships and aircraft on the Spratlys and harassing their Asian neighbors. You've got to understand that if the US has been a wolf, the CCP is a wolf in sheep's clothing. The latter's far more dangerous. If the CCP become the most powerful country in the world, it'll be an authoritarian world where they'll hold military, political, and economic leverage at unprecedented levels. I also don't believe universal suffrage would descend into "mob rule". I don't want to sound like an ethnic supremacist, and I am not, but us Chinese on average are an intelligent people capable of coming together and making decisions. If we go back to our own history and culture, Daoism teaches us that we must follow the natural flow of society, to find order within chaos and to not seek excessive control over everything. Even Confucianism, in theory, teaches that a ruler must be benevolent in order to rule, and that his subjects have the right to choose their ruler and oppose tyranny. It's the politicized version of Confucianism practiced in feudal China that emphasized more on the parts about hierarchy and obedience while deliberately not paying attention to the parts that call for the ruler to govern well and for the people to keep tabs on their ruler. I also believe it would be unfair to characterize these protests as "riots". It would be especially unfair to the majority of the protesters who have been peaceful. I don't know if the especially violent ones should be severely punished and I don't know what and if their punishment should be. Overall, I would like HK to go all the way, and I hope that one day the mainland will have the spirit of the republic revived.
3:10 "There was an HK man who murdered his HK girl friend when they were in Taiwan..." The crime was done in Taiwan, and HK could not prosecute the killer for murder. Taiwan could not prosecute the killer because he is in HK. Thus they needed an extradition treaty with Taiwan to properly prosecute the killer. To the family of the dead girl: "Tough Luck!"
Too bad they slipped in an extradition to China as well and to be tried for any major crime (definition of 7 years). Any unsanctioned protest is labelled "riot" and therefore carries a punishment of "7 years". Hrmmm. I'm sure HK people would not have a problem with the extradition to Taiwan only. However mainland China is basically concentration camps, death and organ harvesting.
@@ronochow Why worry about the Bill ? If you obey the law and there is no way you can be extradited to China .How can HongKong ppl being so easily fooled ?
@@ronochow what kind of miserable life you had that makes you easily describe an country with 1.4 billion human beings as "concentration camp," "organ harvest". This is 2019, but your narrow mind still sounds shocking.
@@victorx1731 fam not to be rude but the systemic oppression of ethnic minorities in Xinjiang and Tibet as well as the draconian measures the regime has for maintaining order makes it hard to get excited about extradition for minor offenses such as rioting. This is never a wholesale judgement of the chinese or the history and culture of mainland China. It is however an assessment of how CCP-led china deals with dissidents, and it is brutal.
Munkhbileg N I haven't been to HK since the 1960's. Back then they were protesting against the British and not waving the Union Jack and singing the British national anthem. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@nmbileg It is better off with the British. The PRC is what happens when wealth meets a government that has no checks and balance guaranteeing civil rights. The PRC can only publicize lifting it's citizens out of extreme poverty as improving their human rights. The right not to be hungry, the right to have shelter, etc. 😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞
@@umovie24ma The 1960's Hong Kong protestors were anti-British red infiltrators?? They were pretending to be fleeing the PRC to Hong Kong, but were secretly loyal to the CPC?? Plausible. In Hawaii, we know the Red Chinese have spy networks among the Chinese communities. Watch old episodes of Hawaii 5-O. Sometimes Inspector McGarret has meetings with the leader of the the Red Chinese spy ring where he asks the Red Chinese Spy Master to give up a fugitive Chinese criminal. 😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐
What a classic example of how annoying these protesters are. When Carrie Lam announced the Bill was dead, they said "dead" is not a official legal term, they demanded "Withdrawal". Now Carrie Lam compromised by announcing Withdrawal publicly, they said the Bill has not been officially withdrawn.
@@livinology Because a Bill is a legal thing and every action taken to it HAS to be legally correct. And if you do know clearly how withdrawing a bill in the Legco works you know that if the bill hasn't pass through Legco it isn't withdrawn. This is about correctness and accuracy in every single step. What the CE says is not any kind of legal confirmation and so nothing is firmly set until the Legco announce official withdrawal.
Eh... Cuz no one trusts Carrie Lam. That is why. There are urbanisation plains in Hong Kong that Lam planning to demolish the places. She promised the citizens to preserve them, then the next moment she just demolished them haha 😂 Nothing about the protest, it's just everyone (nothing politics) hates her for not promising things.
Regarding the girl's eye got shot incidence, these people say that the police officers were aiming at her eyes intentionally. Apparently these people have got 0 experience on using guns. I support 民主(it is not 100% equal to democracy), which means that the people make the decisions. However, crimes are crimes, riots are riots. No matter what you want the government know, what you have done wrong is simply wrong, and there is no excuse for that.
I don’t understand why Asian Boss almost ask the rioters’s thoughts . I watched lots of videos about HK events. These rioters destroy and damage HK. I shame on them
@ ，I'm Hongkonger. I'm one of the millions Hongkongers who refuse the cold blooded rioters! pls respect the human right, freedom, the voice... of the majority.
@@aw888492 people like you only gas-light and mention the violent protesters and thugs, how about mentioning the peaceful protestors too? And those who were harmed/killed because they believe in what they stand? Hello? How about supporting peaceful and innocent people too?
road ON peaceful protestor does not get arrested. Or at least not all protestor arrested are peaceful. And there are a lot of violent protesters on streets still need to be arrested. So why protesters are requesting releasing of all protesters?
It's wonderful to see how many people just flush the comment section just to bash Asian boss for making this video. I don't know how many of you are paid or brainwashed or controlled by the Chinese government, but I wish you enjoyed your time outside the great wall! ^^
@Alias Sobriquet haha maybe you find it funny or humiliating to attack something with sexuality, but that just show how uneducated you are :) One more tip to you, attacking someone saying they're gwailo won't do anything, wumao.
@Alias Sobriquet Well, thank you for calling me, a Hong Konger, as gwailo, I never knew you support the independence of Hong Kong! And shhh, don't let the lovely great mother China know about that, she might be angry and you might go missing! I will keep the secret ;)
People have lost their sense of right and wrong. They think that supporting China for their atrocities means patriotism. But taking away the rights of normal civilians is crossing the boundaries and hong kongers are doing the right thing. I wonder how many ccp clowns down at the comments are being paid to bash the coverage of what's going on in hk
kids contribute to society by going to school and becoming educated so that they can go on to university (hopefully) or join the workforce. they have a future
china formally agreed to not interfere with hong kong until 2047. it's only fair for hong kongers to demand their rights back. protest is the only way to get heard against a brutal dictatorship like china. it would be even better if hong kong holds a referendum to join taiwan, us, uk, australia, or another free country.
Although the interview was trying to be objective and neutral, but still ending up biased. 1. we all know the fact that both side has abusively used violence from all the media source, this video mainly chose the comments towards the police violence. Also by arranging those comments at the end of the video, which a more prominent timing that concludes a video clip, this video looks biased. 2. samples' opinion are overly towards to police, out of 6 samples, there's only 1's opinion is saying that protestors are affecting daily life. By knowing that there are so many's daily life been impacted by the protesting, the samples' opinion should be even out to 3:3 for presenting to the viewers and leave it to the viewers to digest the situation. Nothing wrong for a media to express their stands, but please don't be biased when you trying to make the video looks objective.
Well if you'd like a more representative sample, shouldn't you petition the government for a straightforward referendum/election? Wouldn't that solve the supposed problems of bias once and for all?
@@jeffrey8770 that's not likely to be the case when considering how BJ rule their lands. It might be a good reason for revolution, but hurting innocent people with no intention to be part of is another story. It could have be more peaceful time for HK now if these young folks can see hope in their future.
”Aiming at the eye”, why would police want to blind a random protesters eye? in those riots , at those distances,movements and mass crowd, they have a lot of confidence in the police’s technique to be able to aim at one eye under those circumstances. And accusing it of being deliberate without any grounds apart from suspicion, it just doesnt stand
The protest has been going on for three months now. At least thousands of rubber bullets are fired against riotors with hammers and iron bars. It's statistically reasonable that one or more bullets hit their eyes. On the contrary, these masked rioters never mention how many molotovs they have thrown and how many random people have they have beaten up the street
real balance no thanx, its ok. Im in no need of 50 cents. I dont feel that special, this should be common sense but sadly isnt. I would also like to see some evidence regarding the rumour of the fifty cents stuff. Its unrealistic to state that everyone who can do some normal thinking is paid for commenting
Cecillia Yau journalists and first aiders are neutral people not taking a stand on any party, why would they deliberately aim at them rather than people involved in the riots? With these weapons that are not designed to blind an eye? Think! Accidents do happen with these weapons and maybe its a call for designing safer ones, but its unlikely it is deliberate
it is simple. US would like to divide China to prevent its rise. The National Endowment for Democracy (NED) is bankrolling Hong Kong pro-democracy and anti-Beijing groups such as the Solidarity Center, the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and Hong Kong Human Rights Monitor to the tune of millions. Some rioters received sufficient equipment, trainings, advice for local tactics from CIA covert agents.
I live in Canada now, I was once at the wrong place at the wrong time when there was a riot (CNE concert riot, the band did not come and people got angry), and the riot police charged with horses, I ran away as quickly as I could although i just happened to be walking outside the stadium and was not part of the riot When the police ask you to disperse and you do not leave after repeated warning because you are doing nothing, then you are doing "something" by not leaving, and there are consequences
You can't speak for others' circumstances if you weren't there. Canadian riot police showing up to a concert you intentionally chose to go to and had the mental capacity, time, and physical ability to leave. Where a child ending up in an area Hong Kong riot police were at are two entirely different situations. If a protest happened in a shopping center (where the /child/ was sent to buy books), she could have gotten disoriented, lost, or not out of the area in time once she realized what was happening. I don't know if you were a child at your concert, but there are a lot of reasons the police could have taken her to jail that weren't her fault. Simply not being out of an area in time doesn't fault the child and make them deserve jail. Mobs of police and mobs of rioters can impact people's ability to leave an area, even if she wasn't a child. You shouldn't blame a child (especially with an alibi) for what happened to her. She's likely traumatized as is.
I find it hard to respect protesters who destroys their own city, vandalizing here and there in the name of "full democracy". How can the government take you seriously when you are abusing democracy itself with the destruction of the city? It doesn't make sense.
Arvi they were peacefully protesting for months and the Lam chick wouldn’t retract the Extradition Bill. So naturally, like a fire that isn’t extinguished, the situation escalated.
@@EViLSiDE520 That doesn't justify the smashing of stop lights, burning of things, blocking of roads affecting lives of people just working to earn a living for their family, and vandalizing public places. Love of country/city/state/home should be observed even in protests. These violent protesters are destroying the very thing they are trying to save. I'm sure not all protesters are like that. Though some are acting like this is PubG in real life. It's just a sad sight to see.
the title speak for itself, they talk to the protesters, it would be bias if the title said "the truth behind"... what is happening then they just interview one side. Wait for their interviews with other sides of this protest, you cannot squeeze that much information within less than 20 minutes. It is amazing how a 20 minute video could make commenters conclude that the channel is bias and a propaganda, when all their other videos are definitely not bias. Maybe lets go back to Miss Hiroko with her Japanese topics.
Maybe you're not Chinese. If you were Chinese you'll easily sense that they are indeed BIASED. Not because of its title but the attitude toward the incident and the way they're covering it.
you mean the other side of the chinese tourist? i went to these pro china rallys and unsurprisingly....many dont speak proper cantonese and have an accent. i wonder why...
There is no excuse of using violence against the government. Nothing could justify those chaos. If they want to use violence to be independent, that is even ridiculous. HK cannot be independent because all the citizen living depends on the mainland! Those students not only overlook how the city has changed so far but also try to justify those rioters and even claimed they are for the next generation . OMG, they gonna fire HK and rebuild it up on ashes I think. Extremists and racists! Why Asian boss is biased? Because they are interviewing the criminals who destroyed publish safety 100% sure and trying to use those excuse to justify those rioters. Violence cannot be acceptable and justified!!!!
@@常宁-l6v The Joker: "Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos. I'm an agent of chaos. Oh, and you know the thing about chaos? It's fair!"
hmm i think that the bill isn't fair but the way the protestors are protesting is worsening the situation tbh. violence doesn't solve anything and they are just destroying public property. im all for these protests but i feel like violence or destrution isn't really the way.
5 лет назад+12
@@jadesomething5623 Its not like the Police are any better.
Thanks for this interview. It will be nice to have the thoughts of those in the mainland and not only the people living in Hong Kong, so we can have different opinions on this subject.
