@@Q.Andersonthere is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
*In an Alternate dimension* "Did you know, that Elsa was originally supposed to be the HERO in frozen? That's right! And she actually was also supposed to be Anna's older sis!!"
I disagree. Elsa and Anna have the WEAKEST sibling story of any Disney movie. Brother Bear, Lilo and Stitch and especially Encanto pulled off much more emotional and realistic portrayals of brotherly and sisterly love. All Elsa and Anna have is Anna convincing Elsa she doesn’t have to be afraid of herself anymore, but that doesn’t change how Anna acted for a majority of the movie, including almost completely cutting ties with Elsa just to marry Hans
@@candymareSweets just sayin. They could’ve done the sisterly love message for Anna and Elsa a lot better. One of the biggest problems I have is Anna’s willingness to completely cut ties with Elsa just for Hans and her personal happiness, sick of Elsa ignoring her. But, once she realizes her powers, she does a complete 180 and all of a sudden cares about Elsa more than anyone else. Elsa NEVER even tries to explain why their parents made the stupid decision of erasing Anna’s memories. The fact Anna never discovers she was almost killed as a child just bugs me so much. All the trolls had to do was finally restore her memories or just tell her what happened and why it made Elsa basically hate herself. But no, Anna doesn’t learn about that and its that secret that literally forces Elsa to keep shoving her away, even after Anna knows about her powers. Brother Bear, Encanto, Lilo and Stitch and arguably Big Hero 6 had more developed sibling stories and why certain characters went a certain route. Elsa and Anna became popular simply because they’re sisters and princesses. I’d argue even Ariel had more of a story with her sisters in Ariel’s Beginning and how their mother’s death affected their entire family
I don't think Frozen would've been so popular if Elsa was evil. ❄️After Anna saved her from getting killed by Hans she learned that love was the key of controlling her powers. So Frozen was about sister love!
idk man, people sometimes _love_ the villains more than the heroes! Like Scar from the Lion King, or the Joker and Harley Quinn. Evil Elsa could have been a hit.
@@WxIxLxLxIxAxMxSbut kids don't, and the movie was a lot popular because of the younger demographic who bought toys..t shirts, accessories for school The target of the movie were the Kids and they love more the main character, princess and everything related to that
To be honest we didn't necessarily need Hans or some villain in general I think it would've been enough if Elsa just went crazy with her powers and was so oberwhelmed that she thought that she is just harming everyone with it and then Anna is there for her and makes her understand that she isn't harming everyone she just needs to control her powers
@@Gabry4777 nah, it made the movie so much better. The only downside is that it resulted in Hans being turned into a villain, which was done a little too late and made him a pretty weak villain.
@@Gabry4777 in what sense? I thought she was well-written! It’s nothing spectacular, but her character has actual depth and is relatable in more ways than one. This also lead to her being the protagonist of Frozen 2, and I loved her there! Let’s also not forget that she’s probably Disney’s most popular princess (or queen) among kids. That would’ve never happened if she was kept as a villain and Frozen would not have become the most successful animated film of all time (and later be dethroned by its sequel).
People always act like this is shocking, but in the ogre story, Hans was Anna's bro and the Snow Queen stole him and turned his heart to ice. People act like this storyline never existed.
The ogre story? Hans and Anna? You mean Gerda and Kay from the Snow Queen? They weren't actually siblings btw, but cared enough for each other as if they were.
I think the original Kristoff was supposed to be the robber girl, and Hans seemed to have a similar role to Gerda rather than Kay.... We could have had yuribait
This is why Hans is such a poorly written villain Edit: please stop arguing in the replies, I like the film I just personally think Hans was badly written and his character seemed rushed to me, you're all entitled to your own opinion
Yeah honestly the twist didn't really make sense, especially cause earlier in the movie he seemed really worried about Anna and had even defended Elsa. Maybe if they put more thought in the twist and either hinted at the twist (or didn't make him so caring) the twist wouldn't seem like some last minute change/addition after they realised they didn't have a good villain.
@iliketea1427 I saw his deceptively caring nature to be very well written, and obviously... well, deceptive. As noble prince, naturally, being believably kind would be part of his lessons as a royal, as a part of establishing connections and finding a royal spouse of his own. Honestly, him seeming to fall in love with her so much that he asks her to marry him without so much as asking input from his father or eldest brother almost makes the heel turn expected. Would have been completely obvious if this wasn't a *Disney* movie.
