Who Can Dethrone the Siemens Charger? - The 5008 Show |S2|E1|

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2024

Комментарии • 51

  • @SalmanMentos
    @SalmanMentos 15 часов назад +9

    *O N T A R I O N O R T H L A N D*

    • @jmrgg3669
      @jmrgg3669 11 часов назад

      The Milwaukee Road Canadian edition.

  • @Pensyfan19
    @Pensyfan19 21 час назад +6

    ALL HAIL TEAM SIEMENS!!!! Great to see a brand new season of this series, and with an amazing intro too (featuring a 2 car coaster train and the 7 Eleven Charger). Even though I can definitely see Siemens gaining several more orders over the next few years even to the point where they'll eventually be running THREE manufacturing plants, I could honestly see Stadler offering a competitor locomotive for the Charger since they have more orders in the U.S. with high reliability, as well as a few electric locomotive classes in Europe (such as the EuroDual) that they could easily modify for the U.S. as a battery engine, electric engine, or some other third option. Although, I wouldn't leave Alstom entirely out of the running with their ALP-45 which was inherited from Bombardier, although I've heard some mixed reviews about that engine.

  • @jmrgg3669
    @jmrgg3669 4 дня назад +5

    Hmm let's see if we could create the most produced train ever:
    Siemens Mobility: Chorgers - SC-44/ALC-42
    General Electric Transportation (Wabtec): GEVOs & P42DC
    EMD (Progress Rail): GP40s & F40PHs
    Stadler: KISS EMUs
    Alstom (Bombardier Transportation): Multilevel Coach/Cab Cars & Acela I trainsets w/Hybrid K5LAs

  • @SteveGettingAroundPhilly
    @SteveGettingAroundPhilly 18 часов назад +2

    The thing I will definitely make note of is that Alstom and Stadler do make locomotives, just not for the North American market. The Stadler Dual and EuroDual and the Alstom Traxx have been highly successful competing against the Siemens Vectron (Which both the ACS-64 and to a lesser extent the Charger are based on). The EuroDual in particular could be a potent competitor to current GE/Wabtec and EMD/Progress Rail offerings in freight service, since they're dual mode Diesel/Electric dual modes, and the Traxx has been used as a mixed traffic platform for freight and passenger trains for a while. Those platforms could definitely find success if they are convinced to enter the market. What might be the trigger for them to do so is the question.

  • @Mcnibbus
    @Mcnibbus 20 часов назад +3

    by technicality GE has made a passenger loco besides the p42. They had owned MPI before they went under and with that MPI used the GEVO 12 cylinder as the main prime mover. With that partnership out popped the HSP 46.

  • @mitchellgloss6365
    @mitchellgloss6365 12 часов назад

    The GE P42 Genesis is the goat locomotive. Keep up the videos. Happy Holidays!

  • @Guaga_
    @Guaga_ 20 часов назад +2

    to answer the title, probably any sort of weather

  • @TheRandCrews
    @TheRandCrews 17 часов назад +2

    Alstom has built the ALP-45 being used currently by Montreal Exo as Diesel trains because no mainline electric lines to run dual mode. Unless Alstom can build their Diesel Locomotive variant of the TRAXX either with a genset style (multiple smaller engines) or traditional (one big engine) that’s rated higher than 100mph or 160km/h to at least 125mph or 200km/h. They got a lot of facilities in US and Canada to do so,

  • @theconceptualist8626
    @theconceptualist8626 8 часов назад +1

    WE ARE SO BACK BABY!!!

  • @00Zy99
    @00Zy99 14 часов назад

    Alstom PL42 says HI!!!! Yes, they made diesels for NJTransit. AS well as dual-modes.
    But the better idea is to just electrify everything.

  • @caltrain914studios
    @caltrain914studios 19 часов назад +3

    7:36 alstom actually did make locos

    • @GamingRailfanner
      @GamingRailfanner 11 часов назад +1

      ALP-45DP doesn't count as it was inherited from Bombardier along with anything formerly Bombardier
      The Acela and HHP-8 are joint builds from former Bombardier and Alstom, not Alstom themselves (At the time)

    • @caltrain914studios
      @caltrain914studios 11 часов назад

      @@GamingRailfanner *cough* PL42AC *cough*

    • @GamingRailfanner
      @GamingRailfanner 9 часов назад

      @@caltrain914studios Sure I guess, but those were for NJT between 2003-2006, they never made it as far as the chargers are right now

    • @caltrain914studios
      @caltrain914studios 9 часов назад

      @@GamingRailfanner they could overhaul them though, make them tier four type shi

  • @CynthiaWilliams-pz8cl
    @CynthiaWilliams-pz8cl 20 часов назад +2

    1:53 LOL😂

  • @GamingRailfanner
    @GamingRailfanner 8 часов назад

    Stadler could have a presence, but not towards large commuter railroads that run long trains for capacity and/or still prefer loco-hauled (Metra, GO, COASTER, WCE, ACE, etc..).
    Alstom could.. If they would make a locomotive that could compete with Siemens' current Diesel-electric market (The last time they did it was 2003-2006 with the PL42AC, so pretty much 20 years ago).
    GE/MPI is pretty much out.
    EMD is also pretty much out, the F125 seemed to be the last straw (Also the logistical issues they had with production of the F125 before they even came out).
    So Siemens is in it for what looks like the long run.