Most mainland Chinese are spouting the same propaganda: "Shame on Hong Kong." There's media control to such an extent that majority of them don't know the real details and are being fed info to make them believe Hong Kong is lashing out against China or attacking Chinese citizens. That's how it always is in China, media control and the way the government operates teaches the citizens not to ask too many questions, so most of them are in a bubble of ignorance. And as for those that aren't, it isn't safe for them to voice their opinions.
@@chinakachung Your comment show that you didnt live or stay in China and pretend to know China. I suggest you visit China before comment this kind of statement.
You did well, Jonghyun ummm but they are attacking Chinese citizens, did they not? They are attacking people with different views on the situation are they not? That doesn’t seem like very democratic behaviour to me. My parents are both from Hong Kong and I’ve spent a good number of years living there. The behaviour from these rioters are triggered by foreign influence and meddling while a lingering Hong Kong superiority mindset. They want us to fight for democracy and freedom. Ok, well why are they blocking public transit and destroying all the MTR stations? They call storming of the Legislative Council symbolic vandalism. Well, what about everything else they are doing? It looks like JUST vandalism.
Jesse Chan it’s a shame that you fail to understand the essence of the protests, but I would love to further discuss this with you. May I offer a reminder that these protests began peaceful. 2 million marched on the street, however their opinions were simply ignored by the government. May I also remind you of the Umbrella Revolution in 2014 - peaceful sit ins... resulted in the protestors voices being ignored. If a protest were to not have any impact on any person’s lives, what point is there to it? If everyday life went on as normal, then what can the protest possibly achieve? It would not be conveying any message whatsoever. Now, in no way am I justifying violence, I just sincerely hope you can find it in your heart to realise the protestors are real people. In an ideal world, the government would listen to its people after a peaceful, uneventful protest. However this was not the case. Please understand that the protestors are real people whose freedoms are being taken away. They are not saints. They will get angry and upset. After all, it is part of the human condition. I cannot fathom how one could not get upset when their friends are being beaten up by police, who are meant to serve its people, and others committing suicide as they feel like they have no future. And all this is whilst the government continues to ignore the voices of its people. P.S foreign influence is a pretty good joke haha. You think they’d pay 2 million people to protest on the street? Man I want to know where the money is, because I never got any. P.P.S some of the violent protestors were found to be undercover cops pretending to be protestors.
they just admitted that they are acceptable that they can pretest violently, but not acceptable when the polices abuse their power. is this called double standard?
They never tell the truth of their destructive violent behaviours, but fabricating stories & lies, staged acts for propaganda to seek sympathy, blaming & smearing the police.
Alright, let's talked about this topic. First, who started the fights. We must know under Hongkong law, any large scale marches and rallies are must be approved by the Hongkong police department, and under control, otherwise, it would be seen as illegal. Please noticed this law was already there since Hongkong was till under British government. In the beginning, protesters were still under control, however, when the night came they try to break the area that police set up, and police try to push them back to where they should be, that's how the fights start. So now, who starts the fight? I do believe that the police's job is to control and keep the social system safe and organized when somebody tries to break the system polices were allowed to use some proper violent to control these people who're breaking the rule. And on the other hand, sorry, protesters were never ever given the rights to use any violence, yet, follow the law is what everybody's obligation. Second, anybody dies? That girl said that the internet said there were 22 people were dead even we have no evidence but we were sure they were sacrificed. Does it sound like some kind of ghost story online? Social networking is super developed nowadays. Unlike P.R.China, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook are super popular in Hongkong, actually, if someone dies, it's impossible to cover nowadays, no matter how the Hongkong government wanted. However, until today, those protesters can't even pull out one specific name from these people who they believed were killed by the Hongkong police. Why? If you were together even teammate you should know their name, right? And since you act like so angry for their death, don't you want to nonce their name to all citizen to show how Hongkong police evil? Yes, they can't, coz once they put up any specific information, it would be so easy to find out the truth. We can easily to find out one people's life only by a single name nowadays. Two days before there were a list was put on the internet that says these people were killed by police, still no name but there were lots of details, however not even one day this list was already proved it's fake because there was so many wrong information. And one dead man found in the sea that those protesters thought they finally find the evidence, but just a moment this dead man's family claim he has no link with any protests actions. You might also know the girl who got shot on her eye，but you may not know she applicated an injunction for others can't investigate and public her medical report. Why? Doesn't she want to show the citizen how she gets hurt by the police? Of cause she wants, The only reason she did it maybe just because of the medical report shows the truth which is not what she wants to show. Until today all we heard from those protesters just tones of ghost stories that can not be approved. Please remember we are on the ground so just don't keep your head on the clouds, go and find evidence out. Talk of the ghost story those protesters did claim they can saw a human figure shows up in the fire in the photo of that subway station, and then some psychic jump out said that he can feel the spirits there. Third, violence. I do agree that girl with a mask that she said if you want to turn over a government in a quick way you have to use violence. But now it's come to a question are they really fighters, warriors, or even heroes? Well, let's see what they do for their protests. they blocked the main traffic, affording citizens go strike with them, beating people who against their opinions, break the public utilities. What they actually do is breaking innocence citizens normal life, so what's actually sacrificed is the Hongkong citizens' daily life. But when the police come, instead of fighting against the police, these "warriors" run into people and used innocence citizen as their shield. They changed their outfits and pretend as normal citizens and cry. that is what we see from the video in the subway station. They put on a yellow vest acts as they are the ambulances and shout out of the closed gate. And for all these I said you can also find photos and videos online. Think of that, they called themselves warriors for people said they are fighting for the citizen but what they really doing is against the law, breaking the society, and what is the real evil is after they do all of these they still use people as shield to hide and acting they are innocence, that is really discussed. Did you ever see a hero hiding at the back of people? I do respect to those ones who are really sacrificing themselves, even I might not agree with their opinions. But I do hate that one who is using innocent people and still claiming they are fighting for others. Forth, police are no longer believable, there is an interesting test, they said that try to put on full gear and go to the police station to shout out the protest slogans, and then change the outfit and go to the protester's group and said support police and sing the P. R. China song then let's see who will beat you. I do think this is a good social test to see who is more dangerous. And then you may find out the truth. Fifth, actually Hongkong government still following the system that leftover by the old English system, it was never changed since 1997, all the government decision still voted and built by the Hong Kong Legislative Council. Therefore, we should ask why these Legislative Council members who voted by Hongkong citizen did not achieve these protesters' opinions? Should not we doublethink of that does these protesters' voice be representing all Hongkongers' opinion or just their own? And please notice one group of people's opinion never make up a social system.
Yes, no evidence whatsoever regarding these deaths. Also the girl lost an eye due to ball bearing fired from a sling shot by a protestor. And also she refused initially to have the medical evidence released, why, because she is a protestor and is expected to collect a very large sum of dollars from organisers to keep quiet.
The trust between police and citizens in general has been completely broken. There were simply too many evidence, such as news livestreams, photos of police turning their noses to people being beaten. For example, on 721 when normal citizens (not just protesters) were beaten up by local gangs in the subway station. Where were the police? There were video evidence of two policemen literally turning their backs on people dressed in white who were beating up random citizens. What's more is that the police only arrived more than 30 minutes after the fights broke out, meanwhile the nearest police station is less than 20 minutes away. Yes, the protesters' opinion may not represent all of Hong Kong. However, in this incident we see how the government may treat you if you oppose to them, and how the systems in the HK Police Force are poorly regulated. At the end of the day, you may not agree with the protesters. Yet, we must acknowledge what is wrong and what is right, and hold the supposed "protectors of the city" responsible for their overuse of violence.
@@joshienikko2255 and you are aware that 2 goggles were at the scene. Reported by the medic in attendance. Who said the injury did not match the damage to goggles. Why would the girl refuse to allow medical evidence to be released. . WHY ARE YOU TRYING TO DESTROY HK.
When the girl started to cry, I just wanted to give her a hug (if you read this, I send you a virtual hug!). I cannot imagine how it must feel to have your world turned upside down like that and not feel safe anymore. I stand with all Hongkongers protesting for their rights. Stay strong, Hong Kong! Love from Spain ❤️🇪🇸
My thoughts are that China will not let Hong Kong have autonomy because it would appear that Hong Kong could undermine China's authority, so I think that the conflict between Hong Kong and the CCP will be a long and desperate one. And I hope that Hong Kong will win autonomy again someday.
@@vince7362 there isn't any freedom in Hong Kong now because the thugs are running the streets and applying street justice on anyone who disagrees with them.
@@903IDFOLEY I'' ve seen a video that a riot try to grab a police's gun. And he got shot by the police. However you guys distorted the true and said the teenager got shot for nothing. I am pretty sure in any country, especially in USA, trying to grab a police's gun will be shot to death. These riots deserve it. Stop spreading lies.
@@shakebooty I suppose you're going to claim the guy getting set on fire by a protester isn't actually his neighbor or setting people on fire doesn't count as "beat up"?
If those young people did the same things in US, they had been incarcerated already. How dare they standing there and talking freely while make other working classes suffering!
I used to like Asian Boss but you totally disappointed me this time. Please talk to victims of these rioters, esp. policemens children horribly bullied by kids instigated by these si called freedom fighters.
5 лет назад+3
Police men are not going to put their families public, Xi will harvest their organs.
@@vince7362 No one deserves to be bullied. As a fellow human being, this is extremely ignorant. I totally understand that you have your voice and your government isn't doing good enough in this issue, but really, families and kids shouldn't be bullied. No one should. Not you, not me, not the police, not the protestors and definitely not the families. I wish you well.
i disagree with the violence by both protestors and the police because i am not sure how this will help advance the cause (for citizens, getting what they want in the long run, and for policemen, containing the situation). Furthermore, it lays grounds for the PRC government to undertake a heavy intervention if they would want to (i.e. that HK's situation is beyond rescue/out of control). Of course, a military intervention seems unlikely now given that the PRC is embroiled in the trade war with the West and by doing a public display against human rights, it gives them a lesser ground to negotiate with the States... I wish this would stop in HK and the people's needs met without too much violence. Each week I read the papers, it just makes me sad.
I believe it is a wrong decision by the US and the world to stand by idly as the CCP grows to become an increasingly globally ambitious regime that has committed and is continuing to perpetrate numerous abuses of human rights and fundamental freedoms. The CCP seeks to not only confine its oppressive methods to mainland China and greater China, but it wishes to export its system of totalitarian governance and internet / media censorship abroad. The US and the West are no saints, far from it, but in the face of the CCP I am gradually seeing that the US and its allies may be the lesser of two evils. To put it simply, if the US has been a wolf, the CCP (note, CCP, not to be conflated with the Chinese people) is a wolf in sheep's clothing that has managed to charm much of the world. Furthermore, the amount of economic leverage that the world's largest totalitarian regime holds over trade makes many countries afraid to fully acknowledge, stand up to and condemn the CCP. If the CCP becomes a, or THE global hegemon, the world would be an absolutely frightening place that would make Big Brother's dream come true. The CCP already possesses, and is already using some of the world's most advanced surveillance and counter-dissent technologies without challenge by its own population due to brainwashing / fear, whereas the same or similar technologies have resulted in much backlash and even exposure (think Snowden) in Western countries that are still relatively freer when it comes to political and social expression. I do not agree with the extremists among the HK protesters and I believe that their methods are only sabotaging the cause and disrupting the lives of others. However, if we look at it from another perspective, we don't know just what some of them may have gone through, and maybe they've suffered so much that they don't feel there's any other way but to seek address for their wishes through these violent actions. The core of the movement remains peaceful and the police are monsters. The world needs to wake up to the beast that is the CCP, which stands as an ambitious threatening entity to the present and the future of classical liberal values in our world. Unfortunately, the world as it is cares so much more about monetary benefits over much more important, non-materialistic values that should be defended. Someone like Trump is a businessman at heart who always wants the best deal. If I were him I'd care not so much about striking a trade deal with the CCP than doing everything I can to stop the CCP socially, politically, economically, and militarily. Democracy as currently practiced is far from what it could be. As flawed as it is, and as susceptible is it can be to its own kinds of abuses, I believe that if we refine it and make it better, it would still be the best realistically achievable political system that at least tries to grant us fundamental freedoms and liberties to the greatest extent possible. It's far better than any of its less freer alternatives, and some people who support totalitarian regimes and say they're in favor of giving up their freedoms have never lived under one.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 I strongly disagree with you when comparing US and China in term of aggressiveness. I don't want to talk about how we feel. Let's be realistic and talk about proof. Just how many war the US created in the 20th and 21st centuary? I can see around 40 of them, and I can easily name a few such as Vietnam, Lybia, Syria, Iran... We even have a list of them on Wikipedia. And how many China has? None. They just have internal conflict between their own race. Don't get me wrong. China does try to harass neighbour country in south china sea. We Vietnamese expericed that first hand. But that's all. So as far as the statistic show, the US is far more dangerous to the world peace than China.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 While the CCP is bad, the west hasn't done anything for far worst regimes like the persecution of Chinese minorities groups like Tibetans and Uyghur. I really doubt that HK is the hill that they choose to die on in regards to lifting a finger to intervene.