@@SallyMarsAlso bare in mind the black community also do not like it when their AAVE is used by anyone outside of the community and when passed off as internet, etc. "slang"?
@@TheSapphireLeo why are you trying to educate me on the black community without knowing if I’m part of the black community or not? You sound like a dummy speaking for a whole group of people as if it’s fact.
i wish that the frozen team had stuck with their original plan i love frozen but the original story that they came up with sounds better than what we got and i think that Else would have been a very tragic and sympathetic villan she was essentially abused and neglected by her parents and kingdom because of her ice powers.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
@@pinkie_playz2732 the snow queen was not a movie it was a fairy tale written by Hans Christian Anderson not a movie he also wrote the original version of the little mermaid and the ugly duckling also i like to imagine that the original snow queen was Else and Anna's ancestor wich would explain why the sisters parents acted the way they did
It was meant to be something along the lines of: Anna was a peasant, who had her heartbroken. She went to see the snow queen and asked her to freeze her heart. That's all I think I know. I'm not sure, this could be wrong
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
It's all about the framing. Imagine you are an ordinary citizen of Arendelle and your newly crowned queen suddenly cast an eternal winter over the town you are living in. Famine is imminent and you fear that your family, your friends and yourself might face starvation in the near future. Then you would most definitely consider Elsa to be a villain. And even after Elsa comes back and restores the weather, that does not make everything okay. You will be aware that you live in a kingdom with a queen that has proven that she will use her powerful magic against her own people when her vulnerable feelings are hurt.
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
I do not like the idea of Elsa being the Maleficent/Ursula of the Revival era. She could have been an awesome villain, sure, and it would mean Anna would be a Disney Princess, but I think that it would have been more beneficial for Elsa’s character arc to be further fleshed out and for the Duke Of Weselton to be the villain instead. Also the original Pinocchio and Little Mermaid stories had their protags fucking die so don’t come crying that this is still unfaithful to the original fairy tale.
@@henrythef1guy768there's a good reason why they didn't get killed and that's the fact that disney movies are catered towards children... what are you saying?
@@lasagna970 I’m not saying I dislike that, I’m saying that you shouldn’t complain about Frozen being unfaithful when that’s happened lots of times before.
@@henrythef1guy768 yes I understand that bit, but using the deaths of main characters isn't that great of an example tbh. I agree with everything else though
I agreee them being sisters and elsa villain would have been great story. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
That makes sense. I remember being so confused with how the “snow queen” was nothing remotely similar to the original from the stories. Disney does make their changes, but I feel like this was their biggest change. Neither good nor bad. Just different 🤔
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
I actually prefer the fairytale. Especially because Hans wasn't really a well written villain or a interesting one (honestly the twist just seemed to be last minute, cause earlier in the movie he cares for anna and defends elsa and then suddenly he just doesn't).
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
@@winxclubflora8446doesn’t that have rather cheap animation? Well, check out “The Lantern in the snow” in Cookie Run: Kingdom. It’s similar to the original Snow Queen but it’s more bittersweet and the Queen isn’t really a villain.
@@Ebh55. Anna is a better character than Elsa, and it’s no wonder because they completely changed Elsa’s character from being a villain to being her sister. Anna didn’t really get changed much, she’s supposed to be the protagonist so her character is better and makes more sense.
As much as the sisterly love was a refresher from true loves kiss and all that, I genuinely wish Elsa was the villain. It just seems so much more interesting and would make Hans into a better villain himself. Anna would have so much more internal conflict, and Elsa not feeling remorse for her actions would lead to an interesting bout of emotions Of course, this version of the movie doesn’t exist, so I don’t know if it would actually make for a better movie. But it’s something Id like to see!
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
apparently, they made Let It Go, and realized it didn't fit a villain. So they made Anna her sister to highlight the good in her.
Yeah, because it’s not like villain of the film has EVER sung a catchy song that has stuck with the audience for generations. (Laughing in “Be prepared,” “the mob song,” “the Siamese cat song,” and “poor unfortunate souls.”)
It's obvious if you watch the first movie. She looked back at arendale or however you spell it and saw it was frozen and kept going. She knew what she did. She sent a monster to attack her sister. In the second one she sent Ana and Olaf to their deaths right at the giants. She is obviously a bad person. That guy from the first one wasn't the main bad guy he took advantage of Elsa doing what she was doing then portrayed as rhe main bad guy as if Elsa didn't cause all this. As if She didn't freeze everyone over. Two bad guys in frozen one and just like our judicial systen only one person took the fall.