  • @Trashtruckmaster
    @Trashtruckmaster 18 часов назад

    Great to see you back. Can’t wait for future uploads.

  • @SanBernadinoSub_Railfan
    @SanBernadinoSub_Railfan 4 дня назад +12

    Stadler KISS EMUs. I don’t this this really needs questioning ngl

    • @GamingRailfanner
      @GamingRailfanner 11 часов назад +1

      Not all passenger railroads would want Multiple Units, let alone having to electrify the network unless they want to (Sure DMUs, Battery, Hydrogen but that wont work with things like say GOs 12 car long sets)

    • @SanBernadinoSub_Railfan
      @SanBernadinoSub_Railfan 8 часов назад

      @@GamingRailfanner good point

  • @leanderhartl9504
    @leanderhartl9504 Час назад

    Stadler still could theoretically do something with the Eurodual or the Eurolight.

  • @KJW-Transit
    @KJW-Transit 17 часов назад

    THE INTRO THOUGH

  • @mambonummer5
    @mambonummer5 3 часа назад

    Tbf Stadler has expertise in Diesel locomotives (abeit dual mode ones with pantographs) in the form of the former Vossloh products and its derivatives; eg. the Euro 3000 & 4000. They're not adjusted to American specifications, but it's not outside the realm of possibilities.

  • @procrastinatingpuma
    @procrastinatingpuma 18 часов назад +1

    > Who Can Dethrone the Siemens Charger?
    Skunkworks, obviously

  • @Dodener
    @Dodener 14 часов назад

    FULL COWL GEVOS LETS GO

  • @johnrobinson5205
    @johnrobinson5205 19 часов назад +1

    Was there ever a p41 for amtrak if that exists

  • @AmtrakFunkandDiscoFan
    @AmtrakFunkandDiscoFan 20 часов назад +1

    Bro, why didn't you mention Nippon Sharyo. But, great work by the way.

  • @kevinb8881
    @kevinb8881 11 часов назад

    Siemens plays hard to win, Alstom plays hard not to lose!!!

  • @az196823
    @az196823 12 часов назад

    Alstom delivered the ALP-45DP to NJT. Formerly a bombardier product.

    • @GamingRailfanner
      @GamingRailfanner 11 часов назад

      Alstom technically didn't make it themselves, they had to inherit Bombadier

    • @az196823
      @az196823 11 часов назад

      @GamingRailfanner Yes I know that's why I mentioned it.

    • @az196823
      @az196823 11 часов назад

      @GamingRailfanner Also our newer units have the Alstom logos and badges on them.

  • @Texas_North
    @Texas_North 18 часов назад

    WE ARE SO BACK

  • @BoeingAvation8490
    @BoeingAvation8490 3 дня назад

    Yes sir 5008 is back

  • @scale_model_apprentice
    @scale_model_apprentice 19 часов назад

    The F125 is still in Progress Rail's catalog. Anyone could order one.

  • @Thenumbersthatareodd
    @Thenumbersthatareodd 20 часов назад

    We are back🗣🗣🔥🔥

  • @AmtrakFan6905
    @AmtrakFan6905 4 дня назад +1

    LETS GO!

  • @FanoftrainsfromCA
    @FanoftrainsfromCA 4 дня назад

    Aw hell yeah he’s back!

    • @TrainsTrashTrucks
      @TrainsTrashTrucks 20 часов назад

      stfu Mitchell stop obsessing and accusing me get a life

  • @traingame6905
    @traingame6905 10 часов назад

    At least these things are better than the alc-42s.

  • @jmrgg3669
    @jmrgg3669 11 часов назад

    Hey 5008, how about the F40PH & PHM-4C?

  • @NCLOFFICAL
    @NCLOFFICAL 20 часов назад

    7/11 Charger 0:54

  • @Frank-c6p
    @Frank-c6p 21 час назад +1

    You made me laugh how you say everyone's favorite: 1:51 😂😂😂

  • @UP1988yappenese
    @UP1988yappenese День назад

    LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEETTTTTTTTTTSSSSSSSSSSS FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @gb9727
    @gb9727 17 часов назад +1

    Stadler can with the KISS EMUs