Another good piece of reporting. While some could argue that many of the protesters are driven by political or ideological differences with the government it's quite evident that the young lady who became emotional at the end was speaking from her heart and not from any desire to push a political agenda. This is not to say that the protesters are not being sincere, because I believe that they are being sincere in their demands. It's just hard to deny the appeal of someone who speaks of their personal pain from their heart. This is what the government needs to sit up and pay attention to. When the government has lost the hearts and minds of the everyday citizens they have truly lost.
@Ray Chan it's painfully evident which side of this issue you are on. At no point did I compare the Hong Kong police with police in the US or anywhere else. If you are trying to put forth an argument you are doing it a disservice by insulting those you might wish to influence. My comment was simply to address the real human emotions displayed by the young lady at the end of the video. If you can't understand plain English you might want to stop commenting in that language. Have a wonderful day. You do realize that RT news is simply Russian propaganda and a mouthpiece of the state?
ok, now i'm waiting for part 2 talking to the silent majority, divided by age grp (under20, 20-40,40-60,60+) part 3 talking to the police, part 4 talking to prodemocratic politicians, part 5 proestablishment politicians
mike4ty4 yeah US wouldn’t really report about that news. And the retreat of US army led to the attack of Turkish military against the Kurdish people, who jailed and killed most of the IS terrorist. If Turkish army bomb the jail and all the prisoners get to flee, welcome to another war again.
I would like to hear the anonymous opinions of police.
Obviously Asian boss is biased. How dare they claim themselves to be the who are doing the real news. WHAT A SHAME ON THEM!
@X H I don't get the point. What was the point?
@@akaobjects6536 Biased in what way?
@@quintrankid8045 If you re not native Chinese, you would never know. they mistranslated several words intendly.
I didn't think I'd see Asian boss become a propaganda channel. Asian boss has an agenda. Hong Kongers are manipulative racists and it amazes me anyone would take what they say at face value.
Why is everyone ignoring the fact that a girl got murdered and the man who did it went to hongkong and he's leaving the prison soon? This was never mentioned on the news in my country.
This is because liberals like these people support criminal rights
Because they are all anti-China propanda video to weaken China and Hong Kong people fell for it. Remember the opium war which brought famine to China by the British?
There had been multiple crimes already in recent years, same story, boyfriend takes girlfriend to Taiwan to murder her, then go back HK live on happily forever. This law is really necessary in my point of view, but the politicians made the whole thing political and relate it to China wanting to kidnap people from HK. This is what they fear for themselves. The young people are influenced by them.
Because Taiwan already told HK Government that it will not accept the arrangement. So even if the bill passed, the man will not be extradited to Taiwan.
What happened is just an excuse for China to do something it’s been wanting to do for a while, it’s not because of the murder at all, just a happy coincidence as far as China is concerned.
to all the people saying this was biased, it wasn't… the title is "we talked to protesters" and thats what you got, not everyones view
There are a tonne of people who always cry "bias" on every video regardless of country. They seem to miss the whole point about street interviews and a 13 minute video done by volunteers. smh
but that by itself is a bias
"We believe having meaningful discussions with people with different opinions is extremely important."
Okay, then where's the video for the other side?
@@stevepang7943 Go to Russia Today or CCTV... LOL!!
@@CuracaoChic Yes, hah hah "volunteers"
The teenage girl and mom hit me so hard when they were saying that everybody likes the police back in the day and now they cannot trust them and dont feel safe anymore.....
@Young Baller read twice
I trust the rioters even less with more footages of their violence coming out on the web
I' ve seen a video that a riot try to grab a police's gun. And he got shot by the police. However someone distorted the true and said the teenager got shot for nothing. They edit the video by deleting the first couple of second, so the people only see the picture while the police firing and ignore the fact that the police have no choice at all, because if the potester grab his gun, god know what would happen. I am pretty sure in any country, especially in USA, trying to grab a police's gun will be shot to death. These riots deserve it.
I agree on the idealism of democracy, however, something is wrong about this protest or riot.. Pushing kids to the front line, burning a man only because he does not agree on the protester, Using a brick to kill a cleaner who try to clean the barricade.....The rioter even threaten to kill the police's family.. If you guys see more news, you can easily realize that it's not only protest any more. This is not justice, this is evil, using democracy as its mask.
Jiayu He okay but why did the officer have his gun out in the first place??? literally no immediate threat and he pulls his gun out??? if you really did see all the footage you would notice that
and there’s countless of evidence of police threatening rape and death on protesters, as well as hurting innocent civilians. you alright over there??
I am a Chinese Singaporean.
I do not wish to comment on Hong Kong politics because I have no knowledge and no right to do so.
Your interviews appear to be objectively conducted and reported compare to some other news agencies.
However, other than the interviews of the ordinary citizens that were too briefed and too few in numbers, it will be good to also interview parties from the other sides, namely the Government, Police, the people who work in the public transport system, etc.
From many other news reports and videos, I can see that many so-called peaceful protesters are damaging - and also set fires upon - government buildings, MTR stations and its facilities, blocking roads, disrupting the normal operation of its airport, attacking police with many types of weapons, and also attack others who express different opinions from them.
Further, accusations about the Police brutality and oppressing the protesters with extreme excessive force, and the rumoured death of many protesters must be substantiated with evidence, lest it can continue passing it as real incidents and it can be prejudiced against the authorities.
Finally, I believe the interviewees ought to be made known about how other nations’ police force handle their own protesters and rioters, especially those police force in the supposedly democratic western world, like the USA, UK, Germany, and France, etc, so that the interviewees can interpret - and appreciate - more accurately the notion of police brutality.
well said
This isn't the BBC or CNN etc. This is a RUclips channel run by civilian volunteers. Those expectations are more appropriate for news organisations that are established with an abundance of resources and networks to gain access to those kinds of sources. AB make short 13 minute videos. It's not Panorama. There are street interviews so it is purely opinion based. Furthermore, knowing about how other countries treat people doesn't mean you shouldn't expect certain things from your own. Just because police may be worse elsewhere in comparison, certain behaviours shouldn't be excused just because it's not as bad as elsewhere. That's just ridiculous. If you are looking for a more in-depth report covering more sources from all sides, I recommend you look at more established and popular news organisations.
Hong Kong Chinese here
those violence are true claim for sure, but don't forget that the government are refused to hear the huge voice from protester to withdraw the bill since MAY until SEPTEMBER and police outbreak the excessive forces FIRST on 12 JUNE, before that it's still peace and only outbreak some physical conflicts
The fact is after 12 June incident, the bill is still in the pending list while Carrie Lam said "suspend" "bill is dead", it gave no mean to response the 1 demand "withdraw the bill", and protesters keep suffered by the polices' excessive forces, these factors let protesters have no choice but to make the worst scenario happens----occupy the LegCo and add 4 more to let her realise how bad the situation is.
moreover, police forces keep claim that incident as riot and refuse to apologise every excessive force they use, even try to avoid the law by covering their identities and arresting innocents
and why the violence elevated, it's mostly began from July when police start indiscriminate attacking to the crowd indoors, tolerate and even allowing triads attacking innocents, keep misusing riot control weapons, arresting innocents, undercover infiltrated in illegal protests, suspected torture, dehumanising protesters as cockroaches, unreasonable cancelling protect while making legal protests etc
as an advanced city, could those unprofessional and illegal action be tolerated? surely not, and most of the Hong Kong People has no military training for their whole live, and Hong Kong has gifted for having very high level of freedom of protest and speech as well, and they ranked very high compared to other countries' police, they are actually ruin the society more than protester themselves, especially social security.
even though there's quite a lot of evidence that Chinese central government has a hand on it, especially treating MTR and Cathay Pacific in words or proposing sanctions, 50 Cents, CCP-based media fake and biased news, and pro-beijing lawmakers and parties, who have quite a lot of relationships to China liaison office, funded triads to operate pro-beijing marches and flash mobs, especially Junius Ho, one of the most radical pro-bejing lawmakers who made Yuen Long incident.
that's why protest desperately need government to accept those 5 demands, as it suffer too much on those false claims and the structural problem on both police force and government
those violence are more likely an reaction to those incidents and unreasonable claims, and tardiness of response the demands, although it impacts infrastructures and some kind of industry, but I'm sure they deserved that violence, when police can't protect citizens, only vigilances could solves
if you think violence can't solve everything, the reality is no matter violence made or not, pro-beijing stakeholders and government still keep its point or even harder to suppress the huge voice, as they have the dominance of the whole political system and backed by Beijing government.
that's why the quote “It was you who taught me peaceful marches are useless.” has shown in the damaged LegCo
you might think protesters need to make some conversations to the government, sorry, no one believe that, as Carrie Lam has a very bad record on fulfilling promises after agreement created during conversations and making compromises each other, and she's one of the origin for outbreaks umbrella movement, there's no hope to make compromises with her but make compromises by herself to show her sincerity on stopping the protester's madness, she's the only key to stop the rage.
why protesters want American assistance is they need a power to balance the power distribution between Chinese government(incl. Hong Kong gov't) and protester themselves, as they have no hope on Beijing to solve but keep flaming them as rioters or making independence, American has the power to give threats to China to truly protect the "one country two system, highly autonomous, rule by Hong Kong people, unchanged for 50 years" promise, as this is the promise of China to Britain, and even the whole world, and also the real universal suffrage with a truly promotion from population and elect themselves, which is promised in the Basic Law itself
Lastly, I respect your opinion, and you have enough knowledge to analyse the whole situation, but I'd like you to sincerely accept my points, I have much more information than you got, perhaps mediacorp might not give you too much information about this movement, those reason above might be the core idea of whole protest, and give you another view of the protest instead of vandalism and assaulting other-opinion person
I agree! Western media likes to spread lies and distort reality about China.
@CuracaoChic
Whatever views and decisions you make, you are always right.
Therefore:
You are right to accept opinion-based reports and not fact-based reports.
You are right to apply only subjective test to all situations in life, and disregard and ignore objectivity in all situations, especially in so-called police brutality.
You are right that, in order to access to “more in-depth reports covering more sources from all sides”, we should look at more established and popular news organisations. Otherwise, we will have to accept whatever news reports from less established and less popular news organisations.
I hope you are happy that I have commented that whatever your views and decisions are, you are always right.
when the girl started to cry... it was like we saw the moment she realized that her whole world got turned upside down. just imagine how many people must feel like her..
@jessicalee you've just been watching the news the government wants you to watch. Attack citizens ? Come on please the soo called victims you watched on TV are triads or associates and attack the protestors first. And not to mention 721, 811, 831, 911 incidents. And now all the deaths the police did and are covering up are surfacing. It seems your the one that's fast to judge on the situation before actually doing research lol. So get off your high horse sunshine
@@jujubae_ Well if they didn't wear a mask then the police will go after them,they are just trying to protect themselves. When you are having a revolution conflicts and fights are inevitable,you need to take that into account. I think they get violent because the police started it first,it's all about self-defense
Jessica Lee theyre fighting for their rights, Jessica.
@@AnimeFreakcx yeah by destroying their own country.
Yong Yi that was led by the police after they starting attacking not only protesters but also local citizens of HK
Why not interview some police as well to hear what they have to say from the other side
Then you come to contact them to be new Asian boss
agreed
Because anyone part of the police can only safely express one opinion: that the protesters are wrong and the police are right. Otherwise, they could lose their job. Even just being on camera is too much of a risk.
PPRP and yellow object from a white hkpopo.
Kristin Wu is right. If you were a police officer, you would not risk such a thing especially as your job at stake. if you had even an inkling of a doubt of that stopping the protest is wrong, you would have quit your job and became a protester instead.
Also I imagine on AsianBoss side, it's risky enough having the protester be interviewed. What's the point of interviewing the police when their action already speak their view. An anonymous interview sounds promising but it's not something many officers would take, assuming AsianBoss would even find one.
I don't think it's a good thing to generalize the entire police force despite all of what I just typed, but for individual opinions it's only worthwhile to get the protesters' side in my opinion.
Asian Boss could you please interview Macau about this issue. They're a Special Administrative Region as well, yet media never shows how they feel about these protests.
Macau is just filled with privileged or the underserved casino workers mostly foreign.