@@jbnhgaming3680 someone pointing out truths that may not fit into your perfect world do not mean I'm drama. It shows my intelligence is much higher and therefor I need to explain to the simpleton who cannot comprehend a child's movie what's going on. Drama would be starting a fight to be in a fight.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
If Elsa was a villainess, I would’ve actually watched the movie lmao 💀 didn’t like Frozen as a kid, don’t like it now. I did have a Princess phase when I was a kid, but that was primarily just Snow White and Aurora lol.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
You can watch this plot in the movie snow queen. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
I'm so happy that elsa hadn't became the villain in frozen and she was changed and rewritten to anna's older sister and to the disney character we love today💙💙💙💙💖💖💖💖❤️❤️❤️❤️
I'm glad that didn't work out Disney literally got hundreds of villians against there princesses I really liked to see two sisters facing different problems & not another villain .
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
Yeah because its mainly inspired from Andersen's story Snow Queen which is extremily beautiful and almost dreamy, definitely recommend it if you like something more dwrker than Frozen thats similar
I agree elsa wasnt interesting character. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
@@henrythef1guy768 They removed a huge part of the sisterly dynamic from the movie. The song life’s too short is a great song and they removed it and it’s better than all the songs in the final film.
@@crashban4t.f.s.b783 Life too short elsa calls anna fool . And only disney villains who used this word on their heroes. And they didn't what elsa as a villain. She is a disney princess.
Honestly their story now is much better as it provides good moral to children as well. And their story is wholesome, and the story of Elsa's inheritance of her powers made the movie more colorful and interesting
It’d be nice if they release a new FROZEN movie where something will trigger Elsa to become evil ice queen, where her powers becomes uncontrollable because of anger, hate and fear
The loop doesn't make sense because "What if she was originally the villain?" is what actually happened. It would make sense if it was "What if they had kept with the original concept of" (then the loop).
I remember they came out with a commercial and it showed Elsa it’s something along the lines of zooming into the castle, and you see her face and she freezes the camera (person approaching)
I guess it was a last minute choice because i remember an ad that said "that's no blizzard that's my sister" and it showed Elsa purposefully freezing things
I remember an old trailer where Anna was talking to Cristoff where he would ask what was going on and Anna looked worried and said "its not a storm, its my sister" (in portuguese, because I'm portuguese)
Long before this movie came out, I went to middle school and highschool with sisters named Elsa and Ana Perez. Elsa was the oldest and mean, and Ana kissed my boyfriend. Makes me wonder how common this name pairing is for sisters. What a coincidence. Class of 2012
I know, I have read The Snow Queen which Frozen was originally intended to be adapted from. Since it has become one of my favorite fairy tales I wish it had a more accurate adaptation, although it does have an old animated film that is very accurate.
The story is, once they heard the song "Let It Go" - they KNEW she couldn't be a villian as it was such an AMAZING song they rewrote the whole story around it!
I feel like they still can make her evil by the colder she becomes the more she turns. I mean her hair went from platinum blonde but a bit more blonde in frozen to near white in the frozen 2 that I noticed.
i like this more unique story line a lot better.... instead of the overdone, simplistic and overly scary wicked ice queen.... love the subtlety and sister and sybling thing they weaved in... its like the story ended up writing itself, as if it was fated ....
This kinda makes me wish the story was more similar to the original tale. Maybe instead have the story be about a girl trying to find and save her sister from the snow queen but she discovers that her sister IS the snow queen.
![Sean Rii, Karyon, Sharzkii - Taungule [My Love] (Official Music Video)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eJoMuypbSzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Mawatzi mawatzi mawatzi
Oh I'm Elsa is my favorite character
@@AkiramnnejRazibahur not Elsa??
@@MILO_PURPLEshe meant her favorite character is Elsa not that she is Elsa it made a mistake nothing else
@@user-qf5vo9vu2x ohh ok
thoughts?
Another fun fact: Disney had plans in place for a "Snow Queen" adaptation as far back as 1939.
Walt Disney had soo many plans he never saw to fruition. I don't think the guy could ever turn his brain off tbh
@@WxIxLxLxIxAxMxSMakes me wonder if he had ADHD cause I know I can't turn my brain off, lol.
I would have preferred a classic Disney snow queen version similar to sleeping beauty and snow white tbh.
@@disneytoysr4fun975hi again
@@tsukiaquamooncat2041yeh and people with adhd or mental disabilities like it tend to be very creative too so it would make sense
We need a Frozen: The Multliverse where the "original" story is told
Edit: omg I have NEVER had this much likes in a yt shorts comment before lol
YES! I also want Avatar Elsa (Nickelodeon, not James Cameron), and an Elsa as a shapeshifter. Both my theories combined!
@@Q.Andersonthere is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
I also NEED a story where ANNA turns evil :
ruclips.net/video/9HWEPq4gfZM/видео.htmlsi=LMvcmt1rEqc4UUwY
It was frozen was a thing bafore dusney
Please. No. Don’t open that up.
*In an Alternate dimension*
"Did you know, that Elsa was originally supposed to be the HERO in frozen? That's right! And she actually was also supposed to be Anna's older sis!!"
She is Anna’s older sister
@@alanaheiman3478it’s a joke, if the og was the actual storyline, and hero Elsa would be the storyline that wasn’t chosen
@@alanaheiman3478 they mean in an alt dimension where Elsa WAS the villain,
@@alanaheiman3478tell me you dont get the joke without telling me you dont get the joke 🎉
I prefer the direction they went. Having Elsa and Anna be sisters and both be good just nailed in a much stronger lesson for kids.
me too an evil snow queen would keep me up at night
I disagree. Elsa and Anna have the WEAKEST sibling story of any Disney movie. Brother Bear, Lilo and Stitch and especially Encanto pulled off much more emotional and realistic portrayals of brotherly and sisterly love. All Elsa and Anna have is Anna convincing Elsa she doesn’t have to be afraid of herself anymore, but that doesn’t change how Anna acted for a majority of the movie, including almost completely cutting ties with Elsa just to marry Hans
@@kristinahuchison2511here yall go..
@@candymareSweets just sayin. They could’ve done the sisterly love message for Anna and Elsa a lot better. One of the biggest problems I have is Anna’s willingness to completely cut ties with Elsa just for Hans and her personal happiness, sick of Elsa ignoring her. But, once she realizes her powers, she does a complete 180 and all of a sudden cares about Elsa more than anyone else. Elsa NEVER even tries to explain why their parents made the stupid decision of erasing Anna’s memories. The fact Anna never discovers she was almost killed as a child just bugs me so much. All the trolls had to do was finally restore her memories or just tell her what happened and why it made Elsa basically hate herself. But no, Anna doesn’t learn about that and its that secret that literally forces Elsa to keep shoving her away, even after Anna knows about her powers. Brother Bear, Encanto, Lilo and Stitch and arguably Big Hero 6 had more developed sibling stories and why certain characters went a certain route. Elsa and Anna became popular simply because they’re sisters and princesses. I’d argue even Ariel had more of a story with her sisters in Ariel’s Beginning and how their mother’s death affected their entire family
@@candymareSweetsthey literally spoke facts though. Frozen’s plot was WEAK
No ones gonna talk about how shes flipping us off in the picture w black hair💀
I'm crying. 😭😂
That's her index finger, not her middle finger
Wait, what? [Looks for it in the video] Holy crap, she is! 😂
Oh my god!!!!!!! Elsa!!!!!!!
naughty naughty
I don't think Frozen would've been so popular if Elsa was evil. ❄️After Anna saved her from getting killed by Hans she learned that love was the key of controlling her powers. So Frozen was about sister love!
Maybe it would have been so popular if Elsa was evil, who knows.
idk man, people sometimes _love_ the villains more than the heroes! Like Scar from the Lion King, or the Joker and Harley Quinn. Evil Elsa could have been a hit.
@@WxIxLxLxIxAxMxSbut kids don't, and the movie was a lot popular because of the younger demographic who bought toys..t shirts, accessories for school
The target of the movie were the Kids and they love more the main character, princess and everything related to that
@@pinklamborghini6446 maybe, but honestly I think it was a hit with the kiddos because of _Let It Go_ and _Do you wanna build a snowman?_
@@WxIxLxLxIxAxMxS wich potraited both the girls as two good characters
Elsa with blonde hair: 😊
Elsa with black hair: 💀
They Made the snow queen elsa is based on in once upon time the aunt of Anna and elsa instead
Well if you make the ice melts you get floods obviously 😒
ikr blondes look so much better in blue especially elsa good thing they didnt keep it lmao
And a black skin
To be honest we didn't necessarily need Hans or some villain in general I think it would've been enough if Elsa just went crazy with her powers and was so oberwhelmed that she thought that she is just harming everyone with it and then Anna is there for her and makes her understand that she isn't harming everyone she just needs to control her powers
You forgot to mention that Let It Go was the song that made the creators change their mind on Elsa being the villain.