Someone can start an interview on Macau.
HahahaDRY Macau actually loves China, every year the government gives the people a lot of 💴 now that it’s given back to China, since they didn’t when it was a Portuguese colony
let me put it this way, Macau isn't an internationalised place compared to Hong Kong. And most of Macau people have Portugal Passport. They are just opposing what Hongkongers're doing because they can go where they want in EU when they unsatisfied with PRC China.
And you pointed something important here. PRC China thinks Macau is a successful example of running one country two system. This is exactly the convict arises between China and Hongkongers
@15Y6C41 LI SHUYAO Stop spinning the problem to housing and the economy!!! Red-Developers are the biggest land hoarder in Hong Kong right now. There is no doubt that trigger of the riot in 1967 is the Labor Dispute. But the trigger of this initial protest is nothing but the amendment bill which is PURELY political stuff.
Go to a book shop and buy a book namely, the dictators' learning curve. And you understand everything. I sponsor you with 50 cents!
Thanks Asian boss brings this to the world!
Sorry, I dont agree on what they said at last. A real report should cover all the aspects. You only asked the protests and ordinary hong kong citizens who are not biased , however the protests will never confess you everything, which means it is biased. So, for showing us your justice, please interview the police side and the mainland Chinese's views
If Asian boss wants to bring this to the world, DON'T BE BIASED. Reveal opinions from different sides. It's not that people in mainland China are completely blind by the internet censorship. It's not all Hong Kongers favor the protestors' sides. People want peace. Violence comes from both sides, but the Chinese police side is more a passive reactive side because those protestors are affecting normal life of a regular hongkonger. Shame on those who keep stimulating riots
@@Oggyoggy2833 Lmao you are basically asking asian boss to ask mainland chinese the issue of hk in china and imagine what will happen,they will be arrested if anyone even tries to side with hk,even if some mainland chinese wanna be truthful they will have no choice but to fake their loyalty to the party. You still gonna get inaccurate opinions at the end of the day because they cant voice their real thoughts.
@@Oggyoggy2833 the mainland Chinese citizens views doesn't matter as the issue originated in Hong Kong, and concerns only the Hong Kong citizens and the Hong Kong government. The police views also doesn't matter as they are just following government orders. Even if someone from the police support the protest they cannot do so as a government servant.
They could have got the view of the government, but it is already known to the public.
Go For Broke 你是有被害妄想症嗎，你只相信自己的幻想不願意承認現實，百分百的弱智
Asian boss please make video about the victim of haze from forest fire in Borneo
Wait what's it about?
@@maceydullas4098 the forests in parts of indonesia is burning the air quality in Indonesia Malaysia Singapore Brunei and parts of Thailand is getting worse
I'm breathing haze right now in Malaysia
@@waterboih2054 im in Singapore
Hihihi. Victim?? Who?? No human was harmed to death. Earth is sick. They just killing the earth.
Thank you Asian Boss for covering Hong Kong news!
Not surprised. They are Anti-Japan and Anti-Taiwan.
@@VaYomerHashem who are you referring to? I am from Hong Kong, and according to my knowledge (as a local) the majority of Hong Kong adores Taiwan and Japan.....
To Everyone Saying that the video is biased towards the protestors... Look at the video title... "Talk TO Hong Kong PROTESTOR" 😂
agree with your view, 100%
The intro is biased.
Yeet, you got me
Im ABC from HK and I dont support these protests at all
@@dartagnan9094 So in your opinion everyone that agrees with anything China says is a Wumao and the 50 million Chinese that lives overseas are all wumaos as well? lol.
Wow I can’t believe I don’t need subtitles this time around 😂😂😂
Jajajaja Pre 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Jejejeje pre
IKR this is very rare for us
Jajajaja Pre You speak Canto?? 😐😐😐😐😐
Wow 😮
To be fair, please interview the authorities too. I'm curious to hear them
i dont think theyd be allowed to. its such a sensitive topic so to get authorities to talk at all to them on this topic would be shooting themselves in the foot.
Yes a Hong Kong police officer's perspective will be well-added. I'm sure {as I watched this video from Sydney Australia} that there are police in Hong Kong who are abusing their power and attacking the protesters and committing crimes {like making murder of suspected off duty protesters look like suicide} + participating in corruption before ALL these protests started. I remember watching on the NEWS the image of *THAT ONE* police officer who was ambushed by protesters and beaten with a long stick and held in a head-lock. Good *HONEST* police anywhere deserve to feel safe and have the right to know they won't die on duty. I agree with the protesters that Hong Kong needs an independent commission against corruption to investigate police that can be reported safety and anonymously by honest police OR by their citizens *JUST LIKE IN AUSTRALIA* . 🙋♂️🗣💬🔮🎭👮♂️
Remy Offixial actually there are tons of press conference and you can watch those to get the views of authorities
Please feel free to go on the HK Police's Facebook Page. They hold "press conference" every day which they tell lies blatantly, e.g. this week they claim their staff was just kicking an "yellow object" in the back alley... and they don't know what the "object" is. While in reality it was a middle aged man in yellow vest who got dragged away from the reporters and got kicked by a dozen of police in his head.
I think BBC or some news network did an interview of some HK police. If I find it Ill share it here for you.
Asian boss, there's a Massive student rally from all over Indonesia regarding the new controversial Bill by legislative & executive. Please do a video about them.
No. Do not put legitimacy to that fake, pointless, paid protest.
@@lizbennet90 this people called *cebong* in Indonesia. All negatif thing about government is *hoax* for them and Mr. Zo ko Wie is like holy human that never wrong.
I would recommend you send an email or reach out them through other methods rather than just leaving a comment here. You know how difficult to spot a comment in RUclips, eh?
Nah. Do a video about the haze
UP
If these people are in America, they won't be able to survive till this interview.
Wrong. People in America are allowed to be armed legally. And police officers who used excessive force are punished by law.
Laughing for that.
Well, protecting yourself doesn’t mean destroying public transport, burning down banks and stores.
Abigail Yang that’s the point, the government won’t listen.. i remember someone describe HK as a crying baby, because the *mother* doesn’t care, and what happens? the baby’s cry will become stronger and louder
floweryou JK As far as I know, the mother has given the child the best she can give. But mother can’t do anything now, because the west is watching
Let the hongers kill hongers. Dismiss the police force and army siege the whole city. Let's see how many can survive after 6 months.
@Rooster Long haha, you don't need to repeat 3 times. you must be one of the rioters. How many citizens have you beaten in these months? Fun?
@Rooster Long And I said dismiss the police force. Are the police and government not who you guys hate the most?
Is this Cantonese? It sounds so different from Mandarin
Yeah it is
Yes it is. Different Mainland
China not only have Mandarin and Cantonese, but also more than 100 languages.
@@jackielee6699 Slang
@@jackielee6699 not language but dialects, sounds somewhat similar but difference because of providence
"Until now I haven't seen any police who got hurt" ?? She can't be serious.
They turn the other way
LOL
zGBz BIoT Yes. One policeman almost got his neck chopped off. The youths in the riots look very similar to the story “Lord
Of the Flies” by William Goldings. Whatever you try to beautify your lawlessness and criminal acts, these are criminal offences, young protesters, what you are doing is to injure your own future. No country will accept you even if you migrate. Not Malaysia, not Taiwan, not Singapore, not Germany, not Australia, not the United States (they are particularly against Asian immigrants who are taking their jobs) and last of all your beloved UK (you must decide which part to go to England, Scotland or Northern Ireland. After Brexit, they might not be one but if you migrate early you might be able to participate in their protests. Chère the Police do not tolerate violence and they use live firearms). Of UK is keen to take you in, they would not only offer six-month BNO instead of full passports which Portugal have to Macau which will allow them to go to any part of the EU, including the UK, until Brexit. And yet not many people in Macau take up the offer. Trust me,’the best place for Hong Kong for Hong Kongers is Hong Kong and ironically, GuangZhou and surroundings because you can continue to speak Cantonese. Hong Kong is an odd man out in terms of Chinese speaking ex-colonies are concerned. In Singapore, they are happy to be able to speak English in first language, Mandarin, Cantonese and Hokkien as a second language and Malay as a third language. In Malaysia, their first language is Malay and the others are at second language level. They can go anywhere they want to. Even Taiwan has a dialect and Mandarin. They can find the best part of China to go to or Singapore or Malaysia. Hong Kongers are funny creatures. You do not like places who welcome you but you rather go to places who despise you. Who would want to take in as citizens modern versions of the Red Guards?
At the time of this recoding there had not been any attacks on officers.
Hahhahahhahahahah, As they say, THIS IS JOURNALISM!
The protesters conveniently forgot to mention the destruction and trouble they caused to innocent civilians, and the verbal abuse and physical injury they inflicted on civilians who disagreed or showed signs of physical opposing them, Eg the old man on the street and the young man outside JPMorgan. And the vigilante justice they are meting out, Eg, the taxi driver who knocked down 2 protesters in his way.
You mean the old man who was trying to beat protesters with a bottle? Yeah I'm not sure why the banker was beat-up aside from his pro-China affiliations, that did seem overkill. I mean when you can't trust the police to do their job, and there's been more than one taxi driver case. You have one where they just plowed into people intentionally.
The taxi driver hit down a girl causing her bone fracture. Vigilante justice is used as the police refuse to arrest the criminal
so much for "democracy" lol
So much resentment in Hong Kong these days
@@ronochow I don't think problems can be satisfied solved after 5 demands are met since this politic movement is being out of control and more and more outside politic powers are involved under the long term propagating of anti ccp(including ytub). I don't object all kinds of non violent protest but I really don't want to see the tragedy happened as similar as arabi spring movement. HK people should think higher and further instead of blackmailed by politician plot. China is already very open on everything except politic system, this could be a new door of activator on CH gov. reform rather than attack and hatred.
Asian boss, please make a video about how mainland China people think about the protest.
we know what's going on, ever heard of VPN? you idiot.
@@frejawa6301 你在逗我
please don't because they are so rude and disrespectful like the comments upstairs.
Take off your masks and stop the crimes of violence. STOP doing STUPID thing. Help the family of the HK's girl who have been killed to catch the murderer as soon as possible. Otherwise you are not qualified to say that others are rude.
@@nicolesit4330 Rudeness is mutual, people say rude things to you because they are offended. Don't always expect other people to agree with you when you yourself are not informed of both side of the story, and insult others because they won't change their mind
Asian Boss, please cover about HAZE caused by forest burning in Indonesia. For almost two decades now, every single year the livelihood of neighbor countries such as Singapore, Malaysia and Brunei suffered from haze.
Edit: I want to hear real people's opinion on real issues and that's what Asian Boss does best. For example, why is haze happening in Indonesia every single year, affecting neighbouring countries. How they feel about the haze. What exactly the authorities have done to curb this. The people's opinion for the best solution to stop the open burning/haze etc. etc.
as usual Malaysians are always complaining about smoke & blaspheming Indonesia ... but when Indonesia's forests are not burning why don't you give praise or at least gratitude because our forests provide the oxygen you breathe?
you indonesian always like this when thing got bigger trying to get away and throw thing at us where are your sanity?lack of intelligence to think of others isnt just malasyia got into the trouble but other neighbour country as well
@@ariusxander2684 get away and throw things to you? if you don't want to help at least can you stop blaspheming our country & people?
@@hetzatheofany2235 Complaining were mostly aimed to the person responsible/related with the haze (the farmers/company/the authorities disregarding their nationality). We don’t have anything against the unrelated innocent by-standers as many countries including yours are affected and suffered from the damn haze. FYI, last week Indonesia refuse to accept Malaysia's offer to help fight the fire 🤔
Praise and be grateful to Indonesia for the oxygen provided for us? Enough with the ‘proud’ ‘takbur’ ‘high and mighty’ mentality. Ain’t nobody got time for that.
@@hetzatheofany2235 If you're not causing the haze, why do you feel attacked? The problem lies where open burning is taking place.
I'm Singaporean , thanks to Hong Kong rioters now Singapore has replaced Hong Kong as a safe haven to do business and live in, for Westerners and Asians. Hong Kong economy has also fallen and currency value dropped , Singapore has over taken Hong Kong. Thank you HK rioters.
Aq Zing lol
Aq Zing and?
asian boss can you do a video on how foreigners feel about the hong kong protests ?
for those who claim this video is biased, go check the title again. It's about the opinions of the protesters.
Show more opinions not selected ones. Do you want to show mine?
Yes it is biased, why never bother to get opinions from police force or lawmakers?
Hence is bias cause other non protester never got the chance. Not the whole of Hong Kong are protesters. Most people in chat believes that the police are some sort of monsters when they are far from it.