Smg4 luigi: hey that pretty good
And that's why the fil has been butchered...
@@Gabry4777 nah, it made the movie so much better. The only downside is that it resulted in Hans being turned into a villain, which was done a little too late and made him a pretty weak villain.
@@xXmlgamingXx355 well, apart from that she is not a well written antagonist
@@Gabry4777 in what sense? I thought she was well-written! It’s nothing spectacular, but her character has actual depth and is relatable in more ways than one. This also lead to her being the protagonist of Frozen 2, and I loved her there!
Let’s also not forget that she’s probably Disney’s most popular princess (or queen) among kids. That would’ve never happened if she was kept as a villain and Frozen would not have become the most successful animated film of all time (and later be dethroned by its sequel).
People always act like this is shocking, but in the ogre story, Hans was Anna's bro and the Snow Queen stole him and turned his heart to ice. People act like this storyline never existed.
Oh wow, you really expect everyone to know this? Like every single person?
Few people know the original the fairytale.
Did you expect the kids at the time of the release of Frozen knew that already? 🤔
The ogre story? Hans and Anna?
You mean Gerda and Kay from the Snow Queen? They weren't actually siblings btw, but cared enough for each other as if they were.
I think the original Kristoff was supposed to be the robber girl, and Hans seemed to have a similar role to Gerda rather than Kay....
We could have had yuribait
In some universe, our version of Elsa was the original but was changed and people wish to see what this version would be like
I bet if DreamWorks adapted The Snow Queen into a movie, the antagonist would be inspired by Elsa
This is why Hans is such a poorly written villain
Edit: please stop arguing in the replies, I like the film I just personally think Hans was badly written and his character seemed rushed to me, you're all entitled to your own opinion
No he isn't.
@@abdullahsnowking8590yes he is stop being bias about a movie we all know has bad writing
To each their own.
Yeah honestly the twist didn't really make sense, especially cause earlier in the movie he seemed really worried about Anna and had even defended Elsa. Maybe if they put more thought in the twist and either hinted at the twist (or didn't make him so caring) the twist wouldn't seem like some last minute change/addition after they realised they didn't have a good villain.
@iliketea1427 I saw his deceptively caring nature to be very well written, and obviously... well, deceptive. As noble prince, naturally, being believably kind would be part of his lessons as a royal, as a part of establishing connections and finding a royal spouse of his own. Honestly, him seeming to fall in love with her so much that he asks her to marry him without so much as asking input from his father or eldest brother almost makes the heel turn expected. Would have been completely obvious if this wasn't a *Disney* movie.
Tbh Let It Go would have been a fire villain song
or ice
Let it go was actually the song that made them change their minds and make Elsa not evil.
@@SallyMars that's the point
@@SallyMarsAlso bare in mind the black community also do not like it when their AAVE is used by anyone outside of the community and when passed off as internet, etc. "slang"?
@@TheSapphireLeo why are you trying to educate me on the black community without knowing if I’m part of the black community or not? You sound like a dummy speaking for a whole group of people as if it’s fact.
i wish that the frozen team had stuck with their original plan i love frozen but the original story that they came up with sounds better than what we got and i think that Else would have been a very tragic and sympathetic villan she was essentially abused and neglected by her parents and kingdom because of her ice powers.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
@@pinkie_playz2732 the snow queen was not a movie it was a fairy tale written by Hans Christian Anderson not a movie he also wrote the original version of the little mermaid and the ugly duckling also i like to imagine that the original snow queen was Else and Anna's ancestor wich would explain why the sisters parents acted the way they did
It was meant to be something along the lines of:
Anna was a peasant, who had her heartbroken. She went to see the snow queen and asked her to freeze her heart.