8 rantsky why are they wearing masks,why do they edited the interviews ,can you represent your city wearing a mask,it’s ridiculous
Are you blinded
@@beanhwak 2 mill protesters is not one or two. Indeed this country need a change in the leaders ranks. Like in most western countries do need it too.
Was waiting on this to come about but I thought it might also be too dangerous to cover at the same time. Great insight. Thanks Asian Boss. Also finally get to understand something without subtitles ahaha
hi asian boss, first of all, thank you so much for always giving people more insight about current affairs in Aisa, especially now that you're covering the protests in Hong Kong.
However, if you guys are gonna make another video about this issue in Hong Kong, I would really love to see you guys interview other parties as well, because on social media these days, we are mainly bombarded by the opinions of the protesters, but we rarely see information/ opinions from e.g. the police (not just their official representatives on the news lol) , the shopkeepers in affected areas, the residents in certain places, or maybe even the family members of the police/protesters as well. It would be nice if we could gain a more comprehensive understanding of the whole situation as well from multiple parties :D
But again, thank you so much for covering this, I hope that you guys can still be a source of unbiased and comprehensive news for viewers all around the world!!! :D
the young girl and her mom are just common residents and not protestors, no?
@ beside the police this guy has raised mamy interesting opinions. I think is only to give the audience a comprehensive look into the effect of the protest as it has effected many not just the protesters.
Thank you for your work. THIS is real news. I haven't watched Corporate Media in almost two years and I'm never going back.
Very good episode. Well done! The interview with the mother and young women was particularly touching. She is a good mother to stand by and allow her daughter to express herself, and work through some very difficult emotions. The young women's poise and thoughtful analysis is proof of excellent parenting and education. It is amazing, and challenges my grasp on reality, that it is possible for a government to ignore so many people; to press ahead with an agenda that so many of its citizens are overtly against.
You know what? Have you seen how those rioters keep on using violence to destroy the city and attack innocient people? You know nothing but just being misled by this so called episode? STUPID!
For the girl who is considering to immigrate, my suggestion is to do it right now. HK is part of China and mainland will never allow HK to be separated. This is a fact no matter if you accept or not.
So if you are unsatisfied with HK police or current HK situation, please immigrate to another country you like, maybe UK or US.
Just a question for you. For the same situation happened in UK or US, how will their policemen deal with it? Will you satisfied with that?
Its different because it is the CCP breaking its promise of one country two systems.
No cuts between dialogs, people who support or dislike the protest both get screen time. This is the journalism we need.
Yeah, we need to hear each other's opinions or else democracy can't exist.
That isn’t exactly true however Asian boss did show the true intentions of the young protestors whether it is right or wrong. Notice how most of them that were interviewed were young. Again I still applaud Asian boss for tell us the true concerns of these youngsters not all the BS western media likes to frame it.
100 Videos And No Subscribers well to understand the truth, you have to go see yourself. A lot of ‘the other parties’ are we’re not present and did not see what the police/ government did. There are a lot of recorded evidence but no other media seem to dare to put it into their accounts. And most of these evidence gets deleted very quickly.
From these kids talking, just realise how toxic the HK news.
The power of medias today.
It's not just in Hong Kong. News outlets are all about power and money, just like politics.
I pray there is equitable conclusion for Hong Kong citizens and government
there already is an equity conclusion.
hong kong remains a democracy and china leaves it alone.
the only long-term solution is for hong kong to join taiwain, us, uk, or another democratic country.
test so there is no solution.
@@test-mm7bv that definitely won't happen.
Before 1950, still possible
@@test-mm7bv No democracy will allow demonstrators to attack the police, and no country is willing to accept them
@@test-mm7bv The democracy the demonstrators fought for was deformed, all for the sake of anti-government and anti-society
Thank you so much for these interviews!
A mistake everyone is making the extradition bill has not been officially withdrawn. You should correct that. ALSO protesters are ordinary Hong Kong citizens.
In Carrie Lam's press statement on Sep 04, she said it will be withdrawn once parliament reopens in October.
I believe it was officially withdrawn on the 4th?
Andi Cee it has been officially withdrawn on the 4th of September you dumbass. ALSO the protestors are beating up citizens who are against their opinions.
Did you not watch the news that the proposed bill had been officially withdrawn? This is why the protests do not end, the riotors are running out of legitimate excuses. Yesterday there wer news that they are attacking shops and restaurants. On what grounds do the mobs have to exert such violence on ordinary citizens and normal businesses? Even if we hold different political views, this does not give anyone the super authority to override the laws and basic civility. Really shameless mobs!
Well the article I saw set that it has been officially withdrawn. So do you have any other information that it hasn't? I mean like a link or something?
Since the extradition bill has been withdraw, will the girl that was murderer receive justice?
Regardless the reasonable intentions of these protestors, does not justify their violence and adverse impact on other people living in Hong Kong. Crime is crime.
Fighting heroically for freedom is fighting heroically for freedom.
Is there going to be one called "We talked to the Hong Kong Police" or "We talked to the everyday Hong Kong people who are not protesters (rioters)" because this only shows one side of the whole story.
@smitemeomightysmiter well clearly they didn't ask enough people.
@@ape413 they asked old people, who aren't protesters. they simply complained about them destroying public facilities.
did you ask them about waving UK / USA flags?
If it's not in the video they didn't. Lmao what kind of comment is that? Did you watch the video?
@@dxelson how do you know they didn't? maybe the interviewer did ask or some interviewees mentioned about waving flags buy they excluded that part of the video. I was just curious because I have watched it and saw the scence that they waving western flags (but didn't know someone is stupid enough to not understand my simple question or you just act dumb. I have no idea 😉)
@@dxelson Logan paul subscriber??? no doubt about your lacking of intelligence 😂😂
They're viewed as a bunch of traitors/colonal subjects and etc.
@@cattcatt6795 must be sad liking your own comments and stalking users 😂. P.s I don't even know how I'm subbed to him since he doesn't even appear on my feed lmao. Even if they did you expect them to reply saying they did but decided to exclude it hurting their reputation? Who's the dummy here lmaooo
I'm with the one lady. What are they doing to investigate these supposed "suicides"
Many people on mainland China seem to die from the most ridiculously supposed suicide or from the daftest accidents. The excuses are more stupid that ‘the dog ate my homework’ and I think because they’re so far fetched, people aren’t questioning them.
Obviously the mainland police are butting into Hong Kong. They all share ideas and use the same tricks. I feel very saddened for the people of Hong Kong. I have a hospital appointment tomorrow and shall be wearing my ‘free HK 🇭🇰 ‘ t shirt!
Those suicides are suicides lol...I was there at the Pacific Place one, the emergency people set up an inflatable thing and the person jumped and missed the inflatable. Idk whether the person did it on purpose or by accident but you can’t blame that on anyone else. Also why would they need to ‘disappear’ these people? These are not important instigators, if they really wanted to fake a suicide they’d do it to someone more important
I agree with the idea of investigate the relationship between rainy days and HK police. LMAO
That lady sounds pretty gullible.
@@AbsoluteMiniacGena Yes it's horrible. There're more than 10,000ppl die everyday in China. What an evil government. Why don't you come and save us? Don't you have mercy?
Who's making the economy worse? Who's smashing everything? Who's beating up anyone who doesn't agree with them? Is this democracy?
Douchbag LQL whos killing people ?
@@Bella-rz5vh The police hasn't killed anyone. In 1967, under British rule, British police killed more than 10 people and arrested more than the Hong Kong Police.
@@liqiller seem like you know history but not the present. Uyghurs re dying in china's camp. Number of uyghurs talking here is a MILLION people. they killing they own people and then u talking the police did not kill anyone, did you watch the new the hk police did the interview with korea news? oh sure the police did not kill anyone :)) FYI: if you like to learn some history here is some "tiananmen square 1989 ".
@@Bella-rz5vh Of course I know about that 1989 incident. You probably just know some of "facts", such as the military killed a lot of students and stuff. I am telling you, it is made up by the Western media. On the way to Tiananmen square, the military did countered some students and there were conflict. Some students were killed on the way, and some soldiers were being burned. At the Tiananmen Square, there is real footage that the students and the military had a peaceful agreement, then the students marched out of the Tiananmen Square peacefully. After a few years, even some student activists admitted it. I believe that the students were controlled by Western countries like USA. Cuz right after the incident, so many students fled to America, holding an American passport (it was very hard to leave China as a citizen at that time). So? What do you think?
@@liqiller peaceful agreement with tanks inside the city?? they re real footage. How can you say it a incident?? its a massacre.That's why people called Tiananmen square massacre. You can not even talk or mention about that massacre in china or you can not even search pooh bear because its been banned. Whos care about economy worse when you dont even have basic human right. Human right is which you should be learn in school or maybe they dont even teach that.
Next Stop: We Talked to the Police For Their Opinions |Asian Boss|
Hey, i want to ask is it safe to say in HK that i don’t support protest?
its not safe... lol my friend is currently working in HK.. him and his wife are considering moving back to mainland. someone just got beaten up straight for speaking mandarin under his building.
if you are foreigner you may be safe from beating.
Yes, just don't actively provoke anyone
Neki Tamo For sure it’s safe if you have reasons.
カリム HKer speaks Cantonese, but mainlanders speaks mandarin. Because a lot of HK protesters hate the mainlanders, anyone who speaks mandarin may be in danger of getting cursed or even beat up. That includes Taiwanese and some overseas Chinese, although they speak mandarin with slightly different accents.
I know, it’s crazy!
It'd be tough to get an interview with the police, due to their job security and personal safety, but I think that would make this a more balance and complete reporting.
The police, for the most part, are following order from the government, as it is their profession. They have been trained to follow order, so when the government defined certain protesters action has broken the law, it is their professional duty to take action. But, as many of the protesters mentioned, they are now being blame for the abusive of power.
Hong Kong police are also Hong Kong's citizen with ordinary family, and many of them have young children who perhaps have view similar to, or align with the protester's view. in other words, many of them are being caught in the middle between their family and their professional duty. Their view/ their perspective would give this reporting another dimension that is unique, and perhaps, provide some insight that are missing from almost all other reporting.
Well said. But asian boss in this case is biased. Some of their content is good, but this one is well below crap.
Although I agree that most of them are there for their jobs, many of them have been recorded to be doing things that far exceed what they're expected of their jobs. Just recently there had been an incident where a man was arrested and dragged into an alleyway to be beaten up by a large group of cops, concrete video evidence showing this. The next day the cops twisted it and said that the police were actually kicking "a yellow object", not a person by any means, which is a very blatant lie. Moving away from the individual level the police force as an institution is also highly flawed, with many of the officers refusing to show their warrant cards when making arrests, nor wearing their ID badges when in uniform. This removes the accountability that is absolutely essential in checking the power of a group that is enforcing the law. So yeah, HKPF is super flawed in its current state.
Makes you wonder if the policemen with masks are actually from hong kong.
Sounds like you know the situation of some of the police members quite well. Close friends or family perhaps?
They could well be interviewed under anonymity, they just need to show their badge or staff card without revealing the ID/serial number.
@@galaxcsy well said
You are the only few that interview local people who don’t speak English! The real common local residents.
The young woman at the end was really heart wrenching. The people’s trust in the authorities has been severely wounded on any side of the protest.
Asian Boss helps me understand these protests a lot better. Even some ordinary citizens feel the affect by the security and government.
Even though I’m a Hong Kong protester, I agree to get police interviewed. Everyone should have a chance to voice their opinion in Hong Kong
小小小莉柚 well you’re only one then. All ur other protesters friends are staunch activists against freedom of speech against their views
I totally support you guys. Freedom is what we all fight for. So many revolution in the past were for this reason. Fight before it's too late. And as the guy in the video said, revolution can be violent and can upset the economy but for the future of your younger generation, it is inevitable. I dont think anyone globally should condemn protesters in any country because it is not us who are living in the hell you are in right now. So 加油! But please also look after the hong kongers who are innocent by standers.
As a protesters, I also agree to interview those police as long they have good reasons and they are calm. That’s what we are fighting for, to have freedom of speech
@@weloveyoona693 would you kindly define what "living in hell" is like?
@@fyerraCommunism is hell. No freedom of speech nor actions or else you end up locked up and even executed. We are all human beings of equal standards, who are they to execute or CONTROL us? What kind of a government are they when they cannot accept criticism? That's Hell when in your short lifetime, you cannot live freely as you want. Have you heard about the book writers and sellers who mysteriously disappeared from their Hong Kong homes because they were publishing articles about the chinese president? The chinese governments are hypocrites.
Please so listen to the police force too. I believe not just protesters are injured, police are also. Can you imagine a group of protesters beat just one police too.
Gee I wonder why a group of protesters would beat a policeman who have been throwing tear gas canisters at them, have been nothing but violent at them, have caused them harm and have treated them like dirt... wow, I freaking wonder why protesters would feel the need to beat a policeman who has done nothing but oppress them. GEE poor policeman boohoooo
The protests on Hong Kong reminds me of the protesters in Gwangju during May the 18th. As a Korean, I am currently choosing to be neutral about the protests. However, the government really needs to listen to the people, or else they would have to pay a higher price.
홍지우 Jay Hong May you explain what happened in the protest there? I would like to know more about it.
@@shootingguard7321 So, okay.
Like a few decades ago, South Korea had to face many dictatorships. Hundreds of protests were made throughout the country. The most famous protests were the ones made in the city of Gwangju during May 1980. As the protests got bigger and bigger, then the infamous dictator, president Jun Du Hwan declared all the protesters "communists," roadblocked Gwangju to make sure nobody escapes, and ordered immediate arrest on all the people of Gwangju. (Including innocent citizens who had nothing to do with this). Then the people made their own army, armed themselves with stolen weapons, and started fighting against the government. Many were killed or arrested that day.
@@shootingguard7321 Luckily, he was thrown out in June.
@@shootingguard7321 The protests were reported by reporter Jurgen Hintzpeter. He was buried in Gwangju after his death.
홍지우 Jay Hong thanks for telling me!
When we look at these protests we have to remember that as with any big demographic, their views are all over the place. Some are very thoughtful, recalling that the protests began as peaceful rallies that the government attempted to ignore, and that this is the boiling point of Hong Kong's various societal problems and goes way beyond the now-dead extradition bill. Some also recall the swift government response to past instances of civil unrest in the 1960s, and that today's HKP was caught inexperienced and unprepared for this level of discontent.
Others are full of irrational hate and looking for enemies to blame for the very violence that they started, forgetting that all police actions are in fact reactions to events and environments. They talk laws and procedures, but they've lost the moral high ground by calling all police corrupt and screaming "colourful greetings" to their mothers at every confrontation.
Many, especially the younger students who have not learned the nuances of fact-checking and professional journalism, are obviously influenced by social media echo chambers, spewing rumours such as police murdering detainees, with no basis in reality.
I do not agree with what some of the protesters have done (more so because they're sabotaging their own cause), but then if we look at it from another perspective we don't know just what they might have gone through to make the feel as if they've reached that breaking point. The majority are peaceful. I'm a mainlander and I fully support their cause and I hope this wave of democracy will spread to the mainland.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 Exactly. 3 of the 5 things that HKers are asking for are good things, but the fringe rioters are hurting the chances of those things being achieved (I patently disagree with the remaining 2 as they are a dangerous step towards mob rule). Also, the constant spread of fake news is counter-productive.
@@canto_v12 If by "remaining two" you're talking about the removal of the term "riots" and universal suffrage, I've got to say that I am supportive of all five demands being addressed. The HK Basic Law says that "Hong Kongers shall govern Hong Kong", but the CCP deliberately twists these words by appointing local officials but CCP sanctioned. It's a very clever use of ambiguity of language.
If they really wanted universal suffrage for Hong Kong, they'd say something like "Hong Kongers elected through universal suffrage in the city shall be responsible for governance." It's this fear of a lack of clarity and the CCP's strategic ambiguity in politics and law that made HK so fearful in the first place. Mainland China has got no rule of law, the Party is the country and can dictate anything according to its will. Since it lacks a religious or at least a humanist framework, there are absolutely no moral or ethical constraints as to what they'll do.
I am aware of the fact that a CCP proposal for HK's political reform was rejected by the pan-democrats a year after the Occupy movement (2015). I believe it was right for the pan-democrats to have rejected the CCP and not compromised because the CCP simply cannot be counted on their word whether towards mainlanders, HK / TW / Macau, or the world. They said they weren't going to militarize the South China Sea but now they're building bases for ships and aircraft on the Spratlys and harassing their Asian neighbors.
You've got to understand that if the US has been a wolf, the CCP is a wolf in sheep's clothing. The latter's far more dangerous. If the CCP become the most powerful country in the world, it'll be an authoritarian world where they'll hold military, political, and economic leverage at unprecedented levels.
I also don't believe universal suffrage would descend into "mob rule". I don't want to sound like an ethnic supremacist, and I am not, but us Chinese on average are an intelligent people capable of coming together and making decisions. If we go back to our own history and culture, Daoism teaches us that we must follow the natural flow of society, to find order within chaos and to not seek excessive control over everything. Even Confucianism, in theory, teaches that a ruler must be benevolent in order to rule, and that his subjects have the right to choose their ruler and oppose tyranny. It's the politicized version of Confucianism practiced in feudal China that emphasized more on the parts about hierarchy and obedience while deliberately not paying attention to the parts that call for the ruler to govern well and for the people to keep tabs on their ruler.
I also believe it would be unfair to characterize these protests as "riots". It would be especially unfair to the majority of the protesters who have been peaceful. I don't know if the especially violent ones should be severely punished and I don't know what and if their punishment should be. Overall, I would like HK to go all the way, and I hope that one day the mainland will have the spirit of the republic revived.
“君择臣”，但臣也可以择君。当然，现代社会的公民意识已经和古代的君臣关系不一样了。我认为东亚文化跟自由民主制度并没有冲突，我认为能够在自由民主的基础上把东亚文化的优点保留下来并进行传承，这才是最理想的。中西各有利弊吧。
I long to see democracy in all of China. Only then will I support the full integration of HK, Macau and Taiwan under one China.
I've been waiting for this for so long.
3:10 "There was an HK man who murdered his HK girl friend when they were in Taiwan..."
The crime was done in Taiwan, and HK could not prosecute the killer for murder. Taiwan could not prosecute the killer because he is in HK. Thus they needed an extradition treaty with Taiwan to properly prosecute the killer.
To the family of the dead girl: "Tough Luck!"
Too bad they slipped in an extradition to China as well and to be tried for any major crime (definition of 7 years). Any unsanctioned protest is labelled "riot" and therefore carries a punishment of "7 years". Hrmmm.
I'm sure HK people would not have a problem with the extradition to Taiwan only. However mainland China is basically concentration camps, death and organ harvesting.
@@ronochow Why worry about the Bill ? If you obey the law and there is no way you can be extradited to China .How can HongKong ppl being so easily fooled ?
@@ronochow what kind of miserable life you had that makes you easily describe an country with 1.4 billion human beings as "concentration camp," "organ harvest". This is 2019, but your narrow mind still sounds shocking.
@@victorx1731 fam not to be rude but the systemic oppression of ethnic minorities in Xinjiang and Tibet as well as the draconian measures the regime has for maintaining order makes it hard to get excited about extradition for minor offenses such as rioting. This is never a wholesale judgement of the chinese or the history and culture of mainland China. It is however an assessment of how CCP-led china deals with dissidents, and it is brutal.
@real balance yeah sure... they even have laws jailing gays like you.
Steve is stressed so much, his face is like mid 30 or early 40
Uh that's how old he is
He’s in his 50s n look young for his age
@parkjihoon he is around his 30s
I love HK, used to travel there often but haven't been there for a long time. Hope the situation resolves asap.
Munkhbileg N I haven't been to HK since the 1960's. Back then they were protesting against the British and not waving the Union Jack and singing the British national anthem. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@John77Doe My parents were just a child at that time lol. But they think it's better off with the British rather than the communists.
@@nmbileg It is better off with the British. The PRC is what happens when wealth meets a government that has no checks and balance guaranteeing civil rights. The PRC can only publicize lifting it's citizens out of extreme poverty as improving their human rights. The right not to be hungry, the right to have shelter, etc.
😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞
@@John77Doe Those are red army . After that they hide themselves and monopoly many business including HONGKONG's book market.
@@umovie24ma The 1960's Hong Kong protestors were anti-British red infiltrators?? They were pretending to be fleeing the PRC to Hong Kong, but were secretly loyal to the CPC?? Plausible. In Hawaii, we know the Red Chinese have spy networks among the Chinese communities. Watch old episodes of Hawaii 5-O. Sometimes Inspector McGarret has meetings with the leader of the the Red Chinese spy ring where he asks the Red Chinese Spy Master to give up a fugitive Chinese criminal.
😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐😐
14:23 aww i love how the interviewer tries to comfort her because she sees how sad the girl is
I agree it was a very sweet thing to do.
As a hongkonger, thank you for this video
Thank you asian boss for updating
Stay safe hong kong people 🙏🙏
If they don't protest they would be very safe.
打倒汉奸走狗卖国贼!!!中国战士 Wrong. If they don’t protest, the next generation is over.
The bill has not been officially withdrawn yet, the chief executive just ANNOUNCED to withdraw the bill
What a classic example of how annoying these protesters are. When Carrie Lam announced the Bill was dead, they said "dead" is not a official legal term, they demanded "Withdrawal". Now Carrie Lam compromised by announcing Withdrawal publicly, they said the Bill has not been officially withdrawn.
@@livinology They don't trust politicians, that's why.
Oh man. You should update your information now.
@@livinology Because a Bill is a legal thing and every action taken to it HAS to be legally correct. And if you do know clearly how withdrawing a bill in the Legco works you know that if the bill hasn't pass through Legco it isn't withdrawn. This is about correctness and accuracy in every single step. What the CE says is not any kind of legal confirmation and so nothing is firmly set until the Legco announce official withdrawal.
Eh... Cuz no one trusts Carrie Lam. That is why. There are urbanisation plains in Hong Kong that Lam planning to demolish the places. She promised the citizens to preserve them, then the next moment she just demolished them haha 😂 Nothing about the protest, it's just everyone (nothing politics) hates her for not promising things.
Regarding the girl's eye got shot incidence, these people say that the police officers were aiming at her eyes intentionally. Apparently these people have got 0 experience on using guns.
I support 民主(it is not 100% equal to democracy), which means that the people make the decisions. However, crimes are crimes, riots are riots. No matter what you want the government know, what you have done wrong is simply wrong, and there is no excuse for that.
but things like these has a lot of grey areas. where do you draw the line?
I don’t understand why Asian Boss almost ask the rioters’s thoughts . I watched lots of videos about HK events. These rioters destroy and damage HK. I shame on them
I love this channel. You guys are amazing.
The rioters are insane and cold blooded! I support HK police and HK govt.!
hello there, wumao how's you day
@ ，I'm Hongkonger. I'm one of the millions Hongkongers who refuse the cold blooded rioters! pls respect the human right, freedom, the voice... of the majority.
@@aw888492 people like you only gas-light and mention the violent protesters and thugs, how about mentioning the peaceful protestors too? And those who were harmed/killed because they believe in what they stand? Hello? How about supporting peaceful and innocent people too?
road ON peaceful protestor does not get arrested. Or at least not all protestor arrested are peaceful. And there are a lot of violent protesters on streets still need to be arrested. So why protesters are requesting releasing of all protesters?
@@kenwu174 so you are suggesting all who were arrested must have committed crimes? That statement in itself is biased and extreme.
It's wonderful to see how many people just flush the comment section just to bash Asian boss for making this video. I don't know how many of you are paid or brainwashed or controlled by the Chinese government, but I wish you enjoyed your time outside the great wall! ^^
@Alias Sobriquet I feel sad knowing you can do nothing but cry like a baby online ;)
@Alias Sobriquet haha maybe you find it funny or humiliating to attack something with sexuality, but that just show how uneducated you are :) One more tip to you, attacking someone saying they're gwailo won't do anything, wumao.
@Alias Sobriquet Well, thank you for calling me, a Hong Konger, as gwailo, I never knew you support the independence of Hong Kong! And shhh, don't let the lovely great mother China know about that, she might be angry and you might go missing! I will keep the secret ;)
What make you think all the commenters that supported the HK police are from the mainland!?
People have lost their sense of right and wrong. They think that supporting China for their atrocities means patriotism. But taking away the rights of normal civilians is crossing the boundaries and hong kongers are doing the right thing. I wonder how many ccp clowns down at the comments are being paid to bash the coverage of what's going on in hk
Kids who ocntributed zero percent to the city yet ask 1000 demands.
kids contribute to society by going to school and becoming educated so that they can go on to university (hopefully) or join the workforce. they have a future
Remember the title is "We Talked To The Hong Kong Protesters" so you get views from only one side of the HK people.
when American protesters occupied White House and got shoot 🤣and western media called it terrorism, such double standard 🤣
china formally agreed to not interfere with hong kong until 2047.
it's only fair for hong kongers to demand their rights back.
protest is the only way to get heard against a brutal dictatorship like china.
it would be even better if hong kong holds a referendum to join taiwan, us, uk, australia, or another free country.