That's all I think I know. I'm not sure, this could be wrong
😢 why is the original so good tho like its so good i wish they kept the direction as it was
Well you can always read the original story “the snow queen” if you want to see a plot like this in action
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
It's all about the framing. Imagine you are an ordinary citizen of Arendelle and your newly crowned queen suddenly cast an eternal winter over the town you are living in. Famine is imminent and you fear that your family, your friends and yourself might face starvation in the near future. Then you would most definitely consider Elsa to be a villain. And even after Elsa comes back and restores the weather, that does not make everything okay. You will be aware that you live in a kingdom with a queen that has proven that she will use her powerful magic against her own people when her vulnerable feelings are hurt.
I believe they changed her when they wrote let it go
I think it would've worked better if they kept Elsa as the villain. That is a hill i am willing to die on.
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
I do not like the idea of Elsa being the Maleficent/Ursula of the Revival era. She could have been an awesome villain, sure, and it would mean Anna would be a Disney Princess, but I think that it would have been more beneficial for Elsa’s character arc to be further fleshed out and for the Duke Of Weselton to be the villain instead.
Also the original Pinocchio and Little Mermaid stories had their protags fucking die so don’t come crying that this is still unfaithful to the original fairy tale.
@@henrythef1guy768there's a good reason why they didn't get killed and that's the fact that disney movies are catered towards children... what are you saying?
@@lasagna970 I’m not saying I dislike that, I’m saying that you shouldn’t complain about Frozen being unfaithful when that’s happened lots of times before.
@@henrythef1guy768 yes I understand that bit, but using the deaths of main characters isn't that great of an example tbh. I agree with everything else though
I think it would be a better idea if Elsa was evil yet they were still sisters
I agreee them being sisters and elsa villain would have been great story. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
@@winxclubflora8446 no way u just recommended a russian animated movie andbddh
@@beelzebub6414 the movie was awesomeeeeeee so whats the problem?
@@beelzebub6414 whats wrong with recommending russian movie?
Exactly 😂😅😊😊 that would have been interesting to see but made up as friends at the end 🔚 i guess
That makes sense. I remember being so confused with how the “snow queen” was nothing remotely similar to the original from the stories. Disney does make their changes, but I feel like this was their biggest change. Neither good nor bad. Just different 🤔
Honestly im super happy there sisters ❤
is no one gonna talk about the fact the elsa with black hair is giving us the middle finger-
No.
@@snowinxfars1332Yes.
@@Ebh55. Then go ahead.
@@snowinxfars1332 She's giving us the middle finger and that is so funny. 😂
@@Ebh55.Someone said it's her index finger. Not really sure since the quality of my video, for me at least is literally at 144p. 💀
I want to stop everybody ruining my childhood👹
Fr
Fr😢😅
Damn so many like but thank ya'll 😀
Damn, what _else_ am I supposed to do with my brand new time machine....😒
I understand you but theres nothing we can do 👁️💧👄💧👁️
That would've been such a slay
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
The snow queen (2012) movie be like: 💀
Maybe they could do a third frozen where Elsa has an evil doppelganger from another dimension🤨
Sure. Why not?
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
I actually prefer the fairytale. Especially because Hans wasn't really a well written villain or a interesting one (honestly the twist just seemed to be last minute, cause earlier in the movie he cares for anna and defends elsa and then suddenly he just doesn't).
Seriously! There was absolutely *no* foreshadowing or hint or _anything_ that suggested he was anything less than another prince charming!
there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
@@winxclubflora8446doesn’t that have rather cheap animation?
Well, check out “The Lantern in the snow” in Cookie Run: Kingdom. It’s similar to the original Snow Queen but it’s more bittersweet and the Queen isn’t really a villain.
Her oroginal design is gorgeous. As well as the little art clips here! :D..Kida reminds me of a certain Ballora design from a fnaf game.
Ikr who made these??
@@windsyDschultz that’s what I wanna know!
Yo, imagine if Elsa is evil and prince Hans who is the good guy
No wonder Anna is the better character
@@BlackCat-qr6gyi agree anna is muchhh better than elsa
@@BlackCat-qr6gy I didn't get what you exactly mean.
@@Ebh55. Anna is a better character than Elsa, and it’s no wonder because they completely changed Elsa’s character from being a villain to being her sister. Anna didn’t really get changed much, she’s supposed to be the protagonist so her character is better and makes more sense.