China never formally agreed on that. They only agreed to keep the existing system of HK, given that such incidents not happen.
修改法律條款，是杜絕犯罪份子殺人的機會，而不應該是蒙面人示威遊行的理由。自由不是縱容犯罪的藉口。
你應該看更全面的新聞。
1) 蔡英文一再重複，台灣不會承認香港的逃犯條例，因為不承認一個中國，港府和中央卻完全沒提過。港府也拒絕用日落條款移送殺人犯。 2) 向來政治冷感的港人因為這條例引爆了擠壓已久的不滿。香港自回歸心平氣和了22年，就被壓榨了22年，中共利用港英政府留下的好去建設中國，這種霸權，不是犯罪嗎？中共現在不斷嚇唬說軍車來武力鎮壓香港，卻不見踪影，像個笑話，中國有多依賴香港，你看不出嗎？
Support Hong Kong from India🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Although the interview was trying to be objective and neutral, but still ending up biased.
1. we all know the fact that both side has abusively used violence from all the media source, this video mainly chose the comments towards the police violence. Also by arranging those comments at the end of the video, which a more prominent timing that concludes a video clip, this video looks biased.
2. samples' opinion are overly towards to police, out of 6 samples, there's only 1's opinion is saying that protestors are affecting daily life. By knowing that there are so many's daily life been impacted by the protesting, the samples' opinion should be even out to 3:3 for presenting to the viewers and leave it to the viewers to digest the situation.
Nothing wrong for a media to express their stands, but please don't be biased when you trying to make the video looks objective.
Well if you'd like a more representative sample, shouldn't you petition the government for a straightforward referendum/election?
Wouldn't that solve the supposed problems of bias once and for all?
@@jeffrey8770 that's not likely to be the case when considering how BJ rule their lands. It might be a good reason for revolution, but hurting innocent people with no intention to be part of is another story.
It could have be more peaceful time for HK now if these young folks can see hope in their future.
”Aiming at the eye”, why would police want to blind a random protesters eye? in those riots , at those distances,movements and mass crowd, they have a lot of confidence in the police’s technique to be able to aim at one eye under those circumstances. And accusing it of being deliberate without any grounds apart from suspicion, it just doesnt stand
And that was a bean bag fired from a shutgun, how the hell can anyone aim with that
The protest has been going on for three months now. At least thousands of rubber bullets are fired against riotors with hammers and iron bars. It's statistically reasonable that one or more bullets hit their eyes. On the contrary, these masked rioters never mention how many molotovs they have thrown and how many random people have they have beaten up the street
real balance no thanx, its ok. Im in no need of 50 cents. I dont feel that special, this should be common sense but sadly isnt. I would also like to see some evidence regarding the rumour of the fifty cents stuff. Its unrealistic to state that everyone who can do some normal thinking is paid for commenting
Cecillia Yau journalists and first aiders are neutral people not taking a stand on any party, why would they deliberately aim at them rather than people involved in the riots? With these weapons that are not designed to blind an eye? Think! Accidents do happen with these weapons and maybe its a call for designing safer ones, but its unlikely it is deliberate
Asian boss should interview both side to make this more clear.
Not just protesters.
The situation between police and protestors is the exact same in France. Crazy. But we are far less organized during protests than Hong Kongers
It's because the stakes are different, at least the youth in France has a future regardless of whether they fight. HK youths don't have that luxury
@poortaiwanese CCP 50¢ bot go home
@@eddy-currents it's funny how you call everyone disagree you "bot".
@poortaiwanese go take your meds.
@@adlerzwei another loser who dares not comment with logic and argument but just attack ppl with different opinions. Just like those HK rioters
Hong Kong problem is very complicated, god bless Hong Kong!
it is simple. US would like to divide China to prevent its rise. The National Endowment for Democracy (NED) is bankrolling Hong Kong pro-democracy and anti-Beijing groups such as the Solidarity Center, the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and Hong Kong Human Rights Monitor to the tune of millions. Some rioters received sufficient equipment, trainings, advice for local tactics from CIA covert agents.
I live in Canada now, I was once at the wrong place at the wrong time when there was a riot (CNE concert riot, the band did not come and people got angry), and the riot police charged with horses, I ran away as quickly as I could although i just happened to be walking outside the stadium and was not part of the riot
When the police ask you to disperse and you do not leave after repeated warning because you are doing nothing, then you are doing "something" by not leaving, and there are consequences
exactly.
You can't speak for others' circumstances if you weren't there. Canadian riot police showing up to a concert you intentionally chose to go to and had the mental capacity, time, and physical ability to leave. Where a child ending up in an area Hong Kong riot police were at are two entirely different situations. If a protest happened in a shopping center (where the /child/ was sent to buy books), she could have gotten disoriented, lost, or not out of the area in time once she realized what was happening. I don't know if you were a child at your concert, but there are a lot of reasons the police could have taken her to jail that weren't her fault. Simply not being out of an area in time doesn't fault the child and make them deserve jail. Mobs of police and mobs of rioters can impact people's ability to leave an area, even if she wasn't a child. You shouldn't blame a child (especially with an alibi) for what happened to her. She's likely traumatized as is.
I find it hard to respect protesters who destroys their own city, vandalizing here and there in the name of "full democracy". How can the government take you seriously when you are abusing democracy itself with the destruction of the city? It doesn't make sense.
Arvi they were peacefully protesting for months and the Lam chick wouldn’t retract the Extradition Bill. So naturally, like a fire that isn’t extinguished, the situation escalated.
@@EViLSiDE520 That doesn't justify the smashing of stop lights, burning of things, blocking of roads affecting lives of people just working to earn a living for their family, and vandalizing public places. Love of country/city/state/home should be observed even in protests. These violent protesters are destroying the very thing they are trying to save. I'm sure not all protesters are like that. Though some are acting like this is PubG in real life. It's just a sad sight to see.
Arvi You’re right. Thats why I never implied it justified anything. I implied its natural.
the title speak for itself, they talk to the protesters, it would be bias if the title said "the truth behind"... what is happening then they just interview one side. Wait for their interviews with other sides of this protest, you cannot squeeze that much information within less than 20 minutes. It is amazing how a 20 minute video could make commenters conclude that the channel is bias and a propaganda, when all their other videos are definitely not bias. Maybe lets go back to Miss Hiroko with her Japanese topics.
Maybe you're not Chinese. If you were Chinese you'll easily sense that they are indeed BIASED. Not because of its title but the attitude toward the incident and the way they're covering it.
Somemore a reporter should interview people with two different point of side and not just one point of view and that Asian Boss is biased
you mean the other side of the chinese tourist? i went to these pro china rallys and unsurprisingly....many dont speak proper cantonese and have an accent. i wonder why...
There is no excuse of using violence against the government. Nothing could justify those chaos. If they want to use violence to be independent, that is even ridiculous. HK cannot be independent because all the citizen living depends on the mainland!
Those students not only overlook how the city has changed so far but also try to justify those rioters and even claimed they are for the next generation . OMG, they gonna fire HK and rebuild it up on ashes I think. Extremists and racists!
Why Asian boss is biased? Because they are interviewing the criminals who destroyed publish safety 100% sure and trying to use those excuse to justify those rioters. Violence cannot be acceptable and justified!!!!
@@常宁-l6v The Joker: "Introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos. I'm an agent of chaos. Oh, and you know the thing about chaos? It's fair!"
Great channel but some of the comments here scares me.
yeah the truth sometimes does that
Lots of Chinese bots, or people so full of themselves they'll defend an authoritarian regime from the comforts of their home.
hmm i think that the bill isn't fair but the way the protestors are protesting is worsening the situation tbh. violence doesn't solve anything and they are just destroying public property. im all for these protests but i feel like violence or destrution isn't really the way.
@@jadesomething5623 Its not like the Police are any better.
@ huh maybe not but i still think its the wrong way to go about and break stuff you know.
Thanks for this interview. It will be nice to have the thoughts of those in the mainland and not only the people living in Hong Kong, so we can have different opinions on this subject.
Is it safe for mainland Chinese to express their their opinions?
Most mainland Chinese are spouting the same propaganda: "Shame on Hong Kong." There's media control to such an extent that majority of them don't know the real details and are being fed info to make them believe Hong Kong is lashing out against China or attacking Chinese citizens. That's how it always is in China, media control and the way the government operates teaches the citizens not to ask too many questions, so most of them are in a bubble of ignorance. And as for those that aren't, it isn't safe for them to voice their opinions.
@@chinakachung Your comment show that you didnt live or stay in China and pretend to know China. I suggest you visit China before comment this kind of statement.
You did well, Jonghyun ummm but they are attacking Chinese citizens, did they not? They are attacking people with different views on the situation are they not? That doesn’t seem like very democratic behaviour to me. My parents are both from Hong Kong and I’ve spent a good number of years living there. The behaviour from these rioters are triggered by foreign influence and meddling while a lingering Hong Kong superiority mindset. They want us to fight for democracy and freedom. Ok, well why are they blocking public transit and destroying all the MTR stations? They call storming of the Legislative Council symbolic vandalism. Well, what about everything else they are doing? It looks like JUST vandalism.
Jesse Chan it’s a shame that you fail to understand the essence of the protests, but I would love to further discuss this with you. May I offer a reminder that these protests began peaceful. 2 million marched on the street, however their opinions were simply ignored by the government. May I also remind you of the Umbrella Revolution in 2014 - peaceful sit ins... resulted in the protestors voices being ignored. If a protest were to not have any impact on any person’s lives, what point is there to it? If everyday life went on as normal, then what can the protest possibly achieve? It would not be conveying any message whatsoever. Now, in no way am I justifying violence, I just sincerely hope you can find it in your heart to realise the protestors are real people. In an ideal world, the government would listen to its people after a peaceful, uneventful protest. However this was not the case. Please understand that the protestors are real people whose freedoms are being taken away. They are not saints. They will get angry and upset. After all, it is part of the human condition. I cannot fathom how one could not get upset when their friends are being beaten up by police, who are meant to serve its people, and others committing suicide as they feel like they have no future. And all this is whilst the government continues to ignore the voices of its people.
P.S foreign influence is a pretty good joke haha. You think they’d pay 2 million people to protest on the street? Man I want to know where the money is, because I never got any.
P.P.S some of the violent protestors were found to be undercover cops pretending to be protestors.
Strange that at 11.21 both girls agreed that protest need to be done with violence, yet complain about it when police responded to their violence 🙄
they just admitted that they are acceptable that they can pretest violently, but not acceptable when the polices abuse their power. is this called double standard?
I am so impressed by these young Hong Kongers. They are so knowledgeable, passionate, and determined. Go Hong Kong. The world is behind you.
They are like zombies... Try to tell them u support government... They'll start beating you
@@Mr_Chow_Man Just shut up
They never tell the truth of their destructive violent behaviours, but fabricating stories & lies, staged acts for propaganda to seek sympathy, blaming & smearing the police.
Yea... they’re really aren’t lol. It’s a mob mentality
@@vtdl88 you too, idiot.
Alright, let's talked about this topic.
First, who started the fights. We must know under Hongkong law, any large scale marches and rallies are must be approved by the Hongkong police department, and under control, otherwise, it would be seen as illegal. Please noticed this law was already there since Hongkong was till under British government. In the beginning, protesters were still under control, however, when the night came they try to break the area that police set up, and police try to push them back to where they should be, that's how the fights start.
So now, who starts the fight? I do believe that the police's job is to control and keep the social system safe and organized when somebody tries to break the system polices were allowed to use some proper violent to control these people who're breaking the rule. And on the other hand, sorry, protesters were never ever given the rights to use any violence, yet, follow the law is what everybody's obligation.
Second, anybody dies? That girl said that the internet said there were 22 people were dead even we have no evidence but we were sure they were sacrificed. Does it sound like some kind of ghost story online? Social networking is super developed nowadays. Unlike P.R.China, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook are super popular in Hongkong, actually, if someone dies, it's impossible to cover nowadays, no matter how the Hongkong government wanted. However, until today, those protesters can't even pull out one specific name from these people who they believed were killed by the Hongkong police. Why? If you were together even teammate you should know their name, right? And since you act like so angry for their death, don't you want to nonce their name to all citizen to show how Hongkong police evil? Yes, they can't, coz once they put up any specific information, it would be so easy to find out the truth. We can easily to find out one people's life only by a single name nowadays. Two days before there were a list was put on the internet that says these people were killed by police, still no name but there were lots of details, however not even one day this list was already proved it's fake because there was so many wrong information. And one dead man found in the sea that those protesters thought they finally find the evidence, but just a moment this dead man's family claim he has no link with any protests actions.
You might also know the girl who got shot on her eye，but you may not know she applicated an injunction for others can't investigate and public her medical report. Why? Doesn't she want to show the citizen how she gets hurt by the police? Of cause she wants, The only reason she did it maybe just because of the medical report shows the truth which is not what she wants to show. Until today all we heard from those protesters just tones of ghost stories that can not be approved. Please remember we are on the ground so just don't keep your head on the clouds, go and find evidence out. Talk of the ghost story those protesters did claim they can saw a human figure shows up in the fire in the photo of that subway station, and then some psychic jump out said that he can feel the spirits there.
Third, violence. I do agree that girl with a mask that she said if you want to turn over a government in a quick way you have to use violence. But now it's come to a question are they really fighters, warriors, or even heroes? Well, let's see what they do for their protests. they blocked the main traffic, affording citizens go strike with them, beating people who against their opinions, break the public utilities. What they actually do is breaking innocence citizens normal life, so what's actually sacrificed is the Hongkong citizens' daily life. But when the police come, instead of fighting against the police, these "warriors" run into people and used innocence citizen as their shield. They changed their outfits and pretend as normal citizens and cry. that is what we see from the video in the subway station. They put on a yellow vest acts as they are the ambulances and shout out of the closed gate. And for all these I said you can also find photos and videos online. Think of that, they called themselves warriors for people said they are fighting for the citizen but what they really doing is against the law, breaking the society, and what is the real evil is after they do all of these they still use people as shield to hide and acting they are innocence, that is really discussed. Did you ever see a hero hiding at the back of people? I do respect to those ones who are really sacrificing themselves, even I might not agree with their opinions. But I do hate that one who is using innocent people and still claiming they are fighting for others.
Forth, police are no longer believable, there is an interesting test, they said that try to put on full gear and go to the police station to shout out the protest slogans, and then change the outfit and go to the protester's group and said support police and sing the P. R. China song then let's see who will beat you. I do think this is a good social test to see who is more dangerous. And then you may find out the truth.
Fifth, actually Hongkong government still following the system that leftover by the old English system, it was never changed since 1997, all the government decision still voted and built by the Hong Kong Legislative Council. Therefore, we should ask why these Legislative Council members who voted by Hongkong citizen did not achieve these protesters' opinions? Should not we doublethink of that does these protesters' voice be representing all Hongkongers' opinion or just their own? And please notice one group of people's opinion never make up a social system.
Yes, no evidence whatsoever regarding these deaths.
Also the girl lost an eye due to ball bearing fired from a sling shot by a protestor. And also she refused initially to have the medical evidence released, why, because she is a protestor and is expected to collect a very large sum of dollars from organisers to keep quiet.
@@Hottiger1818 It has been reported that a bullet could be found lodged inside the injured girl's safety goggles. Don't try to turn black to white.
The trust between police and citizens in general has been completely broken. There were simply too many evidence, such as news livestreams, photos of police turning their noses to people being beaten. For example, on 721 when normal citizens (not just protesters) were beaten up by local gangs in the subway station. Where were the police? There were video evidence of two policemen literally turning their backs on people dressed in white who were beating up random citizens. What's more is that the police only arrived more than 30 minutes after the fights broke out, meanwhile the nearest police station is less than 20 minutes away. Yes, the protesters' opinion may not represent all of Hong Kong. However, in this incident we see how the government may treat you if you oppose to them, and how the systems in the HK Police Force are poorly regulated.
At the end of the day, you may not agree with the protesters. Yet, we must acknowledge what is wrong and what is right, and hold the supposed "protectors of the city" responsible for their overuse of violence.
Well said and well analyzed unfortunately these brainwashed Hong Kong people do not care about the truth perhaps it is just fun out there.
@@joshienikko2255 and you are aware that 2 goggles were at the scene. Reported by the medic in attendance. Who said the injury did not match the damage to goggles.
Why would the girl refuse to allow medical evidence to be released.
.
WHY ARE YOU TRYING TO DESTROY HK.
When the girl started to cry, I just wanted to give her a hug (if you read this, I send you a virtual hug!). I cannot imagine how it must feel to have your world turned upside down like that and not feel safe anymore. I stand with all Hongkongers protesting for their rights. Stay strong, Hong Kong! Love from Spain ❤️🇪🇸
My thoughts are that China will not let Hong Kong have autonomy because it would appear that Hong Kong could undermine China's authority, so I think that the conflict between Hong Kong and the CCP will be a long and desperate one. And I hope that Hong Kong will win autonomy again someday.
Why do you allow protesters to speak incognito and not revealing their faces while regular citizens' faces are openly displayed?
Lucas Peng it is called freedom. Ohhh wait, there aint none in hk anymore.
@@vince7362 there isn't any freedom in Hong Kong now because the thugs are running the streets and applying street justice on anyone who disagrees with them.
@@trexy29 Justice demands retribution. And the police do not enforce law of justice anymore.
Cause the police gonna yoink them at night when they sleeping
infact, some of the rioters were come from Taiwan.
HK to Indonesia : welcome to the club
We did concern about indo as well in HK. We think the protesters in Indo are brave
@@nao24031 yea so sadd
@@waybi0051 yea we should fight for the rights
You may find it disappointing that HK is ranked 3rd among all countries&areas in the world of freedom level.
we read the news here from HK too, time to stand against the tyranny especially Indo law bill is more insane and ridiculous
Prayers for hongkong protesters🇺🇸
Hats off to Asian Boss .
great video.
“Neighbours and protestors did not do anything wrong and get beaten “ sure... ok hahaha best joke i hear of the day.
Not a joke at all.
Protesters get beaten by police for rioting. Protesters beat up neighbours for say they deserve it.
@@903IDFOLEY I'' ve seen a video that a riot try to grab a police's gun. And he got shot by the police. However you guys distorted the true and said the teenager got shot for nothing. I am pretty sure in any country, especially in USA, trying to grab a police's gun will be shot to death. These riots deserve it. Stop spreading lies.
@@903IDFOLEY lol, another blinded person, sad =/
@@shakebooty I suppose you're going to claim the guy getting set on fire by a protester isn't actually his neighbor or setting people on fire doesn't count as "beat up"?
@@903IDFOLEY oh my bad, I thought you meant the police were beating up neighbours, lol,
If those young people did the same things in US, they had been incarcerated already. How dare they standing there and talking freely while make other working classes suffering!
yeah yeah u Chinese bot using VPN
Leo 859 nah I live in nz
wow they even captured graffitis with Cantonese swears on the wall
I used to like Asian Boss but you totally disappointed me this time. Please talk to victims of these rioters, esp. policemens children horribly bullied by kids instigated by these si called freedom fighters.
Police men are not going to put their families public, Xi will harvest their organs.
No one wants to hear their story. Deserve to be bullied.
@@vince7362 so do you then
@@vince7362 No one deserves to be bullied. As a fellow human being, this is extremely ignorant. I totally understand that you have your voice and your government isn't doing good enough in this issue, but really, families and kids shouldn't be bullied. No one should. Not you, not me, not the police, not the protestors and definitely not the families. I wish you well.
i disagree with the violence by both protestors and the police because i am not sure how this will help advance the cause (for citizens, getting what they want in the long run, and for policemen, containing the situation). Furthermore, it lays grounds for the PRC government to undertake a heavy intervention if they would want to (i.e. that HK's situation is beyond rescue/out of control). Of course, a military intervention seems unlikely now given that the PRC is embroiled in the trade war with the West and by doing a public display against human rights, it gives them a lesser ground to negotiate with the States... I wish this would stop in HK and the people's needs met without too much violence. Each week I read the papers, it just makes me sad.
I believe it is a wrong decision by the US and the world to stand by idly as the CCP grows to become an increasingly globally ambitious regime that has committed and is continuing to perpetrate numerous abuses of human rights and fundamental freedoms. The CCP seeks to not only confine its oppressive methods to mainland China and greater China, but it wishes to export its system of totalitarian governance and internet / media censorship abroad. The US and the West are no saints, far from it, but in the face of the CCP I am gradually seeing that the US and its allies may be the lesser of two evils. To put it simply, if the US has been a wolf, the CCP (note, CCP, not to be conflated with the Chinese people) is a wolf in sheep's clothing that has managed to charm much of the world. Furthermore, the amount of economic leverage that the world's largest totalitarian regime holds over trade makes many countries afraid to fully acknowledge, stand up to and condemn the CCP. If the CCP becomes a, or THE global hegemon, the world would be an absolutely frightening place that would make Big Brother's dream come true. The CCP already possesses, and is already using some of the world's most advanced surveillance and counter-dissent technologies without challenge by its own population due to brainwashing / fear, whereas the same or similar technologies have resulted in much backlash and even exposure (think Snowden) in Western countries that are still relatively freer when it comes to political and social expression.
I do not agree with the extremists among the HK protesters and I believe that their methods are only sabotaging the cause and disrupting the lives of others. However, if we look at it from another perspective, we don't know just what some of them may have gone through, and maybe they've suffered so much that they don't feel there's any other way but to seek address for their wishes through these violent actions. The core of the movement remains peaceful and the police are monsters. The world needs to wake up to the beast that is the CCP, which stands as an ambitious threatening entity to the present and the future of classical liberal values in our world. Unfortunately, the world as it is cares so much more about monetary benefits over much more important, non-materialistic values that should be defended. Someone like Trump is a businessman at heart who always wants the best deal. If I were him I'd care not so much about striking a trade deal with the CCP than doing everything I can to stop the CCP socially, politically, economically, and militarily.
Democracy as currently practiced is far from what it could be. As flawed as it is, and as susceptible is it can be to its own kinds of abuses, I believe that if we refine it and make it better, it would still be the best realistically achievable political system that at least tries to grant us fundamental freedoms and liberties to the greatest extent possible. It's far better than any of its less freer alternatives, and some people who support totalitarian regimes and say they're in favor of giving up their freedoms have never lived under one.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 I strongly disagree with you when comparing US and China in term of aggressiveness. I don't want to talk about how we feel. Let's be realistic and talk about proof. Just how many war the US created in the 20th and 21st centuary? I can see around 40 of them, and I can easily name a few such as Vietnam, Lybia, Syria, Iran... We even have a list of them on Wikipedia. And how many China has? None. They just have internal conflict between their own race.
Don't get me wrong. China does try to harass neighbour country in south china sea. We Vietnamese expericed that first hand. But that's all.
So as far as the statistic show, the US is far more dangerous to the world peace than China.
@@AbsoluteZero6714 While the CCP is bad, the west hasn't done anything for far worst regimes like the persecution of Chinese minorities groups like Tibetans and Uyghur. I really doubt that HK is the hill that they choose to die on in regards to lifting a finger to intervene.
Another good piece of reporting. While some could argue that many of the protesters are driven by political or ideological differences with the government it's quite evident that the young lady who became emotional at the end was speaking from her heart and not from any desire to push a political agenda. This is not to say that the protesters are not being sincere, because I believe that they are being sincere in their demands. It's just hard to deny the appeal of someone who speaks of their personal pain from their heart. This is what the government needs to sit up and pay attention to. When the government has lost the hearts and minds of the everyday citizens they have truly lost.
@Ray Chan it's painfully evident which side of this issue you are on. At no point did I compare the Hong Kong police with police in the US or anywhere else. If you are trying to put forth an argument you are doing it a disservice by insulting those you might wish to influence. My comment was simply to address the real human emotions displayed by the young lady at the end of the video. If you can't understand plain English you might want to stop commenting in that language. Have a wonderful day.
You do realize that RT news is simply Russian propaganda and a mouthpiece of the state?
giantrotatingcarrot - You may be right. The motive of these riots may have some hidden political agenda.
good interviews but please also do interviews with other citizens on street who have other opinions towards protests
@Alt Swede are you scared of the truth?
ok, now i'm waiting for
part 2 talking to the silent majority, divided by age grp (under20, 20-40,40-60,60+)
part 3 talking to the police,
part 4 talking to prodemocratic politicians,
part 5 proestablishment politicians
This channel is truly amazing! I wish there would be the same kind for other continents like an "African boss" lol
thank you for spreading the light on the situation
I Learned a lesson. Never trust NEWS again.
I’m sorry, but I think the news about 107 of Iranian being killed in just 6 days while protesting is way more severe than the HK issue.
Yow! Now THAT's what you can call a "brutal tyrant regime" alright!
mike4ty4 yeah US wouldn’t really report about that news. And the retreat of US army led to the attack of Turkish military against the Kurdish people, who jailed and killed most of the IS terrorist. If Turkish army bomb the jail and all the prisoners get to flee, welcome to another war again.