As much as the sisterly love was a refresher from true loves kiss and all that, I genuinely wish Elsa was the villain. It just seems so much more interesting and would make Hans into a better villain himself. Anna would have so much more internal conflict, and Elsa not feeling remorse for her actions would lead to an interesting bout of emotions
Of course, this version of the movie doesn’t exist, so I don’t know if it would actually make for a better movie. But it’s something Id like to see!
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
Dude I thought my phone was busted
"A solid story"
Uhhhhh, debatable
I woulda just loved a monstrous Elsa and the delivery of a more authentic retelling of the Snow Queen!
apparently, they made Let It Go, and realized it didn't fit a villain. So they made Anna her sister to highlight the good in her.
Yeah, because it’s
not like villain of the film has EVER sung a catchy song that has stuck
with the audience for generations.
(Laughing in “Be
prepared,” “the mob song,” “the Siamese cat song,” and “poor unfortunate souls.”)
Let's not forget "Gaston," which isn't really a villain song but really a bunch of guys praising another guy for being awesome.
I now have poor unfortunate souls permanently stuck in my head lmfaoo
It's obvious if you watch the first movie. She looked back at arendale or however you spell it and saw it was frozen and kept going. She knew what she did. She sent a monster to attack her sister. In the second one she sent Ana and Olaf to their deaths right at the giants. She is obviously a bad person. That guy from the first one wasn't the main bad guy he took advantage of Elsa doing what she was doing then portrayed as rhe main bad guy as if Elsa didn't cause all this. As if She didn't freeze everyone over. Two bad guys in frozen one and just like our judicial systen only one person took the fall.
Wow funny, nice drama
@@soyaliovee drama? I guess frozen could be classified as a drama. I would say kids movie.
@@Toad2Dopethey mean you’re drama
STOP RUINING MY CHILDHOOD 👹👹👹👹👹
@@jbnhgaming3680 someone pointing out truths that may not fit into your perfect world do not mean I'm drama. It shows my intelligence is much higher and therefor I need to explain to the simpleton who cannot comprehend a child's movie what's going on. Drama would be starting a fight to be in a fight.
HOW I WISH THEY WENT FOR THAT 😭😭😭🖤🖤🖤
ELSA is really fitting for a villainess!
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
So glad they went with the sister love story ❤
If 6yo me saw this I’d be crying lol
If Elsa was a villainess I would never watch the move .😅
Why? It could have been great.
Yes so true😮
@@imhere19 Why?
Closed minded much?
If Elsa was a villainess, I would’ve actually watched the movie lmao 💀 didn’t like Frozen as a kid, don’t like it now. I did have a Princess phase when I was a kid, but that was primarily just Snow White and Aurora lol.
ACTUALLY fitting into those is crqzy 😭
I’m glad they mixed the plot up! It made for a timeless classic!
Honestly, would’ve been a better movie.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
I like this plot better
You can watch this plot in the movie snow queen. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
I'm so happy that elsa hadn't became the villain in frozen and she was changed and rewritten to anna's older sister and to the disney character we love today💙💙💙💙💖💖💖💖❤️❤️❤️❤️
Perhaps because the original is so dark even Disney couldn't disneyfy it...
I'm glad that didn't work out
Disney literally got hundreds of villians against there princesses
I really liked to see two sisters facing different problems & not another villain .
The perfect loop doesn’t exi-
I fought his mom Eat Too Much Ice😂
Black haired Elsa is looking like she’s giving us the bird.
No wonder Elsa was a badly re-written character in the final product.
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
Love her being the good guy all snow Queen's can't be that bad just got to be a few good ones meaning of snow Queen's can't be that bad
The concept art looks so cool
The song Let It Ho is actually responsible for the changes to Elsa’s character
Should’ve kept her as the villain
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
WHAT!!!!!
I'm just glad your comment wasn't long
"Stop making fake stories by ur own"
Yeah because its mainly inspired from Andersen's story Snow Queen which is extremily beautiful and almost dreamy, definitely recommend it if you like something more dwrker than Frozen thats similar
Elsa would’ve been an actual interesting character? Woah
I agree elsa wasnt interesting character. there is a movie called snow queen(animated by wizart) its having 4 movies (you can skip the second movie) ;snow queen(1st),fire and ice(3rd) and mirrorlands(4th) its based on the original story and is an aamazingggg movie
Wasn't she already interesting 😂😅😊😊 who has ice powers tbh who??? Lmaoo
Yeah, but if she were an evil snow queen the movie would look like it was copied or mostly inspired from the og snow Queen movie and it would probably not look as original.
I would not call frozen’s story solid.
She was a villain, just not an antagonist.
that thin and creppy concept design is soo coool
It was originally going to be an interesting movie instead of a meh one.
You do not like redeemable Elsa?
@@henrythef1guy768 They removed a huge part of the sisterly dynamic from the movie. The song life’s too short is a great song and they removed it and it’s better than all the songs in the final film.
@@crashban4t.f.s.b783
Life too short elsa calls anna fool . And only disney villains who used this word on their heroes. And they didn't what elsa as a villain. She is a disney princess.
@@abdullahsnowking8590 And we can’t have an evil Disney Princess?
@@abdullahsnowking8590 We have evil Disney Kings like Mufasa and Simba so.
Honestly their story now is much better as it provides good moral to children as well. And their story is wholesome, and the story of Elsa's inheritance of her powers made the movie more colorful and interesting
It’d be nice if they release a new FROZEN movie where something will trigger Elsa to become evil ice queen, where her powers becomes uncontrollable because of anger, hate and fear
Smug looping videos is now my new pet peeve
The plot would’ve benefited supremely if they kept Elsa as the villainess.
I remember all the trailers portraying Elsa as a villain
My whole childhood turned upside down because that was my most favourite movie when i was a kid
“Solid design and story.” Yeah, solid story my butt
Now i wanna make a comic thats similar to this original one
Bro lost me when he made merch of his art, including Cory. That’s when I knew he didn’t intend to treat Cory’s case seriously
The loop doesn't make sense because "What if she was originally the villain?" is what actually happened. It would make sense if it was "What if they had kept with the original concept of" (then the loop).
I love how Ana looks in this original Version
I love how I clicked on this as if I didn't read the whole frozen concept art book lol
That look of: "please do not let me kill these aliens..."
Omggg, In that art style I would loveeeee to see the original plan they haddd😱😱😭
same i love that art style sm
If you think about it, Frozen does have heavy prequel vibes
She was literally a villain but with a good ending 😅
Exactly 😂😅😊😊
I remember they came out with a commercial and it showed Elsa it’s something along the lines of zooming into the castle, and you see her face and she freezes the camera (person approaching)
the kingdomhearts level of frozen rlly shows how the elsa villian story got scrapped
my crusty childhood self would be broken 💀 (cause anna and elsa were my fav😢)
I guess it was a last minute choice because i remember an ad that said "that's no blizzard that's my sister" and it showed Elsa purposefully freezing things
"LET IT FREEZE.....LET IT FREEEEZE!"
Her old design reminds me of a mix between hades and dr falicier
I remember an old trailer where Anna was talking to Cristoff where he would ask what was going on and Anna looked worried and said "its not a storm, its my sister" (in portuguese, because I'm portuguese)
I want to see that ferret coat irl
“Luckily the solid plot was solid”
It's always the better versions that gets cut
Long before this movie came out, I went to middle school and highschool with sisters named Elsa and Ana Perez. Elsa was the oldest and mean, and Ana kissed my boyfriend.
Makes me wonder how common this name pairing is for sisters. What a coincidence.
Class of 2012
I know, I have read The Snow Queen which Frozen was originally intended to be adapted from. Since it has become one of my favorite fairy tales I wish it had a more accurate adaptation, although it does have an old animated film that is very accurate.
The story is, once they heard the song "Let It Go" - they KNEW she couldn't be a villian as it was such an AMAZING song they rewrote the whole story around it!
this is unrelated but SNOW QUEEN HAS A WHOLE GYATTTTTT IN THE PICTURE WITH HER GIVING ANNA DRESSES OH MY DEAR OH
I feel like they still can make her evil by the colder she becomes the more she turns. I mean her hair went from platinum blonde but a bit more blonde in frozen to near white in the frozen 2 that I noticed.
I wonder if that’s how OUAT came up with the snow queen being Anna and Elsa’s aunt
They need to make a short of this cuz I need to see the deigns in action. Blue hair? Living ermine coat??
i like this more unique story line a lot better.... instead of the overdone, simplistic and overly scary wicked ice queen.... love the subtlety and sister and sybling thing they weaved in... its like the story ended up writing itself, as if it was fated ....
This kinda makes me wish the story was more similar to the original tale. Maybe instead have the story be about a girl trying to find and save her sister from the snow queen but she discovers that her sister IS the snow queen.